News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Resumes are dangerous? by smallerfish on Monday April 25, 2022 @08:36AM (#31153566)
As a hiring manager for a tech startup, I find resumes useful as a filter.

There is a class of applicants who produce 3-4 page resumes filled with tedious details, with every technology they ever used bolded, and turgid prose describing internal software projects as if they should be common knowledge. It takes me probably 15 seconds to move on to the next candidate if I see one of those.

The next thing I filter on is choice of employers. If I see health insurer, big insurance, blah fortune 500 firm, government contractor, ... over and over again, then unless there's something in the first half of the first page of the resume that otherwise catches my eye, that resume is also going in the discard pile after 30 seconds.

Finally I'll scan for interesting projects. I generally want to find people who have done more than just CRUD UIs, and show some passion about the technology they've built and worked with. For somebody who makes it past this point, I'll have spent max 60 seconds with their resume. I then customize and send the message in the ATS and invite the applicant to check out the company and job posting.

Re:Resumes are dangerous? by onion2k on Monday April 25, 2022 @11:54AM (#31156641)
I generally want to find people who have done more than just CRUD UIs..

FWIW I could describe my current role as "Building a cash management application to track $500m+ revenue for a global ethical cosmetics organisation" on my resume, which is 100% true, but really it's a React app with about a dozen pages of fairly simple CRUD actions. What the reality of the app is and how someone describes it on their resume are two very different things.

Re:Resumes are dangerous? by htkibar on Monday April 25, 2022 @08:42AM (#31153617)
This is horrifying to read. So much bias...
Re:Resumes are dangerous? by beej71 on Monday April 25, 2022 @09:25AM (#31154233)
I think the only really uncommon thing here is that they're spending a full 15 seconds per resume. :)

When I put together a resume, I figure I have about 3 seconds to get them to decide to continue reading the resume. So I do my best to put in whatever it takes to accomplish that (within the bounds of truth).

No one reads a resume straight through; they skim for the highlights they want to see.

The more skimming passes you get them to make over your resume because you've kept their interest up, the more likely the interview.

And if you're thinking that a resume is a poor format for getting this job done, you're right. :)

Re:Resumes are dangerous? by Cd00d on Monday April 25, 2022 @10:42AM (#31155550)
Why don't you have a recruiter paring down the number of resumes dramatically so that you can actually give each one that passes that review adequate reading?
Re:Resumes are dangerous? by recursive on Monday April 25, 2022 @12:38PM (#31157307)
1. Recruiters are expensive. 2. It's hard to find a recruiter who doesn't increase your incoming resume volume without a corresponding increase on quality or fit. As far as I can tell recruitment has settled into a stable equilibrium of being a volume game.
Re:Resumes are dangerous? by smallerfish on Monday April 25, 2022 @08:47AM (#31153673)
Tell me one you find horrifying and I'll explain the rationale for doing it.
Re:Resumes are dangerous? by ensignavenger on Monday April 25, 2022 @12:26PM (#31157117)
The Fortune 500 one is a bit disconcerting. I know there are a lot of Fortune 500 developers that would not fit well in a startup, but there are plenty of interesting projects within many Fortune 500s where you would find great developers who would be great startup employees. You do say that you look for something else that catches your eye... but its hard to know what that may be and is probably a lot of chance.

You also state that you want to see "passion" for the technology they have used. I don't really know how to put that in a resume. I have a lot of passion for most of the tech I use- I think that would show within minutes during a conversation or interview. But I'm not confidant my resume really communicates it. Putting "I Love Python!!!" in my resume seems a bit over the top...

Re:Resumes are dangerous? by smallerfish on Monday April 25, 2022 @12:40PM (#31157328)
The fortune 500 one I qualified (as I mentioned to a couple other people who objected to this.) I understand why it's disconcerting, but in my position (small startup, small team, need to not waste 3-6 months on a bad hire) I need to increase my chances for a successful hire. Lots of bigcorp devs are used to having everything laid out for them. Early stage startups are unlikely to give the same structure.

