News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Britain being forced to go cashless 'against its will' by sgt on Thursday March 31, 2022 @01:26AM (#30864089)
Seriously?! How did they justify donating to the truckers as something to be punished? That sounds almost like a police state to me.
Re:Britain being forced to go cashless 'against its will' by halfnormalform on Thursday March 31, 2022 @01:30AM (#30864110)
They didn't punish a single person who donated. That's just ridiculous.
Re:Britain being forced to go cashless 'against its will' by cscurmudgeon on Thursday March 31, 2022 @02:37AM (#30864443)
Freezing their accounts is not punishment?

https://nationalpost.com/news/politics/even-small-donation-t...

> Even small donation to Freedom Convoy after Feb. 15 enough to have donor's bank accounts frozen, finance committee told

Re:Britain being forced to go cashless 'against its will' by throwaway111023 on Thursday March 31, 2022 @01:33AM (#30864129)
how is freezing their donations not punishment?
Re:Britain being forced to go cashless 'against its will' by halfnormalform on Thursday March 31, 2022 @01:44AM (#30864181)
Because once you donate money, you have given it away, and it's gone. If you're expecting something in return you are trying to make a purchase, not a donation.

Punishment would involve having something further taken away. If they jailed people for donating, that would be punishment.

Re:Britain being forced to go cashless 'against its will' by hatefulmoron on Thursday March 31, 2022 @01:50AM (#30864219)
> Because once you donate money, you have given it away, and it's gone.

Presumably to the entity you intended to donate to, no? I would argue that determining where your money goes is a right.. If I intercepted all of your future charitable donations for my own purposes you would be understandably upset.

Re:Britain being forced to go cashless 'against its will' by luciusdomitius on Thursday March 31, 2022 @04:24AM (#30865014)
Great. So, stealing from charity is now ethical. Good to know !!!
Re:Britain being forced to go cashless 'against its will' by fennecfoxy on Friday April 01, 2022 @09:30AM (#30877865)
Ha ha, so easy to refute. Is it unethical for the government to stop me from say, donating to a terrorist organisation? It's still "charity", right? ;)
Re:Britain being forced to go cashless 'against its will' by leach on Friday April 01, 2022 @04:19PM (#30882867)
if we really want to get dirty with things aren't you already doing that through taxes? black budgets and such?

also what constitutes a terrorist? its easy to say ISIS is terrorism, but are the truckers or January 6th people considered terrorists?

if so then BLM can be considered terrorists, and then how come they never got their donations seized?

deep rabbit hole with no way out

Re:Britain being forced to go cashless 'against its will' by kurisufag on Thursday March 31, 2022 @07:46AM (#30866113)
donation are purchases -- you are buying capital for the fund of your choice. if it turned out a charity you donated to was funneling money somewhere, they would be effectively stealing from you, as the thing you were purchasing was never given.
Re:Britain being forced to go cashless 'against its will' by mrozbarry on Thursday March 31, 2022 @09:09AM (#30866745)
This wasn't strictly freezing donations, it was completely freezing a person's bank account.
Re:Britain being forced to go cashless 'against its will' by TomSwirly on Thursday March 31, 2022 @05:08AM (#30865237)
They didn't. You are responding to someone who is consciously telling an untruth.
Re:Britain being forced to go cashless 'against its will' by xdennis on Thursday March 31, 2022 @07:09AM (#30865877)
https://www.newsweek.com/banks-have-begun-freezing-accounts-...

> On February 17, Deputy Prime Minister Chrystia Freeland said in a press conference that financial institutions have started freezing accounts and canceling credit cards in accordance with the Emergencies Act, which Prime Minister Justin Trudeau invoked earlier this week.

> The powers granted by the act would allow banks to target the accounts of people who have donated to crowdfunding platforms, like the fundraising campaigns on GoFundMe and GiveSendGo, that have fueled the ongoing protests, but Freeland said she would not give "specifics of whose accounts are being frozen."

They can lock anything for any amount and not give any details. Supposedly they have unlocked some, but there's no way of knowing who and why not for others. Typical petrostate behavior.

