News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Pet Airways by danhak on Thursday April 28, 2022 @06:21PM (#31198940)
Some people are allergic. Some people have phobias. Some people would simply prefer not to be near an animal that may drool, shed, bark or otherwise act unpredictably when stressed on a flight.

None of that is unreasonable. I have nothing against dogs and dog owners but too many owners these days seem oblivious to the fact that many other people would prefer not to be forced to share space with animals.

Re:Pet Airways by powerset on Thursday April 28, 2022 @06:23PM (#31198962)
If we're being honest, many people would prefer not to be forced to share space with other humans, either
Re:Pet Airways by majormajor on Thursday April 28, 2022 @06:26PM (#31198995)
Yeah, and it's easier for me to deal with that as a result: I can pay extra and get a first class ticket to get (depending on the plane) either some more space or A LOT more space to myself.

Would be nice if airlines would make it just as easy to buy some more space for my pet. Pay more to buy the row out, pay more to get on a limited selection of "pet friendly" flights, probably other ideas could work too...

Re:Pet Airways by dwighttk on Thursday April 28, 2022 @06:51PM (#31199216)
pet friendly flights seems like the best bet here... I was sort of assuming this was a pet friendly airline, not just a plane that you can put your pet on.
Re:Pet Airways by bscphil on Friday April 29, 2022 @03:38AM (#31202451)
> Yeah, and it's easier for me to deal with that as a result: I can pay extra and get a first class ticket to get (depending on the plane) either some more space or A LOT more space to myself.

I see people bring crying babies into first class all the time. I would dispute that most people really have an option to avoid "nuisance" contact with other people. (Not an option for me either way, I have never had a first class seat.)

Re:Pet Airways by imgabe on Thursday April 28, 2022 @07:28PM (#31199508)
You’re not forced to go on an airplane. If you don’t want to be around other humans, stay home.

The comfort of other humans is more important than anyone’s selfish desire to drag their pet to each and every place they happen to go.

Re:Pet Airways by turkeygizzard on Thursday April 28, 2022 @07:31PM (#31199527)
I think a similar argument could be applied to babies on planes
Re:Pet Airways by imgabe on Thursday April 28, 2022 @07:33PM (#31199541)
Babies are people. Dogs are not. We prioritize people over dogs. It’s really not that complicated.
Re:Pet Airways by turkeygizzard on Thursday April 28, 2022 @07:40PM (#31199596)
Right, but if you just replace "pet" with "baby" in your comment, the argument is still relevant. I'm not saying either way is wrong, but I don't think you can immediately conclude that it's fair to bring a baby on a plane that disturbs the 30+ people in immediate proximity while obviously unfair to bring a small pet on board
Re:Pet Airways by imgabe on Thursday April 28, 2022 @07:45PM (#31199627)
It's not still relevant because a baby and a dog are not equivalent. A baby has rights a dog doesn't. A baby might disturb people, so might an adult, but both are humans and you have to take the risk of being disturbed by humans because society is made of humans. Society is not made of or for dogs. Dogs are optional.

The OP was not talking about small pets, which are already allowed. They're talking about buying a separate seat for a large dog. It is utterly insane to expect anyone to spend a cross-country flight with an 80lb Labrador next to them slobbering all over them.

Re:Pet Airways by turkeygizzard on Thursday April 28, 2022 @07:48PM (#31199641)
Fair points! That said, I think I'd personally pay a small premium to sit next to someone's (well behaved) dog lol
Re:Pet Airways by tamaharbor on Friday April 29, 2022 @09:48AM (#31205034)
There should be a known seating area on every plane for pets and babies. Other passengers can select their seats as appropriate.
Re:Pet Airways by amelius on Thursday April 28, 2022 @07:05PM (#31199336)
Humans are not as unpredictable as most pets.
Re:Pet Airways by smt88 on Thursday April 28, 2022 @07:09PM (#31199372)
This is untrue of babies and small children, which are more common on flights than pets.
Re:Pet Airways by blooalien on Thursday April 28, 2022 @08:48PM (#31200063)
Hell, it's honestly untrue of entirely too many adult humans these days, too. Humans have just become plain unpredictable in general (unless you predict "crazy"). :(
Re:Pet Airways by lijogdfljk on Thursday April 28, 2022 @07:33PM (#31199545)
Heh, the last flight to florida i was on someone had urinated on the seat.

if only.

