News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by theandrewbailey on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @01:31PM (#30089654)
> I'd say the answer to that should be determined by the hospital capacity. If a region has sufficient hospital capacity that it would not be overwhelmed by the increase in COVID cases among the unvaccinated go ahead and lift most restrictions.

Having anyone's freedoms dependent on available hospital capacity is a terrible way to run a society. Note that these freedoms were debated and won in an era where medicine was terrible.

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by Nbox9 on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @01:46PM (#30089890)
I’d like to know that if I have a heart attack or get hit by a bus then I’ll have access to top quality healthcare —- not burnt out understaffed hospitals.

Sharing limited resources is a major role of the government, and managing hospital capacity seems to fall under “promote general welfare” to me.

My $0.02

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by enchiridion on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @01:54PM (#30090020)
It definitely is, but they’re addressing it from the wrong end.

If the pandemic could be fixed by the government managing individual behavior we’d be done with it by now.

Instead the government should be focused on expanding highly covid specific care capacity. That is by far a better way to spend the covid relief money than distributing it to sustain a nebulous lockdown.

As far as I understand from talking with doctors, at no time within the last year have hospitals been at maximum emergency covid capacity, as in hospital beds in the hall ways, cafeteria, etc. This tells me that we are close to the amount of beds we need, and it would be feasible to build out additional capacity quickly, relieve the strain, and get back to normal.

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by joshuamorton on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @02:14PM (#30090306)
> Instead the government should be focused on expanding highly covid specific care capacity. That is by far a better way to spend the covid relief money than distributing it to sustain a nebulous lockdown.

This is not something the government can do. It's not something anyone can do. What you're asking for (though you may not know it) is for their to suddenly be more nurses and medical practitioners. That's not a thing that can just suddenly happen, or even happen with 2-3 years of prep. You need a decade to actually functionally increase the supply of nurses and specialists.

Now there are lots of short term fixes the government has done, such as activating the national guard in locations (to reduce non-medical load on nurses) and hospitals can pause elective services to free up space and time, but that has huge downsides since it means people get life saving nonemergency surgeries like cancer removal.

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by enchiridion on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @04:14PM (#30091967)
From what I’ve seen the current shortages are primarily due to lack of sufficient pay and firing nurses who don’t want to get vaccinated. Additionally it seems like current nurses are over qualified for covid care.

How long would it take to train someone from a nursing adjacent field to treat 95% of what they are likely to see when treating a covid patient? Is anyone even asking that question? If not, why not?

It seems like we’re willing to take drastic action when it comes to mandate public behavior, but not when it comes to reforming bureaucracies, processes, and regulations.

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by dpark on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @04:55PM (#30092523)
> firing nurses who don’t want to get vaccinated.

I would love to see stats on that. From what I can tell, the actual percentage of medical practitioners quitting due to vaccine mandates is very small. My family work in the medical field in a red state and the set of people actually quitting over the vaccine requirement (as opposed to making a lot of noise and then deciding unemployment is unattractive) is tiny, but this may not be representative.

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by coryfklein on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @03:46PM (#30091537)
> You need a decade to actually functionally increase the supply of nurses and specialists.

Similar things were said for the vaccine.

There is so much gatekeeping in the medical community that is not totally necessary. A doctor or nurse that immigrates to the US from a different country which has better health care than we do cannot practice were without jumping through tons of hoops. That is a pretty straightforward way the government – in a state of national emergency mind you! – could instantly and functionally increase the supply of nurses and specialists.

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by Nbox9 on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @04:05PM (#30091830)
Isn’t the shortage of healthcare workers world wide? How does reducing the friction of moving into the US do anything but shift the problem around?
Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by coryfklein on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @04:20PM (#30092059)
Consider the already immigrated medical professionals living in the United States right now that are unable to practice because of the above described licensing issues.

To give a couple examples. If a nurse moves to the US and learns he can't practice without going back to medical school, he may opt instead to work a different job and defer his medical career. If a doctor moves to the US and is in the same position, she may choose to remain a stay-at-home mom and let her husband be the primary breadwinner.

