News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Asian-Americans fight back against school discrimination by tyjen on Tuesday March 01, 2022 @11:44PM (#30523840)
I'm a confused by the equity claim to justify discriminatory behavior with what seems like heavy emphasis on race. It seems difficult to achieve equity without transparent, and standardized methods emphasizing a holistic assessment covering visible and invisible, immutable and mutable characteristics--each of which impact individual outcomes.

I understand that tackling overrepresentation and underrepresentation is important; but, when emphasizing race to the degree that these academic institutions are, isn't this leading to representation disparities within the racial categories themselves? The racial categories are a very American centric and limited term, and arguably rooted largely as social constructs that loosely define the ethnic populations they cover. For example, and I don't mean any offense or to call any group out specifically, Koreans are overrepresented compared to Cambodians at the academic institutions listed in the article per their population proportion. This doesn't seem to be captured and accounted for under the current system. The same underlying disparity potentiality applies to whites, Blacks, Hispanics, Native Americans, etc...

The interpretation being, that it's a sort of half-committed approach to equity that isn't really leading to equitable outcomes if that makes sense, and may even be exacerbating ethnic marginalization within the racial categories.

Another question is, if this isn't leading to genuine equity of outcomes and instead passing discriminatory behavior onto smaller, marginalized ethnic groups, what do you do then? Do you revisit implementing an improved meritocracy system, or implement an equity based system with greater accuracy and precision to prevent this?

This doesn't even begin to tackle the issues current racial categorization creates with multiracial people and the essence of "purism."

Re:Asian-Americans fight back against school discrimination by roenxi on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @12:10AM (#30523996)
> ... when emphasizing race to the degree that these academic institutions are ...

There is a fairly classic manoeuvre where the elites feel threatened by the middle class, so they form an alliance with the lower classes to fight them. Eg, a lot of tax & spend policies make it harder to accumulate wealth in the middle class but the very wealthy can shield themselves.

If Asians are not benefiting from being a racial minority, I do wonder if admission policy is focused more on race or more on excluding people who look middle class. I see some mention of Harvard. The point of Harvard is to politely set up the next generation of leaders. Not educate the masses.

Possibly the article offers a view on this, but it is paywalled.

Re:Asian-Americans fight back against school discrimination by weq on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @01:40AM (#30524460)
100% this is poltical properganda. Asians are conservative gold-mines in Australia. Somehow our version of the Republicans have convinced them they are on their side, while also playing the jobs saviour for the working class and being anti-asian. its a schitzophrenic relationship underscored public debts subsidising private profits.

The only this article points out correctly is that "Elite" universities, and therefor most modern day research in every field, is tainted by Racist Aristrocratic idealogies. They protect their own kind at the expense of all others.

If you are dreaming of an elite school, you are the problem. You give them power.

Re:Asian-Americans fight back against school discrimination by BadCookie on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @01:19AM (#30524357)
It would be more fair to create admission quotas based on family economic status, but I can’t imagine that would ever be put into practice because it would hurt the wealthy too much. The universities wouldn’t like the financial impact either. But if true equality of opportunity were the goal, then that’s how you’d need to do it I think.
Re:Asian-Americans fight back against school discrimination by giveyouareply on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @01:49AM (#30524512)
It can be gamed.

A long while back at University, I noticed very wealthy students on student income schemes that were only meant to be accessed by students whose parents qualified as low income status. The bar to qualify was quite difficult, if you had one parent employed in a job then it was unlikely you would qualify.

I asked how they could qualify, while almost everyone had to work part time jobs to cover costs.

It turns out their parents paid themselves a very low salary in order to qualify.

Re:Asian-Americans fight back against school discrimination by sdoering on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @02:24AM (#30524734)
I remember nearly the same in Germany. When I was at university governmental student loans were a thing (still are). I didn't qualify, as my single dad earned too much (while having to pay the credit on the house and money was always tight). I worked two jobs next to my university.

Quite a few economics and law students driving new BMWs, Mercedes and the likes received student loans (they only needed to be paid back in part, so quite a good investment to cover living expenses one could say) as their parents mostly lived from dividends with the family income from salaries (from their parent owned companies) were by design very low to reduce tax burden and had the nice side effect for their daughters and sons to qualify for government subsidized student loans.

