This doesn't answer the question in the article tho. The question isn't "Who has the rights to a copy of my medical images". It's "Who owns the copyright to my medical images".
To answer that question, you'd first have to find out if your medical images are even protected by copyright in the first place. The answer to this question depends wholly on the picture itself.
Let's say a medical image of yours is indeed protected by copyright, then -- even in your country in Europe (regardless of which country it actually is) -- the copyright holder is the person who took the image. Not you. It may very well be that in your country this copyright is restricted by other laws (i.e. Persönlichkeitsrecht in Germany).
only if you didn't contract that person to take the image for you. So it makes sense, imho, that the person who paid for the image to be taken to own the copyright.
The point is that work-for-hire has to be explicit. For medical imagery, it would seem that the creator of the images would have the rights, but HIPAA would preclude them using them unless there was a specific release (which is common in teaching hospitals.)
Exception #1: The contract could provide for the image-maker to assign the copyright to the image subject. See 17 U.S.C. § 204, https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/17/204.
Exception #2: The parties could sign a written work-made-for-hire agreement before the image is created, IFF the work is specially ordered or commissioned for use • as a contribution to a collective work, • as a part of a motion picture or other audiovisual work, • as a translation, • as a supplementary work, • as a compilation, • as an instructional text, • as a test, • as answer material for a test, or • as an atlas. See 17 U.S.C. § 101, https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/17/101.
For the purpose of Exception #2 “supplementary work” is a work prepared for a publication as a secondary adjunct to a work by another author for the purpose of • introducing, • concluding, • illustrating, • explaining, • revising, • commenting upon, or • assisting in the use of the other work, such as • forewords, • afterwords, • pictorial illustrations, • maps, •charts, • tables, • editorial notes, • musical arrangements, • answer material for tests, • bibliographies, • appendixes, and • indexes; and an “instructional text” is a • literary, • pictorial, or • graphic work prepared for publication and intended to be used in systematic instructional activities. See 17 U.S.C. § 101, https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/17/101.
I can imagine that a court might see things differently, given that under Supreme Court precedent [1] it takes comparatively-little human creative effort to constitute an "original work of authorship" as required by the Copyright Act. But it's also likely that no one has ever cared enough about claiming copyright in a medical image to go challenging the Office's position — or that I''m simply not up to date on this area of the law (which isn't part of my day-to-day practice).
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monkey_selfie_copyright_disput...
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Feist_Publications,_Inc.,_v._R....
I was originally thinking it would fall under the monkey taking a selfie as the technician (not photographer) is merely activating a machine that actually makes an image (and not photo, it's actually a radiograph), like a programmer executing code that has an AI generate an image. Particularly in the case of the auto-panning machines. But everything in this paragraph can be wildly misinterpreted by the eyes and lies of a lawyer, since the user of a camera isn't taking a photo, they're pressing a button and the camera generates an image.
So you're absolutely correct on the "in a courtroom" setting.
Speaking as a (former) litigator, I think you have a misimpression about what lawyers and judges do in our common-law judicial system. In part, we deal with edge- and corner cases that simply aren't clearly addressed in the statute. (If you're a software developer, you're surely familiar with the phenomenon.)
It could be argued that in a civil case, if a statute doesn't clearly allow the plaintiff to recover, then the court should simply deny the requested relief. But that's not how the Anglo-American system works. Anciently, to help keep the peace, common-law judges tried to figure out, "what would the King do if he were here?" Likewise, in our modern system, they ask, "what was the intent of [Parliament | Congress | the state legislature] in an edge- or corner case like this?" and to grant or deny relief accordingly. Is that a perfect system? No. But it has worked reasonably well for centuries, and so there'd be a huge path-dependence problem in trying to change it.
In Germany there is a distinction between copyright holder (Inhaber des Urheberrechts) and the entity that is allowed to act on the copyright (Inhaber des Nutzungsrechts). If I take a picture that you contracted me to take, I'm the former and you're the latter.