Re:Pet Airways by silisili on Thursday April 28, 2022 @06:26PM (#31198997)
Same. I love dogs. I don't want to share an airplane with them, sorry.

I once made the mistake of staying in a 'pet friendly' section of a hotel. The smell alone was enough to make me check for that next time.

Re:Pet Airways by Sebb767 on Thursday April 28, 2022 @07:16PM (#31199422)
Thirded. It also depends quite a bit on the pet itself. Most dogs are very cute and well behaved, but some are quite loud and then there are some people with completely spoiled and possibly aggressive dogs, who are then put under stress in an enclosed space with a lot of other animals (prey and rivals alike). Combined with an owner who is unable or unwilling to control them, this is a recipe for disaster. Sure, there are not too many of those, but it only takes one to ruin a lot of days at once.
Re:Pet Airways by smeej on Thursday April 28, 2022 @07:42PM (#31199610)
And the people who own that last kind of pet are the least likely to believe anyone sane could ever find their pet annoying.
Re:Pet Airways by Johnny555 on Thursday April 28, 2022 @08:20PM (#31199872)
I've never seen a hotel with a "pet friendly" section, usually hotels that allow pets allow them pretty much anywhere.
Re:Pet Airways by silisili on Thursday April 28, 2022 @08:39PM (#31200002)
IIRC, the first floor was pet friendly, the other floors were not.
Re:Pet Airways by wcarss on Thursday April 28, 2022 @06:25PM (#31198990)
They could offer just a few "pet flights", with different livery, and interiors for easier cleaning, and a premium on the tickets for the pet owner and pet seats -- then also a discount for the excess no-pet travelers who explicitly opt into filling out a pet flight.

It might be a terrible idea, but I've both heard and had worse!

Re:Pet Airways by slillibri on Thursday April 28, 2022 @06:39PM (#31199120)
I doubt there is enough demand for them to invest the hundreds of millions per aircraft to provide this service. In addition, each of the routes they would be able to provide would remove gates for other, more profitable flights. Another factor would be turnaround, i.e. cleaning and resetting a ‘pet-friendly’ flight would probably take longer then a regular flight, increasing the at-gate time and thus reducing the number of flights that could use that gate.
Re:Pet Airways by netr0ute on Thursday April 28, 2022 @07:03PM (#31199322)
> I doubt there is enough demand for them to invest the hundreds of millions per aircraft to provide this service.

Hooters tried something similar but arguably more niche back in the 2000s.

Re:Pet Airways by nagisa on Thursday April 28, 2022 @06:29PM (#31199026)
There are also many people who would prefer to not sit next to a human that may droll, vomit, start screaming or otherwise act unpredictably when stressed on a flight.

None of that is unreasonable… is it? That's why I don't fly with my dog (in large part out of concern of their well-being), but maybe airlines should also consider not allowing toddlers on the plane if these things are the concern?

Re:Pet Airways by thedailymail on Thursday April 28, 2022 @07:16PM (#31199418)
I was a frequent air traveler for around 15 years and would sometimes fantasize about an airline or subsidiary that catered only to human people with, say, 500,000 miles in experience as passengers. No kids, no pets, no rookies. But I am even happier now with my unplanned alternative – no air travel at for 2+ years.
Re:Pet Airways by boopmaster on Thursday April 28, 2022 @06:35PM (#31199085)
Oh, wow... was really not expecting "toddlers". Those descriptions of otherwise unpredictably acting humans is not restricted to merely the toddler aged humans.
Re:Pet Airways by tshaddox on Thursday April 28, 2022 @07:22PM (#31199462)
Very young humans visibly in prolonged intense agony probably shouldn't have been brought onto the plane either.
Re:Pet Airways by Angostura on Thursday April 28, 2022 @07:29PM (#31199518)
Generally it's frowned upon to put your toddler in a kennel for a week.
Re:Pet Airways by gumby on Thursday April 28, 2022 @07:22PM (#31199456)
Toddlers should be fine as long as they qualify for free cocktails.
Re:Pet Airways by Fezzik on Thursday April 28, 2022 @07:31PM (#31199526)
FWIW it’s worth (not much, obviously) I’m allergic to cats but I would much rather sit next to someone with a cat on an airplane than the absolutely noxious scents so many people insist in dousing themselves in before flying. The headaches from the latter are excruciating.
Re:Pet Airways by robbrown451 on Thursday April 28, 2022 @06:37PM (#31199093)
What if the back of the plane is pets ok and the front of the plane is for people who don't want to be near them?

