News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Stablecoins: Growth potential and impact on banking by stjohnswarts on Tuesday February 01, 2022 @06:17PM (#30171075)
Honest question: how many hackernews people are cool with all their purchases being on a blockchain forever that is accessible ad infinitum to whichever party has access to it (and potentially all of the public) ?
Re:Stablecoins: Growth potential and impact on banking by tcgv on Tuesday February 01, 2022 @06:37PM (#30171345)
Good question. There are tools and procedures that can be used to maintain anonymity within the blockchain. For instance, tornado cash is a popular dapp used to break the on-chain link between source and destination addresses of a transaction, so you could fund a spending address and make payments with it. The companies receiving money (stablecoins) would maintain off-chain data of your purchase (e.g. product, quantity, your contact info and delivery address) not available publicly.
Re:Stablecoins: Growth potential and impact on banking by woodruffw on Tuesday February 01, 2022 @08:34PM (#30172355)
The UX of paying a third-party broker to opt into a semblance of privacy isn't particularly great.

It's amusing (to me) how the cryptocurrency community has managed to convince its members to accept ridiculous amounts of commoditization and middlemen in exchange for anonymity properties that are strictly worse than cash, and arguably worse than payment cards.

Re:Stablecoins: Growth potential and impact on banking by tcgv on Tuesday February 01, 2022 @09:41PM (#30172948)
What do you mean by third party broker?

Tornado Cash is a decentralized protocol based on zero knowledge proofs. Its smart contracts are immutable, have no admins.

Besides that, let us not forget that the Mastercard/Visa middlemen charge us large fees for using their services and knows everthing about our purchase habits.

(unless you're living a cash based life, but that would make you an exception)

Re:Stablecoins: Growth potential and impact on banking by woodruffw on Tuesday February 01, 2022 @10:45PM (#30173425)
I don't know about Tornado Cash specifically, but every cryptocurrency tumbler that I'm familiar with takes a cut of the pork, on top of any transaction fees. This community discussion[1] makes it sound expensive.

> Besides that, let us not forget that the Mastercard/Visa middlemen charge us large fees for using their services and knows everthing about our purchase habits.

This is a common refrain, but it isn't quite accurate: the payment card networks charge merchants to use their services.

And sure, they know what you buy. But my Aunt Susie doesn't, nor does the next person who I pay using my payment card. Privacy as a concept is described by the security or threat model one is trying to conform to; cash and payment cards both protect me from unrelated prying eyes. Cryptocurrencies can also protect me from prying eyes, but they charge me for the privilege. By default, both my Aunt Susie and my neighborhood restaurant can see that I've been unfaithful and tried a new place for dinner.

[1]: https://torn.community/t/fee-how-much-does-it-cost-to-use/68

Re:Stablecoins: Growth potential and impact on banking by seibelj on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @12:36AM (#30174138)
Cash is dying and all credit card payments, bank transfers, Venmo / PayPal, literally everything is sucked up by data miners and is easily available to the government. You are arguing against a new system by comparing it to an irretrievably broken privacy financial system.

Privacy is difficult on the blockchain but not impossible. The tools continue to get better. I anticipate the privacy tools in the blockchain world will improve faster than any semblance or hope of privacy in the traditional financial world.

Re:Stablecoins: Growth potential and impact on banking by woodruffw on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @12:57AM (#30174279)
Again: the privacy/threat model is what matters.

I do not operate under the delusion that I will stop my bank or payment card provider from seeing my transactions, or that my government can't obtain a lawful order to inspect the details of my finances. My interest is in protecting my privacy from people who are not in those domains: my local bodega owner, a bored Internet denizen who decides that They Just Don't Like Me, a snooping relative. I do not want to live in a world where those people, by default, get to see and evaluate my financial behavior. That, so far, is the only world that immutable public ledgers currently offer me.

Thus far, privacy in the blockchain space seems to have become more expensive, not "better" in either the statistical or colloquial sense of the word. I'll believe it when I see it. In the mean time, the dollars I use to buy my morning coffee are about as anonymous as they were yesterday, last week, and last year.

Re:Stablecoins: Growth potential and impact on banking by TimJRobinson on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @02:26AM (#30174776)
There are technologies like Tornado cash and Railgun that can hide transactions on Ethereum. The current issue is they're too expensive to use on mainnet.

Once we have layer 2 payments using zk-rollups, transaction costs will fall to a few cents and many apps could easily integrate these technologies to tumble your wallet (taking all funds and send them through this tech into a new wallet) any time you want for a dollar or two. Or they could automatically do this after every transaction.

Then everyone will have access to easy completely anonymous payments in any currency they like.

We're just in the early days of this tech, like the internet when we used http everywhere and no one knew what a VPN was.

Re:Stablecoins: Growth potential and impact on banking by T0Bi on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @06:12AM (#30176092)
Fortunately tornado cash is already on L2, I think even on every single bigger L2.

Not with the same volume as on mainnet, but still gradually increasing.

Re:Stablecoins: Growth potential and impact on banking by gogopuppygogo on Tuesday February 01, 2022 @09:28PM (#30172814)
I am not. When I speak with those in defi they hardly even understand the most basic aspects of this technology. My personal hope is that quantum computing develops fast enough to decimate the decentralized financial industry powered by blockchain.
Re:Stablecoins: Growth potential and impact on banking by Galanwe on Tuesday February 01, 2022 @11:40PM (#30173787)
I don't think any forward looking state of quantum computing threatens SHA2.
Re:Stablecoins: Growth potential and impact on banking by godot on Tuesday February 01, 2022 @07:05PM (#30171648)
This question presumes the envisioned future is where each person has their own non-custodial wallet that holds stablecoins that they use in transactions, no?

