News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Upper limits on partial Dyson spheres in the Milky Way by nyx on Saturday February 19, 2022 @01:35AM (#30394889)
Most people get baked, wonder if we're alone in the universe, and take a nap. Astrophysicists get baked, wonder if we're alone in the universe, and publish papers like this.

Jokes aside, is there really any practical value in this sort of research, or is it the kind of thing that we do because it's interesting and kinda cool? Don't get me wrong, I think it's valuable for that alone, but...

Re:Upper limits on partial Dyson spheres in the Milky Way by wesleywt on Saturday February 19, 2022 @02:13AM (#30395033)
Research should NEVER be limited by whether it has practical value or not. Because we don't know if future generations will make it practical.
Re:Upper limits on partial Dyson spheres in the Milky Way by XorNot on Saturday February 19, 2022 @02:44AM (#30395171)
Exactly. Any research which takes something we don't know, and turns it into something we now know, is valuable.
Re:Upper limits on partial Dyson spheres in the Milky Way by ncmncm on Saturday February 19, 2022 @03:28AM (#30395391)
Research is ALWAYS limited to what the person performing it considered practical. Getting a paper published is as practical as most researchers need to get. (Some do more.) If they don't publish, they soon don't get to do research anymore, and have to start doing what somebody else considers practical.
Re:Upper limits on partial Dyson spheres in the Milky Way by wesleywt on Saturday February 19, 2022 @05:57AM (#30396129)
You missed the word I wrote "should". Funding agencies want to fund only "practical" research. But studying the migratory patterns of a single species of butterfly should be funded as much as the latest biotech fad that supposedly is of "practical value".
Re:Upper limits on partial Dyson spheres in the Milky Way by captainmuon on Saturday February 19, 2022 @02:46AM (#30395175)
Searching for Dyson spheres is not too different from searching for other hypothetical astronomical objects. Maybe it is a low-stakes analysis you could put some students on, so they learn something. Data collection, statistical methods, paper writing is all identical to "traditional" searches. I come from particle physics, and we did quite a few searches for very weird particles that, I admit, didn't believe in. But it was quick to retool the search for more plausible models.

Also I think science works the way that you use your fantasy to come up with outlandish things, and then try to rule them out with logic.

Re:Upper limits on partial Dyson spheres in the Milky Way by dillondoyle on Saturday February 19, 2022 @03:06AM (#30395278)
How do you find one? Is it similar to a black hole where you can detect the gravity, but can't see any of the energy coming from the covered sun?
Re:Upper limits on partial Dyson spheres in the Milky Way by terramex on Saturday February 19, 2022 @03:21AM (#30395350)
Dyson sphere would emit significant amount of infrared light but no visible light. Original Freeman Dyson's paper from 1960 was titled "Search for Artificial Stellar Sources of Infrared Radiation" https://sci-hub.ee/10.1126/science.131.3414.1667
Re:Upper limits on partial Dyson spheres in the Milky Way by ncmncm on Saturday February 19, 2022 @04:33AM (#30395698)
When somebody got a telescope that could, they found there were way more sources of infrared radiation than visible stars.
Re:Upper limits on partial Dyson spheres in the Milky Way by dillondoyle on Tuesday February 22, 2022 @02:19AM (#30424923)
Cool. maybe James Webb will find one ;)
Re:Upper limits on partial Dyson spheres in the Milky Way by tannhauser23 on Saturday February 19, 2022 @02:49PM (#30399915)
It's a low cost, low probability way to look for advanced civilizations. Chances are low that you'll find anything, but hey the data's already here and we have powerful computers so let's run some calculations. And occasionally you find weird and interesting anomalies that push science forward: https://www.space.com/alien-megastructure-mysteriously-dimmi...
Re:Upper limits on partial Dyson spheres in the Milky Way by tapas73 on Saturday February 19, 2022 @02:15AM (#30395048)
All fundamental research is reaserch for the sake of knowledge, for the sake of satisfying curiosity.

Once it is done, possibly much much much later, somebody may stumble upon it and use it in some creative (and unforseen) ways for other research.

On the other hand if you give any probability to alien existence, then this is very much practical already in the search for them.

