News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by oneoff786 on Sunday May 22, 2022 @11:18AM (#31469086)
If everyone invests in the sp500 then the price of the sp500 will climb, guaranteed, because you know that next months paychecks will purchase more of it.

You can’t really do anything about this even if you’re actively aware of this mechanism and think it’s fundamentally over valued.

It’s like a decentralized Ponzi scheme

Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by gruez on Sunday May 22, 2022 @11:33AM (#31469251)
What isn't a ponzi scheme these days? If you're passively investing in stocks, it's a ponzi because of the reason you outlined. However, if you're actively investing and bought a stock that's a little too popular (eg. tesla), then that's also a ponzi because "the company doesn't make a profit and the way people are making money is from new investors paying older investors". Hell, even if you only buy blue chip stocks with reliable earnings, some of your original complaint is still there (ie. people mindlessly buying it because they know it's reliable, new investors paying old investors).
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by kaashif on Sunday May 22, 2022 @01:56PM (#31470915)
While the stock market may be stupid, it's not a Ponzi scheme. A Ponzi scheme involves a fraudster lying about where the money is going and coming from, and thus defrauding people.

If people know what they're buying, and they later really sell it to a willing buyer without lying to them, that's not even any kind of fraud, let alone a Ponzi scheme.

Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by salawat on Sunday May 22, 2022 @02:53PM (#31471491)
It's funny, because I have yet to have a company give me access to the entirety of their books to analyze.

That's info asymmetry.

Ergo, lying.

Specifically by omission.

So the Ponzi essence is still there.

Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by JumpCrisscross on Sunday May 22, 2022 @03:13PM (#31471649)
> I have yet to have a company give me access to the entirety of their books to analyze

Have you gone to a shareholder meeting? Submitted a question to an earnings call?

Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by oneoff786 on Sunday May 22, 2022 @12:39PM (#31470050)
Making shareholders liable for company debts in the event of bankruptcy would be a start.
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by shukantpal on Sunday May 22, 2022 @12:45PM (#31470125)
That's a foolish idea, happy to know it's from a one off.
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by oneoff786 on Sunday May 22, 2022 @12:49PM (#31470179)
We’re all one offs in the end
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by shukantpal on Tuesday May 24, 2022 @12:32AM (#31488022)
I'm not a one off 786.
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by datadata on Sunday May 22, 2022 @03:24PM (#31471760)
Debt based monetary policy is the root ponzi here. Our rate of assuming new debt depends on the assumption of endless economic growth.
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by fartcannon on Sunday May 22, 2022 @11:40AM (#31469336)
I cant tell if youre joking or not because I sorta do think it is all a scam. I think the stock market is a way to keep the sociopaths doing something less dangerous than continuous war and insurrection. Whether intentionally or not, I think that's it's primary value.

It basically magnifies wealth discrepancy which is what the sociopaths want. The rest of us just try not to become poor by playing their games. Whenever everyone gets too close to fair, they invent a new game, or take the ball and go home. You know? I'm only sort of kidding. :D

Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by andsoitis on Sunday May 22, 2022 @11:45AM (#31469389)
> Whenever everyone gets too close to fair, they invent a new game, or take the ball and go home.

who is “they”?

Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by fartcannon on Sunday May 22, 2022 @11:47AM (#31469417)
Sociopaths
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by TedDoesntTalk on Sunday May 22, 2022 @12:50PM (#31470190)
What an interesting world view.
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by fartcannon on Sunday May 22, 2022 @02:29PM (#31471242)
I try and think about it from our tribal, small group primate origin perspective. I hope you're not mocking me, but if you are, I still do think it's interesting actually. :)

Like maybe we didn't kill the neanderthals, you know? I think we probably convinced them to kill each other. That's kind of our specialty.

Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by TedDoesntTalk on Sunday May 22, 2022 @03:03PM (#31471572)
I’m not mocking you. But if I had that world view, I might not get out of bed in the morning.
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by JumpCrisscross on Sunday May 22, 2022 @03:14PM (#31471665)
> if I had that world view, I might not get out of bed in the morning

It might be the inverse. Someone not wanting to get out of bed in the morning projecting that view onto the world.

Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by fartcannon on Sunday May 22, 2022 @03:20PM (#31471724)
It's neither! What's the problem with trying to explain human motivations like greed using our evolution? I genuinely think it's interesting.
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by JumpCrisscross on Sunday May 22, 2022 @03:29PM (#31471818)
> What's the problem with trying to explain human motivations like greed using our evolution?

Look up Social Darwinism. Broadly: most evolutionary explanations for social behaviour aren’t science. They’re parlour tricks. One can posit reasonable-sounding explanations for any behaviour, real or hypothetical, none of which is testable.

Example: I can construct individual-selection arguments for humans being evolved sociopaths and group-selection arguments for humans being collectivist sheep. There is truth in both statements. But their predictive value is totally dependent on the immeasurable mix and mechanics thereof, all of which is blissfully ignored, both in substance and evaluation, by this framing.

Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by fartcannon on Sunday May 22, 2022 @03:56PM (#31472090)
I think maybe you're talking about something else, or believe that I am, or I'm misunderstanding you because it feels like you're trying to tell me that my _imagination_ is a parlour trick. Ive been on the internet for a long time and this is the first time that has ever happened.

I value the time you put into explaining your position, however I dont think creative thought exercises like trying to explain why wall street is full of a-holes using evoluton is a parlour trick. Because there's no trick. It's just a thought. On a discussion forum. Where people discuss things.

Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by JumpCrisscross on Sunday May 22, 2022 @04:15PM (#31472286)
> my _imagination_ is a parlour trick...there's no trick. It's just a thought

There is a trick. You're claiming artistic license as a fictional narrator. That's fine! That's a thing!

But it doesn't work when presenting explanations for the real world. One in which the stock market is a "scam" whose "primary value" is "to keep the sociopaths" busy while it "magnifies wealth discrepancy which is what the sociopaths want" all while if someone other than "they" start winning "they invent a new game, or take the ball and go home" [1].

Evolutionary explanations of sociology have a long history of being deeply flawed. At best, they're arbitrary [2]. As explanations for the present state of the world, they aren't useful. As fictional devices, sure, why not.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31469336

[2] Caveat: evolutionary thinking works when one starts with real-world observations and supposes how they evolved. Cf: the evolution of altruism in humans [a]. It fails when one supposes evolutionary pressures to predict human behavior, e.g. natural selection and social competition exist, herego we should expect our leaders to be sociopaths. Observation, not supposition, before conclusion.

[a] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25061670

Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by fartcannon on Sunday May 22, 2022 @04:41PM (#31472533)
I notice you left out the 'I think' from when you quoted me. That's how you were supposed to know it's not fiction, it's not a parlor trick, it's a thought. Kinda like brainstorming. Suggesting there is a 'trick' to what I'm writing implies (to me at least) that I'm attempting to deceive. I assure you I am not.

And since we're quoting each other, you opened with, "It might be the inverse. Someone not wanting to get out of bed in the morning projecting that view onto the world." I assure you I love getting out of bed. On the other hand, I kinda get the vibe the discussion you're having is a continuation of one you've had before with someone else and maybe you're projecting it on to me?

I checked out your profile and now I understand! Haha. Fun times. Thanks for the links.

Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by fartcannon on Sunday May 22, 2022 @03:19PM (#31471704)
Ah, I see. Well, I assure you that it invigorates and inspires me. I consider it one of my stronger assets and I highly recommend it.
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by kaashif on Sunday May 22, 2022 @01:52PM (#31470859)
> It’s like a decentralized Ponzi scheme

A Ponzi scheme is a type of fraud where someone lies about where the money paying off earlier investors is coming from - they say it comes from investment in some kind of business or other businesses, but it actually comes from later investors' investments.

The stock market is transparent, it is obvious that when you buy something, part of the return will come from a later investor buying it from you - that's the whole point of buying something.

It's not a Ponzi scheme if there's no-one lying about where the money comes from.

Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by renewiltord on Sunday May 22, 2022 @11:35AM (#31469275)
Okay, I'll buy your 358 VOO Puts expiring May 27 at 1¢ each. Easy money for you. I will pay you $100 for 100 such contracts (usual lot size 100).

EDIT: Counter offer or decline acceptable. I can go up to $1k on this. I have money in play from this site up to 3x payout. Your call.

Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by oneoff786 on Sunday May 22, 2022 @02:51PM (#31471453)
You edited your post to add more detail for some reason. No, it’s still not clever.

Believing passive investing at scale causes irrational rises in price does not mean it’s wise to assume the price will definitely go up or down. It’s obviously not the only effect in the market.

Going long on the general market is a bet that things will generally continue. That’s about it.

Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by renewiltord on Sunday May 22, 2022 @03:06PM (#31471598)
I comment in bursts, which has me hit rate limits on HN. Then I have to use edit-functionality till rate-limit-expiry.

In any case, if you don't want to play that's fine. I enjoy this; you don't. No reason to be offended. Offer open to others. Has been taken up in the past. Fun for all.

Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by oneoff786 on Sunday May 22, 2022 @12:33PM (#31469978)
These gotchas aren’t nearly as clever as you think.
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by thrwyoilarticle on Sunday May 22, 2022 @03:23PM (#31471753)
>If everyone invests in the sp500

...being the key phrase. There's a long way to go to 100%.

Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by oneoff786 on Sunday May 22, 2022 @06:03PM (#31473253)
It doesn’t need to be 100%. It just needs to be a fairly large portion of the holders of the sp500.

Technically it can’t be 100%, else there’s nobody to buy from.

Many of the heavily targeted companies are at 20-30% index fund ownership.