I am too cynical to believe this. Would be nice though.
Unfortunately, the answer is whomever is in power.
Quis custodiet ipsos custodes.
The standard solution of course is to divide up power and create checks and balances amongst trusted groups.
The american constitution wasn't designed around the idea that slaves were supposed to be fairly dealt with by the government
Its a global truth that corruption and tyranny is always a risk, but the amount of that risk varries with the solution proposed, and there are plenty of ways it could be mitigated to varrying degrees.
I can describe how I'd set one up, to guarantee personal freedoms and human rights, and reasonable systems of governance, but at the end of the day, I think "whomever is in power" will make better decisions about human well-being than the invisible hand of capitalism.
I think China has some elements of the right approach:
- Free markets for mass-produced commodities.
- Socialized banks, resources, real estate, and other rent-collecting industries.
- A hybrid for tech and information
What are you requesting be done to you if you are found to be truant from your mandatory education? That's the other side of laws that seems to be ignored in these kinds of proposals.
With classes, I guess I don't advance in my career as much.
Critically, society would be structured with room for this, and a place I'm expected to be without distraction.
However, the system will fall apart if it's mandatory for all. People will shirk their 32-hour work week, do the bare minimum for 8 hours mandatory education (e.g. clicking through modules super fast, or Googling all of the answers), make their own video games (which would be great), go through the motions of mandatory exercise, brew alcohol, grow or synthesize drugs, and create their own social network, even via amateur radio.
The counter-culture sounds a lot more fun. Also, the utopia is incompatible with people with dreams of becoming game developers, people who critique expensive wine, and people who spend a variable amount of time self-learning on their own, versus fixed hours.
The imposition of how a person spends their time is a separate principle from guarantees of a job (an income guarantee is preferred, because a lot of people will effectively and potentially rationally do the bare minimum/no work at the job), housing, food, and medical care.
A utopia for non-minorities, you mean? Because the 1930s were not necessarily a pleasant time for everyone involved.
That's when communism and fascism were sparring with democracy in Europe, China had the Kuomintang and CCP visions, the Soviet system was new, and so on. There was a lot of interesting political thought.
On the whole, I am glad for China. I like having multiple systems, and unlike many others, I feel like the government is trying very hard to improve, and sometimes succeeding.
However, I think your view of it as closer to a utopia is a little disconnected from reality. The US is still a nicer place to live than China, unless you're a tourist. The gap has closed rapidly, but it's still there.
I think each system has upsides and downsides. I'm glad for having multiple systems. I hope they can learn from each other. The Chinese concepts of meritocracy, family, and long-term planning, as well as the emphasis on education, would go a long ways here. I also like what's socialized and what isn't. I like weak IP laws and contracts; I think China's in the right place there now (I wouldn't have said so a few years back, where it was the wild west)
The US still has lower corruption. The US is much more transparent. I also don't like the way Chinese politicians are kinda dicks, openly insulting the US. Then there's issues like Tibet, Honk Kong, Taiwan, and the Uighurs, as well as mass surveillance (although the US is not much better on the last one, as of late).
I feel like at some point, China might find a chill government who will let a lot of those slide or move into a more balanced position.
I hope they do. I can see path for China to really become closer to a utopia than virtually any other place right now.
Fundamentally all you're saying is that you're a child who needs to be told what to do. That is not compelling.
The solution you're looking for is to grow up. You don't need a totalitarian government to do that for you. You can get that done on your own.
> I can describe how I'd set one up, to guarantee personal freedoms and human rights, and reasonable systems of governance
Maybe just do what Europe, Canada, Australia, and New Zealand are doing. They're not perfect, but they sound more like what you want while also allowing you to be an adult.
I'm managing several major projects, and I like having a project manager tell me what to do. Before that, I had an admin to boss me around. At some point, I figured out that scheduling and planning all this stuff is no fun. If I wake up, and have a calendar of meetings, or a big block of time for writing, or whatever, I am much happier than if I'm planning it myself. If I have a project, deadlines are nice. I set them, but an RPM or admin can harass me to make sure I remember them and meet them.
My project manager, and before that, my admin, report to me. It's not totalitarian at all.
I don't see why a government needs to be totalitarian to structure my life. I think everyone should have a free basic home. I also think everyone should be welcome to buy a nicer home if they choose.
What do you believe is not childish in an adult saying they are unable to control themselves and that they need someone to do it for them?
Here's what Alexis de Tocqueville (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alexis_de_Tocqueville and https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Democracy_in_America) says about it:
> "What good does it do me, after all, if an ever-watchful authority keeps an eye out to ensure that my pleasures will be tranquil and races ahead of me to ward off all danger, sparing me the need even to think about such things, if that authority, even as it removes the smallest thorns from my path, is also absolute master of my liberty and my life; if it monopolizes vitality and existence to such a degree that when it languishes, everything around it must also languish; when it sleeps, everything must also sleep; and when it dies, everything must also perish?