If the current trajectory is any indication, it's more likely that everyday users would mostly hold custodial accounts at organizations (e.g. Coinbase, like banks) and use stablecoins that way, which control aggregate wallets, and trackability stays within the org level (also like banks). Probably not as easy for the public to access (possible in data hacks) but just as easy for government access.

Re:Stablecoins: Growth potential and impact on banking by elevaet on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @03:09AM (#30175014)
Amusing how it's gone from "be your own bank" back around to centralization, but this time with a colossal energy footprint behind it. Same shit, bigger pile I guess.
Re:Stablecoins: Growth potential and impact on banking by tenuousemphasis on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @03:36AM (#30175195)
You can always build centralized systems on top of decentralized ones in order to mitigate the scaling costs of decentralization. It's essentially impossible to build a decentralized system on top of a centralized one in order to mitigate the downsides of centralization.
Re:Stablecoins: Growth potential and impact on banking by spupe on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @05:00AM (#30175663)
I don't think that's the case. If Paypal wanted, and it was legally allowed, they could anonymize my data to an extent where not even their own team could know who I am. We don't do it because it would be open to fraud and scams, not because it is impossible.
Re:Stablecoins: Growth potential and impact on banking by tenuousemphasis on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @08:54AM (#30177495)
You didn't actually address anything I said. I'm not talking about privacy at all.
Re:Stablecoins: Growth potential and impact on banking by golergka on Tuesday February 01, 2022 @07:39PM (#30171950)
For most purposes, it doesn't matter. For others, there's Monero.
Re:Stablecoins: Growth potential and impact on banking by tenuousemphasis on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @03:34AM (#30175184)
Even Bitcoin has the Lightning network that uses some clever smart contacts to avoid having to record every purchase on the blockchain. it's a layer built on top of Bitcoin that only requires an on-chain transaction to open or close a payment channel. Once the channel is open you can make a lot of extremely private payments through it.
Re:Stablecoins: Growth potential and impact on banking by steelstraw on Tuesday February 01, 2022 @07:09PM (#30171685)
There are ways to maintain privacy with things like Block Wallet: https://blockwallet.io/
Re:Stablecoins: Growth potential and impact on banking by wmf on Tuesday February 01, 2022 @06:59PM (#30171587)
Crypto isn't for purchases, but if you decide to do that you should use an anonymous cryptocurrency.
Re:Stablecoins: Growth potential and impact on banking by pirate787 on Tuesday February 01, 2022 @07:44PM (#30171992)
Actually Bitcoin's initial promise was as a form of cash for purchases, and it has failed spectacularly to the point where even the strongest proponents rarely make that claim.
Re:Stablecoins: Growth potential and impact on banking by dougk16 on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @02:47AM (#30174878)
Is "purchase" some technical definition you're using? I've purchased many goods and services with cryptocurrency these past few years. Used physical silver a lot as well. Even paid rent. Also partially paid a contracting bill with one ounce of gold. It takes a bit more legwork and explanation but monetary systems don't change by magic. It takes an impassioned minority individually putting the work in.
Re:Stablecoins: Growth potential and impact on banking by wmf on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @12:57PM (#30181256)
You can do it but it's not a good idea. Transactions are slow, they're public on the blockchain forever, fees are variable, there's no way to correct erroneous transactions or dispute fraud, and of course you're missing out on future appreciation.

It's worth going through eary adopter hassles if the eventual result is better, but crypto won't ever be better.

Re:Stablecoins: Growth potential and impact on banking by dougk16 on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @11:37PM (#30188740)
I generally only use private cryptocurrencies with low fees and fast transaction times, like Monero and PirateChain. If I have to use Bitcoin or any other surveillance coin, I am well-versed in "cleaning" my coins, but that's not desirable for a number of reasons. Perhaps you're focusing on co-opted surveillance coins, but privacy coins are amazing.
Re:Stablecoins: Growth potential and impact on banking by losteric on Tuesday February 01, 2022 @08:14PM (#30172217)
cryptocurrency is not intended for making purchases?
Re:Stablecoins: Growth potential and impact on banking by wmf on Tuesday February 01, 2022 @08:54PM (#30172518)
Cryptocurrency is not currency (unit of account); we just call it that for historical reasons. It's not usable for purchases and the intent is irrelevant.
Re:Stablecoins: Growth potential and impact on banking by Bellyache5 on Tuesday February 01, 2022 @10:34PM (#30173357)
So what is it then?
Re:Stablecoins: Growth potential and impact on banking by yazaddaruvala on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @12:00AM (#30173910)
Disclaimer: This is just my interpretation of “unit of account”. This is not me agreeing with it or advocating for it.

When people say “unit of account” basically what they are saying is:

Cryptocurrency is an Open Source rewrite of the banking systems that currently run on Cobal. “Banks, please start using them as your database and reconciliation layer instead of your legacy software.”

Meanwhile, users continue to use credit / debit cards as they do now, and they continue to see some number on their bank accounts going up and down regardless of where the “money” actually is. Which is the same as today. That’s why we see “Pending” across so many of our transactions.

Re:Stablecoins: Growth potential and impact on banking by rmbyrro on Tuesday February 01, 2022 @07:13PM (#30171719)
I'm in