Passion for tech - you are right that this is hard to boil down to a formula. I'm looking for people who exhibit signals like (for example) they read HN, have interests in learning languages beyond the ones they're comfortable in, have maybe messed around a little with hardware, were in technology clubs in high school or college, learned programming as a kid, have a hobby project, etc. It's not so much about the hours that people will put in, but rather their engagement / pride-in-work / creativity / ability to propose alternate-solutions, all of which are good things to have, and are easy to qualify for with "enjoys technology."

Re:Resumes are dangerous? by ensignavenger on Monday April 25, 2022 @12:58PM (#31157625)
At least at my current job at a "boring" Fortune 500, we don't work that way at all. I'm sure there are plenty that do though. I guess if you are getting enough hires using your current system, there is certainly no reason to change it.

I suppose I should consider a way to indicate the I read Hacker News on my resume :) Thanks for responding, I may be able to improve my resume some by considering how to show more of those things. Right now, I focus a lot on Python in my resume, because that is my primary language of expertise and what I use every day. But I am very interested in Rust and various functional languages in general too.

Re:Resumes are dangerous? by quanticle on Monday April 25, 2022 @03:17PM (#31159379)
I generally want to find people who have done more than just CRUD UIs, and show some passion about the technology they've built and worked with.

CRUD stands for Create, Read, Update, Delete. Isn't every UI, at some level, a CRUD UI? A wiki is a CRUD UI. A recipe tracker is a CRUD UI. A custom CMS for a community organization is a CRUD UI. A custom web forum is a CRUD UI. Facebook is a CRUD UI.

Someone could reimplement Mediawiki, and you'd reject them because "it's just a CRUD UI?"

Re:Resumes are dangerous? by tqi on Monday April 25, 2022 @11:44AM (#31156477)
What kind of projects are the people you hire working on, and is it more than just CRUD UIs?
Re:Resumes are dangerous? by throwaway675309 on Monday April 25, 2022 @11:00PM (#31163522)
Everyone is biased, they just happen to be a little bit more upfront about it.

Frankly, I like that not everyone is conforming to the exact same hiring metrics. As somebody who's built dozens of personal projects (a few of which I've been able to monetize), this would have been precisely the kind of hiring manager that a younger version of me would have liked to see.

Re:Resumes are dangerous? by woodweb on Monday April 25, 2022 @09:15AM (#31154078)
What is so horrifying? He's hiring startup developers who need self-direction.

Look like his rationale is if you can't speak high level and you can't resist over-engineering solutions; it isn't going to work out. That saves everyone time and sounds reasonable to me.

Re:Resumes are dangerous? by Cd00d on Monday April 25, 2022 @10:45AM (#31155601)
He's flat out rejecting people for corporate experience. You don't know the reasons people take jobs or why they're looking for a change.
Re:Resumes are dangerous? by smallerfish on Monday April 25, 2022 @10:57AM (#31155774)
I qualified that by "over and over again" and "first half of first page". If you're switching from nothing but bigcorps to startups, you need to give me something on the resume to make me think that you can adapt to the cultural change.
Re:Resumes are dangerous? by em-bee on Monday April 25, 2022 @11:32AM (#31156304)
it also depends on the companies. where i am now, big corporations work their engineers to exhaustion and teach them a very competitive attitude. that's not something i want in my small company. i need cooperation and mutual support, where developers back each other up and not try to gain favors with their manager at the expense of their teammates.
Re:Resumes are dangerous? by astura on Monday April 25, 2022 @09:17AM (#31154104)
>If I see health insurer, big insurance, blah fortune 500 firm, government contractor, ... over and over again

That's where 95% of the software jobs are. Where are people supposed to work if not the places that employ the majority of software engineers?

Re:Resumes are dangerous? by cmrdporcupine on Monday April 25, 2022 @11:45AM (#31156501)
Not to mention there's a regional bias here. There are plenty places around the continent that just don't have many cool "startup" type jobs. (Or if they do there's a feeding frenzy for them because everything else in the area is insurance/finance, etc.)
Re:Resumes are dangerous? by smallerfish on Monday April 25, 2022 @11:59AM (#31156729)
I'm aware of that, and have done a lot of hiring from the midwest, fwiw. I've been in a position where I don't have a ton of time for mentoring, so I tend to hire senior engineers who are used to running with looser requirements than they may get from a bigcorp, and don't mind juggling a main project with a small backlog of cleanup or bugfixes. I learned this filter after not doing it, and having candidates used to a more structured environment flail. That said, like I mentioned originally, if you can demonstrate in your resume (perhaps even with a "What I'm looking for" section) that you have the skills necessary to thrive, I'll overlook this point.

