News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Principles of Engineering Management by PragmaticPulp on Monday April 25, 2022 @11:52AM (#31156609)
I consumed a lot of blog posts like this before becoming a manager. It feels satisfying to read vague principles like this:

> Facilitate wellbeing

> Personal safety, dignity, and wellbeing of every team member are paramount. Team success is only success if team members feel good about it.

But then you become an actual manager and realize that these are largely just feel-good aphorisms that don't really help navigate the hard work of being a manager.

Don't get me wrong: I think "facilitate wellbeing" and similar tidbits are valid advice. Likewise, a manager who chooses to not facilitate wellbeing would clearly be in the wrong. But when you get into management you realize that the hard work isn't waking up and deciding to facilitate wellbeing. The hard work often involves making unpopular decisions, or telling someone "no" when their pet request wouldn't be in the best interests of the team, or defusing interpersonal conflict among two team members who have been feuding for months.

These feel-good blog posts seem rather vacuous after being in the trenches of management for several years. Again, not because the advice is bad or wrong, but because it's just a lot of text around the basics of being a decent human being. Learning how to do the hard things about management or how to make unpopular but necessary decisions is something that you won't learn from the average blog post or LinkedIn post, largely because these function more as personal branding pieces than actual advice.

In my experience, the best management advice comes from talking to the best managers you know personally. Online, the most practical management advice comes on smaller forums where people are either anonymous (and therefore less interested in personal brand building) or older and accomplished (and therefore not worried about blowback impacting their career). The type of feel-good blog posts or LinkedIn blurbs that people associate with their personal brand don't really add much value after you've read 5-10 articles saying the exact same aphorisms.

Re:Principles of Engineering Management by hintymad on Monday April 25, 2022 @12:43PM (#31157391)
Similar feeling. These principles somehow do not help me make decisions or build mechanisms for my teams. On the other hand, the principles in the book Turn the Ship Around, the book No Rules Rule, and Amazon's 14 leadership principles helped me a lot because they give clear guidelines on how to make trade-offs. In particular, Turn the Ship Around advocates pursuing excellence instead of minimizing errors. Netflix advocates Freedom and Responsibility. Amazon advocates working backwards (customer obsession) and making two-way door decisions. More importantly, they prescribe a system to balance trade-offs especially when there's conflicting choices. For instance, Turn the Ship Around explores how to make sure everyone delivers yet the leader can fully delegate responsibilities -- it's not surprising that it requires a system.
Re:Principles of Engineering Management by nickff on Monday April 25, 2022 @03:58PM (#31159754)
I was a bit skeptical of "Turn the Ship Around" because of its title, and despite all the positive reviews, but it's one of the best management books I've ever read. It's definitely worth a read, even if you're not a manager, as it applies to any team-related activity, and provides a useful toolkit for improving your team, whether you're the leader or not.
Re:Principles of Engineering Management by jackosdev on Monday April 25, 2022 @08:14PM (#31162512)
Jim Keller (helped design the spec for x86-64, was in management during Apple, AMD and Tesla's ultra successful periods) said when he was interested in management he just read like 100's of books on it, and turned out there was lots of really useful information that he applied and got great results from.
Re:Principles of Engineering Management by hintymad on Monday April 25, 2022 @04:50PM (#31160416)
Yeah, the book also passes Taleb's Skin in the Game test: the author is also the practitioner of what he wrote about.
Re:Principles of Engineering Management by kqr on Tuesday April 26, 2022 @12:08AM (#31163837)
Hm. That's a generous take. Marquet lived the experience once. Now he goes around and lectures people in it instead.

I have all respect for Marquet and I agree with most of the things he says about leadership, as well as try to apply it daily myself. But my best reading of Taleb is that the sort of thing Marquet does (potentially get lucky, extract oneself from the situation, and then live off of the one experience), that's the opposite of skin in the game.

Re:Principles of Engineering Management by disgruntledphd2 on Tuesday April 26, 2022 @04:52AM (#31165336)
To be fair, that's pretty true of Taleb himself.
Re:Principles of Engineering Management by kqr on Tuesday April 26, 2022 @12:01PM (#31169131)
Sure it is. But, and this is a subtle point, he does not go around telling people specifically how they ought to invest, or how they ought to insure against tail risk.

He tells people how he invests, and some theoretical consequences of tail risk depending on input parameters.

It's a small difference, but, from what I understand, a meaningful one to Taleb.

