News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by kuon on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @03:48AM (#31735953)
I was talking with my car dealer as I wanted to buy an electric car. He was using the car for his own usage to get a good idea. The main thing that came out is that most available charging stations are 22kW max and very often they are shared using "smart charge", which basically means a lower duty cycle (/N). In practice it means it requires about 7 hours to charge the 50kW/h battery.

After this discussion, I asked my utility company, and it would cost around $20k to install a 22kW charging station in my home. And what the person told me over the phone was basically "the grid is not ready, we would need to upgrade hundred of meters of cable".

This is in Europe (Switzerland), but it shows how impractical super fast charging is with the current state of the grid and infrastructure (we can't start a turbine when you plug your car). I don't know if trying to make it work is possible. The current grid was built over decades. To me it seems way easier to use other form of energy transfer (hydrogen refill or battery swap).

Edit:

I'm at the limit of the current I can draw from the utility line (40A for my house) as I have a geothermal pump that can use up to 25A when running. Even if I put a smaller charging station, the utility will have to change my introduction box, and in all cases it is quite expensive. I asked for 22kW because we live in a remote location, and while not strictly necessary, it might become so in the future, for example if we have visitors with 3 cars, they might need recharge.

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by valdiorn on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @04:33AM (#31736203)
I used to work for Reykjavik Energy as a junior analyst about 12 years ago. One of my tasks was using their geo database to pull out cable and transformer data for every neighbourhood and use it to generate load models (using Siemens PSS mostly).

We knew the high voltage system (100kv+) was fine as there are quite a few big power hungry users on the network. We focused our research on the "neighbourhood transformers" - These are the transformers that take you from 11kv to 400v (3 phase, of which one leg is connected to a consumer fuseboard). They're generally sized so that each transformer can service a small neighborhood, but power can be routed through less efficient ways in case they break. We combined all the electrical data with traffic data to estimate when people finish work and would likely be plugging their cars in at home.

The conclusion we came to was that if only 15 percent of homes wanted fast charge ability (which at the time was a lot less than what testa offers today) the majority of the city's transformers would be over their current limit.

Iceland has a pretty decent and modern power infrastructure so this was a bit of a shock to everyone. I think my research was even presented to parliament :)

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by cm2187 on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @05:41AM (#31736604)
But why do you need fast charge ability at home? I thought it only made sense on the go.
Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by yakak on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @07:48AM (#31737721)
It seems more like convenience to me as long as you can charge overnight and have a high enough range per charge. There could be households with complex lifestyles that share one car though.

I would still worry about this indicator for capacity though, if 100% of people were heavily overlapping on 8 hour of charging at night that seems like hours of the same draw as 15% of people who all fast charge at the same time for some reason. Whole neighborhoods might be 100% electric within a couple years of no longer selling new ICE vehicles.

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by turtlebits on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @09:46AM (#31739426)
A level 2 charger even at 3000w (2 space heaters) will give you 140 miles overnight (12 hours), which should be enough for most drivers.
Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by jaclaz on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @01:39PM (#31743045)
Happy to see that someone actually did make some accurate calculations and found out with actual data that - even in a country where the main distribution lines are just fine and the "local" transformers and lines are modern/recent - the "last km" is/will be an issue.

Now imagine what would be the results of similar analysis in European cities (relatively densely inhabited, with an aged/aging infrastructure, a number of limitations for new lines and what not).

I mean, if you live in a solo or bifamily (or even very small condo's) house somewhere outside the city, or in a village, there will probably be less issues with upgrading the lines and transformers (at a cost), but for medium or large condo's in or near the city centre it will be impossible to provide enough power even for 7kW chargers when there will be many of them.

AFAIK here (Italy) a typical "local" transformer 20,000 to 380 V or 10,000 to 380V, it depends on the specific areas, is usually within the 300/400 kW range and serves 50-100 houses/apartments, each one having 3-4.5-6 kW contracts, and it is already near 100% use.

When/if each house (or anyway a recharge column for 1 car each) will want (or need) some 7 kW available, even if only at night, the amount of 380V electricity will be at the very least twice the current one.

Very likely the current infrastructure can bear an increase of 5-10%, maybe 15%, and as said this with only "slow" chargers.

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by Gravityloss on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @06:50AM (#31737079)
Build a 800V DC neighborhood fast charging spot at the 11 kV access point. Maybe have a cafe there as well...

Some of these are quite nice I would say. https://www.vastavalo.net/albums/userpics/12399/normal_Kultt...

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by Philip-J-Fry on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @03:57AM (#31736010)
Ok, so there's a key point here, and that's that fast charging is not meant for the home!

You can fully charge an EV overnight on a 7KW charger. You don't need a fast charger at home.

The other thing is that home chargers are AC and the car converts the current. This means that there's a cap to how much power you can give it. For example, my car can only accept 11KW and that's pretty typical. So 22KW chargers are a waste at home today.

Maybe you'd need a fast charger at home if you never sleep. But the majority of people spend at least 7 hours at home. You'll always wake up to a fully charged car. Why do you need anything else?

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by janlaureys on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @04:01AM (#31736034)
Hell I park my car in an underground parking garage, and it's been a whole discussion about who wants to and how they want to install 7kW/11/kW chargers. In the meantime I just charge it on the wall plug now and then. Yeah sometimes my battery is not fully charged, but I hardly ever drive 450km in one go anyway.
Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by Symbiote on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @06:57AM (#31737127)
A few years ago one of my neighbours asked for a socket in the underground car park.

I assume they paid the full cost themselves, although it probably wasn't that much -- the electrical supply to the building including the meters for each apartment are just behind his parking space. They installed a normal 16A 400V 3P+E plug (the big red one), which is an easy 11kW. There isn't any sort of 'car charger' on the wall, just this socket.

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by cbozeman on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @05:09AM (#31736422)
> You don't need a fast charger at home.

