News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by nh23423fefe on Sunday May 22, 2022 @10:21AM (#31468459)
Everytime one of these articles comes up, someone says, "but who will do price discovery, this is terrible"

What's the argument that active managers aren't just rent seeking parasites lying about their roles? Why have active fees gone down if they provided value all along?

Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by throw0101a on Sunday May 22, 2022 @11:22AM (#31469133)
> Everytime one of these articles comes up, someone says, "but who will do price discovery, this is terrible"

Note that this has been around since 1980:

> The Grossman-Stiglitz Paradox is a paradox introduced by Sanford J. Grossman and Joseph Stiglitz in a joint publication in American Economic Review in 1980[1] that argues perfectly informationally efficient markets are an impossibility since, if prices perfectly reflected available information, there is no profit to gathering information, in which case there would be little reason to trade and markets would eventually collapse.[2]

* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grossman-Stiglitz_Paradox

Paper:

* http://www.dklevine.com/archive/refs41908.pdf

* https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=228054

Price discovery happens at the edges: you probably don't need a lot activity for it. I think we're seeing a lot of the also-ran active managers (slowly) being weeded out, and the remainders will increasingly be those that actually manage to get things right every so often.

Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by ItsMonkk on Sunday May 22, 2022 @12:06PM (#31469638)
This isn't taking into account that there is really no such thing as 'passive'. In reality, passive investors are constantly either investing with their paycheck, or selling in retirement. They are the world's simplest active investors. If you put money into passive then the index buys. If you request money, the index sells.

So what you need to track is the net flows. If the net flows are positive, and there is so little active left in the market that no matter what the active investors do the stock still has positive net flows, then active has no other option than to buy. This eventually leads to stocks having an infinite price as there is no downward force. On the other hand, if net flows are negative, then prices go to 0.

Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by skybrian on Sunday May 22, 2022 @01:16PM (#31470469)
That’s an interesting way of looking at it, but it seems incomplete because for every buyer, there is a seller. A paycheck isn’t converted into stock, it’s traded for it, so some other account gets the cash. Supply and demand meant that asset prices went up, but that meant that the sellers got more cash for less stock.

Who was selling? Recent retirees did well when they sold, but is there more to it than that?

It’s an odd time when cash does poorly (inflation), bonds do worse, and the stock market fell. Prices are relative, though. I guess it’s all relative to commodities and labor.

It seems like increased debt due to higher-priced assets as collateral probably needs to be taken into account too.

Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by throw0101a on Sunday May 22, 2022 @06:11PM (#31473315)
> This isn't taking into account that there is really no such thing as 'passive'. In reality, passive investors are constantly either investing with their paycheck, or selling in retirement. They are the world's simplest active investors. If you put money into passive then the index buys. If you request money, the index sells.

Passive investing means something, and what you are saying is not it. From William F. Sharpe, Nobel-winning economist who came up with capital asset pricing model (CAPM):

> A passive investor always holds every security from the market, with each represented in the same manner as in the market. Thus if security X represents 3 per cent of the value of the securities in the market, a passive investor's portfolio will have 3 per cent of its value invested in X. Equivalently, a passive manager will hold the same percentage of the total outstanding amount of each security in the market[2].

* https://web.stanford.edu/~wfsharpe/art/active/active.htm

A "passive" investment strategy is not about not-buying/selling, but rather about not actively choosing particular financial instruments.

> Passive management (also called passive investing) is an investing strategy that tracks a market-weighted index or portfolio.[1][2] Passive management is most common on the equity market, where index funds track a stock market index, but it is becoming more common in other investment types, including bonds, commodities and hedge funds.[3]

* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Passive_management

Following a particular index (NASDAQ, Dow Jones, S&P 500, Russell 3000, Wilshire 5000, TSX, FTSE 100, MSCI EAFE) is passive investing, even if you put in money every pay cheque.

Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by medvezhenok on Sunday May 22, 2022 @06:56PM (#31473630)
I think grandparent has a point - passive is a misnomer. Academic analyses of passive investing start right after the securities have been acquired and before they’re sold, which pretends that passive flows have no effect on the market (by definition - « always holding exactly 3% » implies no selling or buying, otherwise it is not possible)

« Passive » funds do buy & sell based on flows and tracking of the index, not to mention when companies IPO and/or drop in/out of things like the S&P 500. Market weighted fund might be a better overall name than passive.

Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by throw0101a on Sunday May 22, 2022 @07:07PM (#31473698)
I am aware of the terminology subtleties:

> The terms passive investing and index investing are often intertwined, but they are not exactly the same thing. Today’s guest is Adriana Robertson, the Honourable Justice Frank Iacobucci Chair in Capital Markets Regulation and an associate professor of Law and Finance at the University of Toronto Faculty of Law and Rotman School of Management. Adriana is interested in index investing and, in this episode, we hear her views on whether or not index investing is passive. Hear facts from her paper on the S&P 500 Index fund specifically, and all of the reasons that it's not passive, as well as some of the issues that are potentially arising from the creation of so many indexes or so-called passive investments. A more recent paper by Adriana, published in The Journal of Finance, surveyed a representative sample of U.S. individual investors about how well leading academic theories describe their financial beliefs and decisions, and Adriana shares the differences in something like value growth from an academic perspective versus a real-world perspective. Find out how investors can go about evaluating the performance of their portfolios and what they should be looking for when deciding which index fund to invest in, as well as why index funds aren’t a meaningful category anyway, factors from Adriana’s surveys that might influence investor’s equity allocation, and the trend towards indexing and whether it will overtake active portfolios. Tune in today for all this and more!

* https://rationalreminder.ca/podcast/133

Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by jleahy on Sunday May 22, 2022 @06:40PM (#31473518)
Technically speaking the Dow would not be a passive investment (by the definitions above), as it’s not market cap weighted.
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by lupire on Sunday May 22, 2022 @07:38PM (#31473908)
Does anyone invest in a DoW index fund?
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by yareally on Sunday May 22, 2022 @08:32PM (#31474212)
Yeah, people buy shares of DIA all the time. It's a popular index fund. Not as liquid as spx/spy/qqq, but it's still up there
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by im3w1l on Sunday May 22, 2022 @12:21PM (#31469811)
That's a passive failure mode I haven't seen before. To elaborate on what you said:

Imagine an index, and an index fund tracking it. The index fund will own x% of every stock in the index. Someone buys the index fund, and the index fund now try to achieve x+epsilon% in every stock.

But what if 100-x% of the stock is owned by diamond-hands hodlers, that wont sell at any price? The index fund bids higher and higher, and the sellers refuse to let their shares go, making the price reach ridiculous levels.

The price reaching 0 seems less likely, as there will always be bargain hunters.

Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by nradov on Sunday May 22, 2022 @12:35PM (#31470000)
Index fund managers aren't idiots. Their trading systems still have a degree of sanity checking and human oversight, so they won't attempt to track the index exactly if things get weird. But for large-cap indexes like S&P 500, the "diamond-hands hodlers" lack the capital reserves necessary to really manipulate the market. At some point many of the underlying companies would also take advantage of excessive stock prices by issuing secondary offerings, thus increasing the supply.
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by lupire on Sunday May 22, 2022 @07:42PM (#31473937)
Yah stock won't go to infinity. But TSLA joining the S&P 500 created synthetic demand that synthetically increased price/valuation.
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by dsr_ on Sunday May 22, 2022 @12:35PM (#31469993)
You're leaving out three factors: indexes are not static over long terms; the creation/destruction of new public corporations; and the possibility of existing public corporations offering more stock.
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by HALtheWise on Sunday May 22, 2022 @12:47PM (#31470153)
There's two key ways new stock can be created to avoid this risk: companies can issue it, or short sellers can create it. If the company sees its stock rising, it can and should see that as a cheap source of capital and absorb some of it through a stock sale to do more of whatever business they're in.
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by ItsMonkk on Sunday May 22, 2022 @01:20PM (#31470510)
You think that companies are going to issue new stock in order to ensure that the value of their company doesn't go UP? If anything, the more they take out loans and buyback their stock, the faster it goes to infinity. And the faster it goes to infinity, the more collateral it has, to take out another loan, to buy more stock...

And you think short-sellers are going to risk infinite losses? This is a prisoner's dilemma that you aren't going to win.

Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by jbay808 on Sunday May 22, 2022 @01:46PM (#31470797)
> If the company sees its stock rising, it can and should... absorb some of it through a stock sale

That's ultimately down to the incentives in place. If the board members have a lot of options in their compensation package, they might prefer to see the stock price climb and climb. In fact if the incentives are set up that way they might do a buyback to help fuel the rise, even at the cost of longer-term harm to the company.

Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by nightski on Sunday May 22, 2022 @01:58PM (#31470937)
Short sellers do not create stock. They are selling borrowed stocks. What am I missing.
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by lupire on Sunday May 22, 2022 @07:41PM (#31473928)
The person they borrowed it from also still owns the original share. The borrow creates a share, and the repayment destroys it. Fractional reserve stockholding.
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by nly on Sunday May 22, 2022 @03:28PM (#31471808)
Privileged market participants can definitely lend out more stock then they hold, provided eveurnting is collateralised
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by svnt on Sunday May 22, 2022 @02:18PM (#31471144)
Synthetic longs.
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by blibble on Sunday May 22, 2022 @12:51PM (#31470199)
the genius thing about ETFs is they don't have to buy or sell the stock: others do it for them

have a read about the creation/redemption mechanism and you'll see why this won't heppen

Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by im3w1l on Monday May 23, 2022 @09:16AM (#31478613)
Yeah, I knew about that. I had to look up their relative size to mutual funds though. Turns out mutual funds manage $23.9T compared to $5.4T in ETFs. I guess passive funds are more likely to be ETFs. But it could mean there is enough passive mutual fund money to pose a problem.

https://www.investopedia.com/articles/exchangetradedfunds/08...

Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by thoughtstheseus on Sunday May 22, 2022 @03:16PM (#31471688)
They issue the person redeeming the the actual underlying securities. Then it’s up to them to sell it. Fun model.
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by Majromax on Sunday May 22, 2022 @01:53PM (#31470873)
> Note that this has been around since 1980:

The strong efficient market hypothesis combined with completely rational (no-noise) market participants leads to a "no-trade theorem." If anyone tried to buy or sell a security based on new information, other market participants would incorporate that attempt into their information about the market. The notional price would change (bid/ask), but the security wouldn't trade hands.

This is of course absurd in practice because securities do in fact trade, but it tells us that we don't need random retail investors picking stocks with coin flips (or asset managers doing so and charging 2%/yr for the privilege) in order to discover fair prices.

Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by jeffreyrogers on Sunday May 22, 2022 @11:23AM (#31469141)
> What's the argument that active managers aren't just rent seeking parasites lying about their roles?

That someone has to set prices and structurally index funds can't do that job. How are prices going to be set without active participants? You could do it by formula I guess, but that would be gamed by companies around earnings time and doesn't account for differences in industries or differences in corporate strategy.

> Why have active fees gone down if they provided value all along?

That's exactly what you would expect as more firms enter providing the same service. The same thing happens in every other market. More competition drives down margins.

Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by cyphar on Sunday May 22, 2022 @07:40PM (#31473918)
If markets stop being efficient at price discovery, why wouldn't active managers and hedge funds exploit that inefficiency? In other words, why are active managers and their supporters arguing that they aren't good at their job?

(The answer is that they would exploit the inefficiency and the market would maintain efficient price discovery, but they'll get more business by fear-mongering around index funds.)

Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by michaelt on Sunday May 22, 2022 @10:45AM (#31468735)
> What's the argument that active managers aren't just rent seeking parasites lying about their roles?

"That might be true of other active managers - not me though, this fund I manage has outperformed the market over the past 10 years."

Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by dmoy on Sunday May 22, 2022 @10:49AM (#31468792)
* shovels records of 9 other defunct funds under the rug, to hide any evidence of survivorship bias *
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by briHass on Sunday May 22, 2022 @12:15PM (#31469726)
Also, forgets to mention 'before fees'. When the ER is included, it is a loser compared to a low ER index fund.
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by oneoff786 on Sunday May 22, 2022 @11:18AM (#31469086)
If everyone invests in the sp500 then the price of the sp500 will climb, guaranteed, because you know that next months paychecks will purchase more of it.

You can’t really do anything about this even if you’re actively aware of this mechanism and think it’s fundamentally over valued.