The system is setup to be gamed by those who have the financial means to do so without actual need to do so. While those with a need but no means need to pay (for those others).

It was quite grotesque. Not few of these kids had higher end cars and more spending money than their professors. While still being subsidized by the state.

Re:Asian-Americans fight back against school discrimination by lordnacho on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @04:39AM (#30525527)
Seriously? So for instance I could just pay myself double this year and nothing next year from my personal corporation, and my kid would somehow pass as having a low income parent?

Surely you have to count things like dividends, income in previous years, assets...

Failing that just make it clear that you know when you're tricking the system and fingers will be pointed.

Re:Asian-Americans fight back against school discrimination by aiisjustanif on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @04:09PM (#30533193)
Nope, FASFA doesn’t even look at previous years, you could be poor now and not later as far as they are concerned. We could do a lot more research into each families situation but that’s a lot of time,effort, and probably very expensive.

You could also get married young and hide it.

Re:Asian-Americans fight back against school discrimination by lordnacho on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @04:12PM (#30533243)
> You could also get married young and hide it.

What's the significance of that?

Re:Asian-Americans fight back against school discrimination by TulliusCicero on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @02:49AM (#30524875)
I was easily able to get federal money for college even though my parents were doing fine and supporting me. I didn't cheat or lie or even bend the rules, I just had a secret power: I was married. Because of that, my parents' financial status wasn't even entered into the picture. It didn't even come up on any form.
Re:Asian-Americans fight back against school discrimination by seanmcdirmid on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @01:36AM (#30524447)
> but I can’t imagine that would ever be put into practice because it would hurt the wealthy too much.

It definitely would hurt their bottom lines, since most of the private elites also provide non-loan financial aid out of their endowments to people who can’t otherwise afford to go. That only works if only a few poorer people make it over the bar.

Public schools should step up more here, as it is their mission.

Re:Asian-Americans fight back against school discrimination by MontyCarloHall on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @07:21AM (#30526529)
> That only works if only a few poorer people make it over the bar.

That is not true. The per-capita endowment of Harvard (and other schools of its caliber) is so large that it could afford to entirely eliminate tuition[0]. Currently, approximately 60% of students receive some sort of financial aid, and 20% pay no tuition at all[1]. These figures are similar at other similar schools.

[0] https://www.businessinsider.com/harvard-should-stop-charging...

[1] https://college.harvard.edu/guides/financial-aid-fact-sheet

Re:Asian-Americans fight back against school discrimination by x3n0ph3n3 on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @12:01AM (#30523944)
> The racial categories are a very American centric and limited term, and arguably rooted largely as social constructs that loosely define the ethnic populations they cover. For example, and I don't mean any offense or to call any group out specifically, Koreans are overrepresented compared to Cambodians at the academic institutions listed in the article per their population proportion. This doesn't seem to be captured and accounted for under the current system.

You've really hit the heart of the logical conclusion of intersectionality that those espousing it fight to avoid: individualism. Once you have to start accounting for subgroups of subgroups, you reach the fact that the smallest subgroup to account for is an individual person.

Re:Asian-Americans fight back against school discrimination by pessimizer on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @09:09AM (#30527442)
While Asians not being fungible has something to say about individuality (although not much), I don't know what it has to do with "intersectionality." It's very difficult to be Cambodian yet not Asian. Being both Asian and Cambodian is not an "intersection."
Re:Asian-Americans fight back against school discrimination by x3n0ph3n3 on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @02:08PM (#30531430)
It's not about the intersection of the group with the subgroup, but the fact that the group is not a good proxy for the individual. The subgroup is a _better_ proxy, and each further subdivision becomes closer and closer to clearly representing the individual. Ultimately, the person being an individual is the highest fidelity subdivision.
Re:Asian-Americans fight back against school discrimination by ThrustVectoring on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @02:04AM (#30524589)
For elite universities in particular, I doubt they care about racial equity for its own sake. Instead, it's a component of their strategic interests, to wit:

1. Admitting children-of-elites for funding and advancement purposes 2. Admitting extremely high-competent students to build an alumni reputation 3. Maintaining a demographics profile that the general population will see as legitimate

Fundamentally, today's racial quotas and preferences are in place for the same reason as why Harvard discriminated against Jewish students in the 1920s and 30s. If they didn't, the university would be seen as an attempt by outside demographic groups to install elites by a significant section of the population.