Re:Britain being forced to go cashless 'against its will' by crtasm on Thursday March 31, 2022 @11:07AM (#30868038)
I'm sure if this happened to people who'd just sent a donation at least one of them would have come forward by now and we'd have some evidence instead of the handwaving "what if" in this article and your comment.
Re:Britain being forced to go cashless 'against its will' by srslack on Thursday March 31, 2022 @12:26PM (#30869063)
https://www.nationalreview.com/news/canada-unlocks-vast-majo...

>“Just to be clear, a financial contribution either through a crowdsourced platform or directly, could result in their bank account being frozen?” Lawrence asked.

>“Yes,” Jacques answered.

https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/mp-mark-stra...

Re:Britain being forced to go cashless 'against its will' by crtasm on Thursday March 31, 2022 @03:17PM (#30871199)
I'm aware they said it could happen. That is not the same as something actually happening.
Re:Britain being forced to go cashless 'against its will' by raydev on Thursday March 31, 2022 @01:55PM (#30870270)
“Could”.

Still waiting to see the evidence that it happened.

Re:Britain being forced to go cashless 'against its will' by incomingpain on Thursday March 31, 2022 @07:50AM (#30866159)
They did. https://blockade.rcmp.ca/news-nouvelles/ncr-rcn211130-s-d-en...

RCMP denied being involved and were rushing to unfreeze those accounts.

Re:Britain being forced to go cashless 'against its will' by honkdaddy on Thursday March 31, 2022 @08:13AM (#30866295)
You're wrong TomSwirly, they did, and unless you're Canadian familiar with the situation (I assume you're not), you should really be more careful about untruths. In your case I assume it comes from a place of ignorance, not malice, but it's tough to be certain.
Re:Britain being forced to go cashless 'against its will' by incomingpain on Thursday March 31, 2022 @07:49AM (#30866148)
>Seriously?! How did they justify donating to the truckers as something to be punished? That sounds almost like a police state to me.

So imagine Trudeau's point of view. The Canadian media smeared the protest as nazis, racists, white supremacists, who were going to Ottawa to overthrow the government. Indie and international media clearly disproved this, but Trudeau never saw this. Joel Lightbound, one of Trudeau's top allies saw this.

So imagine you are Trudeau. You believe that a bunch of nazis are looking to overthrow the government. You absolutely declare a national emergency and send the police to arrest them. You also seize the bank accounts of those who are involved in the military occupation of the capital.

The problem? The canadian media was lying quite extensively. This was a legitimate protest of regular canadians who are good people.

Re:Britain being forced to go cashless 'against its will' by mrozbarry on Thursday March 31, 2022 @09:04AM (#30866703)
CBC is literally state-funded media, and Trudea literally lives in Ottawa. In no world does he have an excuse to be blind, and even in some sliver of hope where he honestly didn't know, why didn't he make a public apology?
Re:Britain being forced to go cashless 'against its will' by account42 on Thursday March 31, 2022 @08:15AM (#30866305)
I don't think you can excuse this by blaming the media - shouldn't it be the government's responsibility to make sure they have the correct information before making use of emergency powers?
Re:Britain being forced to go cashless 'against its will' by incomingpain on Thursday March 31, 2022 @08:20AM (#30866339)
>I don't think you can excuse this by blaming the media - shouldn't it be the government's responsibility to make sure they have the correct information before making use of emergency powers?

I never intended to excuse anything. The media is bought and paid for by the government. This is the state propaganda who called the protest a bunch of nazis.

Worse yet... Joel Lightbound is a liberal quebec MP. He made the huge mistake of going to the protest and talk to them and he was astounded by how misrepresented the protest was by Canadian media. Over a week before the emergency was declared he said exactly what should happen. Stop the inflammatory messaging calling them all nazis, they are not nazis. Give us a roadmap to when our rights will be restored.

That would have solved the entire problem long before anything went down. Today, not only did everything that the protest was protesting still remains without a roadmap, they have added new restrictions to our rights.

