http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/graph/?id=FYGFD
We were merely reducing one kind of debt, namely debt held by the public. Total debt continued to increase.
The debt wasn't being paid off at a great rate but it was being paid off and the person's main point that you responded to is correct. We were well off financially until some very irresponsible actions by the Bush administration.
I disagree with the point about us never being able to pay off the debt. It can be done and there are historical examples of countries with higher debt/GDP ratios that were paid off.
Note: When talking about debt of a country people generally mean the debt of the government. There was a budget surplus at the end of the Clinton presidency and this is what people usually mean when they claim a government was/is "paying off the debt".
DATE VALUE
1990-09-30 3206.3
1991-09-30 3598.2
1992-09-30 4001.8
1993-09-30 4351.0
1994-09-30 4643.3
1995-09-30 4920.6
1996-09-30 5181.5
1997-09-30 5369.2
1998-09-30 5478.2
1999-09-30 5605.5
2000-09-30 5628.7
2001-09-30 5769.9
2002-09-30 6198.4
http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/data/FYGFD.txthttp://www.cbo.gov/budget/data/historical.pdf
According to the PDF there was a decrease in public debt for a number of years during the Clinton administration.
NOTE: I think the chart you linked to includes private debt and isn't just federal debt.
Your note is also incorrect. From my link:
Title: Gross Federal DebtIf the government borrows from Social Security, it takes that money out of itself and spends it out in the economy. SS and the government has a smaller pile of cash, and the government owes itself. When the money is put back, it's with funds that could either be used to buy bullets or put back in SS.
What cost $5605.5 in 1999 would cost $5796.09 in 2000. http://www.westegg.com/inflation/infl.cgi and 5769.9 is less than $5796.09.
Edit: I have seen the same argument vs infrastructure or GPD. But I think inflation is probably the safest measurement, because GDP can drop.
The question in my mind is - if a country like the US has the ability to print the world's reserve currency, isn't it beneficial to run a small deficit to increase GDP? I don't see any problems running small deficits, of course large amounts of public debt are rarely ever a good idea.
A look at sectoral balances helps to analyze this: the government's budget deficit is equal to the non-government's (private plus external sector) budget surplus. That's just a basic accounting fact.
So if the non-government sector desires to be in surplus (as it usually does), then the government must run a deficit. If it tries to run a surplus despite the non-government desires, there is a conflict, and someone will have to budge. Usually, the first ones forced to budge are those with the least economic clout. The result tends to be large scale unemployment.
There is nothing inherently bad or good about government deficits (I dislike the sentiment that is so often voiced by politicians, who frame the deficit and debt as a moral issue - those are just numbers in computers, for Bob's sake! Unemployment, poverty, those are issues where morals come into play). It's simply that given the typical long-term private sector behavior, a long-term government deficit is the pragmatic and economically responsible thing to have.
Mr. Greenspan said he was concerned that if the government did not begin to curtail its revenue, it would have more money than it needed when most of its debts were paid, leading to an accumulation of cash that he opposed. He said the government needed to start planning soon because there was $750 billion of debt that would not mature by 2011, so cash accumulation would begin by then, based on current projections, even though some of the debt would remain unpaid.
Source: http://www.nytimes.com/2001/01/26/news/26iht-fed.2.t_1.html
The Bush Administration figured out a couple different solutions to this problem.
The distinction between gross and public-held debt is also not very useful. The difference between them is government debt held by parts of the government, which is money that the government owes to itself. Public-held debt was decreasing even more: http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/graph/?g=2TI
So the graph is misleading in the sense that some people may draw the conclusion that government has used austerity measures, run surpluses, to reduce its debt. In fact, the government did not run surpluses during those periods in which the debt-to-GDP ratio was reduced so drastically. It ran deficits, which helped an already growing economy further along.
Implementing austerity is not going to start a sudden and drastic drop of debt-to-GDP measures in the current economic climate. If you honestly care about debt-to-GDP (why, btw?), you'd do better to stimulate the hell out of the economy.