It’s like a decentralized Ponzi scheme

Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by gruez on Sunday May 22, 2022 @11:33AM (#31469251)
What isn't a ponzi scheme these days? If you're passively investing in stocks, it's a ponzi because of the reason you outlined. However, if you're actively investing and bought a stock that's a little too popular (eg. tesla), then that's also a ponzi because "the company doesn't make a profit and the way people are making money is from new investors paying older investors". Hell, even if you only buy blue chip stocks with reliable earnings, some of your original complaint is still there (ie. people mindlessly buying it because they know it's reliable, new investors paying old investors).
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by kaashif on Sunday May 22, 2022 @01:56PM (#31470915)
While the stock market may be stupid, it's not a Ponzi scheme. A Ponzi scheme involves a fraudster lying about where the money is going and coming from, and thus defrauding people.

If people know what they're buying, and they later really sell it to a willing buyer without lying to them, that's not even any kind of fraud, let alone a Ponzi scheme.

Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by salawat on Sunday May 22, 2022 @02:53PM (#31471491)
It's funny, because I have yet to have a company give me access to the entirety of their books to analyze.

That's info asymmetry.

Ergo, lying.

Specifically by omission.

So the Ponzi essence is still there.

Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by JumpCrisscross on Sunday May 22, 2022 @03:13PM (#31471649)
> I have yet to have a company give me access to the entirety of their books to analyze

Have you gone to a shareholder meeting? Submitted a question to an earnings call?

Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by oneoff786 on Sunday May 22, 2022 @12:39PM (#31470050)
Making shareholders liable for company debts in the event of bankruptcy would be a start.
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by shukantpal on Sunday May 22, 2022 @12:45PM (#31470125)
That's a foolish idea, happy to know it's from a one off.
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by oneoff786 on Sunday May 22, 2022 @12:49PM (#31470179)
We’re all one offs in the end
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by shukantpal on Tuesday May 24, 2022 @12:32AM (#31488022)
I'm not a one off 786.
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by datadata on Sunday May 22, 2022 @03:24PM (#31471760)
Debt based monetary policy is the root ponzi here. Our rate of assuming new debt depends on the assumption of endless economic growth.
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by fartcannon on Sunday May 22, 2022 @11:40AM (#31469336)
I cant tell if youre joking or not because I sorta do think it is all a scam. I think the stock market is a way to keep the sociopaths doing something less dangerous than continuous war and insurrection. Whether intentionally or not, I think that's it's primary value.

It basically magnifies wealth discrepancy which is what the sociopaths want. The rest of us just try not to become poor by playing their games. Whenever everyone gets too close to fair, they invent a new game, or take the ball and go home. You know? I'm only sort of kidding. :D

Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by andsoitis on Sunday May 22, 2022 @11:45AM (#31469389)
> Whenever everyone gets too close to fair, they invent a new game, or take the ball and go home.

who is “they”?

Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by fartcannon on Sunday May 22, 2022 @11:47AM (#31469417)
Sociopaths
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by TedDoesntTalk on Sunday May 22, 2022 @12:50PM (#31470190)
What an interesting world view.
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by fartcannon on Sunday May 22, 2022 @02:29PM (#31471242)
I try and think about it from our tribal, small group primate origin perspective. I hope you're not mocking me, but if you are, I still do think it's interesting actually. :)

Like maybe we didn't kill the neanderthals, you know? I think we probably convinced them to kill each other. That's kind of our specialty.

Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by TedDoesntTalk on Sunday May 22, 2022 @03:03PM (#31471572)
I’m not mocking you. But if I had that world view, I might not get out of bed in the morning.
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by JumpCrisscross on Sunday May 22, 2022 @03:14PM (#31471665)
> if I had that world view, I might not get out of bed in the morning

It might be the inverse. Someone not wanting to get out of bed in the morning projecting that view onto the world.

Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by fartcannon on Sunday May 22, 2022 @03:20PM (#31471724)
It's neither! What's the problem with trying to explain human motivations like greed using our evolution? I genuinely think it's interesting.
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by JumpCrisscross on Sunday May 22, 2022 @03:29PM (#31471818)
> What's the problem with trying to explain human motivations like greed using our evolution?

