News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by Philip-J-Fry on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @03:57AM (#31736010)
Ok, so there's a key point here, and that's that fast charging is not meant for the home!

You can fully charge an EV overnight on a 7KW charger. You don't need a fast charger at home.

The other thing is that home chargers are AC and the car converts the current. This means that there's a cap to how much power you can give it. For example, my car can only accept 11KW and that's pretty typical. So 22KW chargers are a waste at home today.

Maybe you'd need a fast charger at home if you never sleep. But the majority of people spend at least 7 hours at home. You'll always wake up to a fully charged car. Why do you need anything else?

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by janlaureys on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @04:01AM (#31736034)
Hell I park my car in an underground parking garage, and it's been a whole discussion about who wants to and how they want to install 7kW/11/kW chargers. In the meantime I just charge it on the wall plug now and then. Yeah sometimes my battery is not fully charged, but I hardly ever drive 450km in one go anyway.
Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by Symbiote on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @06:57AM (#31737127)
A few years ago one of my neighbours asked for a socket in the underground car park.

I assume they paid the full cost themselves, although it probably wasn't that much -- the electrical supply to the building including the meters for each apartment are just behind his parking space. They installed a normal 16A 400V 3P+E plug (the big red one), which is an easy 11kW. There isn't any sort of 'car charger' on the wall, just this socket.

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by cbozeman on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @05:09AM (#31736422)
> You don't need a fast charger at home.

This is such an arrogant statement.

I may not "need" 3 petabytes of storage for my home media server, but I have it.

I may not "need" a 64-core Threadripper 3990X workstation with 256 GB of RAM, but I have it.

I may not "need" enterprise-grade networking and WiFi gear, but I have it.

I may not "need" a 60 kW Kohler diesel generator, but I have it.

> Why do you need anything else?

Because he wants it. The same reason I have everything I listed.

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by Philip-J-Fry on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @05:46AM (#31736641)
>This is such an arrogant statement.

It's not an arrogant statement. A lot of people don't understand how electric cars work.

It's one of the biggest things holding them back. I still hear people saying "I don't want to spend 30 minutes recharging every week" when you don't need to. You can plug in a car overnight. But people struggle to understand that you can wake up every day with a "full tank" which is something a fossil fuel vehicle can't do. It requires thinking about your usage of a vehicle differently.

>Because he wants it. The same reason I have everything I listed.

I ask the question because, again, people don't understand how electric cars work. A lot of people think a 22KW charger at home will be like a 22KW DC charger.

It's an attempt to gauge the actual reasoning behind wanting it. If his reasoning is to be future proof, then that's fine, it's perfectly reasonable to want that. But if his reasoning is to charge at 22KW then it's just a misunderstanding and something we can help him understand.

Don't assume everyone asking questions is being naive or dismissive.

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by coderenegade on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @06:03AM (#31736758)
I don't think it's that people don't understand how electric cars work, because I don't think that gives people enough credit. I think it's more that BEV advocates misunderstand how other people buy vehicles, or rather, they might have different purchasing habits because they skew wealthy.

I don't buy a vehicle for the average use case -- I buy it for the edge cases. When I need to be able to move stuff or tow a trailer, I can. If I needed to cross the country tonight because of a family emergency, I could. I think this is a fairly common mindset for most people, because after a house, a car is the most expensive thing we'll ever own. The cost and continued upkeep mandates that a vehicle has utility beyond what a person needs on average.

You're right that most people don't need a 22kW charger for their car, and they can wake up with a full tank every morning, but most people are probably also averse to the idea that their car has a downtime of several hours when they might really need it. You aren't just paying for the privilege of going from A to B, because if that's all it were, you could just call a cab -- part of owning and paying the upkeep for a car is that you're able to go right now when you need to.

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by XorNot on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @06:46AM (#31737039)
In all those use cases though you are anywhere but your home. So you would be using fast chargers provided in the same way gas stations are.

The situation you're describing is "I drive enough to drain my car completely, then take it home to recharge it, then immediately plan to do that again within 30 minutes of going home, and will never stop at a fast charger on that journey which can be completed within the 450km range of my battery".

It's conceivable, but so convoluted that it would never happen.

