The bigger story here is what this means for the divide between tech-literate people and the rest of the population. I don't think the parent commenter was wrong to write their script, and I don't think I was wrong to write mine, and if you wrote something similar I think it was a reasonable move as well. But we have to recognize the advantage this gives us, as people who are able to spot these opportunities and act on them.
I don't have any answers, but I think this story brings up a good discussion. I'm curious to hear other people's thoughts on this.
You could probably poke holes in that system I just described, but it seems more fair than one that is prone to someone writing up a script to scoop it up. I don't want to live in a world of script wars where every desirable entity is quickly snatched by one of several competing computer programs.
The problem is that typically the person selling the item doesn’t care who gets it, so there’s literally zero incentive to spend any effort making a fairer distribution system.
Auctions are a great way to see that the item ends up in the hands of the person who “values” it most, where value is measured in currency. It does have the problem that in a system of high inequality the people at the bottom have essentially zero chance of winning.
The person selling the house wants to see offers as soon as possible and can accept one at any time--the sooner the better--or hold out for a better one if they're not satisfied. Any system that changes that dynamic to the seller's detriment is not "more fair" to the seller.
we expect that an auto mechanic gets a good deal getting his own car fixed, that real estate brokers have an edge getting their own properties, doctors with medical care, etc.
You spent years becoming tech savvy to save you a little time scanning real estate ads... I'm not sure what problem you're trying to fix?
Stocks should be traded this way, too. Having an arms race for fiber latency makes a mockery of the idea that they are for efficient allocation of capital. Queue up all the trades requested in each second/minute, then execute them in random order.
Where I live the good deals from private sellers (mostly older people) pretty much never get posted online, thus you would have to socially integrate somehow offline in the region you would like to buy a house :). It looks like I still have to wait for some cultural development to benefit from your proposed divide.
COVID vaccination slots were put online and would disappear the second they went up. Vulnerable people, like the elderly, had trouble booking the appointments they needed.
What ended up happening is a few developers got together and put together an alert system that scraped for appointment slots and automated alerts about when they were available publicly on social media. Quite a few people were able to get slots they wouldn't have got by just manually trying to get a slot.
And the people who played fair didn't get those slots. Obviously there's nothing illegal about this (or the articles similar solution) but it rubs me the wrong way morally. Similar to people getting appointments because they knew someone working in a vaccine centre. If there is a clear order and booking system (e.g. oldest + most vulnerable to youngest/national booking system) and you skip the line or 'hack' the system to give yourself a better chance at getting a slot I'd find it hard not to think you're a dick. NB: this depends a lot on how things work in your specific country so I'm not judging your specific situation but just generally, 'hacking' systems to give yourself an unfair chance at getting something in high demand feels wrong to me.
When I was looking for a new apartment one of my friends told me about his startup that was basically scraping databases of realestate companies and I signed up with them and to my surprise I was alerted for an apartment in the location I wanted and it was up just a few minutes so I was able to contact the agent before they even started their advertisements.
I got the apartment but sadly the startup was bought and shut down operations soon aferwards
I found this very unfair. Better would have been to let all the kids list there preferences and then fairly distribute the kids over the activities. However, I could see why the school wouldn't want to bother with this.
I ended up creating a tool (1) for them to do this easily. It's quite ugly, but it's open source (2) and it works. The tool is in dutch because it's a dutch school.
(1) https://eerlijke-indeling.nl/ (2) https://github.com/deliriouspenguin/eerlijke-indeling
We're in Beta so stability is still a goal we're pursuing, but for many happy paths Monitoro is a huge timesaver.
[0]: https://monitoro.co
Subverting a small aspect of the Hostile Environment[1] took a little bit of the edge of the general bastardry of the whole process. Still a bloody expensive and emotionally draining experience though: if it has to be done again, I won't be putting a loved one though that again and we'll both be leaving.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Home_Office_hostile_environmen...
Somewhat similar story for me. I live in a big European city where young people/students predominantly live in flatshares. One website which pretty much has a monopoly on room ads here also allows room seekers to post an inquiry themselves. So many people do it that after less than half an hour, your ad will already be somewhere at the end of page 2. I wrote a script to automatically update my ad every few minutes to push it back to the top. I ended up getting a lot of responses I probably wouldn't have gotten otherwise.
I wrote it in 2012 to automatically buy bitcoin once a week.
Serious major events use a lottery system, which is vastly more fair and means you don't need the server infrastructure to deal with this huge flood of requests. I'm not really sure why everything doesn't work like that: let people submit their requests/applications/whatever, and if you truly have zero other criteria, just process them in random order after a cutoff.
And it's not obvious how to fix it in a way that doesn't screw up the system for someone else:
- exorbitant cancellation fees would punish people whose plans change, and a lot of people would just swallow the extra cost anyway.
- insisting that the entire timeframe be in scope at time of booking would make it hard or impossible to book longer vacations at popular spots (which at this point is basically anything within 4h of Toronto).
