News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by ItsMonkk on Sunday May 22, 2022 @12:06PM (#31469638)
This isn't taking into account that there is really no such thing as 'passive'. In reality, passive investors are constantly either investing with their paycheck, or selling in retirement. They are the world's simplest active investors. If you put money into passive then the index buys. If you request money, the index sells.

So what you need to track is the net flows. If the net flows are positive, and there is so little active left in the market that no matter what the active investors do the stock still has positive net flows, then active has no other option than to buy. This eventually leads to stocks having an infinite price as there is no downward force. On the other hand, if net flows are negative, then prices go to 0.

Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by skybrian on Sunday May 22, 2022 @01:16PM (#31470469)
That’s an interesting way of looking at it, but it seems incomplete because for every buyer, there is a seller. A paycheck isn’t converted into stock, it’s traded for it, so some other account gets the cash. Supply and demand meant that asset prices went up, but that meant that the sellers got more cash for less stock.

Who was selling? Recent retirees did well when they sold, but is there more to it than that?

It’s an odd time when cash does poorly (inflation), bonds do worse, and the stock market fell. Prices are relative, though. I guess it’s all relative to commodities and labor.

It seems like increased debt due to higher-priced assets as collateral probably needs to be taken into account too.

Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by throw0101a on Sunday May 22, 2022 @06:11PM (#31473315)
> This isn't taking into account that there is really no such thing as 'passive'. In reality, passive investors are constantly either investing with their paycheck, or selling in retirement. They are the world's simplest active investors. If you put money into passive then the index buys. If you request money, the index sells.

Passive investing means something, and what you are saying is not it. From William F. Sharpe, Nobel-winning economist who came up with capital asset pricing model (CAPM):

> A passive investor always holds every security from the market, with each represented in the same manner as in the market. Thus if security X represents 3 per cent of the value of the securities in the market, a passive investor's portfolio will have 3 per cent of its value invested in X. Equivalently, a passive manager will hold the same percentage of the total outstanding amount of each security in the market[2].

* https://web.stanford.edu/~wfsharpe/art/active/active.htm

A "passive" investment strategy is not about not-buying/selling, but rather about not actively choosing particular financial instruments.

> Passive management (also called passive investing) is an investing strategy that tracks a market-weighted index or portfolio.[1][2] Passive management is most common on the equity market, where index funds track a stock market index, but it is becoming more common in other investment types, including bonds, commodities and hedge funds.[3]

* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Passive_management

Following a particular index (NASDAQ, Dow Jones, S&P 500, Russell 3000, Wilshire 5000, TSX, FTSE 100, MSCI EAFE) is passive investing, even if you put in money every pay cheque.

Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by medvezhenok on Sunday May 22, 2022 @06:56PM (#31473630)
I think grandparent has a point - passive is a misnomer. Academic analyses of passive investing start right after the securities have been acquired and before they’re sold, which pretends that passive flows have no effect on the market (by definition - « always holding exactly 3% » implies no selling or buying, otherwise it is not possible)

« Passive » funds do buy & sell based on flows and tracking of the index, not to mention when companies IPO and/or drop in/out of things like the S&P 500. Market weighted fund might be a better overall name than passive.

Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by throw0101a on Sunday May 22, 2022 @07:07PM (#31473698)
I am aware of the terminology subtleties:

> The terms passive investing and index investing are often intertwined, but they are not exactly the same thing. Today’s guest is Adriana Robertson, the Honourable Justice Frank Iacobucci Chair in Capital Markets Regulation and an associate professor of Law and Finance at the University of Toronto Faculty of Law and Rotman School of Management. Adriana is interested in index investing and, in this episode, we hear her views on whether or not index investing is passive. Hear facts from her paper on the S&P 500 Index fund specifically, and all of the reasons that it's not passive, as well as some of the issues that are potentially arising from the creation of so many indexes or so-called passive investments. A more recent paper by Adriana, published in The Journal of Finance, surveyed a representative sample of U.S. individual investors about how well leading academic theories describe their financial beliefs and decisions, and Adriana shares the differences in something like value growth from an academic perspective versus a real-world perspective. Find out how investors can go about evaluating the performance of their portfolios and what they should be looking for when deciding which index fund to invest in, as well as why index funds aren’t a meaningful category anyway, factors from Adriana’s surveys that might influence investor’s equity allocation, and the trend towards indexing and whether it will overtake active portfolios. Tune in today for all this and more!