Where I live people bring the dogs into the grocery store (carrying them, putting them in the cart, or just walking on a leash.... and no, they aren't all service dogs) and I've never seen a problem.

Personally I think you should be able to get a special collar or jacket for them that says they have passed a test that they are well enough trained for such things etc.

Re:Pet Airways by sophacles on Thursday April 28, 2022 @06:46PM (#31199172)
> Personally I think you should be able to get a special collar or jacket for them that says they have passed a test that they are well enough trained for such things etc.

I agree with your overall point - but I doubt this would be effective. Supposedly we already have such a system for service animals, but there's been enough shenanigans around that to make me cautious of this specific plan.

Re:Pet Airways by robbrown451 on Thursday April 28, 2022 @08:30PM (#31199941)
Well it's better than nothing. But as I said, where I live (San Francisco) people bring dogs in stores all the time, and I never see problems. Presumably most of them realize that if their pet is going to poop on the floor or bark or snap at people, they just don't bring them in.

What are the shenanigans you are aware of with service dogs? Badly behaved dogs, or just people that lie about why they need a dog? My suggested plan would make such lying unnecessary since all you need to do is prove the dog can pass a behavior test, it has nothing to do with whether you supposedly need the emotional support animal. (and of course, this doesn't give anyone the right to bring the dog in a store or in a plane or whatever, unless the business wants to allow it)

Re:Pet Airways by kelnos on Friday April 29, 2022 @03:10AM (#31202266)
> What are the shenanigans you are aware of with service dogs? Badly behaved dogs, or just people that lie about why they need a dog?

The problem with "service" dogs is that you can buy a vest on Amazon for $25[0] without that dog having been trained to do anything in particular. Many people (in San Francisco especially; I'm surprised you haven't seen this) just put these on their dog and claim that they can bring the dog into restaurants (where non-service animals are specifically banned by health code).

The whole "emotional support animal" thing has been abused like crazy by people who just feel entitled to bring their pet anywhere they want, regardless of the law, or even just the policy of a particular establishment. Generally it's fairly legally perilous for a business owner to attempt to ascertain if the animal is really a service animal that's been properly trained to do tasks for their human, so they often feel stuck and unable to turn them away.

I like (most) dogs just fine, but I don't want to be seated indoors in a restaurant one table over from one, even if they're well-behaved. I'm fairly allergic to some breeds, and I don't want to spend my meal with itchy eyes and a stuffy nose. And I certainly don't want random pets walking around grocery stores, sniffing the produce and shedding hair on everything. Actual service animals are trained to handle those situations properly and not be a nuisance, but your random pet or "emotional support animal" is not.

[0] https://smile.amazon.com/Service-Vest-Hook-Straps-Handle/dp/... for example

Re:Pet Airways by robbrown451 on Friday April 29, 2022 @03:37AM (#31202440)
Oh I've seen people with service dog vests, but don't have any knowledge of whether they are "real".

But see, I don't care if the person really needs a service dog. Some are for "emotional support", and while I think that is a bit silly, whatever.

What I'm concerned about is badly behaved dogs. I haven't seen that inside stores or restaurants.

I really don't care about whether they are sniffing produce or whatever (not they they seem to do that), if I'm going to get sick from something in a store, most likely it is from a human, since humans tend to host human-infecting germs.

Have you actually ever gotten allergies from a pet in a restaurant? I have cat allergies, but they tend to kick in when I am in someone's home where a cat lives.

Re:Pet Airways by 8note on Thursday April 28, 2022 @07:35PM (#31199556)
Does that fix my allergies to them? Or am I allowed to cover to dog owner in snot in exchange?
Re:Pet Airways by robbrown451 on Thursday April 28, 2022 @08:22PM (#31199883)
I think if pets are only in one part of the plane it should not be a problem. Planes filter the air more than just about any other environment. I have pretty severe cat allergies and don't think it would be a problem for me unless it is in the same row.
Re:Pet Airways by kelnos on Friday April 29, 2022 @03:16AM (#31202302)
I've been on a plane with a dog three or four rows behind me, and was stuffy and sneezing for most of the flight. And my allergies aren't even that severe. Sure, maybe it would have been fine had the dog been 10 rows back, but maybe not, and maybe not for someone with more severe allergies.

