News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Humanly traversable wormholes (2020) by shireboy on Saturday March 26, 2022 @02:00PM (#30813886)
I wasn’t aware of the constraint that travel within wormhole must take longer than travel between the mouths. Given that, is there any real practical use for them? In scifi they are usually presented as shortcuts, but this constraint makes that seem less likely to ever be true.
Re:Humanly traversable wormholes (2020) by beecafe on Saturday March 26, 2022 @02:03PM (#30813904)
This constraint is needed because having a shortcut would allow time travel, like all FTL does.
Re:Humanly traversable wormholes (2020) by codethief on Saturday March 26, 2022 @03:56PM (#30814835)
But that's not a problem per se. The speed of light is only a limit locally but globally there is no such thing and in General Relativity there is nothing preventing time travel (closed timelike curves) at a global level, even though the existence of such curves is rather unlikely.

The paper notes:

> Interestingly, they are allowed in the quantum theory, but with one catch, the time it takes to go through the wormhole should be longer than the time it takes to travel between the two mouths on the outside.

Does anyone know why exactly "quantum theory" would impose such requirements? A priori to me it sounds like quite a stretch to take a local theory like quantum mechanics to make claims about the global topology of the universe, given that QM and GR haven't been unified yet. Unless of course by "quantum theory" Maldacena actually means "string theory" or "AdS/CFT" – which wouldn't surprise me at all.

Re:Humanly traversable wormholes (2020) by disentanglement on Saturday March 26, 2022 @06:34PM (#30815972)
> Unless of course by "quantum theory" Maldacena actually means "string theory" or "AdS/CFT" – which wouldn't surprise me at all.

The wormhole solutions from the paper are semi-classical: they are obtained by taking the expectations value of the energy configuration of a quantum theory and feeding that into the classical Einstein equations. Therefore, no string theory or AdS/CFT is needed for the construction.

Re:Humanly traversable wormholes (2020) by codethief on Sunday March 27, 2022 @12:09PM (#30821367)
Since it's part of the introductory chapter, my interpretation had been that the portion I quoted was supposed to be a general, well-known "law" implied by quantum theory, i.e. not a result specific to the situation at hand. Hence my question where that supposed law is coming from.

But it seems they were indeed merely announcing a result specific to the wormhole they constructed since on p. 6 the authors say:

> In deriving (2.12) we assumed that the distance d between the two black holes is smaller than l, d << l. Even when we do not make that assumption we find that the time through the wormhole is always longer than through the outside, πl > d.

Re:Humanly traversable wormholes (2020) by ben_w on Saturday March 26, 2022 @04:44PM (#30815192)
IIRC (I’m not a physicist), if you combine a closed timelike curve with quantum mechanics, then a random fluctuation in the photon field (which happens all the time) appearing in the middle of it will go all the way around, meet itself, and now there are two of them, then four, then eight, …

But as this is in a closed loop of time, from the outside it goes to infinity instantly.

Re:Humanly traversable wormholes (2020) by zozbot234 on Saturday March 26, 2022 @04:56PM (#30815286)
A closed timelike curve simply has to be consistent. It might reach a state where the fluctuations simply interfere with one another and reach some kind of non-infinity fixpoint, which always exists if there are no discontinuities.
Re:Humanly traversable wormholes (2020) by ben_w on Saturday March 26, 2022 @05:35PM (#30815564)
Given the way light works, I think the expectation is that all of the possible wavelengths will start doing this all the time — all the ones that interfere destructively will do so, all the ones that interfere constructively will also do so, but the former has a minimum of zero and the latter is unbounded, so one of these will just run off to infinity.

(It does feel like trying and failing to make one, getting asymptotically close should release infinite free energy as virtual photons almost get into a CTC, but IANAP).

Re:Humanly traversable wormholes (2020) by Beldin on Saturday March 26, 2022 @06:48PM (#30816049)
Huh. So maybe gamma ray bursts are wormholes opening/closing?