Look up Social Darwinism. Broadly: most evolutionary explanations for social behaviour aren’t science. They’re parlour tricks. One can posit reasonable-sounding explanations for any behaviour, real or hypothetical, none of which is testable.

Example: I can construct individual-selection arguments for humans being evolved sociopaths and group-selection arguments for humans being collectivist sheep. There is truth in both statements. But their predictive value is totally dependent on the immeasurable mix and mechanics thereof, all of which is blissfully ignored, both in substance and evaluation, by this framing.

Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by fartcannon on Sunday May 22, 2022 @03:56PM (#31472090)
I think maybe you're talking about something else, or believe that I am, or I'm misunderstanding you because it feels like you're trying to tell me that my _imagination_ is a parlour trick. Ive been on the internet for a long time and this is the first time that has ever happened.

I value the time you put into explaining your position, however I dont think creative thought exercises like trying to explain why wall street is full of a-holes using evoluton is a parlour trick. Because there's no trick. It's just a thought. On a discussion forum. Where people discuss things.

Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by JumpCrisscross on Sunday May 22, 2022 @04:15PM (#31472286)
> my _imagination_ is a parlour trick...there's no trick. It's just a thought

There is a trick. You're claiming artistic license as a fictional narrator. That's fine! That's a thing!

But it doesn't work when presenting explanations for the real world. One in which the stock market is a "scam" whose "primary value" is "to keep the sociopaths" busy while it "magnifies wealth discrepancy which is what the sociopaths want" all while if someone other than "they" start winning "they invent a new game, or take the ball and go home" [1].

Evolutionary explanations of sociology have a long history of being deeply flawed. At best, they're arbitrary [2]. As explanations for the present state of the world, they aren't useful. As fictional devices, sure, why not.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31469336

[2] Caveat: evolutionary thinking works when one starts with real-world observations and supposes how they evolved. Cf: the evolution of altruism in humans [a]. It fails when one supposes evolutionary pressures to predict human behavior, e.g. natural selection and social competition exist, herego we should expect our leaders to be sociopaths. Observation, not supposition, before conclusion.

[a] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25061670

Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by fartcannon on Sunday May 22, 2022 @04:41PM (#31472533)
I notice you left out the 'I think' from when you quoted me. That's how you were supposed to know it's not fiction, it's not a parlor trick, it's a thought. Kinda like brainstorming. Suggesting there is a 'trick' to what I'm writing implies (to me at least) that I'm attempting to deceive. I assure you I am not.

And since we're quoting each other, you opened with, "It might be the inverse. Someone not wanting to get out of bed in the morning projecting that view onto the world." I assure you I love getting out of bed. On the other hand, I kinda get the vibe the discussion you're having is a continuation of one you've had before with someone else and maybe you're projecting it on to me?

I checked out your profile and now I understand! Haha. Fun times. Thanks for the links.

Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by fartcannon on Sunday May 22, 2022 @03:19PM (#31471704)
Ah, I see. Well, I assure you that it invigorates and inspires me. I consider it one of my stronger assets and I highly recommend it.
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by kaashif on Sunday May 22, 2022 @01:52PM (#31470859)
> It’s like a decentralized Ponzi scheme

A Ponzi scheme is a type of fraud where someone lies about where the money paying off earlier investors is coming from - they say it comes from investment in some kind of business or other businesses, but it actually comes from later investors' investments.

The stock market is transparent, it is obvious that when you buy something, part of the return will come from a later investor buying it from you - that's the whole point of buying something.

It's not a Ponzi scheme if there's no-one lying about where the money comes from.

Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by renewiltord on Sunday May 22, 2022 @11:35AM (#31469275)
Okay, I'll buy your 358 VOO Puts expiring May 27 at 1¢ each. Easy money for you. I will pay you $100 for 100 such contracts (usual lot size 100).

EDIT: Counter offer or decline acceptable. I can go up to $1k on this. I have money in play from this site up to 3x payout. Your call.

Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by oneoff786 on Sunday May 22, 2022 @02:51PM (#31471453)
You edited your post to add more detail for some reason. No, it’s still not clever.

Believing passive investing at scale causes irrational rises in price does not mean it’s wise to assume the price will definitely go up or down. It’s obviously not the only effect in the market.

Going long on the general market is a bet that things will generally continue. That’s about it.

Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by renewiltord on Sunday May 22, 2022 @03:06PM (#31471598)
I comment in bursts, which has me hit rate limits on HN. Then I have to use edit-functionality till rate-limit-expiry.

In any case, if you don't want to play that's fine. I enjoy this; you don't. No reason to be offended. Offer open to others. Has been taken up in the past. Fun for all.

Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by oneoff786 on Sunday May 22, 2022 @12:33PM (#31469978)
These gotchas aren’t nearly as clever as you think.
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by thrwyoilarticle on Sunday May 22, 2022 @03:23PM (#31471753)
>If everyone invests in the sp500

...being the key phrase. There's a long way to go to 100%.

Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by oneoff786 on Sunday May 22, 2022 @06:03PM (#31473253)
It doesn’t need to be 100%. It just needs to be a fairly large portion of the holders of the sp500.

Technically it can’t be 100%, else there’s nobody to buy from.

Many of the heavily targeted companies are at 20-30% index fund ownership.

Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by IMSAI8080 on Sunday May 22, 2022 @12:50PM (#31470188)
There'll never be a shortage of people who think they can beat the market. Market beating is just such a compelling illusion. Also passive funds are not quite 100% passive. What does everyone do when they're broke? Stop investing. How about when times are good? Pile more into investments. There's also many different types of passive funds with slightly different biases. There's world passive funds (which have maybe 40% not in the S&P). There's passive funds that track other specific countries. There's ESG passive funds that avoid oil companies and such. There's passive that skips China. There's investor biases in there and prices being discovered all over.
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by legulere on Sunday May 22, 2022 @03:28PM (#31471809)
If passive funds are not passive like for instance synthetic ETFs and you cannot beat the market then how are they making money?
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by IMSAI8080 on Friday May 27, 2022 @04:42PM (#31534628)
They charge fees. They also lend stocks to shorters (and charge a fee for that). And cheap brokers sell order flow.
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by Invictus0 on Sunday May 22, 2022 @12:57PM (#31470269)
Yes, Berkshire Hathaway and Renaissance are just figments of the imagination.
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by IMSAI8080 on Sunday May 22, 2022 @01:24PM (#31470553)
Now throw in all the other active funds and average them out. Also Berkshire would not have been the better investment over the last decade. Can you guarantee me Berkshire will pull ahead before I retire?
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by blitzar on Sunday May 22, 2022 @01:35PM (#31470679)
Berkshire is up 280% vs S&P up 180% for the last decade.

That said Berkshire is a pretty poor example as it has a pretty diverse range of holdings, its basically a passive index of its own.

Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by lotsofpulp on Sunday May 22, 2022 @01:51PM (#31470855)
https://dqydj.com/sp-500-return-calculator/

This site says SP500 with dividend reinvested is 270%.

I also feel like SP500 has a lot less risk because politicians are very incentivized to provide a backstop to SP500 price, but not as much to BRK.

Also, BRK is squeaking out 280% vs SPY 270% by being 25%+ invested in a single company, Apple. That is a lot of extra risk for not a lot of extra return.

Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by IMSAI8080 on Sunday May 22, 2022 @02:23PM (#31471192)
That's incorrect, you forgot the dividends. I went with an analysis from last year where Berkshire was behind and was doing worse than the S&P. Now they're about evens. Berkshire is now an S&P500 tracker.
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by Invictus0 on Sunday May 22, 2022 @01:32PM (#31470650)
What a silly thing to stay. Let me just ignore that and explain why Berkshire works. It's possible to beat the market because it's possible to buy $1 for $0.95. That's the whole trick. It takes a lot of work, a lot of smart people, and you have to make big enough deals to cover the cost of paying the managers, but yes, these opportunities exist and they are abundant. The real mistake is thinking that the market is a bunch of random number generators with no rhyme or reason to it. But no, there are no guarantees--the SPY doesn't come with a guarantee either.
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by IMSAI8080 on Sunday May 22, 2022 @01:53PM (#31470874)
That makes no sense at all. What you're saying is it's possible to hire people who can see the future. Index tracking works because the market as a whole generally trends upwards if you wait long enough. This would be expected as the world generally gets richer and technology generally improves. The problem is you can't predict which exact company is going to do the improving. So just buy a very wide spread of companies and take the average. 80% of active managers fail to beat the market because they cannot see the future. The other 20% are lucky (today). If you want a lesson in the dangers of active management, look up Neil Woodford.
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by svnt on Sunday May 22, 2022 @02:21PM (#31471176)
You only need to hire people who can see the future from the perspective of the market. It is entirely possible, and it is the reason why insider trading is heavily regulated.
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by cko on Monday May 23, 2022 @12:03AM (#31475234)
Ben Felix cited in a video that Berkshire's excess returns can be explained by their value tilt, and after accounting for that, this apparent excess return is statistically insignificant.

