News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by quacked on Monday February 21, 2022 @05:55PM (#30421815)
This is exactly how it feels with every iteration of my company's new design. Let's disappear scroll bars! Let's hide the menu! Let's order sub-menus by frequency of use, rather than by alphabetical order! Let's get rid of border lines around text entry boxes! Let's make clickable and non-clickable text the same font, style, and color! Let's--

I do not understand why designers are so insistent on making tools so difficult and unpleasant to use.

Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by manachar on Monday February 21, 2022 @06:08PM (#30421946)
"Move fast and break things" with a healthy does of deep disrespect for the user mixed into a young and mostly self taught discipline (UI/UX) based on nice sounding pseudo-science that cherry picks usability studies to meet aesthetic desires of the highest-paid opinion in the room.

The modern web disgusts and enrages me more often than not.

Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by aaaaaaaaata on Monday February 21, 2022 @08:13PM (#30422945)
It's one of few ways a small, scrappy firm can stand out —

talking to the user instead of taking the decision made by some investor/suit in a larger, less efficient firm.

Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by _Algernon_ on Monday February 21, 2022 @06:13PM (#30421992)
If UI designers were making a car, the pedals would switch spots for no apparent reason every year, and the steering wheel would turn into a trendy motion control interface.
Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by tempestn on Monday February 21, 2022 @07:09PM (#30422477)
You jest, but we're almost there with Tesla, where the wheel is no longer a wheel, the turn signals are two buttons (on the same side of the wheel) rather than a stalk, the gear shifter is removed and the car literally tries to guess whether you want to go forward or backward, and every other control is on a touchscreen, and does indeed move around or disappear into a menu at least every year.
Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by bbarnett on Monday February 21, 2022 @07:35PM (#30422709)
Based upon this alone, I cannot see myself buying Tesla -- especially with so many other options opening up.
Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by tempestn on Tuesday February 22, 2022 @12:58AM (#30424482)
The irony is I actually own a Tesla, but it's a Model Y, so fortunately doesn't yet have most of the worst of these.
Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by netr0ute on Monday February 21, 2022 @08:37PM (#30423089)
You just described (almost) every real race car in the past few decades, where everything is bespoke engineered and done solely for "UI/UX."
Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by gifnamething on Monday February 21, 2022 @09:13PM (#30423312)
Race cars are optimised for racing, not manoeuvring. Try applying their wheel geometry to you road car. You won't get far, though you will get there very fast and very sideways.

Aftermarket steering wheels are widely available for road cars. Most of them are wheel shaped.

Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by zestyping on Monday February 21, 2022 @07:08PM (#30422473)
This is not all that far from what's happening with touchscreens in cars.

Pros of touchscreens:

- You can make the UI look like anything you want.

Cons of touchscreens:

- You can make the UI look like anything you want.

Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by Zak on Monday February 21, 2022 @07:25PM (#30422621)
The more important con of touchscreens for cars is that you have to look at them. Well-designed controls for cars can be reliably operated by feel once learned.
Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by XorNot on Monday February 21, 2022 @09:40PM (#30423474)
I'm less convinced by this: controls within easy reach while driving need to be physical because you can reach them without looking, but the center control dash is always a little bit too far away from a comfortable driving position to start with - and thus a reasonable candidate to be touchscreen-ifyed provided you don't put serious controls on it.

i.e. I don't mind touchscreen A/C controls or something, provided the driver's wheel also has those controls (which in my old Toyota Prius it does).

IMO the big innovation is making sure that everything I would want to do while driving is literally at my fingertips, which should be on the steering wheel.

Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by fpoling on Monday February 21, 2022 @11:39PM (#30424049)
I do not understand how Tesla was allowed to put de-fog button for the windshield in a submenu on the touchscreen. This is a critical safety feature. The only explanation is that it is not needed often in California.
Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by Phrodo_00 on Monday February 21, 2022 @10:26PM (#30423691)
While you generally have to do a quick glance to find the center console controls, after you get a hold on them you can put your eyes back on the road because of the physical feedback. You would need incredibly good haptics on a touch screen to accomplish the same (I haven't experienced incredibly good haptics on any car I've rented (my car uses mostly physical buttons))
Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by ignu on Monday February 21, 2022 @07:31PM (#30422674)
biggest con is you have to look at it to do anything.

being able to turn the heater or defrosters on without looking is a pretty big upside when driving.

tesla changing where that is in updates and making you look for it in a new design just makes a bad problem worse

Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by userbinator on Monday February 21, 2022 @07:48PM (#30422797)
tesla changing where that is in updates and making you look for it in a new design just makes a bad problem worse

There was extensive discussion about that on here a short while ago:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30140984

Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by Nextgrid on Monday February 21, 2022 @09:40PM (#30423471)
The problem isn't that you can make the UI look like anything you want, it's that only the manufacturer can do so, without authorization nor notice.

Actually being able to customise it yourself (and have the changes persist long-term) wouldn't be that bad.

Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by Lio on Tuesday February 22, 2022 @04:35AM (#30425817)
I’d develop that argument a little further, you can’t stop the manufacturer from changing the UI you currently like arbitrarily at some point in the future.

I don’t like that on my computer and definitely don’t want it in my car. It’s bad enough when you buy a new car and things have been “improved”.

Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by kloch on Monday February 21, 2022 @06:23PM (#30422077)
This was a real problem until US Gov mandated "PRND" shift order, among other things.

Now, if they could just make the windshield wiper controls all work the same direction...

Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by __david__ on Monday February 21, 2022 @06:50PM (#30422323)
Why not just remove the physical windshield wiper controls, try to make them automatic, and then bury the overrides in a touchscreen menu 2 layers deep? And what if you got rid of the PRND stock and putting your car in reverse involved making a gesture on the same touchscreen? Genius!
Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by Arrath on Monday February 21, 2022 @07:07PM (#30422463)
No see to put your car in reverse you need to throw your arm over the passenger seat and look over your shoulder, activating the pressure sensor in the back of the passenger headrest, and the face recognition sensor in the rear window.
Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by mushyhammer on Tuesday February 22, 2022 @02:54AM (#30425139)
To be fair, that's not a bad idea. It'd probably stop a bunch of drivers driving backwards without looking. Let's do it.
Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by niek_pas on Tuesday February 22, 2022 @04:19AM (#30425693)
I don't know if you're being sarcastic or not, but this is a terrible idea. A family is driving on the highway. Kids are fighting in the back seat. The mother, who is driving, turns her head and tells them to stop. The car is rear-ended by a dump truck, and all three are dead.
Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by Arrath on Tuesday February 22, 2022 @12:16PM (#30430572)
I have to assume modern auto transmissions have computer lockouts to prevent you from money-shifting it into R while at speed, don't they? I'm thinking like modern dial-a-shift where you aren't directly manipulating the transmission with the shifter.

I've never tried to test it cause I don't like horribly expensive mechanical noises, but yeah.

Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by tempestn on Monday February 21, 2022 @07:10PM (#30422491)
If only we could have Tesla's excellent electric drive trains without all the rest of their "innovation".
Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by plebianRube on Monday February 21, 2022 @08:40PM (#30423107)
So true. Victims of the 'We are better at this one thing than other automakers, so clearly we will be better at all of the other things too' mentality.' Like seeing metrics that defrost is rarely used so lets bury it in a sub menu.
Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by glandium on Monday February 21, 2022 @10:39PM (#30423753)
> Why not just remove the physical windshield wiper controls, try to make them automatic

FWIW, 25 years ago, I had some generic assignment when I was student, I don't remember the exact details, but I made it on auto-windshield wiping tech, and what I found was that multiple patents already existed back then (one from Mercedes or BMW, I don't remember which ; it might have been both). I'm mystified that we aren't seeing those everywhere yet.

Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by fpoling on Monday February 21, 2022 @11:52PM (#30424122)
I drove a few rented cars in Norway. All automatic windshield wipers sucked. They did not active in a light rain and in heavier rain drove wipers unnecessary frequently. The least bad was Kia. At least they got frequency right.
Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by seszett on Tuesday February 22, 2022 @04:31AM (#30425800)
They might not be common in the US? All the cars I've had in the past ten years (French and German brands) had automatic wipers and they were not expensive models.

Some work better than others, but most of the time when they don't work well it's because the wipers are worn and need to be replaced.

Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by Lio on Tuesday February 22, 2022 @04:20AM (#30425702)
I think I must be missing something in this discussion but my 2014 Golf came with auto-wipers, auto-headlights on, auto-rear view mirror dimming and auto-full beam dipping.

Isn’t this a solved problem and completely standard on most new cars for a few years now?

Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by the_pwner224 on Monday February 21, 2022 @11:44PM (#30424073)
That has been slowly but surely trickling down. I think the high trim Honda Civics have auto wipers now.

The new tech these days is to spray fluid out of the wipers themselves. The blades have a lot of holes laser cut into them, as the blades move across the windshield they spray fluid just an inch ahead of the blade. It's starting to become very common in the luxury car brands, even the lower tier Lexueses and BMWs are getting them as the newer gen cars are released.

It doesn't sound particularly cool, but when you try using them it is a very nice feature to have.

Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by a_t48 on Tuesday February 22, 2022 @01:13AM (#30424550)
My Jetta GLI has automatic wipers, I don't quite trust them yet, though. Seattle rain has a way of making things hard to see without much actual liquid happening.
Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by ntr-- on Tuesday February 22, 2022 @03:21AM (#30425298)
That sounds like a very effective way to replace cheap, generic, easily replaceable windscreen wipers with expensive, high margin, brand specific wipers.
Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by seszett on Tuesday February 22, 2022 @04:37AM (#30425824)
On my old Peugeot 405 (from 1990) that was done by an additional tube attached to the metal of the wipers. The wipers themselves were just standard and not especially expensive.

It was interesting but I didn't find it especially better. They moved away from this and the later models just have normal sprayers. Maybe the very latest have that again, I don't know.

Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by u801e on Monday February 21, 2022 @08:02PM (#30422888)
> This was a real problem until US Gov mandated "PRND" shift order

Automakers also equip automatic transmission cars with paddle shifters, which really give you no tactile feedback to let you know what gear you're in. They also make it difficult to shift while turning. A traditional manual with the HH shift pattern gives you that feedback that allows you to know what gear you're in and doesn't limit your ability to shift while turning.

Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by XorNot on Monday February 21, 2022 @09:41PM (#30423477)
Conversely it's an automatic car - generally speaking you're not shifting. The flappy paddle style is just for the pseudo-racecar feel, not practicality.
Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by fpoling on Monday February 21, 2022 @11:56PM (#30424141)
When driving in mountains with a lot of downhill shifting gears is must unless one wants to melt the brakes.
Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by jldl805 on Tuesday February 22, 2022 @01:48AM (#30424723)
You don't need paddle shifters or a manual transmission to do that, though.
Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by u801e on Tuesday February 22, 2022 @07:01PM (#30435647)
Some automatics don't really give you much control over what gear you're in. I have a 2012 Honda Odyssey with a PRNDL button. With L, you can drive in first gear up to red line (not sure of the speed). There is a D3 button that will downshift to 3rd gear if the shifter is in the D position. You can downshift to 2nd if you move the shifter to the L position when going less than 60 mph, but that's not obvious. The car will also downshift to 1st if your speed drops below 30 mph and won't upshift to 2nd even if the speed goes above 30 mph (meaning I have to shift it back to D and then back to L if I want to keep it in 2nd). 3rd gear doesn't really provide much in terms of engine braking when going less than 50 mph
Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by duxup on Monday February 21, 2022 @07:35PM (#30422713)
Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by colpabar on Monday February 21, 2022 @06:18PM (#30422030)
Sounds like the spotify app. Why can't there just be a static button to get me to my recommended weekly/daily playlists?
Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by bobsmooth on Monday February 21, 2022 @07:10PM (#30422493)
You don't have a "Made for you" button under the "Browse" tab?
Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by salzig on Monday February 21, 2022 @06:27PM (#30422122)
There is? You can follow those playlist and place them at the top of your playlists. Who needs the crap „startpage“ as a startpage anyways.
Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by colpabar on Monday February 21, 2022 @06:41PM (#30422245)
> Who needs the crap „startpage“ as a startpage anyways.

