News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by strogonoff on Saturday June 11, 2022 @05:03AM (#31703040)
The problem I have with blockchain enthusiasts, after talking with them about their philosophy, is that they seem to consider trust a bug, and believe that ideal world is achievable with straitjackets of technical solutions that eliminate trust.

Trust is a feature, not a bug. If trust is violated by rogue agents, it is because they exist[0], not because trust itself is a folly.

However, blockchain-adjacent initiatives seem to suggest a future where we implicitly label[1] every human as motivated to hurt another by making all aspects of their activities subject to verification checks.

In addition to strong dystopian vibes, won’t this act of labeling everyone as potential threat actually be instrumental in bringing this motivation to everyone, making it a self-fulfilling prophecy? Aren’t we sort of codifying malicious intent, instead of trying to remove it from the equation? Whom would this serve?

There is place for verification in the interim, such as maintaining security of your home, but if we are looking ahead (as blockchain enthusiasts do) we should strive for a future where humans are not motivated to hurt other humans. Not treating it as some sort of default is a good start.

[0] Their core motivation to benefit at others’ expense is to me indicative of mental health issues, possibly caused by insecurity and upbringing trauma.

[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Labeling_theory

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by kibwen on Saturday June 11, 2022 @07:31AM (#31703701)
Even without considering the social benefits of trust, from an economic perspective, trust is often enormously, ridiculously efficient compared to distrust. If I need to borrow my neighbor's weed whacker, I don't need to determine its value (plus interest and opportunity cost) and write up a contract and register collateral on the world's slowest and least efficient database, I can just say, hey, mind if I borrow this? Trust and reputation are force multipliers.
Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by Vetch on Saturday June 11, 2022 @10:34AM (#31704705)
Trust is an ideal to strive towards but the unfortunate case is that its reliability quickly starts to strain with scale. I'd argue the economy at large is held together not by trust but by reputation, curation, regulation and threat of lawsuits and jail time. With the last concentrating trust in legal institutions, overall reducing trust burden.

In many countries, the richest companies operate unethically, with impunity because the legal system is in the pocket of a corrupt few in power. In such countries trust in institutions is nonexistent. In developed economies, regulatory capture still leads to inequities and gross inefficiencies.

Today on the internet, reviews and product search results can no longer be trusted. For a very long while, buying from a large class of products on Amazon was a gamble. A breakdown in reputation and curation.

Computing environments were originally high trust, a property they could not retain at scale. Encryption, https everywhere, anti-ad tracking, secure VMs, gated app stores, "Don't trust the client" designs, onion routers, anti binary blobs are technologies and principles which reduce the need for trust. Technologies like DRM, copy protection rootkits and Trusted Computing are corporations communicating their lack of trust in humans inhumanly.

There's always some minimal amount of trust necessary. The optimal minimum generally decreases with scale. Hawala might seem an exception but closer inspection shows it depends on shared belief systems, local interactions on reputation networks and honor; memes which reduce trust burden at scale.

I'd also argue bitcoin isn't about trust but about issues which arise with open permissions and no centralized enforcement mechanism. Its throughput issues addressed by "layer 2" solutions, as decentralized credit networks (from a dispute and authority perspective), actually have fair overlap with honor based informal money transfer systems but without the centuries to have ironed out issues.

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by Schroedingersat on Saturday June 11, 2022 @03:38PM (#31707543)
Then the solution is clearly to reduce scale where possible.

Many of the things that scale is being forced into don't actually increase their net benefit to the people with scale (usually it is the opposite when you consider the requisite slavery/coups/wars/etc. to provide the infrastructure and labour), merely the amount that can be extracted by some centralized entity.

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by rglullis on Saturday June 11, 2022 @11:01AM (#31704925)
Now, let's say that you have a car that you'd like to put in a "social car-sharing app." Those participating get an opportunity to make some money, those without cars would benefit from having an increased supply, and your city would benefit because that would mean that the increased utilization of the car fleet would lead to less parking spaces being needed.

Question: how would you do that without rent-extracting middlemen? And even if you are willing to accept a middlemen, why do you think this type of service is not available today? Assume that all the legal barriers for it could be removed - your insurance policy gives you exemption to this and you can have a standard contract defining what would happen in case someone driving your car got involved in an accident, or if you car got stolen by a driver, etc.

If you think that doing that with a car is too complicated, or if you are a cycling advocate: same thing, but for bikes.

Just to make my point explicit: the idea of "trustlessness" is not to get rid of the "trust" in the existing activities that can be handled at the local/"human" scale. The idea is to be able to enable these kind of activities at the higher levels that the institutions (formal or informal) can not cover. If there are things that we can do without a blockchain, great! But think of all the applications that can not be done at all today just because we don't have the tools to enforce the "rules" at a larger scale.

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by topkai22 on Saturday June 11, 2022 @01:10PM (#31706097)
How do you deal with a dispute about a messy car? Or if the car pickup had no gas? Or a disputed theft of personal possessions?

Middleman add value by dealing with edge cases and aggregating trust. They aren’t pure rent extractors.

We had hyper well defined ride sharing system with clear rules unbiased rules, high anonymity, focused on individual providers prior to Uber and Lyft- Taxis. People hated it, as it was rife with little abuses. Uber, Lyft, and similar provide a ton of value by brokering trust between the provider and rider.

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by rglullis on Saturday June 11, 2022 @02:02PM (#31706592)
Up until 4 years ago, there was no practical way to have a money exchange without a middleman. Today we have all the Uniswap-style decentralized exchange who makes more transaction volume than all of the other centralized exchanges, and do it without wash trading, and no operator can steal or embezzle the funds.

To get this, all it was needed was to have a protocol, namely the Automatic Market Maker system popularized by Uniswap.

Protocol is what we need, not platforms.

One protocol being developed to deal with conflict resolution is https://kleros.io. A decentralized car sharing company could work initially just like a regular car-rental company, by having the renter providing an deposit to cover for damages and refunded when the vehicle is returned in acceptable conditions. In case of small disputes, a pre-arranged third party works as a arbiter. And in the case where there are some serious problems, actual courts and the "traditional" institutions should be there to execute their role.

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by t-3 on Saturday June 11, 2022 @01:53PM (#31706487)
The only real difference between an Uber and a taxi from a customer POV is the price. Not sure what trust has to do with it.
Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by marssaxman on Sunday June 12, 2022 @09:55AM (#31714521)
I don't even know what the price of a taxi is anymore. That is the least important difference!

An Uber or a Lyft will actually show up - and quickly - when I call it; will actually take me where I want to go without wasting time running up the meter; and will actually charge me in a fair and predictable way, which does not involve dickering with the driver or unexpectedly having to find a bunch of cash because the card reader is "broken".

All of these things can be reasonably summarized as forms of trustworthiness.

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by rglullis on Saturday June 11, 2022 @02:04PM (#31706609)
Not to mention that if Über really provided "tons of value", they would've been profitable by now. But they only got popular because they have Softbank subsidizing riders for over 10 years already.
Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by a_t48 on Saturday June 11, 2022 @11:48AM (#31705378)
Do Getaround/Zipcar/Turo not fit what you’re talking about?
Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by rglullis on Saturday June 11, 2022 @11:52AM (#31705415)
They lease their own fleets, no? I am talking about the a system where individuals can put their own vehicles in the "market" for others to use.

Edit: Okay. I am checking Turo now, I wasn't aware of them. Still, they are a middleman between car owner and driver, right? How do they make money?

Edit 2: Reading from their website, it seems like they are focusing on being a rental aggregator. All the talk about "building your business" seems to indicate their cars are not from individual owners that actually use the car. So, no, I wouldn't say they qualify as an alternative to what I am talking about.

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by towaway15463 on Saturday June 11, 2022 @10:30AM (#31704675)
This is an important observation. Your neighbour trusts you because of the relationship you have with them, your membership in the same group (home ownership in a neighborhood), proximity and availability (they know where you live and can contact you easily if they want the weedwhacker back), and you already have collateral in play (ownership of your home and reputation in the community).