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by coderenegade on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @07:46AM (#31737699)
The situation I'm describing is any trip for which the potential of waiting an hour (or more, in many cases) at a fast charger is problematic. My car can be nearly empty in my driveway, and it costs me two minutes to fill it up. This means that if I needed to sprint to the state border before it closed (a real-life scenario for several of my coworkers during COVID), I could. Ditto for any other situation where you might be time pressed. A BEV is charged every time you take it out, but it also needs to be, because charging isn't a two minute thing. Like it or not, this affects its utility relative to a standard vehicle, in certain situations. Maybe it's a 1% kind of thing, but again, I'm not convinced that most of us buy cars for the average use case. If we did, SUVs wouldn't be the highest selling segment of the market.
Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by imtringued on Wednesday June 15, 2022 @03:33AM (#31750124)
It takes me more than two minutes to fill my car up.
Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by carlmr on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @09:08AM (#31738846)
>The cost and continued upkeep mandates that a vehicle has utility beyond what a person needs on average.

Exactly! I hate the 90% of drives are less than 50km argument which is always made about range issues. I don't want to buy another car for the 10%.

Also I take the train to work, I walk/cycle to the store. Almost all my driving is for hiking, climbing, skiing, or other vacations. I won't buy a car that has a max range with a new battery and no AC on that just barely gets me there and back.

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by Philip-J-Fry on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @12:06PM (#31741436)
You don't buy another car for the 10%. EVs do more than 50km...

You rent a car for the case where you're going over 400km and charging is an issue. Probably 0.1% of trips, maybe less.

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by carlmr on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @01:54PM (#31743270)
400km is already only with new battery and no AC on most affordable EVs.

And I do 400km trips most of the months, it's definitely more than 0.1% for me.

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by turtlebits on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @10:11AM (#31739777)
Sorry, but that makes no sense. You can also wake up to a car with no gas. So your dilemma will be to either get gas to your home (will likely require another vehicle) or to plug in (until you have range get to a fast charge- or just let it charge)

And yes, you can make that cross country trip in an EV. It will probably take longer (2-3 hours spent fast charging).

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by nomel on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @12:23PM (#31741710)
I did this last weekend, and it single handedly killed my desire to go all electric. I reserved two cars at two different rental agencies, showed up, and both said they had no cars. Another two didn't have the size I needed (+1 of ICE car capacity). The final one ended up costing $200/day, all after a few hours driving around town. This was just a random weekend. I can't imagine if there was any sort of desire to leave town, amongst the larger population. I'll be keeping my ICE car to go along with my electric, even if it just sits there, rusting. With that three day weekend excursion, I've paid for 13 months of my ICE car insurance.
Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by Philip-J-Fry on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @07:10AM (#31737267)
>I don't buy a vehicle for the average use case -- I buy it for the edge cases. When I need to be able to move stuff or tow a trailer, I can. If I needed to cross the country tonight because of a family emergency, I could. I think this is a fairly common mindset for most people,

That really isn't the common mindset. If it was, everyone would be driving huge 7 seater trucks for the edge case where they need to haul some lumber with their 7 person family.

Most people buy a car for their typical needs. If they want to move a lot of stuff, they rent a van or a trailer.

If you needed to cross the country tonight because of a family emergency you could do that in any car, EV or fossil fuel. A modern EV might take you longer because of charging stops, but when you factor in scheduled breaks of a typical cross country drive, the charging times don't actually add up to a lot more at all.

>You're right that most people don't need a 22kW charger for their car, and they can wake up with a full tank every morning, but most people are probably also averse to the idea that their car has a downtime of several hours when they might really need it

If you need a full car then you drive to a fast charger and charge it. They exist for this exact purpose of needing a fast charge.

I can charge my car to 80% in like 20 minutes.

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by throw0101a on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @07:24AM (#31737443)
> That really isn't the common mindset. If it was, everyone would be driving huge 7 seater trucks for the edge case where they need to haul some lumber with their 7 person family.

> Most people buy a car for their typical needs. If they want to move a lot of stuff, they rent a van or a trailer.

The top three selling vehicles in the US are F-150, Ram 1500/2500/3500, and Chevrolet Silverado:

* https://www.caranddriver.com/news/g36005989/best-selling-car...

* https://www.edmunds.com/most-popular-cars/

The F-series has been on the top of the list for decades.

