News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Does targeted advertising work at all? by soared on Saturday February 05, 2022 @09:34PM (#30228718)
Yes. Brands, third parties, google, etc have all ran incremental sales lift tests, brand lift studies, customer lifetime value tests, etc and determined how successful tactics are and moved budget accordingly. There is a reason google/etc are worth billions.

I’ve posted this comment before, but:

1. It’s hard to tell when someone has bought a product. You buy it at a reseller and the brand will never know. Or you buy it on mobile, but have researched the brand on desktop. Or you purchased it at work, but were researching it at home. Advertisers suppress known buyers but they don’t perfectly match you to all of your devices.

2. Just like there are not so good developers and not so good code, there are not so good marketers who aren’t that great at their job. Or they have too much work and didn’t set it up correctly. DSPs are extremely extremely complicated, so it’s to make mistakes.

3. Retention and advertising to previous purchasers drives more additional purchases. Maybe you only purchased blinds for the main floor of your house but not the basement.

Re:Ask HN: Does targeted advertising work at all? by Syonyk on Saturday February 05, 2022 @09:52PM (#30228847)
> It’s hard to tell when someone has bought a product.

How about, "I've literally got it in my last-day purchase history on eBay and they keep showing me the same thing and a bunch of related stuff to the item that hasn't even arrived yet, but that they've taken my money for"?

... and then eBay follows me around showing the same stuff on other sites. The thing I've purchased. From eBay. At least, they did, until I got more aggressive blocking ads and started using the internet a ton less.

Re:Ask HN: Does targeted advertising work at all? by pooper on Saturday February 05, 2022 @09:58PM (#30228894)
A certain national bank which I shall not name had a banner on top of its app. The link opens a web page that goes to double click and then opens the bank's website. Why would a bank app take me through a double click link just to take me back to their own website? My guess is this is the same reason why eBay shows you ads for things you just bought. There are massive inefficiencies in these large organizations. I'm sure everything they do is locally optimal but not even close globally.
Re:Ask HN: Does targeted advertising work at all? by names_are_hard on Sunday February 06, 2022 @03:55AM (#30230616)
Wow...I think you just discovered a hole in Apple's draconian app store policies. They don't let you link to your website from your app if the site has a way to buy a subscription without paying the Apple tax. But what if you sell ad space in your app through an intermediary, and then turn around and bid on ads for users that have your app installed? You might be able to get them to notice you and sign up on the web instead of through the app.

Genius.

(I'm only being half-facetious)

Re:Ask HN: Does targeted advertising work at all? by pooper on Tuesday February 08, 2022 @07:19AM (#30257573)
Thank you for your reply. I went back to look at where I had mentioned that I had used an iPhone but you're right. I have an iPhone and and Android phone but I use banking apps exclusively on the iPhone.

Interesting idea. Probably still would be cheaper than paying 30% tax to Apple.

Re:Ask HN: Does targeted advertising work at all? by soared on Saturday February 05, 2022 @10:32PM (#30229108)
In-app analytics is done through a “mobile measurement partner” which have limitations in tracking so sometimes you need workarounds like using a redirect.

Also likely the app is a totally different team and getting them to change a link is difficult, but giving them a link where the web team can change the redirect is easy.

Re:Ask HN: Does targeted advertising work at all? by iamstupidsimple on Sunday February 06, 2022 @09:43AM (#30232923)
It's called a "house ad" and is generally free for the publisher. They appear when there's no other inventory (like insurance ads). Usually double-click stuff is all negotiated by publishers and has little to do with AdSense or bidding.
Re:Ask HN: Does targeted advertising work at all? by dylan604 on Saturday February 05, 2022 @10:29PM (#30229095)
if it didn't do the round trip, it would leave a hole in the analytics. They get paid on the analytics, so the analytics must be kept whole
Re:Ask HN: Does targeted advertising work at all? by Scoundreller on Sunday February 06, 2022 @01:56AM (#30230120)
At least it’s a thing you bought. I wanted to sell a thing, so I went onto newegg to copy the description and paste it into my eBay listing and I got ads following me around the internet to buy the thing for weeks.

Like, I’m the opposite of interested in buying it, I’m trying to get rid of it.

