It really goes to show that nukes just shouldn’t exist- there’s no “counter” to them if the other side is suicidal
>I am admittedly not even close to an expert to what's going on over there...
Don't let that stop you from weighing in with your opinions. It doesn't deter the other eleventy billion people pontificating about this crisis in somewhere they hadn't heard of til a fortnight ago.The Russians have legitimate fears about the encroachment of NATO and American weaponry right onto their doorstep. You might want to look up a historical event called 'The Cuban Missile Crisis' to see how the US has acted in the past, in a similar situation [see also Nicaragua, Venezuela, etc]
The Russians believe that a democratically elected and pro-Russian government in Ukraine was over-thrown by a US engineered coup [Euro Maidan] and replaced by a fiercely right-wing anti-Russian regime, which is hell-bent on joining NATO and thus having American missiles stationed there [and Ukraine is a lot closer to Russia than Cuba is to America]
The Russians also say their citizens in the two breakaway regions are being genocided. Although that is, at best, an exaggeration used to justify the invasion.
Now, before you accuse me of being a Russian supporter or apologist, I'm not. I'm as outraged by this invasion as anyone else. But to simply pretend that it's all happened because evil mad dictator Putin has suddenly turned into Adolf Hitler reincarnated, while Uncle Sam has been innocently sitting on the sidelines, polishing his halo, is to bring a play school level of critical thought process to bear on the situation.
Unfortunately, Putin doesn't seem to care.
We need to stop thinking of nations as this one dimensional cult of personality of their leader.
I think Putin would have a very difficult time getting his generals to agree to nuking Kyiv.
That's the kind of order which leads to coups.
They just don’t know how much support they have
The default penalty for a slightly different perspective is 15 years in prison
The expected penalty is falling out of a first floor window
Everyone is surrounded by people vying for power that will double cross anyone to imprison their direct competitors
Its a prisoners dilemma that allows Putin to use his consolidated power unabated
Except if you would assassinate Putin.
Ukraine never joined NATO. Ukraine was never even given a membership action plan.
> and the west didn't care about his line drawing.
Neither did Putin; the moving red lines were about pretext, not reasoning.
THat's the point of nukes. Even if your economy and army suck, you still can be sure that no one will try to go through your borders to get some
Nukes have been around for less than a century, a blink of an eye in historical terms, and have already come close to obliterating the world multiple times. It only takes a single war to undue millennia of progress.
There have been several proxy wars between USSR and USA during the Cold War.
NATO should immediately begin a no fly zone over the Lviv region (with the possibility of widening it as necessary), in case Zelenskyy needs to leave Kyiv and or the Ukrainians generally need to establish a new base of government. They could shield that region / territory from Russia right now without prompting a Russia v NATO war, as it would require no attack on Russia to maintain near-term. If Russia tries to contest it, they're initiating the war, as they knew the area was protected by NATO forces. It would work as a maneuver. Putin could of course always claim that any move by NATO into Ukraine is an act of war, and or that Russia owns Ukrainian territory so any move by NATO into Ukraine is identical to invading Russia and other blatherings, but he can invent claims at any time to proclaim NATO started a war: the question is, can it be pulled off without sparking a war with Russia, and right now I believe it could be.
Rumors are they haven't seen him for days and he's out of the country now, setting up a government in exile, and continue waging a US-backed insurgency.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/national-security/2022/03/05/...
So many very serious people gravely explain that we must stand by and watch residential areas get shelled and rocketed to smithereens, creating a million refugees in the first week, as a democratic nation gets overrun by a mad dictator.
Apparently we have to do this because otherwise the mad dictator will irradiate Europe and maybe North America too.
But somehow the mad dictator won't split the atom if we only crater the mad dictator's economy and provide the weapons that kill his troops.
> ... with a lunatic
Do mad dictators have clearly demarcated red lines like that?
Seems like a truly mad dictator would unleash doomsday if he's losing the war, regardless of which side of the red line we're on.
It's well known that the secret to winning the game theoretical stalemate is to pretend you're irrational.
There are just so many ways this goes very badly, I don’t see how one can be optimistic.
If only playing crazy could get you anything you wanted life would be so easy for good actors. He could pretend he won, pack and go home. If his propaganda machine is so strong people will eat it and even if they don't there's not much they can do about it anyway. He may just need a pyrrhic victory he can sell domestically.
He keeps advancing and capture of Kiev is now only a matter of time.
And all the while, the sanctions will destroy his economy. No economy = no money to build more war machine.
Edit: read about it some more and Kiev appears to be the old name from the Soviet era which is not well accepted by Ukraine people. It's odd that we in Romania still use this old form given that Kyiv was proposed and accepted in 1995.
It's to shift into conquest mode and burn up your system. It's a non-sustainable move, and if you're going to do it, then typically they go for broader conquest (Moldova would be an example of expanding the conquest, as would formally taking Belarus). In normal times the economy is sustainable: you have $n GDP and $n tax revenue coming in, and you can do certain things with that stream. Sanctions crimp that heavily of course. So Putin can move to an unsustainable model, which means it'll collapse on him eventually, but people in his situation often do it anyway.
You do it by forced labor, labor gulags, forced building of manufacturing, total war mobilization of the large Russian population like it's WW2 again. Over time this would break Russia, near-term it would be a potent spike in their potential to march and conquer territory. The Germans did this during WW2, shifting out of sustainable economy to burn-it-up mode. It can't last indefinitely and it involves killing large numbers of citizens in the process. You have to redirect your economy into a command funnel, which starts to destroy all sorts of structures as you shift your resource allocations to war efforts (so for example Putin shifts labor resources to manufacturing tanks, and as a consequence there's not enough labor to operate grocery stores or repair potholes in the streets or whatever).
The Russian army hasn't been making progress against Kyiv for several days, and in fact Ukraine has been launching successful counteroffensives the last two days.
Russia has been successfully killing civilians though.
> Please don't post insinuations about astroturfing, shilling, bots, brigading, foreign agents and the like. It degrades discussion and is usually mistaken. If you're worried about abuse, email [email protected] and we'll look at the data.
He could probably just withdraw, no? Russia isn't under existential threat. Is taking Ukraine really the only option for Putin?
His only play is to act (?) even crazier.
'War' means nuclear war, means the death of probably a large portion of the world population. It's the thing we thought we could stop worrying about 30 years ago.
He doesn't like that he's clearly losing, so he's decided to threaten the end times if he can't get his way. And it might even work, if we truly believe he'll do it.
The problem is the best way he can prove that is to crack the atom over Kyiv.