News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Twitter CEO fires two top executives, freezes hiring by jmyeet on Thursday May 12, 2022 @02:27PM (#31358193)
The two execs fired were:

- Kayvon Beykpour, Head of Consumer Product (3 years, 11 months) [1]; and

- Bruce Falck, Revenue Product Lead (5 years at Twitter, 3 years and 11 months in this position) [2]

Kinda weird that both people were just shy of serving 4 years in their current roles. When I see moves like this my immediate thought is always, it's to save or make money. For example, there could be an options pool in the event of a change of control. Well, you've just fired a couple of people right before a huge vest (probably; I have no concrete information) and increased your share of that options pool.

It just reminds me of Skype firing executives at the Microsoft buyout to avoid payouts [3].

Otherwise making these moves before an acquisition has closed doesn't make a lot of sense. My money is on this having everything to do with money.

EDIT: Updated comment as the link was updated from the original Twitter thread by Kayvon Beykpour about his firing.

[1]: https://www.linkedin.com/in/kayvon-beykpour-2b264b4?original...

[2]: https://www.linkedin.com/in/brucefalck?original_referer=http...

[3]: https://www.seattletimes.com/business/skype-fires-executives....

Re:Twitter CEO fires two top executives, freezes hiring by dymk on Thursday May 12, 2022 @03:18PM (#31358981)
The vesting / payout theory makes no sense, firstly Twitter vesting at that point would be quarterly, so the company would be saving at most 1/16th of what those employees had already vested from their initial grant.

Secondly, it's the employees who would have the incentive to leave, not the company to fire them. Assuming a typical 4 year vesting period, it's right at this year when their compensation would have _dropped precipitously_.

Thirdly, the second individual had been at Twitter for more than 4 years, and unless they left and came back (doesn't look like they did), they'd still be vesting their original equity grant. The amount of time they've been at the company isn't even common between the two, so I don't see why you'd use it to establish a theory.

Re:Twitter CEO fires two top executives, freezes hiring by jmyeet on Thursday May 12, 2022 @04:00PM (#31359489)
It's true that there's a lot we don't know. Executive employment contracts are bespoke and quite different to peon contracts. There will be various incentives that might be cash or incentivized stock options ("ISOs") as well as regular compensation that might be RSUs, non-qualified stock options ("NSOs") or both.

But we do know:

1. The acquisition is imminent but not closed;

2. Executive contracts often include bonuses on acquisition and/or accelerations for change of control;

3. There are numerous examples of companies cleaning house to avoid payouts prior to an acquisition closing;

4. Generally a company on the verge of a likely acquisition just keeps the lights on and doesn't make any big moves so things like hiring freezes make sense; and

5. The circumstancial evidence that both executives just happen to be shy of their 4 year anniversary (in their current roles).

Conclusive? No. Kinda sus? Absolutely.

Re:Twitter CEO fires two top executives, freezes hiring by tinbad on Thursday May 12, 2022 @05:24PM (#31360284)
It's not uncommon for companies to "clear house" right before close of acquisitions, especially on exec level. However I don't believe it's for the reasons you mentioned (saving money). Instead it's likely to better align with new ownership (whether perceived or actual alignment) and ensure the company is well positioned for the change.

An established/relatively healthy org like Twitter will likely not be penny pinching at the risk of more fallout/attrition. In fact, I'm sure the convo went something like "if you leave now, you will keep xyz/golden parachute".

This has at least been my experience based on limited experience of being part of a few acquisitions and working closely with execs.

Re:Twitter CEO fires two top executives, freezes hiring by throwaway_1928 on Thursday May 12, 2022 @03:30PM (#31359140)
This may be Parag's hail mary play to appease his new master and keep his lucrative job.

I would not be surprised if his next move is to publicly extol the virtues of Free Speech and the First Amendment.