Re:Principles of Engineering Management by willturman on Monday April 25, 2022 @12:21PM (#31157020)
> Again, not because the advice is bad or wrong, but because it's just a lot of text around the basics of being a decent human being.

Judging by the trends observed in the Great Resignation [1] and the popularity of forums like /r/antiwork, it seems that the basics of being a decent human being are often being overlooked by management.

I took a very different interpretation of what facilitating wellbeing looks like than you - interpreting facilitating wellbeing as being flexible when team members need some time to navigate their personal lives, scheduling project timelines and scoping work to necessitate productive work while alleviating burn-out, providing space for people to discuss ideas or provide feedback in a team setting, allowing for growth or transition into roles they may find more interesting or rewarding. Facilitating wellbeing doesn't conflict with making necessary but perhaps unpopular decisions, or de-prioritizing a pet project or whatever - it's much more basic than that.

[1] https://www.shrm.org/resourcesandtools/hr-topics/talent-acqu...

Re:Principles of Engineering Management by marcinzm on Monday April 25, 2022 @12:39PM (#31157319)
>it seems that the basics of being a decent human being are often being overlooked by management.

People working in tech companies may not realize how un-decent a lot of other companies and their management are.

Re:Principles of Engineering Management by redisman on Monday April 25, 2022 @11:56PM (#31163786)
Tech is hardly a paragon of good management. I can count on two fingers the amount of skilled managers I’ve had in my 15 year career. Both got promoted out of line management very quickly because they were too good. Some have been truly terrible and abusive towards their team.
Re:Principles of Engineering Management by nuancebydefault on Tuesday April 26, 2022 @12:32AM (#31163949)
This!
Re:Principles of Engineering Management by pkaye on Monday April 25, 2022 @04:17PM (#31160001)
There are a lot of shitty employers and employees around and the rest are trying to avoid them by different means.
Re:Principles of Engineering Management by vasco on Monday April 25, 2022 @12:41PM (#31157368)
This right here is the juice. Generic management advice is like relationship advice. Be honest, care about the other person, respect the other person and so on. But anyone that's been in a relationship knows it's way more about breathing deep twice when you see the dishes not clean or whatever annoys you than the rest of it. Obviously you need to try and be honest, but good outcomes are created first and foremost from adequately dealing with daily situations in a balanced manner.

There's no playbook for being a good manager the same way there's no playbook for being a good partner or a good parent. The playbook would have to be too generic or too specific and end up being mostly useless.

Best you can get is someone who genuinely tries to improve and listens to you because they seem to care about you. If that takes the form of "how was your weekend" in the beginning of a 1-1 or having your back in a compensation review, that all depends on the situations.

Re:Principles of Engineering Management by TameAntelope on Monday April 25, 2022 @12:15PM (#31156938)
I think "facilitate wellbeing" is more than just a feel-good aphorism, because it really does help when there's a difficult decision on your desk, at least for me.

My instinct is to push hard, let "the most correct" idea win, and not really give a shit about how it impacts others. All, as you know, awful, very bad, no good ways of managing. Being reminded that one of my primary jobs is to "facilitate wellbeing" helps keep me grounded.

Let someone take the day off even if there's a deadline looming, be cool with a later start date than would be perfect, take that vacation week and really don't plug in, a) for yourself and b) to show that as acceptable behavior for your team to do as well.

None of this is how I, naturally, would behave, and I need to be reminded and continually work at doing things like that, for the sake of the health of my team. None of this is theoretical in my view, I see it as specific and practical advice.

Re:Principles of Engineering Management by hitekker on Monday April 25, 2022 @12:30PM (#31157176)
What you're speaking of is "Prioritize Wellbeing" which is a worthy belief to hold and to remind ourselves as engineering managers.

However, the specific word used by the OP is "Facilitate" which gives managers the leeway to be weak and lazy. A manager can say "I let my team take PTO a few days each quarter, I facilitated their well-being!" while they passively allow their stakeholders to dictate the workload of their engineers, with zero pushback. In practice, "Prioritize" basically means conflict and action, "facilitate" means whatever the manager wants it to mean.

Going further: most "principles" like the kind the OP wrote are designed for a manager's self-therapy. Beliefs that justify decisions the manager has already taken, dressed up in nice-looking words, the kind of drivel that influencers peddle on LinkedIn. Whereas real principles that the GP refers to are meant for self-discipline. Beliefs that call into question decisions, and force the manager to really think their next steps through carefully.