Then again, sometimes we just have to suck it up and deal with it, and hope the airline staff can do what they can to separate the animals from the people with allergies as much as possible. While there are certainly some people who bizarrely can't go anywhere without their pet (and I personally don't care if we don't make accommodations for them), but people do legitimately need to travel with their pet sometimes, and we need safe ways to do that. We have two cats, and if we were to move to somewhere far enough away that driving were infeasible, I would want to travel with them in-cabin.

Re:Pet Airways by armchairhacker on Thursday April 28, 2022 @06:25PM (#31198984)
There's an easy solution to this: pet-friendly and pet-unfriendly airlines. The prices shouldn't be much different, because there are benefits to both being allowed to bring your pet and not being around pets, and in most cases the experience is nearly the same. If they are, the pet-friendly airline would be the more expensive one.
Re:Pet Airways by lotsofpulp on Thursday April 28, 2022 @06:31PM (#31199043)
And then everyone claims their animal is a service animal so they do not have to pay extra to go on the pet friendly airline per ADA, and we are back to square one.

edit: sorry, I meant claiming their dog is a service animal, not any animal

Re:Pet Airways by scott_w on Thursday April 28, 2022 @06:41PM (#31199142)
That’s not how that works. You don’t just “declare” they’re a service animal and all is well. In fact, even real service animals often have issues in spite of the laws supposedly ensuring their access.
Re:Pet Airways by xyzzyz on Thursday April 28, 2022 @07:03PM (#31199316)
That’s exactly how it works. People do just in fact declare their animals to be “service”, and because of how disability accommodation laws work, you cannot do anything about it.
Re:Pet Airways by lotsofpulp on Thursday April 28, 2022 @06:59PM (#31199280)
Sorry, I meant claiming any dog is a service animal.

Per this website:

https://www.transportation.gov/individuals/aviation-consumer...

And this one:

https://beta.ada.gov/topics/service-animals/

It seems like there is nothing stopping someone from claiming their dog is a service animal.

The DOT website says airlines can ask service animal owners to fill out a couple self attestation forms, and while that puts a little bit of skin in the game for the service animal owner, it does not seem easy to prove fraud.

Re:Pet Airways by xeromal on Thursday April 28, 2022 @10:29PM (#31200717)
Come out to LA and you'll see "emotional support" dogs/animals that are definitely not trained pooping all over and eating produce in the grocery stores. All it takes is a 100$ and signing a paper and they get the little slip and vest.
Re:Pet Airways by dwighttk on Thursday April 28, 2022 @06:59PM (#31199284)
>You don’t just “declare” they’re a service animal and all is well.

https://www.cbsnews.com/news/united-airlines-changes-policy-...

the peacock didn't get to fly, but before they changed their policy it was $125 for a pet or $0 for a comfort animal, and they hadn't been checking if the animal was vaccinated, obedient, or that there was any medical reason for the person to have the animal (so it seems like you could just declare your pet to be a comfort animal and save $125)

Re:Pet Airways by rockemsockem on Thursday April 28, 2022 @06:43PM (#31199154)
No one is making their animal a service animal to save money. They're doing it to avoid putting their animal under the plane. The "saving money by making your dog an ESA or service animal" was just airline propaganda.
Re:Pet Airways by lotsofpulp on Thursday April 28, 2022 @07:02PM (#31199315)
People do it at hotels everyday. All you have to do is say your dog is a service animal and make up a task that it does for you.
Re:Pet Airways by spaetzleesser on Thursday April 28, 2022 @07:20PM (#31199439)
Getting the service animal status is quite difficult. There used to be a category “support animal” but that has been pretty much scrapped.
Re:Pet Airways by kube-system on Thursday April 28, 2022 @07:31PM (#31199529)
I think there could be negative feedback loop here.

If there’s enough demand to justify the change, then it’s going to turn into a barn yard atmosphere when you’re the only airline that does this and every flight has 20 untrained dogs on board.

If there’s not that much demand, then what do you have to gain by risking the loss of profitable business fliers for some occasional pet flyers?

