News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:IQ Test Made by Mensa Norway by ryandvm on Tuesday May 03, 2022 @01:42PM (#31251161)
Based on my experience with Mensa members, being obsessed with your own intelligence is seemingly the primary criterion for joining Mensa. A long, boring test was probably exactly the selection filter they're looking for.
Re:IQ Test Made by Mensa Norway by whatshisface on Tuesday May 03, 2022 @01:51PM (#31251260)
Mensa doesn't need a special filter for that, by virtue of being an IQ organization and not a chemistry/literature/mathematics organization (where it's about using your IQ for something) they will end up with the people who haven't joined an organization that's more specific to their interests: a great implicit filter for people who don't have interests other than solving puzzles.
Re:IQ Test Made by Mensa Norway by mdp2021 on Tuesday May 03, 2022 @03:04PM (#31252169)
We are not restricted to one membership (of course).

Editing for the skimmer who will not read the implicit: it's about an interest in meta-skills, transversal, exportable.

Re:IQ Test Made by Mensa Norway by blagie on Tuesday May 03, 2022 @02:09PM (#31251487)
I've never been part of Mensa, but it seems like good concept for when it was created.

The basic problem a lot of bright people had -- in the days before telecommunications -- was that the only people you had access to lived on your own street. If you were a nerd, most were boring.

A lot of work went into finding interesting people, be that through ham radio, organizations like Mensa, universities (at the time, about 5% of people went to university), gifted programs, or other places nerds could congregate.

I don't see much point to Mensa in 2022, but I think the cynicism is unwarranted. What do you do when you have a social club which is suddenly obsoleted by cars, phones, air planes, and the internet?

Re:IQ Test Made by Mensa Norway by coldtea on Tuesday May 03, 2022 @02:20PM (#31251628)
>I've never been part of Mensa, but it seems like good concept for when it was created

"Let's create an wannabe intellectual elite club based on a controversial and not really representative test, milking suckers with paid tests, and giving them a false sense of achievement and superiority"

(and I score in the high range, it's not about sour grapes)

Re:IQ Test Made by Mensa Norway by dusted on Wednesday May 04, 2022 @02:29AM (#31257371)
I don't think it's about wanting to be an intellectual (evidently, IQ has very little to do with that), but rathe about finding someone who might also be able to think in the same way you do, and socialize and talk with them.

I've found that there are people with whom I can share many thoughts and concepts as they pop into my head, and they will "get" it, maybe not agree, but they have the capacity to entertain my idea, bad as it may be. I find that kind of socializing very pleasant, and I much prefer it to "talking about weather and current events in sports and popculture" which also have it's place, but which can be discussed with a much broader selection of people.

And that's just me, and I'm not one of the smart ones, but if I can feel like that, I can only imagine that someone in the top 1 percentile would feel something similar, if stronger, and thus would need to make an extra effort to find such company.

If you don't feel like this, it's just very likely that you already have this need met from someone around you, and you've just never noticed?

Re:IQ Test Made by Mensa Norway by sitkack on Tuesday May 03, 2022 @03:24PM (#31252387)
Is it better or worse than having a club for Ivy League schools? At least Mensa doesn't gate membership on political connections and class (yes by proxy, lets be charitable).
Re:IQ Test Made by Mensa Norway by blagie on Tuesday May 03, 2022 @03:28PM (#31252442)
Tests in 1946 didn't have the same types of controversy as in 2022.

Prior to standardized testing, college admissions was literally based on belonging to a club. Rich parents would send you to a prep school, and admissions was based on admissions officers knowing the prep school (and grades, recommendations, etc. there-from). It was introduced to allow anyone from any socioeconomic background, and more demographic backgrounds, to be admitted based on ability rather than wealth. At the time, admissions rates to elite schools weren't nearly as cut-throat. A poor kid could study hard, take a test, and go to Harvard.

They didn't make the world equal, but they made it /more/ equal.

I really don't think the cynicism is warranted. Institutions go obsolete.

Re:IQ Test Made by Mensa Norway by DiggyJohnson on Wednesday May 04, 2022 @09:12AM (#31259896)
Did you not read the thread you’re commenting in? There’s a very good reply just a few comments up explaining how the origins of MENSA seem much more reasonable to our modern sensibilities in a lower tech world. Are you dismissing that perspective, or did you just not see it? Ranting about an IQ Club that you’re not a part of seems to me even more embarrassing than what you’re accusing them of. Does that make sense?