Re:Ask HN: Does targeted advertising work at all? by Tomte on Sunday February 06, 2022 @12:45AM (#30229841)
My standard response to this: Prior purchases do have predictive power. They can very well be positively correlated to further purchases.

I've often bought stuff that didn't work for some reason. It was broken, or it had something that was bothering me. Maybe the power adapter was annoyingly loud (looking at you, Kyocera).

So I sent it back. But before I managed to go to the postal office a few days later I was already searching for a replacement online.

If I buy a TV set, I have indicated that I need/want a TV set. The rate of returns is broadly known (and maybe even specifically for me the return rate is known).

So Amazon et. al. do well to recommend similar stuff or things from the exact same product category to me.

Even right after I have bought a graphics tablet I'm infinitely more likely to buy a graphics tablet tomorrow, compared to my parents who have never bought one in their lives, and never will.

Or maybe the new TV turns out to be great, and I realize it would be nice to have a second one in my sleeping room, and why not buy a third one for the bathroom? ;-)

Re:Ask HN: Does targeted advertising work at all? by onion2k on Sunday February 06, 2022 @04:04AM (#30230674)
But before I managed to go to the postal office a few days later I was already searching for a replacement online.

While plausible, that sort of situation doesn't sound common enough that it should underpin the entire online advertising industry.

Even right after I have bought a graphics tablet I'm infinitely more likely to buy a graphics tablet tomorrow, compared to my parents who have never bought one in their lives, and never will.

But you're more likely still to buy another stylus, or art software, or an accessory, or physical art materials, etc. Why don't advertisers understand that?

Re:Ask HN: Does targeted advertising work at all? by watwut on Sunday February 06, 2022 @04:44AM (#30230933)
None of this sounds super frequent?
Re:Ask HN: Does targeted advertising work at all? by Tomte on Sunday February 06, 2022 @04:55AM (#30230979)
Doesn't matter in the slightest. You've identified yourself as someone who is definitely interested in that product. And not "just looking", but actually paying money. That's super valuable to businesses.

I still maintain that people who have bought a TV yesterday are more likely to buy a TV today than people who haven't bought a TV yesterday. Very few people buy a TV today. Or in the coming days.

It seems like a straightforward application of the base rate fallacy. Sure, most people who bought the TV yesterday keep their TV and don't need a second one.

But unless you have specific information about other people's interest in buying one, they may still be your best shot at selling another one.

Also, both you and sibling commenter argue as if there were a scarcity of ads. Amazon showing me a TV ad doesn't preclude Amazon from showing me a kitchen utensil ad on the next page.

Re:Ask HN: Does targeted advertising work at all? by watwut on Sunday February 06, 2022 @05:00AM (#30231010)
But what you described does not match my behavior at all. Not the one of my friends. It sounds like logical theory, sure.

And it is completely at odds with how I buy things. Or how people I know buy things.

> I still maintain that people who have bought a TV yesterday are more likely to buy a TV today than people who haven't bought a TV yesterday.

I never ever seen anyone buy second TV shortly after buying first one. Never.

> Amazon showing me a TV ad doesn't preclude Amazon from showing me a kitchen utensil ad on the next page.

I get monothematic ads. There is always that one thing that follows me everywhere. I don't get mix of ads. It is as if their system thought I buy only shoes. Or only TV.

Re:Ask HN: Does targeted advertising work at all? by Tomte on Sunday February 06, 2022 @05:08AM (#30231051)
I'm not married to my theory, "It sounds like logical theory, sure" is pretty much all I'd like to get out of my comment.

I simply cannot believe that this superficially irrational behaviour is as irrational as always asserted on HN.

The big companies are spending a gazillion dollars on ad tech, and while I believe that there is lots of stupid money floating around, I don't believe it's so obviously irrational. Just look at behavioral biology or psychology how much of seemingly irrational or downright stupid behaviour makes a lot of sense when you find the right vantage point.

Unfortunately, there will probably nobody come forward and tell us how it really is, so we can only speculate and build our own pet theories.

Re:Ask HN: Does targeted advertising work at all? by watwut on Sunday February 06, 2022 @07:17AM (#30231846)
> Just look at behavioral biology or psychology how much of seemingly irrational or downright stupid behaviour makes a lot of sense when you find the right vantage point.