Re:Britain being forced to go cashless 'against its will' by philistine on Thursday March 31, 2022 @09:24AM (#30866864)
The leaders of the protest sought to overthrow the government. It was written on their list of demands. https://conservativespolitics.com/leaders-of-truck-convoy-pr...
Re:Britain being forced to go cashless 'against its will' by s1artibartfast on Thursday March 31, 2022 @10:54AM (#30867889)
absolute FUD and lies. They wanted policy change. Telling your government to use its powers is not revolution. They wanted to "overthrow" the government in the same sense that protestors to legalize gay marriage want to overthrow the government.
Re:Britain being forced to go cashless 'against its will' by philistine on Thursday March 31, 2022 @11:54AM (#30868597)
Asking the Governor General to act against the advice of her Prime Minister is a good definition of an overthrow of government.
Re:Britain being forced to go cashless 'against its will' by s1artibartfast on Thursday March 31, 2022 @12:05PM (#30868727)
Is it? Is it overthrow for a senator or citizen to vote against the advice of the PM?

There is an intentional conflation between political reform and treason/rebellion happening here.

Not doing what you're told to and seeking political reform is only rebellion in an absolute dictatorship

Re:Britain being forced to go cashless 'against its will' by philistine on Thursday March 31, 2022 @12:47PM (#30869387)
You misunderstand the Canadian political system. A senator or MP is free to act according to their own desire; they are political actors elected or appointed expressly for that.

The Governor General is Canada's representative of the Queen. They are not a politician. Literal centuries of British and Canadian jurisprudence have defined the Governor General to have no ability to act without the advice of their Prime Minister. As an unelected representative of the Monarch, if they act without the advice of the Prime Minister, that's a tyrant overthrowing the elected government. England cut off the head of the last monarch to act against the will of the House.

Re:Britain being forced to go cashless 'against its will' by s1artibartfast on Thursday March 31, 2022 @02:06PM (#30870384)
I will openly admit that I have limited knowledgeable of the role of the Governor General in Canadian constitution and legal history.

I still think that characterizing the memorandum of understanding as treason is a misunderstanding of both what a MoU is and the contents of this specific MoU.

First, a MoU is a declaration of intent and a commitment to take an action - Not a legislative bill.

This MoU was addressed to both the Senate and the Governor General.

It doesn't specify how the parties will achieve their their commitment. It is up to the parties to determine if there is a lawful way to meet their commitments before making them.

Senators in Canada have the ability to introduce bills, which can be approved via the traditional pathway.

It also doesn't say anything about removal of the PM.

https://canada-unity.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/01/Combined...

Re:Britain being forced to go cashless 'against its will' by philistine on Thursday March 31, 2022 @08:16PM (#30873779)
I never said it was treason. Treason is a criminal offense. https://www.thecanadianencyclopedia.ca/en/article/treason

I said it was undemocratically overthrowing the government. That is a political act.

Re:Britain being forced to go cashless 'against its will' by s1artibartfast on Thursday March 31, 2022 @11:58PM (#30875026)
I fail to see the distinctions drawn. What makes it UN democratic to ask your government to make change through lawful process? It's not like the policies were put in place by public referendum.

How can something be a terrorist plot to overthrow the government, but not treason?

Re:Britain being forced to go cashless 'against its will' by incomingpain on Thursday March 31, 2022 @09:51AM (#30867167)
>The leaders of the protest sought to overthrow the government. It was written on their list of demands. https://conservativespolitics.com/leaders-of-truck-convoy-pr...

I dont know this website. Article written March 10th well after the fact and just hosts a very clearly one sided view of this. Jody thomas? I dont know wtf this is about.

Let me explain in much better detail about what you're trying to get at.

There was a website named 'canada unity' who put together a MOU in which called on the governor general to inform Trudeau that he has to return our charter rights. In a way you can read it as saying the governor general is overthrowing the government by effectively dissolving Trudeau's government.

This poorly put together was run by JAMES BAUDER and his wife. They were never even for a second one of the protest leaders.

Yet the canadian media portrayed this website as THE protest leaders. Used this MOU as justification of calling on the governor general to overthrow the government's sovereignty. This is how they are claiming the protest was overthrowing the government.

So for example: https://www.ctvnews.ca/canada/who-is-who-a-guide-to-the-majo...

Notice how James Bauder is literally the top of the list.