Re:Upper limits on partial Dyson spheres in the Milky Way by JuettnerDistrib on Saturday February 19, 2022 @01:55AM (#30394948)
> is there really any practical value in this sort of research

In many ways it is too early to do this research, so it is a kind of art (as is a lot of research, imho). As long as only a few people do it, it's cool and useful so we can be aware of our potential future.

On the other hand, since we have no credible evidence of extraterrestrials, it would be surprising to find a civilisation so advanced to build a Dyson sphere. If they can build Dyson spheres, wouldn't they already be all over the place?

Ok, I suppose I should actually go read the paper now...

Re:Upper limits on partial Dyson spheres in the Milky Way by awb on Saturday February 19, 2022 @02:30AM (#30395105)
> If they can build Dyson spheres, wouldn't they already be all over the place?

The number I’ve seen quoted is 50M years to colonize the galaxy: http://www.sentientdevelopments.com/2012/01/new-mathematical...

> they calculated that any galactic empire would have spread outwards from its home planet at about 0.25% of the speed of light. The result is that after 50m years it would extend over 130,000 light years, with zealous colonisers moving in a relatively uniform cloud and more reticent ones protruding from a central blob. Since the Milky Way is estimated to be 100,000-120,000 light years across, outposts would be sprinkled throughout the galaxy, even if the home planet were, like Earth, located on the periphery.

It’s actually so fast that advanced civilizations would have had time to colonize the galaxy and go extinct many times over without us noticing.

Or maybe their spheres were built so long ago they’ve already collapsed and been consumed by the stars again.

It’s a great mystery and interesting thought experiment though.

Re:Upper limits on partial Dyson spheres in the Milky Way by denton-scratch on Saturday February 19, 2022 @04:54AM (#30395802)
> 50M years to colonize the galaxy

Our ancestors from 50M years ago are all extinct. So a civilisation spreading through the galaxy would have evolved in all kinds of different ways. It's not obvious to me that these diverse evolutionary strands would all still be interested in Dyson spheres, or space travel, or even astronomy.

There's a belief that's hard to shake off, that the properties humans have that we think most important represent some kind of evolutionary pinnacle. Typically, those properties are language, and a large brain for processing language. But if language and a large brain are really such great evolutionary advantages, why are humans the only creatures on Earth that have evolved those properties? Possibly language and a large brain are an evolutionary backwater.

At 0.25% of the speed of light, it would take us 1,600 years to reach Proxima Centauri; but it might take a lot longer to reach a star with habitable planets. We'd definitely need generation ships. After (say) a million years, we'd presumably have evolved to adapt to life on generation ships. It's not obvious to me that such adaptations would leave us fit to inhabit a planet. And perhaps adaptation to life on a generation ship means adapting to eating your fellow passengers.

Given the history of humanity, I find it hard to believe that the population of a generation ship could survive as long as 100 years without war breaking out on-board. We've had large brains and language for about 50,000 years, as far as I can tell; we've been warring the whole time. Maybe large brains and language pre-dispose us to war? If that's right, then it seems unlikely that intelligent life would ever spread far from it's planet of origin.

I'm very sceptical of the idea that any "civilisation" could ever spread far from its home planet. There are two things that we refeer to as a civilisation: a culture, and a species. Culture changes very quickly - over a single lifetime. But on a scale of millions of years, speciation is also pretty quick. So I can't see how any kind of homogenous civilisation or species could spread through a galaxy. They would have diversified before the train even reached its first stop.

So I don't have any insurance against being kidnapped by aliens.

Re:Upper limits on partial Dyson spheres in the Milky Way by awb on Saturday February 19, 2022 @11:17AM (#30398181)
Much of what you say is reasonable.

Only two minor nits:

> why are humans the only creatures on Earth that have evolved those properties? Possibly language and a large brain are an evolutionary backwater.

Nearly every animal has language, for cooperation, competition, raising their young or to find a mate. Bees, whales, primates, birds, etc. all communicate strategically with some type of language.

> Given the history of humanity, I find it hard to believe that the population of a generation ship could survive as long as 100 years without war breaking out on-board. We've had large brains and language for about 50,000 years, as far as I can tell; we've been warring the whole time.

There’s been war somewhere the whole time, but not everywhere. Costa Rica, Iceland, Panama and several minor countries have no military: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_without_ar...