http://docs.lhpedersen.com/BuffettsAlpha.pdf

Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by lotsofpulp on Sunday May 22, 2022 @01:23PM (#31470542)
Has BRK outperformed SP500 since 2009?
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by pkulak on Sunday May 22, 2022 @12:25PM (#31469874)
> but who will do price discovery, this is terrible

Whoever actually believes they have more information than the market and is willing to stake their own money on the proposition. I'd guess that we need surprisingly few of those folks to keep the machinery humming.

Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by wsostt on Sunday May 22, 2022 @11:46AM (#31469408)
You’re not considering that a lot of active managers are helping clients define bespoke investment strategies that suit their assets and liabilities. They set a strategy, pick a benchmark, and invest. In some cases, a portion of those investments may be passive instruments and other portions may be research-driven asset allocation by the manager.
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by the_cat_kittles on Sunday May 22, 2022 @12:26PM (#31469893)
i think its all just bullshit to make the client feel like they are heard / in charge. its like a mutual agreement to make eachother feel important.
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by wsostt on Sunday May 22, 2022 @12:53PM (#31470227)
Clients are heard and in charge. These are smart people who will terminate the relationship if their goals aren’t being met. This isn’t your retirement account. These are accounts in the 9+ figure range.
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by m3nu on Sunday May 22, 2022 @11:55AM (#31469504)
That sounds like a financial adviser, not a manager of an active fund.
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by SkipperCat on Sunday May 22, 2022 @12:01PM (#31469579)
There are actively managed funds that hold stocks, bonds and other instruments and constantly balance those ratio on a daily basis to give investors a steady state of returns (think 4% to 6%). A lot of folks who want fixed income returns instead of cap gains growth purchase these funds. Retirees and pension funds are big consumers of these product.

This requires complex daily work and would be nearly impossible for a financial advisor to perform.

Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by 55555 on Sunday May 22, 2022 @12:58PM (#31470285)
Can you give any examples of these which can be bought via brokerage account?
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by wsostt on Sunday May 22, 2022 @01:12PM (#31470430)
Not OP, but I doubt it. These are individual mandates with mandatory minimums in the tens of millions of dollars for a small shop.
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by SkipperCat on Sunday May 22, 2022 @10:20PM (#31474770)
Vanguard targeted retirement funds. VTTHX is their 2035 target fund. They are constantly readjusting their balance of stocks/bond/cash to meet a stable return in the year 2035.

Virtus AZNAX is another fund that blends a bunch of financial instruments to achieve a targeted return.

There's plenty others and they're all available from any retail brokerage firm.

Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by jshaqaw on Sunday May 22, 2022 @05:12PM (#31472849)
Interest to revisit such militant attitudes should the current crash of inflated bullshit techcos continue.

Is your kids 529 plan on the S&P. Well congrats - you got to buy Tesla at the peak of Elon’s pump train just in time to be a ticket holder for his self-immolation show.

Does your 401k hold small cap exposure to the Russell. Yippee you get to be the bag holder for a good chunk of the SPAC garbage VCs dumped into public markets based on things like projections that personal electric helicopter taxis would become ubiquitous in US urban markets by 2025.

Passive investing got gamed by Silicon Valley and isn’t exactly what Bogle had in mind when he got started.

Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by sepiasaucer on Sunday May 22, 2022 @05:30PM (#31472986)
I don’t understand what point you are trying to make.

Specific stocks being bad investments is not an argument against passive investing. The whole point of index funds is to diversify your portfolio so you track the overall market, not any specific stock or group of stocks.

