News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by vasco on Sunday May 01, 2022 @06:17AM (#31223713)
The venn diagram of internet users that read about super specific financial products, decide to buy them, while not even understanding the need to keep an emergency fund such that a move like this leaves them with under $200 in their account seems to be growing.

It seems to be a weird mix of wall street cosplay and financial ineptitude.

Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by JusticeJuice on Sunday May 01, 2022 @07:02AM (#31223953)
I work in the financial advice industry, and I honestly personally believe current legislation in most countries have truly failed to protect normal people from bad financial advice, despite that being their entire point.

The problem is, giving financial advice en-masse is very expensive and risky for a company. You need to ask a lot of questions about the users situation (assets, debt, income, dependants, etc) to make an informed decision. If you give bad financial advice, your putting yourself at big legal risk. The language has to be very specific (aka hard to understand for normal humans). And often the advice comes out as rather un-opinionated and general, which for most people means it's hard to actually action and put in place. All in all, it's a big investment, big cost, stresses out your legal team - which means less companies choose to do it, which in turn make it less accessible.

The alternative camp is very clearly just choosing to give 0 advice. Just giving access to investment products, with a full hands off 'make your own choices man' approach. Think robinhood. This is where people make mistakes.

The weird thing is while legitimate companies are afraid of giving advice, anyone with a social media presence can get online and talk whatever smack they want, with very little worry of blowback. One of the biggest mistakes I see is somebody from one country (say AU) watching a youtuber talking about another country (say US) like it's a universal truth. Different financial systems have their own metas depending on government retirement schemes, importance of credit scores, mortgage systems etc. Most useful and practical advice is country specific.

Legislation has just fully failed to protect consumers from bad advice, by making the barrier to entry so high for legitimate companies looking to inform at scale that it's not financially viable - compared to just doing the hands off 'not our problem man' approach. They've also done nothing to stop people taking advice from randoms online (not that they really could). Unfortunately visiting a personalised financial advisor in the same way you'd visit a doctor, is just expensive and not an option for most.

Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by pmontra on Sunday May 01, 2022 @07:07AM (#31223982)
> And often the advice comes out as rather un-opinionated and general, which for most people means it's hard to actually action and put in place

I agree with this. It seems that I have to make all the choices myself to shield the company from any responsibility so why should I pay some fee for the advice? No wonders that people get advice from random videos on YouTube or any equivalent source.

Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by JusticeJuice on Sunday May 01, 2022 @07:37AM (#31224171)
I have found there is really good advice out there, it's just in places most people won't look.

The first one is books. Go to a book shop, and find a book on personal finances, written by a registered financial advisor in your country, for your country. It'll be long, stuffy, boring as fuck, but you'll likely come away well informed. I think if you're reading HN this would suit.

Second one is personal financial advisers. You want to talk to an independant one, who's not tied to a company that's actually selling financial products. They shouldn't be paid a percentage commision (also called trailhead) on your money - I never understood how somebody can be 'acting in your best interests' if they're paid by how you invest. You should pay them by their time, like you would a doctor. Except it'll cost like $200

You also want a personalised financial adviser. Some advisors say like the one you'd find it you went to a bank, or a mortgage shop have a limited scope - they're only allowed to give advice about the bank's products, or mortgages specifically. You want full picture. Sometimes employee assistance programmes if you have that will actually get you a few free sessions with an adviser, use them.

Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by daurnimator on Sunday May 01, 2022 @09:21AM (#31224811)
> You should pay them by their time, like you would a doctor. Except it'll cost like $200

I looked into this a couple of months ago. It turns out it costs minimum ~$2,000 here in Australia to get anything that's not "General Advice only".

Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by JusticeJuice on Sunday May 01, 2022 @02:30PM (#31227446)
Ah dang. I was a bit worried I low-balled that number. You might've already seen this, but you tried this guide for finding one? There's a register of advisers in aus, could shop around a bit?

https://static1.squarespace.com/static/5eb4889e5e47b4255c410...

Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by Ozzie_osman on Sunday May 01, 2022 @09:58AM (#31225054)
> Except it'll cost like $200

I don't know where you could possibly get high-quality, personalized financial advice (with fiduciary standard) for 200. From my experience it's more likely it's on the order of thousands of dollars.

Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by Ekaros on Sunday May 01, 2022 @10:21AM (#31225214)
Question is do you need personalized financial advice? Or would covering the basics be enough? And here I'm talking about average people with somewhat middle or upper-middle class income.
Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by dehrmann on Sunday May 01, 2022 @02:18PM (#31227348)
For the most part, no, I don't think most people need it. A boglehead lazy portfolio will be good enough. The tricky bit is what to do if you want to buy a house in the next few years.
Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by usrn on Sunday May 01, 2022 @09:07AM (#31224724)
I'm not sure it's possible to protect people from bad financial advice without creating class stratification between those who can actually invest in useful things and those that can't.
Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by elzbardico on Sunday May 01, 2022 @10:58AM (#31225533)
People are desperate about the future. Gone are the times when having a good job, paying a reasonable mortgage for a reasonably paid house, saving a reasonable amount for retirement, while keeping a reasonable amount for emergencies (rare, before lay-offs become the knee jerk reaction of MBAs to fatten their bonuses).

Due to the increasing financialization of the economy, more and more people feel like they need to become wannabe speculators to protect their situations.

Thanks, Wall Street and Harvard Business School for fucking us all.

And fuck the Uniparty for squashing any real option to them.

Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by ChrisLomont on Sunday May 01, 2022 @02:49PM (#31227586)
>Gone are the times

Those times never existed for the vast majority of people. Minorities, single women, most men...... None of them had this rose colored past.

Statistically, more people now have more income in the US than ever before. Each income level is higher, some more than others (and this is a static snapshot, most people move around income quintiles throughout a career), options for goods are higher, items are safer (cars especially), and on and on.

The "life used to be so easy to make a good pay and have a great life" views are not backed by the evidence.

Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by depingus on Sunday May 01, 2022 @04:30PM (#31228370)
> Those times never existed for the vast majority of people. Minorities, single women, most men...... None of them had this rose colored past.

I don't know about that. My minority, immigrant, non-English speaking grandparents and their siblings (several are still alive and in their 90's) all own their homes and are still collecting pensions from their blue-collar private sector jobs. Some of them worked in factories sewing ladies undergarments, purses, and shoes. Some of them worked on road construction crews. And one was a janitor in an office building.

Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by ChrisLomont on Sunday May 01, 2022 @08:35PM (#31230146)
>I don't know about that

The majority of people never were in a pension plan, and even now a lot of people in pension plans don't work for that employer a full career, only getting partial payouts.

Currently the main source of retirement funds for most retirees is Social Security. So all those supposed people in wonderful pensions from the 1970s and so on either don't exist or make so little from those pensions that SS still pays more.

Don't assume your local situation is what the majority sees.

Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by depingus on Monday May 02, 2022 @12:40PM (#31237452)
"By yearend 1960, pension plans covered 23 million persons, about one-half of all private sector workers."

"By yearend 1977, total employer contributions to defined benefit pension plans had risen [...] covering nearly 35 million active employees." [More than half.]

https://www.bls.gov/mlr/1991/12/art3full.pdf

https://www.thebalance.com/the-history-of-the-pension-plan-2...

https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/USPRIV

Add to that, the public sector workers that were (mostly) all pension and you have more than a majority of workers on pension plan during that time period. No one is wearing rose tinted glasses.

Yes, obviously today, pensions have been removed from (almost) all private sector work places and are rapidly disappearing from the public sector too. Everything has been converted to some kind of investment plan; to pump money into to Wall Street. And we saw how great these investment plans worked out for the poor folks that had planned to retire around 2008.

Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by ChrisLomont on Tuesday May 03, 2022 @08:14AM (#31247338)
I like that you inject "[More than half]" when referring to the nearly 35 million workers in 1977.

Except there were over 90 million workers by then [1]. The FRED series you picked is not all employed people.

> And we saw how great these investment plans worked out for the poor folks that had planned to retire around 2008.

Ah, cherry picking, the best of all logical fallacies.

It's already known that those pensions didn't turn out too well either, since most of the people in that time now get most of their retirement income from Social Security.....

>to pump money into to Wall Street

And now the bias shows. Why not own some productive assets? What do you think pension plans do with money? Sit on it in a safe? Invest them all in the employing company, increasing risk, so that when/if the parent company fails the people get screwed? (Which happens and still happens a lot).