The key to building trust online is to recreate some of these aspects. You should have an identity in the community that you belong to and you should own assets under that identity so you can’t easily abandon it and start somewhere else with your ill gotten gains. Communication amongst members of the community should be easy and common. There should even be shared ownership of community assets and the community should provide services to its members.

I imagine this looking something like a discord server combined with some of the hosting features of FB like image sharing, posts, groups, etc. You’d also need a built in token that could be used within the community but also exchanged on a broader network of federated communities.

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by Schroedingersat on Saturday June 11, 2022 @03:34PM (#31707515)
Even further if your neighbor totally trusts you you can just go grab it and they will know that it will be back where it belongs, fully fueled/charged and maintained when needed.

This drive to atomize humanity and make all relationships fungible is insane, and the only benefit is it allows long distance fuedalism.

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by t-3 on Saturday June 11, 2022 @01:51PM (#31706458)
Trust isn't necessary for lending tools to your neighbor, pure self-interest is good enough. Cultivating good relationships with people who know where you sleep is just good sense, and looking out for your neighborhood is mutual aid. Next to reason, trust is inconsequential in such a situation.
Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by pibechorro on Saturday June 11, 2022 @08:02AM (#31703863)
Slowest and least efficient.. you realize some blockchains update in seconds? For a low value proposition like borrowing a lawnmower you dont need the most secure public network on earth to do it. You use the right blocchain for the right applications.

The problem with trust, is that its awesome until it aint. When we are deaing with gov policy, billions of dollars, war, your life savings,etc a break in trust is beyond costly, making the use cost of a slower but secure blockchain the responsible thing to do.

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by nonameiguess on Saturday June 11, 2022 @08:25AM (#31703955)
So war on the blockchain? That sounds like a good example of what is meant by "dystopian." Imagine a world where whether Ukraine gets to stay sovereign or becomes part of Russia is determined by a global consensus of the wealthiest wallet addresses on a blockchain. It's like you took democracy, but got rid of the elements of constitutional republicanism that mitigate the weaknesses of democracy, leaving only the weaknesses. Except not really, because that would be a plain tyranny of the majority of unique human persons and this is a tyranny of a majority of wealth, which may only be a tiny number of people. I guess it's more like returning to feudalism, except the lords and kings no longer have to raise armies and fight each other. The richest coalition just wins automatically.
Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by gumby on Saturday June 11, 2022 @09:11AM (#31704194)
> Imagine a world where whether Ukraine gets to stay sovereign or becomes part of Russia is determined by a global consensus of the wealthiest wallet addresses on a blockchain.

Actully, this is basically what’s happening in your example.

The citizens of the wealthiest countries are participating in the war by sending armaments and aid to Ukraine. The majority of the world’s citizens* are sitting it out or providing some amount of assistance to the Russian side, mainly through commerce.

It’s not on the blockchain, but essentially wealth is “voting”.

FWIW I’m far, far from being a blockchain supporter. I’m just addressing your example.

* yes, at the UN the majority states voted against Russia, but if you look by populations, the west won an “electoral college” victory on the topic.

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by jnovek on Saturday June 11, 2022 @10:50AM (#31704835)
I think the point is that it’s just a change of venue for making consensus; the roles don’t change.

A small number of people with lots of resources choose whether a large number of people with few resources fight each other to the death.

GGP implied that war was something a blockchain could “fix”, but GP argues that it, at best, it maintains the status quo.

In my opinion, it’s a little worse than the status quo because at least before those with few resources got some small say in the matter via their elected representatives.

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by gumby on Saturday June 11, 2022 @09:06AM (#31704163)
> Slowest and least efficient.. you realize some blockchains update in seconds?

Imagine if when you pushed the “buy now” button on Amazon it took seconds for the transaction to complete. You’d stop using Amazon.

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by ntoskrnl on Saturday June 11, 2022 @09:27AM (#31704281)
It already does take seconds. Sometimes even minutes or hours. When you click "buy now", Amazon optimistically pretends the order completed instantly, and queues a backend job to charge your card. If your card is declined, you get an email some time later.
Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by moritonal on Saturday June 11, 2022 @10:18AM (#31704600)
It's almost as if they use trust to be efficient.
Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by actionablefiber on Saturday June 11, 2022 @09:26AM (#31704275)
I agree it's inefficient, but, um, that happens to me all the time when I'm in a part of my house where the Wi-Fi doesn't reach very well, and I still go to that part of the house and I still use Amazon in it. Waiting 10 seconds for an order confirmation is not a big deal if the result is I can get a rice cooker shipped to my house within 24 hours.
Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by rglullis on Saturday June 11, 2022 @06:23AM (#31703404)
> The problem with blockchainers

It's hard to take any of what you say seriously when you start a comment with such a blanket statement.

Also, I think I've already seen your type of "argument" so many times, I think I am able to just play the whole tape by just pointing out to previous comments I've made:

- https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31195939 / https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31545427 (trustlessness is not about "eliminating trust")

- https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31463534 (Yeah, you are right that there is no such thing as an "ideal" world. What you are missing is that also applies to the anti-crypto mentality, who think that just because they were born in a place with functional institutions, they think that is the natural state of things. It's good when institutions work, but they are not perfect and we need to prepared for the times when they fail.)

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by strogonoff on Saturday June 11, 2022 @06:47AM (#31703503)
Then fix your institutions. Do you believe you can solve a human problem by forcing a technical solution? Don’t you think you will have to end up duplicating the very same institutions (possibly with more friction, less oversight and ways to appeal)? And if you go full freedom and anarchy, then drop into chaos until command economy next door eats you for lunch?

Besides, we are talking about attitudes very much in countries with more or less functional institutions.

Also, edited first paragraph to be less dogmatic. This is my subjective opinion.

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by rglullis on Saturday June 11, 2022 @06:54AM (#31703542)
See, I know that I can keep up this by simply linking to previous comments. This one is from one year ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25906731 (Tell me how a dissenting Russian or Chinese would go around "fixing their institutions")

Edit: Though I do agree that BTC has failed and I now think that Ethereum (the blockchain, not saying anything about Ether as a "currency") is more suited to this, here is something from 8 years ago!! https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8413908

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by strogonoff on Saturday June 11, 2022 @07:52AM (#31703815)
Personally, even if my opinions have not shifted at all (which barely ever happens), I practice having to express them again so that I find more eloquent ways of doing so. Once they solidify enough, I might write an essay I could mention I wrote, but in most scenarios I wouldn’t refer someone to my own quotes out of respect.

I hold others to the same standard, so for the record I’m not reading links to your own comments.

Imagine people talking by a water cooler; yes I know roughly your view, and you know mine, but it doesn’t mean you should mandate me to hear quotes of yourself recorded at this same water cooler in the past instead of responding.

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by rglullis on Saturday June 11, 2022 @08:29AM (#31703976)
> I might write an essay

Even if I went through all the trouble of writing an essay, it would be a simple collage of all these arguments, maybe organized in some more coherent form. For what? Those "in favor" would just not see anything new, those "against" it would just use it to nitpick and create strawmen in an attempt to keep their worldview intact.

I'd rather keep the discussion focused on the parts that can be addressed directly to avoid this.

> I practice having to express them again so that I find more eloquent ways of doing so.

I've gotten to the point where I discussed this with so many people that I ran out of ways of conveying the same idea. I am not putting the links out of snark. I am putting them because they already express the same idea that I would've typed out anyway. Would you feel better if I simply copied-and-pasted these responses?

> Imagine people talking by a water cooler; yes I know roughly your view, and you know mine.

I am not telling you to listen to all the battle cries or the "put downs" that have been recorded. I was using these links as a way to advance the conversation to a point where we can actually establish the differences. Can you imagine if everybody only wanted to debate something if they re-hashed all their priors?