There are simply too many candidates to give everybody a fair chance, and a good number of candidates left over post-filters who will require fewer interviews to narrow down to a hire. Resumes are about marketing yourself to get to the initial screening call so that you can make your case that you are qualified. It sucks, but if you haven't been dealt the lucky cards and you want to break into startups, I think it's probably useful to know the filtering that you're up against.

Re:Resumes are dangerous? by denton-scratch on Monday April 25, 2022 @09:25AM (#31154239)
> 3-4 page resumes

That's way too much, even for a long career. Two pages is enough. The more resume there is, the more bullshit you have to read. The career history part should be a list of job-titles and dates, with a brief description of each role, noting any salient achievements. Many recruiters will set aside any resume longer than two pages.

Re:Resumes are dangerous? by smallerfish on Monday April 25, 2022 @09:31AM (#31154345)
I once had a candidate submit a 20 page(!) resume. They were so full of themselves. That one I actually did spend 5 minutes with to see what they found so fascinating about their history, but it was otherwise an instant reject.
Re:Resumes are dangerous? by denton-scratch on Monday April 25, 2022 @12:56PM (#31157595)
A 20-page resume bespeaks someone inexperienced in job applications.

One of the important skills I would be looking for in a recruit would be the ability to express themselves clearly, concisely, and persuasively. Clarity and conciseness are marks of the ability to think. Persuasiveness is actually something that makes me suspicious, but in many jobs the ability to persuade others is an asset (leadership positions, for example). So YMMV.

I've always struggled with conciseness; I'm in love with the sound of my own voice.

Re:Resumes are dangerous? by Cd00d on Monday April 25, 2022 @10:43AM (#31155564)
That may be a cultural/experiential difference. You may not be familiar with CVs as opposed to resumes.
Re:Resumes are dangerous? by astura on Monday April 25, 2022 @09:42AM (#31154539)
Re:Resumes are dangerous? by HWR_14 on Monday April 25, 2022 @06:42PM (#31161755)
In some industries (or academia) a 20 page resume listing every project, publication, patent, etc. is considered normal and desirable. If could be that case.
Re:Resumes are dangerous? by derwiki on Monday April 25, 2022 @09:34AM (#31154403)
I feel like one page is enough unless you have a truly remarkable career. At this point my earliest roles just don’t earn their keep; no one cares any more that I was a Micro Computer Support Specialist in undergrad.
Re:Resumes are dangerous? by em-bee on Monday April 25, 2022 @11:25AM (#31156187)
all right, i am guilty of that. my resume has 5 pages, but it is split up in clear sections that i can easily remove if appropriate:

    page 1:
        general objectives
        current occupation
        summary of the most important or interesting skills and projects
    page 2:
        skills (that's the list of all tech i ever worked with. just the names, no details. only the most important ones are bold.)
        work history (list of companies, dates and titles)
    page 3:
        education
        detailed work experience (that's a long list of every project i ever worked on, and the role i had there, split up in multiple subsections that i can include as appropriate)
            software development
            sysadmin work
    page 4: 
            mentor and teaching experience
            presentations and workshops
    page 5:
            organizing events
            experience working with kids (that i only include for relevant ed-tech or training jobs)
so technically, you could stop reading after page 2. and only scan the rest if you want more details.

do you think it would be better to just skip the project list? i think it's better than a list of projects on github (which wouldn't have any of the interesting projects)

Re:Resumes are dangerous? by tqi on Monday April 25, 2022 @11:50AM (#31156580)
From what I've seen, a few things that could be helpful are:

- Skip the objective, they are often really generic so people have become accustomed to just skipping ahead rather than reading carefully.

- Presentations and workshops, especially if they are at bigger conferences, could be worth highlighting for more senior roles.

