Re:How head posture affects perceived cooperativeness: A cro...
by ARandomerDude on Saturday June 04, 2022 @02:19AM
(#31617558)
Original paper title was "How head posture affects perceived cooperativeness: A
cross-cultural perspective."
"Friendly" in the HN title is inaccurate in my opinion. The paper asked participants to rate a person's perceived cooperativeness, not friendliness. While it's true that cooperation is a component of being friendly, the two are not identical.
For example, "he is cooperating with authorities" is very different than "he is friendly with the authorities."
Re:How head posture affects perceived cooperativeness: A cro...
by nonrandomstring on Saturday June 04, 2022 @04:14AM
(#31618107)
Yes, in US English the word "cooperate" has a distinctly different
meaning than it's literal definition. It is more congruent with
"comply", "submit" or even "surrender".
With that usage, of course head-down position looks more
subservient. A person who is fearful, or surrounded by a generally
hostile population might perceive that as "more friendly" at a stretch
of semantics, but that would say more about the culture and context.
My experience is quite the opposite. Heads-up with eye contact
indicates an engaging personality, readiness to listen and see, and
therefore a more sociable outlook. First thing you get taught in
cadets or scouts or whatever is "heads-up!" - a ready/attentional
posture.
Indeed, the widespread problem with smartphones is visible in any
British high-street. People bimbling along, heads-down, necks craned,
staring into the 6 inches of virtual reality through which they see
the world. It's not only horrifying from the POV of their health and
safety, it sends a "non-approachable" signal.
Re:How head posture affects perceived cooperativeness: A cro...
by fleetwoodsnack on Saturday June 04, 2022 @12:54PM
(#31622623)
It might be generational. Cooperative usually meant “works well with others,” where I’ve studied and worked. These types usually have a handle on themselves and are looked-at to lead sometimes.
If I may follow the grandparent commentor and provide an unsubstantiated thought: the heads-up angle may suffer from being double-edged; it may indicate someone who suffers from excess self-esteem. From experience, these types are harder to deal with because many times one has to help them relieve themselves of their ego first, before anything substantive can be accomplished. Sometimes, especially as we age, the juice is simply not worth the squeeze and we’d rather just work with someone who is better ready to work together.
Re:How head posture affects perceived cooperativeness: A cro...
by nonrandomstring on Saturday June 04, 2022 @01:23PM
(#31622945)
> heads-up angle may suffer from being double-edged; it may indicate
someone who suffers from excess self-esteem. From experience, these
types are harder to deal with because many times one has to help
them relieve themselves of their ego first, before anything
Sure, there's a definite line between heads-up and a cocky
nose-in-the-air. As another commenter said, it's more than just head
angle, you need to consider face expression and eye position too.
The expression "looking down at people" is probably captured in
precisely that ratio of head-eye angle that gives off haughtiness, and
the "chad" comic posted above sums up the excess of other body
language that makes one send out "I'm a dick" signals.
Re:How head posture affects perceived cooperativeness: A cro...
by nonrandomstring on Saturday June 04, 2022 @01:13PM
(#31622846)
Interesting. Perhaps that's how it comes across on this side of the
Atlantic. I've heard so many times American police or forces say
something like "We had to open fire when they failed to cooperate".
In fact I heard that so many times on TV as kid in the 1970s and 1980s
that I considered "capitulate" as a drop-in replacement for
"cooperate". Only later did I revise the meaning as something that
happens between parties on an equal power footing.
I guess that's what happens when people misuse words as a euphemistic
way to soften intentions and behaviours - like "collateral damage" and
so on, and then that culture gets exported through popular media.
Re:How head posture affects perceived cooperativeness: A cro...
by sumy23 on Saturday June 04, 2022 @02:42PM
(#31623781)
Forced cooperation with police is definitely a usage of cooperate. If you’re only exposure to U.S. English is popular media, then I could see how you associate cooperate with a police context. However, I don’t think that’s the first thing people in the U.S. think of when they hear the word.
Re:How head posture affects perceived cooperativeness: A cro...
by starkd on Saturday June 04, 2022 @10:59AM
(#31621060)
I think this is looking at the head tilt. Not eye contact or the position of the head. The example photo on the site illustrates the concept. The woman is clearly making eye contact in all three photos, but her head is tilted up and level in the first two. The impression given in the first is a haughty contempt. The third photo is one who you might want to converse or even have a drink with. It's a total attitude shift.
