News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The cold hard truth about electric vehicles in winter by sandworm101 on Friday March 04, 2022 @01:13PM (#30558269)
Sounds like you own a horse more than a car. If I have to plan my day around waking my horse up, feeding it breakfast, stopping so it can rest at a supercharger, arranging my bathroom breaks to suit its needs ... I would rather own a car.

I'm at work right now. I have not seen green grass since early November. It's currently -12c. Predictions for next week are lows below -20c. We had a good two months below -30, with a couple weeks touching below -40 in the mornings. Last year I had to drive to work once at -47c. My tiny Honda lives outside in the elements but always starts without complaint. It gets me to work each morning without fail. (Fyi,-40c is the same temp as -40f. -12c is about +10f)

Re:The cold hard truth about electric vehicles in winter by olyjohn on Friday March 04, 2022 @01:52PM (#30558787)
Wow so a lot of people go out and warm their cars up before they leave for work. I have done it on days where it's not even below freezing... You're really exaggerating the amount of work it is to warm up the Tesla.

And it also sounds like you're in a place where an EV doesn't make sense. They don't make sense for everybody, but that doesn't mean they aren't fine for the majority of people who drive. So don't buy an EV. I'm not sure that your argument makes sense for most people. I've never even experienced -40, or anything close, and neither have most people that I know.

Re:The cold hard truth about electric vehicles in winter by sandworm101 on Friday March 04, 2022 @02:04PM (#30558941)
The difference is that people warm up their car for comfort, not necessity. At sub-zero temperatures a modern gasoline-burning car[1] doesn't need to warm up for more than a few seconds, at least once it is properly started. The only practical reason to let them warm up before moving is to get some heat into the passenger compartment.

[1] The issues regarding diesel in winter is a whole other discussion. Diesel fuel is longer molecules and gets very thick in cold. Diesel cars/trucks/generators can have real issues in winter.

Re:The cold hard truth about electric vehicles in winter by Cd00d on Friday March 04, 2022 @02:13PM (#30559051)
But enough people do it for comfort that my last two cars came with remote start as standard.

You're being too negative saying starting your car early is the same as taking care of a horse, which undermines your point - it makes you look anti-EV and less sincere.

Re:The cold hard truth about electric vehicles in winter by SECProto on Friday March 04, 2022 @02:46PM (#30559458)
> The only practical reason to let them warm up before moving is to get some heat into the passenger compartment.

Which can be pretty critical for safety - my breath fogs the windows if I don't let the engine warm up for at least a couple minutes before driving when it's -20C.

Re:The cold hard truth about electric vehicles in winter by tharkun__ on Friday March 04, 2022 @06:02PM (#30561807)
This makes no sense to me. I drive at or around those temps all the time. Sure today it was only -16C but it has been like that for forever now. Like the GP since about November. Some breaks with warmer weather, some stretches of -25C for weeks on end.

I have yet to have my breath fog up the window even if I start the car and drive off right away.

Of course it's cold. Of course the radio display is sloooooow. You can feel how much slower releasing the clutch is. Can't get into first gear at all unless the car is fully stopped either. So rolling stops need to use 2nd gear.

Make sure you don't use the washer fluid. Scrape everything free. Even with pure "-40" fluid you will get it to freeze and you will have to wait or use the wiper fluid constantly until things get warm. Have the blower on de-fog for the windshield and even if you don't wait even a second before driving off you should have no issues at all. Even the cold moving air is enough to keep things fog free. And defog actually runs the AC too, not that it's needed when the cold outside air you're blowing onto your windshield there has much need to be dehumidifierd.

Re:The cold hard truth about electric vehicles in winter by SECProto on Friday March 04, 2022 @08:49PM (#30563212)
Not sure what to tell you. I do all those, obviously, I live in a place where I also experienced -25 for couple weeks straight straight (and never anywhere close to -40). Agree on clutch and LCD, agree on not using washer fluid and scraping the windshield properly, and I'd add on lift your wiper blades now that the sun has some heat as your wipers will easily freeze on top of the mini-greenhouse that is your dash. But if I hop in my car and drive away immediately, the windshield will be foggy before I've gone a km - regardless whether I have the compressor (defog) on or not.
Re:The cold hard truth about electric vehicles in winter by blake1 on Friday March 04, 2022 @03:58PM (#30560474)
It is necessary to let my internal combustion van warm up for at least a minute on a cold day, otherwise the steering and brakes feel heavy to me. Plus, I don’t like to think of the damage being done to the engine cylinders if I drive without letting the oil warm up. And it takes many seconds just to start.

