News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by onychomys on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @09:43AM (#30360553)
It's totally bonkers that the Japanese leadership didn't surrender after this raid. Or at least after the next ones that showed that the US could do it basically at will anywhere in Japan. I just will never understand how they could sit around and watch their citizens burn and continue to fight. Think of how many Japanese lives they could have saved if they'd surrendered in June instead of August.
Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by mc32 on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @09:55AM (#30360732)
War can be like a freight train. It's hard to stop on a dime --especially when the population has been completely sucked into the effort through religion (emperor-god) and additional propaganda. Just about all the civilian population was directly or indirectly supporting the war effort. It's hard to over-state how wrapped up in the war effort he whole nation was.

It was untenable to just quit. Of course there we some seasoned military figures who knew better, but just like us, when our generals warn against war (Iraq invasion for example) when the wheels are set in motion, there is little stopping it.)

Germany as well. The war was over way before Berlin capitulated.

Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by adolph on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @10:42AM (#30361409)
> War can be like a freight train. It's hard to stop on a dime --especially when the population has been completely sucked into the effort through religion (emperor-god) and additional propaganda.

Case in point:

After Japan officially surrendered in August 1945, Japanese holdouts in Southeast Asian countries and Pacific islands that had been part of the Japanese empire continued to fight local police, government forces, and American and British forces stationed to assist the newly formed governments. Many holdouts were discovered in Southeast Asia and the Pacific Islands over the following decades, with the last verified holdout, Private Teruo Nakamura, surrendering on Morotai Island in Indonesia in December 1974.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Japanese_holdout

Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by jacquesm on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @04:11PM (#30365735)
Brainwashing is a powerful thing. Make sure it never happens to you.
Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by thorncorona on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @04:42PM (#30366137)
It was war from the top led by the far-right. A great video about how Japan went from a democracy to an ultra-nationalist war-hawk government. [1]

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=voo0CpPcE0c

Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by nradov on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @10:27AM (#30361179)
The civilian population had no control and their religious beliefs were irrelevant to policy. The emperor and the top military leaders could have just quit at any time. I understand why they didn't want to quit, but they always had that option.
Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by mc32 on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @10:31AM (#30361221)
With decades under their belt trouncing and prancing around the East and having their way, marauding, pillaging, raping, burning, invading, etc., it was unthinkable for most in their military leadership (as well as civilians) that they could be defeated on their "home islands". (You know, previous war doctrines and all). It was unfathomable.

I do think their religious beliefs were relevant to policy. The US was very cognizant of this when they demanded the unconditional surrender of Japan.

Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by livueta on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @06:24PM (#30367254)
> I do think their religious beliefs were relevant to policy. The US was very cognizant of this when they demanded the unconditional surrender of Japan.

That's certainly the Chrysanthemum and the Sword take on it. I'd agree that American conceptions of Japanese religious beliefs influenced American policy. The extent to which emperor-worship was truly inculcated in the population at large is still subject to scholarly debate, but the trend is toward understanding that Japanese internal religious propaganda doesn't necessarily reflect deeply-held cultural beliefs. It's unquestionable that タケヤリで (with bamboo spears) was a thing to an extent and that an invasion of the mainland would have been a clusterfuck, but I personally see it (as described up-thread) as more ascribable to the comprehensive failure of the nation's autocratic elites at holding non-idiotic worldviews, rather than them (or the population at large) being hyper-fanatic State Shintoists.

Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by numpad0 on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @01:05PM (#30363379)
> The emperor and the top military leaders could have just quit at any time.

And trigger an immediate army coup to secure the Emperor and destroy defeat acceptance recordings. That happened.

Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by livueta on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @06:08PM (#30367111)
The military-political establishment had spent the past decade or more basically purity-spiralling out anyone seen as insufficiently dedicated to the cause of imperial expansion.

To me, the most striking example of this is what happened to Ishiwara Kanji[1]. This is the guy who gekokujou'd Manchukuo into existence, so not exactly a cautious humanitarian.

Ishiwara later got purged for opposing further expansionism in China: he thought that grabbing Manchukuo had been enough to assure Japan's quest for autarky in vital military materials, and that continued messing around in China would accelerate confrontation with the West and act as a resource drain on Japan's ability to shape itself into a militarily self-sufficient state. He was totally right, of course, but got it in the neck anyway.

There's a lot more examples of this, both in the military branches and in elite political circles. I highly recommend the scholarly book Japan Prepares For Total War[2] if you're interested in the details. The result, though, was that many voices of reason were explicitly removed from power for being too reasonable. At this point in the war, the cast of characters running the show weren't able or willing to see sense and had insulated themselves from all advice and criticism.

