DATE VALUE
1990-09-30 3206.3
1991-09-30 3598.2
1992-09-30 4001.8
1993-09-30 4351.0
1994-09-30 4643.3
1995-09-30 4920.6
1996-09-30 5181.5
1997-09-30 5369.2
1998-09-30 5478.2
1999-09-30 5605.5
2000-09-30 5628.7
2001-09-30 5769.9
2002-09-30 6198.4
http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/data/FYGFD.txthttp://www.cbo.gov/budget/data/historical.pdf
According to the PDF there was a decrease in public debt for a number of years during the Clinton administration.
NOTE: I think the chart you linked to includes private debt and isn't just federal debt.
Your note is also incorrect. From my link:
Title: Gross Federal DebtIf the government borrows from Social Security, it takes that money out of itself and spends it out in the economy. SS and the government has a smaller pile of cash, and the government owes itself. When the money is put back, it's with funds that could either be used to buy bullets or put back in SS.
What cost $5605.5 in 1999 would cost $5796.09 in 2000. http://www.westegg.com/inflation/infl.cgi and 5769.9 is less than $5796.09.
Edit: I have seen the same argument vs infrastructure or GPD. But I think inflation is probably the safest measurement, because GDP can drop.
The question in my mind is - if a country like the US has the ability to print the world's reserve currency, isn't it beneficial to run a small deficit to increase GDP? I don't see any problems running small deficits, of course large amounts of public debt are rarely ever a good idea.
A look at sectoral balances helps to analyze this: the government's budget deficit is equal to the non-government's (private plus external sector) budget surplus. That's just a basic accounting fact.
So if the non-government sector desires to be in surplus (as it usually does), then the government must run a deficit. If it tries to run a surplus despite the non-government desires, there is a conflict, and someone will have to budge. Usually, the first ones forced to budge are those with the least economic clout. The result tends to be large scale unemployment.
There is nothing inherently bad or good about government deficits (I dislike the sentiment that is so often voiced by politicians, who frame the deficit and debt as a moral issue - those are just numbers in computers, for Bob's sake! Unemployment, poverty, those are issues where morals come into play). It's simply that given the typical long-term private sector behavior, a long-term government deficit is the pragmatic and economically responsible thing to have.
The debt wasn't being paid off at a great rate but it was being paid off and the person's main point that you responded to is correct. We were well off financially until some very irresponsible actions by the Bush administration.
I disagree with the point about us never being able to pay off the debt. It can be done and there are historical examples of countries with higher debt/GDP ratios that were paid off.
Note: When talking about debt of a country people generally mean the debt of the government. There was a budget surplus at the end of the Clinton presidency and this is what people usually mean when they claim a government was/is "paying off the debt".