This is such an arrogant statement.

I may not "need" 3 petabytes of storage for my home media server, but I have it.

I may not "need" a 64-core Threadripper 3990X workstation with 256 GB of RAM, but I have it.

I may not "need" enterprise-grade networking and WiFi gear, but I have it.

I may not "need" a 60 kW Kohler diesel generator, but I have it.

> Why do you need anything else?

Because he wants it. The same reason I have everything I listed.

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by Philip-J-Fry on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @05:46AM (#31736641)
>This is such an arrogant statement.

It's not an arrogant statement. A lot of people don't understand how electric cars work.

It's one of the biggest things holding them back. I still hear people saying "I don't want to spend 30 minutes recharging every week" when you don't need to. You can plug in a car overnight. But people struggle to understand that you can wake up every day with a "full tank" which is something a fossil fuel vehicle can't do. It requires thinking about your usage of a vehicle differently.

>Because he wants it. The same reason I have everything I listed.

I ask the question because, again, people don't understand how electric cars work. A lot of people think a 22KW charger at home will be like a 22KW DC charger.

It's an attempt to gauge the actual reasoning behind wanting it. If his reasoning is to be future proof, then that's fine, it's perfectly reasonable to want that. But if his reasoning is to charge at 22KW then it's just a misunderstanding and something we can help him understand.

Don't assume everyone asking questions is being naive or dismissive.

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by coderenegade on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @06:03AM (#31736758)
I don't think it's that people don't understand how electric cars work, because I don't think that gives people enough credit. I think it's more that BEV advocates misunderstand how other people buy vehicles, or rather, they might have different purchasing habits because they skew wealthy.

I don't buy a vehicle for the average use case -- I buy it for the edge cases. When I need to be able to move stuff or tow a trailer, I can. If I needed to cross the country tonight because of a family emergency, I could. I think this is a fairly common mindset for most people, because after a house, a car is the most expensive thing we'll ever own. The cost and continued upkeep mandates that a vehicle has utility beyond what a person needs on average.

You're right that most people don't need a 22kW charger for their car, and they can wake up with a full tank every morning, but most people are probably also averse to the idea that their car has a downtime of several hours when they might really need it. You aren't just paying for the privilege of going from A to B, because if that's all it were, you could just call a cab -- part of owning and paying the upkeep for a car is that you're able to go right now when you need to.

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by XorNot on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @06:46AM (#31737039)
In all those use cases though you are anywhere but your home. So you would be using fast chargers provided in the same way gas stations are.

The situation you're describing is "I drive enough to drain my car completely, then take it home to recharge it, then immediately plan to do that again within 30 minutes of going home, and will never stop at a fast charger on that journey which can be completed within the 450km range of my battery".

It's conceivable, but so convoluted that it would never happen.

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by coderenegade on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @07:46AM (#31737699)
The situation I'm describing is any trip for which the potential of waiting an hour (or more, in many cases) at a fast charger is problematic. My car can be nearly empty in my driveway, and it costs me two minutes to fill it up. This means that if I needed to sprint to the state border before it closed (a real-life scenario for several of my coworkers during COVID), I could. Ditto for any other situation where you might be time pressed. A BEV is charged every time you take it out, but it also needs to be, because charging isn't a two minute thing. Like it or not, this affects its utility relative to a standard vehicle, in certain situations. Maybe it's a 1% kind of thing, but again, I'm not convinced that most of us buy cars for the average use case. If we did, SUVs wouldn't be the highest selling segment of the market.
Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by imtringued on Wednesday June 15, 2022 @03:33AM (#31750124)
It takes me more than two minutes to fill my car up.
Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by carlmr on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @09:08AM (#31738846)
>The cost and continued upkeep mandates that a vehicle has utility beyond what a person needs on average.

Exactly! I hate the 90% of drives are less than 50km argument which is always made about range issues. I don't want to buy another car for the 10%.

Also I take the train to work, I walk/cycle to the store. Almost all my driving is for hiking, climbing, skiing, or other vacations. I won't buy a car that has a max range with a new battery and no AC on that just barely gets me there and back.

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by Philip-J-Fry on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @12:06PM (#31741436)
You don't buy another car for the 10%. EVs do more than 50km...

You rent a car for the case where you're going over 400km and charging is an issue. Probably 0.1% of trips, maybe less.

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by carlmr on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @01:54PM (#31743270)
400km is already only with new battery and no AC on most affordable EVs.

And I do 400km trips most of the months, it's definitely more than 0.1% for me.

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by turtlebits on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @10:11AM (#31739777)
Sorry, but that makes no sense. You can also wake up to a car with no gas. So your dilemma will be to either get gas to your home (will likely require another vehicle) or to plug in (until you have range get to a fast charge- or just let it charge)

And yes, you can make that cross country trip in an EV. It will probably take longer (2-3 hours spent fast charging).

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by nomel on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @12:23PM (#31741710)
I did this last weekend, and it single handedly killed my desire to go all electric. I reserved two cars at two different rental agencies, showed up, and both said they had no cars. Another two didn't have the size I needed (+1 of ICE car capacity). The final one ended up costing $200/day, all after a few hours driving around town. This was just a random weekend. I can't imagine if there was any sort of desire to leave town, amongst the larger population. I'll be keeping my ICE car to go along with my electric, even if it just sits there, rusting. With that three day weekend excursion, I've paid for 13 months of my ICE car insurance.
Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by Philip-J-Fry on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @07:10AM (#31737267)
>I don't buy a vehicle for the average use case -- I buy it for the edge cases. When I need to be able to move stuff or tow a trailer, I can. If I needed to cross the country tonight because of a family emergency, I could. I think this is a fairly common mindset for most people,

That really isn't the common mindset. If it was, everyone would be driving huge 7 seater trucks for the edge case where they need to haul some lumber with their 7 person family.