Yes, but those tend to make you notice that "yep I have actually seen this". This one does not make me think that. Not when it comes to TVs, chairs, beds or other durable items. If we talked about beer or chocolate, sure. Someone who bought beer might want to buy exact same beer.

Someone who bought book might want to buy another book. But, not that exact same book again, that person might want to buy another similar book. With TV, no, nope.

Re:Ask HN: Does targeted advertising work at all? by XorNot on Sunday February 06, 2022 @04:51AM (#30230965)
As far as I know, the convention about this is that when you buy a thing, the most likely next purchase statistically is in fact the same thing because you are unhappy with the one you bought.
Re:Ask HN: Does targeted advertising work at all? by vba616 on Monday February 07, 2022 @01:22AM (#30241077)
Ever seen really weird combinations in "people who bought X also bought..."?
Re:Ask HN: Does targeted advertising work at all? by soared on Saturday February 05, 2022 @10:38PM (#30229146)
This doesn’t seem like a genuine discourse, but purchase suppression can occur in batches. So that purchase data may not get fed back into all the advertising systems for days/weeks if it’s using a poor set up.

For example, sometimes for suppression brands literally just export a csv of customers and upload it to google. If your marketing guy does it once a week..

I’d assume eBay’s doesn’t work like that, but it’s possible. Also possible they just don’t suppress recently bought items !

Re:Ask HN: Does targeted advertising work at all? by david_allison on Saturday February 05, 2022 @10:05PM (#30228940)
If you buy a product and you're dissatisfied, you're more likely than the average person to buy a similar product.
Re:Ask HN: Does targeted advertising work at all? by amelius on Sunday February 06, 2022 @08:49AM (#30232439)
Just give me a button "I already own this".
Re:Ask HN: Does targeted advertising work at all? by mikewarot on Saturday February 05, 2022 @10:04PM (#30228928)
It is entirely possible that large corporations measure the effectiveness of their advertising by comparing it to sales, and are confusing correlation with causation on a massive scale. They spend more on advertising, and point to sales in the same time frame, as a cause, even if reality disagrees.

There are zero incentives for anyone to figure this out and fix it within corporate structures. I'd be thankful it makes advertising easy to spot, and less effective in real life. ;-)

Imagine if you're in the middle management of Google and you realize that target ads don't work, and the results to this point are just luck. You'd want to do something like "Improve your advertising spend" by making the ads "more efficient", and selling targeted ads to people that you know have already purchased, but the advertiser doesn't.

Eventually you could advertise that your ads are measured to be more than 80% correlated with a rise in sales. (Leaving out the reversed causality).

If this IS the case... shhhhhh... don't tell anyone. It would crash Google's stock price. Nah, who am I kidding, the market stays irrational for decades. ;-)

Never attribute to malice, that which can be explained by incompetence.

Re:Ask HN: Does targeted advertising work at all? by isomel on Sunday February 06, 2022 @03:28AM (#30230510)
Reminds me of this urban legend:

The VP of marketing of ebay realized that the keyword for which they spent the most money was "eBay". He thought this was nonsense and that people who looked for eBay should know how to get to their website, so he decided to save some marketing money and stopped putting money on they keyword. Result: no changes in the amount of visit to the website. However, the click-through rate, which is the metric by which marketing department was measured, decreased significantly. So the VP was fired and they even increased the money spent on the keyword.

Re:Ask HN: Does targeted advertising work at all? by names_are_hard on Sunday February 06, 2022 @04:03AM (#30230673)
And never attribute to incompetence that which can be explained by hundreds of individually intelligent people optimizing for their own short term benefit (ie career growth).

We see this in the software industry all the time. Large organizations act inefficiently or against their own interests because large organizations don't actually have consciousness, instead their decisions emerge from the sum of a lot of little decisions and actions, each of which might be individually reasonable.

As an aside, I believe that's how large organizations can come to be evil even if the vast majority of members are not evil.

Re:Ask HN: Does targeted advertising work at all? by oblaff on Saturday February 05, 2022 @10:25PM (#30229072)
Agreed. Online advertising measurement remains opaque and there is no incentive to fix it.

