If they aren't lining up women for the boards voluntarily, it is because nobody with money thinks there is a benefit from doing so. The effect is probably just the so-called Berkson's paradox [0] and will likely disappear if hiring teams start seeking out female candidates.
You achieve straight A’s for a promised juice box reward, but the teacher refuses to give it to you because you’re a boy, and too many other boys got A’s in the past.
However a law that says that the board of a large enough company can’t be all male (and then also not all female) is actually not the stupidest idea.
It should absolutely be considered a temporary stop-gap and automatically revoked as soon as some threshold of women on boards is achieved, but it actually is sometimes necessary to give people a little kick in the butt to get things going.
I don’t live in California so I don’t know the specifics of this law, just saying that the idea in general is not as terrible as some of the bad woke stuff.
[1] I say privileged in quotes because usually it’s enough that people look similar to people that are or have been privileged.
It doesn’t do those individuals any good if you roll the laws back in a few years.
Your assumption is that board seats are being allocated to their rightful owners today, and this law would be a corruption of that. That’s a pretty big assumption. What rooms are you in where the ten most qualified people are _ever_ all male? Even in tech that’s not that common.
Many profession are also above the 90% segregation line, and most of them are women dominated professions. Most of those work places will have rooms where ten most qualified people are of the same gender. Most of those work places also have women dominating from the top.
Tech is actually pretty much in the average in terms of gender segregation, at around 70%.
But it is also the reality that these seats aren’t really filled based on pure merit. It’s mostly (or at least a real prerequisite) a question if you belong to the right “club”. These laws expand the club a bit which I think is a good thing.
I agree that the idea that decision making will be better simply because there are women is suspect.
Wow, I really hope you're not in any position of authority.
You may want to think hard about when millions of people have been wrong and trampled on rights you would wish for courts to protect. It may not always go your way based on your approach above.