Most people buy a car for their typical needs. If they want to move a lot of stuff, they rent a van or a trailer.

If you needed to cross the country tonight because of a family emergency you could do that in any car, EV or fossil fuel. A modern EV might take you longer because of charging stops, but when you factor in scheduled breaks of a typical cross country drive, the charging times don't actually add up to a lot more at all.

>You're right that most people don't need a 22kW charger for their car, and they can wake up with a full tank every morning, but most people are probably also averse to the idea that their car has a downtime of several hours when they might really need it

If you need a full car then you drive to a fast charger and charge it. They exist for this exact purpose of needing a fast charge.

I can charge my car to 80% in like 20 minutes.

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by throw0101a on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @07:24AM (#31737443)
> That really isn't the common mindset. If it was, everyone would be driving huge 7 seater trucks for the edge case where they need to haul some lumber with their 7 person family.

> Most people buy a car for their typical needs. If they want to move a lot of stuff, they rent a van or a trailer.

The top three selling vehicles in the US are F-150, Ram 1500/2500/3500, and Chevrolet Silverado:

* https://www.caranddriver.com/news/g36005989/best-selling-car...

* https://www.edmunds.com/most-popular-cars/

The F-series has been on the top of the list for decades.

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by Philip-J-Fry on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @12:07PM (#31741461)
This doesn't hold true for anywhere outside of the US.
Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by coderenegade on Wednesday June 15, 2022 @07:27AM (#31751455)
Do SUVs count? They're one of the top selling vehicle classes in most countries, and aside from BEVs, the only one seeing significant growth. China has seen higher adoption of SUVs over the last decade than the US.
Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by imtringued on Wednesday June 15, 2022 @03:30AM (#31750098)
I'm surprised to hear that the people going on 400km trips every month aren't the wealthy ones. I only drive 1000km per month. A 400km trip+return is 80% of my monthly commute meaning it would double my fuel expenses from roughly 120€ to 240€ per month.
Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by CHY872 on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @06:23AM (#31736877)
Yeah no. GP is arguing that most people should not buy an electric car for a reason that's invalid for the 99th percentile of people, and saying that it's too expensive to install a solution that is not what you need to make an electric car viable.

I can go buy a $50k top of rack switch to route data between my WiFi APs, yes, and I might want to! But it's not valid to then go around telling people that they're not ready for multiple access points because the tech to link them costs $50k. And it's certainly not 'arrogant' to correct people of their misconceptions, because this is a huge EV misconception.

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by dendriti on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @05:38AM (#31736585)
Please calm down. No one is attacking you. The point is, MOST people don't have a 3990X at home, because they don't need it, and MOST people won't have a fast charger at home, because they don't need it.
Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by sorenjan on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @06:54AM (#31737106)
What you're describing is over consumption, and it's what got us in the mess we're in and trying to fix. Everyone have a legal right to buy more than they need because they want it, that doesn't mean they should.

Flying on vacation, buying new clothes from the other side of the world each month, replacing a fully working car with a new one, having the AC blasting in a poorly insulated house, etc, these things all have a cost to the system but people have started thinking of these excesses as rights.

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by revertmean on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @06:20AM (#31736852)
> I may not "need" a 60 kW Kohler diesel generator, but I have it.

Those run about $20k don't they? If you'd come on here complaining that generator technology wasn't ready yet because you'd been quoted $20k for your 60kW Kohler, you'd probably get the same response: you don't really need it.

GP clearly doesn't want that 22kW charging station that much, because they've been told how much it costs (same as your generator) and they're unwilling to pay that.

And they don't need it.

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by Schroedingersat on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @09:11AM (#31738896)
You're the one being arrogant here.

If what you want requires most of the city infrastructure to be rebuilt then you can pay for it.

If you can't afford to pay for a new gas electric plant plus externalities and new poles with thicker wires then tough. Don't demand handouts.

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by koide on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @02:51PM (#31744178)
The ability of getting everything one wants just because one can is not a good thing, in my view.

Also, how is this relevant to the point above? One point is it's too expensive - so even if he wants it he might not be able to get it in the current reality. The counterpoint is that you can charge your car with a slower charger.

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by sshagent on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @06:13AM (#31736811)
3 pb home media storage. Nice indeed. I'm impressed
Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by cbozeman on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @06:57PM (#31747034)
It was luck, honestly. I got three WD Ultrastar Data60s from a friend whose company was upgrading to some even more ridiculous storage solution. They were letting them go for $10,000 each or so, populated with 14 TB drives, so I went for all three.

I fully expect that I won't have to upgrade storage for the rest of my life, because, honestly... I don't know where we go past 4K. 8K is just dumb for everyone unless you have a 200 foot screen that you sit 10 feet away from or so. As far as games go, yes, they're approaching 250 GB, but there does come a point where textures, models, and sound will become "good enough". I figure 1 TB games will be pretty much "the end", but then again... the first computer I got was 28 years ago and had a 540 MB hard drive, but in fairness, that seemed small even back then.

I guess some day someone will bitch that their computer only has 6 PB of storage...

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by sshagent on Wednesday June 15, 2022 @07:00PM (#31760534)
Thanks for the reply, lovely stuff.

I've only recently really started to bring my hardware back home and only have a few TB. I don't mind purchase price for hardware, but it's the power consumption that's an issue. Especially as our electricity has gone up 60% a few months ago, and likely going up again October.

My day job is scooping up film data, and if my last 15 years here has shown me anything were always going to need more disk. Staying at 4k the be lovely.

