But even if there was, would that be a good reason to act on it? This "logic" never seems to be deployed in men's favour. It's obvious that strong male firefighters will have better outcomes than female firefighters, that's why New York had to make the qualification tests easier in order to hire more women. Yet the rules were changed anyway.
"I honestly don't know how anyone can believe the market will find the optimal outcome."
Because of enormous amounts of history, theory and practice showing that it will? BTW the "confused, reactionary, panicky, racist, sexist, bigoted people" would appear to describe the people breaking the law in order to ban men from powerful positions on the basis of their gender, wouldn't it.
Re: 1, I don't know Re: 2, I believe that there is a place for affirmative action, especially in places like the boardroom where physical aspects of gender differences have no meaning. Re: 3, There's plenty of evidence showing places where markets are discriminatory in preference to being efficient: https://danluu.com/bad-decisions/
Is it obvious, though? Sure, perhaps for a few specific things, but outside of a very limited set of things... probably not. You don't need to be a strong manly man to drive a fire truck nor to use hoses. The test probably didn't actually measure what was necessary before and likely disqualified women not because it was difficult, but because it didn't actually measure how fit for the job women were (example: Measuring upper body strength alone instead of measuring how well they could carry someone out of the fire or hooking up hoses). I mean, somehow women are strong enough to be lifting patients in a nursing home but not helping folks out in a fire? I doubt this.
It helps if you’re going to be doing literally anything other than just driving the apparatus.
Also, why should men be relegated to the most dangerous jobs, just so that we can fill a female hiring quota by giving women the safer, less demanding jobs?
> … nor to use hoses.
You absolutely need to be built to man a firehose.
It takes your full weight and strength to keep control of a hose with the diameters and pressures used in firefighting.
With a 2.5”+ hose, it can take two full-grown men to keep control of the line with the nozzle open, especially when advancing.
Nevermind hauling a charged line into a building, up stairs, etc. The weight alone is tremendous.
> I mean, somehow women are strong enough to be lifting patients in a nursing home
Male staffers are generally asked to do the lifting, and sometimes medical services literally call in the fire department for a lift assist.
> … but not helping folks out in a fire?
The structure gear alone weighs about 70 pounds. By the time you find someone in a building, you’ve been using a heavy tools, in the heat, to sound floors and search rooms rapidly in the most exhausting way possible.
It’s so much more difficult than just lifting someone without all the gear on.
There’s also forced entry into doors, etc, which benefits substantially from weight, leverage, and upper body strength.
> I doubt this.
Only because you know nothing about firefighting.
Of course this should have nothing to do with a board position. Perhaps women would actually excel in board positions as those mostly have to do with building/having social networks, something women certainly seem to be better at than men on average.
Most of it is going to be speculation until we see larger numbers and can compare boards with women to boards without (and even boards with only women). It's tough to say, as the 'old boys club' seems to be dying out regardless.
> We found evidence for a positive effect of women on corporate boards on both measures of company performance—ROA and PER—apart from the percentage of female executives in the case of ROA when estimated through pooled OLS. However, the outcomes of panel data fixed-effects and random-effects revealed the lack of connection between board gender diversity and ROA but a positive impact of the number and percentage of women on board on PER.
[1] https://jfin-swufe.springeropen.com/articles/10.1186/s40854-...
https://finance.yahoo.com/chart/SHE#eyJpbnRlcnZhbCI6IndlZWsi...
If you're bringing up a claim or a hypothesis in a discussion, you need to allow for the claim to be falsifiable.
There is, I believe, plenty of evidence in the literature of cultural factors like stereotypes, preconceptions, and prejudices having a very real impact on group performance. But that's not a specific claim about WHICH factors are at play in this circumstance.
You posted a study that seems to show no impact when adding women to boards, so I was pointing out how a study that doesn't control for those kinds of cultural inertia factors can't say anything about the existence or non-existence of those factors.
As for the specific example "if a diverse board leads to comparatively better outcomes, it's the fact that they were diverse, but if it doesn't, it's the fault of everyone not trusting the female-identifying board members enough" which you describe as an un-falsifiable claim, but it's not. Something as simple as an analysis of meeting calendars or emails on diverse and non-diverse boards might be able to determine if the communication patterns are a negative or positive influence on performance.
If the original claim ("Companies perform better with more women on boards") is not provable in a comparatively simple metric like growth, and if there are indications that in fact, 'other factors' like cultural inertia currently is diametral to female success in boards, then making a law that shoehorns more women in boards is not designed to make companies perform better, but to change the assumed cultural inertia at the expense of short- to medium-term economic growth. It becomes an experiment - with the countries that do not have that kind of laws and are unlikely to implement them as a control group (looking at you, China).
It only would be fair to tell that - instead of painting an unproven (and to some extend: disproven) claim a fact.
Differently from you, I don't assume the idea that co-ed teams will eventually outperform more homogenous teams is a foregone conclusion. Which means that there are scenarios in which we don't all win.
[1] https://finance.yahoo.com/chart/SHE#eyJpbnRlcnZhbCI6IndlZWsi...
If you wanted a good comparison you'd have to be comparing an equal sized subset of the DJI that only included boards with low diversity. Junk conclusions from junk data. When it was actually studied with rigor, e.g. the study you linked to (https://jfin-swufe.springeropen.com/articles/10.1186/s40854-...) "We found evidence for a positive effect of women on corporate boards on both measures of company performance—ROA and PER"
1. women on corporate boards are a competitive advantage for reasons stated above. 2. women on corporate boards are a competitive dis-advantage because of social factors based around the cultural idea that women are not normally on boards.
If that's the case, then the market won't unlock the advantages of the first factor unless something happens to disrupt the second factor.
I honestly don't know how anyone can believe the market will find the optimal outcome. At best it finds an optimal outcome within constraints put on it by the confused, reactionary, panicky, racist, sexist, bigoted people who are the things actually acting out "the market".