---

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kanji_Ishiwara

[2] https://books.google.com/books/about/Japan_Prepares_for_Tota...

Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by bonsoir on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @03:57PM (#30365570)
The US was asking for surrendering without conditions. That was the part that was debated by Japanese internaly, it’s all documented. Remember, their Emperor was considered to be a God. Put yourself in their shoe, what would be consequences for the population to have the US potentially trial and give death penalty to their Emperor ? Would it still be Japan? (keep in mind, people were brainwashed). In the end, even the US decided that keeping the Emperor in place was for the best, however the Japanese had no way to know beforehand, because the US wouldn’t give guarentee.
Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by throwthere on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @06:30PM (#30367319)
Are you sure? I thought the US repeatedly called for unconditional surrender of the military, not total surrender?
Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by eschulz on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @10:06AM (#30360893)
You're right since this not only killed many thousands but demonstrated that the US was completely capable in destroying any Japanese city at their whim. Sure rearming and maintaining aircraft can take days, but at this point the Japanese military played no part in defending their cities, and it was just all up to US decision making whether to continue to quick destruction of Japanese municipalities.

I think the saga of the Japanese leadership considering surrender is fascinating. Obviously everything will be destroyed pretty soon without capitulation, but it's clear that the leadership had a difficult time admitting that their decades of confidence in the Japanese military's destiny were wrong.

Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by 1270018080 on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @01:09PM (#30363440)
A quote from Mitsuo Fuchida, a Pearl Harbor attack pilot:

"You did the right thing. You know the Japanese attitude at that time, how fanatic they were, they'd die for the Emperor ... Every man, woman, and child would have resisted that invasion with sticks and stones if necessary ... Can you imagine what a slaughter it would be to invade Japan? It would have been terrible. The Japanese people know more about that than the American public will ever know."

Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by fatbird on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @01:52PM (#30364056)
At the time the bombs were dropped in August 1945, there were also 900,000 veteran Japanese soldiers on the Home Islands. Even if the civilians didn't pick up sticks and stones, the Japanese death toll would almost certainly include that number.
Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by fatbird on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @01:50PM (#30364028)
Japan was run by the Emperor and a six person cabinet; the military held half the cabinet seats. The Emperor didn't rule the cabinet, and thus the country; the group governed by internal consensus.

Even after the atomic bombs were dropped, the military half of the cabinet would not accept unconditional surrender; the Emperor and civilian half would have accepted surrender much earlier, but feared the military would simply seize control, as had happened many times before in Japanese history. And even after the Emperor forced the decision in cabinet to accept surrender, there was an attempted coup by parts of the military.

Japanese obstinacy was driven mainly by a kind of hybrid fascist/bushido doctrine that dominated the Japanese military starting in the 20s.

Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by InTheArena on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @09:57AM (#30360767)
The Japanese leadership believed (not without reason) that they could make the cost of invading Japan so incredibly catastrophic in American blood that the decadent, racially and culturally inferior United States would not pay it.

People forget but the bloodiest days of WW2 where not in the insanely large battles where the Hitler regime was defeated, but rather in the last months when obvious defeat was years earlier for the Nazis - and where where Eastern Europe was devastated between the Germans the Soviets. The flow of blood was unimaginable.

I personally would hope that would have been the case that the USA not invade, as the intelligence started to show that the two-stage Americans invasion plans for the Japanese home islands badly underestimated the Japanese. Washington was already concerned about the cost, but we know now that these estimates where off by almost 50%.

They still had options, even without the Atomic bombs. That alternative would have been a starvation blockade. Given the complete collapse of the Japanese economy, the complete inability to import food, that blockade would have made what occurred in WWI with Britain blockading Germany, or the earlier famines in Bangladesh, or even the systematic starvation program that the Bolsheviks unleashed in the Ukraine (The Holodomor) look like Child's play.

Edit - honestly curious why people are downvoting this?

Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by panick21_ on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @11:46AM (#30362249)
People might down vote because they are uninformed.

Once you seriously look into Japan plans for suicide attacks on massive scales would have been very costly. They were doing series effort in transformed their air-force and navy into suicide attack armed forces.

And these suicide attacks are not crazy, they were well plant and well executed attacks designed inflict massive costly attrition on the US.

Think about literally 10000s of well planned and executed suicide plans and suicide submarines attacks, army willing to suffer mass sacrifice.

And the fact is, the US did not have any solution for these suicide wave attacks. They were literally designed to work around US air defense patterns, and by the end of the war, the US had not figured out how to decisively defeated these attacks.

Landing 100000s of troupes in Japan against massive waves of suicide plans would have been insane.