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by MrMan on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @07:42AM (#31737661)
you sound like the arrogant one, to be honest
Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by fragmede on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @03:55AM (#31735993)
I... what are you doing that you need a 22kW charging station? 7 hrs to charge a 50 kW/h battery seems fine. Are you a taxi driver?
Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by jnsaff2 on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @04:12AM (#31736101)
I happen to have 22kW at home (3x32A) but my TM3LR is only capable of 11kW (3x16A) but this means that no matter what my car can always be charged during the time I sleep. Most of the time in practice however I only charge during the hours electricity is really cheap as it's not too often I come in with a completely empty battery and need to drive full battery capacity next day (two days of ~500km each in a row).

I find fast charging is only needed for road trips and quite possibly for fleet operations (taxis, delivery vans etc). For a private car 11kW is plenty and less could be doable as well.

As for grid .. our grid here in Estonia has the opposite problems, most people want to start selling to the grid with solar panels. And grid people being really inflexible (in a charitable interpretation) or greedy (by wanting to people pay for all the work needed to modernize the aging grid) also want to charge ridiculous fees for any increases in capacity.

With lots of EV's I kinda understand that the grid may have more problems but with local generation the load on the grid goes down (as electricity needs to be transported much shorter distances, think: your neighbors). So my trust that 3x32A installation cost of $20k is justified is very low (unless this is a rural farm or something that really is far from nearest transformer).

Just last week someone was quoted 4 million euros to upgrade an existing connection to support a 15kW PV installation (rural, but most of the cost came apparently from needing to upgrade a 330kV transformer station).

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by elihu on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @05:39AM (#31736591)
Very few people are likely to have that sort of charger installed in their house. High speed charging makes sense though where it'll be heavily utilized, like at charging stations along major highways.

(I'm hoping eventually the highways will become the charging stations, probably with some kind of device that makes a physical connection to rails embedded in the road that supply power to moving vehicles, kind of like a big slot car. For that application, fast-charging batteries are great because it means you only have to electrify short sections of road at regular intervals, not the whole thing.)

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by squishy47 on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @04:00AM (#31736025)
$20k to install a 22kW charger!!!! i was quoted £1300 (uk) to have one fitted and i thought that was expensive! to reply to another comment about why a 22kW is needed. if you're on a flexi tariff where energy price is super cheap from like 12-4am then having it fully charge in that time is needed to maximise the best price
Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by PeterBarrett on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @04:14AM (#31736113)
In the UK you have the advantage of easy access to 3 phase electricity, most houses can simply pull 2 more wires from the mains and have it. Whereas in the likes of Ireland you need a special setup and massive extra cost to get 3 phase.

Having a 22kw charger at home is amazing especially for only £1300!

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by VBprogrammer on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @04:34AM (#31736208)
Emm. No we don't. We only have a single phase supply to the home. At least traditionally, new homes may be built to different standards.

Ours comes into the house via a very scary looking lead sheathed TN-S cable.

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by PeterBarrett on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @04:45AM (#31736277)
Hmm, fair enough, maybe it's only in large towns and cities. The pricing you got seems a bit suspect in that case because you would need 3 phase to run a 22kw charger and if you don't have easy access to 3 phase then the cost would be quite a bit higher as new wires would need to be added.

The charger alone would cost around 1000 (if not slightly more) so I can't imagine them doing the amount of required work for 300 pounds.

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by VBprogrammer on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @07:31AM (#31737529)
It's actually usually the other way around. In a rural location you are much more likely to have access to a 3-phase supply. Farms for example almost always have a 3 phase supply for running pumps, motors and heaters etc.
Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by IshKebab on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @06:31AM (#31736937)
Yes we do. Well, theoretically anyway - you know those electricity poles with 4 cables above each other? That's 3 phase. Usually each house just gets one phase but I guess theoretically having 3 phase would just be a matter of connecting up the other wires too.

I'd be surprised if you could actually convince suppliers to do that for a house though, and definitely not for £1300.

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by VBprogrammer on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @07:29AM (#31737506)
This is the same the world over. Power is generated and distributed as 3 phase because it is better for the generators and it makes better use of the power cable since you don't require a neutral for a balanced 3 phase load.
Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by cr3ative on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @06:39AM (#31736997)
Ha, my cables are all underground, making life harder.

Some DNOs are only installing 3-phase now - they'll just connect a single phase up, but the wiring will be ready for three.

Not mine, of course. Bitter about that.

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by Bayart on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @04:10AM (#31736087)
$20k problably includes the cost of digging tranches and lay new cables. Here in France it's tops a few thousand euros if you want 36kVA, but that doesn't include civil engineering.
Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by bushbaba on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @04:08AM (#31736073)
22kwh is 90 amps at 230 volts. Surprised is 20k to install a single one of these.

In the us most newer homes have 200+ amps of service providing 48kw of peak electric capacity.

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by kuon on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @04:25AM (#31736160)
no, 22kW is 32A as we use three 240V (to neutral, so around 400V between phases) phases here. Most home here have 40A capacity (mine does).

You have to pay for the introduction box, which need to be changed in my case and is about 7000$ [1] and you have to may for each extra A capacity, which is 150$ per A. So 32*150 is 4800 + 7000. And that's only to change the capacity of what we call the "introduction". Then I have to change the cabling inside the house up to the breaker room and install a charging station. The whole thing is about 20k

[1]: https://www.romande-energie.ch/images/files/conditions/2021-...

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by jnsaff2 on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @06:27AM (#31736901)
I don't get what you are saying.

You have 3x40A. Your biggest user is occasional 3x25A. So you have 3x15A available almost all the time. 3x16A is 11kW, you can tell your car or charger to go no more than 3x13A or 3x10A or whatever, this can even be automated by most charging stations. When you have your local EV meetup with 3 cars and all want to charge then either take turns or have all charge at 3x13 each and switch the heating off for that time.

I have this at home [0]. It plugs into a regular (red) 3x16A socket, has RCD protection built in and needs 0 installation cost and no nonsense about utility needing to come and do anything.

Surely you have one of those red 3x16A or 3x32A sockets in your garage/workshop wherever? If not your local electrician can put it in for xx instead of utility doing something unneeded for xxxx or xxxxx.