It’s possible to find many countries who have not fought wars in the past 100 years. If you look more narrowly it’s possible to find communities unaffected by local war in hundreds or maybe even thousands of years (in other words, they fought a war but did so by traveling great distances, not fighting each other).

A ship would be much more like a tiny, isolated island colony rather than the geopolitical tensions that dominate the news.

Finally, wars rarely result in the extinction of both sides. Even if there was a large scale conflict it would likely be resolved prior to social collapse. There would be little incentive to kill so many of your fellow crew to the point where you’re putting every survivor at risk.

Re:Upper limits on partial Dyson spheres in the Milky Way by mannykannot on Saturday February 19, 2022 @03:11PM (#30400081)
>> why are humans the only creatures on Earth that have evolved those properties? Possibly language and a large brain are an evolutionary backwater.

> Nearly every animal has language, for cooperation, competition, raising their young or to find a mate. Bees, whales, primates, birds, etc. all communicate strategically with some type of language.

There is currently only one species on Earth capable of even imagining the things being discussed here. On the other hand, it seems there may well have been more, but the others are now extinct.

One of these issues only we are discussing is the evolutionary viability of those abilities, and the fact we can do so suggests that it is, to some extent, up to us whether or not they will be.

Re:Upper limits on partial Dyson spheres in the Milky Way by denton-scratch on Saturday February 19, 2022 @05:12PM (#30401011)
It's just struck me that a civilisation propagating through space can be envisaged a bit like light-cones, as in GR, except that the velocity factor isn't c, it's b (the maximum speed at which beings can move), which kinda depends on the beings.

But I think the cones thing is still interesting; it means that for any given maximum travel speed, there must be other civilisations that can never know anything about you, nor you about them.

Re:Upper limits on partial Dyson spheres in the Milky Way by denton-scratch on Saturday February 19, 2022 @03:30PM (#30400240)
> Nearly every animal has language

Yes, I elided that bit, in the aim of brevity. I think there is a difference between human language and animal languages, in that human language is "creative" - we can freely create new utterances with new meanings, and expect to be understood. We know this of human language, but I would be very interested to learn of evidence of it in other species (chimps come close).

Re:Upper limits on partial Dyson spheres in the Milky Way by webmaven on Saturday February 19, 2022 @08:43PM (#30402422)
> Our ancestors from 50M years ago are all extinct. So a civilisation spreading through the galaxy would have evolved in all kinds of different ways. It's not obvious to me that these diverse evolutionary strands would all still be interested in Dyson spheres, or space travel, or even astronomy.

There is no need for all, or even most, of the civilizational variants to retain those characteristics. As long as some variants do, civilization would continue its inexorable interstellar spread, it would just end up being lumpy rather than a relatively even wavefront.

Indeed, survivorship bias would seemingly tend to conserve the required characteristics and possibly start constraining the ways in which civilizational offshoots can vary. And it isn't hard to imagine stay-at-home variants succumbing to the influence of later arriving spreader variants to become spreaders once more.

Re:Upper limits on partial Dyson spheres in the Milky Way by ncmncm on Saturday February 19, 2022 @05:01AM (#30395839)
Indeed, any culture that actually lasted long enough to get to the next star would have become, in the interval, comfortable with not being near any star, and could roam freely, doing nothing that could attract our attention.
Re:Upper limits on partial Dyson spheres in the Milky Way by awb on Saturday February 19, 2022 @11:24AM (#30398242)
True, unless their lifespans are high enough that a trip to a nearby star is only a fraction of their existence (or they travel cryogenically and aren’t conscious during transit).
Re:Upper limits on partial Dyson spheres in the Milky Way by bryanrasmussen on Saturday February 19, 2022 @02:11AM (#30395018)
Being able to build Dyson spheres does not make them capable of going faster than the speed of light, so any civilization capable of building a Dyson sphere would probably still be clustered around a couple stars and that's it.

Would such a civilization spread to more than one star is actually also a question, or would they control their population rationally stay on their Dyson sphere and only start to move when the star had less than 100,000 years left to go.

Only some Dyson sphere variants, like Shkadov thrusters, are primarily conceived as ways to move around. Which personally seems to me less likely, is a civilization, as well as the ability to construct these objects, also going to have a species level interest in going exploring?