I hate to trot this link out again, but: http://internationalecon.com/Finance/Fch5/F5-9.php
>We were merely reducing one kind of debt, namely debt held by the public. Total debt continued to increase.
George W. Bush Al Gore
Popular vote 50,456,002 50,999,897Also, a link that works: http://www.theonion.com/articles/bush-our-long-national-nigh...
Yes, it sucks either way, but when debt is the problem, more debt is not the cure. 'Stimulating' is just borrowing future funds to try and get things going now, which, at best, just moves the problem down the road.
Many people are quick to try and string up politicians who point out the truth. Sadly this means the politicians who push the problem forwards and reassure people are the ones that get voted in. And the problem gets pushed further down the track and gets even more malignant.
Ireland is improving (hello from Cork) in relative terms because it genuinely had nowhere further south left to go. 20% of the population is on the dole, property prices are down 60% from 2007 and are still falling, mobility of potential jobseekers has been curtailed by the fact that they can't sell up and move because their mortgages are worth twice what the house is.
We also took the old government out back and swung an axe into its head in February. The party of government for 80% of the entire history of Ireland as an independent state is now polling in fourth position. Its erstwhile coalition partner is within the margin of error of zero.
You cannot but imperil private sector growth by removing massive amounts of cash from the economy all at once[1]. Public employees spend that money they're paid.
[1. Please note use of phrase 'all at once'.]
When you loan money to stimulate defense contractors, non-competitive solar manufacturers and for all sorts of other boondoggles and build bridges to nowhere, no.
The problem is that the process of spending on infrastructure rarely is positive in most places for a whole host of reasons. Therefore, austerity is better because it avoids malinvestment. Doing nothing is better than wasting capital.
If you borrow money to spend, the spending has to create more return than the cost of the borrowed money, or the money is wasted. This is true in the case of the individual, the company and the government. Individuals rarely invest money for greater returns (think : new cars), companies that last always invest for greater returns, but governments have few incentives to do so.
They would much rather make a big splash and announce jobs now, than worry about whether or not they are creating something worthwhile.
The problem, of course, is always in measuring the positive returns of large public spending. But again, in times of over-borrowing, governments should always err on the side of caution.
Austerity plans are always a tough pill to swallow, and they can cost elections - as it did to Cardoso's sucessor in 2002 - but I fail to understand what is this madness you are talking about. If it were not for the economic policy that forced a surplus in the Brazilian budget, I don't think they would be in the (calmer) situation they are today.
I do not know much about Mexico.
As for the boom that came afterwards: Lula kept the basis of the economic policy started by Cardoso. In was only in the last two years of Lula's second mandate (2009-2010) that they tried to loose a little bit on government spending (as a way to fight contagion by Housing Crisis), and inflation had shown signs on creeping up again.
And even that increase in spending was only possible due to the austerity policies from the previous 15 years that allowed the country to grow their reserves. Had they not followed the IMF rules, they would be in the same situation that Greece/Portugal/Ireland/Italy are today.
Isn't it funny how the magical IMF benefits only come about after the IMF has been kicked out of the country.
GDP in dollars fell in 1998 due to changes in the exchange rate. The price of the dollar went from BRL 1.2 to 1.98 in a matter of a week.
Further, the spike that you see in your chart after 2002 was due to the dollar hitting an all-time high of BRL 4.00 when Lula was elected, and there was huge speculation in the market. After he took office and kept the monetary policy, the market calmed down and the BRL has been rising in value since.
Had the price of the dollar kept stable during these years, you would see a curve that shows exactly the numbers I mentioned before.
The IMF has not been kicked out of the country. Debts with the IMF were paid, but the monetary and economic policy is still there. The Brazilian Central Bank still recommends austerity policies for government spending. They still have the highest interest (inflation adjusted) rate in the world. Your cute chart does not prove anything.
P.S: It's in times like these that I really hate voting in discussion forums, and makes me even less of a believer in "the rule of the mob". You are completely wrong, but your cheap jab managed to convince a couple of uninformed people that what I said is worthy of a down vote.