[0] - https://eauto.si/metron-shop/product/pc05t-3x16a-3-phase/

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by kuon on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @11:20AM (#31740778)
As I said I am at the limit already, I have my home lab and a small server farm for work, I also have a workshop. I already cannot put everything on, if I use the workshop, you cannot use the kitchen oven for example. I realize 11kW is enough for most usage, but in my case, even that requires changing infrastructure, which is expensive.
Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by jnsaff2 on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @12:42PM (#31742064)
Most chargers have Dynamic Load Management readyness where they have a Modbus power meter at your main circuit breaker and makes sure the charger only uses available power. So you can switch on your oven and car will automatically back off.

For this kind of consumption tho I would consider installing solar panels if that is possible/feasible.

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by koide on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @02:58PM (#31744291)
I have an 11A charger and some 5kW solar panel setup, and I am lucky enough that I'm able to charge during the day the trips I make early in the morning just with solar.
Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by WatchDog on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @04:16AM (#31736127)
Aren't US homes running at 120 volts?

22kw at 230 volts would be ~95 amps. 22kw at 120 volts would be ~183 amps. 48kw at 120 volts would be 400 amps.

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by goodcanadian on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @04:27AM (#31736173)
Aren't US homes running at 120 volts?

Yes . . . and no. In North America, homes are actually supplied with 240V. A split-phase system with a centre-tap transformer is then used to create two 120V "phases." So, your typical outlets will be on one of two 120V phases. However, there are usually a couple of 240V outlets as well for things like electric stoves, and clothes dryers. So, in short, single phase 240V is available in essentially every U.S. household.

The cars, themselves, usually require 3-phase 240V to do 22kW. You are highly unlikely to have access to that in a U.S. home.

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by proto_lambda on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @04:22AM (#31736145)
No, US homes are typically 240V split-phase: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Split-phase_electric_power
Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by greenthrow on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @07:04AM (#31737210)
He's talking nonsense. He's talking running a new line from the nearest electrical pole to his house. That is almost never necessary.
Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by cr3ative on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @05:55AM (#31736710)
This price is only applicable in the UK if you already have 3-phase electricity to the property, which is rare. 7kw otherwise.
Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by piokoch on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @05:29AM (#31736531)
That's only one of many, many issues electric cars "revolution" is going to face. Where do we get all the lithium, copper, cobalt to build electric cars? The reality check for EV will be very brutal, according to those stats [1] we would need:

"meeting UK electric car targets for 2050 would require production of just under two times the current total annual world cobalt production, nearly the entire world production of neodymium, three quarters the world’s lithium production and at least half of the world’s copper production."

And this is only UK. In order to switch to EV we need revolution in battery production, we need revolution in electricity production and grid construction and I don't see any of this happening for now. I am tracking all news about "new, better battery" and typically it at the end of the news it turns out, that this new great battery weight is 2 tonnes or it can work in temperature range up to -200 degrees, etc.

[1] https://www.greencarcongress.com/2019/06/20190624-uk.html

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by lm28469 on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @05:42AM (#31736609)
> Where do we get all the lithium, copper, cobalt to build electric cars? The reality check for EV will be very brutal

We're doing the same thing as we did with ICE cars. We're ignoring all the drawbacks and telling ourselves we'll find hypothetical solutions sometimes in the future. We're basically green washing the entire auto industry: "shhh don't worry it's electric, now buy our $50k car and tell your friends you're saving the planet"

When the average driver does like 30km per day all you need is some kind of hybrid car with a small but efficient gas engine. 90% of your travel will be fully electric, the occasional road trip would use gas (which would be expensive but something the average user doesn't need more than a few times a year)

But I guess it's more marketable to sell AWD, 600+ HP, three tonnes lithium monsters than glorified priuses. This industry is fucked up and doesn't care one bit about sustainability.

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by greenthrow on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @07:00AM (#31737164)
A hybrid car is the worst of both worlds. Most people would always have been fine 99% of the time with a short range EV like a Nissan Leaf. But the human brain can't let go of the "what if" and long range EVs have proven necessary for large scale adoption.

Regardless, batteries are highly recyclable. Lithium is super plentiful. Cobalt reduction and eventual elimination is making progress. EVs are the future and it will be great. Let go of your fear, it is not rational.

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by lm28469 on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @07:16AM (#31737338)
It's the best of both world. No city pollution, 90% of usage is fully electric, small batteries, your "what if" problem disappear.

> batteries are highly recyclable

Yet only 5% of batteries are recycled world wide

> Lithium is super plentiful. Cobalt reduction and eventual elimination is making progress

I'd suggest you to look at the mining industry and come back to me with your sustainability talk.

> EVs are the future and it will be great. Let go of your fear, it is not rational.

Freon is the future and it will be great. Let go of your fear, it is not rational.

Leaded gas is the future and it will be great. Let go of your fear, it is not rational.

Leaded paint is the future and it will be great. Let go of your fear, it is not rational.

Asbestos is the future and it will be great. Let go of your fear, it is not rational.

Radium lipstick is the future and it will be great. Let go of your fear, it is not rational.

The future is the end of personal vehicles, a fleet of state/city owned and shared small sized electric vehicles would be a vision of the future I can get behind. Three tonnes of steel and 600kg of battery to move our fat asses 30km a day isn't a future I believe in, it's a waste of space, resource and energy. Nothing in the auto industry makes sense right now, making them electric just displace the problem slightly further from us.

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by greenthrow on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @07:22AM (#31737420)
Hybrids combine all the downsides of an ICE car (way more maintenance, destroying the earth) with all the downsided of an EV (solving battery sustainability, requiring us to embrace renewable energy and move off coal and gas).

Most Batteries not currently being recycled is a problem in the same way as most cars on the road still being ICE. Yeah it's an issue, but it's one which has obvious solutions.

