I knew of certain defunct malls that decided to get rid of things that doesn't make money and only keep the high profit inventories.
Soon people stopped coming and they went under..
It's a bit harder for me to see this as an acceptable approach to health care. Not every segment of the economy needs to be a constant drunkard's walk in search of maximum profitability in the aggregate. Sometimes what the public actually desires is stability and reliability.
I had a friend who ran an unprofitable arcade for some time. His trash was nothing but food and drinks from other local businesses, particularly piles of bubble tea cups from a place across the street. It seemed rather likely it was worth paying him a bit to stay there.
Businesses exist to give us what we want. Those that do it well are profitable, those that don’t aren’t.
Keep in mind that the effort spent to make healthcare more stable could have instead been used to provide more healthcare overall. Or something else entirely, like shoes or haircuts.
All services are not as good as they could be, because the effort beyond “good enough” gets shifted to some other more valuable purpose, where things are not good enough yet.
Given that the USA pays higher-than-average prices for poorer-than-average outcomes, I'd say this is a spurious hypothetical, mostly useful for helping to demarcate the point where economics ceases to be an empirical, scientific pursuit and instead becomes a sort of low-rigor offshoot of moral philosophy.
But, back in the realm of epiricism, we know that this is one of those situations where closer government regulation can produce higher quality of service at lower cost, because the rest of the developed world has figured out multiple successful formulae for doing so. The only clear downside, if you can call it that, is that their hospital administrators don't seem to have quite such large collections of luxury watches.
Most people realize that a business will only change if a significant portion of buyers change their spending habits, and individually choosing to not support a business out of ethical concerns only hurts themselves.
Then there ends up being a lot of people who buy products from businesses they hate, and would support collective action against those businesses, like passing laws.
People like that aren't dumb, they are just trying to work around how their next best option is so much worse than buying the original product.
> Soon people stopped coming
Ah, yes. Why didn't we think of this before? By increasing the cost of (geriatric) healthcare, we can destroy demand. That's how supply/demand curves work right? In this way the invisible hand delivers unto us a fountain of youth ;)
But why? Are elderly clients underserved in that area? Are they going to ditch their original care provider and all come here?
Old people in the USA are EXTREMELY wealthy in terms of healthcare purchasing power. All retired people have medicare. Many retired people have additional healthcare coverage from their former employers (doesn't exist anymore -- disappeared along with pensions -- but this benefit used to be common). Many retired people have significant savings in addition to medicare and private health insurance.
Most new parents have little to no government assistance, do not have significant expendable income, and have little to no accumulated wealth. Children, of course, are even poorer than their deadbeat parents.
Or by cutting the cost.
The first, mentioned already in this thread, is that maximizing profits should not be the ultimate yardstick in all cases.
The second is that we are not setting incentives correctly in healthcare: preventative care still plays second fiddle to curative care. If the healthcare industry were purely free market, this could be attributed to individuals not understanding the long-term benefits of preventative care, or overly discounting the distant future. But the healthcare system is not purely free market. The largest payers, public and private, could do a lot to correct the incentives by setting their reimbursements accordingly.
https://www.nbcnews.com/health/health-care/private-equity-fi...
I hate every part of it.
The WWII generation fixed the ozone hole, but their kids didn’t lift a finger for global warming.
Subsequent generations are scrambling to pick up the pieces for our kids, while crap like this, and our rapidly collapsing democracy keep sabotaging our efforts. Heck, in California, we’re actively causing psychological harm to an entire generation of kids (with masks) because of a tiny minority of anti-vaxxer school teachers.
Of course, progressive boomers exist, as do idiotic younger people. However, the current generation of leadership in the US has completely failed us.
Anyway, it’s not surprising to me that that crowd decided to shunt healthcare resources away from their (great) grandkids and into elder care.
It's really crazy that the only way it seems like we can get these senators/congresspeople out of office is death from old age.
The fact is, your mind DOES deteriorate when you get older. That's why so many phone scams are special built to target older people.
A change I'd make to the constitution is that "nobody over the age of 70 can hold a governmental position".
They won't live long enough to have to deal with their consequences of their actions, and they clearly don't care if they burn the planet down before their kids inherit it.
I think this translates to an age limit of 65-75.
More importantly, I think this should be applied to voters as well.
I agree, someone with a compromised ability to evaluate risk is probably more than capable at doing most desk jobs. However, the last thing we need is politicians who's aging brains have been compromised in evaluating future risks. Putting someone most likely to send scammers gift cards in charge of foreign policy and assessing climate change risks is simply a recipe for disaster.
It doesn't seem all that crazy to demand that the ~300 people running the US not be at an age where mental decline is common.
[1] https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/why-older-adults-... [2] https://neurosciencenews.com/ventromedial-prefrontal-cortex-...