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by JohnHaugeland on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @09:13AM (#31738938)
> See, I know that I can keep up this by simply linking to previous comments.

As long as you don't mind that nobody but you is convinced at the end, perhaps

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by rglullis on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @02:17PM (#31743603)
You are missing the point. I know the people arguing based on these old misconceptions are not going to be convinced anyway. I am linking to previous comments to avoid having to re-hash the same pointless argument every time.
Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by hetspookjee on Saturday June 11, 2022 @06:30AM (#31703432)
Sometimes I dream of a argument recogniser that just maps out an argument on an argument map and hashes it out more or less like you just did. With the goal of not endless rehashing of the same iteration like some stuck genetic algo in a local optima, but rather moving forward as some kind of warm start.
Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by oldsj on Saturday June 11, 2022 @10:49AM (#31704826)
I think there's something to this and have been thinking about this for a while too. Just today tried to see if diff.me was available, sadly it's not.

I was thinking something like a git repo with a flat file in it. You list your beliefs / opinions / things you think are facts in a structured way (maybe a tree like structure) going all the way back to some "root". Then you can easily diff this file with someone else and see where you agree and differ. Changing someone's mind could just be a pull request :)

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by strogonoff on Saturday June 11, 2022 @06:47AM (#31703506)
I made an argument and asked questions at the end, leaving it for someone objecting to provide a constructive answer.
Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by hetspookjee on Saturday June 11, 2022 @10:32AM (#31704684)
Oh yes, I think you made an excellent contribution by pulling up past arguments and trying to continu the conversation. I was just observing it and noting how nice itd be in general if this were automatic
Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by JohnHaugeland on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @09:12AM (#31738916)
It's easy enough to have a discussion about you which you don't take seriously

An anti-vaxxer might respond the same way to "the problem with anti-vaxxers," hoping to make sure that nobody discusses the very real problems with them

It's generally okay if people being criticized don't want the people speaking about them to think poorly of them.

It's generally okay if a person being criticized believes that what's said to them can be rebuffed with canned content.

You go ahead and tell everyone that the reason you're polluting with a dysfunctional casino is "you weren't born with functional institutions" if you like

Every notice how anti-vaxxers have canned responses that they think landed, but nobody else does?

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by rglullis on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @02:07PM (#31743460)
Did you notice your rhetoric is so poor that you could not address any actual argument? You did nothing except (a) resorting to throw false accusations hoping that this is enough to discredit your "opponent" and (b) "othering" via an absurd analogy?

If you only tried to reason properly and read at least part of what has been discussed before, you'd find out that:

- I am not in favor of BTC. I think it worked as a proof-of-concept for a system to transfer value without intermediaries, but it has failed as a currency - no privacy, too expensive, too volatile and its fixed supply makes it unworkable as money.

- I am not in favor of PoW. There are cheaper and more efficient ways to secure a blockchain and we are close to make a switch.

- I am not in favor of all these token projects that create opportunities for speculation but are not connected to real economic activity.

My "thing" is using crypto for payments and small-scale banking as an alternative for the global financial system [0]. So, unless you think that the status quo is "good", you will have a better shot at changing my mind if you show me a superior solution to the problem we are trying to tackle. Trying to dismiss me and my work with self-righteous, sophomoric rhetoric does not help anyone and does not solve anything.

[0]: https://hub20.io/about

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by bawolff on Saturday June 11, 2022 @05:37AM (#31703193)
I disagree - trust is a bug in technical systems. Maintaining trust has a really high cost and is an obvious and common single point of failure.

Take TLS - wouldn't it be nice if we could have the same system without certificate authorities?

The thing is - like everything else, trust is a tradeoff. Bitcoin folks will discard it at any cost. Sometimes discarding it is not worth the cost. That doesn't mean adding trusted third parties is a good thing, just that it is often the lesser evil.

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by strogonoff on Saturday June 11, 2022 @07:27AM (#31703690)
But that is in technical systems. More or less it’s an equivalent of defending your home, or using password auth: there are humans motivated to increase their well-being at your expense (at the expense of the environment, and so on).

This tech seems often to be pushed onto human society as a whole, though. It’s like giving up on solving the underlying issues that give humans the above-mentioned motivation to betray each other, and instead baking into the fabric society an assumption that it’s human nature to be this way.

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by snikeris on Saturday June 11, 2022 @09:06AM (#31704158)
The tech (money) has already been adopted by human society as a whole though. So it's not about pushing tech onto human society, but upgrading the existing tech.

> It’s like giving up on solving the underlying issues that give humans the above-mentioned motivation to betray each other, and instead baking into the fabric society an assumption that it’s human nature to be this way.

Not all humans are that way, but those who desire power tend to be. I simply don't trust those in power to manage the money properly. It's too much power for anyone to wield. This is not theory; the historical record is damning for fiat money.

Also, as the world has become more globalized, a world reserve currency has emerged. It makes trade easier if everyone has $USD on hand. However, other countries shouldn't have to trust in the good faith in the U.S. government just to engage in global commerce.

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by strogonoff on Monday June 13, 2022 @02:45AM (#31722051)
> those who desire power tend to be

People who desire power are often, unfortunately, the very kind I mentioned: seeking to secure themselves and easily corrupted. Sadly, power still converts to money, and less than scrupulous corporations and kleptocracies are always knocking at your door to offer a big chunk for turning a blind eye and to infect with corruption.

Again, the core problem is not that we are allowing that to happen. The problem is that some people want to do force others into finite zero-sum games and win—and if these people are already well-off, and especially in a civilization without shortage of resource (which should presumably be slowly arriving), the only reason they would want to do that is mental issues and deep-seated insecurities, distrust and fear for own financial safety.

This motivation will find its way no matter how many checks and verifications you institute. It manifests itself by people stealing other peoples’ stuff, people seeking power to enrich themselves unjustly (and in less lucky countries, using violence and pervasive control to maintain that power), corporations dumping waste into the environment and imbuing every living thing with microplastics and PFAS, etc. etc.

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by atoav on Saturday June 11, 2022 @05:53AM (#31703279)
The thing is, it is not always a bug and it does not always help to give the decision out of your own hands.

E.g. I would really trust myself to decide which products should stay in my Online Shop and which I want out. I don't need (or even want) a public append-only structure that is out of my control. For me the blockchain is good for all usecases where I would in real life use a notary. And that is not many use cases.

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by bottled_poe on Saturday June 11, 2022 @09:49AM (#31704394)
In the real world we operate as humans. And it seems this desire amongst crypto enthusiasts for decentralised trust is easily disproved. As a consumer, I want recourse. I want protections. I want humanity to protect me when I make mistakes. This isn’t going away until robots rule the earth. Perhaps one day, but there will be war before this is reality.
Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by bawolff on Saturday June 11, 2022 @05:20PM (#31708532)
Right, but that cuts both ways.

As a consumer you want due process and fairness, protection from arbitrary punishment etc.

You want trust for all the things you mentioned, those are reasonable goals. They do come at a cost (the system could be abused), and you wouldnt want to add more trust points unless you were getting something of value out of them

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by maxerickson on Saturday June 11, 2022 @09:31AM (#31704303)
"Take TLS - wouldn't it be nice if we could have the same system without certificate authorities?"

Absent that thing existing, this is a demonstration of the value trust provides!

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by hgomersall on Saturday June 11, 2022 @07:14AM (#31703642)
But even with Bitcoin you're super reliant on trust in (a) the technology not to be broken or compromised and (b) the system that supports the actual world outside of crypto (i.e. actual resources that matter).
Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by DennisP on Saturday June 11, 2022 @10:50AM (#31704830)
Every few months, my credit card blocks one of my purchases because its statistical algorithm decides it looks sketchy and wants me to respond to a verification email. How is this any more trusting?