But the only way to meaningfully measure GDP is to measure it against a single unchanging metric, and that's what they did here. Otherwise a country could double its GDP by simply devaluing its currency by half.
More importantly, it looks like it works the other way around. If you are devaluing your currency in half, your GDP in dollars (or whatever means of comparison you use) will be cut in half, not double. This is what your chart is showing. It will be a bigger number in the domestic currency, but then it doesn't mean anything because you are just changing the scale.
Anyway, we are arguing over details. The larger point is that the economic policy mandated by the IMF is still largely in place, and whenever the Brazilian government tried to increase government spending, a short growth burst was experienced with a very long bust.
Lula gave a 1001 speeches saying that "they were breaking free from the IMF", but in the end it is just political bullshit: interest rates are still high and it is the only instrument the Central Bank is able to use to keep inflation under control. This is pretty much the IMF "formula".
Update: looks like you are correct that they use current dollars. It still seems a misleading chart. Take a look at http://goo.gl/BCNIo and you can see the numbers I was mentioning.
Note that IMF-type policies of austerity can theoretically "work", if there are sufficient net exports. Even when domestic demand is savaged by austerity measures, the economy can grow by producing goods for the US and the EU at cheap prices. But net exports-led recoveries are a typical case of fallacy of composition: if there is a world-wide recession, then going for net exports will fail (unless we somehow manage to export to Mars...).
The problem facing the US and EU these days is that people seem to have forgotten that austerity was only ever a policy meant for the others.
This is how we got here in the first place.
When excessive debt is the problem, no amount of spending can cure it. The debt must be paid down or written off, most likely a combination of both.
Sadly your type of thinking is pervasive because it sounds so compelling. But while nobody in their right mind runs up a credit card thinking that this will somehow make them richer, there persists a widespread belief that borrowing and spending somehow makes a country better off. It doesn't, and it won't.
If anything positive is to come out of all of this, it might be the final discrediting of borrow and spend programs created in the name of Keynes. It will hopefully be the death of the widespread belief that you can borrow or tax your way to prosperity. Perhaps someone will come up with a kindergarten rhyme to teach children not to believe in free lunches.
The growth happened after the government spending (ie, military) was wound down. It was the retiring servicemen and women wanting to get on with the rest of their lives that caused the productivity boom.
After the war, the U.S. was in a great position to supply the world, having an economy running at full steam and no war damage to repair. But the Great Depression ended as war began, due to demand for military equipment.
You can pretend that our economy revolves around who's president and what political party system they belong to but no matter how hard you pretend it still isn't true.
Those are real policies, and they have real impact. You can pretend that they don't and that politics is all a "game", but no matter how hard you pretend it isn't true. (Sure, it's mostly a game, but at the margins it's important stuff, and not well served by bland internet cynicism).
Suggesting that Clinton was responsible for the takeoff of internet companies in 2000 and the housing boom is silly. He was a major beneficiary of a great economic time.
The crash of 2008? Many economists wisely point to Republican-led market deregulation, notably the repeal of Glass-Steagal in 1999, as the causes.
Considering that Democrats fight for stronger regulation and pass them (Dodd-Frank... even if that one is DOA), while Republicans fight for deregulation, it's a bit off to imply that the party has no effect on the economy.
That's a huge ideological difference and one that has significant effects on the economy, even in the short-mid term.
Um, Gramm-Leach was supported by a majority of both Dems and Reps. Clinton signed it.
The only major dispute between the parties was over whether to make CRA compliance a precursor for banking mergers. (I.e., banks can't merge or acquire if they don't lend to enough minorities.)
As far as I know, Bush's main forays into finance were Sarbox (increasing regulation), his ill-fated attempts to more strictly regulate Fannie and Freddie, and various laws pushing more people into homeownership (again, increasing regulation). Could you point out any acts of Republican-led market deregulation, ideally from the past 10 or so years?
