News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by cm2187 on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @04:03AM (#31407339)
> “More women on corporate boards means better decisions and businesses that outperform the competition,” Atkins said in a statement. “We believe this law remains important, despite the disheartening ruling.”

If they really believe that they would let the market make it happen. It is because they don’t really believe it that they are trying to enforce it by law.

Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by hectorlorenzo on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @04:24AM (#31407472)
How would that happen? I'm curious because I've never seen markets as being specially good at enforcing policies that (some or most) parts of society see as morally good (as vague as these terms are). For example, markets never managed to prevent child labour (they still don't!), we had to pass laws to enforce them in Western countries.

What are your specific thoughts on how would this process unfold?

Edit: On a second read of the article and parent comment, I understand it now as an ironic take on a flawed justification for the law that tries to satisfy everyone ("We're doing this for the markets!").

Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by TheAceOfHearts on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @04:44AM (#31407619)
My guess is that GP means that it's not actually a competitive advantage, otherwise the markets would already be including women on their boards in equal proportions to men?

Markets don't tend to experiment that much when they have something that works unless further competition shows up, see electric cars for example.

Markets are meant to serve humans, not the other way around.

Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by 88 on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @04:43AM (#31407612)
If it’s widely accepted that placing more women on corporate boards delivers better results for companies, then investors will push companies to do just that.

Those that fail to do so will see their share price lag behind their competitors.

Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by hectorlorenzo on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @05:10AM (#31407792)
I understand now. However, I think it unfairly assumes that markets are run (or executed?) by rational actors that always make optimal decisions without getting bogged down by biases or passed down wisdom.
Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by ericmay on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @05:25AM (#31407914)
Sure, but then you’re replacing that with assuming the government is making the optimal decision and not being bogged down by biases or politically expedient self-serving moves.

Given that the feedback loop for government actions is slow and often time indirect, I’m not sure the government is making the best decision either.

Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by hectorlorenzo on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @05:34AM (#31407986)
I don't think I ever said that passing this law was correct or that governments were free from bias. I just questioned whether it was a good idea to let markets make decisions and expect them to be optimal, or whether optimising for competitive advantage is inherently good.
Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by shaftoe on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @05:49AM (#31408111)
I think it's similarly fair to question whether it is a good idea to let governments make decisions and expect them to be optimal, or whether optimizing for equity in outcome is inherently good.
Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by TheOtherHobbes on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @06:16AM (#31408311)
Why do you think corporations aren't part of the government?

They certainly have huge influence over policy. IMO it's extremely superficial to believe that just because they're not part of the official party political process they're somehow not in a senior leadership role.

Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by hectorlorenzo on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @06:05AM (#31408238)
I agree.
[dead]
Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by thrill on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @10:49AM (#31411525)
People are supposed to seriously take your social policies as beneficial when you use derogatory terms like "old white dudes"?
Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by ivan_gammel on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @06:34PM (#31417075)
Social policies are not mine and I personally do not have a goal to promote them among the privileged class to which I myself belong, so it should not matter what terms I use in this conversation. It’s just the matter of fact that certain class of people of certain ancestry and gender is often ignorant to the social progress and lives by the book of Ayn Rand, rather than by the book of Acemoglu and Robinson.
Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by darawk on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @04:30AM (#31407521)
The part he quoted was about running a more efficient business (i.e. outcompeting the competition), not being morally better. Markets are generally pretty good at promoting that.
Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by hectorlorenzo on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @05:12AM (#31407813)
Get it, then I think disagreement runs deeper than I thought. As a sibling comment mentioned, I believe that markets are meant to serve humans, not the other way around.

Edit: typo

Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by olalonde on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @05:57AM (#31408174)
The question is: is it more desirable for society to have the most competent people running a business or to have a balanced representation of gender, sexual orientation, skin color or <insert other arbitrary way to classify people here> running it? Free market proponents would argue the former is more desirable.
Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by hectorlorenzo on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @06:22AM (#31408356)
This question might be a binary over-simplification. We currently do not have the tools to measure who is "the most competent people running a business". Markets are never pure so I do not think that the current situation (predominantly white men in boards) is the outcome of rational optimisation over the years. If anything, free market proponents should welcome these laws as a way to experiment with different variables to empirically determine what's the best way to run a business.