There's also the arbitrage aspect here: globally we may have a healthcare worker shortage, but it may be more severe in one place than another. Reducing the friction involved in moving the workforce could allow workers that are in relative over-supply to move to an area with relative under-supply, improving the overall efficiency of the system.

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by joshuamorton on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @04:55PM (#30092525)
> Consider the already immigrated medical professionals living in the United States right now that are unable to practice because of the above described licensing issues.

New York and New Jersey did this. In early 2020 (so two years ago). Despite this, they ran into extreme shortages. So now that we've done that, what next?

> If a doctor moves to the US and is in the same position, she may choose to remain a stay-at-home mom and let her husband be the primary breadwinner.

And is she just going to suddenly start working if the licensure requirement goes away? Some might, but a lot won't because they are already parenting. This is what I mean by these policies require years to have an impact.

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by mrcrumb1 on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @04:04PM (#30091815)
Are you suggesting that people rely on unprecedented medical advancements as a policy solution?
Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by coryfklein on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @04:23PM (#30092097)
:lol_sob: Why can't we have nice things mrcrumb1?? Hahaha.

But yes. Yes, I'm advocating that people be just a little bit more open minded and flexible about this issue and, ideally, the so many others like it. Sometimes it's quite depressing to consider the giant gap between how society functions today and how it could function if it operated by different rules.

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by spookthesunset on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @03:30PM (#30091322)
Okay, then instead of punishing the general public, how about they go build more capacity? They've had 2 years at this point and they are still freaking out about "overflowing hospitals". It's not fair, ethical or moral to push mandates on citizens at this point.
Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by azakai on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @03:41PM (#30091467)
It takes a long time to train doctors and nurses and other relevant staff. Worse, the hard working conditions those people have been enduring since 2020 has led to a lot of burnout and attrition.
Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by spookthesunset on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @05:06PM (#30092698)
That sounds like excuses. This thing is an emergency, right? Well, fix it!

Punishing the public with these awful mandates because “it’s too hard” is a huge failure of our government.

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by mlyle on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @01:55PM (#30090042)
> Sharing limited resources is a major role of the government, and managing hospital capacity seems to fall under “promote general welfare” to me.

Sure. It's a pretty delicate balance between individual liberties and preventing bad collective outcomes, though.

If you lock down 340 million people for a week-- maybe the net effect is stealing 3.5 days of life's "enjoyment" or "quality" from each. That's 3.3 million years of quality life taken.

You need to save 20 years of quality life for 165,000 people to break even. In the first wave we probably exceeded that benefit, but it's highly doubtful any subsequent time passes that bar.

And, IMO, if there's ever anything close to a "tie", you need to favor individual liberty.

Maybe making people mask "costs" 0.2 days per week-- much smaller cost, but also a smaller effect. I think it's still justified, but only barely... It won't be soon.

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by CWuestefeld on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @03:29PM (#30091306)
Having anyone's freedoms dependent on available hospital capacity is a terrible way to run a society.

You should note that government regulations are designed to keep hospitals running nearer capacity. See "certificates of need", which are (in most places) required to get authorization to build a new hospital. You've got to prove to the gov't that a new hospital really is necessary. And thanks to regulatory capture, the tendency is for existing providers to try to sink such applications.

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by tzs on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @02:12PM (#30090271)
> Note that these freedoms were debated and won in an era where medicine was terrible.

That was also an era when the US was subject to numerous epidemics and pandemics of diseases such as cholera, typhus, yellow fever, bubonic plague, smallpox, and influenza, and it was debated and found that placing restrictions to try to limit the harm from those epidemics was a legitimate exercise of the state's police power and not an infringement of civil rights.

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by e40 on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @01:53PM (#30090013)
I hate this casting of the issue as "freedom". It's absurd.

My "freedom" to live because I have a medical issue but cannot get treatment will be severely impacted if hospitals are overrun with patients and worn out workers.

See, we can both play the "freedom" game.

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by theandrewbailey on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @02:35PM (#30090544)
> See, we can both play the "freedom" game.