The book Subprime Attention Crisis by Tim Hwang does a good job covering this! (It is a solid bear case for fb,g,etc as well :p)

Re:Ask HN: Does targeted advertising work at all? by soared on Saturday February 05, 2022 @10:29PM (#30229096)
You clearly have no idea what you are talking about. Entire business are built on testing the effectiveness of online advertising, and providing that as a consulting device to brands. Do you think Nike would be happy if their vendor just said, “yeah everything drives positive lift”.

Nobody is confusing correlation and causation. These are rigorous studies completed by literal data scientists and statisticians. They are employed by neutral third parties who make money regardless of the outcome of the study, and showing positive outcomes where they do not occur would be hugely detrimental to their business.

And to your point, realizing advertising does not work happens all the fucking time. I see it literally all the time. It’s why you run studies. Then you take your budget, move it somewhere else, and run a test to see if it’s effective. Every major brand does it this way.

Re:Ask HN: Does targeted advertising work at all? by kcplate on Saturday February 05, 2022 @11:04PM (#30229301)
> Every major brand does it this way

This is not completely accurate in my experience. Some brands do, particularly emerging brands.

However, I can assure you there are a few major established brands that I could drop on here (but cannot due to NDAs) that everybody on HN regardless of their location worldwide would recognize. If I was to tell you the inner workings their marketing operations you would be surprised at the lack of measurement and analysis they actually perform on campaigns. The words “indiscriminate carpet bombing and assume the enemies are dead” are probably the best analogy I can think of to describe their efforts.

Re:Ask HN: Does targeted advertising work at all? by soared on Saturday February 05, 2022 @11:44PM (#30229524)
I suppose it’s probably worth rephrasing as every major brand I’ve worked with, in that case :). Unfortunate to hear that but I guess not surprising
Re:Ask HN: Does targeted advertising work at all? by kcplate on Sunday February 06, 2022 @11:24AM (#30233942)
Honestly I think after you reach a certain point of brand awareness your marketing becomes just about maintaining name saturation and letting brand loyalty and affinity do it’s thing. Watching it in action is strange to people like me that put a great deal of value into measuring campaign value.

As much as I am critical of the approach, I can’t really says it’s a bad strategy, as these are brands that had worldwide reputations long before I became involved and most of my involvement was pretty narrow to a specific product or product vertical.

Re:Ask HN: Does targeted advertising work at all? by notfromhere on Sunday February 06, 2022 @12:32PM (#30234704)
It's true. At some point you do hit the maximum brand awareness, and after that point, you're just paying to stop your competitors from doing the same.
Re:Ask HN: Does targeted advertising work at all? by youngtaff on Sunday February 06, 2022 @04:10AM (#30230716)
And then there's the example of P&G, or Unilever or some other FCMG company that stopped advertising and saw no change in their business

Bob Hoffman's take on advertising e.g. Advertising for Skeptics, is well worth reading - he's an ex-adman who thinks the ad industry and particularly the personalised ad industry is full of shit

When you look at the online ad industry it's reasonably clear that the people who are making the money are the ad tech companies and not the advertisers

Re:Ask HN: Does targeted advertising work at all? by xapata on Sunday February 06, 2022 @04:36AM (#30230883)
Coca-Cola's advertising is so good, the sugar water literally tastes better if you know it's Coke, compared with a blind taste test.
Re:Ask HN: Does targeted advertising work at all? by mcv on Sunday February 06, 2022 @06:05AM (#30231385)
So their advertising influences taste, but does it actually influence sales?
Re:Ask HN: Does targeted advertising work at all? by notfromhere on Sunday February 06, 2022 @12:34PM (#30234738)
The basis for every DTC brand is paid advertising. Advertising definitely works, especially in B2B contexts when you can directly track activity to a sale. But there's definitely marginal returns on it once you saturate your market.
Re:Ask HN: Does targeted advertising work at all? by it_does_follow on Sunday February 06, 2022 @02:05AM (#30230155)
> Do you think Nike would be happy if their vendor just said, “yeah everything drives positive lift”.

It's fairly known in the industry (worked in a range of different ad-tech/marketing companies for around a decade), that more or less this is what makes Nike happy.