Your litany of non-sequitors doesn't warrant a response.

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by lm28469 on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @12:27PM (#31741785)
> destroying the earth

Again, research about mining, transport, by-product storage, efficiency, &c. When you need XXg of rare earth and each gram requires you to extract a tonne of earth, to filter it with nasty af chemicals and store it in leaky trailing dams.

Solution to EV problems are always "you just need to do X", "we don't do it yet but I swear we'll do it later", "it's not technically feasible for now but we're working on it". It's either wishful thinking or complete delusion.

The only thing EVs do is put the pollution far away from you, on a global scale it's not much better for the planet, we're just going to consume the next resource until we hit a wall and realise all over again that we fucked up once more. And on top of that it perpetuates the hell that modern cities became thanks to personal vehicles

But sure it allows tech bros in Silicon Valley to drive $100k teslas with 600+ hp and pat themselves on the back about how much they're doing to save the planet.

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by imtringued on Wednesday June 15, 2022 @03:46AM (#31750206)
The future is actually something akin to the eRockit which is a Pedelec turned into a small motorcycle. It has a max speed of 90km/h. I would rather commute with that than a car.
Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by aeha3hq on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @06:05AM (#31736768)
>We're doing the same thing as we did with ICE cars.

Are we? Despite all the spin that the green crowd like the put on things it's not like we actually had any idea back in the day about things like the impact CO2 emissions would have longterm. We had hints, people working on wildly different problems had data that contained the patterns that they needed to realize, but no one actually realized the scope of things with ICE cars for a long long time and while we've woken up to the problems with ICE vehicles now... fuel is hardly one of those problems and saying otherwise is just histrionics.

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by Maarten88 on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @06:10AM (#31736797)
> telling ourselves we'll find hypothetical solutions sometimes in the future

Or we just put in LFP batteries now. No cobalt and nickel needed. Energy density is a bit lower, but costs are lower and durability is better

Most Chinese brands use these; Tesla as well on some models

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by greenthrow on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @06:57AM (#31737130)
These are the same non-argument statements EV opponents bave been shoveling for decades.

Any large scale change is necessarily going to be an enormous undertaking. That's self evident.

Imagine telling someone in 2007 how many billions of iPhones and Android phones would be made and put into the hands of nearly every person on earth. They could have made exactly the same weak arguments you are making here of how it's not possible. But that's nonsense.

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by cm2187 on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @05:45AM (#31736634)
Plus the additional power generation.

But I tend to think this can be solved by the market. Look at the extent we go to find oil at sea. If there is a market, the production will ramp up. What I would be curious is if there is a physical supply of those materials in such volumes.

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by uluyol on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @06:08AM (#31736786)
Well how fast is capacity ramping up? And how much does the Earth have of these materials that we can sustainably harvest?

I don't know the answers to those questions, but it seems like you need to know that to determine whether 100% EV roads can actually work.

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by XorNot on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @06:41AM (#31737011)
This isn't an argument. You can't point to existing production in light of existing demand and say "this is insurmountable". You might as well be crying "we can't switch to electric cars! Where would we get all the electric cars from? Did you know that the current production of electric cars won't meet the demand if everyone switches?"

The question is whether the materials are fundamentally unavailable in the accessible environment.

Cobalt is only 140,000 metric tonnes per year, compared to an estimated 7.1 million tons currently known in reserves (and is a recyclable material).[1]

China alone has 44 million tons of known neodymium. Global production was only 280,000 tons in 2021 but was an increase over 2018 which was 190,000.[2]

Copper has known global reserves of 870 million tons, with 28 million tons a year of demand [3].

Lithium is the only resource where there's potentially an issue - known reserves are about 14 million tons, and production in 2018 was 85,000 tons so we have about 165 years worth at present rates but obviously that would increase. [4]

But all these materials are recyclable - aggressively so. Once they enter the industrial chain they leave it very slowly.

But what's strangest is the context: in a world where computers were expensive, then got so cheap we have them everywhere due to production efficiencies, suddenly on this issue capitalism cannot possibly work. There will only be more expensive goods forever, competition doesn't happen, a "gold rush" to find large reserves of demanded materials could not possibly result in a production boom.

[1] https://www.nsenergybusiness.com/features/largest-cobalt-res...

[2] https://investingnews.com/daily/resource-investing/critical-...

[3] https://copperalliance.org/sustainable-copper/about-copper/c...

[4] https://www.volkswagenag.com/en/news/stories/2020/03/lithium...

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by pornel on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @08:07AM (#31737942)
It's important to remember that EVs can be left charging unattended. This makes time requirements very different than filling up with gas.

If you park your car at home, leave it charging overnight. It doesn't matter if it will take 4, 8 or 12 hours — you have the whole night. Also it's unlikely that you will run it down to 0% every day, so you just need to top it up.

If you have a parking with chargers at work, you can plug it there. That's 8 hours when the car is sitting idle and could be charging. Or at a supermarket — plug it in when you're shopping. Even with a relatively slow charger you'll likely return home with more battery than you've left with. This is called destination charging, and these chargers are designed to top up your car while you're parked there for longer periods anyway.

Really fast charging is needed on road trips, but there you will want at least 100kW. For daily home use charging speed literally doesn't matter.

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by watt on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @06:52AM (#31737091)
You don't need 22kW charger if your car has 50kWh battery. Those cars usually have 11 kW on-board AC charger anyway. In fact, for daily driving, 3 kW overnight charging at your home should be plenty - you would be able to charge up 30 kWh in 10 hours.

22 kW chargers are for cars with ludicrously large battery, like Tesla Model X which has 100 kWh battery.

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by greenthrow on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @06:15AM (#31736830)
This is nonsense.