Maybe that last line is a bit harsh, but I presume MENSA has never negatively impacted your life - certainly not tangibly. This is my experience, and I have no interest in joining. Assuming the worst, and denigrating those that haven’t done anything to deserve it is immature at best, yet it’s something that we seem to be getting more comfortable with. It frustrates me.

Re:IQ Test Made by Mensa Norway by giraffe_lady on Tuesday May 03, 2022 @02:27PM (#31251717)
sure but:

> If you were a nerd, most were boring.

Is either of those strongly linked to IQ? Anecdotally and in my experience not really.

You can get pretty far on this by implicitly grouping a certain set of interests into "nerdy" or whatever but that is highly culturally mediated. A generation ago video games and sci-fi would have been a core of that set, but those are just the culture now.

The most nerd energy I've ever run across outside of my own interests is in people who follow auto racing and sports. Fiber arts and baking too. Not typically considered or even recognized as valid nerdery but very similar kind and degree of interest.

I'd argue that people who want to be in a group of other high IQ people probably do feel superior to people who can't be in that group. Now, and in the past too. Whether that's a useful grouping or a warranted superiority I don't want to get into. But it's really not more complicated than that, sorry.

Re:IQ Test Made by Mensa Norway by blagie on Tuesday May 03, 2022 @03:33PM (#31252494)
I think you're underestimating just how disconnected the world of 1946 was.

In 2022, it's awfully easy to find people into whatever you're into, and you can talk to them around the world. In 1946, if you were a physics nerd and you ran into a chemistry nerd or biology nerd, you'd be excited to have a friend who shared your interest in /science/.

As a footnote: Performance on a test like Mensa's is strongly culturally-mediated. I suspect most people can score decently with a bit of practice and training. I think the major question was:

- Do you want to talk about football and sports?

- Dating and gossip?

- Intellectual stuff

A lot of this also had to do with how people spend their time. It's a lot easier to be an intellectual / nerd in 2022 than in 1946. I have the world's information at my fingertips.

Re:IQ Test Made by Mensa Norway by mdp2021 on Tuesday May 03, 2022 @03:06PM (#31252208)
> I don't see much point to Mensa in 2022

To connect people who might have something to exchange. Not differently from HN, really.

Re:IQ Test Made by Mensa Norway by karmakaze on Tuesday May 03, 2022 @02:06PM (#31251454)
Googled it for you:

> To qualify for Mensa, you must have scored in the top 2 percent of the general population on any one of more than 200 accepted, standardized intelligence tests — including our Mensa Admission tests — at any point in your life. An estimated six million Americans are eligible for membership.

I've met some members. Their personalities are not what I would associate with the most intelligent people I've otherwise met. People who memorize digits of Pi come to mind.

Re:IQ Test Made by Mensa Norway by GuB-42 on Tuesday May 03, 2022 @03:19PM (#31252333)
> in the top 2 percent of the general population on any one of more than 200 accepted

> An estimated six million Americans are eligible for membership.

That's not how it works. 6 million Americans is about 2%. It means that in order to have such a filter, you only have one chance on a single test. Not, "1 of more than 200 at any point in your life"

Out of 200 tests, even among those of the highest standards, you are bound to find one where you are particularly good at, and then you can try again several times, because you are unlikely to be at the exact same position every time. Furthermore, the "general population" includes people who are not in their best shape and yet, "any point in your life" tests your peak performance. And there is training of course.

I wouldn't be surprised if it was more than 10% in reality. By that I mean "pick a random person and give him a huge incentive (ex. millions of dollars) to pass". If we restrict to people who really want to join without further incentive, it may be way higher.

Re:IQ Test Made by Mensa Norway by outworlder on Tuesday May 03, 2022 @02:19PM (#31251617)
> People who memorize digits of Pi come to mind.

Hey, I feel attacked. What's wrong with memorizing digits of Pi?

Re:IQ Test Made by Mensa Norway by karmakaze on Tuesday May 03, 2022 @04:07PM (#31252918)
You should have been memorizing Tau, of course! Don't embarrass the human race to our galactic neighbours. Imagine what we'd think of receiving a signal that was an encoding of e/2?
Re:IQ Test Made by Mensa Norway by coldtea on Tuesday May 03, 2022 @02:22PM (#31251645)
For starters, they're infinite, so it's a futile endeavour...
Re:IQ Test Made by Mensa Norway by dibujante on Tuesday May 03, 2022 @03:03PM (#31252158)
I think you will quickly find that there are only 10 distinct digits found within pi.
Re:IQ Test Made by Mensa Norway by matthewmacleod on Tuesday May 03, 2022 @03:21PM (#31252363)
This is a very base-10 mindset.