> the systematic starvation program that the Bolsheviks unleashed in the Ukraine (The Holodomor)

Just FYI, it was not a systematic starvation program, it was a systematic food export program. And it was not target at Ukraine, but was applied in much the same way all over the Soviet Union.

I know there are some books that push the ethnic angle (and doing so is very popular particularly now), but its pretty clear from the top level documents and policies that it wasn't some form of ethnic warfare.

It was do whatever you need to export food so you can buy machines from the West.

Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by throwaway0a5e on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @01:21PM (#30363603)
>Just FYI, it was not a systematic starvation program, it was a systematic food export program. And it was not target at Ukraine, but was applied in much the same way all over the Soviet Union.

Food production was initially fine. After USSR central planning shenanigans shaking things up production was less. Those crops were then allocated away from Ukraine because they were last in line to be fed and first in line to starve for political reasons.

Whether that constitutes "systemic starvation" or just "normal starvation" is pretty much an exercise in taxonomy because the fact of the matter is that intentional decisions by the people in charge are what lead to the problem.

Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by panick21_ on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @03:25PM (#30365220)
What matter to the top people at the government was not total production, but rather total share of production controlled by the government. They didn't not care if total production went down.

> intentional decisions by the people in charge are what lead to the problem

And I am not denying that. What I am arguing against is the claim that this was ethnic derived warfare target at destroying Ukrainian nationalism. That is the story often told today.

Stalin certainty was engaged in class warfare ('taking a class approach' is the common translation used from his writings) and many different cultures and ethnicity were hit. Kazakhs, Ukrainians and lets not remember the many Russian victims too, and of course many more.

Their fundamental driver was getting the resources need for spending on industrialization.

Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by csense on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @10:28PM (#30369218)
> They didn't care if total production went down.

They didn't care if millions of people died slowly and horribly of starvation.

Phrasing it as "Production went down" is a rather extreme euphemism.

Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by panick21_ on Thursday February 17, 2022 @03:55AM (#30370956)
Yes that's correct. From a practical standpoint that simply means lower overall production, that communist party logical for you. Gaining control over the means of production is what mattered to them. Anything cost was acceptable to achieve that outcome.
Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by myth_drannon on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @12:40PM (#30363024)
I think less of an export issue but mass collectivization all across USSR. My g-grandfather was sent to Siberia in 1932 for refusing to give up his cow to collective farm. That's one good farmer family less to produce. Now multiply it by one million and you get a famine on unimaginable scale.
Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by panick21_ on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @03:29PM (#30365258)
Sure, the reason they did the collectivization beyond the ideology is so they could then control that production and channel it towards the uses they desired.

Total production was expected to go down. The regime was very well aware of that. But their control over that production was increased exponentially.

And considering the industrialization, a lot of that went into exports where it was exchanged for industrial goods.

Sorry for your g-grandfather, must have been a horrible time. Its insane that back then they considered anybody a 'wealthy farmer' who had like 1-2 cows.

Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by InTheArena on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @02:31PM (#30364601)
It's fair to note that this is contentious - I would just point that the most recent scholarship has focused on (not surprisingly) Stalin's point of view with the Ukraine (and he absolutely did view it as a systematic way to weaken the Kulak's and the Ukraine), and Historians seem to now be generally viewing it as a genocide. That's not universal, but certainly the way that the scholarship (at the moment) is trending.
Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by panick21_ on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @04:38PM (#30366096)
I do not venture in what is and isn't genocide. The legal definition and common use and so on. I don't know.

My point is that it is not primarily target towards ethnicity. It was certainty targeted towards Kulak's and of course, Ukraine had a productive land and thus a fair number of 'Kulaks'. The typical translation that is most often repeated in Stalin writing and the 'party line' was 'taking a class approach'.

What I dislike is the Ukrainian nationalist attempt to own the history. The same policy hit other ethnic groups just as hard. The Kazakh population was probably more effected in terms of %.

A huge amount of ethnically Russian farmer died as well, and they often get no mention in discussions of this.

I has become fashionable to portray it as a Ukrainian tragedy, rather then a Eurasian tragedy. It effect people between Moldova, Omsk and Arkhangelsk and beyond.

The most powerful version of that is Red Famine by Anne Applebaum. And that book as a pretty clear focus on Ukraine and a political message for the current situation for Western audiences. Ukrainian nationalism has been trying to use the Holodomor in the same way Israel does with the Holocaust, it gives it the permenent victim role and the moral high ground. She her self of course is a political commentator on those matters and her husband is politically active in trying to pull Ukraine into Europe. While here book does pay some small amount of attention to the other aspect and other victims, the overwhelming message is about Ukrainians suffering and overcoming basically intentional attempts at destruction of Ukraine and that is what the conversation around the book has universally focused on those aspects.