Re:Upper limits on partial Dyson spheres in the Milky Way by perihelions on Saturday February 19, 2022 @03:44AM (#30395477)
> "Being able to build Dyson spheres does not make them capable of going faster than the speed of light, so any civilization capable of building a Dyson sphere would probably still be clustered around a couple stars and that's it."

Check your math: this galaxy is ~10^5 light-years in size and ~10^10 years in age.

Re:Upper limits on partial Dyson spheres in the Milky Way by bryanrasmussen on Saturday February 19, 2022 @04:00AM (#30395553)
what does that have to do with anything I said? Yes, I guess they would be everywhere if their civilization was able to make Dyson spheres 1 year after the creation of the galaxy, also if they decided to

1. Not control their population for some reason.

2. Had some sort of interest in exploring.

3. Implicit also in the speed of light thing, would find it really interesting to send a portion of their population to the next available and suitable star which might be enough light years away to make communication impractical. I mean for our civilization there is some level of argument that says it would be a ridiculous idea to move to a new solar system and we have an intellectual exploratory streak in our species.

I mean we are currently not at the level of being able to do a Dyson sphere, it took us 4.543 billion years (age of earth) to get to the part that somebody could conceive of it. There is also some discussion as to whether or not our civilization is going to last, so given that and the other things I said it seems unlikely to me that any Dyson sphere civilization would actually build more than one, but maybe some build two because binary stars or some other weird circumstance which makes it worthwhile to do.

on edit: if we get to Dyson sphere building capabilities which seems really unlikely, will we build more than one? How many more?

Re:Upper limits on partial Dyson spheres in the Milky Way by MattPalmer1086 on Saturday February 19, 2022 @04:26AM (#30395664)
The point is that you don't need to go faster than the speed of light. There's more than enough time to cover the entire galaxy in a relatively short period of time at sublight speeds. A few million years is sufficient.
Re:Upper limits on partial Dyson spheres in the Milky Way by bryanrasmussen on Saturday February 19, 2022 @07:09AM (#30396509)
yeah, sure, enough time to GO everywhere but not enough time to BE everywhere, which is a different thing entirely, even if all the other things I brought up as to why the aliens weren't everywhere were not things to take into consideration.

So again, still haven't heard any argument why an alien civilization achieving the ability to build Dyson spheres, even if they did so far enough in the past that they would then have adequate time to traverse the galaxy afterwards, would then have to be everywhere?

Re:Upper limits on partial Dyson spheres in the Milky Way by MattPalmer1086 on Saturday February 19, 2022 @09:07AM (#30397213)
I'm not sure I understand your argument. There is sufficient time, with waves of colonisation to spread across the galaxy many times over. This can include pauses of thousands of years between colonisation waves. Some of those colonies could also build Dyson spheres. You would end up with them scattered all over the galaxy. Even if the colonies dies out subsequently, the spheres would still be detectable.
Re:Upper limits on partial Dyson spheres in the Milky Way by bryanrasmussen on Saturday February 19, 2022 @03:55PM (#30400456)
>I'm not sure I understand your argument. There is sufficient time, with waves of colonisation to spread across the galaxy many times over.

yes, there is, if the achievement of Dyson sphere building happened long enough in the past for there to have been sufficient time. 50,000 years ago even, no. The length of human civilization is 6000 years approximately, what if this civilization much, much older than ours 6000 years ago just started building it's first Dyson sphere. For some reason the assumption is that it was far enough in the past that they COULD be everywhere if they wanted to.

But then the phrasing is not that they could be everywhere but rather they would be everywhere, hence no civilization has built Dyson spheres. A lot of this theory that the aliens will go about building lots and lots of Dyson spheres seems based on the assumption that they will be a lot like us, but actually I don't even think we would ever build more than one. If we built a Dyson sphere it would be because we were at the point we needed the energy and we had the technology to do it of course, and we had a political system that could harness everyone to do it. But once we had the Dyson sphere I am not sure we would ever be at the position were we would need another one. Since people tend to have fewer kids the higher their standard of living it may be that with the standard of living of Dyson sphere civ that our population would be at replacement level, that is to say we would never need to move from one Dyson sphere until the sun was just about used up.

So again, sure there is sufficient time with waves of colonization (started far enough in the past) - but waves of colonization assumes a species that has a colonization urge and perhaps one that has a colonization urge greater than that of humanity. That's a pretty big if, considering all the other big ifs in the whole building a Dyson sphere scenario.