I understand this 100%. Youtube is the same exact thing - the home page is total garbage unless you enjoy watching the same 8 videos you just watched. But we're in a thread about bad UI/UX, so I'm going to complain that the "default" being bad is a bad thing.

Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by _Algernon_ on Tuesday February 22, 2022 @09:31AM (#30428325)
Perhaps a bit off-topic, but the browser extension Unhook^[1] can be used to clean up the Youtube interface pretty well. I use it to remove everything except the subscription feed.

[1]: FF: https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/youtube-recom... Chrome: https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/unhook-remove-yout...

Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by d0gsg0w00f on Monday February 21, 2022 @08:26PM (#30423017)
This made me laugh and it also made me wonder if UI people have jokes about how annoying engineers are.
Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by pixl97 on Monday February 21, 2022 @06:25PM (#30422092)
Now let's not give Tesla any ideas...
Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by charcircuit on Monday February 21, 2022 @08:24PM (#30423003)
>and the steering wheel would turn into a trendy motion control interface.

The steering wheel is already motion controlled.

Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by mhh__ on Monday February 21, 2022 @07:32PM (#30422680)
Saab made a car with a centre console stick instead of a wheel once
Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by LegitShady on Monday February 21, 2022 @07:59PM (#30422867)
we've noticed you use the gas pedal significantly more than the brake pedal - in the next update we will be removing the brake pedal.
Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by CSMastermind on Monday February 21, 2022 @10:55PM (#30423831)
Lol you should look into car design pre-1970.

It was basically this.

Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by nicoffeine on Monday February 21, 2022 @08:44PM (#30423140)
> I do not understand why designers are so insistent on making tools so difficult and unpleasant to use.

Because they need something to pad their resume. In fact, most of the things that are wrong with software today are for the same reason.

Executives want to make bold changes, so the Start button must be "re-imagined." For the same reason, Product Managers "re-imagine" the menus that have been in place for years and Product Designers "re-imagine" the design language to remove all cues that a button clicks and a panel scrolls.

In my routine trips to the auto parts stores over the past 20 years, I have seen their throughput drop as more and more of these modern ideas seeped in. Their text menus had been the same for decades, with as many options for a next action as there were keys on the keyboard. If my intuition is correct, they were remote sessions to a server/mainframe. How about that for keeping the computation close to the data. Now that has all been replaced with a single button and a cursor.

I'm not a die-hard CLI user by any stretch, but I understand the impulse after watching usability circle the drain year after year. There's a healthy middle somewhere and I am hoping to find it.

Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by userbinator on Monday February 21, 2022 @07:23PM (#30422592)
Let's make clickable and non-clickable text the same font, style, and color!

Let's remove all indications that buttons are buttons!

I've actually had to use a site which had all four combinations: static text that looks like static text, static text that looks like a button, buttons that look like static text, and buttons that look like buttons.

Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by creakingstairs on Monday February 21, 2022 @06:30PM (#30422144)
I think it's because they are usually targeting the design for the broadest audience, so they design for the lowest common denominators and simplify the screen as much as possible to streamline "the main flow" of their app. This involves removing as much elements as possible to cause the least confusion when they interact with the app for the first time.

This means that the app will work amazing and without thought ("it just works!") for 80% of the population but will be non-functional for the 20% of the population which includes power users and users who would have been willing to go through the initial learning curve for a more powerful app.