In fact, if we use base-π representation then π=1 and memorisation is trivial. QED.

Re:IQ Test Made by Mensa Norway by dibujante on Tuesday May 03, 2022 @04:11PM (#31252964)
Oh no, then if n=∞, there are infinite digits in pi!
Re:IQ Test Made by Mensa Norway by stinos on Tuesday May 03, 2022 @02:39PM (#31251858)
Is life itself really more than a series of rather futile endeavours? The point is that futility is, luckily, orthogonal to being enjoyable.
Re:IQ Test Made by Mensa Norway by munch117 on Tuesday May 03, 2022 @02:42PM (#31251899)
Infinite? Only if you include duplicates...
Re:IQ Test Made by Mensa Norway by coldtea on Tuesday May 03, 2022 @04:59PM (#31253505)
Or if you include order, which is what was meant (that's called literal irony)
Re:IQ Test Made by Mensa Norway by JackFr on Tuesday May 03, 2022 @02:48PM (#31251977)
I got you -- it's 0 through 9.
Re:IQ Test Made by Mensa Norway by giantg2 on Tuesday May 03, 2022 @02:19PM (#31251621)
They used to allow you to join based on SAT scores. I know someone from that era. They don't seem very intelligent. I'm guessing they just studied a lot. Maybe it's the same for those people.
Re:IQ Test Made by Mensa Norway by stavros on Tuesday May 03, 2022 @01:53PM (#31251290)
I joined Mensa today because I overheard some good reviews, but that's my biggest fear. I want a group that I can go for coffee and have interesting conversations with, not a group of people who are all about how smart they are.

I don't want to be biased before even going, though.

Re:IQ Test Made by Mensa Norway by syedkarim on Tuesday May 03, 2022 @02:22PM (#31251655)
The thing to remember is that one in fifty people qualifies to be in Mensa, which is not particularly selective or exclusive. This is 2% of the general population, not 2% of, for example, readers of Hacker News. Or 2% of software developers or 2% of people who read more than one book per year.

My experience with Mensa is from 20 years ago with the group in Chicago. I was in my twenties and my guess is that the average age of members was late-fifties. In theory, they were interested in recruiting younger people, in practice they were not interested in changing the activities in a way that would attract younger members, like focusing efforts to solve real-world problems. I felt they were more interested in showcasing depth in various atypical hobbies, or to simply talk about how smart they were. I was never in awe of anyone’s intellect. Pretty much just normal people. I don’t think I came across anyone that was exceptionally accomplished at anything.

Re:IQ Test Made by Mensa Norway by InitialLastName on Tuesday May 03, 2022 @02:11PM (#31251511)
You self-filtered into a group that's only about how smart people are, though.

In my experience, interesting conversations involve people with interests (and navel-gazing is antithetical to that).

Re:IQ Test Made by Mensa Norway by mdp2021 on Tuesday May 03, 2022 @03:10PM (#31252251)
A transversal quality does not imply «navel-gazing».
Re:IQ Test Made by Mensa Norway by torstenvl on Tuesday May 03, 2022 @02:10PM (#31251497)
This largely comes down to local group culture. In my experience, in the U.S. at least, more rural groups seem better. I speculate that this is due to: (1) lack of alternatives for intellectual engagement and (2) demographics, specifically that older generations are more likely to join clubs and organizations of all kinds. Both of these would balance the trend of millennial professionals to only join such an organization out of arrogance.
Re:IQ Test Made by Mensa Norway by pessimizer on Tuesday May 03, 2022 @02:29PM (#31251746)
I joined in Chicago for a year, and it turns out that it's really a board gaming club.
Re:IQ Test Made by Mensa Norway by stavros on Tuesday May 03, 2022 @02:35PM (#31251818)
Honestly that would be a great outcome.
Re:IQ Test Made by Mensa Norway by pessimizer on Tuesday May 03, 2022 @03:05PM (#31252198)
It wasn't bad. The people were a little bland and John Galty, but I love playing board games. The main problem was that they call it a Chicago chapter, but it was way out in the suburbs. I assumed that it was to be as far away from black people as possible (along with its membership, I think I was the only black person at the first meeting I went to out of probably 60 people IIRC), but I assume bad faith.

edit: would recommend if you live nearby and treat it as a board gaming club.

edit2: also, if I remember correctly you could bring two guests to meetings, so you're not stuck with only Mensa members.

