If you can default on a loan, you force loan writers to only provide payable loans. $200k loan for an English major? Low chance for a good enough job to pay it back. Comp Sci major at state school who had a 2.0 in high school? High chance of drop out, low chance of payback.
We should just give loan companies the kick they need to stop writing bad loans just because it’s protected. Let the free market do it’s thing.
I think the same argument applies to cigarettes. Require those companies to underwrite medical care for cigarette related illness, but let people make any decisions they want. Build the externalities into the product price. Doing this would raise cost of cigarettes since you’d essentially have to self-insure with every pack.
On the other hand, it could also be a good thing since it would push more people towards the trades, which we sorely need. And maybe it would provide downward pressure on the cost of an education.
Or do the same for all smokers. Back of the envelope, it looks like about $370B in medical expenses & lost economic output per year, with about 20B packs of cigarettes sold (US), so that's about $19/pack of cigarettes.
Then put that money into a trust to cover expenses for smokers so that they don't burden non-smokers in either tax dollars or increased insurance premiums. You'll need some money to administer the process too, so let's say another $2/pack for that. Call it the "True Cost Smoking Tax".
Right now, smokers die earlier. In theory, despite the treatments for lung cancer, the earlier death means that overall it is cheaper to the “system.” A person dying under 65 means no social security payouts, etc.
Yes, Prime Minister noted that cigarette related deaths saved the country significant amounts overall.
Also our “system” is overburdened now, so the savings there would probably not be refunded.
Also, holding companies liable for illegal usage of their products is a constraint on growth.
Why not charge the store that illegal sold the children the Menthol cigarettes?
Why not ask the children what ads they say with cigarettes in them and charge the marketing agency?
Should we hold government officials in contempt of society when they build roads that people die on? Should we hold generals as murderers when a mission fails?
Is it better to save 1000 lives by regulating something than saving 10000 lives over the long run with new technology?
It's much harder to quantify the negative impacts of regulations in terms of medicines never developed, healthcare never delivered, food innovation never discovered, etc.
This is done already in the form of large fines and revoked licenses.
Otherwise: Assuming the companies would just pass on the cost by raising prices, this is making people accept personal responsibility. A direct tax on cigarettes would be a different way of doing it.
I wouldn't limit this to estimated costs for illegal smoking. Make everyone pay more for cigarettes to cover their actual costs-- costs currently payed by society in general. Right now the increase in medical costs is subsidized by non-smokers.
Strict individual responsibility had been the rule for cigarette smoking before and it was not successful.
Market growth is not so important.
We'll see if markets crash around the globe the famine that emerges.
Market health is important, fixation on growth is in my opinion a big cause for lots of issues we face globally. Everything is built in a way where it constantly has to grow in order to work. But everything we have and do cannot be done or had endlessly, everything has its limits. Our markets don't exist in a vacuum, growing means to take space away from other things or beings.
Constant growth is not possible and things which are focused on it are bound to fail or turn ugly.
What's a better way to do it?
People who know what the Club of Rome discusses might be able to chime in, but 2052[1](not affiliated) largely shaped my opinion about this topic. Can't put it into perfect guidelines, but I would wish for a system which is dicated based on how happy it makes its people and on how sustainable it is.
Otherwise, if we still stay focused on growth, I don't see how we should handle climate change and other global issues. Because exactly this desire to always grow and expand seems to be the common factor behind a lot of these issues. Continue growing and buying Co2-certificates is not what's going to save us, we have to rethink our western, first-world way of living and maybe turn down our luxuries a bit.
In my opinion, expanding wealth gaps are a big issue as well. People who have the means to just ignore climate change and other things by spending money will never care, at the same time the same people are exactly the ones using the most resources.
As you can see, I'm more rambling than really answering your question, but we can gladly continue discussing this topic.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2052:_A_Global_Forecast_for_th...
Market growth for tobacco products is not important, full stop.
Why? People always put this out there as a universal moral virtue but I just don't see it that way. The ideology of individual responsibility for all negative consequences has led us to horrific places. It's useful and necessary sometimes but not always, and I don't think here.
> Also, holding companies liable for illegal usage of their products is a constraint on growth.