[1] https://www.jstor.org/stable/41840558

Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by depingus on Friday May 06, 2022 @07:09PM (#31290488)
> Ah, cherry picking, the best of all logical fallacies.

I don't appreciate your tone here. Everything I posted was the result of a quick web search. It just so happened that the FRED data I found corroborated the numbers in the study I found. Maybe you missed it, but both the study and FRED data are specifically about private sector workers.

Here is some more data (not hidden behind a paywall like your study):

https://data.bls.gov/pdq/SurveyOutputServlet

It looks like at the end of 1977 there was 85M people employed (total) in the US. Which is certainly not "moving above the 90-million mark" as your page suggests. So maybe your data is cherry picked? Is your data even US data? The page you provided doesn't say.

> It's already known that those pensions didn't turn out too well either

You didn't back this up with anything. Private pensions are protected by ERISA that was passed in 1974. It requires employers to have separate assets to cover their pensions and created the PBGC which insures them. The only pensions that I've seen go belly up are state (Kentucky) pensions where the state governments (not beholden to ERISA) raided the pension funds for other things.

> Why not own some productive assets?

If by "productive assets" you mean real estate, the price to play is way too high. And on a moral note, allowing family homes to be commoditizated into investment vehicles for the rich is part of the problem. If, instead, "productive assets" is just your fancy way of saying stocks and their derivatives then yeah; I'm invested in the market. I'm not happy about it, but there isn't another choice.

> And now the bias shows.

Yes I'm biased. Fuck Wall Street. It has nothing to do with "investing in companies". It's all about wealth extraction (from companies and now from dumb money). It produces nothing of value.

Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by elzbardico on Sunday May 01, 2022 @08:41PM (#31230182)
Contrary to what Americans apparently believe there is a world outside the US. Half my grandparents were black and yet they bought a house way younger than what I did
Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by scarface74 on Sunday May 01, 2022 @12:23PM (#31226288)
Isn’t buying a US backed bond the opposite of “speculation”?. The rate of return for a US bond has been called the “risk free rate of return” since I was in grad school over two decades ago.
Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by everfree on Sunday May 01, 2022 @02:59PM (#31227667)
In general, yes. However, unlike other bonds I-bonds have no secondary market, so there's no way to liquidate them in an emergency if you need them before their maturity date (1 year).

With I-bonds you don't need to speculate on whether the bond will default, but it does force you to speculate on what your financial situation will be over the next year.

Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by Handytinge on Tuesday May 03, 2022 @06:57AM (#31246836)
Sorry, I'm not trying to be picky, but I cannot grok this sentence:

> Gone are the times when having a good job, paying a reasonable mortgage for a reasonably paid house, saving a reasonable amount for retirement, while keeping a reasonable amount for emergencies (rare, before lay-offs become the knee jerk reaction of MBAs fatten their bonuses).

Is there a word or half the sentence missing there? I cannot follow your meaning.

Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by rockbruno on Sunday May 01, 2022 @06:56AM (#31223923)
I have witnessed this working at FAANG where people usually have the choice to allocate their grants into either risky options or safe, straight cash. The amount of people I see going all-in into the riskiest option and then proceeding to not understand why they lost their "compensation" (?) when the stock drops frightens me.
Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by antihero on Sunday May 01, 2022 @08:35AM (#31224505)
It's because in tech you are paid so fucking much that any ridiculous screw up you might do only affects you momentarily, you can still afford your bizzaro happy life, if you've fucked your savings money there's always more cash for rent, bills, enjoyment, on the horizon. Life become a fucking toy on some levels. There is no fear.
Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by tmpz22 on Sunday May 01, 2022 @09:29AM (#31224865)
A lot of FANNG is non-software roles. A lot of FANNG are contractors. A lot of FANNG is over leveraged (house, random tax liabilities, supporting family members).

I’m utterly convinced FANNG comp is overvalued due to selection bias on Blind and direct PR efforts by those companies.

Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by scarface74 on Sunday May 01, 2022 @12:26PM (#31226313)
When someone talks about “people working for a FAANG”, realistically no one is referring to Amazon warehouse workers neither are people talking about Uber drivers. Mostly they are talking about software engineers and adjacent roles.

Thats not meant to throw shade on warehouse workers as “lesser”. My dad is retired factory worker.

Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by heartbreak on Sunday May 01, 2022 @01:19PM (#31226758)
It’s not just warehouse workers and drivers. Accounting, marketing, legal, HR, etc. all exist.
Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by scarface74 on Sunday May 01, 2022 @01:53PM (#31227069)
Yes, and at least at Amazon, they all pay much more than the $130K that it takes to be in the 90th percentile income level in the US if you are at least a mid level (L5) employee.
Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by annoyingnoob on Sunday May 01, 2022 @11:06AM (#31225604)
If you have ever been to any company 401K meeting, the 401K rep will always, always, encourage young people to make risky investments and encourage people closer to retirement to make conservative investments.
Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by _moof on Sunday May 01, 2022 @02:30PM (#31227449)
Because recruiters love to go on and on about how "if the stock goes to a billion, you'll make a zillion," and they never, ever, ever mention that the stock might become worthless. The other thing is that we've had absolutely stellar economic growth since the 2008 crash, and no one under the age of 32 was working before 2008, so they really have no notion that the economy won't always be growing. It's just not on their radar.
Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by phreeza on Sunday May 01, 2022 @07:45AM (#31224220)
Do any faang still pay in options still? Google is mostly RSUs these days.
Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by jtc331 on Sunday May 01, 2022 @07:47AM (#31224229)
Options? Or RSUs?
Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by rockbruno on Sunday May 01, 2022 @08:24AM (#31224451)
Spotify has both RSUs and options, you can choose which one you want and I think they do a very good job of explaining the differences in risk. You can also choose to be paid in cash if you want zero risk (but also zero gain)
Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by scarface74 on Sunday May 01, 2022 @12:30PM (#31226343)
And zero loss as I watch my unvested FAANG RSUs drop by a third. I’m glad at least the first two years were mostly a signing bonus I could use to stabilize my finances - pay off debt and build a cash reserve. My RSUs vest heavily on the back end.

Yes I know, how do you tell someone where you work without telling them where you work.

Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by maximus-decimus on Sunday May 01, 2022 @02:03PM (#31227197)
I have a colleague who just can't justify to themselves having an emergency fund while they still have debt to pay... yet buy a brand new 40k car and think about replacing it after 2 years even though they have nothing against it.

I feel like a lot of people just can't stand having money standing there doing nothing as an insurance policy when they could be making money or buying something with it.

Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by dehrmann on Sunday May 01, 2022 @02:14PM (#31227318)
> I have a colleague who just can't justify to themselves having an emergency fund while they still have debt to pay

Depending on the interest rates, and assuming they can keep the line of credit if they lose their job, this might make sense since it's a choice between reducing debt now vs potentially increasing debt later.

The second part is just silly, but it's probably the attitude they got them in debt in the first place.

Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by kube-system on Sunday May 01, 2022 @05:13PM (#31228718)
> people just can't stand having money standing there doing nothing as an insurance policy

And then, they pay more on their actual insurance policies to have low deductibles because they can’t afford a larger deductible because they don’t save anything.

Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by bombcar on Sunday May 01, 2022 @06:21AM (#31223724)
To be fair this mystical 8.4% has been plastered everywhere as a “buy now” which is causing serious fomo.

Also the blog clearly indicates they were going to poke the fate bear, poked said bear, and then went surprised pikachu.

Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by redisman on Sunday May 01, 2022 @01:46PM (#31226999)
The investment is good and safe. I also bought I bonds and will buy more as I accrue cash. It’s not even really an investment as technically you make $0 in purchasing power. This is more of a UX and lack of emergency fund fail.
Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by tjoff on Sunday May 01, 2022 @09:15AM (#31224780)
This move was calculated though. With incoming pay he knew that he'd be fine regardless. Sure, another emergency before the payback might suck but likely not catastrophic given the $10k coming back in a few weeks.
Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by msrenee on Sunday May 01, 2022 @10:40AM (#31225374)
Oh, I didn't realize he had worked it out so that he could still cover bills, etc. I just caught the ~$300 in the savings account and didnt see the timeline on paychecks and bills.
Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by scarface74 on Sunday May 01, 2022 @12:32PM (#31226354)
Exactly, he wrote it as if it were more of a minor and semi amusing nuisance than a life altering mistake.
Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by gHA5 on Sunday May 01, 2022 @09:51AM (#31225005)
A Venn diagram is just a graphical representation of sets. You're thinking of an intersection (of sets).
Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by atombender on Monday May 02, 2022 @04:46AM (#31232692)
A Venn diagram visualizes operations between sets; that's the whole point. A diagram with two overlapping circles, for example, shows the sets and their intersection. Venn diagrams can also express unions and other logical relations.
Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by ttybird2 on Sunday May 01, 2022 @07:21AM (#31224075)
Quite a few of them are just normal people trying to stay ahead of the inflation.
Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by fortran77 on Sunday May 01, 2022 @10:17AM (#31225183)
You can take the money out of an ibond with a small penalty after a relatively short time. So it's not a huge risk if you have enough short-term credit, etc, for an emergency before the time comes when you can cash the iBond.
Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by loeg on Sunday May 01, 2022 @12:18PM (#31226245)
The lockup period ("relatively short time") is a full year. For immediate cashflow purposes, I wouldn't really consider that relatively short.
Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by mynameishere on Sunday May 01, 2022 @11:34AM (#31225860)
Seriously, what the hell. Acting like this guy is blowing his future on a roulette wheel by getting some savings bonds.