People want to take their pets with them, but will they foot the bill for that cabin space and put up with everyone else’s pet, and do it in large enough numbers to fill planes?

Re:Pet Airways by pontus on Thursday April 28, 2022 @07:41PM (#31199602)
I used to have a dog and got this feedback from people quite often.

As far as I understand, pet allergies are not like peanut allergies in that they're not actually lethal (correct me if I'm wrong!) As such, I feel like it's just one of those things that people might just need to deal with when they're part of a shared space much like sitting next to someone with bad body oder, someone chewing loudly, or someone laughing out loud when they're watching their tv. If it's too much of an annoyance maybe one can try to get moved to a different seat?

Re:Pet Airways by Merad on Thursday April 28, 2022 @07:51PM (#31199671)
I mean no offense, but this is insane. I have a cat that I love like it's my child, so I sympathize with where you're coming from, but come on. You're basically saying that people with legitimate medical conditions caused by your pet's presence should just suck it up because at least they aren't going to die. All so you can travel with your pet. Talk about a lack of empathy...
Re:Pet Airways by pontus on Monday May 02, 2022 @09:25PM (#31243239)
No, that's not at all what I'm saying. I'm saying that if someone seated next to me is allergic to my pet (or for whatever reason doesn't want to sit next to it), then they could relocate either me or that person so that we're sufficiently far apart not to cause any issues.

The argument presented to me in the past (and also the argument in comment I was replying to) is that since some people are allergic to pets or otherwise dislike them, we should completely disallow traveling with pets in a blanket fashion. I'm simply saying that I think that's too extreme and that a middle ground can be found.

If we're going to completely ban pets on airplanes, then we should consider also banning flying with a cold because of immunocompromised people (in fact this is perhaps more warranted given the severity of the situation).

Re:Pet Airways by bscphil on Friday April 29, 2022 @03:47AM (#31202497)
> it's just one of those things that people might just need to deal with when they're part of a shared space much like sitting next to someone with bad body oder, someone chewing loudly, or someone laughing out loud when they're watching their tv

These are things we accept with extreme annoyance, because the alternative is creating a scene or having to deal with the sort of person who's already shown themselves willing to act with disregard for others. It's not something we treat as normal and right behavior that the victim just needs to "get over". Surely you've encountered someone playing loud music on public transportation or something similar; just because no one says anything doesn't mean that we all think it's okay.

Re:Pet Airways by rush340 on Thursday April 28, 2022 @08:20PM (#31199866)
Who cares if the allergies are lethal or not? They'll cause the person to be miserable for days, possibly cause hives, possibly cause an asthma attack. That's not comparable to sitting next to someone who's annoying/smelly.
Re:Pet Airways by kelnos on Friday April 29, 2022 @03:20AM (#31202329)
My allergies aren't too bad, but they are still worlds worse than sitting next to someone who smells bad.

I have two cats and love them to death, but if I were to fly with them, I would volunteer to move to a different seat if I found out I was seated near someone with bad allergies.

Re:Pet Airways by ldiracdelta on Thursday April 28, 2022 @06:39PM (#31199114)
If you think a crying baby is a bummer on a flight, try a crying dog. Just happened to me on my last flight.
Re:Pet Airways by amelius on Thursday April 28, 2022 @07:08PM (#31199365)
I completely support making flights less comfortable. Less flying means less pollution. Bring in the pets! And let's remove the chairs while we're at it.
Re:Pet Airways by ajmurmann on Thursday April 28, 2022 @07:38PM (#31199579)
While the cases you lay out are valid, cats and dogs are already allowed on flights. They must fit into a cannel that fits under the seat though. If I recall correctly you can take the dog on your lap once in the air as well (might misremember this part. It's been a long time sober I've done this). Still would be a problem for anyone who struggles with allergies.
Re:Pet Airways by remuskaos on Thursday April 28, 2022 @06:25PM (#31198989)
Surely, these people would still have the option not to book a flight with PetFriendlyAirways.
Re:Pet Airways by jen20 on Thursday April 28, 2022 @06:24PM (#31198972)
> Some people would simply prefer not to sit next to an animal that may drool, shed, bark or otherwise act unpredictably when stressed on a flight.

Can we at least apply this same standard to the other human passengers on a flight then?