These are the guidelines that has made HN the awesome place which attracted you as users. If users then change the way HN operates, then HN risks becoming something different than what initially attracted you.
For example:
"Comments should get more thoughtful and substantive"
and
"Please don't comment about the voting on comments."
mouzogu, I suggest that your two comments are not in the spirit of the guidelines.
Re:How head posture affects perceived cooperativeness: A cro...
by sohdas on Saturday June 04, 2022 @10:28AM
(#31620716)
I think it would be the opposite. Someone who is taller than you would on average look more like their head is tilted up from your perspective, and vice versa for someone shorter than you.
Re:How head posture affects perceived cooperativeness: A cro...
by mike81today on Sunday June 05, 2022 @10:37PM
(#31636829)
It's my guess that it is rare that someone decides the tilt of their head. Posture is cultural, it varies from culture to culture. In industrialized nations most people have excessively curved spines and as a result most heads tilt back, as shown in the first photo. When people have balanced posture the face is vertical, as in the second photo. The study gives another reason (an appearance of cooperation) to balance your posture, so your bones are on the axial line of gravity.
Re:How head posture affects perceived cooperativeness: A cro...
by timbit42 on Saturday June 04, 2022 @03:13PM
(#31624078)
I'm 5'4" and over the decades I've noticed occasionally that tall people think I'm smiling or happy when I'm not. The white boxes on the faces in the article obscure this but the girl appears to be frowning when her head is tilted up and smiling when it is tilted down. This is the natural result of end sides of the mouth curving back toward the cheeks. This is what I first thought of when I read the headline and was surprised it wasn't mentioned in the article or other comments here.
Re:How head posture affects perceived cooperativeness: A cro...
by bigmattystyles on Saturday June 04, 2022 @12:32PM
(#31622370)
Seems like head posture alone wouldn’t be enough, body posture and facial expressions are a package deal in my mind. In fact a quick counterpoint to the chin down seems more cooperative/ friendly, Robert Patrick as the T1000. When I looked at the right most picture, I didn’t get more cooperative, I got Robert Patrick / ‘come at me bro’ vibes.
Re:How head posture affects perceived cooperativeness: A cro...
by golemotron on Saturday June 04, 2022 @03:36AM
(#31617963)
Amazing to see people do research about something so obvious. The postures are assertion and submissiveness. Placing oneself above another or below by head angle. It isn't just humans either. You see it in primates, dogs and cats.
The submissive gesture essentially communicates "I am not primed to physically attack."
Re:How head posture affects perceived cooperativeness: A cro...
by DoingIsLearning on Saturday June 04, 2022 @09:42AM
(#31620226)
> The submissive gesture essentially communicates "I am not primed to physically attack."
Its not that straighforward. It's a combination of posture + facial expression.
In a real fight the first thing you do is to tuck your chin in and tense up your neck to get a chance at not getting knocked out.
So I would say as shown in the paper figures it is the combination of lower chin angle plus neutral or friendly facial expression that is important.
Probably my own bias but in a male context I would interpret a lowered chin as a sign of incoming aggression unless it is combined with a friendly/neutral expression.
Re:How head posture affects perceived cooperativeness: A cro...
by RcouF1uZ4gsC on Saturday June 04, 2022 @04:32PM
(#31624756)
One thing to note that these “posture” studies have a huge issue with reproducibility. In addition, even when they may have statistical significance, the effect size is so small that is is often of no real world significance (other than selling clicks and ads).
Re:How head posture affects perceived cooperativeness: A cro...
by _k9p4 on Saturday June 04, 2022 @11:58AM
(#31621901)
I'm Asian. The authors of the paper are Asian. But this:
> “a possible explanation may be that Asians have a greater tendency to live in collective societies and are perhaps more likely to emphasize group dynamics rather than individual prowess”
Re:How head posture affects perceived cooperativeness: A cro...
by porknubbins on Saturday June 04, 2022 @04:36PM
(#31624798)
This isn’t racism in any meaningful sense. It would be racism to use this statement to make presumptions about an individual, or to assert the superiority of one race over another.
