edit: sorry, I meant claiming their dog is a service animal, not any animal
Per this website:
https://www.transportation.gov/individuals/aviation-consumer...
And this one:
https://beta.ada.gov/topics/service-animals/
It seems like there is nothing stopping someone from claiming their dog is a service animal.
The DOT website says airlines can ask service animal owners to fill out a couple self attestation forms, and while that puts a little bit of skin in the game for the service animal owner, it does not seem easy to prove fraud.
https://www.cbsnews.com/news/united-airlines-changes-policy-...
the peacock didn't get to fly, but before they changed their policy it was $125 for a pet or $0 for a comfort animal, and they hadn't been checking if the animal was vaccinated, obedient, or that there was any medical reason for the person to have the animal (so it seems like you could just declare your pet to be a comfort animal and save $125)
If there’s enough demand to justify the change, then it’s going to turn into a barn yard atmosphere when you’re the only airline that does this and every flight has 20 untrained dogs on board.
If there’s not that much demand, then what do you have to gain by risking the loss of profitable business fliers for some occasional pet flyers?
People want to take their pets with them, but will they foot the bill for that cabin space and put up with everyone else’s pet, and do it in large enough numbers to fill planes?