Steven Kotkin biography of Stalin that just came out spent a lot time at looking at the Presidential archives, meaning the archives of actual stuff on Stalin desk. With Stalin writing on it. Very often Stalin notes his responses directly on the reports he gets. And the overwhelming focus on that is showing how Stalin had on his desk lots of reports of starvation from all over the Soviet Union, his response a lot of focus getting his party to hit requisition quotas and that the reports about starvation were exaggerated or excuses by functionaries for failing to hit quotas. Very little is about 'lets plan a mass starvation because we are afraid of Ukrainian nationalism'. The overwhelming focus is on building and wielding a governmental machine to impose a new state dominate economic system on everybody, no matter the cost.

I have certainty not done an exhaustive study of all books and paper published on this topic in the last decade so your overall characterization of the debate might be accurate.

The term 'systematic starvation' implies that starvation was the goal. This is not the case in my opinion. The Soviet certainty expected economic disruption and people like Alexei Rykov (2nd most powerful guy in the Soviet Union) opposed the collectivization on those grounds. However even in Rykov worst prediction fell well short of what was actually required to push this all the way to the end. Their reports don't say 'great success, mass starvation achieved', they actually believed their own propaganda about how collective farms would be far more efficient and so on.

The difference seem to me that Soviets are willing to tolerate starvation to achieve their goals, not that they deliberately engineered starvation to achieve their goals. And their primary goals were not targeting Ukrainian nationalism.

All in all, its a difficult topic and has been used as a political weapon before it even started so its of course a minefield.

Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by Aloha on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @06:03PM (#30367069)
You drew the same conclusions I did.

The Soviet system is the best example of what happens when the measurement becomes the metric - it produces all sorts of unintended effects, trains of freight being moved hundreds of miles to fulfill a ton-mile quota, ignoring what functionaries in the aparat say, because they dont fit the measurement-metric, etc.

Like you, I don't believe that mass starvation was the point, but it did have the effect of temporarily tamping down nationalism too.

I also found https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B007CJLZKQ/ quite interesting, as to how it painted stalinist society, and gave me a clearer understanding.

I'm eagerly looking forward to the final part of the biography on stalin.

Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by vkou on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @10:14AM (#30360993)
> The Japanese leadership believed (not without reason) that they could make the cost of invading Japan so incredibly catastrophic in American blood that the decadent, racially and culturally inferior United States would not pay it.

They also forgot that right on the other side of a small channel was the world's largest army that was willing to pay it. The US has a total of 160,000 dead in the entirety of the Pacific war. That was a week of active fighting on the Eastern front.

To their credit, they didn't actually forget, they were simply hoping that the USSR would keep it's word and not break their non-aggression pact. It didn't, though, and overran Japan's continental holdings in a matter of days.

Losing Manchuria was huge in bringing Japan to the negotiating table.

Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by InTheArena on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @10:40AM (#30361375)
The Kwangtung army had been stripped to the bone, and then the Japanese has built up the army with underfed conscripts. They were faced with a army that didn't think a thing of spending lives or even being economical about the lives they spent, due to years of radicalization on the western front.

That said, this point is usually very overblown by cold-war theorists. It was a factor, but not the Factor. The Atomic bomb was the critical factor in Hirohito's thinking and Kids in particular - and the imperial court is what forced the end of the war. Supposedly the Army was more concerned about the Russians, but the Army never cared about Japanese civilians anyways - and their concern went so far that leadership cliques in the Army tried to overthrow Hirohito.

Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by GartzenDeHaes on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @10:34AM (#30361296)
Not to mention that the USSR had already taken several of Japan's northern islands, which are still held by Russia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kuril_Islands_dispute
Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by chrisseaton on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @09:50AM (#30360655)
Did they think at the time that their people would suffer more under occupation than they would trying to continue to fight?

(Actual question, not rhetorical.)

Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by dairylee on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @10:00AM (#30360829)
The Japanese Government didn't want an unconditional surrender as it would have meant the Emperor (Who was seen as quasi-divine) would have potentially been tried for war crimes and executed.

They didn't care about their citizens, just the Emperor.

Fantastic video which explains everything: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RCRTgtpC-Go

Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by s1artibartfast on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @01:19PM (#30363570)
Happiness utilitarianism is so pervasive today that people forget alternatives even exist, but there are a wide array of value systems.

For at least some, the suffering was irrelevant. Many held that it would be better for every Japanese person to die than loose the war.

Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by duxup on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @09:58AM (#30360789)
It seemed to me there was a sort of victory or death kind of dynamic.

