News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by bawolff on Saturday June 11, 2022 @05:37AM (#31703193)
I disagree - trust is a bug in technical systems. Maintaining trust has a really high cost and is an obvious and common single point of failure.

Take TLS - wouldn't it be nice if we could have the same system without certificate authorities?

The thing is - like everything else, trust is a tradeoff. Bitcoin folks will discard it at any cost. Sometimes discarding it is not worth the cost. That doesn't mean adding trusted third parties is a good thing, just that it is often the lesser evil.

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by strogonoff on Saturday June 11, 2022 @07:27AM (#31703690)
But that is in technical systems. More or less it’s an equivalent of defending your home, or using password auth: there are humans motivated to increase their well-being at your expense (at the expense of the environment, and so on).

This tech seems often to be pushed onto human society as a whole, though. It’s like giving up on solving the underlying issues that give humans the above-mentioned motivation to betray each other, and instead baking into the fabric society an assumption that it’s human nature to be this way.

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by snikeris on Saturday June 11, 2022 @09:06AM (#31704158)
The tech (money) has already been adopted by human society as a whole though. So it's not about pushing tech onto human society, but upgrading the existing tech.

> It’s like giving up on solving the underlying issues that give humans the above-mentioned motivation to betray each other, and instead baking into the fabric society an assumption that it’s human nature to be this way.

Not all humans are that way, but those who desire power tend to be. I simply don't trust those in power to manage the money properly. It's too much power for anyone to wield. This is not theory; the historical record is damning for fiat money.

Also, as the world has become more globalized, a world reserve currency has emerged. It makes trade easier if everyone has $USD on hand. However, other countries shouldn't have to trust in the good faith in the U.S. government just to engage in global commerce.

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by strogonoff on Monday June 13, 2022 @02:45AM (#31722051)
> those who desire power tend to be

People who desire power are often, unfortunately, the very kind I mentioned: seeking to secure themselves and easily corrupted. Sadly, power still converts to money, and less than scrupulous corporations and kleptocracies are always knocking at your door to offer a big chunk for turning a blind eye and to infect with corruption.

Again, the core problem is not that we are allowing that to happen. The problem is that some people want to do force others into finite zero-sum games and win—and if these people are already well-off, and especially in a civilization without shortage of resource (which should presumably be slowly arriving), the only reason they would want to do that is mental issues and deep-seated insecurities, distrust and fear for own financial safety.

This motivation will find its way no matter how many checks and verifications you institute. It manifests itself by people stealing other peoples’ stuff, people seeking power to enrich themselves unjustly (and in less lucky countries, using violence and pervasive control to maintain that power), corporations dumping waste into the environment and imbuing every living thing with microplastics and PFAS, etc. etc.

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by atoav on Saturday June 11, 2022 @05:53AM (#31703279)
The thing is, it is not always a bug and it does not always help to give the decision out of your own hands.

E.g. I would really trust myself to decide which products should stay in my Online Shop and which I want out. I don't need (or even want) a public append-only structure that is out of my control. For me the blockchain is good for all usecases where I would in real life use a notary. And that is not many use cases.

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by bottled_poe on Saturday June 11, 2022 @09:49AM (#31704394)
In the real world we operate as humans. And it seems this desire amongst crypto enthusiasts for decentralised trust is easily disproved. As a consumer, I want recourse. I want protections. I want humanity to protect me when I make mistakes. This isn’t going away until robots rule the earth. Perhaps one day, but there will be war before this is reality.
Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by bawolff on Saturday June 11, 2022 @05:20PM (#31708532)
Right, but that cuts both ways.

As a consumer you want due process and fairness, protection from arbitrary punishment etc.

You want trust for all the things you mentioned, those are reasonable goals. They do come at a cost (the system could be abused), and you wouldnt want to add more trust points unless you were getting something of value out of them

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by maxerickson on Saturday June 11, 2022 @09:31AM (#31704303)
"Take TLS - wouldn't it be nice if we could have the same system without certificate authorities?"

Absent that thing existing, this is a demonstration of the value trust provides!

Re:Is “acceptably non-dystopian” self-sovereign identity eve... by hgomersall on Saturday June 11, 2022 @07:14AM (#31703642)
But even with Bitcoin you're super reliant on trust in (a) the technology not to be broken or compromised and (b) the system that supports the actual world outside of crypto (i.e. actual resources that matter).