Either way, it is not my experience that you can drive a combusting car “seconds” after ignition.

Re:The cold hard truth about electric vehicles in winter by ragingrobot on Friday March 04, 2022 @04:57PM (#30561156)
This has not been necessary for quite some time. With modern tolerances in manufacturing, it is not necessary, even wasteful (burned gas and small amounts of wear that add up over time) to warm up a vehicle.

It may have been another story at long ago with larger gaps between rings, differential expansion of materials, newer oil formulations and so on.

With my daily driver 1995 Grand Prix (which just a few weeks ago bit the bullet, non-engine related), I never, even in the coldest weather let it sit idling warming up. Most mornings even around 0F, I turned the key and drove off. It died with ~289,800 miles. It did not consume any oil or coolant, the spark plugs are clean as new.

In fact, driving off easy will warm the engine up faster than letting it idle.

Re:The cold hard truth about electric vehicles in winter by Schiendelman on Saturday March 05, 2022 @07:33AM (#30566965)
My partner’s 2017 Subaru asks us with an indicator to let it warm up on cold mornings.
Re:The cold hard truth about electric vehicles in winter by ragingrobot on Saturday March 05, 2022 @01:38PM (#30570483)
Interesting, I have never seen such a thing. Perhaps it's more for comfort than mechanical reasons?
Re:The cold hard truth about electric vehicles in winter by frumper on Friday March 04, 2022 @05:12PM (#30561306)
My Tesla auto warms up every morning on a schedule. If I didn't set the schedule it's literally a button tap on from my phone. That's a far cry from burdensome.
Re:The cold hard truth about electric vehicles in winter by eptcyka on Friday March 04, 2022 @02:14PM (#30559069)
I warm up my Pete car for engine longevity.
Re:The cold hard truth about electric vehicles in winter by sandworm101 on Friday March 04, 2022 @02:25PM (#30559210)
That was a bigger thing in the past. Once upon a time engines were made with different metals that expanded/contracted at different rates. Then is was a good idea to let the engine get all up to the designed temp before putting any load on the engine. And carburetors were sensitive to temperature too. But modern engines with modern tolerances are all built out of one metal, mooting most of the reason behind letting the engine warm up completely. I wouldn't go racing on a cold engine, but running at 2000rpm driving slowly won't do more damage than idling at 1500rpm. Some even argue that doing so will get the engine up to temperature more quickly, reducing wear.
Re:The cold hard truth about electric vehicles in winter by Lanolderen on Friday March 04, 2022 @03:57PM (#30560468)
New engines are however made en masse out of alu which expands more than iron/steel. The argument that driving reduces wear makes little sense to me since whatever you do outside of sitting in neutral (fast idling if need be/not already programmed into the ECU) is increasing stress on the components that are not (optimally) lubricated and at a tighter than optimal clearance. Then again manufacturers know people can't even wait 30 seconds so engines are designed with that stress in mind so it's not the end of the world.
Re:The cold hard truth about electric vehicles in winter by ragingrobot on Friday March 04, 2022 @05:01PM (#30561201)
Engines are lubricated almost immediately. The oil pump is typically camshaft driven, so it's only a matter of seconds before everything is lubricated. In addition, modern oils tend to "stick" to parts better and don't drain off as easily. It takes quite some time before they're completely dry.

As far as the material, at one time engines had components of various materials. Blocks of cast iron, heads or intake of aluminum. Now as you state, they are mostly aluminum. While it may expand more than steel, the majority of the components are going to expand at the same rate, unlike in the past.