Yeah, that probably only makes sense in armchair physics. Which is all I'm licensed for anyway, so fine with me!

Re:Humanly traversable wormholes (2020) by ben_w on Sunday March 27, 2022 @07:46AM (#30819512)
Possibly even the entire universe, assuming CTCs and quantum fields actually did the things I’ve suggested, but you shouldn’t take this as more than merely speculative — I’m already making far too many assumptions for this to be taken more seriously than a sci-fi plot device.
Re:Humanly traversable wormholes (2020) by joe_the_user on Saturday March 26, 2022 @05:12PM (#30815417)
One thought I've had is that all time travel contradictions are based on conscious agents. Without a conscious agent who aims to change things, what happened is happened.
Re:Humanly traversable wormholes (2020) by karpierz on Saturday March 26, 2022 @05:15PM (#30815433)
That's not true, here's an example where it's billiard balls:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Novikov_self-consistency_princ...

Re:Humanly traversable wormholes (2020) by PeterisP on Saturday March 26, 2022 @09:21PM (#30816877)
Consciousness is about self-awareness and it does not strictly require nondeterminism or true free will; it is possible to have a universe with conscious agents who aim to change things and experience these changes, however their aims, choices, attempts at change and any success is fully deterministic, what happened is happened.
Re:Humanly traversable wormholes (2020) by arcastroe on Saturday March 26, 2022 @04:23PM (#30815051)
> FTL would imply time travel

But not "time travel" in the sense that you could go back and kill your grandfather. Only in the sense that different observers could not agree on the order of events.

And this doesn't seem so problematic to me. There always seems to exist some "true" order of events that results in the observations experienced by all observers, even if they don't agree based on their own individual knowledge.

Re:Humanly traversable wormholes (2020) by dghf on Saturday March 26, 2022 @04:46PM (#30815210)
ETA: my comment was more than a little confused. Original stands below.

What I should have said is that different observers can already, in the absence of FTL, disagree about the order of events with space-like separation, but it doesn't matter because by definition anything that happens at one such event can't affect anything happening at another.

FTL removes that restriction -- if something can travel faster than light, it can be present at two space-like separated events -- and that's what threatens causality, assuming something like the Novikov consistency conjecture doesn't hold.

========

Original comment:

> Only in the sense that different observers could not agree on the order of events.

But that's already true of events with space-like separation anyway. You don't need FTL travel for that.

With FTL, you run the risk of observers disagreeing about the order of events with time-like separation, so you are getting into grandfather-paradox territory.

Re:Humanly traversable wormholes (2020) by Andrew_nenakhov on Saturday March 26, 2022 @05:55PM (#30815705)
I still don't see why this would be a problem. Substitute light with sound and sight with hearing. We can exceed the speed of sound and produce noises that some observer would perceive in the incorrect order (in fact, happens all the time with supersonic jets). And the world doesn't seem to break because of that, no?
Re:Humanly traversable wormholes (2020) by foerbert on Saturday March 26, 2022 @07:29PM (#30816277)
It's not really about light. It's not so much the case that the speed of light is itself special, so much as it is that light (in a vacuum) travels at a special speed. That speed is effectively that of causality, in the 'speed of the ability to cause' sense.

Trying to make conclusions about that by using simple analogies to light isn't likely to get you anywhere. You're not dealing with the actual thing you're interested in in the first place.

Re:Humanly traversable wormholes (2020) by dghf on Sunday March 27, 2022 @07:36AM (#30819469)
I try to think about the speed of light as a geometric property of the universe, similar to how you can’t draw a straight line between two points on a circle that’s longer than the circle’s diameter.

I don’t know if that’s correct, but the analogy helps me (until I think about it too hard, and then my head hurts).

Re:Humanly traversable wormholes (2020) by dghf on Saturday March 26, 2022 @08:20PM (#30816567)
It’s not a matter of perception or “wrong” order: events that are close enough in time and distant enough in space that it is impossible to be present at both, even travelling at the speed of light — so-called “spacelike separated events” — do not have a single correct order.