Re:How head posture affects perceived cooperativeness: A cro...
by the_only_law on Saturday June 04, 2022 @12:57PM
(#31622667)
I personally wouldn’t say the passage itself is racist, as there are cultures that are more communal and those that are less, and alone thats not offensive or racist it’s just natural, but the idea has been used to put l people down as convenient arguments for political slap fights. I remember when the covid thing first started, seeing comments start to pop like: “Asian people are naturally all submissive to authority and that’s why they all wear masks willingly”.
The wording may not quite, he right but it gives the general idea.
Re:How head posture affects perceived cooperativeness: A cro...
by jessaustin on Saturday June 04, 2022 @12:35PM
(#31622390)
Would "have a more extensive history of living in collective societies" be better in your view? This seems like it could have been more what they meant?
"Friendly" in the HN title is inaccurate in my opinion. The paper asked participants to rate a person's perceived cooperativeness, not friendliness. While it's true that cooperation is a component of being friendly, the two are not identical.
For example, "he is cooperating with authorities" is very different than "he is friendly with the authorities."
With that usage, of course head-down position looks more subservient. A person who is fearful, or surrounded by a generally hostile population might perceive that as "more friendly" at a stretch of semantics, but that would say more about the culture and context.
My experience is quite the opposite. Heads-up with eye contact indicates an engaging personality, readiness to listen and see, and therefore a more sociable outlook. First thing you get taught in cadets or scouts or whatever is "heads-up!" - a ready/attentional posture.
Indeed, the widespread problem with smartphones is visible in any British high-street. People bimbling along, heads-down, necks craned, staring into the 6 inches of virtual reality through which they see the world. It's not only horrifying from the POV of their health and safety, it sends a "non-approachable" signal.
If I may follow the grandparent commentor and provide an unsubstantiated thought: the heads-up angle may suffer from being double-edged; it may indicate someone who suffers from excess self-esteem. From experience, these types are harder to deal with because many times one has to help them relieve themselves of their ego first, before anything substantive can be accomplished. Sometimes, especially as we age, the juice is simply not worth the squeeze and we’d rather just work with someone who is better ready to work together.
Sure, there's a definite line between heads-up and a cocky nose-in-the-air. As another commenter said, it's more than just head angle, you need to consider face expression and eye position too.
The expression "looking down at people" is probably captured in precisely that ratio of head-eye angle that gives off haughtiness, and the "chad" comic posted above sums up the excess of other body language that makes one send out "I'm a dick" signals.
In fact I heard that so many times on TV as kid in the 1970s and 1980s that I considered "capitulate" as a drop-in replacement for "cooperate". Only later did I revise the meaning as something that happens between parties on an equal power footing.
I guess that's what happens when people misuse words as a euphemistic way to soften intentions and behaviours - like "collateral damage" and so on, and then that culture gets exported through popular media.
https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
These are the guidelines that has made HN the awesome place which attracted you as users. If users then change the way HN operates, then HN risks becoming something different than what initially attracted you.
For example:
"Comments should get more thoughtful and substantive"
and
"Please don't comment about the voting on comments."
mouzogu, I suggest that your two comments are not in the spirit of the guidelines.
(I'm going to observe what I'm doing myself the next time I talk to a shorter person :-))
— Charlie, It’s Always Sunny In Philadelphia
The submissive gesture essentially communicates "I am not primed to physically attack."
That's why as pets they get along with cats - they both think they're winning.
(Despite being a prey animal who dies of upset stomach if it doesn't eat grass 24/7, nobody has a bigger ego than a rabbit.)
Its not that straighforward. It's a combination of posture + facial expression.
In a real fight the first thing you do is to tuck your chin in and tense up your neck to get a chance at not getting knocked out.
So I would say as shown in the paper figures it is the combination of lower chin angle plus neutral or friendly facial expression that is important.
Probably my own bias but in a male context I would interpret a lowered chin as a sign of incoming aggression unless it is combined with a friendly/neutral expression.
> “a possible explanation may be that Asians have a greater tendency to live in collective societies and are perhaps more likely to emphasize group dynamics rather than individual prowess”
sounds racist AF
Can you explain what you find racist about it?
The wording may not quite, he right but it gives the general idea.
* Condescending * Neutral/Trustworthy * Scheming!
I am a taller person at around ~ 1.95m, so that may influence my own biases.
https://images.app.goo.gl/f3P1yibkFqSVR5WY6