1. No politicians
2. No journalists
3. No institutions
4. No companies
5. No entertainment
6. No anonymous accounts
7. Some notable exceptions in all the categories above
8. Mute words to taste
What's left is mostly genuinely interesting people who post about things they understand and truly care about.I primarily browse the chronological timeline without retweets courtesy of a nice search function hack (you must be logged in for this to work):
https://twitter.com/search?q=filter%3Afollows%20exclude%3Are...
The algorithmic timeline has a bad reputation but it's actually useful for stuff you missed. But I only check it after looking at the chronological feed.
I also like and mostly follow these suggestions for using Twitter effectively: https://twitter.com/AlanLevinovitz/status/151946437478365184...
by “anonymous”, do most people mean pseudonymous users who haven’t established an identity (i.e. few to no posts, or no bio, or egg avatar)? or do most people mean to capture all pseudonymous users under that “anonymous” label? (in which case, how does one evaluate if the user is pseudonymous or using their legal name? even blue-checks can be pseudonymous).
> 3 : lacking individuality, distinction, or recognizability
Which is clearly not true for Twitter users due to their handle and public profile. However, it's also defined as:
> 2 : not named or identified
The example is even a book author, which you'd classify as pseudonymous. I think in this case it makes sense to make the distinction, since there are anonymous social networks, but it's not technically wrong.
Arguing about pseudonymous vs. anonymous seems overly pedantic, and not particularly helpful.
This is very different compared to more anonymous forums like 4chan, (former) YikYak and it's successor Jodel. User profiles exist in all of these, but are not presented or publicly visible and postings are not linked to the same account, excluding direct replies.
a _lot_ of people complain about "anonymous Twitter users", and i want to understand what they mean by that. i think it's the sort of "[anonymous] asshole slides into my timeline and then leaves" behavior. and if so, i suspect it's not actually identity or its form but _reputation_ that matters in these interactions: "non-reputable asshole slides into my timeline" (and so considering reputation becomes important in your interactions). but they could equally mean "this person could have multiple identities on this site and that doesn't work for me" (e.g. some person could be playing both a left-leaning and a right-leaning account and using those multiple identities to drive a wedge into some community), so maybe they really do want to avoid interacting with people who don't have a verifiably singular identity (this isn't easy).
i should have distilled it to that point: when a person says they don't deal with anonymous users, do they actually care about identity, or are they using identity as a proxy for reputation -- and reputation is the more direct concern?
Occasionally, it's used by other people properly to refer to a space used by government for official purposes; I suspect much of the other use is dual purpose, that is, it intends to discredit the proper use as much as to advance a more overt purpose.
What it is good for is sending sound bites at each other.
(For emergency communications SMS is better and sufficient.)
Whether or not you believe it is unsuitable for such purposes has no bearing on the fact that government has indeed used it for such purposes, and that this imposes legal requirements on the use of those government accounts as public fora that do not apply to Twitter generally.
Of course it does. It's called having friends.
If you're having a conversation in a restaurant, and a stranger at another table overhears you and decides to interrupt with their contrary opinion, do you "owe" them an argument, or do you tell them to mind their own business and go away?
And then will the interrupter whine, "A restaurant is a public place! If you wanted to have a private conversation, you should have had dinner at home."
There's almost no situation IRL where you're arguing with strangers. That only happens online.
Have you ever... been on Twitter?
Seriously, Twitter randos often consider it a badge of honor to get blocked by someone after they tweet unsolicited hostile replies. "Ha, they blocked me, what a snowflake! Can't handle any criticism."
I see very little partisan politics on my timeline now.
That said, I don’t really need a smarter algorithm than “show my tweets with a lot of favorites”.
Just like a prefer to have Reddit sort by best vs new.
A rather meta example: scroll down to the "More Tweets" section under this recent Elon Musk tweet - https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1525738556102164480
I don't know what it might curate for each person reading this, but I'll bet you'll see what I'm talking about.
I don't follow every player, coach, or organization and it's common for me to see 1 tweet from one of my follows and the More Tweets to contain content I want to consume from the 1000's of others talking about this specific scene.
I'd also recommend not using the More Tweets feature for anything too popular as it's like reading a youtube comments section.
I think the algorithmic feed actually does a good job of promoting the things Twitter does well and I wonder how many people who hate it actually just disagree with the Twitter devs about how the service should work.
In my case, the algo is pretty good at surfacing useful tweets and people: both new stuff that I find relevant, and tweets from the people I'm following that I missed.
So I generally use lists to interact with different groups of people I'm already interested (including the ones I'm following) and the homepage is great for discovery.
There was a period of time when Twitter was testing an interface that had the two feeds on tabs and it kept reverting back to the algorithmic tab. I almost quit.
This also worked for Facebook back when I still had an account. All the posts I saw were ones directly related to my interests and local events that I was interested in. We have a lot of control over how social media presents us with information, just most people don't bother trying to make it work for them.
It's just not worth it. I can hop into a Matrix room or a Subreddit and make posts about a topic I'm interested in and receive immediate interaction without seeing a firehose of emotional or inflammatory content. On those platforms you need to post/read a lot or come with a controversial mindset before you start dealing with the problems of the platform, so your initial start can be gentle and you still derive value from the interactions.