I also do not think that (most) proponents of a balanced representation favour diversity over competency. Speaking for myself, I do believe (from experience) that having diversity in a team results in more resilient, efficient, and "optimal" decision-making. Again, we do not have sufficient tools to prove that empirically, so we better A/B test the hell out of it :)

Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by thrill on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @10:51AM (#31411551)
"free market proponents should welcome these laws as a way to experiment"

Mandated experiments are not experiments.

Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by hectorlorenzo on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @10:57AM (#31411659)
As nice as this sounds, I do not think I follow. Can you elaborate?
Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by TheOtherHobbes on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @06:10AM (#31408271)
Free market proponents would be wrong.

If you're excluding a significant proportion of your population from leadership roles - which is what happens predictably, almost as if by magic, when "markets" make decisions about leadership - your markets are anything but free.

Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by olalonde on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @06:32AM (#31408432)
> your markets are anything but free

I believe you are using a non standard definition of "free market" here? Also I am not sure I understand what you mean by "excluding a significant proportion of your population from leadership roles". Of course, competency/qualification requirements excludes a large proportion of the population.

Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by himinlomax on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @06:28AM (#31408401)
> How would that happen?

How would that not happen? Businesses are always looking for an edge over the competition. If it was clear that women bosses outperformed men, any smart investor would insist on having them run the joint. The only counter argument would be that investors hate women more than they love money, which is just patently absurd on the face of it, since they obviously love nothing more than money.

Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by flipbrad on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @04:08AM (#31407369)
Perhaps they also believe markets are imperfect, especially over the short to medium term timescales that the current and incoming generation of women (and other people who care about these things) actually care about?
Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by roenxi on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @05:36AM (#31408015)
More likely it just isn't true. Markets respond quite aggressively to even a small change in the bottom line. Often companies are quite happy to ignore the law, common sense or basic decency to achieve a bit more profit.

If they aren't lining up women for the boards voluntarily, it is because nobody with money thinks there is a benefit from doing so. The effect is probably just the so-called Berkson's paradox [0] and will likely disappear if hiring teams start seeking out female candidates.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Berkson%27s_paradox

Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by taylorius on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @05:05AM (#31407748)
Actually they don't think that, they don't care one way or another. They just want women on boards, and they assume the market will make it work somehow.
Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by kepler1 on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @04:23AM (#31407466)
Just because someone says that they believe in something, does that mean that they're right, and that they get to force others to do anything they want based on that belief? Including discriminating against yet others?
Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by kennywinker on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @04:27AM (#31407497)
If you arrived at the snack table early and grabbed 10 juice boxes, and the teacher comes and takes five of them away from you and gives them to the other kids, you're not being discriminated against.
Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by taylorius on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @05:07AM (#31407757)
Yes, a teacher, and the children that are in their charge. That's exactly the attitude these politicians have. How lucky we are that they know best!
Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by kennywinker on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @05:16AM (#31407850)
I know you really want it to be top down patronizing politicians doing this kind of thing all on their own, but there are actually millions of Californians who agree this is a good idea. In my metaphor, those are the adults in the room.
Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by teakettle42 on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @05:40AM (#31408047)
Your analogy is poor. A better one, if we’re going to stick with childish analogies:

You achieve straight A’s for a promised juice box reward, but the teacher refuses to give it to you because you’re a boy, and too many other boys got A’s in the past.

Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by Swenrekcah on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @05:51AM (#31408127)
I understand your frustration because there really is the sentiment among some people today that “privileged” [1] people should be punished for the crimes of their ancestors.

However a law that says that the board of a large enough company can’t be all male (and then also not all female) is actually not the stupidest idea.

It should absolutely be considered a temporary stop-gap and automatically revoked as soon as some threshold of women on boards is achieved, but it actually is sometimes necessary to give people a little kick in the butt to get things going.