Re:The cold hard truth about electric vehicles in winter by Lanolderen on Friday March 04, 2022 @06:51PM (#30562208)
Oils are definitely better but I really don't believe the marketing in winter. At low temperatures even modern oil has high viscosity. Combined with tight bearing clearances I firmly believe in waiting a bit to be sure everything is nicely coated. Maybe I'm just paranoid from horror stories of dudes getting on their bikes and ragging them right off the bat, seizing the engine.

I mentioned the aluminium mainly because piston slap came to mind. More slop, more slap. It's better than everything twisting though.

Re:The cold hard truth about electric vehicles in winter by landemva on Friday March 04, 2022 @08:27PM (#30563039)
I use full synthetic engine oil for cold weather startability, primarily.
Re:The cold hard truth about electric vehicles in winter by officeplant on Friday March 04, 2022 @04:23PM (#30560773)
Most of the car manuals for the last few cars I've owned (VW Passat, Kia Rio) all state to avoid excessive idling in general. Cylinder wash from unburnt gas at idle as the car warms up being the main culprit in engine damage. It rarely gets below 20F or so here so at most I start the car and give it a few seconds to get oil moving and once I see the revs come down its careful sub 2.5K rpm driving as the car warms up.
Re:The cold hard truth about electric vehicles in winter by Lanolderen on Friday March 04, 2022 @07:04PM (#30562323)
Weren't the excessive idling warning introduced as an emissions thing? Correct me if I'm wrong. Just did a little search and found a nice compilation of user manual info regarding startup procedure [1] and they all pretty much go on about wasted fuel.

[1]https://info.ornl.gov/sites/publications/files/pub61263.pdf

Re:The cold hard truth about electric vehicles in winter by cryptofistMonk on Saturday March 05, 2022 @10:30AM (#30568356)
> sounds like you're in a place where an EV doesn't make sense. They don't make sense for everybody, but that doesn't mean they aren't fine for the majority of people who drive. So don't buy an EV

Sounds great, the problem is when law makers get involved - BC is banning the sale of ICE vehicles within the next 10-15 years, the law is already on the books. Plenty of real cold places here, not to mention the fact the our electrical grid will never be able to keep up

Re:The cold hard truth about electric vehicles in winter by CosmicShadow on Friday March 04, 2022 @02:12PM (#30559041)
Sounds like you don't live in Canada.
Re:The cold hard truth about electric vehicles in winter by SECProto on Friday March 04, 2022 @02:48PM (#30559479)
Most of Canada doesn't live in Canada, if your standard is "months of -30 and lows hitting -40". That's pretty much constrained to the prairies and the territories.
Re:The cold hard truth about electric vehicles in winter by ketralnis on Friday March 04, 2022 @02:33PM (#30559320)
Also sound like they don't live in Botswana. So?
Re:The cold hard truth about electric vehicles in winter by CosmicShadow on Friday March 04, 2022 @04:42PM (#30561005)
"I've never even experienced -40, or anything close, and neither have most people that I know."

I can easily say that most of the people I know haven't not experienced -40, it just depends where you live.

Re:The cold hard truth about electric vehicles in winter by SECProto on Friday March 04, 2022 @05:36PM (#30561543)
Vancouver Island&lower mainland, as well as the eastern half of Ontario, southern half of Quebec, all of NB, NS, PE, Newfoundland - none of these places experience -40, and contain give or take 28 of Canada's 38 million people
Re:The cold hard truth about electric vehicles in winter by tharkun__ on Friday March 04, 2022 @06:38PM (#30562100)
I wonder what you call the southern half of Quebec. Quebec goes way up north. Southern half of Quebec would exclude almost the entire population of Quebec.

But let's assume you meant stuff close to the US and Ontario border vs. Quebec City. I had to find something where Weathernetwork had data and for some reason the border crossing town of Lacolle, which is about as far south as Quebec goes showed no data but Hemmingford is the same height, just a bit to the west:

https://www.theweathernetwork.com/ca/monthly/quebec/hemmingf...