But wait lets look at this closer.

https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/ottawa/tamara-lich-chris-barb...

Ctrl + f "bauder": 0 results.

James Bauder was nobody.

Tamara Lich was the key organizer. Involvement in several previous protests. She represented the protest in negotiations with the mayor of ottawa. She represented the protest in court over the honking situation.

Chris Barber had Jordan Peterson's audience.

Pat King is an actor on the otherhand. His acting played the canadian media's bias against themselves so badly.

What exactly was the crime the protest was committing. Parking violations really.

The only problem that anyone can explain about this peaceful protest is ParKing violations.

Yet here we are, everyone is a nazis, confederates, racists. Pat King offered the canadian media every prejudice, every biased hate thing he could think of. He got into the limelight because they ate up everything he said. He gave them everything they ever wanted on a golden platter.

For multiple elections conservatives have run on the plan to defund these lying canadian media. They got played big time.

Flipside, we're now a month later and pat king is still in jail. Original charge was just 'counseling mischief' but the new charges are 'counseling a felony that wasnt committed."

Absurd vague fake charges to crush a peaceful protest.

Re:Britain being forced to go cashless 'against its will' by philistine on Thursday March 31, 2022 @10:19AM (#30867506)
We were not discussing whether the protest was peaceful or not; we are discussing whether or not self-evident leaders of the movement wanted a coup.

You can personnally cry and cry that they were not leaders of the movement, but never has Tamara Lich publically denounced James Bauder, or denied her desire to overthrow the government. She never went on record denouncing his involvement in any leadership position. Letting someone in a protest you supposedely organize run around and demand the overthrow of the government is a thing that happens all the time; it's common. Whenever that person has the limelight on them, you vigorously denounce them and deny any sort of leadership on their part. Failure to do so means you agree.

Ultimately, this whole convoy was dangerously inept. That's a thing. You can be so clueless, so reckless that you're a danger to others.

Re:Britain being forced to go cashless 'against its will' by incomingpain on Thursday March 31, 2022 @02:23PM (#30870584)
>We were not discussing whether the protest was peaceful or not;

Excellent, you cede that they were peaceful and therefore their charter rights were violated.

>we are discussing whether or not self-evident leaders of the movement wanted a coup.

They didn't. The Media doesnt get to pick who the leaders are neither.

>You can personnally cry and cry that they were not leaders of the movement, but never has Tamara Lich publically denounced James Bauder, or denied her desire to overthrow the government.

I provided CBC who clearly never listed James Bauder as a protest leader. Never did Tamara Lich ever call for overthrow of the government. You want to think the media gets to choose some random protester, say he is leader and then use them?

> She never went on record denouncing his involvement in any leadership position.

She doesnt need to. That's a ridiculous requirement.

>Letting someone in a protest you supposedely organize run around and demand the overthrow of the government is a thing that happens all the time; it's common.

Perfect! In future... the media gets to pick who the leader of all protests are. Not the protest itself. Did you meet John Smith the ecoterrorist who wishes to destroy Canada? Every future protest = illegal now.

>Whenever that person has the limelight on them, you vigorously denounce them and deny any sort of leadership on their part. Failure to do so means you agree.

Great, going forward all left-wing protests will have John Smith the ecoterrorist speaking for them.

>Ultimately, this whole convoy was dangerously inept. That's a thing. You can be so clueless, so reckless that you're a danger to others.

How dare they so recklessly exercise their right to protest!

Re:Britain being forced to go cashless 'against its will' by philistine on Thursday March 31, 2022 @08:25PM (#30873853)
Your whole house of cards rest on the idea that I have to agree that James Bauder was never a leader of the movement. When James Bauder said he was a leader of the movement. When many news outlet identified him as a leader of the movement. When many protesters identified him as a leader of the movement. And Tamara Lich never denounced him or any of his formal requests to the Governor General.

Reality doesn't care about your feelings about James Bauder.

Re:Britain being forced to go cashless 'against its will' by incomingpain on Friday April 01, 2022 @07:53AM (#30877238)
>Your whole house of cards rest on the idea that I have to agree that James Bauder was never a leader of the movement.