Re:Asian-Americans fight back against school discrimination by tootie on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @09:45AM (#30527863)
NYC is going through the same thing and it's really awful. They have danced around a wild mix of policies to encourage meritocracy through testing, school choice across boroughs, charter schools. I am all for equity and inclusion, but achieving it by changing the rules of admission to top schools is the lamest answer. What we need are for schools to be better. Let's stop having so many bad schools that people run away from. Unfortunately, that's the hard problem we don't have an answer for. And the author of this article isn't presenting any decent solutions either.
Re:Asian-Americans fight back against school discrimination by uejfiweun on Tuesday March 01, 2022 @11:51PM (#30523882)
You have to understand, this is the last dying throes of a liberal fire that has been raging for hundreds of years. Liberalism has achieved great things in the west, including expanding the rights of women, minorities, and LGBT individuals. We are all better off for its achievements. However, the low hanging fruit is taken, and now the same activists that once fought for noble goals are reduced to taking ever more divisive measures in pursuit of an unattainable ideological purity. The hyper focus on race, the election of Trump, the increasingly bizarre language of the modern liberal intelligentsia - these are all symptoms. Expect these crazy racist programs & ideas to intensify in the next 10 years until the whole movement collapses in on itself like a dying star (it may have already started, look at SF school board elections).
Re:Asian-Americans fight back against school discrimination by SyzygistSix on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @07:59AM (#30526822)
You make it seem like the US no longer has an issue when there's an entire class of people who are not being educated, has high crime, and ending in mass incarceration.

I can accept that some people have an issue with current liberal ideas because they think they don't work. If so, what is going to work? Or is the current state inevitable in order to have the high-functioning economy that the US has?

Certainly more Harvard grads isn't the solution. But finding a path to even good high school educations and any college has been elusive to say the least.

Re:Asian-Americans fight back against school discrimination by scarmig on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @09:35AM (#30527749)
> there's an entire class of people who are not being educated, has high crime, and ending in mass incarceration.

Men?

Re:Asian-Americans fight back against school discrimination by SyzygistSix on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @09:53AM (#30527969)
Definitely especially men, specifically poor men in urban and rural places. Obviously the relevant issues are not going to all be solved at Harvard. But the people at Harvard are more likely to be the ones tasked with solving it.
Re:Asian-Americans fight back against school discrimination by kbelder on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @01:25PM (#30530830)
>The people at Harvard are more likely to be the ones tasked with solving it.

That doesn't fill me with confidence.

Re:Asian-Americans fight back against school discrimination by someguydave on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @09:02AM (#30527370)
Plenty of people-groups have endured horrible abuses and have not turned into a criminal underclass. Therefore, other groups are not responsible for any particular group’s criminality.

As to what might work I would consider medicine or genetic augmentation maybe?

Re:Asian-Americans fight back against school discrimination by quantum_solanum on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @10:40AM (#30528531)
> As to what might work I would consider medicine or genetic augmentation maybe?

you're a fucking nazi freak, foh with this Mengele shit

Re:Asian-Americans fight back against school discrimination by someguydave on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @11:15AM (#30528956)
If there was an injection that made you less criminal, are you saying it should not be mandated? I fully agree.
Re:Asian-Americans fight back against school discrimination by shard on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @10:55PM (#30536983)
Higher testosterone has been linked to more violent crimes. Would you propose that high testosterone individuals be mandated to receive shots to reduce testosterone?
Re:Asian-Americans fight back against school discrimination by mbg721 on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @10:57PM (#30536988)
Nah, we can all just eat a ton of processed food, and we're good.
Re:Asian-Americans fight back against school discrimination by someguydave on Thursday March 03, 2022 @10:09AM (#30542005)
probably not but there might be a therapy with similar effects and fewer side effects
Re:Asian-Americans fight back against school discrimination by rayiner on Thursday March 03, 2022 @12:33AM (#30537516)
> You make it seem like the US no longer has an issue when there's an entire class of people who are not being educated, has high crime, and ending in mass incarceration.