Re:Principles of Engineering Management by TameAntelope on Monday April 25, 2022 @02:03PM (#31158493)
I just don't see how you can read "facilitate wellbeing" and be this upset about it, especially given how you feel about "prioritize wellbeing".
Re:Principles of Engineering Management by JamesBarney on Monday April 25, 2022 @07:44PM (#31162311)
But for every manager like yourself who naturally over prioritizes correct ideas there is a manager who is over prioritizes harmony.
Re:Principles of Engineering Management by acjohnson55 on Monday April 25, 2022 @07:06PM (#31161998)
FWIW, what you wrote here is very similar to the situation I had and the mistakes I made that led to the lesson learned and that sentence being in the piece.
Re:Principles of Engineering Management by cjalmeida on Monday April 25, 2022 @12:26PM (#31157106)
You would be amazed at the number of managers that largely ignore the "feel-good" part of the job, or even contribute to the workplace being a crappy place to work.

Like the author said, actively improving the working environment when possible earns you "currency" and trust into making unpopular decisions easier to swallow.

Re:Principles of Engineering Management by acjohnson55 on Monday April 25, 2022 @07:02PM (#31161959)
Author here.

I think the lack of specificity is a fair criticism of what I wrote in the piece, but this is also something I was very aware of when I wrote it, which is why this caveat is included:

> The management principles below reflect lessons I have learned the hard way. These are things I wish I would have known and internalized when I first became a manager. By keeping this brief, I hope that it will be easily consumed, perhaps at the cost of people being able to fully understand each point.

Maybe at some point, this expands into multiple pieces or a short book, but for now, this is what I've produced. It won't be specific enough to be useful to everyone, but hopefully some folks find it helpful.

There is no manual to being a good manager. Only ideas you can project into your own approach.

Re:Principles of Engineering Management by darkerside on Monday April 25, 2022 @09:53PM (#31163129)
I'm sad to see parent post at the top of the page. It nitpicks the one most abstract bullet and calls the whole thing unactionable. I think that's silly. I enjoyed your article and agree with many points.
Re:Principles of Engineering Management by antod on Monday April 25, 2022 @11:13PM (#31163588)
I rate your article (ie up to a dozen headings with a paragraph of text each) higher than having to wade through a book of padding to get not much more actual information.

Thanks.

Re:Principles of Engineering Management by wheaties on Monday April 25, 2022 @08:59PM (#31162788)
Alan, nice to see you on the front cover of HN. Life has been good for you post-Arena, eh?

Most of those critical of what you wrote haven't had an article like this happen. Don't sweat it.

Re:Principles of Engineering Management by acjohnson55 on Monday April 25, 2022 @11:58PM (#31163791)
Thanks Owein! I've been around HN long enough to know that nothing pleases everyone, but getting enough upvotes to hit the top of the front page feels great. On a day without Elon buying Twitter, I might have hit #1 :)
Re:Principles of Engineering Management by gmfawcett on Monday April 25, 2022 @08:37PM (#31162641)
Eh, there are literally thousands of manuals on being a good manager. Still I hope people find your contribution helpful!
Re:Principles of Engineering Management by acjohnson55 on Tuesday April 26, 2022 @12:01AM (#31163802)
I could have phrased it better, but my point is that no single book on management can reliably make people into good managers, any more than a single book on engineering can make people into good engineers.
Re:Principles of Engineering Management by fuzzfactor on Wednesday April 27, 2022 @01:56AM (#31176788)
Some people may say some points are common sense, but when you condense your personal perspective it adds the depth of your experience without having to write a book.

When managers of unrelated industries come up with some similar preferred practices, that can show fair agreement that it's more likely to be worthwhile.

People need to realize there are lots of companies that fail on almost all of the eleven points you have here, and if the right key person were to just take your page to heart and follow it with action it would be like a breath of fresh air across the entire project environment.

Like they have never seen.

Re:Principles of Engineering Management by tootie on Monday April 25, 2022 @06:50PM (#31161843)
It also seems like 99% of management advice is about how to manage down. Not topics like how to set expectations with stakeholders, how to fight for budget, how to get your team positioned for highly visible work.
Re:Principles of Engineering Management by computerdork on Monday April 25, 2022 @07:20PM (#31162125)
And office politics can be brutal, especially in large organizations - watching out for other teams trying to trap you into unrealistic deadlines, pushing their work on to you, deflecting blame - You want to be a team player and help the company achieve its goals, but there are can be a lot of pitfalls to look out for when others teams depend on you and your team's work.
Re:Principles of Engineering Management by lbriner on Monday April 25, 2022 @12:34PM (#31157223)
You are right but there is something that has to underpin all of this advice and that is openness, honesty and balance.