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by Philip-J-Fry on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @12:07PM (#31741461)
This doesn't hold true for anywhere outside of the US.
Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by coderenegade on Wednesday June 15, 2022 @07:27AM (#31751455)
Do SUVs count? They're one of the top selling vehicle classes in most countries, and aside from BEVs, the only one seeing significant growth. China has seen higher adoption of SUVs over the last decade than the US.
Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by imtringued on Wednesday June 15, 2022 @03:30AM (#31750098)
I'm surprised to hear that the people going on 400km trips every month aren't the wealthy ones. I only drive 1000km per month. A 400km trip+return is 80% of my monthly commute meaning it would double my fuel expenses from roughly 120€ to 240€ per month.
Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by CHY872 on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @06:23AM (#31736877)
Yeah no. GP is arguing that most people should not buy an electric car for a reason that's invalid for the 99th percentile of people, and saying that it's too expensive to install a solution that is not what you need to make an electric car viable.

I can go buy a $50k top of rack switch to route data between my WiFi APs, yes, and I might want to! But it's not valid to then go around telling people that they're not ready for multiple access points because the tech to link them costs $50k. And it's certainly not 'arrogant' to correct people of their misconceptions, because this is a huge EV misconception.

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by dendriti on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @05:38AM (#31736585)
Please calm down. No one is attacking you. The point is, MOST people don't have a 3990X at home, because they don't need it, and MOST people won't have a fast charger at home, because they don't need it.
Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by sorenjan on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @06:54AM (#31737106)
What you're describing is over consumption, and it's what got us in the mess we're in and trying to fix. Everyone have a legal right to buy more than they need because they want it, that doesn't mean they should.

Flying on vacation, buying new clothes from the other side of the world each month, replacing a fully working car with a new one, having the AC blasting in a poorly insulated house, etc, these things all have a cost to the system but people have started thinking of these excesses as rights.

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by revertmean on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @06:20AM (#31736852)
> I may not "need" a 60 kW Kohler diesel generator, but I have it.

Those run about $20k don't they? If you'd come on here complaining that generator technology wasn't ready yet because you'd been quoted $20k for your 60kW Kohler, you'd probably get the same response: you don't really need it.

GP clearly doesn't want that 22kW charging station that much, because they've been told how much it costs (same as your generator) and they're unwilling to pay that.

And they don't need it.

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by Schroedingersat on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @09:11AM (#31738896)
You're the one being arrogant here.

If what you want requires most of the city infrastructure to be rebuilt then you can pay for it.

If you can't afford to pay for a new gas electric plant plus externalities and new poles with thicker wires then tough. Don't demand handouts.

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by koide on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @02:51PM (#31744178)
The ability of getting everything one wants just because one can is not a good thing, in my view.

Also, how is this relevant to the point above? One point is it's too expensive - so even if he wants it he might not be able to get it in the current reality. The counterpoint is that you can charge your car with a slower charger.

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by sshagent on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @06:13AM (#31736811)
3 pb home media storage. Nice indeed. I'm impressed
Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by cbozeman on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @06:57PM (#31747034)
It was luck, honestly. I got three WD Ultrastar Data60s from a friend whose company was upgrading to some even more ridiculous storage solution. They were letting them go for $10,000 each or so, populated with 14 TB drives, so I went for all three.

I fully expect that I won't have to upgrade storage for the rest of my life, because, honestly... I don't know where we go past 4K. 8K is just dumb for everyone unless you have a 200 foot screen that you sit 10 feet away from or so. As far as games go, yes, they're approaching 250 GB, but there does come a point where textures, models, and sound will become "good enough". I figure 1 TB games will be pretty much "the end", but then again... the first computer I got was 28 years ago and had a 540 MB hard drive, but in fairness, that seemed small even back then.

I guess some day someone will bitch that their computer only has 6 PB of storage...

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by sshagent on Wednesday June 15, 2022 @07:00PM (#31760534)
Thanks for the reply, lovely stuff.

I've only recently really started to bring my hardware back home and only have a few TB. I don't mind purchase price for hardware, but it's the power consumption that's an issue. Especially as our electricity has gone up 60% a few months ago, and likely going up again October.

My day job is scooping up film data, and if my last 15 years here has shown me anything were always going to need more disk. Staying at 4k the be lovely.

Re:Electric vehicle battery capable of 98% charge in less th... by MrMan on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @07:42AM (#31737661)
you sound like the arrogant one, to be honest