Re:Upper limits on partial Dyson spheres in the Milky Way by MattPalmer1086 on Saturday February 19, 2022 @11:28AM (#30398278)
I'm not sure anyone is arguing that aliens who can build Dyson spheres HAVE to be everywhere. They could, as you say, just build one or two and live there. Or a species that colonises could build them as it goes.
Re:Upper limits on partial Dyson spheres in the Milky Way by bryanrasmussen on Saturday February 19, 2022 @03:27PM (#30400212)
That was in fact the statement of the post that I replied to "If they can build Dyson spheres, wouldn't they already be all over the place?"
Re:Upper limits on partial Dyson spheres in the Milky Way by MattPalmer1086 on Saturday February 19, 2022 @07:04PM (#30401801)
Got it, I missed that part of it. Totally agree that just because you can build a Dyson sphere doesn't imply you're going to travel a lot.
Re:Upper limits on partial Dyson spheres in the Milky Way by caf on Saturday February 19, 2022 @06:00AM (#30396149)
They may not be moving around to explore so much as to keep their solar system safe.

Galactic orbits are far more chaotic than the sedate stable orbits within the solar system - stars closely approach each other on a somewhat regular basis.

Re:Upper limits on partial Dyson spheres in the Milky Way by bryanrasmussen on Saturday February 19, 2022 @08:46AM (#30397089)
that's a good point, but I guess at Dyson sphere level a star approaching is like discovering oil on your property.
Re:Upper limits on partial Dyson spheres in the Milky Way by dave_sullivan on Saturday February 19, 2022 @02:11AM (#30395023)
No Dyson spheres, but there are black holes all over the place. Some people think those would make great computing devices, many of their origins are not well explained as super nova remnants, and they efficiently harness energy from companion stars. They have all the properties of Dyson spheres but they actually exist. Maybe with advanced enough physics, intelligent civilizations learn to manufacture and harness black holes, neutron stars, and other dense objects for societal benefit.
Re:Upper limits on partial Dyson spheres in the Milky Way by jonathankoren on Saturday February 19, 2022 @02:32AM (#30395115)
> No Dyson spheres, but there are black holes all over the place. Some people think those would make great computing devices

They’re crappy computing devices. Even if you figured out how to program one — and that’s an “if” that would make Sagittarius A* look like a neutrino — there’s no way to read the information out except Hawking Radiation, and that would take 10^70 years.

https://youtu.be/0GLgZvTCbaA (8:36)

Re:Upper limits on partial Dyson spheres in the Milky Way by alfiedotwtf on Saturday February 19, 2022 @02:32AM (#30395116)
This is the first time I've heard of this. Wow, yes! A blackhole is far more efficient at consuming energy than a Dyson Sphere... the hard part though is kickstarting the process I guess
Re:Upper limits on partial Dyson spheres in the Milky Way by ohyeshedid on Saturday February 19, 2022 @02:24AM (#30395083)
> If they can build Dyson spheres, wouldn't they already be all over the place?

I figure they'd have to be.

They'd need more than a solar system's worth of raw resources to build the sphere. They may need more than a solar system's worth of resources just to build the tools and craft to be able to build the sphere. They're going to need an insane amount of production facilities for various components, and that's going to take a massive amount of resources. That's going to require exploring quite a bit of a galaxy.

Re:Upper limits on partial Dyson spheres in the Milky Way by dnsco on Saturday February 19, 2022 @01:56AM (#30394955)
It depends on how you define practical value. Immediately capitalizable? Probably not outside of Hollywood. Building a theoretical underpinning for the future of our species? I hope so.
Re:Upper limits on partial Dyson spheres in the Milky Way by TheDudeMan on Saturday February 19, 2022 @02:06AM (#30394997)
This probably has implications around the Fermi paradox and the great filter(s). We would like to pass whatever filters are ahead of us.
Re:Upper limits on partial Dyson spheres in the Milky Way by kragen on Saturday February 19, 2022 @03:05AM (#30395268)
Was there any practical value in Columbus discovering America? If the Aztecs had instead sailed to Europe or Africa and discovered them, would that have been of any practical value to them?