Both systems recognize the existence of fraudulent actors, and handle the problem in different ways. Blockchains use cryptographically-signed transactions, so merchants get no information they can use against you. Credit cards hand your credentials over to every merchant and try to fix their fundamental insecurity by flagging unusual transactions, insuring against losses, and issuing new credentials when bad actors get them (which brings lots of associated hassle, that I've gone through a couple times in the last few years). Bank transfers handle the problem by simply delaying full access to the money, at least for larger amounts, until banks on both ends have checked everything.

The same applies to more complex systems. Blockchains try to build systems with extreme transparency and security (and sometimes fail at that). Traditional finance builds systems reliant on centralized actors, and adds lots of regulation, oversight, and incentives such as criminal penalties to keep those actors in check (and sometimes fails at that).

We certainly should strive for a more idealistic future. But legacy banking/finance is not doing that. Blockchain platforms at least provide the possibility of building something new that's better; on top of an open trustless platform, you can build your own system assuming whatever level of trust and altruism you like.

Two examples on Ethereum: optimistic rollups are more scalable second layers, in which withdrawals work more like bank transfers: withdrawals aren't cryptographically verified, but have a delay during which anyone can submit proof of fraud. A more idealistic example is Gitcoin, in which people donate to public goods and the money is allocated with a quadratic funding system.

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by strogonoff on Sunday June 12, 2022 @08:43AM (#31714054)
> Bank transfers handle the problem by simply delaying full access to the money, at least for larger amounts, until banks on both ends have checked everything.

They are doing it for good reasons, presence of malicious agents (money launderers, etc.) exploiting trust requires it. (In fact, I’d argue banks are getting away with not doing it enough with very moneyed customers.)

Blockchain does not eliminate this need in current age—either equivalent institutions would have to be reproduced all anew, or we need to end the motivations that make people want to exploit financial system in the first place.

And if we do address the latter (the only sustainable solution in the long run), then what is the benefit of blockchain and all? Isn’t it just pure overhead then?

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by peyton on Sunday June 12, 2022 @12:42PM (#31715893)
> what is the benefit of blockchain and all?

The design space is way bigger, so you can create better solutions. “Trust institution X” is a special case.

I can open a position on my favorite DEX (trusting the DEX administer, which can be a centralized authority, not to push an upgrade that drains my balance) and also trust that my position can be liquidated (due to incentives for anybody to submit the liquidation transaction, thereby not having to trust that a centralized liquidation bot won’t have somehow failed at that exact moment).

You could design a brokerage system where accountholders must trust the broker with personal details like SSN, etc, but don’t have to trust the broker not to disable buy/sell buttons due to solvency issues.

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by strogonoff on Monday June 13, 2022 @02:27AM (#31721929)
> don’t have to trust

There we go again. Why are we avoiding trust?

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by fartcannon on Saturday June 11, 2022 @08:58AM (#31704116)
Bitcoins inception was on the heels of the 2008 financial crisis. The genesis block mentions it. What bitcoin enthusiasts don't trust are objectively untrustworthy institutions. That's it. It's real straight forward.
Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by tonypace on Saturday June 11, 2022 @09:06AM (#31704159)
Bitcoin institutions are objectively untrustworthy and most people involved in Bitcoin have no real choice but to rely on them. I trust, say, Citibank more than Bitfinex.
Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by fartcannon on Saturday June 11, 2022 @09:25AM (#31704269)
You dont need bitcoin exchanges.
Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by 8organicbits on Saturday June 11, 2022 @09:51AM (#31704409)
Given the huge number of people who only transact using exchanges, and the usability improvements of doing so, that may technically be true, but probably isn't too helpful. For most people they are inseparable in practice. Worrying about the trustworthiness of the major bitcoin players is practical.
Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by fartcannon on Saturday June 11, 2022 @09:55AM (#31704434)
Absolutely! Dont trust institutions is the message.
Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by 8organicbits on Saturday June 11, 2022 @10:54AM (#31704867)
I suppose that was an original message for Bitcoin, but the current state with various institutions serving in trust-based roles for so many users, Bitcoin doesn't seem to have met that goal.

The users who out of practical concern are considering between trusting Citibank and Bitfinex, will benefit from chosing the one that's regulated.

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by fartcannon on Saturday June 11, 2022 @11:02AM (#31704929)
At this point, I too would not recommend anyone put their life savings into crypto. Especially given the clearly powerful astroturfing campaign against it. But where can you put it? The banks are not trust worthy, they caused the financial crisis. Real estate, I guess. No wait, real estate being corrupt is what got bitcoin started in the first place.
Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by neilwilson on Saturday June 11, 2022 @12:03PM (#31705518)
Only if you want to lose all your assets when the taxman turns up for their cut.

They don’t take Bitcoin and in any sensible sovereign nation never will.

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by photochemsyn on Saturday June 11, 2022 @11:16AM (#31705084)
The reality is that as you move up the social hierarchy in modern human society, trust tends to vanish and is ultimately viewed as something only a rube would rely on. This is why contract law exists, doesn't it?

For example, in the upper tiers of corporations all employment is on a contract basis. Nobody at these levels trusts they will be treated fairly and given a severance package if they are fired, without an explicit contract stating the terms and conditions of employment. Contracts are renewed or renegotiated every few years, right? In contrast, entry-level employees never get contracts, they can be fired at will with no warning or severance, at least in the United States where union power is very limited, relative to Europe.

Similarly, look at the prevalence of marital contracts that imply a lack of trust among the parties, i.e. the famous pre-nuptial agreement regarding how the net wealth of the couple will be divided up in the event of a divorce. There's a zero-trust situation that's increasingly common.

It's true that a society where nobody trusts anyone else and all are suspicious of each other's motives is not a very healthy society, but isn't this also the assumption of the economic theorists who claim all humans are basically little more than rational autonomous self-improving algorithms, with net assets being the benchmark of success?

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by hahajk on Saturday June 11, 2022 @12:04PM (#31705521)
> This is why contract law exists, doesn't it?

When I worked with non-trivial (>$1m) contracts, I learned that the sooner you start pointing to contract language, the sooner the relationship breaks down. “Working with” partners through shortfalls and giving second chances resulted in much more long term success than sticking to the letter of the contract.

Part of the reason, I think, is simple human relationship-building. And a big part of that is trust. Trust and credit also play into it directly - the vendor knows we didn’t penalize them when they delivered a feature a month late, so they’re willing to surge when we have a requirement pop up that needs fixing quicker than we agreed to.

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by throw0101a on Saturday June 11, 2022 @11:49AM (#31705390)
> This is why contract law exists, doesn't it?

Or it exists so that everyone makes sure that everyone else understands the words/concepts being used in the same way.

What does (e.g.) "full payment on final construction" mean? Well, it depends on who you ask. Contracts there to (hopefully) make sure everyone is agreeing to the same transaction.

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by strogonoff on Sunday June 12, 2022 @08:50AM (#31714093)
> The reality is that as you move up the social hierarchy in modern human society, trust tends to vanish and is ultimately viewed as something only a rube would rely on. This is why contract law exists, doesn't it?

I thought about this in such framing, too.

My observation was exactly this: in “higher classes” it looks like trust is implied, and in lower classes everybody is verified.

My logic, however, runs such that we need to elevate the entire society to that level, rather than drop it to the level of “rubes” you mention.

I.e., treat everyone as a respectable individual—a mentally healthy person tends to behave the way they are perceived by others—and by working on general well-being eliminate mental constructs that push people to secure themselves at the expense of others. Does this make sense?

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by vosper on Saturday June 11, 2022 @05:22AM (#31703130)
You hit the nail on the head with this comment. And not only is trust a feature, it’s a requirement for society. It’s a deep part of human nature to trust, and trust can’t be removed from how people manage to function in groups.
Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by gitfan86 on Saturday June 11, 2022 @07:58AM (#31703835)
The problem is scale. If society only had 400 people, the 390 people that were not scammers could remove the 10 people who are scammers from their economic system manually.

If you create a online store, one million strangers could connect to it. You need a way to understand who is a scammer in that situation.