Imagine you’re riding on top of a moving train carriage, standing exactly in the middle of its roof. Suddenly you see lightning strike the front end of the carriage, and simultaneously you see it strike the rear end. You know the strikes must actually have been simultaneous, because you’re standing exactly halfway between them: if the flashes arrived at the same time, they must have left at the same time.

However, from the perspective of someone standing at the trackside, you are moving towards the source of the front flash and away from the source of the rear flash. So the rear flash has further to go to reach you than the front flash. So the flashes can only reach you simultaneously if the rear strike happens first.

Who’s right? Do the strikes happen simultaneously or not?

Answer: both observers are right. Simultaneity, and the order of spacelike separated events, are relative, not absolute.

Re:Humanly traversable wormholes (2020) by knome on Saturday March 26, 2022 @09:57PM (#30817076)
This doesn't at all explain why short wormholes can't exist. The reasoning seems to be heavily about how an observer would see events transpire, but the observer is pretty inconsequential. The events happen. If they seem to come from two directions, or if we see them out of order, who cares?

It's not like we can't see a nova from three different points with the light coming after three different delays due to gravitational lensing.

If we had three black holes in a circle, with some light coming through the middle and the rest lensing around, the middle would seem like a shortcut compared to the lensed light that went around the three, but I fail to see how that, or the wormhole instance, matters at all other than to confuse the observer if they are unaware of the foreshortened distance.

Re:Humanly traversable wormholes (2020) by dghf on Sunday March 27, 2022 @05:16AM (#30818885)
Everything’s probably fine if there’s only one FTL wormhole, and no other method of FTL travel or communication: in that situation, the weird event order is a mere curiosity. “Look at that! In our reference frame, that spaceship left the wormhole before it entered it! Cool!”

But if a hostile observer sees the spaceship emerge from the wormhole before it enters, and they have access to FTL weaponry (or another FTL wormhole to fire missiles through), they could conceivably destroy the ship before it enters the wormhole, which would be a paradox.

(I think, anyway: this is my layman’s understanding.)

Re:Humanly traversable wormholes (2020) by Andrew_nenakhov on Sunday March 27, 2022 @05:54AM (#30819037)
But when the hostile observer will arrive to another end of a wormhole, the spaceship that had entered on that end has already exited from the other end.

What I don't understand is this time travel thing. Two events can happen simultaneously here and on Proxima Centaur, and both observers here and there will see that event in another system with 4 year delay. So what? Just like a speed of sound lags behind the speed of light, speed of light will just lag behind the actual events that take place. How is this time travel?

Re:Humanly traversable wormholes (2020) by dghf on Sunday March 27, 2022 @07:14AM (#30819375)
> But when the hostile observer will arrive to another end of a wormhole, the spaceship that had entered on that end has already exited from the other end.

Not necessarily. If the wormhole allows FTL travel, then the spaceship's entry into and exit from the wormhole are by definition spacelike-separated events. Such events have no absolute, universally applicable order. Therefore there is at least one reference frame in which the ship leaves the wormhole before it enters it. Note: it does not just appear to have done so; in the chronology of that reference frame, the ship leaves the wormhole, then sometime later it enters it.

See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Relativity_of_simultaneity

Re:Humanly traversable wormholes (2020) by Andrew_nenakhov on Sunday March 27, 2022 @10:41AM (#30820588)
Even if it simultaneity is relative, I still don't quite understand why it is a problem. Every local causality is observed. Take this [1] laborous attempt to explain this issue. They explain that 'you can see the message before it was sent'. NO! You can see the message before light from a distant star system delivers you info about it being sent! Like, a bullet arrives to target's head before he has a chance to hear the gunshot. Never a problem for snipers, shouldn't be a problem for FTL messaging either.

