News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Low-cost gel film can pluck drinking water from desert air by conductr on Thursday May 26, 2022 @09:47AM (#31518275)
At scale, this seems awful for desert ecology. Plants and animals have evolved to survive on bare minimum water. The tiny morning dew may be all they get for days/weeks. Now we want to pluck it out before they can get any.

It’s certainly an interesting technology and achievement but one that could be easily misused with “unintended consequences”; or so it seems.

Re:Low-cost gel film can pluck drinking water from desert air by colechristensen on Thursday May 26, 2022 @11:08AM (#31519262)
It could also do the opposite, if used correctly.

Strong Dune vibes.

You could use these to water plants and set up a cycle where a significant portion of the water lost through evaporation was reclaimed and gradually accumulated locally. Dot a landscape with solar powered stacks of these things feeding appropriately selected plantations and you might make the desert bloom or help prevent the spread of deserts.

Re:Low-cost gel film can pluck drinking water from desert air by conductr on Thursday May 26, 2022 @11:32AM (#31519606)
That's an interesting concept I had not considered. I also am not sure if "we" (collective) would roll it out that way. We have a track record of consuming resources in the easiest/cheapest way with minor consideration of the environment. I don't think we'd even view this as a worthy investment if all it did was help prevent the spread of deserts. We still can't even agree if climate change is real and what we should do about it.
Re:Low-cost gel film can pluck drinking water from desert air by colechristensen on Thursday May 26, 2022 @11:37AM (#31519665)
Re:Low-cost gel film can pluck drinking water from desert air by conductr on Thursday May 26, 2022 @02:29PM (#31521814)
That's interesting. Reminds me of when I was a kid and thought I had a completely unique idea to fill the Sahara with water! It will quickly evaporate and turn to a rainforest in no time!!

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sahara_Sea

Re:Low-cost gel film can pluck drinking water from desert air by dylan604 on Thursday May 26, 2022 @11:38AM (#31519676)
I have little trust in the "we" doing anything like this correctly, at first. By that, I mean that it will be the corps to do this as they are the ones with the money to do it. Corps being corps, they will lean into being themselves and extract all of the everything they can with little respect for anything other than their bottom line.

I don't have faith gov't will do it either. Those opposed to climate change will argue it is money spent on fake science. It'll die in congress (for US, s/congress/localGovUselessBody/ for other places).

Someone might get popular enough to crowd source fund it with an NGO type thing, but I'm not holding my breath there either.

Re:Low-cost gel film can pluck drinking water from desert air by yonaguska on Thursday May 26, 2022 @02:14PM (#31521646)
I hope you'll be more optimistic about government outcomes, at least as far as opposition is concerned. I think I'd fall under your bucket of people that are "opposed to climate change", and I put that in quotes, because, it's not that I don't believe in climate change or anything like that. I just don't believe that the current "green" initiatives are the correct way to go about solving climate issues. I do however consider myself an environmentalist. I care more about the non C02 pollution that we are causing than simply trying to reduce C02 emissions.

I think you'd be hard pressed to find organic opposition to tackling environment issues that aren't related to the relatively abstract C02 pollution issues. I say organic because the corporations responsible for pollution will always find ways to manufacture consent that protects their own best interests. But, your stereotypical human-caused climate change denier is likely someone that hunts, fishes, or resides in a rural area, where environmental and conservationist concerns are taken very seriously, regardless of political affiliation. Your opposition is only going to come from people whose livelihood is affected by pollution controls. A broader swathe of people will always oppose addressing C02 related climate concerns because it affects literally everyone's bottom line in the form of rising cost of goods with energy prices going up, and it has abstract consequences, rather than concrete ones like your local streams being poisoned, or your well water going bad because the aquifer has been contaminated.

Re:Low-cost gel film can pluck drinking water from desert air by konschubert on Thursday May 26, 2022 @06:14PM (#31523959)
We could maybe do this with todays technology already - solar powered desalination plants.

There are plenty of desert coastlines.

Not sure how much that would cost per square meter of forest/agriculture, tbh.

Re:Low-cost gel film can pluck drinking water from desert air by bobthepanda on Friday May 27, 2022 @12:13AM (#31525956)
The appeal of relying on nature is that if the conditions are right, nature becomes a self sustaining, nearly zero maintenance solution.

Solar powered desal is pretty expensive.

Re:Low-cost gel film can pluck drinking water from desert air by jhgb on Thursday May 26, 2022 @04:44PM (#31523137)
> Now we want to pluck it out before they can get any.