It's difficult to imagine a discovery that would have more practical import than the discovery of an extraterrestrial civilization.

Re:Upper limits on partial Dyson spheres in the Milky Way by PeterisP on Saturday February 19, 2022 @03:41PM (#30400341)
> Was there any practical value in Columbus discovering America?

Why, yes, of course - even in the immediate short term the ships returned from expeditions with gold and slaves; and from the very start the exploration voyages were planned and funded solely as a practical endeavor for trade and looting, not as an intellectual curiosity.

Re:Upper limits on partial Dyson spheres in the Milky Way by kragen on Saturday February 19, 2022 @06:38PM (#30401626)
Moreover they resulted in a great deal of looting (and, eventually, trade).
Re:Upper limits on partial Dyson spheres in the Milky Way by ncmncm on Saturday February 19, 2022 @03:30AM (#30395399)
Hint: Columbus didn't discover America. Millions of people already lived there, and knew all about it.

But anyway looking for Dyson spheres will not reveal any extraterrestrial civilizations.

Re:Upper limits on partial Dyson spheres in the Milky Way by vasco on Saturday February 19, 2022 @03:50AM (#30395497)
A discovery doesn't have to imply that no living being knew about said thing/ place. It can imply only that the person or the group of people the person is from learns about this new thing. At some point in time nobody in Europe had definite proof of how to get to America. You can call "europeans learning how to get to America" something else other than "discovered America", but what phrasing should one use instead?

To make the point, literally nothing can be classified as "discovered" under your rules because any alien civilization may know about everything we'll ever find or figure out, and if they know about it we can't have discovered it.

Columbus was a murderer and people in America before he got there deserved way better but this type of nitpicking correction is just noise if you don't even say what is a more appropriate phrase.

Re:Upper limits on partial Dyson spheres in the Milky Way by kragen on Saturday February 19, 2022 @03:56AM (#30395533)
Are you saying that, even if extraterrestrial civilizations existed, looking for Dyson spheres wouldn't reveal them? Or are you saying that they don't exist, so nothing will reveal them? In either case, why?
Re:Upper limits on partial Dyson spheres in the Milky Way by ncmncm on Saturday February 19, 2022 @04:36AM (#30395711)
Looking for Dyson spheres wouldn't reveal them, because any extraterrestrial civilization sophisticated enough to make one wouldn't need it or want it.
Re:Upper limits on partial Dyson spheres in the Milky Way by kragen on Saturday February 19, 2022 @05:09PM (#30400988)
Unless you originate from a large confederation of such extraterrestrial civilizations, there's no way for you to know that.
Re:Upper limits on partial Dyson spheres in the Milky Way by ncmncm on Saturday February 19, 2022 @09:54PM (#30402792)
(Sssshhhh! Don't give me away.)
Re:Upper limits on partial Dyson spheres in the Milky Way by zzt123 on Saturday February 19, 2022 @03:35AM (#30395422)
I believe the person you are replying to is saying “discover” relatively rather than Euro-centrically, as they mention a hypothetical Aztecs “discovering” Europe and Africa.
Re:Upper limits on partial Dyson spheres in the Milky Way by GlennS on Saturday February 19, 2022 @04:13AM (#30395612)
Since you're being critical, I think you should suggest a better wording for "Columbus discovered American" that you think will piss fewer people off.
Re:Upper limits on partial Dyson spheres in the Milky Way by ncmncm on Saturday February 19, 2022 @05:22AM (#30395960)
Columbus stumbled over Hispaniola on what he thought was the way to someplace completely different. And then insisted he had got there, instead.
Re:Upper limits on partial Dyson spheres in the Milky Way by GlennS on Saturday February 19, 2022 @06:13AM (#30396219)
Perhaps something a little snappier and with less axe grinding?
Re:Upper limits on partial Dyson spheres in the Milky Way by ncmncm on Saturday February 19, 2022 @09:55PM (#30402797)
Columbus encountered America.
Re:Upper limits on partial Dyson spheres in the Milky Way by GlennS on Sunday February 20, 2022 @04:38AM (#30404478)
Love it!
Re:Upper limits on partial Dyson spheres in the Milky Way by Apocryphon on Saturday February 19, 2022 @02:33AM (#30395117)
You could possibly win an Ig Nobel Award out of it.