[1]: http://www.physicsmatt.com/blog/2016/8/25/why-ftl-implies-ti...

Re:Humanly traversable wormholes (2020) by dghf on Sunday March 27, 2022 @12:05PM (#30821328)
OK, try this one:

Lt Cdr Worf is testing the USS Defiant's impulse engines after a refit. He is currently coasting along in a straight line at a constant 0.6c, and passes Deep Space Nine. We'll call time on board the defiant t and time on board DS9 t', and say that the Defiant flies by DS9 at t = t' = 0.

At t = 10 minutes, Worf decides to reward his efforts with a cup of bahgol, only to discover the replicator is on the blink. After about another 10 minutes of pressing various buttons, he gives up and logs a ticket with the DS9 help desk over the subspace network.

Because the Defiant is travelling in a straight line at a constant speed of reference, it is in an inertial frame reference, and it is just as valid to see DS9 as moving away from the Defiant at 0.6c as the other way round, and this in fact is what we must do to work out what time on DS9 corresponds to "now" on the Defiant. At 0.6c, the Lorentz factor is 1.25: so for every 1.25 minutes that passes on the Defiant, a single minute passes on DS9 -- or put another way, for every minute that passes on the Defiant, only 0.8 minutes pass on DS9. So when Worf submits his ticket at t = 20 minutes, on DS9 it's t' = 16 minutes.

Subspace comms are instantaneous, or so close to it as makes no difference, so O'Brien picks up the ticket very soon after t' = 16 minutes. He replies straight away -- "Have you tried turning it off and on again?" -- and sends the response back over the subspace network.

This is where relativity of simultaneity comes in. DS9 is also in an inertial frame of reference, and in that frame it is the Defiant that is moving away at 0.6c, that has a Lorentz factor of 1.25, and where only 0.8 minutes pass for every minute on DS9. So for O'Brien, t' = 16 minutes is simultaneous with t = 12.8 minutes (not t = 20 minutes): allowing for time for O'Brien to read the ticket and write his response, Worf will receive it somewhere around t = 15 minutes -- while he's still tinkering with the replicator. Somewhat surprised, he tries the solution, it works, and he goes off to enjoy his cuppa, never sending the ticket he's just received a response to.

This is why FTL risks messing with causality.

Re:Humanly traversable wormholes (2020) by Andrew_nenakhov on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @12:35PM (#30844814)
Thank you for this elaborate answer, but this does not seem right. I am not very well versed in the StarTrek lore, but they use warp drives, which are alcubierre drives, so they expand and fold space to move, thus never actually achieving an FTL speed themselves. If we don't move at relativistic speeds, there would be no time dilation effects, so we'll always have t == t'.

Next off, I feel that this backwards inertial frame of reference is not right. But I'm too lazy to get into actual math so let's put this matter to rest until we get means of FTL travel or information transfer.

Re:Humanly traversable wormholes (2020) by knome on Sunday March 27, 2022 @08:13AM (#30819651)
They're seeing old light. Even if things are moving at FTL, they still have rational cause-and-effect.

Your weapon might reach the location where the ship had entered the wormhole faster than any telescope there could see light emitted from your star, but the ship will still have moved into the wormhole prior to exiting.

Assuming that to be able to send or receive FTL data implies breakage in causality itself seems pretty preposterous.

Seeing billions of years into the past when looking at distance galaxies doesn't imply that if we had FTL we would be able to affect them billions of years in the past. They have continued to move and emit light in all the billions of years since. It just hasn't reached us yet.

Re:Humanly traversable wormholes (2020) by dghf on Sunday March 27, 2022 @09:15AM (#30819966)
It’s nothing to do with old light. It’s to do with the relativity of simultaneity. Have a look at the Wikipedia article I linked to.

Or read these posts on Ask a Mathematician / Ask a Physicist:

- this one explains the basis of the phenomenon: https://www.askamathematician.com/2010/12/q-according-to-rel...