Does it matter if you agree or disagree with this? I provided a cbc link that listed the leaders. Bauder was not among them. Why do you think the CBC didn't even list bauder?

In fact, im just doing a search right now... there's no articles on cbc at all listing bauder as anything at all. Which is in fact impossible because I recall reading about bauder, the mou, and how they plan to overthrow the government on the cbc amongst others. It would seem the CBC quietly deleted those articles.

>When James Bauder said he was a leader of the movement.

Did you know I am the leader of BLM?

>hen many news outlet identified him as a leader of the movement. When many protesters identified him as a leader of the movement. And Tamara Lich never denounced him or any of his formal requests to the Governor General.

Why indeed has BLM never denounced me, John Smith the ecoterrorist. Is it by chance Bauder and I were just never a leader. That media smears were ignored by the real leadership?

Politically unaligned media don't get to pick the leaders of a protest.

>Reality doesn't care about your feelings about James Bauder.

I know why you cling to Bauder so much when clearly he's not a real entity. Without this tremendously weak point... you literally have nothing else to say the protest were 'overthrowing the government'. Without this tenuous at best point, how do you ever justify a national emergency.

Ultimately it doesnt even matter. They were parked outfront parliament for weeks and never quite got around to insurrection. The entire narrative that they were trying to overthrow the government is without merit. Reality is on my side.

Re:Britain being forced to go cashless 'against its will' by mschuster91 on Thursday March 31, 2022 @01:35AM (#30864137)
Financing terrorists - and these "truckers" were nothing else, which led to the declaration of the emergency state, a legally defined mechanism! - will lead to issues no matter if it's al-quaeda or y'all-quaeda.

The donors should be happy all they got was a temporary freeze on their bank accounts. Had it been Islamist terror they had donated to, the accounts would have been terminated and criminal charges levied.

Re:Britain being forced to go cashless 'against its will' by ctoth on Thursday March 31, 2022 @01:57AM (#30864245)
I am curious if you generally feel comfortable with the government being able to retroactively define something as "terrorism" when it does not conform with your general political views. Personally I think this is a terrible idea whether or not I agree with the people being targeted.
Re:Britain being forced to go cashless 'against its will' by incomingpain on Thursday March 31, 2022 @07:57AM (#30866203)
>I am curious if you generally feel comfortable with the government being able to retroactively define something as "terrorism" when it does not conform with your general political views. Personally I think this is a terrible idea whether or not I agree with the people being targeted.

There's a hilarious video from our parliament.

Andrew Scheer(former conservative leader, former opposition leader) was talking.

Elizabeth May(former green party leader) got up and started accusing him of 'dogwhistles to nazis' blah blah.

Andrew Scheer stands up with the biggest smile.

He points out Elizabeth May has been arrested and convicted of an illegal blockade while being green party leader. That the precedent set will mean that the green party donaters will have their bank accounts seized as well as her own.

The irony, it's only matter of time that conservatives take government back and very well can do this now.

On twitter a ton of greenpeace and antifa people freaked out at this new precedent.

"What if I donate to greenpeace. Some point later they have a protest that goes sideways. My bank account gets seized?"

Yep.

Re:Britain being forced to go cashless 'against its will' by formerkrogeremp on Thursday March 31, 2022 @08:46AM (#30866553)
It sounds the argument being made here is that this was a dangerous precedent being made that can be abused by political parties against their political opponents. This seems to be presented by you with apparent glee as a conservative vs green party/greenpeace/"antifa" or liberal issue. What you'll actually find is that broader society is just intolerant of the economic duress and disruptions caused by such protests.

Up to a quarter of Canadian-US trade was going through that area, and real people were suffering due to the trucker blockade. These economic disruptions had secondary effects that impact the lingering impacts of the pandemic and exacerbated supply chain issues.

There is not a whit of moral equivalency between climate change protests and some truckers afraid of a needle.

Re:Britain being forced to go cashless 'against its will' by flenserboy on Thursday March 31, 2022 @09:09AM (#30866737)
"It's ok when it happens to people with whom I disagree."
Re:Britain being forced to go cashless 'against its will' by incomingpain on Thursday March 31, 2022 @09:28AM (#30866912)
>It sounds the argument being made here is that this was a dangerous precedent being made that can be abused by political parties against their political opponents.