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by DasIch on Saturday June 11, 2022 @10:45AM (#31704800)
That problem is actually solved though. There are plenty of online stores where you can create an account and buy something via invoice after it got delivered to you. This works just fine.
Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by headsoup on Saturday June 11, 2022 @08:33AM (#31703997)
This is true, and why all political ideologies fail. They can't cater for scale, or when they do, they do so by tyranny, which also fails eventually.

Blockchain/Bitcoin has already been thoroughly corrupted, so ironically will prove itself to be entirely untrustworthy before it even gets established as whatever wonderful thing is assumed is still coming from it.

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by fartcannon on Saturday June 11, 2022 @08:39AM (#31704020)
Who has bitcoin been corrupted by?
Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by headsoup on Saturday June 11, 2022 @08:46AM (#31704058)
The exchanges. Clearly and factually.
Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by ntoskrnl on Saturday June 11, 2022 @09:13AM (#31704207)
If I use my private key to send a transaction to your public key, the exchanges have no say in it. You can choose who to trust. If some exchange is corrupted, just don't use it.
Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by rglullis on Saturday June 11, 2022 @09:39AM (#31704334)
The price of the coin is being manipulated by the exchanges, no matter if you use it or not. One exchange in particular (Bitfinex) is helping to keep the largest fraud scheme in history (Tether/USDT) around.
Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by fartcannon on Saturday June 11, 2022 @08:48AM (#31704066)
I dont understand what you mean. Is there somewhere I can read about this?
Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by headsoup on Saturday June 11, 2022 @09:08AM (#31704174)
For a straightforward start, this guy piles on a bit, but also holds a lot of the history/evidence on record too: https://mobile.twitter.com/Bitfinexed
Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by fartcannon on Saturday June 11, 2022 @09:30AM (#31704290)
Thank you.

However that's not bitcoin being corrupted, he suggests that tether, and an exchange are corrupted.

When people use USD for crime, is USD corrupted?

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by gitfan86 on Saturday June 11, 2022 @09:43AM (#31704359)
Corruption is probably a bad description. It is more like what happened to Tulips during Tulip Mania, or Beanie Babies during that bubble. Beanie Babies are not "corrupted". They are "associated" with a bubble. Crypto as a whole is becoming increasingly associated with zero sum scams like Ponzi/MLMs. And it is partially due to the fee extraction entities that are making a profit of off the "investor's" cash.
Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by fartcannon on Saturday June 11, 2022 @09:57AM (#31704454)
I mean Mt Gox was almost a decade ago. Bad people try to do bad things with other peoples money.

That's the value in bitcoin though. You dont need to use these exchanges. If you're smart, you dont trust large institutions of any kind with your money.

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by dividedbyzero on Saturday June 11, 2022 @10:32AM (#31704686)
That mitigates these risks for people who are able to have an in-depth understanding of Bitcoin, which is in itself extremely complex and requires tons of prior knowledge. Everyone else has to trust someone with their crypto needs and is left to be fleeced with no recourse at all. As of now, that merely replaces the group that profits disproportionately with a crypto bros and the like.
Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by fartcannon on Saturday June 11, 2022 @11:00AM (#31704900)
Crypto Bros are the vaguely defined boogeyman, scape goat, and hate magnet for a coordinated disinformation campagain against crypto .. Are you sure you want to associate your position with that kinda PR?
Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by headsoup on Saturday June 11, 2022 @11:36AM (#31705279)
Don't try to stand up a strawman. The exchanges are manipulating the value of Bitcoin, which affects those not using exchanges' ability to trade at a 'proper' value.
Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by fartcannon on Saturday June 11, 2022 @12:01PM (#31705500)
The strawman here is dividebyzeros fictional people who are too dumb to use bitcoin but somehow smart enough to navigate the financial system.

Crytpo bros are a PR boogeyman.

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by dividedbyzero on Saturday June 11, 2022 @02:54PM (#31707100)
The vast majority of people are well able to have a bank account and pay for things within the existing banking system without getting fleeced (or at least only to a small degree). If you want to solve trust at scale, that'll all have to become some sort of distributed ledger or the like. Scaling this tech to the point where it can do that will pretty much certainly not make it any simpler, so you'll get intermediaries who I've summarized as "crypto bros", but you're free to call them something else, but who will be in a terribly good position to fleece the masses. That's true for almost all areas; if it is to be absolutely governed by a highly obscure piece of software, people who understand the details will have great leverage to game the system, and I don't think that's an improvement over what we have now. It just transfers trust to another level in the chain and power to other people (possibly).
Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by fartcannon on Saturday June 11, 2022 @11:31PM (#31711098)
A distributed ledger.. Like bitcoin? It's already solved! Sorry, Im struggling to understand your point. If you want people not to get fleeced, education is the key. Explain the value of bitcoin to them. Explain why it was created.

And the financial system is obscure already and actively fleeces people all the time. Bitcoin was a direct response to the 2008 financial crisis (read: fleecing). Theyd destroyed lives and got bailed out.

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by headsoup on Sunday June 12, 2022 @02:48AM (#31712155)
This is a redundant argument as it applies just as well to the current financial markets: education is key.

But it's not reality, and Bitcoin opened up to fleecing at massive scale as its growth increased and middlemen services popped up to manage the 'complexity.'

Not that I'm saying the current financial system is good or not corrupted, it certainly is. Bitcoin is not the answer people think it is though.

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by fartcannon on Sunday June 12, 2022 @10:22PM (#31720298)
You havent made that case, yet, to me at least. If anything I'm more interested than ever. I mean, you want to talk massive scale fleecing? Let's talk about destroying the global markets with bogus real estate. Global markets! And then double dipping by having the very people you fleeced bail you out against their will. That's triple A fleecing. It's such a flagrant demonstration of a corrupt system that it makes me totally understand why bitcoin was conceived in the first place.
Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by xorcist on Saturday June 11, 2022 @06:19AM (#31703392)
While certainly not wanting to ruing the humorous undertones here, just for the benefit of other readers it's important to point out that the lack of third party trust has a very specific meaning.

Take for web for example. It is trustless in the same manner. There is no third party (apart from the web browser and the server) that you need to trust in order for you to view a web page. There is no International Web Organization that you need to procure permission from in order to set up a web server. You just start it. (And, conversely, also why so much bad actors exist on the web.)

This is fundamentally a different system than for example all economic transactions, apart from cash. This is why some people argues against the cashless society for not being trustless, and also what the people who experiment with private monetary systems study.

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by tlarkworthy on Saturday June 11, 2022 @06:52AM (#31703528)
Web is not trustless

DNS is part of the web and it is a federated/heirarchical 3rd party trust model you need to route your named traffic to the right server, often managed by states. It's super important to understand, this is why authoritarian governments can still hide what citizens can experience on the internet

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by qsdf38100 on Saturday June 11, 2022 @09:15AM (#31704223)
Certificates are required pretty much for any websites nowadays. IIRC it has to do with TLS, so basically all https websites. Those certificates are ultimately based on a trusted third party. So web is not trustless, not even close.
Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by kwatsonafter on Saturday June 11, 2022 @12:17PM (#31705625)
It's a symptom of our mentally ill society trying to rationalize why in 2022 we haven't solved a bunch or practical problems and yet every year we get new iterations of the IPhone, AI in cars, new services in apps, ect... We start from an idea that Moore's Law somehow correlates with social progress but I think that tremendously remains to be seen. There's a noted relationship between teen suicides and social media (on phones) and one-for-one computing in education hasn't produced the generation of Einsteins and Mozarts that it thought it might in the 70s and 80s. I think crypto is the human imagination trying to bridge the gap between our social arrangements and technological progress and I think at its core that is a good thing. We need to dream big if we're going to build a livable world but that also requires discipline and that's something we're severely lacking in society.