Just to note: I'm not deriding the "lowest common denominators" as I am definitely one for some domains. For example, I chose the app with the simplest deisgn for doing my taxes as I didn't want to spend time learning about taxes.

Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by pmontra on Monday February 21, 2022 @06:59PM (#30422393)
It's that once they did all the useful work they are not old enough to retire so they have to invent something to do. To be fair, most of us are doing only marginally useful work.
Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by alecbz on Monday February 21, 2022 @07:24PM (#30422603)
It won't be "non-functional", just not as functional as they would have otherwise liked.
Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by creakingstairs on Monday February 21, 2022 @07:29PM (#30422648)
You are right. "Non-functional" might have been too strong here.
Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by xigoi on Tuesday February 22, 2022 @12:35AM (#30424367)
It's sad that more apps don't have a “power user mode” hidden somewhere in settings, which would give you the choice.
Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by mrjin on Monday February 21, 2022 @09:10PM (#30423295)
If I remember correctly, Chrome started all this BS with the infamous burger menu. With traditional designs, I can easily find what are the operations available and now I have make at least one extra click to discover that. Making it worse, some websites do not implement the menus correctly so when you move your mouse trying to click one of the sub-menus, the pop-out hides automatically as now you have moved away from the burger menu... It was kinda make sense as we used to have very small screens and the screen estate was very tight. But now we have much bigger screens, such trend just gets worse...
Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by kbutler on Monday February 21, 2022 @06:00PM (#30421880)
Because they are visual designers, not interaction designers, so appearance is the primary criteria, rather than visual affordances to guide the user.

Recommend https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Design_of_Everyday_Things

Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by brimble on Monday February 21, 2022 @06:36PM (#30422202)
What's crazy to me is that I was promised Back In The Day that everything would be sunshine and roses in software design, and especially in Web design, once the "digital natives" took over and all those bad ol' print designers retired or got pushed out—but it sure looks to me like the exact opposite happened.
Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by plorkyeran on Monday February 21, 2022 @08:42PM (#30423123)
What seems to have actually happened is that the "digital natives" are better at dealing with bad UIs than those who learned how to use computers later in life, so the pressure to make usable interfaces diminished.
Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by ajmurmann on Monday February 21, 2022 @07:58PM (#30422861)
I think there also is a conflict between interfaces that have a flat learning curve on one hand and interfaces that work extremely well once you are used to them. I think the second category gets too little attention. It's also much harder to user test the second category but for certain types of applications it's what should be preferred. Ideally you can have both a flat learning curve and high efficiency for experienced users. To me the JetBrains IDEs are an example of this compromise. Examples that are fabulous for experts are of course Vim and emacs
Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by disqard on Monday February 21, 2022 @11:57PM (#30424144)
This is a fantastic observation!

Having done research into UI/interaction design, I can confirm that all research in this area prioritizes things that (a) can be measured quickly and (b) with a high degree of confidence.

Good luck running a controlled experiment where multiple folks use an interface for an entire week and then become power-users of the system!

Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by quacked on Monday February 21, 2022 @06:02PM (#30421896)
Wonderful recommendation (I have read it). I don't think anyone should be allowed to design one single consumer product until they have it practically memorized.
Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by Jerrrry on Monday February 21, 2022 @06:17PM (#30422022)
Functional design ain't pretty.
Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by 542458 on Monday February 21, 2022 @06:48PM (#30422309)
I don’t think is true. Functional design may not be optimally pretty in some cases. However, the eye finds things like readability, organization, and visual hierarchy to be visually appealing - so functional design can very well be pretty in some cases (for example, Blender’s UI is highly functional, but still relatively visually pleasing). I’m not saying that all functional design is pretty, but I am saying that rejecting all pretty designs as non-functional is incorrect.
Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by bbarnett on Tuesday February 22, 2022 @12:27AM (#30424321)
And regardless, function before form does not invalidate form after the fact.