Is anybody else just sick to death of the term "emergency fund"? If you go to /r/personalfinance, every other comment is reminding people to stock up their emergency fund. Towelie says, "Don't forget to bring a towel!"

I'll tell you about my real "emergency fund": In an actual, living emergency, every single dollar I have, in every account, even my IRA, and all my credit lines combined, are my emergency fund. That's the nature of an emergency. If I empty out some specially earmarked emergency fund, I don't tell the doctor to quit taking the bullets out of my spleen because I'm tapped. "Sorry, can't touch my HYSA!" (HYSAs are another butt bug of /r/pf)

What people mean by "emergency fund" obviously is their "don't stupidly overdraft your checking account fund", but they never spell that out.

Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by soared on Sunday May 01, 2022 @12:47PM (#31226485)
It doesn’t sound like you understand the purpose of an emergency fund or what it is. It’s for when a random virus takes down society and you lose your job, but you and your family still need to pay for rent and food for 6 months. That’s why you save x months worth of expenses in cash.

If you’re young and don’t have family/debt you can just use your ira as an emergency fund. If you have a family and kids you need cash available for unexpected events. Most people don’t have tech jobs where they make 5k every two weeks. A car accident with no emergency fund means many people can’t get to work, lose their job, etc. They need safe cash for emergencies.

Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by redisman on Sunday May 01, 2022 @01:48PM (#31227021)
Only $200 in your checking account is just logistically a nightmare. If OP has any autopay set up they’re very likely to overdraw
Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by scarface74 on Sunday May 01, 2022 @12:35PM (#31226385)
I agree, I get downvoted merciless on r/personalfinance when I say that my only conceivable true “emergency” is a job loss. Anything else I can use credit to income smooth and cash flow. I keep one month of bills in savings

More specifically, I have a HELOC and I’m always getting low and no interest balance transfer options from my bank.

Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by UncleMeat on Sunday May 01, 2022 @04:23PM (#31228321)
It is also worth understanding when you situation is far more stable than most people. If you've got a stable job and considerable assets then you can basically self insure. Yes, if you surprise need $40,000 and the market is down it will suck to sell a bunch of investments from your taxable brokerage account or rapidly get a HELOC but that case is rare enough that you are willing to eat the loss in that case for additional expected growth.

Almost nobody has this. The r/personalfinance memes exist largely as "the very basics for people who don't have the first idea how to plan for their financial future."

This is just another one of those benefits of being wealthy. On average, self-insuring saves money. But for a lot of people an emergency fund is a critical thing because they don't have access to liquid assets without gargantuan 401k penalties.

Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by scarface74 on Sunday May 01, 2022 @06:22PM (#31229300)
This was my same thought process when I was making $80K and trying to dig myself out of bad real estate decisions post 2008 and had less than $100 in savings. Yes I know $80K isn’t a bad income in the grand scheme of things. But it is when you have five mortgages on three properties totaling a half a million dollars during the worse real estate crash in years.

Even then my focus was to always be employable and to be able to find a job quickly.

Re:I accidentally loaned all my money to the US government by stjohnswarts on Sunday May 01, 2022 @11:24AM (#31225759)
well he knew that he had a paycheck coming up so he was probably good. I'm not nearly that brave myself but it wasn't a totally awful situation.