I don’t live in California so I don’t know the specifics of this law, just saying that the idea in general is not as terrible as some of the bad woke stuff.

[1] I say privileged in quotes because usually it’s enough that people look similar to people that are or have been privileged.

Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by teakettle42 on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @06:09AM (#31408260)
The explicit harm done to individuals by such a law is not a distant hypothetical; some non-zero number of people were discriminated against on the basis of their gender, by the government, in order to fill a mandatory quota.

It doesn’t do those individuals any good if you roll the laws back in a few years.

Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by kennywinker on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @06:43AM (#31408507)
> some non-zero number of people were discriminated against on the basis of their gender, by the government, in order to fill a mandatory quota.

Your assumption is that board seats are being allocated to their rightful owners today, and this law would be a corruption of that. That’s a pretty big assumption. What rooms are you in where the ten most qualified people are _ever_ all male? Even in tech that’s not that common.

Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by belorn on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @07:50AM (#31409078)
Looking at gender segregation here in Sweden, there are many class rooms where all the ten most qualified people are of the same gender. There are simply just many class rooms that have higher gender segregation than 90%, and many are practically single sex from the simple fact that all the students are of the same gender (teacher included).

Many profession are also above the 90% segregation line, and most of them are women dominated professions. Most of those work places will have rooms where ten most qualified people are of the same gender. Most of those work places also have women dominating from the top.

Tech is actually pretty much in the average in terms of gender segregation, at around 70%.

Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by teakettle42 on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @07:13AM (#31408736)
No, the reality — not my assumption — is that there are a limited number of opportunities and the government mandated that men should be discriminated against when being considered for them.
Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by Swenrekcah on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @08:02AM (#31409196)
I get it, I’m a man and this does me no favours.

But it is also the reality that these seats aren’t really filled based on pure merit. It’s mostly (or at least a real prerequisite) a question if you belong to the right “club”. These laws expand the club a bit which I think is a good thing.

I agree that the idea that decision making will be better simply because there are women is suspect.

Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by kepler1 on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @01:21PM (#31413750)
"Rightful owners"?

Wow, I really hope you're not in any position of authority.

Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by kepler1 on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @01:24PM (#31413784)
When it comes to rights guaranteed in the Constitution, millions of Californians, especially if they want to trample on those rights, are not the adults in the room. Those questions have been removed from the democratic process (by the people, through the Constitution and our fundamental rights) and are not up for grabs just because enough people think that they should.

You may want to think hard about when millions of people have been wrong and trampled on rights you would wish for courts to protect. It may not always go your way based on your approach above.

Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by humanrebar on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @05:34AM (#31407987)
So these "adults in the room" are high and mighty about makeup of boardrooms but they refuse to build more housing? If hoarding is the metaphor, seems like that's the more apt interpretation. The average woman in California is much more affected by rent than access to board positions.
Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by kennywinker on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @06:32AM (#31408433)
I never said it’s a perfect system. There’s lots of times when the government isn’t doing what ANYBODY wants, but that wasn’t what we were talking about. I definitely care more about housing than boardrooms, but that wasn’t what we were talking about either.
Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by taylorius on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @05:29AM (#31407954)
I'm sure that's true - I don't disagree with you. Though I would maintain politicians have a distinctly high-handed approach to dealing with such matters, and are often highly dismissive of collateral damage from their grand schemes.
Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by HelloNurse on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @06:50AM (#31408558)
Given the typically antisocial attitude of "entrepreneurs" treating them like children is unusually defensible.
Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by kepler1 on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @04:29AM (#31407510)
Thank god this kind of lazy and intellectually dishonest thinking (I hesitate to call it logic) gets checked by courts in the end.
Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by modo_mario on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @06:00AM (#31408193)
To what extent do CEO's height compare to the average?
Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by kennywinker on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @04:25AM (#31407483)
It's possible there is two competing market forces:

1. women on corporate boards are a competitive advantage for reasons stated above. 2. women on corporate boards are a competitive dis-advantage because of social factors based around the cultural idea that women are not normally on boards.

If that's the case, then the market won't unlock the advantages of the first factor unless something happens to disrupt the second factor.