- this one explains the implications for FTL travel (and why it can result in time-travel): https://www.askamathematician.com/2011/09/q-hyperspace-warp-...

Re:Humanly traversable wormholes (2020) by dendriti on Saturday March 26, 2022 @10:20PM (#30817178)
You're assuming an objective reality. Events may not truly occur without an observer.
Re:Humanly traversable wormholes (2020) by mr_toad on Saturday March 26, 2022 @08:26PM (#30816592)
You could go back and meet yourself, then wait and both go back, etc, etc, with the number of ‘you’s growing exponentially until you caused a singularity. But of course the past, and the singularity would have already happened, which is still a paradox.

Substitute a virtual particle for ‘you’ and it seems that any potential path back in time runs into this paradox.

Re:Humanly traversable wormholes (2020) by akomtu on Sunday March 27, 2022 @04:25AM (#30818672)
That's only a paradox if there's one "true" arrow of time. If time is more like a chess position, and we are just making moves, then it's possible to have dead-ends or singularities without "contaminating" other positions.
Re:Humanly traversable wormholes (2020) by imglorp on Saturday March 26, 2022 @05:40PM (#30815610)
The most practical constraint is getting to one.

The paper indicates they will "resemble intermediate mass charged black holes". The nearest black hole at the moment, maybe a worm hole candidate, is V723 Monocerotis at 1500 LY away. This would be tens of thousands of years of travel.

So perhaps we can learn from afar but not visit.

Re:Humanly traversable wormholes (2020) by GordonS on Saturday March 26, 2022 @02:37PM (#30814153)
I was just about to say that same thing - any time I've seen wormholes in sci-fi (I'm reading Peter F Hamilton right now!), you go through in an instant (for all observers).

It's like sci-fi uses wormholes as a practical alternative to travelling at sub-C, relativistic speeds.

Re:Humanly traversable wormholes (2020) by dylan604 on Saturday March 26, 2022 @05:36PM (#30815574)
In Contact, <spoilerAlert> the pod drops instantly through from everyone's perspective outside the wormhole, but inside the wormhole 99 hours elapsed (potentially).
Re:Humanly traversable wormholes (2020) by tokai on Saturday March 26, 2022 @03:06PM (#30814400)
In the game Free Space there is travel time through wormholes (subspace jump nodes). In the finale the player intercepts and destroy the enemy flag ship as it is travelling through a wormhole to Earth.

Only scifi example I can think of wormholes with travel time.

Re:Humanly traversable wormholes (2020) by Aerroon on Saturday March 26, 2022 @04:06PM (#30814912)
Stargate has had time travel through wormholes in a few cases.
Re:Humanly traversable wormholes (2020) by JaimeThompson on Saturday March 26, 2022 @05:15PM (#30815436)
The wormhole in Star Trek Deep Space 9 had a travel time.
Re:Humanly traversable wormholes (2020) by ben_w on Sunday March 27, 2022 @10:53AM (#30820672)
Farscape has an episode where wormhole time travel happens.

How does time travel get presented in that game? Searching got me unrelated results.

Re:Humanly traversable wormholes (2020) by Rhinobird on Saturday March 26, 2022 @03:06PM (#30814402)
Yeah. Think teleporter instead of warp drive
Re:Humanly traversable wormholes (2020) by GordonS on Saturday March 26, 2022 @04:14PM (#30814975)
Yes, exactly what I meant, but said more succinctly!
Re:Humanly traversable wormholes (2020) by teeray on Saturday March 26, 2022 @03:38PM (#30814695)
> is there any real practical use for them?

An infinite source of power. Place one wormhole at the top of a hill, another at the bottom. Send rolling generators through them, stop them once in awhile to swap dead batteries for charged ones.