Here are some problems that _don't_ prevent people of any age from becoming a congressman or woman:
- Alcohol abuse
- Narcissism and/or sociopathy
- High debt
- Cult membership
- Most importantly: Personal financial interest in specific policy changes
Why not start with these? Banning elderly because they on average tend to be more gullible seems like a weird way of addressing governmental issues.
On a different level, I find the idea of banning people from governmental positions based on a specific trait deeply undemocratic, and a slippery slope. Principiis obsta.
We DO!
Testosterone production peaks at 18/19.
The minimum age for Congress is 25, for the Senate 30, and for the president 35.
> Why not start with these?
This is a false dilemma.
I've said we would limit age, I did not say there shouldn't be other limits or that it was the most important limit.
oh man, I choose to laugh so I don't start crying hahaha.
I want to turn this into an argument of why age-reversal and other longevity research is such a bad idea (personally, I think it's kind of evil; but maybe I've seen too many villanous cartoon characters throwing everything under the bus so the can live forever).
There's also the fact that science might lock up, since old scientists have more reputation at stake in the old theories (there's an adage "science advances one funeral at a time"). We're not ready as a species for immortality
"X advances one funeral at a time".
Let's not pretend these are comparable challenges.
> our rapidly collapsing democracy keep sabotaging our efforts.
When people say stuff like this, are they being hyperbolic or do they actually mean it? How long is the democratic tradition in the US that is collapsing?
This isn't some outlier event either, democracy has been receding around the world for years. I really, really hope the trend reverses itself, but am scared at how real the threat is.
> democracy has been receding around the world for years
I am skeptical. Majoritarian democracy in the US has only really existed for 40-50 years and I perceive it as continuing to expand both here and abroad.
If enough states had sent contested election results (eg a county or state’s election board is tied in approval or does not approve the results because of one die-hard) then the matter would have gone to the house of reps.
How many of those reps voted not to certify the election results? Now, in the event of contested state results, each state in the house of reps would get one vote. There’s more red states than blue states…how many unscrupulous representatives, who already voted not to certify the results, would it have taken to grant Trump the election?
For what it’s worth, many of the key states in the election had narrowly certified election results. In some cases it came down to a single individual who could have flipped the other way, and the results would have been contested.
You do not realize what a narrow path democracy treads. The anti-democratic forces do understand this, and the last few years have been empowering to them.
And that’s an easy scenario that doesn’t even take into account the very real possibility of political violence - don’t forget that people showed up to the US capitol with weapons and tools for kidnapping.
Honestly I find your take to be either naivety, denial, or willfully obscuring the truth to promote anti-democratic goals.
https://talkingpointsmemo.com/news/j-michael-luttig-op-ed-ja...
Not only that, but global warming was an already known problem at the time CFCs and ozone were being solved.
Campaign finance restrictions.
Referenda that can't be overriden by legislature should require 50% of eligible voter population to support, not 50% of voters in that particular election.
No special elections.
What about things like AirBnB? Limiting those is a form of NIMBYism as is limiting where factories and polluting buildings can be placed and/ran.
that is the whole point of owning land and being a member of a community
If it's entire purpose was to provide pediatric healthcare it should probably have registered itself as a not-for-profit.
If your purpose isn't to return a profit to stakeholders, but to serve some social purpose eligible for charity nonprofit status plus like “pediatric healthcare”, registering as a nonprofit gives you more surplus revenue because of tax exemption and the ability to accept donations that are tax deductible for the donors.
It’s also often good PR.
- SNAP / EBT / Foodstamps for people making so little money. Add onto that, Food banks.
- Farm subsidies for many cheap foodstuffs (Corn) causing massive cheap, albeit junk food that can sustain.
- I can literally grow food in the ground for "free", put it in mason jars and save my food for a year. I can't open a fresh can of broken-arm at the fixed cost.
- Food is fungible, if I'm hungry, I can wait 2, 3, 8+ hours to eat, or have a quick snack until meal time. It's not like I need a Big Mac infusion in the next 10 seconds or else I'll die from lack of special sauce.
- You have many options of food. You can eat Soylent, rice&beans, or steak for every meal at various price points. You don't really get an ala carte when it comes to Chemotherapy.
- You can always eat monkey pellets [1]
[1] https://www.reddit.com/r/moreplatesmoredates/comments/qbfkfl...
This is true only in an extremely pedantic, unrealistic kinda way. If it was easy/free everyone would be growing all their own food.
Within 5 miles, I have at least 10 different grocery stores to shop at. Each will carry hundreds of products at less than $10 each. Not only do I have tons of choices, but the pricing is completely transparent. And that's just grocery stores. Add restaurants (Both sit-down restaurants and fast food), and that number quickly reaches over 100 within a 5-mile radius.