I think there's a sort of person that thinks to themselves, "I want all the benefits of living in an advanced society without actually being obligated to participate in said society." I can't help but think this is a kind of sickness. Self-Determination doesn't necessarily exclude social obligation it only dictates that I might not be tyrannized by these obligations.

There's a kind of, "e-person" who is the perfect Cartesian. The new existentialist who reaps the benefits of a globalized society and what is their sacrifice to the world-machine? --Just their continued existence; nothing more.

Without being crude we used to call those people tramps until Charlie Chaplin taught us to be nice to poor people.

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by k__ on Saturday June 11, 2022 @07:10AM (#31703623)
Don't know what people you talked to, but I'm active in one of the biggest DAOs for 10 months and it's 99% about trust.
Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by goodpoint on Saturday June 11, 2022 @10:29AM (#31704669)
> Trust is a feature, not a bug

Why do people always misunderstand "trustless"?

Being ABLE to trust somebody is a good thing. Being REQUIRED to trust somebody is a problem.

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by Mordisquitos on Saturday June 11, 2022 @10:48AM (#31704821)
That argument is not that clear if you state it in the converse. Being able to operate with nobody trusting you is potentially a problem. Being required to be trusted by at least somebody is arguably a good thing.
Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by goodpoint on Saturday June 11, 2022 @11:10AM (#31705025)
> Being required to be trusted by at least somebody

That's in no way related to what I wrote and to the concept of trustless is security.

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by strogonoff on Sunday June 12, 2022 @09:25AM (#31714309)
Let me phrase it this way: “being required to trust somebody” being a problem is the underlying problem. Why are there untrustworthy people in society?
Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by smokey_circles on Saturday June 11, 2022 @10:44AM (#31704792)
I'm not following.

You will not find trust _in people_ anywhere in modern society.

Banks certify transactions, governments certify identity. We can go on and on here. Whole swathes of law around this topic too lol (see: fraud).

Crypto isn't about not trusting people, it's about not needing to trust strangers.

Some of them are scams, ironically, but when there's money involved... well it's pretty stupid to _just_ trust people.

Unless I've missed something?

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by strogonoff on Sunday June 12, 2022 @09:28AM (#31714340)
Trust is everywhere. I eat at a cafe being trusted to pay later. In South Korea, I am trusted to have paid for my ticket upon entering the train (no one ever checked it). I trust every person I stroll past in a dark alley to not rob me at knifepoint. I am trusted by my customers to not deliver a backdoored codebase (yes, there is the letter of the contract, but really it comes down to interpersonal trust since they cannot verify it themselves). Etc., etc.
Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by mintyDijon on Saturday June 11, 2022 @11:34AM (#31705269)
>Aren’t we sort of codifying malicious intent, instead of trying to remove it from the equation? Whom would this serve?

Define malicious intent.

What and whome one person is willing to trust will always be different than another person. This is a hard truth that we will never work around. Culture vs Culture, family vs family, idea vs idea. We can't get rid of conflict or therefore 'malicious intent' and by extension we can't (or shouldn't) bank on trust. I think the better way to deal with our very real human differences is to look past them in the spirit that all of us are creations of a higher power, and thus working together is in everyone's greatest interest.

Money as a medium of exchange is a very powerful concept It holds the idea of an IOU that can transcend our differences in the spirit of building a better world. But in order for that to happen money needs to be fungible, else our differences will enviably tear it apart.

Perhaps when the dollar was backed by gold this concept was more or less true, but central banks undermined that, hense the pull towards extreme decentralization.

>There is place for verification in the interim, such as maintaining security of your home, but if we are looking ahead (as blockchain enthusiasts do) we should strive for a future where humans are not motivated to hurt other humans. NOT TREATING IT AS SOME SORT OF DEFAULT IS A GOOD START.

I must disagree with this concept.

To treat it in a trusted manner is to ignore the fact that we have insurmountable differences and therefore those differences will raise their ugly heads elsewhere and tear our hopes for peace apart.

Rather to start with the presupposition that these differences exist, but that we will create a form that transcends them for the better of all is imo the ideal.

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by delusional on Saturday June 11, 2022 @06:31AM (#31703436)
I agree. Trust is fundamental to human society, and without it we can't function. No matter how many fancy technological solutions you layer on top.

I think there's a deeper problem that you're ignoring. The desire for trustless systems didn't materialize out of nothing, as has been pointed out many times in the cryptocurrency discussion space. Some of it is surely coming from a libertarian angle of absolute personal freedom to avoid the "unfair" regulation from the government, to avoid the compulsions the state imposes on each of us in order to grant us the rights it does. I think that's a very small part of it though.

I think most of the desire for "zero-trust" comes from a disillusion of the current parties seen as trusted. I can at least say that this is what drives the desire within me. It's very hard to see the fairness in paying taxes when I see the people labeled the most trustworthy abuse the system to hide money in tax havens all while using their entrusted positions to lead the economy of the world into an ever deepening hole. When we see the actors labeled "trustworthy" acting maliciously, it becomes hard to trust the system that calls them "trustworthy".

I go to work every day where I'm asked to ignore my own instincts and instead do whatever some faceless "process" claims is the right thing to work on. I'm asked to ignore the horrible state of our products and instead focus on the massive piles of money we shovel in the door from out entrusted position as a financial institution. Meanwhile I can turn on the TV to see the very same people talk about how they just couldn't have known that billions were being stolen from my government because it's just so hard to be a bank. That shit does stuff to your trust in other people and I'm not alone in that disillusionment.

In that light I think the discussion makes much more sense, even if it doesn't make it any more helpful. Trust is still important, but the current method of obtaining trust, and the by extension people we imbue with it, is broken. For someone in the middle of that, it becomes very logical to discard the whole thing like a junior rewriting a legacy business app.

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by strogonoff on Saturday June 11, 2022 @08:24AM (#31703948)
I heard the opinion where people don’t want to pay taxes that they don’t think do something good, and because the government can freeze their accounts if they don’t pay then they believe it’s unfair.

Presumably, there’s understanding that one cannot participate in a complex web of interdependencies that is advanced human society without giving up complete freedom, due to the presence of the aforementioned malicious actors.

So I don’t understand why not assume other people—whom one without immense hubris would assume to be equally smart—and whom hopefully one voted for, directly or not—have struggled with it and arrived at a solution that works? And if one legitimately thinks it’s a bad solution and cares enough about it, why not attempt to fix it instead? Is this a failure of democracy? Could it be that it moves too slowly for the modern age? Or is there a belief in some underlying conspiracy due to which democracy is not a democracy and no change is possible?

Regarding rogue agents exploiting the system to avoid paying taxes, I don’t think should be a factor that affects my decision on whether I should pay taxes (like what a criminal does shouldn’t be my guiding principle).

What I would agree on is that there’re people incentivised to attempt to benefit at someone else’s cost, and that those people exist everywhere including corporations, institutions, and the government. I’d also agree that, regarding government specifically, it’s worse because such malicious actors are incentivised to actively seek power because power converts to money very well. It’s a truly regrettable state of affair, because government corruption leads to corruption elsewhere. I think part of the issue is democracies being liable to be influenced by kleptocracies in other countries, who funnel unjustly extracted money into Western economies much to the benefit of individuals at the receiving end.

I just don’t think this can be solved technically, we either work on people not being jerks or we will have them find ways to be jerks regardless of any checks, barring complete thought control and predictive crime enforcement dystopia.

---

As another analogy, it’s like a distinction between the spirit and the letter. The spirit is the guiding principle, and the letter is a lossy way to express it. Automatic conversion between the spirit and a letter is not possible: this is a philosophical issue adjacent to the hard problem of consciousness; one human not being able to convey to another human the entirety of what they think or feel, words being always interpreted through another mind’s lens.

Whether the letter can be expressed on paper or as a smart contract, the letter is never going to be equal fidelity to that of the spirit, and for understandable reasons (such as “fallible humans have written it”) should never have precedence over the spirit.