Re:IQ Test Made by Mensa Norway by sitkack on Tuesday May 03, 2022 @03:27PM (#31252428)
> The people were a little bland and John Galty

I feel like that could be the Yelp review for every Mensa club.

Re:IQ Test Made by Mensa Norway by shepardrtc on Tuesday May 03, 2022 @02:00PM (#31251387)
> not a group of people who are all about how smart they are.

You're going to be disappointed.

Seriously though, you can find incredibly intelligent people in the strangest of places. And you find less than you might think in the most obvious of places. Once you learn what to look for, I think it becomes easier to find people to have interesting conversations with. Personally, I find that curiosity about the world around you is a very good indicator of someone I would enjoy speaking with.

Re:IQ Test Made by Mensa Norway by mumblemumble on Tuesday May 03, 2022 @02:10PM (#31251502)
It's funny. I am fascinated by cryptozoology, but generally don't believe cryptids exist. So you'd think skeptics' groups would be my jam? Turns out, nah. All the skeptics' groups I've tried aren't really all that interested in paranormal subjects, per se, just in their agreement that it doesn't exist. And the conversations often don't go much beyond that, so I quickly get bored.

Cryptozoology enthusiast groups are way more fun for me. I may not agree with most people there on whether Mothman exists, but we are 100% agreed that Mothman is awesome and we would like to spend more time talking about the story and what it means to people.

I used to be a regular at a Ruby meetup on similar grounds. I don't actually like the programming language itself very much, but I love Rubyists.

Re:IQ Test Made by Mensa Norway by giantg2 on Tuesday May 03, 2022 @02:20PM (#31251631)
Maybe a 2600 meeting?
Re:IQ Test Made by Mensa Norway by dkarl on Tuesday May 03, 2022 @03:13PM (#31252274)
> being obsessed with your own intelligence is seemingly the primary criterion for joining Mensa

The parent says that scoring like an average person means they "really suck" or are "just dumb," so I think they have the right mentality for Mensa, even if their performance fell short.

Re:IQ Test Made by Mensa Norway by bena on Wednesday May 04, 2022 @09:26AM (#31260047)
Exactly. I don't know exactly what it is about intelligence, but people get really defensive about it. No one wants to be average or even slightly above average. People will go through a lot of mental hoops to stake a claim of incredible intelligence.

We don't do this with any other measure though. The difference being that most other measures can be measured. They run up against reality rather quickly. Am I tall? No. No shame in saying that. No shame in saying I'm around the average. Am I fast? Slow? Strong? Weak? Thin? Fat? How big are my feet? My hands? etc.

All can be measured and seen. All have physical manifestations I cannot argue against.

Intelligence. Well. That's a little more abstract. Abstract to a degree that we don't always recognize that Jeopardy is not really a "smart" game. It's a trivia game. You have to know things. That's not intelligence, that's knowledge.

Re:IQ Test Made by Mensa Norway by pizza234 on Tuesday May 03, 2022 @02:32PM (#31251781)
YMMV :)

I joined mensa in two countries; I was involved in one, while in the other, I went only to one meeting.

The first had mostly regular table/social game events, and cultural events (e.g. chess competitions, museums, literature etc.).

I couldn't tell I was at a Mensa club, if not for the orientation of the cultural events, but especially... for the quantity of engineers :)

I remember there was at least one teenager at the social events, and I wouldn't even exclude that they just allowed them in because he was a friend of somebody - the atmosphere was relaxed and playful.

I'd totally join again a club like the first: 1. it was fun 2. the cultural activities were actually interesting 3. I'd network with SWEs. Which is, in some way, the attractive of Mensa - it definitely attracts nerds :)

Regarding me as a member of Mensa. I wouldn't qualify me obsessed with it; intelligence is a tool for me. And definitely I didn't enroll in college at 13 like some other HN readers :)

Re:IQ Test Made by Mensa Norway by mdp2021 on Tuesday May 03, 2022 @03:24PM (#31252396)
> the primary criterion

You are describing a type in the context of a club of people interested in the opposites of the type. It could suggest you that the deviation may remain the interesting part.

> the primary criterion for joining

Improper formulation. Not that important, but.