While this is true, of those who opposed it, the vast majority were Democrats. 58 Democrats opposed it, only 6 Republicans did. The Republicans also controlled both houses and wrote the legislation so they certainly deserve more blame.
Repealing Glass-Stegal set the fuse by allowing banks to flip loans into the market offloading their risk, but it was the change in the net capital rule (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Net_capital_rule#The_net_capita...) in 2004 under the Bush administration that lit the match and kicked off the crisis by creating a massive amount of potential credit that led to the banks handing out loans like candy to anyone who'd take em knowing they could immediately flip the loan and pocket the profit with little risk.
Glass-Steagall has nothing to do with the secondary market for mortgages. Banks were flipping loans in the early 80's. This is how Salomon Brothers became famous.
...the change in the net capital rule (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Net_capital_rule#The_net_capita...) in 2004 under the Bush administration that lit the match and kicked off the crisis by creating a massive amount of potential credit that led to the banks handing out loans like candy to anyone who'd take em knowing they could immediately flip the loan and pocket the profit with little risk.
I don't think you understand what you are talking about. Flipping is always low risk, regardless of whether you mark to market or mark to model.
All the modified NCR rule would have done is allowed banks to hand out loans like candy and not flip them.
The repeal of Glass-Stegall let them flip loans to the market while their funding was FDIC insured since they were gambling with depositors money, something they didn't have access to before that. That makes flipping more attractive because you're insured by the FEDS.
The net capital rule change amplified this ability making handing them out like candy attractive; what good is a ton of credit if you don't leverage the shit out of for all you can.
> All the modified NCR rule would have done is allowed banks to hand out loans like candy and not flip them.
Which is what I said; I wasn't implying that the flipping was related to the net capital rule.
Whoa... tell that to the folks who worked at Bear Sterns and Lehman during 2007/2008. This is precisely why all of the major banks needed a bail-out. The risk models all automatically assumed that these instruments would maintain their liquidity, but when that capital dries up, it turns into a game of musical chairs.
When your business model fundamentally relies upon a liquid market for short-term credit[1], you typically end up in bankruptcy court when/if the music stops (unless of course you threaten the entire financial system and get a government bail-out).
When the institutions you rely upon for credit lose faith that you can repay your debts, you're sunk. Mark to whatever, that only matters with long-term debt.
[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2007_subprime_mortgage_financia...
Bear collapsed because they held huge long bets on housing with high duration. In contrast, companies like Goldman (mostly short term strategies) survived just fine.
My top comment comes off like I'm a big time republican and that couldn't be further from the truth. I just want to point out that the great economy that Clinton benefited from was not his creation.
I tend to agree that some of the deregulation did contribute to the crash in 2008. Some of that same deregulation also, very likely, contributed to the boom in the early 2000's.
The big housing boom started post-Clinton. It was intentional, to get us out of the 1999 tech crash.
Clinton benefited from the tech boom and the end of the cold war. (Bush I got hammered by the post-war transition recession, which ended before the election.)
Depends on what you mean by paying off the debt. If you pay off the debt by just issuing a sufficiently large amount of reserves at the Fed to do so, then yes, I would agree. Then you just transform one form of government liability (treasury bonds) into another form of government liability (reserves). No problem there.
But if you're actually talking about eliminating net government liabilities, you're missing the point. Here's why:
Individuals in the private sector want to accumulate net financial assets, if only to save for retirement. Every financial asset is somebody else's corresponding financial liability.
But retirement funds & co. are huge. Who is going to incur the necessary net financial liabilities to correspond to them? Private entities? Why would we allow private entities to run up that much debt? Also, with private entities you always have the problem that people might change their mind about their credit-worthiness.
The federal government, on the other hand, is at the top of the pyramid of liabilities (see e.g. here: http://neweconomicperspectives.blogspot.com/2011/09/mmp-blog...), and they can easily incur and sustain the required net financial liabilities to allow the private sector to save in net financial assets.
So government liabilities play an important role in the stability of the financial system.