Openness because you should be able to communicate why something might not be possible in unambiguous terms; honesty so people know they can trust you and that you will tell people the truth and not try and avoid it; and balance because you will be prepared to go some distance for an employee for the benefit of the business but this is not unlimited.

It can be hard to tell someone they are not performing well but it is much easier with those principles in mind, "I think these are areas that you are not performing well in, if I can help you achieve those then please let me know how, otherwise I need someone who can do this job that you were employed to do".

Re:Principles of Engineering Management by kemiller on Monday April 25, 2022 @12:38PM (#31157296)
I think this is a result of the persistent flawed way most companies look at management. The author points at it when he says that most managers are strong in execution, and that's true — it's viewed as the baseline trait for any manager. But execution and maintaining well-being are fundamentally in tension, and most of the time, execution wins if a choice is forced. I think we need to be splitting the role into ones focused on each of these competencies. This sometimes happens informally as it is, but making it formal would change the hiring patterns and maybe lead to better outcomes for everyone.
Re:Principles of Engineering Management by moonhorse on Tuesday April 26, 2022 @06:31AM (#31165753)
True. Recently one of the sales directors at my company threatens the CEO to make him a "co-founder" (which basically means granting him a lot of option), or he will quit. He is responsible for half of our revenue, and he has been empire-building in his org for a while, so that his team answers to him, not the company. If we cut him off, very likely he (and a few key leaders) would deflect to our main competitor with our sales pipeline, and do some real damage. Very brutal situation for the CEO. I can not imagine learning how to handle this in any water-downed advice.
Re:Principles of Engineering Management by ttoinou on Monday April 25, 2022 @12:12PM (#31156909)
Thank you for bringing a different opinion. I feel like the "Thats the spirit!" crowd liking this kind of blog posts are employees who don't know what their manager are going through dealing with them
Re:Principles of Engineering Management by jahbrewski on Monday April 25, 2022 @12:10PM (#31156879)
Good feedback here. Do you have any example “smaller forums” that you have found particularly helpful?
Re:Principles of Engineering Management by superzadeh on Monday April 25, 2022 @02:24PM (#31158756)
teams at work is a good one: https://bunch.ai/slack-community
Re:Principles of Engineering Management by reasonabl_human on Thursday April 28, 2022 @10:40AM (#31193032)
Is this something you use personally?
Re:Principles of Engineering Management by kqr on Monday April 25, 2022 @02:27PM (#31158795)
> The hard work often involves making unpopular decisions, or telling someone "no" when their pet request wouldn't be in the best interests of the team

I realise I'm just plucking a small point out of a large comment here, but I'd like to drill down into this one a little.

My very limited experience is that teams can generally self-manage this sort of thing. You tell them what you're trying to optimise, under what constraints, and lay down some ground rules for equal and fair participation, and then the team can make their own tough decisions and tell each other when they're not acting in the best interest of the team.

What am I missing?

Re:Principles of Engineering Management by jseban on Monday April 25, 2022 @04:51PM (#31160430)
> My very limited experience is that teams can generally self-manage this sort of thing.

My experience is that they can absolutely not self-manage these things, it leads to literally living out lord of the flies in chaotic and dysfunctional teams, that are full of infected conflicts and stalled progress.

On the other hand, what exactly is it that gives you the impression that decision making is suddenly not needed? And what makes you believe that a group of people with different goals and interests, should spontaneously just "get along", especially when there's money involved?

Re:Principles of Engineering Management by NateEag on Tuesday April 26, 2022 @09:40AM (#31167339)
I think what you're missing is that most humans are not what Netflix calls "fully-formed adults."

If your team consists of mature, kind, focused, skilled, honest, emotionally well-regulated people, then yes, the team can self-organize well.

That's very, very unusual, though. I don't think I've personally ever been on a team that consisted solely of such people (and, to be clear, though I strive for those things, I wouldn't say I've got them all nailed down perfectly).

Re:Principles of Engineering Management by turdnagel on Monday April 25, 2022 @05:16PM (#31160731)
It entirely depends on the dynamics of the team.
Re:Principles of Engineering Management by StopDarkPattern on Tuesday April 26, 2022 @12:05AM (#31163828)
Honestly the blog post was really half assed and referenced very little cited sources or material. What does it deserve like a 3/10?