Now you are right in that -40 is not a temperature that will be had for a long time, that is relegated to the prairies. It also does not happen every year. It's seldom that it dips that low. But here some close enough for my taste examples:

Jan 24: -33.3C Jan 26: -34.1C Jan 27: -34.1C Jan 28: -32.7C Jan 29: -33.1C

And then if you look at the Laurentians, which is a popular ski and overall winter destination for the millions of people living in and around Montreal and both of these are basically just going "straight up north" (as in highway direction, not map direction) from Lacolle, these temperatures become more frequent and it's more likely to dip that low more often. And all of these are way south of Quebec City. Climate change is not helping, i.e. more historical data would be better. Weather network doesn't seem to have that.

I definitely know more people that have experienced -40C in their life than ones that don't. I have and I do not live in the prairies.

Re:The cold hard truth about electric vehicles in winter by SECProto on Friday March 04, 2022 @08:42PM (#30563162)
> I definitely know more people that have experienced -40C in their life than ones that don't. I have and I do not live in the prairies.

Yes, the -40 is what I was using for my differentiator. You provided an example of a location that didn't come anywhere close to -40.

Pretty much everyone I know complains about it being -40 out, but it never actually is (they're all talking about -30 with a strong windchill). It is particularly egregious to me, as the difference between -30 and -40 is as significant as -15 (standard chilly) and -25 ("ok I hope there's no wind today"). And when it comes to a technical discussion about something like battery temperature, those few degrees matter a lot.

> I wonder what you call the southern half of Quebec. Quebec goes way up north. Southern half of Quebec would exclude almost the entire population of Quebec.

Yes, I was not being geographically precise - I was mostly referring to the St Lawrence Valley, which contains most of Quebec's population. Obviously Saguenay, etc would have experienced -40. I basically just checked environment Canada's historic records for Montreal, Quebec, and Trois Riviere. It wasn't intended to be terribly precise.

Re:The cold hard truth about electric vehicles in winter by tharkun__ on Friday March 04, 2022 @09:08PM (#30563353)
Fair enough on the exact temp and like I mentioned, yes it seldom is actually -40C. I've seen it on a thermometer tho and like you say, you really just don't want to be outside. I don't live in that place though, so no idea how often that would happen.

Environment Canada is a good one, didn't think of checking that for historical data. Makes sense tho come to think of it. Another thing is the real local conditions vs. actual weather stations. I've seen quite a difference between my thermometers (that all agreed with each other within a degree) vs. what various online sources provided for our location. The next actual weather station where I am is ~15km straight line distance from here for example.

Re:The cold hard truth about electric vehicles in winter by cogman10 on Friday March 04, 2022 @02:19PM (#30559131)
You don't stop at gas stations when you are doing road trips? You don't plug your car into a heater to make sure it will start (I assume yes because you are hitting -40C. That requires an engine block heater or housing for your "horse"). You don't take your horse to the vet every 3000 miles to give it dialysis (oil change).

To heat up my Tesla, I pull up the tesla phone app and tap the "preheat" button. That's it. I keep it plugged in when it's at home (takes me less time to plug it in than it takes you to fill up your car with gas). While my tesla charges, I'm usually doing other stuff at home. It's completely neglected (the poor thing). All in all, the ONLY time I might wait additionally on my EV vs a gas car is when I go on longer road trips (450+km). That's somewhat rare.

And I don't have oil changes, engine problems, etc. The only maintenance I've done are new tires, car washes, and window wiping fluid. This is with a 2018 long range model 3 with 110,000km.

My tiny tesla doesn't have a "start", it is effectively always on. I've never worried that I can't put it in gear and start driving.

Re:The cold hard truth about electric vehicles in winter by krzyk on Friday March 04, 2022 @02:33PM (#30559309)
Why heater for engine block in -40? I haven't heard about such thing, the only issues I know is for Diesel engines in low temperatures but gasoline ones?
Re:The cold hard truth about electric vehicles in winter by sandworm101 on Friday March 04, 2022 @02:37PM (#30559354)
Most people still opt for block heaters in cold weather (<-20). They used to be standard on all cars sold in Canada/Alaska. I use mine when a plug is available. It keeps the engine oil from thickening, making it easier to crank the engine during start. Imho a battery heater is more effective as it increases the cranking power available to the starter. Many use both.
Re:The cold hard truth about electric vehicles in winter by officeplant on Friday March 04, 2022 @04:25PM (#30560804)
Battery heaters can be fairly important at temps that low just to prevent it from an early death.
Re:The cold hard truth about electric vehicles in winter by sonofhans on Friday March 04, 2022 @02:12PM (#30559039)
> Sounds like you own a horse more than a car. If I have to plan my day around waking my horse up, feeding it breakfast, stopping so it can rest at a supercharger, arranging my bathroom breaks to suit its needs ... I would rather own a car.