I have owned an EV for 8 years. It cost $300 to buy and install my EVSE ("charge station") because I already had a 240v plug in my garage. If a 240v line had to be run from my breaker box to my garage it would have been about $2k. But it also wouldn't have been necessary, as 110v charge speed would have been fine. Also that $300 got reimbursed via tax credit.

Stop pushing FUD. This is total nonsense. EV ownership is awesome and has been for years. The only issue is that people living in apartments or condos without a garage usually can't charge at home. These places need to start adding charging infrastructure to parking spaces.

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by nomel on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @12:38PM (#31741990)
> as 110v charge speed would have been fine.

Where I am in California, "super off peak" window is only 6 hours. Energy cost is double outside of that, in the regular "off peak", then quadruple outside of that. This would barely cover the average commute. With housing prices skyrocketing, especially those close to the cities, I think we'll see commutes increasing.

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by maeln on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @04:27AM (#31736176)
I have a Renault Zoe and I charge mostly outside on 22kW charger. The Zoe 2021 has a 42kW/h battery and it take ~2h to fully charge. I don't understand how you get to the 7h figure ?
Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by kuon on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @04:32AM (#31736197)
The car dealer told me he lives in a building with a common parking where the 22kW charger doesn't have 100% duty cycle.
Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by Faaak on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @04:52AM (#31736322)
There are plenty of super fast charging stations (DC) in switzerland (Gofast for example). You don't need 22kW at home. 7kW is plenty enough for a night charge.
Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by alkonaut on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @10:06AM (#31739707)
I have 3x25A fuses at 230V (which is normal here, you either have 3x20 or 3x25 typically) so I could probably run a 22kW charger. But I couldn't run it and run much other stuff at the same time!

I guess the solution is to have something store the capacity, i.e. a second battery. If one really needs to charge at home very quickly (e.g. you are a taxi driver or have some other specific reason) and you can't overload the grid, then the solution must be to slowly charge a battery at home when the car is used, just like most EV owners slowly charge the car over night. Then the home battery can be quickly emptied into the car for a fast charge. In the end, it's just like having 2EVs where one is charging while the other isn't. And of course, buying a 100kWh wall battery is going to also set you back a large part of the cost of a second car too, just like your $20k for a better electricity connection. BUT - the dual battery solution doesn't have the tragedy of the commons issue where not everyone can do it. I doubt more than a single digit % would ever consider needing fast charge at home though.

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by marklubi on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @05:42AM (#31736611)
The problem that I have with the all electric movement is that all of the expectations don't match up with the numbers.

For instance, a new Ford Lightning can power a house for days.

Lets turn this around a bit... To charge your vehicle, it requires multiple days of typical household energy usage.

This doesn't make sense.

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by Gare on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @05:57AM (#31736717)
What doesn't make sense? That traveling by car is extremely energy intensive?
Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by hutzlibu on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @06:19AM (#31736850)
Yeah, also it is quite a surprise for most people, how ridiculous inefficient ICE engines are. Most of the chemic energy just goes into the air as heat. That only worked, because oil was (and still is relativly) so cheap.
Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by marklubi on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @06:30AM (#31736931)
Are you intentionally being obtuse? My point was very clear.
Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by SigmundA on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @07:15AM (#31737327)
The 80 amp charger that allows backfeeding to run the house will charge the lightning in 8 hours, the included 32 amp charger that plugs into a dryer outlet will do it in 19 hours, still less than a day.

There are no loads in your house that will pull 80 amps continuous for 8 hours which is why it can run an average house for days while only taking 8 hours to charge. Your average house has 200 amp service which is normally enough to support the additional charge load.

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by XorNot on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @06:48AM (#31737059)
> Lets turn this around a bit... To charge your vehicle, it requires multiple days of typical household energy usage.

> This doesn't make sense.

Sure it does: you do not actually use a lot of electricity in your house on average. By far the biggest user after you get a Lightning would be charging the lightning.

Your home electrical connection's total capacity is already over-sized relative to your average usage.

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by greenthrow on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @07:02AM (#31737188)
> Lets turn this around a bit... To charge your vehicle, it requires multiple days of typical household energy usage.

Powering your ICE car takes far, far more energy. But you don't think about it because it is in the form lf a toxic liquid sloshing around.

EVs are far, far more efficient than any ICE car.

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by imtringued on Wednesday June 15, 2022 @03:50AM (#31750229)
What? It just means it has a massive energy capacity.
Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by clouddrover on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @03:56AM (#31735998)
You can also have a large battery buffer supporting standard chargers. Or battery integrated chargers are also interesting because they're fast to deploy and cheap to install (though the individual units are more expensive due to the battery):

https://www.bp.com/en/global/corporate/news-and-insights/pre...

https://freewiretech.com/products/dc-boost-charger-200/

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by pmuk on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @06:55AM (#31737113)
If you have the space, you could install close to 20kW of solar PV for $20,000. On a sunny day this would help power a 22kW charging station, and even on a cloudy day you'd probably get around 2kW for trickle charging.
Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by nomel on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @12:32PM (#31741877)
For me, and I think most that use their cars often, the vehicle is driving/away from the house during the day.
Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by CuriousSkeptic on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @03:54AM (#31735985)
When would you need fast charging at home?
Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by kuon on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @04:17AM (#31736129)
Well, I looked at our current use of the cars. I live in a remote area and car is my only option. Also the area is mountainous and after doing some testing and having the car for a week, I have about 100km autonomy with 50kW/h battery when driving around, after that at around 10%, the car turns on low power mode and is very slow (I'd say dangerous) to drive.

On a typical day, my wife does about 40km, so everything is fine, but twice a week I have to go to the music school with my kids and it's 60km away (120km round trip), so I have to be sure to be on a full charge before leaving as I cannot charge the car there, and the time I have to charge the car before leaving is about 2h.