This crazy amount of stewardship for Twitter is pretty nuts. I guess some people really want to be part of The Conversation and they'll do anything to do it, but I'm not that person myself. I can get a lot of value talking on Matrix right now.
I didn't see any of this when I started using Twitter a few months ago.
> This crazy amount of stewardship for Twitter is pretty nuts
What are you talking about? People shared their negative impressions of Twitter. I recently tried Twitter and found that it could be useful, so I decided to share my experience.
> I guess some people really want to be part of The Conversation and they'll do anything to do it
I don't talk to anybody on Twitter and this is an extremely uncharitable take that isn't okay on HN.
Could one say that that's why TikTok is so popular? It works although people don't spend time configuring it?
All of the things you listed seem like they should be the default. But they aren't, which means 99% of people do not even know they are options, and so the site is dumpster fire for most people.
I like spaces and find those useful but the algorithmic feed has close to 0 value for me. I'm not sure how twitter makes money and survives as a company without it though. Can twitter succeed as a pay to use platform? I don't know.
There are certain cesspools I like checking out. For example Grady Booch dunking on cryptobros is still funny to me.
Wait, what? Grady Booch, the UML guy? This, I need to the see.
Unfollow/nute any account that has more than 10k followers. Especially if they are social media famous.
Other than that, it really is about how you curate it. Follow the people you're interested in, engage with the content you find useful, tell Twitter you don't like something by muting/blocking/notinterestedin-ing and you're good.
In that regard it's not unlike any other social media: if you don't tell it what you like, it'll show you what it things you want to see, which won't necessarily be something you'd want to see.
What's the reason for this? I didn't even realize you could do that.
In tweetdeck the block retweets setting blocks them. Retweet with quote isn't counted as a retweet.
All the retweets I see are high quality and interesting. This heavily depends on who you're following, tbh.
Before that I had different curated lists and then it just became a mess.
Let users individually curate the content they want to see instead of trying to use every social media platform as a propaganda tool.
How do you do that? I only know you can disable all retweets from a particular person you follow. I didn't know you could disable non-quote retweets from all accounts you follow.
So I switched back.
In my case it's @simon, and one of my problems is that I get a TON of unwanted mentions. No idea how to solve it, after lots of thinking over the years.
What % of the userbase is "Twitter cesspools" and how do you define that? What exactly is a "Twitter cesspool"? Viewpoints that don't align with yours? Radical politics?
Is Twitter the platform of giving the 10-20% most fringed members of both political parties a voice? Why does what they post get "upvoted/liked/retweeted" enough to the point where it gets visibility instead of being drowned out? What kind of content are they posting exactly that is "ok" to not be removed by moderation policies, but you define it as "cesspool" material?
This is a very presumptuous response.
A more charitable interpretation might just be where discussions are happening that you're not interested in on twitter. For example, 'this person keeps getting embroiled in twitter arguments about covid', so I'm going to unfloow them because even though I agree with their opinions, I'm not interested in the inevitably heated and pointless discussions leaking into my timeline.
I'd imagine it's a personal definition and could be reasonably substituted with "you don't want to hear from." for the same effect.
As far as I can tell, using any social-media site other than with a friends-only reverse-chronological feed is just going to be a bad experience for anyone who values real engagement (i.e. not influencers or wannabes and not passive disinformation consumers). Also, any social-media site without a block button and a culture encouraging people to use it is broken too.
I say this as someone who briefly attempted to dabble in twitter on a few occasions. I have an account. I've tweeted a few times. I now check it probably a few times a year.
Twitter's strength and "problem" (to me), is that its just a firehose of senseless data and you have to manually figure out what you want. I only started enjoying Twitter, by accident, when in college I blacklisted Facebook, Instagram and Reddit on my computer. That said, over the years I've come to prefer it's arguably web-1.0 style of discovery to the curated feeds of today.
I don't think Twitter needs the instant gratification hooks that other platforms have. Sometimes you login, and there's nothing going on.
There are some in the Chrome Web Store too, though I don't have links.
There are more than 20 settings that can be individually enabled/disabled, so it's all up to the user how much they want.
> sketchy with the lack of details on how the click tracking removal works (the easier ways that come to mind on implementation are the same or worse for privacy)
Ah, ok. The word "sketchy" can be ambiguous. :-)
The real URL is actually already hidden in the DOM, so it's a simple matter of replacement.
the worst part of this is the more you invest into making it useable, the worse it is when big brother blocks/mutes you; the more enmeshed you are into this MCI tool for manufacturing consent. it sounds like the type of person who would be into twitter is the type of person who likes to spend a lot of time researching which credit card gives the best 2% cash back or whatever. genuinely just gross and boring to the point of being repulsive to most people on earth
I've left every other social network. No longer on Facebook. No interest in Instagram or TikTok. But Twitter I've continued to get value from. This is entirely because I'm able to curate my feed. My rules for twitter engagement are:
1. Never look at the algorithmic feed. Switch to most recent or use https://tweetdeck.twitter.com for list consumption.
2. Unfollow anyone who consistently pulls you into Twitter cesspools.
3. Follow the people who you find interesting and who doesn't break rule #2
4. Use the mute and block buttons as frequently as you need to.
5. Block retweets which aren't quotes.
Everyonce in a while someone will link to a tweet in a different forum and I'll take a look. 90% of the time I'm shocked at what the author of that Tweet's experience of Twitter is like. My experience is 180 degrees different.