Re:Twitter CEO fires two top executives, freezes hiring by enos_feedler on Thursday May 12, 2022 @03:40PM (#31359268)
Thats what I was thinking too. It felt weird that Dorsey was replaced with such quiet low profile thinker in the first place. He has no presence on earnings calls or spaces. I’ve listened to him take questions and he seems to handle them no better with no deeper insight then even I could provide. Maybe he was keeping things close to his chest. However, it just made me think they sort of put a puppet in charge for the purpose of acquisition. Parag would be easy to control as a lever into change within Twitter. Attractive feature for a buyer. I thought it would be big tech. Never thought Elon would be the one buying and controlling him. What a plot twist!
Re:Twitter CEO fires two top executives, freezes hiring by partiallypro on Thursday May 12, 2022 @03:57PM (#31359450)
There is basically no way that Musk keeps him on, so I don't buy this. He will be replaced in due time once the acquisition is complete.
Re:Twitter CEO fires two top executives, freezes hiring by johannes1234321 on Thursday May 12, 2022 @05:16PM (#31360207)
Even if Musk wouldn't fire him immediately Musk's management style likely will be quite involved and no fun if you don't align with Musk's goals and ideas.
Re:Twitter CEO fires two top executives, freezes hiring by throwaway_2341 on Thursday May 12, 2022 @04:09PM (#31359586)
Honest question. Would a CEO be that desperate to keep his job? I imagine Parag can walk away with plenty after the buyout and do something else that he likes.
Re:Twitter CEO fires two top executives, freezes hiring by furyofantares on Thursday May 12, 2022 @04:19PM (#31359691)
I imagine it's a pretty intense job that takes up most of your life and permeates your sense of identity. Everything you said can be true and I'd still expect a CEO to be very strongly attached to their position.
Re:Twitter CEO fires two top executives, freezes hiring by hello_moto on Thursday May 12, 2022 @05:15PM (#31360202)
CEO jobs aren't plenty like standard SWE jobs.

CEOs typically don't apply for jobs, they can't walk into a company's Career page an apply as a CEO; they are headhunted by specialized headhunter.

Yes, CEO is desperate to keep their job because if they were to let go, they won't score a much higher profile job than their current; they'd be gone to a lower rank companies bidding their luck.

Re:Twitter CEO fires two top executives, freezes hiring by Graffur on Thursday May 12, 2022 @06:52PM (#31361056)
I'd love to read a blog post about CEO movements. One thing they could do is raise money and start a company themselves.
Re:Twitter CEO fires two top executives, freezes hiring by hitpointdrew on Thursday May 12, 2022 @05:05PM (#31360110)
How the hell do you know the vesting period? I get RSU’s at my publicly traded company that vest yearly, in May. This could absolutely been done in order to prevent RSU vesting.
Re:Twitter CEO fires two top executives, freezes hiring by dymk on Thursday May 12, 2022 @09:27PM (#31362195)
here ya go - https://www.levels.fyi/company/Twitter/salaries/

> At Twitter, RSUs are subject to a 4-year vesting schedule: 25% vests in the 1st year (8.33% every 4 months), then 25% in each of the 2nd, 3rd and 4th years (6.25% every 3 months). Every year employees get a new grant that vests over 4 years to bring them up to their target compensation.

it's Twitter, hundreds if not thousands of their employees post detailed compensation information.

Re:Twitter CEO fires two top executives, freezes hiring by fshbbdssbbgdd on Thursday May 12, 2022 @03:44PM (#31359314)
Since the company knows the comp will drop at year four, they will give a large grant for the minority they really need to retain. For rank and file employees, those grants are relatively rare and many will stay anyway because they aren’t optimizing their comp. I think at the executive level, not getting such a grant is tantamount to being fired because executives don’t get overlooked.
Re:Twitter CEO fires two top executives, freezes hiring by wnevets on Thursday May 12, 2022 @03:01PM (#31358721)
Are there really no clauses in contracts or laws to prevent something like this? That sounds incredibly scummy.
Re:Twitter CEO fires two top executives, freezes hiring by jmyeet on Thursday May 12, 2022 @03:14PM (#31358913)
There's a ton of scummy behaviour with things like this.

Skype was particularly scummy. Not only were executives fired to avoid a payout, their options/shares were bought back at a low price (called a clawback agreement) and the company was incorporated in the Caymand Islands (IIRC) so suting them was going to be incredibly difficult.

Mark Pincus of Zynga fame decided a bunch of people didn't deserve to get rich on the IPO so went to some people to get them agree to a smaller options package than they had in exchange for not being fired.