* https://rationalreminder.ca/podcast/133

Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by jleahy on Sunday May 22, 2022 @06:40PM (#31473518)
Technically speaking the Dow would not be a passive investment (by the definitions above), as it’s not market cap weighted.
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by lupire on Sunday May 22, 2022 @07:38PM (#31473908)
Does anyone invest in a DoW index fund?
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by yareally on Sunday May 22, 2022 @08:32PM (#31474212)
Yeah, people buy shares of DIA all the time. It's a popular index fund. Not as liquid as spx/spy/qqq, but it's still up there
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by im3w1l on Sunday May 22, 2022 @12:21PM (#31469811)
That's a passive failure mode I haven't seen before. To elaborate on what you said:

Imagine an index, and an index fund tracking it. The index fund will own x% of every stock in the index. Someone buys the index fund, and the index fund now try to achieve x+epsilon% in every stock.

But what if 100-x% of the stock is owned by diamond-hands hodlers, that wont sell at any price? The index fund bids higher and higher, and the sellers refuse to let their shares go, making the price reach ridiculous levels.

The price reaching 0 seems less likely, as there will always be bargain hunters.

Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by nradov on Sunday May 22, 2022 @12:35PM (#31470000)
Index fund managers aren't idiots. Their trading systems still have a degree of sanity checking and human oversight, so they won't attempt to track the index exactly if things get weird. But for large-cap indexes like S&P 500, the "diamond-hands hodlers" lack the capital reserves necessary to really manipulate the market. At some point many of the underlying companies would also take advantage of excessive stock prices by issuing secondary offerings, thus increasing the supply.
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by lupire on Sunday May 22, 2022 @07:42PM (#31473937)
Yah stock won't go to infinity. But TSLA joining the S&P 500 created synthetic demand that synthetically increased price/valuation.
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by dsr_ on Sunday May 22, 2022 @12:35PM (#31469993)
You're leaving out three factors: indexes are not static over long terms; the creation/destruction of new public corporations; and the possibility of existing public corporations offering more stock.
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by HALtheWise on Sunday May 22, 2022 @12:47PM (#31470153)
There's two key ways new stock can be created to avoid this risk: companies can issue it, or short sellers can create it. If the company sees its stock rising, it can and should see that as a cheap source of capital and absorb some of it through a stock sale to do more of whatever business they're in.
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by ItsMonkk on Sunday May 22, 2022 @01:20PM (#31470510)
You think that companies are going to issue new stock in order to ensure that the value of their company doesn't go UP? If anything, the more they take out loans and buyback their stock, the faster it goes to infinity. And the faster it goes to infinity, the more collateral it has, to take out another loan, to buy more stock...

And you think short-sellers are going to risk infinite losses? This is a prisoner's dilemma that you aren't going to win.

Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by jbay808 on Sunday May 22, 2022 @01:46PM (#31470797)
> If the company sees its stock rising, it can and should... absorb some of it through a stock sale

That's ultimately down to the incentives in place. If the board members have a lot of options in their compensation package, they might prefer to see the stock price climb and climb. In fact if the incentives are set up that way they might do a buyback to help fuel the rise, even at the cost of longer-term harm to the company.

Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by nightski on Sunday May 22, 2022 @01:58PM (#31470937)
Short sellers do not create stock. They are selling borrowed stocks. What am I missing.
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by lupire on Sunday May 22, 2022 @07:41PM (#31473928)
The person they borrowed it from also still owns the original share. The borrow creates a share, and the repayment destroys it. Fractional reserve stockholding.
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by nly on Sunday May 22, 2022 @03:28PM (#31471808)
Privileged market participants can definitely lend out more stock then they hold, provided eveurnting is collateralised
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by svnt on Sunday May 22, 2022 @02:18PM (#31471144)
Synthetic longs.
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by blibble on Sunday May 22, 2022 @12:51PM (#31470199)
the genius thing about ETFs is they don't have to buy or sell the stock: others do it for them

have a read about the creation/redemption mechanism and you'll see why this won't heppen

Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by im3w1l on Monday May 23, 2022 @09:16AM (#31478613)
Yeah, I knew about that. I had to look up their relative size to mutual funds though. Turns out mutual funds manage $23.9T compared to $5.4T in ETFs. I guess passive funds are more likely to be ETFs. But it could mean there is enough passive mutual fund money to pose a problem.

https://www.investopedia.com/articles/exchangetradedfunds/08...

Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers by thoughtstheseus on Sunday May 22, 2022 @03:16PM (#31471688)
They issue the person redeeming the the actual underlying securities. Then it’s up to them to sell it. Fun model.