Because it was the current government abusing the act to use against their political opponents. Do you agree or disagee with this?

>This seems to be presented by you with apparent glee as a conservative vs green party/greenpeace/"antifa" or liberal issue.

If Canada is a free country and we do have fair and free elections. Inevitably the conservatives form government again. Andrew Scheer almost was prime minister.

I guess the glee comes from the above question. If you disagree and that the current government did not abuse the act to crush a peaceful protest. I will immediately agree with you and accept the precedent that this future conservative government gets to crush all dissenting political protests.

The glee you detect isn't glee. I very much disagree with this precedent. The government should NEVER be able to stop a peaceful protest. The glee is how absolutely tyrannical Trudeau acted.

>What you'll actually find is that broader society is just intolerant of the economic duress and disruptions caused by such protests.

Well first of all, this 'broader society' needs citation. The only people who suggest the majority of canadians agree with the use of the emergency act are the same media who called the protests a bunch of nazis. I dont accept state propaganda as facts sorry.

Also what economic duress and disruption? By the government's own admission in their required justification of the emergency act there was no blockades. The emergency act was used entirely and solely as part of the Ottawa protest. Blocking a few blocks in front of parliament. There is no economic duress here at all.

>Up to a quarter of Canadian-US trade was going through that area, and real people were suffering due to the trucker blockade. These economic disruptions had secondary effects that impact the lingering impacts of the pandemic and exacerbated supply chain issues.

1/4 of usa trade goes through downtown ottawa for no damned reason? Can you prove that in any way please?

Or do you mean the detroit bridge blockade? Not only was there 1 lane open, the detroit tunnel was completely unblockaded. Sarnia's bluewater bridge was not blockaded. Niagara falls, not blockaded. And cherry on top... the ambassador bridge dissolved BEFORE they even mentioned talking about the emergency act.

No, I dont expect you are trying to use a non-existent blockade as justification for national emergency. The only place the emergency act was used was in ottawa. Surely you are arguing 1/4 of usa trades has to drive in front of parliament?

>There is not a whit of moral equivalency between climate change protests and some truckers afraid of a needle.

If you say so. I do believe I get to decide upon my own moral decisions.

Here's really what's happened. Trudeau was misinformed greatly by the canadian media. He crushed the legitimate protest because he misunderstood why the canadian media called for the denazification of the protest. Trudeau absolutely acted tyrannically and has not fixed the situation.

The precedent is set, conservatives do NOT have the right to protest right now. All of the original reasons for the original protest still stand AND they've added new vaccine mandates making the reason for protesting to increase.

Without the right to peaceful protest.. it means other protest will now be required.

Re:Britain being forced to go cashless 'against its will' by drekk on Thursday March 31, 2022 @01:56PM (#30870279)
If conservatives want to lead an armed insurrection in Canada over "vaccine mandates" (reactionaries are so good at controlling the discourse with the words they force) they should go for it. Something tells me the consequence will be larger than not being able to swipe your plastic at the gas station.

Funny it took white people getting their bank accounts frozen for there to be noise that the government has too much power and wields it against citizens with impunity. Wonder how Trudeau's government treats the First Nations? Oh that's right, running oil pipelines through their land.

Only a certain demographic has had freedom of protest in Canada. Have you ever been water cannoned for defending your home and the groundwater of your community? But sure, conservatives are the new precedent about not being able to protest. No demographic has been harmed in Canada as deeply or egregiously as the conservatives who live underground now and trade in scrip

Re:Britain being forced to go cashless 'against its will' by incomingpain on Thursday March 31, 2022 @02:17PM (#30870494)
>If conservatives want to lead an armed insurrection in Canada over "vaccine mandates" (reactionaries are so good at controlling the discourse with the words they force) they should go for it. Something tells me the consequence will be larger than not being able to swipe your plastic at the gas station.

If you analyze protests lately like the 'mostly peaceful' burning riots of BLM etc. Which as a quick aside, BLM is fully justified in their protest.Police brutality and clear systemic racism is objectively true.