These two fired suggests they didn't have clauses in their contracts for acceleration in the event of termination and/or they possibly had clauses that would give them a big payout. Or maybe it was just the timing to avoid a final vest (assuming a 4 year vest, which isn't a given).

The two may even have grounds to sue so Twitter may have settled with them prior to this announcement for less than they would've had to pay out. This avoids litigation, the two exxecs get something and Twitter has to pay out less. Win, win, win (sort of).

Re:Twitter CEO fires two top executives, freezes hiring by daniel-cussen on Thursday May 12, 2022 @05:25PM (#31360296)
It's so trivial to fire young people and keep them out of court. Not if they're stupid, I wasn't stupid, more if they don't know the magic words. So in my case a lobotomist deleted all kinds of magic words--well "lobotomy" for one. The intention is to fuck all employees over at least one time. Then they get told the magic word and don't get fucked again (except in my case, I need to get fucked twice to learn the magic word twice, at least so far, knock on wood I only have to learn all the magic words twice).[2]

Similar to college students, same thing, we're talking about harm to youngest adults, the 18-22 age category and ongoing if you get cheated out of your career. Those kids. So I tell college students that if they live on campus they're homeless unless they have a second place to live when they get evicted, which can happen at moment's notice with no accountability[1]. So practically every college student is homeless and might end up on the street unless they suck up to the numerous people around them that have them by the balls.

Obviously they're homeless if they have no idea where they'll sleep that night!

So Stanford in practice has a gigantic homeless population, everyone on campus is homeless, no tenant rights. It looks like it has a small homeless population but really it has a similarly small non-homeless population.

[1] Did I say no accountability? Let me read this shit I wrote. Yeah, it says no accountability. Surely I fucked up saying that, oh no! Famous last words then. There's no accountability! I've been waiting for my trial since Friday, February 6, 2009, well I guess that trial could be called into order on Monday, or on Wednesday, maybe I'm speaking too soon and it's in the pipeline. The dean of freshman verbally swore I'd get a trial, as a guarantee after telling her I had to drop out without one. She gave me girl scout cookies in that meeting, surely it wasn't a lie if she gave me cookies!

Any day now. Older adults always say to be patient and humble. Saying so is an act of impatience and arrogance on their behalf, it's arrogant to call people arrogant, asking for patience is impatient. Just like it's selfish to accuse others of selfishness. To the extent I'm a fucking arrogant guy, and I am (slave of GOD, the last shall be the first), I'm not also giving self-serving advice too.

[2] Oh a new memory came back, at 17:24 May 12, "vicious cycle." A magic word came back to me as I wrote this! Maybe it's a vicious cycle and I'll be getting cheated, told the magic word, lobotomized, and repeat, forever!

Re:Twitter CEO fires two top executives, freezes hiring by t_mann on Thursday May 12, 2022 @03:14PM (#31358906)
Well, there are clauses saying after condition X is met you get Y. Clauses that would say you can't be fired up to Z days before you reach X are neither common, nor would they fundamentally fix the problem if you think about it. If you can prove that preventing bonus vesting was the reason you were let go, it might be worth talking to a lawyer, though - courts have the power in principle to intervene in such cases.
Re:Twitter CEO fires two top executives, freezes hiring by stingraycharles on Thursday May 12, 2022 @03:08PM (#31358814)
I always understood that, while it’s frowned upon, it’s definitely allowed.

It’s very scummy yes, but option plans are always a bit of a disguise trick, as it’s seen as part of your compensation, but in reality should really be considered a retroactive bonus you get after staying with the company for N years.

Re:Twitter CEO fires two top executives, freezes hiring by ntkachov on Thursday May 12, 2022 @03:08PM (#31358816)
That would be on the executive and the company to negotiate that aspect in the contract deal. Executive contracts almost always have lawyers behind them.
Re:Twitter CEO fires two top executives, freezes hiring by roguecoder on Thursday May 12, 2022 @07:21PM (#31361276)
These are highly-paid executives, so it depends on what they individually negotiated with the company.