- making the whole season available at once would create an ultra high stakes feeding frenzy, with the servers probably ending up crashing.
- some kind of bidding or lottery setup would be extra complexity, and would end up rewarding people with the time, money, and schedule flexibility to "play" whatever the system is.
I suppose the Ontario Parks mandate is to just maximize utilization, so from their point of view it doesn't really matter as long as weekends are booked solid and at least some proportion of the canceled midweek days end up being scooped up later by retirees or whoever.
Sadly after two weeks they banned my IP for the rest of the year and I was no longer able to make reservations without going through a proxy.
I have to imagine some sort of regulatory thing was going on here, like they have to provide X% of units at Y% of market rate in order to get some tax concession or something.
I know there's not going to be a lot of sympathy for higher housing prices here, but it does feel like something went wrong in this specific case.
There's also a goodwill aspect in other cases: Sony kept selling PS5s at MSRP even when scalpers were getting $800+, because better for them that people are pissed at the scalpers than dealing with the bad PR of such a huge price hike over previous generations.
It seems possible that a large housing developer has similar incentives.
Homo economicus would understand that the seller is simply being efficient. Homo sapiens gets all emotional about it.
If it’s a place you frequent, pay close attention. The checker is usually a stronger indicator of line speed than the number of items in peoples’ baskets.
Whole Foods near me does this awful thing where the lines are in the aisles. You can’t even see how long the line is without walking the entire length of the store.
On a personal note I found the practice irritating for not really clear reasons. One might be that it’s a chore to traverse the whole queue cordoning when it happens to be empty. In any case, over time being the one skipping the line when a new register opens averages out. Also, there’s the lucky draw feeling when you get to skip that otherwise gets lost.
I think the main thing that's maybe a bit annoying is just that it's easy for the single line to stall if the people at the front of it aren't paying attention or don't know what to look for. So the store often ends up having to have an extra attendant who just stands there and pokes people for when a till comes available.
When I got such a notification I would quickly check photos of the place etc. and then call the seller. The guy selling the place I ended buying, said it felt like I called him up instantly after he posted it online.
I was calling within 1 minute of post time sometimes.
Being first pretty much gets you anything you want in that section.
Our garages actually share a wall.
However, many students would snag a spot in a course only to drop it as they shuffled courses around. There existed a "queue" for the overflow, but it appeared to work as a CRON job or otherwise involved a human in the loop as one would routinely see:
Spanish 102 (Registered: (29/30), Queued:(60))
While in this state, one could simply click on the course and register, completely bypassing this poorly designed queue. So, naturally, I wrote a script to scrape the site on once a minute (hammering it, and so Project Thor) and alert me once a slot had opened up. Eventually provided this service to my friends as well.
The system was pretty smart, except for the part that you could bid negative amount of points on an elective that wasn't particularly popular and increase your total. That was a pretty major flaw.
[edit: I should say that I didn't use my extra points for anything. I wasn't particularly interested in the popular electives anyway. I did make sure to end the year with 10,001 points, hoping they would fix the bug, but I don't think they did.]
My script constantly looks for open/canceled spots and reserves them (some need email/phone confirmation, which makes it a bit harder). Pretty standard stuff.
That's how I got my appointment in 3 days instead of a month.
So, I'm thinking of making money from this, but I'm not sure about the legality of it all.
Sometimes you can just show up (and wait in a queue) but most often you make an appointment beforehand. In many states/cities, the waiting times are weeks and months long (even in my home city everything's booked a month ahead and you can see the big queues if you go in person).
People can indeed just refresh the page themselves and hope a spot opens up, but that's pretty annoying.
We had been looking for a new build for some time and had settled on a development and specific house we wanted to buy, but it was still months away from being released. We were told they released houses in person first, then listed them online later that day, but I was bored and wanted to see when new houses were listed, so I wrote a scraper to alert me whenever a new house became available.
One day, we got a call from the property developer telling us the house we were interested in would be available in person from 10am the next day. Because we wanted to be certain to get it, we appeared at 8am, only to find that 3 other people were already waiting. Houses are released in batches of 2 or 3, so whilst we weren't hopeful, we joined the queue and waited.
At 9am, while waiting in line, I got an alert telling me that the house had been released online, so I open their website on my phone and paid the deposit.
At 10am, when the sales office opened, all hell broke loose as the person first in line (waiting since 5am...) discovered the house they wanted had already been reserved online. I'd effectively stolen his house. It was awkward to say the least as all of us were crammed into a tiny portacabin while this unfolded.
In truth, I felt awful for depriving him of the house he and his family wanted, but relieved that we had reserved the house we wanted after a 5 month wait. A few weeks later the developer got in touch to say that they had changed their policy nationwide and would only be releasing houses online in the future because of "the incident"...
Whilst I wasn't willing to give up our reservation, I worked with the person who had wanted our house so that they were alerted whenever a similar house in the same development became available. He got one, there's no hard feelings, and him and his family are now my next door neighbours.