Compare that to the over the top peaceful protest in Ottawa. Which was intentionally that way. The protest policed itself to not give the media this. The media has been smearing conservatives for so long.

But more importantly, and clearly you went right to armed insurrection. Who said this was an insurrection. Notice also how January 6 went from insurrection to less than a riot. It's not even a riot, it's just an 'attack' now. Trudeau urgently wanted it to turn into an insurrection... the false allegation and propaganda was that the protest was looking to overthrow the government. Which isn't true at all. They sat outside in -20c on the road and NEVER insurrected or even tried to overthrow anything.

This just goes to prove how wrong all of this still is. Conservatives still do not have the right to protest.

>Funny it took white people getting their bank accounts frozen for there to be noise that the government has too much power and wields it against citizens with impunity. Wonder how Trudeau's government treats the First Nations? Oh that's right, running oil pipelines through their land.

Um... the protest in ottawa was disproportionately not white. https://notthebee.com/article/come-and-laugh-with-me-at-the-...

This was another case of Blackface Trudeau harming racial minorities. You bring up first nations...

https://twitter.com/TheRealKeean/status/1486399666677768195

https://twitter.com/BrianBeny/status/1487119890423205890

>Only a certain demographic has had freedom of protest in Canada.

Why do you think Trudeau hates racial minorities so much? Vaccine mandates disproportionately harm racial minorities especially black and indigenous canadians.

>Have you ever been water cannoned for defending your home and the groundwater of your community? But sure, conservatives are the new precedent about not being able to protest. No demographic has been harmed in Canada as deeply or egregiously as the conservatives who live underground now and trade in scrip

It almost reads like you read conservative = white people. How very incorrect.

Let me guess... you're not racial minority.

Re:Britain being forced to go cashless 'against its will' by cscurmudgeon on Thursday March 31, 2022 @02:38AM (#30864453)
The double standard here is quite interesting.

Trudeau backed the farmer's protest in India. Those protests were much more deadly.

https://www.timesnownews.com/international/article/when-the-...

Trudeau on protests in India:

> “I would be remiss if I didn’t start by recognising the news coming from India about the protest by farmers. The situation is concerning. We are all very worried about family and friends. We know that’s a reality for many of you. Let me remind you, Canada will always be there to defend the rights of peaceful protesters. We believe in the process of dialogue. We’ve reached out through multiple means to the Indian authorities to highlight our concerns. This is a moment for all of us to pull together,” Trudeau had said in November 2021.

Those were in fact not peaceful

> 1 journalist killed. One person lynched for alleged desecration. Over 1,500 telecom tower sites damaged by protestors (as of 28 Dec). Government buses and 30 police vehicles damaged on Republic Day.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2020–2021_Indian_farmers%27_pr...

Re:Britain being forced to go cashless 'against its will' by incomingpain on Thursday March 31, 2022 @08:02AM (#30866234)
Here's the other reality. https://www.ctvnews.ca/health/coronavirus/to-tackle-vaccine-...

Race plays a role in vaccination. Black and Indigenous Canadians are only around 50% vaccinated. Indian/Punjabis are somewhere around 70%. An awful lot of truckers are Indian. Especially from Quebec.

One of the original key issues that sparked this protest is the action by Trudeau to ban unvaccinated truckers and put them out of a job. This disproportionately harmed racial minorities including Indians.

The comparison or hypocrisy is that he supported the indian farmers but called the punjabi truckers a bunch of racists. It blows my mind.

Re:Britain being forced to go cashless 'against its will' by halostatue on Thursday March 31, 2022 @08:49PM (#30874009)
[citation required]

Canadian truckers were > 90% vaccinated at the time of the "Trucker" Tantrum. There were very few Southeast Asians in evidence among the tantrum throwers.

They were majority white (mostly because the Southeast Asian truckers in Canada are mostly vaccinated and were quite busy because the people throwing the tantrum weren’t actually working because they refused to get vaccinated).

Re:Britain being forced to go cashless 'against its will' by rosndo on Thursday March 31, 2022 @02:55AM (#30864545)
In the statement you quoted he seems to carefully avoid backing the protesting farmers, no?