Re:Humanly traversable wormholes (2020) by ben_w on Saturday March 26, 2022 @05:24PM (#30815506)
I suspect that (if wormholes can actually be made) gravitational potential would be smooth throughout, and that you’d be pulled up as much while falling out of the top as you get pulled down while approaching the bottom.
Re:Humanly traversable wormholes (2020) by ars on Saturday March 26, 2022 @10:44PM (#30817298)
Keep in mind you can not create or destroy gravitational potential - you can only move it. Otherwise you have a discontinuity.

So you would have to start your wormhole with both mouths at the same place, and then move one mouth to the new location, with gravity "flowing" between them all the while.

Re:Humanly traversable wormholes (2020) by ben_w on Sunday March 27, 2022 @05:06AM (#30818839)
The word “flowing” is ambiguous, I don’t know if you’re agreeing with me or disagreeing with me.
Re:Humanly traversable wormholes (2020) by ars on Sunday March 27, 2022 @12:01PM (#30821279)
A change in gravitational potential (because you moved a mass) flows through normal space. It would do the same through the wormhole.

So I'm agreeing with you, and adding how this gravitational slope is created: It's created at the start of the wormhole and changes as you move the mouths of the wormhole, rather than popping into existence at a later time with the two wormhole mouths separated.

Re:Humanly traversable wormholes (2020) by teekert on Saturday March 26, 2022 @03:58PM (#30814843)
Something tells me the wormhole also costs energy.
Re:Humanly traversable wormholes (2020) by teeray on Saturday March 26, 2022 @05:11PM (#30815406)
Could you power the wormhole with its own energy output? Or would that mean the wormhole requires infinite energy to resolve the conundrum?
Re:Humanly traversable wormholes (2020) by krapp on Saturday March 26, 2022 @05:13PM (#30815426)
You can't resolve the conundrum. You can't have perfect efficiency or free energy. The laws of thermodynamics can't be cheated.

No matter what you do, you will get less work from the system than the energy you put in, and eventually entropy will eat everything. It doesn't matter if it works on paper, we don't live on paper.

Re:Humanly traversable wormholes (2020) by JPLeRouzic on Saturday March 26, 2022 @04:11PM (#30814950)
Or the wormhole will eat the place of the proposed experimentation?
Re:Humanly traversable wormholes (2020) by LadyCailin on Saturday March 26, 2022 @09:11PM (#30816826)
Continuing the hypothetical, seems like a hydroelectric station would be easier and more consistent.
Re:Humanly traversable wormholes (2020) by xwdv on Saturday March 26, 2022 @02:18PM (#30814019)
Well I think you might still experience time as a short trip but everything else would age as if you had completed the physical distance?
Re:Humanly traversable wormholes (2020) by remcob on Saturday March 26, 2022 @02:26PM (#30814084)
This holds true for regular travel nearing light speed too: For an external observer the spaceship never goes faster than light, but the passengers clocks slow down and they can experience arbitrarily high faster-than-light speeds.

For some reason I never see this discussed when people talk about FTL travel, maybe I'm wrong?

Re:Humanly traversable wormholes (2020) by bno1 on Saturday March 26, 2022 @05:37PM (#30815588)
It's because distances and time durations contract the faster you travel. The passangers don't experience faster than light speeds, just shorter distances.

This is how the twin paradox gets solved. The twin that leaves earth sees the trip as if it was shorter in both directions, so from their perspective it makes sense that they aged less than the twin that remained on earth.

Also, if you had infinite energy and you could travel at the speed of light you wouldn't feel any movement or time passing during your trip, it would feel like instantly teleporting from one place to another. Photons wouldn't feel their existence if they could. From their perspective they are produced in one place and instantly absorbed in another place.

Re:Humanly traversable wormholes (2020) by hiptobecubic on Saturday March 26, 2022 @03:51PM (#30814804)
I think because we use words like "faster" to mean "more stuff in less time," not just "feels like less time to you, but isn't."
Re:Humanly traversable wormholes (2020) by pcl on Saturday March 26, 2022 @04:58PM (#30815295)
Orson Scott Card’s sequels to Ender’s Game take this into account.