Being promoted internally, they might not have pushed as hard, but it is very normal for anyone at Director+ level to bring their own lawyer in to negotiate employment contracts. Executives aren't signing the same employment docs you are signing.

Re:Twitter CEO fires two top executives, freezes hiring by nradov on Thursday May 12, 2022 @03:59PM (#31359475)
As an employee, or potential employee, you can always request a contract that guarantees employment for a certain period, or immediately vests all options upon termination. Most employers would only agree to such terms for the most valuable employees.
Re:Twitter CEO fires two top executives, freezes hiring by staticassertion on Thursday May 12, 2022 @04:17PM (#31359661)
There can be so-called 'acceleration' clauses where certain events trigger vests.
Re:Twitter CEO fires two top executives, freezes hiring by dexterdog on Thursday May 12, 2022 @05:11PM (#31360165)
Is it also scummy if they leave immediately after getting that payout?
Re:Twitter CEO fires two top executives, freezes hiring by dang on Thursday May 12, 2022 @03:47PM (#31359349)
Ok, we'll change to that first link (submitted URL was https://twitter.com/kayvz/status/1524787801757126656) - thanks!
Re:Twitter CEO fires two top executives, freezes hiring by lmkg on Thursday May 12, 2022 @03:59PM (#31359471)
Aside from that 3.93 is slightly less than 4, it's odd that both employees were in their current position for the same amount of time. I.e. they were part of the same cohort. What was Twitter doing in June-ish 2018 that resulted in them hiring multiple people in key roles? Was there an expansion, or a re-org, or executive turn-over?

Or just overfitting two data points?

Re:Twitter CEO fires two top executives, freezes hiring by arthurcolle on Thursday May 12, 2022 @04:08PM (#31359580)
That's when the Chik-fil-a "scandal" happened

https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/on-leadership/wp/2018/06...

Re:Twitter CEO fires two top executives, freezes hiring by tmp_anon_22 on Thursday May 12, 2022 @06:16PM (#31360766)
> What was Twitter doing in June-ish 2018

I think your timeline is off, wouldn't executive hires have a much longer timeline from inception to close such that the "event" predicating their hires could have been 5 years, 6 years out?

Re:Twitter CEO fires two top executives, freezes hiring by mattmaroon on Thursday May 12, 2022 @02:53PM (#31358584)
If the moves were made at 11 months I'd agree. It'd be really unusual if there was some large vest at the 4 year mark. Unless maybe they've recently been granted something for retention.
Re:Twitter CEO fires two top executives, freezes hiring by toyg on Thursday May 12, 2022 @03:09PM (#31358830)
More likely they had initial vests at two years, then additional ones every extra year, on a rolling basis.
Re:Twitter CEO fires two top executives, freezes hiring by yuvadam on Thursday May 12, 2022 @03:00PM (#31358689)
Is it common to have huge vesting cliffs at senior management level at those time frames?

This isn't some junior developer waiting for their 1 year cliff, even in that scenario options usually vest on a monthly basis after that.

Re:Twitter CEO fires two top executives, freezes hiring by jiveturkey on Thursday May 12, 2022 @03:07PM (#31358805)
maybe twitter accelerated their vest, or (at the exec level) there's a clause for that in their agreement. i'd lean that way before i considered this is a money saving move.
Re:Twitter CEO fires two top executives, freezes hiring by jollybean on Thursday May 12, 2022 @04:10PM (#31359602)
No, this is not about 'a few options'.

They are about to transform the company - and they need the talent to do that.

It's difficult to tell, but it could be that these guys are scapegoats, or they are going to be stumbling blocks to the 'new approach', or they company wants fresh blood there, or might have fresh blood lined up.

Whatever this is - it's in the domain of 'strategic', not likely to due to someone's equity package.

Re:Twitter CEO fires two top executives, freezes hiring by Simon_O_Rourke on Thursday May 12, 2022 @04:59PM (#31360068)
All of these higher up executive firings do nothing but remind me of those lines in Goodfellas "we had to sit still and take it. It was among the Italians. It was real grease ball s*t."
Re:Twitter CEO fires two top executives, freezes hiring by pikseladam on Thursday May 12, 2022 @02:49PM (#31358508)
wow. i think this is the true answer.