If you think of defeat like death, then surrendering means you die sooner. Military leadership and civilian suicides in the face of defeat were not uncommon.

In the meantime I don't think Japan allowed for many different points of view on the topic and even expressing it might be risky / the same result.

Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by maxk42 on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @06:12PM (#30367159)
What's worse is they didn't surrender after Hiroshima was destroyed. They reasoned that the US military probably only had a few of these weapons, and therefore losing a few cities was considered acceptable losses.

The leadership of Japan during this time was truly reprehensible: Willing to sacrifice millions of their own citizens to continue their failing war of aggression.

Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by CPLX on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @09:53AM (#30360694)
If the Japanese had done it to New York City would you have surrendered?
Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by mc32 on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @09:57AM (#30360775)
I think you're kind of pointing to the London V-II raids. If Germany had had the production, London would have had to surrender. Luckily their initial V-1 bombs were not very accurate and their V-IIs were slow to ramp up, so that bought lots of time.

We have more land, so I think we could have dispersed the population to the country to make the bombs or raids less effective. But at some threshold you do have to give up and fight another day.

Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by panick21_ on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @11:35AM (#30362113)
No they would not have. V2 raids are very ineffective and basically didn't effect the population much at all. Its just out of a blue sometimes a building explodes.

99% of those bombs don't hit anything relevant for the war effort.

At the same time production of those rockets was far more costly then whatever they hit in Britain.

And sure, if they could magically have no limits then maybe. But in practice, Germany had mass starvation while huge amounts of bio-mass was converted into rocket fuel. Not to mention very inefficient uses other materials.

Even ignoring all that, the total payload deployed by German over Britain was laughably small compared to allied bombing raids.

Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by CPLX on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @10:24AM (#30361125)
I think there's a reasonable argument to be made that England would not have surrendered if every single blade of grass and tree stump on the island had been reduced to smoking ash.

Arguable, clearly. But plausible.

Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by mc32 on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @10:28AM (#30361184)
If it were up to Churchill, probably but I don't think the military leadership would have followed all the way there. At some point, you have to be pragmatic. Yet, in this case, Germany would be thirsty for revenge (given the name of the V-II rockets), so that makes the calculus more difficult --on the other hand you had a Vichy France, so who knows.
Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by BurningFrog on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @10:44AM (#30361441)
A separate English peace would have made a lot of sense.

Hitler had no interest in expanding westward. His plan was a great German empire where the Volga would be what the Mississippi is in the US. If France & Britain had not attacked, Germany would very likely have left them alone.

In the east, it was a fight to the death, and both sides knew it. If the Russians surrendered, they faced extinction.

Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by pintxo on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @11:20AM (#30361948)
Yes, Hitler was mainly interested in moving expanding eastward. But he was intelligent enough to see that the (declining but still) empires of France and Britain would not have allowed this to happen. Thus his initial attack westward to neutralize this threat to his eastward expansion plans. It's a tragedy, that Stalin secured this westward move by signing the Hitler-Stalin pact in 1939, basically neutralizing the east while Hitler would sweep the west. We will never know what would have happened if Hitler had adversaries on both fronts from the beginning.
Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by Loughla on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @01:15PM (#30363519)
>We will never know what would have happened if Hitler had adversaries on both fronts from the beginning.

This is just one point among hundreds in this thread that I find fascinating for the same reason.

So many people here know exactly what they would've and what we should've done back then. Because we have the benefit of nearly a hundred years of analysis and hindsight.

Most of the disagreements here aren't actually about what happened, and why, but what the people in this thread would've done and why.

I find that fascinating.

Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by mc32 on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @01:42PM (#30363921)
Exactly.

They're basically the equivalent of "Ha! If I were Yamamoto, I would have...." because they know what happened and when and what would have turned events. But had they been in Yamamoto's (or Nimitz's or Patton's, or Rommel's) position, would have made much worse decisions. As you say they have complete benefit of decades of study of the war and tactics as well as limitations we are privileged to know only after the war.

Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by BurningFrog on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @01:11PM (#30363462)
I mean, when France and Britain declared war 2 days after the invasion of Poland, you didn't need much intelligence to see where things were going.
Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by ceejayoz on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @10:08AM (#30360904)
If they went on to do it to several other cities, demonstrating total control of the airspace and the ability to wipe any city of their choosing off the map overnight, and it was after years of losing battles... probably.
Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by omot on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @10:19AM (#30361063)
I’m not sure. Even then, knowing Japanese atrocities in all of Asia, it’s probably better to just keep fighting to the death as opposed to being subject to slavery, rape, or human experiments.

I’m sure a part of the reason the Japanese refused surrender was because their reflection in the mirror was not pretty.

Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by mynameishere on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @10:02AM (#30360852)
If the probability of success was zero, perhaps. But then the probability of success was zero after Pearl Harbor so perhaps not.
Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by Someone on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @10:18AM (#30361044)
I think all historians agree a US victory was almost certain, if not dead certain after Pearl Harbor. That attack didn’t destroy enough of the US fleet to buy the Japanese time to trie and get even with the USA in production capacity.

Even the Japanese military knew that at the time. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Attack_on_Pearl_Harbor#Strateg...:

Admiral Hara Tadaichi summed up the Japanese result by saying, "We won a great tactical victory at Pearl Harbor and thereby lost the war."

Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by sofixa on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @10:54AM (#30361598)
They knew it before that as well:

> In the first six to twelve months of a war with the United States and Great Britain I will run wild and win victory upon victory. But then, if the war continues after that, I have no expectation of success.

Isoruku Yamamoto, commander-in-chief of the Japanese Navy.

Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by InTheArena on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @10:50AM (#30361542)
The problem with this line of thought is that it's basically ignores the historical exemplar that Japan used to justify their actions in the first place - the Sino-Ruso war. Russia was a juggernaut compared to Japan, but two catastrophic attacks - one surprised removed all support for the war from Japan, and the Czar gave in and ended the war.

Historians are arguing that in a industrialized conflict, where the United States was committed to war, Japan had no shot at winning. And to some degree that's true. But it depended on political factors that were no means set in stone.

But was America truly that dedicated to war with Japan? Turns out yes - but it's not hard to see a world where Japan wasn't quite a closely allied to Germany and/or Midway had gone the other way, or after millions where dead in the home island where that commitment would be tested.

Or conversely - as Hitler hoped - Japan would hold off America just long enough for the Russians to be finished off by the Germans in the East and Britain would finally come to the table. In a "Germany First" Strategy, America could not have taken the offensive in 1942 in that scenario.

But it's also reflective of the dehumanization that Japan's leadership as - the West was soft, just as the Russians were soft, and Japan's greater fighting spirit would carry the day.

Pearl Harbor didn't predetermine history.

Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by sofixa on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @10:56AM (#30361625)
Especially considering Midway was so close, even with the gigantic advantages the US Navy has ( intelligence so they basically knew what the Japanese were doing, in what order and where, and radars).
Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by TomK32 on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @02:45PM (#30364750)
The Japanese tried firebombing the West Coast. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fu-Go_balloon_bomb
Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by newaccount2021 on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @10:02AM (#30360847)
If faced with massive destruction and extremely high anticipated civilian casualties with absolutely no hope of victory...yes, surrender is totally rational

Once the US took Guam, the war was over (Guam was close enough to Japan to enable the US to enact a campaign of unlimited bombing). From that point forward, continued conflict was a matter of Japanese leaders sacrificing their own citizens for absolutely no gain

Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by s1artibartfast on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @01:44PM (#30363952)
Rationality and gain are relative to one's goals and values.
[dead]
Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by mc32 on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @10:18AM (#30361045)
When you're in the middle of a hard fought war you do not have the certainty afforded by history. Everything is at stake. You may think you're ahead but then you suffer unthinkable losses (the battle of the bulge, for example --for both sides and the Korean war). With large scale wars where both sides both have a chance at winning, it's not over till it's over. You have no idea what will happen you cannot afford to say, "I think we'll win, let's pull back". Your fleet can be sunk, your ally can fall unpredictably (leadership death), etc.

You also have to remember, the Axis Japanese were extremely brutal in war. The allies could not afford to think, "maybe they'll turn nice".

Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by syki on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @10:24AM (#30361135)
We can go back and forth and quibble over using the word “murder” as you have and quibble over who ultimately is to blame. I won’t convince you of anything and likewise you won’t convince me of anything. War truly is hell and after the way the Japanese conducted themselves during the war there’s a certain karma involved in terms of them getting the total war they so desired.

War sucks. My dad fought in World War 2. Frontline soldier in Western Europe in Patton’s Third Army. His battalion war book has the names of the dead and many are underlined in red because those are the ones he knew. He was a drunk and abusive and obviously suffered from untreated PTSD.

His division was preparing to transfer to the Pacific when the atomic bombs were dropped. He appreciated that as a result the Japanese surrendered (at least it appeared to be a causal effect from his perspective). Who can possibly calculate the efficacy of the alternatives even in retrospect? It’s easy to criticize after the fact. Are you so certain you’d have decided differently than Curtis LeMay were you in his position?

Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by user-the-name on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @10:32AM (#30361254)
I am not necessarily saying the choice was wrong. It was one bad option out of many.