And this is for one car, I also have a car for my business. I didn't plan to switch to electric yet, but I know I'll have too, thus the 22kW charging station to have some margin to be able to charge them both.

Also, the utility have to upgrade the cables even for 11kW, and the price isn't very different.

The car I tested is a Toyota Proace.

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by patd on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @04:40AM (#31736244)
That car is probably very inefficient as it's not very aerodynamic. If you need that van, you probably need the 75kWh version.

If you don't have many kids, you should probably look at cars that are only electric and designed for it: Tesla, Polestar, VW ID.3/4, Skoda Enyaq, Volva XC40 Recharge, ... You'll get better regenerative break which means that you'll recharge your battery when going downhill and better efficiency.

Without any changes to your home, you can charge your car at 3.6kW and there might be public chargers at 11kW around where you live and shop. I've spent a few weeks with a Tesla Model 3 SR+ (50kW battery) in the mountains of the Val d'Anniviers (Valais) where I couldn't charge at the chalet and I didn't have any issue to drive around and find chargers.

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by magicalhippo on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @06:37AM (#31736988)
> That car is probably very inefficient as it's not very aerodynamic.

Definitely inefficient. My 2017 leaf with a 24kWh battery can do ~120km before it starts reducing output (20% limit).

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by ZeroGravitas on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @04:26AM (#31736163)
EVs should overperform in comparison with ICE at high altitudes and in hilly regions, due to less efficient burning and the ability to regen.

Remote areas with unpredictable usage is probably their weak spot, but a hybrid should still be a solid option for the same reasons EVs work well in the mountains.

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by eimrine on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @07:10AM (#31737265)
> EVs should overperform in comparison with ICE at high altitudes and in hilly regions, due to less efficient burning and the ability to regen.

How about super inefficient work on low revolutions per second mode which is typical for going uphill? And can you really produce any significant measure of energy using recuperation?

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by ZeroGravitas on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @10:34AM (#31740145)
Yes, in stop and go traffic and/or undulating terrain, regen can be a big factor in EVs much higher efficiency than ICE, more than overcoming any loss due to extra weight.
Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by kuon on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @04:30AM (#31736186)
Yes, I am looking at plug in hybrid now.
Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by kwhitefoot on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @06:15AM (#31736827)
Try a more efficient car with a larger battery. You can get EVs with well over 400 km range now. Even my 2015 Model S 70D (70 kWh, four wheel drive) has 330 km range. And it doesn't get dangerously slow at 10% charge.
Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by nomel on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @12:42PM (#31742062)
Used 2015 Model S 70D are going for > $40k right now. In most peoples eyes, paying that much for a used electric with a 7 year old battery is insane.
Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by kwhitefoot on Wednesday June 15, 2022 @03:17AM (#31750038)
I wasn't suggesting that anyone should buy my car. I was pointing out that even my car seems usable and that newer models are much better.

> In most peoples eyes, paying that much for a used electric with a 7 year old battery is insane.

Obviously not in the eyes of the people who are part of that market or the price would be lower. But I get your point.

Nonetheless there are quite a few brand new EVs available at that price and lower. Even in 2021 there were about 15 EV models available in the US at less than that brand new, see https://insideevs.com/news/534027/electric-car-prices-us-202...

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by gregoriol on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @03:58AM (#31736016)
While not strictly useful at home, the problem of connecting to the grid would be the same for many places you could go and need fast charging.
Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by Schroedingersat on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @09:08AM (#31738856)
You don't need a fast charger at home though. 2kW on off-peak hours is fine. That's >100kWh per week.

Save the fast charger for the road trip or for the people with the 1hr commute to use on the way home when they top up once a fortnight.

Or better yet start building infrastructure for a less insane and stupid transport method and transition away from cars altogether.

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by DrScientist on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @05:58AM (#31736728)
If charging is 5 mins, then not everyone needs to charge at home. That's the importance of fast charging - not the convenience.

For example, everybody seems to manage without a petrol pump at home.

If you have dedicated charging stations - then the problem becomes simpler than providing high power to every home.

Still a challenge - but not quite so insurmountable.

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by yunohn on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @05:06AM (#31736411)
> the grid is not ready, we would need to upgrade hundred of meters of cable

I would compare this to the last-mile issues facing internet connections, eg gigabit fiber.

It’s a chicken-egg problem with not enough electric car demand leading to energy companies deciding that it’s not worth providing the right supply.

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by pkphilip on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @06:42AM (#31737015)
This is why a solution like using Hydrogen makes a lot more sense than using pure EVs - even if the efficiencies are lower than in battery driven vehicles.
Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by megablast on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @04:04AM (#31736054)
Electric cars are clearly not the solution.
Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by ZeroGravitas on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @03:58AM (#31736017)
No one needs a 22KW charger in their home.

The speed you quote for a shared 22KW with multiple cars charging is the same as a standard home 7KW charger (e.g. 60Kwh car charging to full from 0 while you sleep for 8 hours, or 2 of those cars charging from 20-80%). But no one drives that many miles per day consistently.

Most normal people can survive with a standard plug, even the 7KW is a luxury to let you think less about it and to help the grid by charging faster when the grid is off peak, enabling faster rollout of cheap renewables.

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by kuon on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @04:37AM (#31736226)
As I said in another comment, I don't absolutely need 22kW now. But I am at the limit of the capacity of my current line, so in all scenarios, I would need to invest quite a bit.
Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by ZeroGravitas on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @04:45AM (#31736279)
Buying a lot of something because it would cost the same for a small amount and 'needing' the larger amount are different things.

22Kw is still overkill for a home, even if it makes sense financially if the costs are mostly fixed based on things other than charging rate.

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by nomel on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @12:44PM (#31742086)
> 22Kw is still overkill for a home

I know many homes with three adults (one driving parent, two kids) who have cars. 22kW isn't enough to charge three cars + home. It's not that crazy, considering the average home has 1.9 cars.