Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers
by Invictus0 on Sunday May 22, 2022 @12:57PM
(#31470269)
Yes, Berkshire Hathaway and Renaissance are just figments of the imagination.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers
by IMSAI8080 on Sunday May 22, 2022 @01:24PM
(#31470553)
Now throw in all the other active funds and average them out. Also Berkshire would not have been the better investment over the last decade. Can you guarantee me Berkshire will pull ahead before I retire?
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers
by blitzar on Sunday May 22, 2022 @01:35PM
(#31470679)
Berkshire is up 280% vs S&P up 180% for the last decade.
That said Berkshire is a pretty poor example as it has a pretty diverse range of holdings, its basically a passive index of its own.
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers
by lotsofpulp on Sunday May 22, 2022 @01:51PM
(#31470855)
https://dqydj.com/sp-500-return-calculator/
This site says SP500 with dividend reinvested is 270%.
I also feel like SP500 has a lot less risk because politicians are very incentivized to provide a backstop to SP500 price, but not as much to BRK.
Also, BRK is squeaking out 280% vs SPY 270% by being 25%+ invested in a single company, Apple. That is a lot of extra risk for not a lot of extra return.
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers
by IMSAI8080 on Sunday May 22, 2022 @02:23PM
(#31471192)
That's incorrect, you forgot the dividends. I went with an analysis from last year where Berkshire was behind and was doing worse than the S&P. Now they're about evens. Berkshire is now an S&P500 tracker.
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers
by Invictus0 on Sunday May 22, 2022 @01:32PM
(#31470650)
What a silly thing to stay. Let me just ignore that and explain why Berkshire works. It's possible to beat the market because it's possible to buy $1 for $0.95. That's the whole trick. It takes a lot of work, a lot of smart people, and you have to make big enough deals to cover the cost of paying the managers, but yes, these opportunities exist and they are abundant. The real mistake is thinking that the market is a bunch of random number generators with no rhyme or reason to it. But no, there are no guarantees--the SPY doesn't come with a guarantee either.
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers
by IMSAI8080 on Sunday May 22, 2022 @01:53PM
(#31470874)
That makes no sense at all. What you're saying is it's possible to hire people who can see the future. Index tracking works because the market as a whole generally trends upwards if you wait long enough. This would be expected as the world generally gets richer and technology generally improves. The problem is you can't predict which exact company is going to do the improving. So just buy a very wide spread of companies and take the average. 80% of active managers fail to beat the market because they cannot see the future. The other 20% are lucky (today). If you want a lesson in the dangers of active management, look up Neil Woodford.
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers
by svnt on Sunday May 22, 2022 @02:21PM
(#31471176)
You only need to hire people who can see the future from the perspective of the market. It is entirely possible, and it is the reason why insider trading is heavily regulated.
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers
by cko on Monday May 23, 2022 @12:03AM
(#31475234)
Ben Felix cited in a video that Berkshire's excess returns can be explained by their value tilt, and after accounting for that, this apparent excess return is statistically insignificant.
Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers
by lotsofpulp on Sunday May 22, 2022 @01:23PM
(#31470542)
Has BRK outperformed SP500 since 2009?