I agree, someone with a compromised ability to evaluate risk is probably more than capable at doing most desk jobs. However, the last thing we need is politicians who's aging brains have been compromised in evaluating future risks. Putting someone most likely to send scammers gift cards in charge of foreign policy and assessing climate change risks is simply a recipe for disaster.
It doesn't seem all that crazy to demand that the ~300 people running the US not be at an age where mental decline is common.
[1] https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/why-older-adults-... [2] https://neurosciencenews.com/ventromedial-prefrontal-cortex-...
Here are some problems that _don't_ prevent people of any age from becoming a congressman or woman:
- Alcohol abuse
- Narcissism and/or sociopathy
- High debt
- Cult membership
- Most importantly: Personal financial interest in specific policy changes
Why not start with these? Banning elderly because they on average tend to be more gullible seems like a weird way of addressing governmental issues.
On a different level, I find the idea of banning people from governmental positions based on a specific trait deeply undemocratic, and a slippery slope. Principiis obsta.
We DO!
Testosterone production peaks at 18/19.
The minimum age for Congress is 25, for the Senate 30, and for the president 35.
> Why not start with these?
This is a false dilemma.
I've said we would limit age, I did not say there shouldn't be other limits or that it was the most important limit.