If I'm in a medical emergency and someone dials 911, I'm likely just being brought to the nearest hospital. I have zero choice in the matter, and will come out with whatever bill they want to charge me.
Even in non-emergencies, good luck shopping on price. Doctor offices don't like giving that out.
There's competition in the food market, but not healthcare.
Where ad hominem is a hallmark of good faith discussion.
> Within 5 miles, I have at least 10 different grocery stores to shop at. Each will carry hundreds of products at less than $10 each. Not only do I have tons of choices, but the pricing is completely transparent. And that's just grocery stores. Add restaurants (Both sit-down restaurants and fast food), and that number quickly reaches over 100 within a 5-mile radius.
This makes sense if you're aware of the fact that each human being eats three meals per day.
> If I'm in a medical emergency and someone dials 911, I'm likely just being brought to the nearest hospital. I have zero choice in the matter, and will come out with whatever bill they want to charge me. Even in non-emergencies, good luck shopping on price. Doctor offices don't like giving that out.
I clearly conceded the point that you can't exit the healthcare market.
> There's competition in the food market, but not healthcare.
Are you under the impression that I disagree with this statement? Consider reading (and, ideally, understanding) the thread in which you are participating prior to commenting.
I challenge you to find the price of a cancer treatment regime protocol in the United States. I will bet you any amount of money you care to wager that no US provider exists anywhere that will give you a price quote for lung cancer treatment in writing anytime before that treatment is provided.
And even IF you could, that only covers the cases where you are still have enough health and mind to rationally evaluate the prices. If you've been in a car accident and are dragged unconscious and bleeding into the ER, you can't shop around, even if they DID give you a price, which they certainly won't until you're already treated.
With respect to ER care, it does seem impossible to 'shop around', but these cases make up a minority of healthcare expenditures. Perhaps government should cover these cases (though this could have horrible incentive problems), or this type of insurance should be separated from the rest, and somehow priced clearly and in advance (according to level of care) by a cartel arrangement or state regulated rates.
I hear this argument, but I don't buy it. What's the incentive exactly?
That people will hurt themselves, so they can go to the ER for free? That's nonsense. Nobody wants to get hurt, nobody wants to get sick, getting hurt or getting sick is not a good. The fact that they don't have to pay to "get hurt" isn't an incentive. Perhaps a few people feel this way and are insane, but those people probably need to get help at government expense either way, before the government ends up paying for them to be in prison or institutionalized anyway.
Believe it or not, it would be way easier politically to implement Medicare For All than to do piecemeal reforms.
Ahem. Regulatory capture would like a word.
The industry is an onion and in order to understand why it is the way it is today you need to peel back all of the layers that have been added by the govt over time and the unintended consequences of those.
[1] https://www.npr.org/2020/10/07/921287295/history-of-employer...
Free markets are the most efficient way for information to be transferred throughout the system.
Stricter campaign finance laws, ending revolving-door politics, etc.
But putting the blame on free markets seems like a mistake.
You can't on the one hand tout the "free market", while on the other complain that we don't have the "right" kind of governmental interference.
Even if you could square that circle, it still sounds disingenuous to argue that we could have the most efficient system if only we were to eliminate _thing that said system actively encourages_. The failure is baked into the game, my friend.
I don’t take such a libertarian view myself, by the way. Just pointing out that I don’t think you can pick apart the argument of the person you replied to in that way.
I'd sign up for a significant increase in my taxes if the US system were replaced by the system that I experienced in Belgium for the first 30 years of my life.
And by successfully, I mean: everybody, irrespective of income or status, can expect to get the care they need.
If it was as easy as paying out way out of the problem we'd have done it already.
Nobody is claiming that the US should copy the system of some specific country verbatim. But it's equally dumb to dismiss the common traits of these other systems, and say "nah, let's do just the opposite."
Well you literally said "I'd sign up for a significant increase in my taxes if the US system were replaced by the system that I experienced in Belgium for the first 30 years of my life" so why don't you tell me how that was supposed to be interpreted?
America shares a very long border with a nation with a functional healthcare system and we generally prefer to compare to them.
What all those systems have in common is that they are a mix of free market and strong regulation. The opposite of "let's do even more free market than what we have now."
I don't know how the US can get there. It's probably impossible, just like school shootings and the "No Way To Prevent This,' Says Only Nation Where This Regularly Happens" argument.
Markets exist by virtue of laws created by governments - property law being the primary example - expecting actors in a free market who aggregate enough wealth to affect those governments not to just strikes me as unrealistic. It reminds me a bit of gaming. Everyone agrees that in a competitive game the most fun part is early on before a 'meta' can be established. But of course that meta will always end up established and it's basically dumb to be mad at people for metagaming or to otherwise expect them not to.