- Education is good to keep just in case there is some kind of automatic filtering.

Personally I have an extended version of my resume that has every job / project written out (that I plan to keep adding to over time), but when I submit a resume I pare down the items to only the ones most relevant to the role.

Re:Resumes are dangerous? by denton-scratch on Monday April 25, 2022 @12:21PM (#31157031)
> do you think it would be better to just skip the project list?

Hey, I'm not a specialist in this stuff - I've tended to stay in the same job until it became impossible for some reason or other, so I haven't applied for that many jobs. But I was hitched to a careers consultant for 15 years, whose core trade was advising students on how to write résumés. Its only purpose is to get you an interview; if you drop your pants in the résumé, then there's nothing left for the recruiter to be curious about.

A résumé is a concise overview of your education and career. If you feel you need to describe your objectives and attitudes, or expand on some major achievement, I think that belongs in your covering letter - which can be an essay of sorts (but I keep mine short). The covering letter is tailored to the firm you are applying to. The résumé can then be boilerplate, so you can use the same résumé for each firm you apply to; only the covering letter is customised.

I treat the résumé as a sort of teaser. The covering letter has all the stuff about "If I can't get a job with your firm I'll have to kill myself, because no other employer will do" (no, please don't say anything like that!). But even the covering letter should not be more than two sides of paper. I'd stick to one side. If your concise pitch doesn't get you an interview, then doubling the length isn't going to improve your chances.

Self-testimonials are a waste of space, if your recruiters are any good. For example, "I am a good team player" is worthless, unless you can provide evidence, such as "In my present position I mentor new recruits, and provide training courses for my colleagues". And I think that kind of stuff belongs in the covering letter.

Again, I stress that I'm not a master of these matters. And most of my experience is based on UK hiring; I think puffing yourself up is more expected in the US tech marketplace. I've had one job in the USA, and I think I probably undersold myself that time.

Re:Resumes are dangerous? by em-bee on Monday April 25, 2022 @01:31PM (#31158078)
well, the first page is more or less the cover letter. and i do adapt that depending on the job.

hiding the list of projects for the sake of having material in the interview seems to contradict the idea that people want to see my projects on github.

either they do want to see projects or they don't. the project descriptions aren't detailed, and definitely less than a github project. so there still is plenty to talk about.

and i prefer interviews to be about things that can't easily be put in writing. spending the interview talking about historic facts feels like a waste of time. obviously as a candidate i can't choose what the interviewer wants to know, but by getting the facts out of the way, i feel like getting the freedom to talk about things that are actually interesting.

worse, if i am asked to share something about an interesting project, i might not know what to talk about because i don't know what the interviewer wants to hear. but if they have the list of projects they can skim it, pick one they find interesting and ask about that. at least that is how my thinking goes. i haven't actually been interviewed for some time, being more on the opposite side of the table.

as an interviewer i value these details because they allow me to find things to talk about. that is especially important with candidates who are not outspoken and may not be doing well answering open-ended questions. or they may just feel nervous, and not know what to say. the more i know about them up-front the easier it is for me to find something to talk about that they should be familiar with and ease them into the situation.

i agree that a long prosaic CV where it is difficult to find the things that the hiring manager is looking for is not helpful, but a list of projects which is effectively a kind of portfolio as an appendix should not be that.

maybe i should explicitly separate the project list from the CV, so that it doesn't look like the CV itself has 5 pages.

Re:Resumes are dangerous? by theandrewbailey on Monday April 25, 2022 @12:16PM (#31156965)
> skills (that's the list of all tech i ever worked with. just the names, no details. only the most important ones are bold.)

Only put down skills and technologies that you want to work with. I used to put Pentaho on my resume, even though it was the most frustrating thing I've ever worked with (before or since). A recruiter messaged me once about a Pentaho role, which I declined. I dropped Pentaho from my resume immediately.

> summary of the most important or interesting skills and projects

Aaand you can stop right there. Pages 2 and onward can be safely omitted.

Re:Resumes are dangerous? by sys_64738 on Monday April 25, 2022 @04:59PM (#31160510)
I spent 30 seconds reading your message here and another 30 seconds in this response. You sound like a plain awful manager.