The doctors and nurses you're asking treatment from are people who deserve freedom and work-life balance, too. Many have been fed up and are quitting. Would you support the government forcing them to continue working? Would you force young people to be doctors and nurses?

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by laurent92 on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @02:03PM (#30090164)
We don’t owe you the right to live with a deadly disease. You cannot mandate others to perform actions just so you can live, if you wouldn’t live naturally.
Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by e40 on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @02:07PM (#30090214)
We do it all the time. You are mandated to get a license to drive a car so that you don't have a higher chance of killing people.
Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by notch656a on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @02:13PM (#30090288)
Not on private property you don't need a license. Similarly, a business on private property should be able to dictate a mask or vaccination isn't required. You shouldn't have a right to dictate what kind of consensual conduct happens on private property.

In Texas, I can get hammered, drive a car drunk without a license behind a fence 10 feet next to the highway (property-side). And there's not a damn thing you can legally do about it, despite any fears I may plow through that fence. The suggested (stricken) OSHA mandates were basically forcing non-consensual penetration, or lose your job.

---------

>That's not totally true. This Texas-based DWI defense attorney says:

You conveniently skipped the top of the page where it explicitly says DWI in Texas must occur in public (a fenced in private property is almost never considered public). Sure a cop can probably find a reason to arrest you no matter what you're doing, if they want to.

>Obviously you should be able to be unvaccinated only on private property then...

Most businesses are on private property. Given that the fourth amendment protects us from handing over documents except on subpeona/court order or probable cause of crime (a few states do compel revealing your identity, although you don't have to reveal your age if the crime is age-related such as alcohol violation), and you can't tell by looking at someone if they're vaccinated, it would essentially be meaningless to make it a crime to be unvaccinated while walking to work for instance. Controlling vaccination is far easier on private property, where you have no freedom to travel and can thus be stopped and checked before entering.

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by Domenic_S on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @03:01PM (#30090885)
That's not totally true. This Texas-based DWI defense attorney says:

> The police can arrest you if they have probable cause to do so for driving under the influence. Even if you are operating your motor vehicle on what you believe is your own property, the police still may have probable cause to believe your conduct is a threat to yourself or others. Therefore, you should not assume that you are completely safe from arrest or conviction if you are driving drunk on your own property. - http://jackpettit.com/blog/dwis-and-drunk-driving-on-private...

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by kube-system on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @04:14PM (#30091968)
Driving is a bad example. Almost any other public safety regulation is a better example; most of them apply to private property. Almost never do private companies get to "choose" to follow safety regulations. McDonalds must follow food safety regulations, construction companies must follow building codes, industrial companies must follow occupational health and safety standards, aircraft operators must follow FAA regulations, etc.
Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by JetAlone on Tuesday February 08, 2022 @03:07AM (#30255995)
Hahaha, in a worldview that has little much more to aspire to than the acquisition of wealth and material things, I guess it's not a shock that people start looking at each other in a legalistic mentality as small, poor, not so well protected corporate entities such that we are fashioned in the image of a company. All of the microbes that live in our guts are our employees, our mind is the CEO sitting in the brain as its office, the other organs hosting other managers.
Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by notch656a on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @05:22PM (#30092910)
Being forced to wear a mask or vaccinate could be a public health risk:

  - Infants/Toddlers (mask): linguistic development health risk
  - Adults (vaccine): risk of anaphylaxis, TTS, GBS, Myocarditis, Pericarditis
Individuals should weigh these risks and determine whether it makes sense in their particular scenario. None of McDonalds food safety regulations I'm aware of involve penetrating a human with a needle.

Also the driving thing was somebody else, I just responded to it. If you didn't like it, it would have made more sense to have told them it was a bad example instead of me. It wasn't my example.