Would such a market allow NDAs?
What do you think of VC-funded "growth" companies that lose money for years while providing products/services at below cost? Is this a case of the free market working or of it being subverted?
Can I hire my friend who is a medical student to perform surgery on me legally? No?
I think it can, I've been thinking about this and it's "scam".
Like, think how often everything in our country is a straight up scam. Healthcare, parking tickets, basically anything you buy. It's almost all snake-oil flim-flam every which way and as a 'consumer' you have to wade through the mire every single day to get scammed as little as possible.
You have to be more precise as there are clearly aspects of capitalism that have resulted in tremendous improvements in quality of life (look at North Korea vs. South Korea).
Regulatory capture is one of the issues & revolving door politics. Especially a big problem in the healthcare & finance industries (the current head of the SEC spent his career at Goldman Sachs for ex.)
Whoever gave you that idea, you should stop listening to them.
Medicare payments are subject to a medicare fee schedule, which is typically much lower than a traditional private enterprise's fee schedule. What that means is medicare gets billed a lot less than a regular patient with insurance.
https://www.kff.org/medicare/issue-brief/how-much-more-than-...
"Private insurers paid nearly double Medicare rates for all hospital services (199% of Medicare rates, on average), ranging from 141% to 259% of Medicare rates across the reviewed studies."
"The difference between private and Medicare rates was greater for outpatient than inpatient hospital services, which averaged 264% and 189% of Medicare rates overall, respectively."
"For physician services, private insurance paid 143% of Medicare rates, on average, ranging from 118% to 179% of Medicare rates across studies."The magnitude of "standard" and "low" are both demonstrated by the fact that when private insurers negotiate pricing contracts (basically, a one-off fee schedule) with hospital groups, they express prices in terms of "medicare multiples".
For example, the insurer will pay up to 13x of what Medicare pays for an fMRI administered under non-emergent circumstances with medically-justifiable cause. Pretty much every multiple is >1x, many are far more than 10x.
And medicare is arguably more expensive to provide, since the probability of confounding issues from disability or age is higher than in the general insured population.
Medicare is very consistent with paying, especially in comparison to private insurance, but the a la carte fees are quite "low" by relatively-freer-market definitions (I say relatively, because the reality is that private insurers negotiating with hospital groups is the antithesis of a free market, in most conceivable dimensions).
---
The main reason medical groups lobby against "medicare for all" is that they will lose lucrative "20xM" payouts from private insurers, and it's difficult to see how their ballooning administrative costs can survive on such a lean diet.
Of course, this line of thinking is deliberately ignorant of the thought that medicare fee schedules can be renegotiated to reflect the population of patients "medicare for all" would incorporate. But nobody's interested in thinking two turns ahead, let alone advancing the game state, when their pockets are nicely-lined on turn zero.
So, private insurers aren't charities that aim to support 'lucrative' payouts either. The often-huge gulf between MC and private (as you said) means that costs would have to drop massively if we did MC4A. Who's going to tell hospitals/admins, and more importantly, doctors and nurses that they have to take a 30%+ paycut?
There are three acts in care. Act 1, you receive treatment and the hospital pays the nurses, doctors, and capital equipment. Act 2, the admin submits a claim and receives a quote from the insurer. Act 3, the insurer pays the admin.
One of the reasons why a certain treatment plan is negotiated at 20x Medicare is that, 50% of the time, the private insurer rejects the claim (correctly or incorrectly), and the hospital group needs to maintain payroll for an admin whose entire job is to contest the rejection and win the ultimately agreed-upon rate.
As you might guess, a large but difficult-to-quantify proportion of the quoted cost is this song and dance in Act 2. In Medicare, the distribution of Act 2's length is more predictable and smaller.
Nobody addresses this elephant in the room, because it makes private insurers and hospital groups look bad, but it's where a lot of ballooning "costs" can be explained away.
Basically, the "expected value" of a private insurance payout is usually not too different from the "expected value" of a medicare payout.
The sticker price of a private insurance payout is very high. The accounting department of providers love the sticker price, because they can carry them forward as payable liabilities, but a large proportion of private insurer payouts and patient deductibles are never realized. Stark contrast to medicare.
They go with Medicare because the pay-out rate (i.e. "collect-ability") for billable services is much higher--and much more predictable--than if they attempted to collect/negotiate with non-governmental providers. A LOT of money is lost by hospital systems due to unpaid patient responsibility (e.g. insurance deductibles), which they can minimize by offering only services already guaranteed to be covered by Medicare.
Whoever implanted this idea into your head was lying to you and you should probably question the other claims that person or organization has said.
Sometimes, it feels like we’re min-maxing ourselves to death over here.