It’s the fault of liberalism. It’s also the fault of conservatives pushing disadvantaged minorities into the arms of liberals (often against their own cultural inclinations) but the root cause is liberalism. History of course plays a role, but liberalism is what perpetuates the problem generation after generation.

A stark realization I had after having my own kids is that my democrat-voting immigrant parents were deeply conservative, from child discipline to staying in an unhappy marriage to avoid any disruption to their kids staying “on track.” The biggest advantage immigrants have is that even when they’re democrats they’re not raised with liberal American attitudes.

Re:Asian-Americans fight back against school discrimination by SyzygistSix on Thursday March 03, 2022 @08:32AM (#30540723)
That's kind of what happens when you teach a group of people that hard work and honesty results in impoverished second class citizenship, generation after generation, until there are few successful role models in a community much less parents who can pass those values on to their kids.
Re:Asian-Americans fight back against school discrimination by zozbot234 on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @10:16AM (#30528265)
Criminal justice reform has always been an interest of enlightened conservatives and libertarians, not liberals. We all know that Biden talked about "super predators" and pushed tough-on-crime policies which are clearly failing today. The BLM protests have really forced the policymakers' hand, but these protests came from the grassroots not from the liberal elite.
Re:Asian-Americans fight back against school discrimination by SyzygistSix on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @11:39AM (#30529278)
I perhaps should have said progressives and you are correct, although I am under the impression that the tough on crime legislation was broadly popular among conservatives and liberals, and not so much enlightened conservatives, libertarians, or progressives. But the latter groups have always been a minority.
Re:Asian-Americans fight back against school discrimination by gxs on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @01:24AM (#30524382)
Thank you for contributing something other than pop-sociology to the comments (omg race is a social construct guys).

I hadn’t thought about this this way before - eventually anyone with an inclination to “rage against the machine” will have to really pinpoint that energy and drill down and down until it seems like a parody.

Not saying we’re there now, but an interesting thought exercise.

Re:Asian-Americans fight back against school discrimination by anon7725 on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @03:26AM (#30525127)
When the idea is backed by corporate HR departments and academic orthodoxies, it’s no longer raging against the machine. It is the machine.
Re:Asian-Americans fight back against school discrimination by kbelder on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @01:27PM (#30530872)
I've noticed this in young people, in school or fresh out. They've somehow been convinced that they're rebelling against the system by thinking and acting exactly as they've been taught.
Re:Asian-Americans fight back against school discrimination by boredumb on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @08:42AM (#30527177)
Liberals need to start speaking out against the 'progressives' that have commandeered their ideology in the public eye or I emphatically agree with your ending to the movement. My worry is what comes next, the people preying on american liberals aren't going to die with them.
Re:Asian-Americans fight back against school discrimination by cuteboy19 on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @01:25AM (#30524388)
Nit: it's not liberalism, but rather the general progressive/socialist movements. Some of the things being championed are highly illiberal, for example CRT has anti-liberalism as a central tenet.
Re:Asian-Americans fight back against school discrimination by oblio on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @05:54AM (#30525951)
Is there some manifesto or doc for it?
Re:Asian-Americans fight back against school discrimination by JohnWhigham on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @06:43AM (#30526211)
Not really, but learning about the Frankfurt School during the Weimar Republic is a good foundation: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frankfurt_School
Re:Asian-Americans fight back against school discrimination by psyc on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @01:26AM (#30524391)
It’s all so depressingly primitive. Half of me wants to protest that surely we’re more enlightened than this in current year. The other half would settle for everyone else admitting that yes we are definitely still this backwards.
Re:Asian-Americans fight back against school discrimination by artificial on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @10:06AM (#30528140)
We are chimps with electricity and gunpowder.