There are some nations in Europe whose inhabitants think of themselves in a sense as colonists, indifferent to the fate of the place they live in. The greatest changes occur in their country without their cooperation. They are not even aware of precisely what has taken place. They suspect it; they have heard of the event by chance. More than that, they are unconcerned with the fortunes of their village, the safety of their streets, the fate of their church and its vestry. They think that such things have nothing to do with them, that they belong to a powerful stranger called “the government.” They enjoy these goods as tenants, without a sense of ownership, and never give a thought to how they might be improved. They are so divorced from their own interests that even when their own security and that of their children is finally compromised, they do not seek to avert the danger themselves but cross their arms and wait for the nation as a whole to come to their aid. Yet as utterly as they sacrifice their own free will, they are no fonder of obedience than anyone else. They submit, it is true, to the whims of a clerk, but no sooner is force removed than they are glad to defy the law as a defeated enemy. Thus one finds them ever wavering between servitude and license.
When a nation has reached this point, it must either change its laws and mores or perish, for the well of public virtue has run dry: in such a place one no longer finds citizens but only subjects."
For starters, you're asserting without argument. Which leads it to appear to be name calling.
Secondly, given you are being downvoted to hell, you should probably reevaluate if it is really a correct assesment. After all, if its obviously correct why aren't people agreeing?
Second you are clearly using childish as an insult, instead of saying what you really think is wrong with that view - which is a second reason why it looks like name calling. Childish can mean a lot of things, some positive some negative, its hard to see from your posts what the specific objection is, which makes it seem like just a shallow insult.
> What do you believe is not childish in an adult saying they are unable to control themselves and that they need someone to do it for them?
For starters, the original poster did not say that. They especially did not say they were unable to control themselves.
They did say they would like to delegate some aspects of their life. I personally wouldn't want to live in their utopia, but its not like it's totally different from how many societies work including our own.
I hired a guy to do my taxes, instead of taking responsibility for them myself. Is that childish?
Some people hire personal trainers instead of coming up with their own exercise plans. Is that childish?
Some people go to university for a structured education, instead of reading textbooks, articles, recorded lecture videos themselves (seriously, between lectures on youtube, open courseware, lib genisis, is there any valid reason to go to university except a lack of self control and discipline?) Is that childish?
I would argue the true mark of an adult is knowing what to take responsibility for yourself, and knowing what to delegate to others. We all have limited attention, if we try to do everything we do nothing very well.
A lot of people are wrong about a lot of things a lot of the time. Popularity doesn't make something true or false. If you're chasing what's popular you will never be honest.
However, it does mean it is not "obviously" true, and you need to provide a compelling argument for why whatever you believe is actually the case instead of just asserting it.
... There's a point in your life you learn to delegate.
It is.
> then fuck being an adult
Have no worry. I will tell you what to do, slave.
Now do as you're told and say that you like it.
For example, with facebook, a good user experience would be turning off the algorithmic feed results in a purely temporal one with all your existing filters in place. I highly doubt facebook is going to reimplement a temporal feed to give people a viable option for turning off the feed they want them to use.
So my prediction is nothing will change because the algorithms disabled option will intentionally be a very poor experience designed to make you immediately turn the algorithms back on.
I assume in China where they can just jail the CEO on bull shit charges they'll definitely put in a good faith effort.
Looking at Google results that clearly favor media outlets compared to any other content, something similar could maybe bring back better search results. I am amazed that Google sabotages their primary product in such a way.
Better search won't change that. If the current state of search is trying to find the one independent needle in a pile of commercially produced hay, imagine how it will be when the farmer didn't hire someone to shovel all the manure out of the barn.
I'd like a button or option to tone down how much a video influences the recommendation. Not ignore since I obviously wanted to watch it but I don't need 500 videos of various scenes in a film just because one popped in my head and I just wanted to see that.
No, it is not.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uyghur_genocide
It's amazing to me how easily people "forget" the actual UN-recognized religious holocaust that is happening right now, while praising its architects.
Also, if intent is the greatest predictor of future deaths (as opposed to just tallying past deaths), a chronically tyrannical regime looks way worse than a democracy's bungled retributive invasion.
If you actually look for the sources of data and don't just blindly believe the western propaganda pieces repeating the same figures, this will become pretty obvious.
I'm not suggesting that there wasn't trouble, death, and suffering during this period but I'd take the multi million death counts generously extrapolated from incomplete with a bolder of salt.
https://mronline.org/2006/09/21/did-mao-really-kill-millions...
Is this the beginning of a world optimized for well-being instead of engagement?