I really don’t see how you could reasonably read that as a statement of support.

Re:Britain being forced to go cashless 'against its will' by cscurmudgeon on Thursday March 31, 2022 @11:50AM (#30868545)
He backs peaceful protests. Why not condem the violent portions of the same protest?

Why not similarly back the democratic legal processes?

Or are Canada's laws more sacred than India's laws?

Why not supoort peaceful protests in Canada?

Re:Britain being forced to go cashless 'against its will' by unmole on Thursday March 31, 2022 @01:46AM (#30864196)
A few questions:

1. Is blocking roads and blowing horns is equivalent to crashing planes into buildings and setting off bombs?

2. Were the truckers designated a terrorist entity under the Anti-Terrorism Act?

3. Was there an actual legal prohibition against financially supporting them?

Re:Britain being forced to go cashless 'against its will' by hoseja on Thursday March 31, 2022 @03:05AM (#30864612)
Terrorism is when you're inconvenient to a western government.
Re:Britain being forced to go cashless 'against its will' by TheOtherHobbes on Thursday March 31, 2022 @02:39AM (#30864454)
This is whataboutery. At the very least the truckers were an extremely unpleasant and potentially dangerous nuisance for everyone in the vicinity.

At worst were literally attempting regime change. They were also largely funded by the US far right, which has obvious links to Russia. In fact Russian propoganda was encouraging similar actions in the US and the EU.

So of course they were defunded.

It's always amusing to see libertarians complaining that a government shoots first - financially in this case, and only after a long delay - and asks questions later, when they're typically the people claiming loudly that far more extreme forms of violence are always legitimate in personal self-defence.

Just as with Jan 6, most of these people should have been jailed and those from the US should have been banned from entering Canada again.

Never mind the political angle, the nuisance and intimidation were more than enough to justify that.

Re:Britain being forced to go cashless 'against its will' by josephg on Thursday March 31, 2022 @03:06AM (#30864618)
I agree that the truckers were super disruptive. I’m glad some punitive action was taken.

But freezing the bank accounts of people who donated to them without due process is beyond the pail. Given that cash is mostly dead as a result of covid, banking needs to be considered a basic right. It shouldn’t be able to be revoked simply because the government doesn’t like what you do with your money.

Re:Britain being forced to go cashless 'against its will' by halostatue on Thursday March 31, 2022 @08:42PM (#30873968)
Claim made not in evidence. Legally frozen were the recipient accounts. Yes, contributors could have had their accounts frozen, but no evidence that the government ordered such an action on any donor.
Re:Britain being forced to go cashless 'against its will' by horns4lyfe on Thursday March 31, 2022 @10:49AM (#30867819)
“It’s ok to punish people with unsavory political beliefs, because of the Russians”. Where have I heard that before?
Re:Britain being forced to go cashless 'against its will' by unmole on Thursday March 31, 2022 @02:45AM (#30864489)
> This is whataboutery.

It is not. The parent comment compared truckers to Al-Qaeda. I pointed out the ridiculouslness of it.

> At worst were literally attempting regime change.

Regime change? You seem to be using words that don't mean what you think they mean

> They were also largely funded by the US far right

And?

> which has obvious links to Russia.

Those links are not obvious to me at all.

> It's always amusing to see libertarians

Rule of law isn't something that only libertarians care about. It's the very basis of liberal democracy.

I'm not going bother responding to the rest of your comment which quite frankly is unworthy of HN.

Re:Britain being forced to go cashless 'against its will' by Bancakes on Thursday March 31, 2022 @04:50AM (#30865146)
You sound severely self-centric and antisocial. Protests are a movement, and the noise they make are the extended arm that you are to grab and hop onto.
Re:Britain being forced to go cashless 'against its will' by kurisufag on Thursday March 31, 2022 @07:49AM (#30866149)
>It's always amusing to see libertarians complaining that a government shoots first - financially in this case, and only after a long delay - and asks questions later, when they're typically the people claiming loudly that far more extreme forms of violence are always legitimate in personal self-defence.

do you regularly see libertarians advocating for shooting the friends & family of an attacker, in your own words, "after a long delay"? this is a very poor comparison.