I suspect that if you think that this is going to give us the ability to suck out all the water out of thousands of cubic kilometers of desert air any time soon, you're probably being a little too optimistic.

Re:Low-cost gel film can pluck drinking water from desert air by rhexs on Thursday May 26, 2022 @08:35PM (#31524898)
This is entirely dependent on whether or not Nestlé MBAs calculate they can make a profit with this bottling "Desert Air Water".
Re:Low-cost gel film can pluck drinking water from desert air by nopenopenopeno on Thursday May 26, 2022 @09:40PM (#31525261)
Yup. That is precisely how global warming works.
Re:Low-cost gel film can pluck drinking water from desert air by blacksqr on Thursday May 26, 2022 @10:09AM (#31518513)
The amount of water vapor in the air is functionally infinite with respect to any practical means to extract it.
Re:Low-cost gel film can pluck drinking water from desert air by rtkwe on Thursday May 26, 2022 @10:36AM (#31518832)
Only true on the large scale but locally you'll still create a depleted zone near the ground down wind of a hypothetical extraction plant.
Re:Low-cost gel film can pluck drinking water from desert air by dawsmik on Thursday May 26, 2022 @02:54PM (#31522086)
Re:Low-cost gel film can pluck drinking water from desert air by grishka on Thursday May 26, 2022 @04:15PM (#31522861)
But the water someone plucked out of desert air and drank doesn't poof out of existence. They'll eventually pee and sweat it out.
Re:Low-cost gel film can pluck drinking water from desert air by a1369209993 on Thursday May 26, 2022 @11:33PM (#31525768)
> They'll eventually pee and sweat [the water] out.

It's infuriatingly hard to find good citations, but I think they actually mostly breathe it out. IIRC, the water breakdown for some (spacecraft) life support system was something like 50% from respiration, 30% in urine, 10% in sweat, and 10% in feces.

Re:Low-cost gel film can pluck drinking water from desert air by ttul on Thursday May 26, 2022 @11:18AM (#31519407)
At 20C, the maximum water content in air is 17.3 x 10^-3 kg/m^3.

At 15% relative humidity, then, you can extract a maximum of 0.15 x 17.3g = 2.6g from every 1,000L of air.

If a person needs 5L/day for survival (I am making this up), then you’d need to dry out 5000 / 2.6 = 1,923L of air each day — that’s just short of two cubic meters…

If the density of people living in an area is 50 per square km, drying the air out to extract water would deplete the first meter of the atmosphere by 10%.

Re:Low-cost gel film can pluck drinking water from desert air by bufferoverflow on Thursday May 26, 2022 @11:31AM (#31519593)
> If a person needs 5L/day for survival (I am making this up), then you’d need to dry out 5000 / 2.6 = 1,923L of air each day

You made a unit conversion mistake there. It's 1923 cubic meters, not liters.

Re:Low-cost gel film can pluck drinking water from desert air by ttul on Thursday May 26, 2022 @02:44PM (#31521990)
Correct. 5,000g / 2.6 g per m^3 = 1,923 m^3

Okay let’s say the bottom 10m of atmosphere is available for water making. That means there are 10 million cubic meters of air per square km, or per 50 people. We will need to dry out 1,923 x 50 = 96,150 cubic meters of air. But there is 10,000,000 available, meaning we are only drying out just under 1% of the air.

Re:Low-cost gel film can pluck drinking water from desert air by npc12345 on Thursday May 26, 2022 @12:24PM (#31520277)
Aren't they equivalent?
Re:Low-cost gel film can pluck drinking water from desert air by tomrod on Thursday May 26, 2022 @12:51PM (#31520601)
liter = 0.001 Cubic meter

I was curious so I looked it up because I also did not know, ref: https://www.google.com/search?q=liters+in+cubic+meter&oq=lit...

Re:Low-cost gel film can pluck drinking water from desert air by martyvis on Thursday May 26, 2022 @04:47PM (#31523161)
Or to better visualise it, it is a 10x10x10 centimetre (cm) cube. (Or just a bit less than a 4x4x4 inch cube for the unmetrical )
Re:Low-cost gel film can pluck drinking water from desert air by npc12345 on Friday May 27, 2022 @04:40PM (#31534617)
Oh my you're right.
Re:Low-cost gel film can pluck drinking water from desert air by conductr on Thursday May 26, 2022 @11:23AM (#31519484)
If those people are living there 5L/day is nowhere near enough water. They are doing more than just surviving. Using Arizona as an example, Google tells me 550L/day/person is actual usage. I know you just put an assumption in but this is a big gap.
Re:Low-cost gel film can pluck drinking water from desert air by function_seven on Thursday May 26, 2022 @11:27AM (#31519538)
1,923,000L per day, right? So each person would need just short of 2,000 m³ of air.
Re:Low-cost gel film can pluck drinking water from desert air by ttul on Friday May 27, 2022 @11:26AM (#31530710)
And, for comparison, “ A 4-stroke engine with one litre displacement operating for 60 minutes at 2500 rpm is estimated to consume 1 L x 2500/2 rpm x 60 minutes/hour = 75,000 litres of air.”