However, I am challenging the incredibly strong urge people have to absolve those who made the choice of any kind of responsibility for having made it. You will see it even in the responses to this comment. We absolutely refuse to even acknowledge that a choice was, in fact, made to kill all of these innocent civilians.

The person I responded to is struggling to understand how the Japanese reacted to this. But he is paying absolute zero mind to the actions and reactions of those on his own side, who chose to bring this tragedy about.

The very idea of thinking about the acts committed by your own side is strongly, strongly taboo.

Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by nradov on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @10:56AM (#30361634)
I absolve those who made the choice of any kind of responsibility for protecting enemy civilians. Their only responsibility was towards Americans. If their choice saved even one American life then in context it was the right choice. How could they possibly ask Americans to contine dying if they had the means to shorten the war?
Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by lowbloodsugar on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @01:25PM (#30363671)
While it is true that many will absolve the decision makers without thinking, or with thoughts of revenge, a deeper analysis shows that it was a reasonable decision. You write them off as "strongly, strongly taboo". Is that as far as that goes then? Wasn't everything, starting with Pearl Harbor, strongly, strongly taboo? Is it ok to murder someone just because they are in a uniform, because two humans, who we will call "kings", or "emperors", or "presidents" have a disagreements? Bottom line you're walking into a moral discussion about war with the idea "killing is bad". Think you need to up your game.
Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by panick21_ on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @11:52AM (#30362334)
I don't think anybody denies this choice was made. Of course it was.

They made it earlier in the war. Civilians were the war economy and civilians were legit targets for all nations in war.

Civilians in a total war are just not typical civilians. Everybody in society was mobilized for war.

> The very idea of thinking about the acts committed by your own side is strongly, strongly taboo.

No it isn't. Lots of historians work on that. There are lots of talks about it in places like WW2 History Museum and so on.

Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by gus_massa on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @12:08PM (#30362526)
> Civilians were the war economy and civilians were legit targets for all nations in war.

That's not what the Geneva Conventions says.

Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by panick21_ on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @12:29PM (#30362806)
The Geneva Conventions from 1949?

Before there there was Hague Conventions of 1899 and 1907. Those were violated in WW1 on a large scale and no alternative had been put into place.

All these things are good and nice, but the reality is, if disagreeing with these is vital to win a war, literally no nation followed them.

Those kinds of agreements are good attempts in peace time to improve the chance of good outcomes, but in reality, in major global they are just pieces of papers that can not be enforced.

If you want to run around and simply say everybody is evil, then you can do that. But if you actually put yourself in the position of those people and try to make decisions if you want to be critical, explain what and how you would have done things differently.

And what cost would you have been willing to engage in to achieve that moral high ground.

Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by onychomys on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @10:31AM (#30361230)
I'm pretty sure I didn't actually pass any judgement one way or the other on the actions of the US military in that post. The two are morally separate, we don't have to do a what-about-ism for it.
Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by user-the-name on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @10:33AM (#30361280)
Indeed you didn't. But you jumped immediately very strongly to one question, rather than to another. You have been conditioned all your life to question the decisions of the enemy, but to never, ever question the decisions of your own side.
Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by onychomys on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @10:58AM (#30361660)
Or maybe I was making a conscious choice to comment on the one but not the other. In the last 20 years or so, there's been a wide reconsideration about the morality of dropping bombs (whether nuclear or conventional) on civilian populations during the war. I don't think we need to have yet another conversation about that. Instead, I'm trying to understand the Japanese viewpoint, where they get a telegram that 100k people have been killed in a raid and think "Bummer, but we fight on!".
Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by user-the-name on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @04:21PM (#30365856)
Has there really been "wide reconsideration" of that?

Or do we like to pretend there has, and that's all done now, but still treat the subject as taboo and avoid it?

Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by bcrosby95 on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @03:22PM (#30365192)
We're all just fleas on the backs of wolves.
Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by DiffEq on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @10:20AM (#30361075)
This is a good questions and deserves an answer. The decision to murder one hundred thousand human beings was made not by the leadership of the United States but by the Japanese Imperial command when they decided to start and continue the war. So the blood of these people is on the hands of the Japanese Imperial Command and none else.

This is also the case when a murderer is put to death for their crime. The murderer is responsible for the person he killed and his own death; the state who put him to death is not responsible for his murder.

Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by user-the-name on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @10:29AM (#30361199)
Absolutely not. Every person involved made a choice, of their own free will. You do not get to absolve the ones you like of responsibility and instead put it all on those who you do not.

Choices were made. They had consequences.

Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by DiffEq on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @12:14PM (#30362612)
Are you saying that U.S. leadership is responsible for the murders of those that were killed in the strategic bombing of Japan? If you are - then you are wrong.
Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by user-the-name on Thursday February 17, 2022 @07:29AM (#30372355)
Did they make the decision to kill those people?
Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by Nabati on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @09:53AM (#30360702)
It's totally bonkers that soldiers are alright with killing hundreds of thousands of people and destroying whole cities without even flinching.
Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by retrac on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @10:02AM (#30360856)
You had a 67% chance of being killed on your first tour with British Bomber Command, rising to 85% after two tours. Were the airmen "alright" with that statistic too, when they were forced into a cockpit? There wasn't much of a choice in the matter for the average soldier on the ground (or in the air) on any side in that great conflict. Most of them were conscripts and desertion potentially carried the death penalty even on the Allied side. That loss of individual agency is part of the war's many horrors; whether you were alright with it or not was quite irrelevant.

It's worth noting psychiatric casualties for bomber crews, for the Allies at least, were sky-high with about a quarter of those not killed in combat being discharged for mental breakdowns. Whether that rate of breakdown is from the extreme risk, or from sometimes coming back smelling like burning flesh, is up for debate.

Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by InTheArena on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @10:19AM (#30361053)
And then take Japanese soldiers, where that wasn't a 67% change, it was 100% that you would eventually get conscripted into a Banzai charge, or a Kamikazi brigade, or given a bamboo spike, and told to hold the Americans at bay.

We really do a disservice when we try to take WWII and put it into a modern relativistic historical analysis. The scope of evil and sacrifice here is completely different from our western conception of War as a video game where kids fly drones and random pixels die.

Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by petermcneeley on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @09:56AM (#30360744)
If I know the history correct Japan actually did get conditional surrender. The USA wanted unconditional surrender which the never got despite dropping 2 atom bombs on cities which were not really military targets.
Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by trothamel on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @10:04AM (#30360872)
"We hereby proclaim the unconditional surrender to the Allied Powers of the Japanese Imperial General Headquarters and of all Japanese armed forces and all armed forces under the Japanese control wherever situated."

That's a quote from the Japanese Instrument of Surrender.

Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by petermcneeley on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @10:28AM (#30361192)
Japan wanted to keep the emperor of japan this is why they wouldnt unconditionally surrender. I was under the impression that they got to keep the emperor thus it was not an unconditional surrender.
Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by boomboomsubban on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @10:43AM (#30361413)
They agreed to unconditional surrender and then got to keep the Emperor. Which makes one wonder if the US had actually offered surrender terms that included keeping the Emperor maybe Japan would have surrendered. Instead they just demanded unconditional surrender.
Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by ApolloFortyNine on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @01:20PM (#30363589)
As with almost everything there are countless reasons why Japan didn't surrender earlier. [1] By June of 1945 Japan's leaders did want out of the war, but were still hoping for a surrender that allowed them to keep much of their holdings (I think people often forget how much of East Asia Japan had solidly controlled for almost 10 years at this point). And they were being strung along by the Soviet union who was supposed to mediate peace, yet had their own motives to prolong the war until they could join.

And even after dropping 2 nukes, and believing the US had 100 more, it took days more, and some additional attacks, to convince Japan to surrender. And even after all this, there was a serious attempted coup.

[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Surrender_of_Japan#:~:text=T....

Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by weeblewobble on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @02:49PM (#30364798)
The official Postdam Declaration (allied surrender terms) didn't mention imperial sovereignty one way or the other, but it appears the Emperor considered it to have been agreed upon prior to the "unconditional" surrender

Some more color, from Wikipedia:

"The Japanese cabinet considered the Allied response, and Suzuki argued that they must reject it and insist on an explicit guarantee for the imperial system. Anami returned to his position that there be no occupation of Japan. Afterward, Tōgō told Suzuki that there was no hope of getting better terms, and Kido conveyed the Emperor's will that Japan surrender. [...]

That day, Hirohito informed the imperial family of his decision to surrender. One of his uncles, Prince Asaka, then asked whether the war would be continued if the kokutai (imperial sovereignty) could not be preserved. The Emperor simply replied "of course.""

Re:History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during Wor... by Retric on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @10:12AM (#30360961)
Hiroshima was a supply and logistics base for the Japanese military with 40,000 soldiers in the city roughly 1/2 where killed by the atomic bomb where closer to 1/4 of the civilian population was killed. It also supported a large war industry, manufacturing parts for planes and boats, for bombs, rifles, and handguns.

By WWII’s low standards that was very much a military target. In comparison Japan tried using unguided balloons to bomb the US which while completely ineffective targeted everyone. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fu-Go_balloon_bomb