> They are employed by neutral third parties who make money regardless of the outcome of the study.

This is a bit naive. Same is true for home appraisers, funny how it always works out that the house appraised for just over what you offered (even in insane markets).

This issue is you might get paid this time for being honest, but you won't get paid again.

> completed by literal data scientists and statisticians.

I'm both of these. Saying that "adtech is bullshit" is absolutely too reductionist but you are wildly too naive about the reality of the industry.

Take A/B testing as an example. I've helped people run A/B tests for many years. I establish rigorous testing setups, make sure people understand confidence in the results, distribution of possible outcomes, etc. I'm honest in my work and so are the people running the tests.

But the truth is that A/B test on customer populations are not controlled experiments. One thing that literally no one in the industry does is go back and review the results of the past years A/B tests. The reason why? People don't really want to know. However, it's obvious these results can't be quite right because teams will run 10 A/B tests in a year, each claiming a 5% improvement in conversion, but clearly you don't see this cumulative impact of a >60% increase in conversion over time.

No one want to know this though, because knowing this helps nobody. Nobody is outright lying, but nobody wants to ask. The one time I worked outside of adtech but saw a problem where model results were almost entirely random noise I got in huge trouble for pointing this out.

Same is true across the board in the adtech world.

Someone else recommended "Subprime Attention Crisis by Tim Hwang" and I very strongly recommend that you read this. It's very well researched and was so inline with my experience that I found it so obvious as to almost be dull.

Re:Ask HN: Does targeted advertising work at all? by lvs on Sunday February 06, 2022 @03:56AM (#30230624)
You seem really defensive about all this. The question at the top of the thread was a little too binary. But the notion that advertising is overvalued would not surprise me at all, nor would it surprise me that many in here depend for their livelihoods on it continuing to be overvalued.
Re:Ask HN: Does targeted advertising work at all? by anothernewdude on Sunday February 06, 2022 @12:20AM (#30229717)
> Do you think Nike would be happy if their vendor just said, “yeah everything drives positive lift”.

No, which is why advertisers are theatre.

Many large businesses have entirely halted online advertising and found little effect, but much saved money.

Re:Ask HN: Does targeted advertising work at all? by watwut on Sunday February 06, 2022 @04:49AM (#30230956)
Honestly, after lifetime of working in companies on capitalist market, the theory that they/we make decisions based on rigorous studies strikes me as unplausible. So does the idea of effective neutral third party. I have seen how consultants work too.
Re:Ask HN: Does targeted advertising work at all? by Joeri on Sunday February 06, 2022 @04:52AM (#30230967)
You are going to have to provide sources for these claims. Freakonomics podcast did an episode on the topic of online advertising and argued largely the opposite of what you’re saying, that there is massive overspending on online advertising, and increases in sales often get misattributed to ad campaigns when they have other causes.

https://freakonomics.com/podcast/does-advertising-actually-w...

Re:Ask HN: Does targeted advertising work at all? by distribot on Sunday February 06, 2022 @05:00AM (#30231006)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Targeted_advertising#:~:text=I...

Markets are imperfect and irrational, but you really don't think that there is a trillion dollar misunderstanding about the efficacy of the practice? Idk jack about advertising but it seems unlikely to me.

Re:Ask HN: Does targeted advertising work at all? by newaccount74 on Sunday February 06, 2022 @08:10AM (#30232191)
Selling homeopathic medicine is also a huge market, so big that every single pharmacy in Austria has an huge range of homeopathic medicine on display.

Just the fact that people buy ad campaigns doesn't mean that they have any effect at all.

Re:Ask HN: Does targeted advertising work at all? by distribot on Sunday February 06, 2022 @12:29PM (#30234664)
That's fair but homepathic medicine is dwarfed by regular medicine in the industrialized world. There's no homepathic Pfizer or Bayer. I think if there was another practice that was way better than targeted advertising, targeted advertising might exist as a distant woo-woo second.
Re:Ask HN: Does targeted advertising work at all? by amelius on Sunday February 06, 2022 @08:51AM (#30232454)
> Advertisers suppress known buyers but they don’t perfectly match you to all of your devices.

And in case of doubt ... they found that it is more advantageous to them to just keep bothering you.