EG, you're building a bridge. It needs to do its job, and not collapse. There are many perfectly functional designs, which have appealing form. Yet, if you want to actually be able to use the beast, it:

- needs to be wide enough to pass traffic, but not too wide (waste of money)

- needs to be able to keep the traffic from careening off into the abyss each use

- needs 100 other things such as the above

But once the above "functional" criteria are met, form is fine. Why not make it look good? Great! Yet, don't (as an example) overlay form which then reflects sunlight into driver's eyes, so they can't see and crash on the bridge.

This is all reasonably understood with normal day objects.

But, when someone engineers a bridge, they have to go to a decade of schooling + years on the job, to rise to that position. And the same for people designing beautiful buildings, or homes. They know the restrictions, the load requirements, and then they layer extra on top of that.

Not even sure what I'm fully rambling on here about, except I guess that I think UX/UI should only be attempted after years of using software in a professional capacity.

I was in to a store the other day, and they were looking up stock. It was an ncurses display. And the employee was zooming through it, as typical, with keyboard shortcuts, and FAST.

UX/UI is really the problem. Making things pretty gets in the way of functional first. Keep it function before form, and you're fine.

And if anyone rattles on about Apple and Steve Jobs, from what I've read, heard, and watched? He was 100% about "function first!". He'd go ballistic if simple functionality was hard to get at, or missing, or buggy, or incomprehensible.

Yup, he wanted form to look good. But that came on top of proper, perfect function.

Which is its own beauty.

Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by sings on Monday February 21, 2022 @09:29PM (#30423414)
I want to push back on this idea that designers are out to destroy everything.

I think one interesting way to look at these sort of changes is analogous to the introduction of new features in code. In the short term, new features can be added to the existing codebase without the need for much change, but eventually, the overhead becomes problematic and there is the need to make more structural adjustments.

I think it’s similar for designers, who get to the point where new features don’t have a natural home in the existing interface and want to make changes. Just as a junior developer might be tempted to rewrite from scratch, a junior designer might be tempted to introduce a new mental model and rearrange everything. In some cases this may be OK but generally you need a more nuanced approach. The fact that users are the consumers of the change, not designers, is where the analogy falls apart, and thus the need for a more thoughtful introduction of any change.

Obviously the abrupt changes are those that cause a negative reaction, especially when combined with the exaggerated desire to clean up an interface. However, not all change is for changes sake. Sometimes it’s just a case of trying to respond to constraints and make the best compromise when dealing with changing software.

Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by worthless-trash on Monday February 21, 2022 @10:52PM (#30423814)
You can always push back, but in the general case, reality is showing otherwise.
Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by 8ytecoder on Monday February 21, 2022 @06:46PM (#30422294)
Let's break login forms into two pages so we can annoy all the password manager users - for kicks.
Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by andrewmackrodt on Monday February 21, 2022 @07:17PM (#30422545)
This annoys me too, but since starting work at a company which uses single sign on, it's started to make sense why certain sites have this pattern, e.g. if your login is an email address and the domain is enrolled to handle sign on outside of the service, you are redirected and the original website doesn't have the ability to capture your password.

For personal use, I find 1Password typically handles multiple screen logins, including 2FA quite well, although requires an extra UI interaction.

Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by Nextgrid on Monday February 21, 2022 @09:42PM (#30423478)
I understand the technical reason behind it but still, it shouldn't be that hard to provide a separate page with both fields on it that non-SSO users can bookmark.
Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by montag on Monday February 21, 2022 @11:23PM (#30423955)
Reminds me of when we removed the “Previous Track” button on the Rdio player controls. The data showed that users skipped to previous only a tiny fraction of the time. Lasted about 3 days in production.

Underlying this fallacy is the assumption that usage should somehow be uniformly distributed across all features. In reality, a power law distribution is more natural.

Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by egypturnash on Monday February 21, 2022 @07:55PM (#30422845)
"Less is more" is a religion that is very easy to carry far past the point where less begins being less.
Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by DocTomoe on Tuesday February 22, 2022 @02:20AM (#30424934)
If a designer doesn't change things, obviously they have achieved peak design, and are now irrelevant and ready to be fired. As long as they move things around, they get a paycheck.
Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by tartoran on Monday February 21, 2022 @05:59PM (#30421867)
Don’t be surprised. They’re brewing dark patterns.
Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by quacked on Monday February 21, 2022 @06:01PM (#30421885)
I don't disagree with you in the slightest for most other software tools, but this is an internal tool that we're selling so that people can build their own applications. There's no advertising--in fact, the fewer seconds people spend inside the application, the better it is for our bottom line because it means we can pump out the applications faster.
Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by Nextgrid on Monday February 21, 2022 @06:36PM (#30422196)
> in fact, the fewer seconds people spend inside the application, the better it is for our bottom line because it means we can pump out the applications faster.

This might be true from a bottom-line perspective, but the marketing/product/engagement manager's targets (whether company-mandated or personally-mandated to use them as resume bullet points) may still hinge on increasing "engagement".

Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by brimble on Monday February 21, 2022 @06:24PM (#30422084)
I think there are a few related causes behind this behavior:

1) Visual changes show better than feature lists. I'm not convinced this matters anywhere near as much for customers as marketing folks seem to think it does, but marketing values it regardless, management values it (it'll show better to their bosses, too), and product managers, designers, and front-end developers value it (so they have nice-looking things for portfolios and presentations, both internal and external)

2) Making something that looks good in a screenshot or demo is not the same thing as making something that works well (that is, has "good UX"), and making something that does both well is hard enough that the talent (and environment/budget) to do it may be fairly rare. The former matters to those concerned about point 1, so that's what gets priority (which is why so many redesigns are neutral, at best, as far as UX, and many are worse).

3) If design is done well, it's heavily cyclical. Design guidelines and languages and component libraries and such should be built up such that most design work only happens when there are initial designs, very large feature add-ons that break with what the previous design guidelines can accommodate, or redesigns. So, if you're a designer and want to stay comfortably employed, and you're a manager who doesn't want to surrender head-count or lose your people to other projects, and a large part of the org has various incentives to push initiatives that result in something nice to to look at (see 1, again) what happens? Lots more redesigns than need to happen. LOTS more.

[EDIT] And all this is before we even consider possible business reasons to deliberately make the product worse, which are also A Thing.

Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by phendrenad2 on Tuesday February 22, 2022 @03:34AM (#30425395)
It's because we (in the tech world) hire UI designers based on how beautiful their portfolio is, not how usable their design is. "But that's the job of UX!" you say. Yes, but we don't hire UX people. We just hire UI people and expect them to secretly be UX people despite giving every indication to the contrary. Oh well.
Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by mitchdoogle on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @11:55AM (#30443166)
Function is as much a part of design as is aesthetic appeal. A designer who doesn't consider function on the same level as aesthetics is a bad designer.
Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by mitchdoogle on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @11:48AM (#30443081)
Frequency of use seems like a better metric than alphabetical order. The order of the alphabet is arbitrary. Besides, I think this is fairly normal - I just had a look at all the applications I have open now and not one has submenus in alphabetical order
Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by ngc248 on Monday February 21, 2022 @11:54PM (#30424129)
They gotta have something to do ... else how will they justify their salary :)
Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by bsedlm on Monday February 21, 2022 @06:41PM (#30422242)
what makes you think they're designing tools for you to use?

what if they're actually designing systems and schemes which use you? (in soviet russia ---and the modern day internet--- computer uses YOU)

I started trying to make a joke but now I'm not laughing :|

Re:I have no capslock and I must scream by 1270018080 on Monday February 21, 2022 @06:51PM (#30422327)
They're not going to allow something well designed to be made on the first pass. Sure that would be good for the user and company, but they need to justify their 40hr/week salaried job somehow. It's like planned obsolescence but for work.