So I wish we invested the effort that goes into inventing higher and higher fidelity letters into, say, alleviating whatever pushes people to violate the spirit in the first place. It’s a much more complex meatspace problem, though.

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by Banana699 on Saturday June 11, 2022 @12:40PM (#31705835)
>there’s understanding that one cannot participate in a complex web of interdependencies that is advanced human society without giving up complete freedom

The problem is, that web is not just a neutral thing that arises organically, it's a bloated mess of faceless coercion that is disproportionally manipulated by a minority.

It used to be that a tribe agreed not to kill or cheat each other and defend against common threats, that's something very basic that I have trouble imagining anybody not wanting. There were manipulators and status seekers, always, but they were forced to divide their attention between the thousands and thousands of tribes and sub-tribes, if I percieve my tribe to be controlled by a trump or a biden or a putin, I can always take my family and go elsewhere, at no more cost than the price of the trip and the risk I'm accepting by leaving the tribe.

Fast forward through 10K years of agriculture, and we're sheep. Lovecraftian faceless horrors called states divide up the entire earth into 200 divisions or so, the vast majority of which are irrelevant (except in deploying violence against you :)), about 10 or 15 control pretty much 99% of what you do. The size acts as a force multiplier for manipualtors and status seekers: Now only the best trumps and bidens and putins compete to govern you, and the winner, as they say, takes all. They can do whatever the F U C K they can, let me tell you, quite honestly and coming from a guy who appreciates democracy and misses it in his country, that democracy is a laugable excuse of a government scheme. You can tell your bullies you hate them? Great, but I'm betting they already know. You can whine and threaten to get them out of the office ? that's it ? you spend a whole 2 or 4 or 6 years raging at a bunch of people and getting other people to rage with you and other people to rage against you, so that, finally, the bullies can "only" bully you as much as they already have, and not more ? and this the best case scenario that you can only get if you're good at convincing people your cause is worthy ? Is this your local optima ?

There is no feedback, the massive inertia of millions and millions of obedient drones serve to condition and dampen any single insurrection. The contradictory feedback of the huge and impotent masses all cancel each other in an orgy of destructive interference, and what remains is the will of the rulers. The coordination overhead asymmetrically influnces those trying to live in freedom, and favors those trying to crush it.

Words alone can't express how I despise and loath hierarchical societies. Words alone can't express how I loath complex huge things that are out of my control and harm me. I don't think that feelings can be serialized into strings, but if they can, it would take me a very large one to express all the myriad and subtle ways that I hate nation states.

>I don’t understand why not assume other people—whom one without immense hubris would assume to be equally smart

I don't think intelligence play into it, at least not the kind of intelligence I respect. Smart people are bullied all the time. Smart people had 10K years to fix the massive clusterfuck that is hierarchical societies or toss them into the dirstiest toilet, and they couldn't. It would be the height of hubris to assume you can succeed where billions failed.

>Is this a failure of democracy?

No, it's a failure of people being dumb enough to think that the social protocls and algorithms that fared well in networks of N=100, struggled in networks of N=1000 and absoultely tore themselves apart in networks of N=10000, can scale well to networks of N=10000000 and above. Anything that doesn't respect the underlying reality is doomed to repeatedly live in fear and failure and die in confusion, and the reality is that distributed systems are hard. It's even harder when the processors were never built to operate like this. You're trying to reinvent ants and bees with primates, and failing so hard that the result is not recognisably any of them.

"Democracy" is a bandaid, a flawed ideal that can never work, and makes things worse by making you think you're doing something.

>I just don’t think this can be solved technically

Correct, it's solved by not being large clusterfuck of coercion and control, by being small and simple and beautiful, by recognizing the fundamental limits to cooperation that being flesh and blood enforces on you, and respecting them.

>work on people not being jerks

You can't. Being a jerk is encoded in your DNA. Life competes. Life meta-competes: competes at the level of the rules of competition itself, to bend and distort it in their favor, the meta-game. Life at its very core is the aspiration of a single celled asshole to convert the entire universe into more versions of itself, it began so, and it remains so.

The only way to emulate altruism, to hack it onto a system after the fact, is to make selfish assholery more expensive than selfless altruism, always. Sometimes that would make sense, like within the boundaries of your gene pool, few people, I love to imagine, think about deceiving and coercing their flesh and blood, and fewer still actually go along all the way.

But that natural familiar affection declines exponentially as the genetic diff grows, and you have to resort to complement it with artifical measures. The problem with artifical measures, though, is that they are second-class citizens, they are never as convincing and natural as natural inlicnations. It's an uphill fight. Invent laws and rules and regulations and constitutions and religions and mainfestos Till The Cows Come Home, you can't put them in the DNA, and DNA is what life is, and what a thing is what a thing does. So it is an arms race: I invent a God today to tell people to be nice to each other, and tomorrow a smooth-talking smooth-brained asshole manages to convince people God Ackshually wants us to do his bidding instead, I invent democracy the day after tomorrow to convince people that everybody matters, and by the weekend that same breed of smooth-talking smooth-brained assholes find the exploit.

Unless, and until, every single nerve signal going in or out of a brain is subject to your rules (by dystopia, by utopian merging of all human minds into one, by anything), you don't have rules, you have suggestions, protocols, paradigm. "Would you please agree not to fuck with me ?", maybe I will, who knows, I'm not my best self all the time, and there are worse. Why put yourself with a bunch of strange assholes and bet your wellbeing on them obeying a buggy protocol they are never truly compelled to follow ?

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by strogonoff on Sunday June 12, 2022 @09:09AM (#31714205)
> I don't think intelligence play into it, at least not the kind of intelligence I respect. Smart people are bullied all the time. Smart people had 10K years to fix the massive clusterfuck that is hierarchical societies or toss them into the dirstiest toilet, and they couldn't. It would be the height of hubris to assume you can succeed where billions failed.

I disagree. We have had parts of society dominate other parts, using them as workforce and such, since humanity historically had A) insufficient resources and capabilities to improve general well-being, and B) insufficient ethical standards to care to do so.

Ethics have been evolving (abolition of slavery, etc.), so clearly (B) is not static. And now, with automation and strong renewable energy sources, we may (or should) be rapidly approaching post-scarcity, addressing (A). The result of it all is a qualitatively new state for humanity.

In such a state, the dog eat dog calculus you describe is thinking in the past, I’d expect better from a technologically progressive mind.

Regarding biological need for competition, I’ll need to think about it but immediately it strikes me that there should be enough ways left to compete fairly.

Regarding bullying, I suffered from being bullied in early years, and I have grown to see my bullies for what they are: mentally traumatized people. The same trauma carries over to people seeking personal security at the expense of others or the environment, resulting in unethical or malicious behavior. Thus the need to improve baseline well-being (and especially mental health) across the board, to stop people being traumatized and passing it on by traumatizing their peers and children.

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by anovikov on Saturday June 11, 2022 @09:34AM (#31704309)
Maybe this explains to a great degree why so many blockchain big names are Russian speakers! Because in Russia, we see trust as a bug, and any necessity to develop trust to anyone as an obstacle (because we know people really can't be trusted).

There are high-trust and low-trust societies out there.

Majority of the world lives in low-trust societies and this is culturally, not economically driven, so unlikely to change fast. Globalisation means these people will permeate - through migration too, but mostly, through cross-border economic activities - all high-trust societies, too, so very quickly people who rely on trust and trust others will either be scammed out of all their lives, or resort to a niche role by picking their interacting parties so diligently they will be cut off from most economic and social activity, and become irrelevant.

So, for the modern world, trust is a bug indeed (and no i don't think blockchain will help this, or anything at all).

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by matheusmoreira on Saturday June 11, 2022 @12:59PM (#31706004)
> Trust is a feature, not a bug.

It's a feature of the system, precisely because it replaces trust in shaky institutions.

I trust strong cryptography. I don't trust governments not to abuse their power. I don't trust corporations not to maximize profits at our expense.