If you are assuming you know which stocks/sectors are under or overvalued, then I guess active investing makes sense, but that seems like a flawed premise to start from.

Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by jshaqaw on Sunday May 22, 2022 @08:41PM (#31474264)
You aren’t tracking the whole market. An index is a subset. Even total market indices have weightings which embed biases. And the whole game has been reverse engineered by charlatans to dump crap into rivers of blind money. If think capital offerings aren’t designed explicitly to target index inclusion criteria then you aren’t in on the joke.
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by cromka on Monday May 23, 2022 @02:30AM (#31475907)
> And the whole game has been reverse engineered by charlatans to dump crap into rivers of blind money. If think capital offerings aren’t designed explicitly to target index inclusion criteria then you aren’t in on the joke.

This is an interesting and plausible take, just wondering if you have actual published resources on that or is it your personal, arguably justified hunch?

Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by jshaqaw on Monday May 23, 2022 @05:32PM (#31485023)
Just talk to VCs, CFOs, and their bankers around offerings. Targeting say the Russell 2k inclusion criteria is an explicit part of the roadshow pitch.
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by LatteLazy on Sunday May 22, 2022 @11:25AM (#31469171)
The arguement in both cases is that if someone is doing something useful in a market (like price discovery) they'll be paid according to how useful they are. And if their pay exceeds the cost then they'll profit. If not then your guy (or girl, or other descriptor) isn't useful and you're paying them from your picket. But it's your job to check and move your money accordingly. And you'll be paid for doing so, and penalised for not doing so.

If your active manager beats the index (in returns and risk) after fees then he is earning his keep both for you and the world in gen

Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by andi999 on Sunday May 22, 2022 @02:34PM (#31471290)
Personally, I dont think price discovery is the biggest problem, but no overseight of the board of directors. Etf do not actively vote (as far as i understand). So this opens up for management and minority owners to run the comopany badly (or even plunder it). This is a negative effect in the long run though.
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by matthewowen on Sunday May 22, 2022 @02:38PM (#31471329)
BlackRock absolutely votes. The concern is arguably the _opposite_: in the index model ownership is concentrated in a few large institutions with very broad diversification, which creates some odd incentives.

Matt Levine has a bunch of articles touching on this topic.

Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by cromka on Monday May 23, 2022 @02:34AM (#31475921)
But ultimately the indices are incentivized by the underlying companies' growth, as to make their customers happy, thus it is in their best interest to take sane votes?
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by kwere on Sunday May 22, 2022 @03:52PM (#31472043)
they vote , usually against all stewardship bogus they like to signal [0].

[0] https://shareaction.org/news/new-data-shows-scant-improvemen...

Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by legitster on Sunday May 22, 2022 @11:19AM (#31469089)
Well, we've kind of known that the benefits of active management would be diminishingly small. In theory they could be working just as hard, but at this point they are being paid to clip coupons that aren't there.
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by lvl102 on Sunday May 22, 2022 @11:04AM (#31468933)
Price discovery just happens on a different pace mostly around earnings. But you’re still at the mercy of market makers which is a big problem on its own. We also have bonds/convertibles to help price securities.
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by FunnyBadger on Sunday May 22, 2022 @05:16PM (#31472878)
The market does price discovery if it's not program traded.

What markets are doing is recording and publishing the results of auctions for the particular good as a time series of data. Indexes hide some of that but there's something far worse: HFT.

The problem is that program trading and HFT has far more in common with the old Scientific American COREWAR game than it does with the fundamentals of price discovery. The buy/sell decisions are about gaming other players rather than discovering price. There are also nonlinear feedback loops with very short loop time constants created that are "nonconservative" in a physics sense and create instablity. The fact that hard limits are required to deal with flash crashes is a warning, not a solution!!

Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by whimsicalism on Sunday May 22, 2022 @12:05PM (#31469626)
Price discovery can be left to the prop traders.
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by missedthecue on Sunday May 22, 2022 @03:55PM (#31472073)
Wouldn't fees go down as a result of more competition in the sector?
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by blitzar on Sunday May 22, 2022 @12:42PM (#31470090)
> "but who will do price discovery, this is terrible" - just rent seeking parasites lying about their roles

I think you copied and pasted your rant from a different rant about finance as it really doesnt have anything to do with this.