If you run down the federal debt, you end up in a situation like the Eurozone, where the entity at the top of the pyramid of liability (i.e. the ECB) does not incur sufficient liabilities (and in fact, does not have the mandate to do so, for good reason) to support a stable financial system. The debt crisis is a direct result of this flawed setup, and you would be wise to avoid copying it in the US.
Other countries deal with surpluses with sovereign wealth or rainy day funds, but you could just as easily envision rebating a surplus as fully-refundable tax credit "dividends".
Then again, they don't actually have an official inflation target, so...
I see no reason the Fed wouldn't go for outright deflation if they thought they could get away with it. They seem to be really happy with their current tight money policy. :(
Think about it, how could it be that it is only 1.5% inflation when the size of the money supply is doubled or tripled?
For the Fed, "inflation" means an increase in the overall money supply. You get an increase in the money supply when people borrow money, and you get a decrease in the money supply when people pay off (or default) on loans. In a macro-economic sense we've been going through a period of pretty severe deflation since the housing market crashed, which is why the Fed is desperately pumping money into circulation. For all the gory details see here:
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com/2008/12/humpty-du...
tl;dr: You can have a rise in the cost of living and deflation at the same time, just like you can have stable prices during inflation.
p.s. If you don't understand why the money supply increases when people borrow, this is a good (though a bit dramatic) primer:
http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-2550156453790090544
Aslo, the Fed is not desperately pumping money into circulation. For example, they're paying interest on reserves (that is, paying banks to park money in accounts at the Fed). If they were trying to get money into circulation, the wouldn't be doing that, or would even be charging interest on excess reserves. Both policies have been used by central banks in the past; in fact the Fed didn't use to pay interest on reserves until the recent bank crisis started.
For inflation expectations? TIPS spreads.
The actual inflation rate is determined based on a basket of goods, which may or may not match your consumption patterns. Of course things get complicated by substitution effects, hedonic adjustments, etc. I don't know that I believe the official number any more than you do. But the fact is that the official number is what the Fed is supposed to target.
Note that groceries are explicitly excluded from "core" inflation calculations in the US because they're subject to severe supply shocks which have nothing to do with the value of money or inflation, by the way.
> how could it be that it is only 1.5% inflation when the > size of the money supply is doubled or tripled?
Trivially, if everyone keeps their money under a mattress. We're not quite that bad, but not much better off right now, either.
Second, I think the fact that the market crashed in 2000 might have a little something to do with gov't deficits as well.
I think the estimates were made for the plans Clinton put. He didn't plan to go on war with Afghanistan or Irak or make huge spending.
To a lay reader like myself, it would easily lead to confusion if people talk about different numbers without making the distinction clear. Is there a well known relationship between government debt and private debt? Or is talking up Total US Debt just a distraction from the article, which talks about Government Debt?
Yes.
"[...T]he difference between the government budget deficit and the trade deficit must equal the difference between private saving and investment[...]"
http://internationalecon.com/Finance/Fch5/F5-9.php
Holding the trade deficit constant and lowering government debt implies a rise in private debt.
It's also a bit of apples-and-oranges when you compare the nominal debt of one country with another without looking at the differences in GDP between the countries, i.e. the size of each country's economy.
The debt dollar is a horrible instrument that will not end well. We may be decades off, but it's gonna be ugly.
Spending increased more slowly from 92-94 before the Gingrich congress came to power, than it ever did afterwards. And Clinton didn't have to shut down the government to do it.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_federal_governmen...
By the way that report is absolutely wrong. Nothing terrible would happen if we paid off the debt. So there wouldn't be federal treasuries. BFD. Just set the risk free return to zero and you can use all of your old formulas. Yes several bank departments would not be able to make money for absolutely zero risk as they do now. Oh well, I suppose the banks would have to do what they are supposed to do, i.e., calculate risk properly.
But of course it is all academic now. Because it is unlikely to ever happen. Paying off the debt means doing something to help the future generations of Americans and it is doubtful any president would do such a thing, and if he did he would probably have to face a lot of angry voters who do not give a shit about the future generations as happened with Al Gore.