It's really simple. I don't believe in any system that requires trusting either governments or corporations. A good system will necessarily work despite them.

> we should strive for a future where humans are not motivated to hurt other humans. Not treating it as some sort of default is a good start.

Trust is inherently selective and small scale. You trust specific individuals that you personally know, not all of humanity. Even that trust is easily broken.

Compare that to modern computer and internet technology where servers are expected to receive input from any other computer on earth. The technological equivalent of children being encouraged to talk to strangers.

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by strogonoff on Sunday June 12, 2022 @10:14AM (#31714647)
I don’t think we can get rid of locks on our doors (metaphorically and literally) right away, but I do think we should invest more effort into making them obsolete (by raising general well-being, ensuring psychological security; treating people as trustworthy is a factor, since we are primed to behave the way we are perceived) than into making more and more sophisticated locks all around us.
Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by logicchains on Saturday June 11, 2022 @08:30AM (#31703982)
>Trust is a feature, not a bug. If trust is violated by rogue agents, it is because they exist[0], not because trust itself is a folly.

It's about building robust systems. A system that assumes counterparties are trustworthy will fail in the case they aren't (as demonstrated clearly in modern OS/web architecture), whereas a system that assumes counterparties are not trustworthy will not fail in that case.

> we should strive for a future where humans are not motivated to hurt other humans.

This is the same premise as communism and has proven to be a complete failure: it's not possible to change human nature. Even with a massive propaganda and brainwashing apparatus like the Chinese education system.

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by strogonoff on Sunday June 12, 2022 @09:39AM (#31714404)
I agree that current technical systems must not assume trust, for as long as we have malicious agents. IMO we should not let this be baked into the fabric of human society though.

And for the record, I believe it is possible to achieve what I am talking about in conditions and general spirit of market and capitalism. Suppressing personal choice (USSR- and China-style) is not the way to get there, it is in fact the opposite—making people feel psychologically secure enough to not feel compelled to be malicious is one thing; forcing them into constraints that prevent them from being malicious does not solve the issue and only obscures it (and besides, party elites will always be free to be whatever they want).

In fact, it is the parallels between blockchain-based social system and some emerging Chinese realities (social karma, etc.) that worry me.

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by nyolfen on Saturday June 11, 2022 @09:20AM (#31704243)
you can trust people all you want. take iou's, accept people at their word, etc -- the existence of trustless systems does nothing to negate this. for everyone you don't trust, you can use a blockchain.

> we should strive for a future where humans are not motivated to hurt other humans.

i don't even know what to say when people say things like this. we should strive for good will and cooperation, but we must be prepared for situations where there is none. this is like arguing against allowing people to put locks on doors. when you create situations where distrust is disallowed, defecting becomes the winning strategy.

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by strogonoff on Sunday June 12, 2022 @09:48AM (#31714464)
Have you ever been in places where locking your bike is perceived as a slight sign of disrespect? It is for a good reason; you have basically just labeled all people there as possible thieves.

I am not arguing that we metaphorically and literally need to do away with locks right now, but that we can and should apply effort in the direction that makes them obsolete as preventative measures. I want to live in a place where I do not need them.

The existence of trustless systems does not make distrust mandatory, it is such systems becoming mandatory that bothers me, as well as the effort spent into developing more and more robust trustless systems—as opposed to trying to make those very systems obsolete by eliminating the underlying motivations that push people to exploit trust.

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by nyolfen on Sunday June 12, 2022 @10:22AM (#31714708)
> Have you ever been in places where locking your bike is perceived as a slight sign of disrespect? It is for a good reason; you have basically just labeled all people there as possible thieves.

the internet is a single, collapsed point in space. your bike is accessible through this aleph, to all of the most skilled bike thieves in the world, forever. the internet might have been different in the past and may yet be different in the future, but if we are going to have a truly global universally-accessible network, we are going to need systems that are built for an adversarial environment.

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by strogonoff on Monday June 13, 2022 @02:32AM (#31721968)
Same logic applies no matter how many people there are. Instituting pervasive checks on everything and distrust by default is not different from failed attempts at communism as exemplified by USSR and China.
Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by nyolfen on Monday June 13, 2022 @04:56PM (#31731661)
i genuinely cannot comprehend the logic behind this statement. nobody is forcing you to use these systems, so you seem to have some emotional discomfort with other people having the ability to protect themselves. what is your alternative? forced trust, dependence on third party authorities?
Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by strogonoff on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @07:40AM (#31737645)
> nobody is forcing you to use these systems

The general sentiment from blockchain enthusiasts I talked with is that conventional system is obsolete and must be superseded by what they’re building ASAP. If you are OK with blockchain and adjacent tech being a niche, then I don’t really have anything to object to (whatever floats your boat and all that).

> what is your alternative? forced trust, dependence on third party authorities?

No… I sort of spent a while describing it in my original comment.

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by nverno on Saturday June 11, 2022 @05:19AM (#31703115)
Everyone is a potential threat, that's the whole point of trust in the first place. If that wasn't the case, trust (in terms of safety) wouldnt even be a thing.
Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by johtso on Saturday June 11, 2022 @05:36AM (#31703184)
Not if you reframe it as the absence of mistrust, trusting being the natural state.
Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by nverno on Saturday June 11, 2022 @05:38AM (#31703198)
Trusting blindly is not a natural state. We evolved in the ecosystem you see around you. In freak cases, eg. the dodo bird, you can see what happens when blind trust meets competition.
Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by headsoup on Saturday June 11, 2022 @08:44AM (#31704050)
I think this is why it is problematic these days. Trust in simple terms would be trusting your local community but not the 'outside' world. But now we're trying to make the whole world one community, so who to distrust? Everyone, because you don't actually really know many people at all 'inside' your community. Everyone is inside and outside at once.

It feels like blockchain is trying to be a solution for the 'global community' that can't trust itself, but will never solve that problem because it's inherently an unsolvable utopian dream.

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by strogonoff on Sunday June 12, 2022 @10:09AM (#31714609)
Isn’t it fundamentally an artifact of scarcity? What if with technological advances in automation and energy sources humanity were approaching a world without it?
Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by milkey_mouse on Saturday June 11, 2022 @12:03PM (#31705514)
> Their core motivation to benefit at others’ expense is to me indicative of mental health issues, possibly caused by insecurity and upbringing trauma.

Could we avoid armchair diagnoses? For society to function we need to maintain the polite fiction that one's actions are determined solely by their will.

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by noduerme on Saturday June 11, 2022 @06:03AM (#31703321)
You're right on a lot of things here, (I appreciate the slightly humorous, gratuitous take on bad actors having had a bad upbringing) but you seem to be inverting the flaws in the no-trust paradigm into a trust-but-verify paradigm based on an assumption of implicit goodness which is no more borne out by reality than the assumption of implicit evil.

Maybe it makes more sense to look at it all through a different lens. Classical, post-mercantile liberal economics, - that is, liberalism - is entirely built around a framework for dealing with the question of establishing trust between parties: Individuals do not have to establish trust, or agree with each other, or be friends, if they certify that they acquiesce to a system where the market is well regulated. In exchange they get the advantage of being in a market where trade can be a non-zero game that advantages both parties. The problem with crypto as it stands has something to do with unregulated markets, something to do with bad actors, but a lot more to do with the fact that no one has yet come up with a use for deflationary currency that's something other than a zero-sum game.

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by strogonoff on Sunday June 12, 2022 @10:05AM (#31714583)
I need time to digest your point, but one note—participants certifying acquiescence to the system still involves trust: as in, you agree to the rules of this mini-game, but I trust that you actually follow them. I suspect that such default meta-trust is sort of important, like presumption of innocence; and if there are people who violate it, then we should throw more resources at treating the underlying causes rather than eliminating symptoms. So far blockchain-based trustless tech to me seems instrumental at treating the symptom only (and I can see how it detracts resources from treating the cause), thus I am wary of it.