Who fucking cares? Again, growth in itself is not a virtue we need to cultivate for its own sake. Growth of what, and for what ends? Growth is a tool we can use, so what are we using it for in this case. And do we even want to be?
Starving people across the world. As the pie grows everyone gets a slice. Now the pie needs to be better divided across the globe, I agree.
> Why?
Inalienable rights are a cornerstone of this country. I think this should include what we ingest. Now, we're not exempt from the consequences of what we ingest. I can def understand situations where the collective has a higher responsibility, but I don't think smoking flavored tobacco is one of them.
Edit: To the person below me, it is ludicrous that healthy people subsidize non-healthy people's healthcare when they choose to smoke.
Should we do the same for people who consume alcohol? What about people who aren't fit, overweight? What about excessive sport, bad posture, eating lots of red meat, sugar or fat, or do or consume [INSERT LIST OF UNHEALTHY THINGS]
Someone may call this a slippery-slope argument, but I'd disagree. If the argument is that people should pay for their own reckless, unhealthy or dangerous behaviour, I don't understand why we would only apply this to smoking.
Lots of things we do as humans are unhealthy and unnecessary, I really don't understand the focus on smoking.
PS: I am not and never was a smoker.
I agree, and don't think it's a slippery slope. I see nothing wrong with health insurance premiums being partially determined by life choices. Life insurance often already does this to some degree. Car insurance does this all the time based on the choices a person has made (choice of car, choice to speed, drive drunk, or otherwise engage in riskier behavior)
The fact that people might argue over where to draw the line is never, by itself, justification for not drawing a line at all. Smoking & alcohol at least are areas with enough research to quantify costs a bit more. Excessive sport is murkier: Are risks of injury offset by an overall healthier body?
Food is more difficult. There are a lot of socioeconomic issues surrounding access & affordability to healthy foods that mean the issue isn't purely one of choice.
This is probably different from person to person, based on their ideology or world-view. Because I don't think that we should be treated differently based on our choices. For me insurances are an act of solidarity - We all pay, and if someone needs money, they receive it. Of course that excludes fraud, but I think you know what I mean. But I respect your view, I understand why people would want premiums to be individual. It's just not my style.
> socioeconomic issues surrounding access & affordability to healthy foods
That's true, yes. Socioeconomic standings can however also influence other factors we have mentioned, though admittedly not so much as food. But one example I have in mind is drug use - Technically opiates and other hard drugs are very dangerous and harmful, and I think we're both aware how much socioeconomic factors influences consumption of such substances.
I have to agree with the other commenter, this sentence is very quotable: "The fact that people might argue over where to draw the line is never, by itself, justification for not drawing a line at all." Good insight, thanks. Will keep this in mind the next time I think about potential lines.
Wow, this is a great quote. I'm using this in the future.
Every ideological group will salivate at the idea of controlling what you can and can't do with your body if the result could be higher medical expenses that need to be paid for by the community.
We could probably just charge tobacco companies the full future medical expenses (including pain, suffering and years of life lost) of any minors that smoke menthol cigarettes when there was advertising or product availability in that child's area.
We have good historical/statistical data for these costs so as a starting point we could charge the tobacco companies up front based off the known stats and put it into a medical fund instead of having to survey individual children.
Why?
Because children aren't responsible for being idiots with poor executive function.
and
Parents who lock their children up to fully protect their kids from the outside world are bad parents (right?)
If parents are solely responsible (the children can't be) than we might as well start sending parents to jail when their kids look at pornography and skip to the point where all parents are in jail or fined into poverty.
Children push boundaries, any industry that manufacturers, targets and profits off of exploiting the nature and developmental stages of children with purely recreational addictive carcinogens should pay the full externalized cost.
Part of respecting children is knowing that they can be extremely smart and their ideas have just as much validity as any adults but their ability to calculate and process the implications of risk is under developed.
That way everyone is treated like an adult who is an adult (companies are run by large groups of adults who know what eggs they are cracking to make their omelet, certainly they do in this case), no nannie state intervention, and importantly, no unpayed externalized costs for our larger society to pay while a small portion of other adults profit.