https://collaboration.cmc.ec.gc.ca/science/rpn/SEM/dossiers/...

Re:Low-cost gel film can pluck drinking water from desert air by TwistedWave on Thursday May 26, 2022 @11:28AM (#31519542)
1,923m^3, not 1,923L
Re:Low-cost gel film can pluck drinking water from desert air by klvino on Thursday May 26, 2022 @10:04AM (#31518473)
That was my first thought as well, heavy use within an existing desert environment would likely have negative ecological impact.

When reading through the article, it has potential application in areas where a local water supply may not be clean enough to drink or lacks sufficient water treatment & filtration.

Re:Low-cost gel film can pluck drinking water from desert air by buu700 on Thursday May 26, 2022 @11:02AM (#31519194)
On the flip side, could it potentially be a cost-efficient method of dehumidifying cities/towns/villages for human comfort?
Re:Low-cost gel film can pluck drinking water from desert air by conductr on Thursday May 26, 2022 @11:19AM (#31519419)
Could even replace desalination since humidity has no salt and it is generally occurring in a similar area/climate.
Re:Low-cost gel film can pluck drinking water from desert air by sandworm101 on Thursday May 26, 2022 @12:29PM (#31520328)
Humidity theoretically doesn't contain salt, but air does. Any technology that is harvesting moisture from air will involve large amounts of air. That air contains dust and sea salt which can contaminate the process. Setup a moisture farm to harvest sea breezes and you will have to address a salt problem.

In many industries this airborne salt can cause corrosion. Talk to anyone with a classic car in LA/SF, both cities with sea breezes. They don't want to leave them outside too much. That's why the aircraft "boneyards" are all in the interior, across the mountains from the sea.

Re:Low-cost gel film can pluck drinking water from desert air by bushbaba on Thursday May 26, 2022 @11:59AM (#31519950)
And dryer air can absorb more water from the nearby sea...so there might not be a huge impact if placed in the right spot
Re:Low-cost gel film can pluck drinking water from desert air by Robotbeat on Thursday May 26, 2022 @11:14AM (#31519339)
Would it? The water will eventually evaporate again. It’s not like the water is burned up to nothing in a fusion reactor.
Re:Low-cost gel film can pluck drinking water from desert air by flockonus on Thursday May 26, 2022 @12:04PM (#31520026)
Could be easily drained down a pipe, the evaporation then is not as relevant even if some of it does, efficiency would most likely be acceptable.
Re:Low-cost gel film can pluck drinking water from desert air by throwaway894345 on Thursday May 26, 2022 @12:52PM (#31520628)
Deserts are expanding; it seems fine to offset that expanse as long as you're somewhat careful not to wipe out an entire ecosystem.
Re:Low-cost gel film can pluck drinking water from desert air by tomcam on Thursday May 26, 2022 @06:53PM (#31524255)
Sort of an interesting point. But don’t forget, in the Sahara, for example, there was less vegetation only 5000 or 6000 years ago
Re:Low-cost gel film can pluck drinking water from desert air by AnimalMuppet on Thursday May 26, 2022 @06:56PM (#31524277)
Less vegetation 5000 years ago? Are you sure you don't mean more?

Wikipedia speaks of an "abrupt desertification" 5400 years ago.

Re:Low-cost gel film can pluck drinking water from desert air by tomcam on Friday May 27, 2022 @12:49AM (#31526102)
Yes I meant more. Downvotes absolutely justified.
Re:Low-cost gel film can pluck drinking water from desert air by AnimalMuppet on Friday May 27, 2022 @12:38PM (#31531582)
Yeah, well, I've never mis-spoken in a post on HN. Never. (Furtively checks posting history) Or at least not today....
Re:Low-cost gel film can pluck drinking water from desert air by tomcam on Friday May 27, 2022 @01:39PM (#31532408)
I’m always grateful for the corrections, but thank you for doing it so gracefully.