This is without a doubt the best take I’ve read on EVs. Certainly they fit many use cases, and certainly they’ll improve to fit more in the future. In the meantime, the hoops that some fans jump through to justify their suitability for tasks at which they’re inadequate are amusing.

Re:The cold hard truth about electric vehicles in winter by cogman10 on Friday March 04, 2022 @02:24PM (#30559200)
Did you read the article? Barring a few exceptions, most EVs have 88%+ of their range in freezing cold weather. Those EVs also tended to have longer range in general.
Re:The cold hard truth about electric vehicles in winter by sandworm101 on Friday March 04, 2022 @02:30PM (#30559279)
I read the article. A 41% loss when I need to run the heater is totally unacceptable.

>> AAA found the loss in driving range could be as high as 41% with the heater on full blast.

Re:The cold hard truth about electric vehicles in winter by cogman10 on Friday March 04, 2022 @02:42PM (#30559414)
Here's the AAA article in question [1]

Notice, that these are all 2018 or older models. Why does that matter? Because battery capacity has increased and newer models have heatpump heaters (which are roughly 4x more efficient).

This is the primary difference in range in the opening info-graphic on the page. Why for lower temps some cars only lost 10% of their range while others lost 40%.

But further, WHY is 40% range loss "totally unacceptable"? What is acceptable? How do you deal with range loss of ICE from overly hot weather?

[1] http://www.aaa.com/AAA/common/AAR/files/AAA-Electric-Vehicle...

Re:The cold hard truth about electric vehicles in winter by thayne on Friday March 04, 2022 @09:18PM (#30563436)
> Notice, that these are all 2018 or older models

I've never bought a car newer than 5 years old. And it looks like the EVs that handle cold better tend to be the more expensive models and brands. So the problem here isn't so much that no EVs work in the cold, as that it reduces the economic feasibility of using an EV for many people.

> But further, WHY is 40% range loss "totally unacceptable"?

Because EVs often already have smaller ranges to begin with, have fewer charging stations than gas stations, and take longer to charge, and a significant decrease in range exarcerbates those problems, and may make an EV completely impractical in some situations. Hopefully all those things improve in the future.

Re:The cold hard truth about electric vehicles in winter by landemva on Friday March 04, 2022 @08:29PM (#30563062)
Are there any concerns about cold weather charging?
Re:The cold hard truth about electric vehicles in winter by shard on Friday March 04, 2022 @04:10PM (#30560629)
Any horse owners here who can speak up? Major differences that come to my mind are exercise requirements, socializing time, health care (grooming and vet care), stable cleaning, needing a stable at the work location. And how far can you take horses in -40c?
Re:The cold hard truth about electric vehicles in winter by jazzyjackson on Saturday March 05, 2022 @12:54AM (#30564720)
> And how far can you take horses in -40c?

I had to check, because I know Siberians don’t just stay inside all Winter in the bad old days (actually I learned from “Gift of the Raven” that siberians travel less nowadays because they can only carry so much gasoline, whereas old fashioned beasts of burden are self refueling aka eat grass under the snow)

Check out this winter adapted horse, complete with antifreeze coursing through its veins:

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yakutian_horse

Re:The cold hard truth about electric vehicles in winter by earleybird on Friday March 04, 2022 @09:53PM (#30563684)
Well, my dad tells stories of their "self driving wagon". Take the wagon (or sled in the winter) in to town, do a bit of shopping (or picking up mail order goods) and head home in the evening. The horse knew the way home (in the dark even). I'm hoping some day to have a car as smart as my dads horse. :-)
Re:The cold hard truth about electric vehicles in winter by officeplant on Friday March 04, 2022 @04:28PM (#30560830)
>socializing time

I've now come to realize that part of me looks forward to having a chat with people at charging stations in 2035.