I honestly don't know how anyone can believe the market will find the optimal outcome. At best it finds an optimal outcome within constraints put on it by the confused, reactionary, panicky, racist, sexist, bigoted people who are the things actually acting out "the market".

Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by native_samples on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @04:54AM (#31407670)
There's no actual evidence that women on boards yields better outcomes, it's just another false belief propagated by junk studies.

But even if there was, would that be a good reason to act on it? This "logic" never seems to be deployed in men's favour. It's obvious that strong male firefighters will have better outcomes than female firefighters, that's why New York had to make the qualification tests easier in order to hire more women. Yet the rules were changed anyway.

"I honestly don't know how anyone can believe the market will find the optimal outcome."

Because of enormous amounts of history, theory and practice showing that it will? BTW the "confused, reactionary, panicky, racist, sexist, bigoted people" would appear to describe the people breaking the law in order to ban men from powerful positions on the basis of their gender, wouldn't it.

Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by shenberg on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @05:16AM (#31407854)
As far as I can tell, your argument is: 1. There is no evidence that women on boards yield better outcomes 2. Even if they led to better outcomes, it's wrong to act on it. 3. Markets are efficient and therefore don't allow for discrimination

Re: 1, I don't know Re: 2, I believe that there is a place for affirmative action, especially in places like the boardroom where physical aspects of gender differences have no meaning. Re: 3, There's plenty of evidence showing places where markets are discriminatory in preference to being efficient: https://danluu.com/bad-decisions/

Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by Broken_Hippo on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @05:07AM (#31407762)
"It's obvious that strong male firefighters will have better outcomes than female firefighters, that's why New York had to make the qualification tests easier in order to hire more women."

Is it obvious, though? Sure, perhaps for a few specific things, but outside of a very limited set of things... probably not. You don't need to be a strong manly man to drive a fire truck nor to use hoses. The test probably didn't actually measure what was necessary before and likely disqualified women not because it was difficult, but because it didn't actually measure how fit for the job women were (example: Measuring upper body strength alone instead of measuring how well they could carry someone out of the fire or hooking up hoses). I mean, somehow women are strong enough to be lifting patients in a nursing home but not helping folks out in a fire? I doubt this.

Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by teakettle42 on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @05:25AM (#31407922)
> You don't need to be a strong manly man to drive a fire truck …

It helps if you’re going to be doing literally anything other than just driving the apparatus.

Also, why should men be relegated to the most dangerous jobs, just so that we can fill a female hiring quota by giving women the safer, less demanding jobs?

> … nor to use hoses.

You absolutely need to be built to man a firehose.

It takes your full weight and strength to keep control of a hose with the diameters and pressures used in firefighting.

With a 2.5”+ hose, it can take two full-grown men to keep control of the line with the nozzle open, especially when advancing.

Nevermind hauling a charged line into a building, up stairs, etc. The weight alone is tremendous.

> I mean, somehow women are strong enough to be lifting patients in a nursing home

Male staffers are generally asked to do the lifting, and sometimes medical services literally call in the fire department for a lift assist.

> … but not helping folks out in a fire?

The structure gear alone weighs about 70 pounds. By the time you find someone in a building, you’ve been using a heavy tools, in the heat, to sound floors and search rooms rapidly in the most exhausting way possible.

It’s so much more difficult than just lifting someone without all the gear on.

There’s also forced entry into doors, etc, which benefits substantially from weight, leverage, and upper body strength.

> I doubt this.

Only because you know nothing about firefighting.

Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by BigJ1211 on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @08:54AM (#31409805)
The same is true for military standards, and potentially some police forces (SWAT).

Of course this should have nothing to do with a board position. Perhaps women would actually excel in board positions as those mostly have to do with building/having social networks, something women certainly seem to be better at than men on average.

Most of it is going to be speculation until we see larger numbers and can compare boards with women to boards without (and even boards with only women). It's tough to say, as the 'old boys club' seems to be dying out regardless.

Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by DocTomoe on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @04:48AM (#31407640)
Wouldn't it be pretty easy to confirm or falsify the theory then? See how companies perform with more diverse boards as compared to those with less diverse boards? That information is public. This study [1] seems to have inconclusive results:

> We found evidence for a positive effect of women on corporate boards on both measures of company performance—ROA and PER—apart from the percentage of female executives in the case of ROA when estimated through pooled OLS. However, the outcomes of panel data fixed-effects and random-effects revealed the lack of connection between board gender diversity and ROA but a positive impact of the number and percentage of women on board on PER.

[1] https://jfin-swufe.springeropen.com/articles/10.1186/s40854-...

Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by thematrixturtle on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @05:45AM (#31408084)
Here's the SSGA Gender Diversity Index ETF vs the DJI. Alas, so far the experiment does not seem to be bearing out the hypothesis.

https://finance.yahoo.com/chart/SHE#eyJpbnRlcnZhbCI6IndlZWsi...

Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by kennywinker on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @05:22AM (#31407895)
Those studies didn’t happen in a vacuum. Imagine your company loses out on some big contract because when the some-women board shows up the all-men board at the other company’s unexamined prejudices kick in and they “just have a bad feeling about that company”. Or maybe it’s that the male faction of the board undervalues the female board members input and it’s functionally like having a smaller board. Those are kinda cartoonish examples of what I’m talking about when I say “cultural forces” - there may be all kinds of hard to quantify hard to control for effects at work. But if those effects would go away if the cultural stereotypes and biases went away, then maybe a law like that would push a skewed system towards one that provides equal opportunity for everyone
Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by DocTomoe on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @07:16AM (#31408762)
To be fair, that sounds a bit like a fallacy ... if a diverse board leads to comparatively better outcomes, it's the fact that they were diverse, but if it doesn't, it's the fault of everyone not trusting the female-identifying board members enough?

If you're bringing up a claim or a hypothesis in a discussion, you need to allow for the claim to be falsifiable.

Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by kennywinker on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @02:00PM (#31414276)
I'm not making a claim. I'm describing a potential mechanism. The start of this thread was a question like "if women make boards better, why doesn't the market put them in those seats", so I was describing the type of system that could be at play - i.e. cultural inertia counteracting the benefits.

There is, I believe, plenty of evidence in the literature of cultural factors like stereotypes, preconceptions, and prejudices having a very real impact on group performance. But that's not a specific claim about WHICH factors are at play in this circumstance.

You posted a study that seems to show no impact when adding women to boards, so I was pointing out how a study that doesn't control for those kinds of cultural inertia factors can't say anything about the existence or non-existence of those factors.

As for the specific example "if a diverse board leads to comparatively better outcomes, it's the fact that they were diverse, but if it doesn't, it's the fault of everyone not trusting the female-identifying board members enough" which you describe as an un-falsifiable claim, but it's not. Something as simple as an analysis of meeting calendars or emails on diverse and non-diverse boards might be able to determine if the communication patterns are a negative or positive influence on performance.

Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by DocTomoe on Wednesday May 18, 2022 @02:36AM (#31419852)
In the end, from a corporate investor level, it's all about the bottom line. Overperformance and underperformance are well-defined terms. If there is a (positive or negative) correlation between ratio of male and female board members and performance, investors won't look twice at more obscure facets like 'meeting patterns' or 'cultural inertia'.

If the original claim ("Companies perform better with more women on boards") is not provable in a comparatively simple metric like growth, and if there are indications that in fact, 'other factors' like cultural inertia currently is diametral to female success in boards, then making a law that shoehorns more women in boards is not designed to make companies perform better, but to change the assumed cultural inertia at the expense of short- to medium-term economic growth. It becomes an experiment - with the countries that do not have that kind of laws and are unlikely to implement them as a control group (looking at you, China).

It only would be fair to tell that - instead of painting an unproven (and to some extend: disproven) claim a fact.

Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by kennywinker on Wednesday May 18, 2022 @01:47PM (#31425579)
Well based on the study you cited, there was no significant impact of women on boards detected - so the worst case is performance stays the same but equality is increased. The best case is that gender-diverse boards perform better in the absence of cultural factors, and this law changes the culture and performance increases. Sounds like we win either way - more equality and stable performance, or more equality and increased performance. Where's the downside?
Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by DocTomoe on Wednesday May 18, 2022 @02:27PM (#31426040)
I should have been more clear: I was also refering to the index comparison shared by thematrixturtle [1].

Differently from you, I don't assume the idea that co-ed teams will eventually outperform more homogenous teams is a foregone conclusion. Which means that there are scenarios in which we don't all win.

[1] https://finance.yahoo.com/chart/SHE#eyJpbnRlcnZhbCI6IndlZWsi...

Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by kennywinker on Wednesday May 18, 2022 @04:15PM (#31427103)
What are we supposed to get from that chart? It looks like a subset of the data performs differently from the set? That's not useful information. Via regression to the mean the larger data set will always be more "normal" either lower or higher than the smaller data set.

If you wanted a good comparison you'd have to be comparing an equal sized subset of the DJI that only included boards with low diversity. Junk conclusions from junk data. When it was actually studied with rigor, e.g. the study you linked to (https://jfin-swufe.springeropen.com/articles/10.1186/s40854-...) "We found evidence for a positive effect of women on corporate boards on both measures of company performance—ROA and PER"

Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by HelloMcFly on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @08:12AM (#31409323)
Forgive the eye-roll, but this is classic HN reductionism.

How many things can you think of - right now - for which there is clear evidence of benefit yet society has not adopted action? Systemic change is slow, sometimes laws help advance systemic change. The gender disparity gap in leadership is closing, but network effects will continue to operate to create inequitible opportunity for quite some time.

Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by cm2187 on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @08:47AM (#31409728)
In term of things that are more profitable, companies tend to be very good at optimising for that, that’s the nature of a free market, economic darwinism through competition. If your objective is equity, not economic performance, then it’s a different objective but that’s not the one quoted by the senator.
Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by HelloMcFly on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @09:02AM (#31409891)
Companies exist within systems that are more than just "pure capitalism", and whose individual-level actors (who often hold decision-making authority) are motivated by more than just "maximizing company returns". The free market is not some independent force of physics, it's operating in a highly complex, multi-factorial society with individual actors and competing forces. For instance: I have seen people lobby for hires - yes, including two instances of appointing board members - based on personal associations vs. a sober-eyed review of qualifications (guess which gender typically benefits?).

The idea that "if it was better the market will make it so" may be right in the fullness of time, but we live in what is effectively a zero-sum society when viewing the present. Patience for the long-tail of change advantages the already advantaged.

Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by honkdaddy on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @09:45AM (#31410522)
>How many things can you think of - right now - for which there is clear evidence of benefit yet society has not adopted action

Which ones can you think of? Keep in mind the article is talking about markets and fiscal health of the company itself, not society as a whole. It's pretty easy to make the case "society would be better if we did the beneficial things", the question at hand is whether it's the governments place to push these on private actors.

Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by niemandhier on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @05:38AM (#31408029)
Gathering data to investigate this is tricky, you cannot really run a randomized controlled trial, so everything is always observational.

This meta analysis study suggests that the suggests that the effect size of having a woman in the board is negligible, but the average number of women in the boards of the considered companies was low:

https://www.researchgate.net/publication/276057102_Does_Gend...

However more recent research finds a positive effect if the number of woman is higher ( they do not report an effect size though):

https://jfin-swufe.springeropen.com/articles/10.1186/s40854-...

This invites a "Laffer curve" like argument: surly we just do not have enough female board members jet.

Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by benhurmarcel on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @08:01AM (#31409191)
You haven't spent a lot of time in large companies if you believe they always choose what makes the most economic sense.
Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by krageon on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @05:47AM (#31408104)
> If they really believe that they would let the market make it happen

"The market" is not an entity. It's a collective of people, those people have prejudices and friends. Those primarily factor into what happens - thus, more of the same in-group ends up at the top. This is frankly such a base explanation it's bordering on bad-faith reasoning, but I'm willing to give you the benefit of the doubt.