The one who took the picture has moral rights, no matter who hired whom. These rights are for life and not transferrable, you have them whether you want it or not. It also means you can't put your work in the public domain. These are "respect the author" rights that can be use if someone defaces you work for instance. Parody and satire are exceptions.
The one who hired the one who took the picture has patrimonial rights if the contract says so. Patrimonial rights are essentially the right to make money and the closest to US copyright. These are transferrable.
But it could be interesting to think about whether a dental X-ray is "your likeness". So even if the dentist holds the copyright, their copyright is burdened/encumbered by the fact that it's a "picture of you". Unless you sign away that right in exchange for treatment, the copyright might not be that useful.
Yes, but that's kind of the point .... the blog post was asking the wrong question.
In the context of the blog post, "but copyright" is BS and the staff member should have been pulled up on it.
Reason ? GDPR. In Europe access to "personally identifiable information" is basically a god given right, saying "no" is not an option. Therefore ..... X-Ray linked to Patient Record = clearly PII = access granted. End of story.
The providing entity has the right to charge a limited fee for "admin" but that's it.
ALSO From a legal perspective, what contract the provider has signed with the equipment manufacturer is IRRELEVANT. The patient's legal relationship is with the healthcare provider. The onus is on the healthcare provider to ensure they are covered downstream for GDPR release, but lack of downstream coverage IS NOT an excuse to withhold GDPR release.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copyright_law_of_the_European_...
You're gonna have a hard time convincing a court that your dental radio was in fact creative art.
It should be near zero to deliver these records. Or at least marginally zero.
I’d rather records be free electronically and let healthcare providers plan for this.
Having costs discourages information sharing, I think.
https://www.theguardian.com/society/2022/may/15/watchdog-urg...
One aspect to this is you are usually the one bridging the doctors dealing with your health, and might be hand handling the relevant data to whoever needs it (e.g. your family doctor can request an X-ray, but after taking you need to switch doctors for any reasons. As you have the actual X-rays, you can hand it to anyone else competent for the case)
They are free in Italy, if you go through the National healthcare.
to answer the question: the images are of the patient, the National health care (SSN) can use them for research purpose only by authorized personel, the distribution must be authorized by the patient.
In some regions the patient can de-authorize them through a web app, but it's not very common yet.
If you go to a private medical center, the scans are included in the price and are yours.
We could vote with our feet, and only use providers that have electronic delivery available. Then they would feel the need to provide it.
Ditto for the complexity regarding the security.
The security depends entirely on the implementation though. I'm guessing that's why your concerned about it.
For me it took months to have a site, and it’s been stale and broken every time I checked.
Why should we trust it more to host such a critical service ?
It takes me a couple of minutes to do my tax return and I can deliver every form to any government organization from one single portal. All my health information is stored on another single portal (same one where I find the Covid pass).
I don’t think the rule that all government software is bad is universally applicable.
Not impressed with their security.
There are supposed to be no intrusions, but honestly the systems is so bad/old(1), that I am not sure they'd even notice.
1 It futures latest and greatest security practices ... from year 2000. Better than nothing, but inadequate nowadays.
I certainly can't speak for all software, but I work on one such and can confirm that there's no licensing or other cost for the doctors burning the disk with embedded viewer aside from the media itself, which can be any off the shelf stuff. Though I know there is some fuckery in related areas—there's at least one company that makes a DICOM printer that only accepts extremely pricy first-party, rfid-tagged paper.
In the United States this would somehow be an excuse to charge you $300 for it. Some people might be lucky enough to have their insurance "cover" it, which means you still somehow end up paying $30 since the insurance only covers 90% for some reason.
I guess on the positive side, they're not faxing it anymore.
Thanks
But I have to pay the doctor the expenses, if there is some work involved (like burning a CD or buying a flash drive - bc of security reasons they don’t let you connect yours, you need to buy a new one).
If you have some kind of 3d images (also dentists create them nowadays), there is usually some kind of licensed viewer software on the disk, where you can view just your own images. And as far as I know, the doctors don’t have to pay a license fee for it. It’s included with their software. And it is a feature they need, to comply with the law, that they have to give images to the patients upon request.