Re:The cold hard truth about electric vehicles in winter by gwbas1c on Friday March 04, 2022 @07:12PM (#30562386)
> Sounds like you own a horse more than a car

Yes, long trips require more planning. That will change once high speed chargers are more common.

> Sounds like you own a horse more than a car

The situation is extremely different for day-to-day driving.

When I owned a gas car, I had to put gas in it about once a week. Each stop at the gas station was about 10 minutes out of my way. Now I charge in my garage and I never need to go out of my way to buy gas.

I also don't need to deal with oil changes.

My gas car was a lot more of a "horse" than my Tesla!

Re:The cold hard truth about electric vehicles in winter by gwbas1c on Friday March 04, 2022 @06:26PM (#30562004)
Where you live, EVs only make sense if you have a very big battery.

Edit: The reason to heat up an EV's battery on a cold day is for regenerative breaking. You don't have to, the car just drives a little weird until the battery heats up otherwise.

Re:The cold hard truth about electric vehicles in winter by BobbyJo on Friday March 04, 2022 @02:30PM (#30559269)
Never buy a car with a high PSI turbo then. I owned a 2010 Mazdaspeed3 and a 2016 WRX and I felt like they both always needed an oil change.
Re:The cold hard truth about electric vehicles in winter by gameswithgo on Friday March 04, 2022 @01:16PM (#30558300)
An EV would also get you to work each morning without fail, unless you are 200 miles from work. It doesn't even need to start up.
Re:The cold hard truth about electric vehicles in winter by sandworm101 on Friday March 04, 2022 @01:25PM (#30558441)
My nearest airport is 200miles away, 400 for the trip. I will be making that drive next week to pickup a work college.

I believe that Tesla and every other lithium-using EV only rates their cars to -30c. Below that might void a warranty, a financial risk I cannot afford. And I shudder at the concept of DRM deciding to brick my car because it is "too cold to drive". That nightmare is coming at us soon. I will then be in the market for a snow machine, which are regular on major roads in my area when the weather is really bad.

Re:The cold hard truth about electric vehicles in winter by c0nfused on Friday March 04, 2022 @01:36PM (#30558590)
I think the current guidance is not below -30 for more than 24 hours because the battery coolant will freeze and then everything blows up.

Based on your weather reporting. I would stick with ICE. As heat isn't free on an electric car in general. So, at the more extreme ends of the spectrum it will be hard to beat ICE

Re:The cold hard truth about electric vehicles in winter by sandworm101 on Friday March 04, 2022 @01:40PM (#30558640)
In our town (about 15,000 people, about 1/2 military-related) there are only a handful of EVs, and only two Teslas. Everyone knows who owns them. They all hibernate through winter in warm garages beside giant ICE pickup trucks. They are just fashion statements rather than 24/7/365 daily drivers. EVs are not an option for those of us who cannot afford multiple vehicles.
Re:The cold hard truth about electric vehicles in winter by JoeAltmaier on Friday March 04, 2022 @01:49PM (#30558753)
The chart in that OP only goes down to freezing. Where I live it hasn't gotten up to freezing this winter but four or five days. It's been single-digit or subzero for months.

Likely that EV is not going to work here, not reliably. There's something to be said for ICE.

Re:The cold hard truth about electric vehicles in winter by sandworm101 on Friday March 04, 2022 @02:11PM (#30559028)
They might be reliable, but with reliably poor performance. A battery-powered EV relies on chemical reactions and all chemical reactions are sensitive to temperature. Hot or cold, it will always be an issue for everyone beyond socal.
Re:The cold hard truth about electric vehicles in winter by Alan_Dillman on Friday March 04, 2022 @03:48PM (#30560339)
It certainly would need to run for a bit to thaw out the window and warm the passenger compartment. One cannot just push start and drive off in climates with actual frost and snowfall.