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by otterley on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @06:11PM (#30093463)
There's often more than one statute that prohibits a certain proscribed activity. You might not be liable under the Texas Vehicle Code for DWI for drinking and driving on a non-public highway; but depending on the circumstances, you could be liable for under the Penal Code for reckless endangerment (section 22.05(a)).
Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by notch656a on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @07:06PM (#30094054)
Can you cite a case where someone has been convicted under 22.05(a) for driving drunk on private property without actually having hit anyone? You can charge whatever you like, a prosecutor/grand jury can "indict a ham sandwich." Texas still has a sodomy law on the books too (although enforcing it has been stricken by supreme court).
Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by otterley on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @09:49PM (#30095588)
Reckless endangerment does not require you actually hit anyone. Where did you get that from?

Texas Penal Code 6.03(c): "A person acts recklessly, or is reckless, with respect to circumstances surrounding his conduct or the result of his conduct when he is aware of but consciously disregards a substantial and unjustifiable risk that the circumstances exist or the result will occur. The risk must be of such a nature and degree that its disregard constitutes a gross deviation from the standard of care that an ordinary person would exercise under all the circumstances as viewed from the actor's standpoint."

And what does the now-void sodomy law have to do with anything?

You're also mixing up indictment with conviction.

At any rate, you don't have to have a fact pattern that precisely matches a previously-recorded case to think "gee, maybe this is a bad idea and puts me at risk of violating some law." Most cases involve fact patterns that are at least somewhat different from previous case law. A prosecutor's job is to make their case based on the facts, the law, and the ability to draw parallels from other cases.

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by notch656a on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @10:28PM (#30095838)
I'm gonna ask the question again, since you completely dodged it: Can you cite a case where someone has been convicted under 22.05(a) for driving drunk on private property without actually having hit anyone?

I know what the difference is between indictment and conviction, stop trying to act like this holier than thou. The 'fact pattern' of drunk driving on private property isn't a rare pattern, it shouldn't be difficult to dig up a conviction under that statute if it has been succesful.

>Reckless endangerment does not require you actually hit anyone. Where did you get that from?

No shit. I got it from my example, where the driver didn't hit anyone. That's what we were both talking about, a drunk driver on their own private property behind a fence. When did I ever say they hit someone? In my example they didn't, which is why I asked for a case where they didn't.

The sodomy law is an example of how overzealous prosecutors can prosecute "a ham sandwich" on whatever they want but it means jack in terms of whether they can actually convict someone, even if the exact letter of the law suggests they can.

>A prosecutor's job is to make their case based on the facts, the law, and the ability to draw parallels from other cases.

Sadly many prosecutors care more about convictions (or just dragging someone through the system, conviction or not) than any of those. And some care more about convictions than even justice, to the point they will imprison people for victimless crimes. A bad prosecutor is one of the most dangerous and despised members of society.

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by otterley on Thursday January 27, 2022 @12:58AM (#30096734)
The fact is that nobody knows right now with certainty whether driving drunk on private property would result in a reckless endangerment conviction. I cited an alternate legal theory that a prosecutor could use. If there’s no case law that is directly on point, we have to go with what the statute says and other case law about the statute in other cases, and make our best guess based on what a prosecutor might argue and how a judge might find. That’s what lawyers do. I’m not being “holier than thou;” I’m using my formal legal training to contribute to the conversation and dispel myths about the law. I don’t want anyone taking unnecessary risks, influenced by false suggestions or claims made here, and ending up in potentially serious trouble as a result. Many criminal cases involve multiple counts of violations of different criminal laws for the same conduct in order to improve the chances of a conviction on at least one of them. That’s just par for the course, and is the basis for the phrase “throw the book at them.”

As for the sodomy law, before it was ruled unconstitutional (and therefore void), it was enforceable and people were convicted of it. See, e.g., https://www.glapn.org/sodomylaws/sensibilities/texas.htm

The fact that it has been voided since is something every prosecutor knows, and so they won’t even try to indict anyone for it. Getting the law off the books is a formality at this point.

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by notch656a on Thursday January 27, 2022 @01:29AM (#30096936)
>As for the sodomy law, you are still wrong. Before it was ruled unconstitutional (and therefore void), it was enforceable and people were convicted of it.

Except I never said that no one had ever been convicted. I'm saying even though the law still is on paper, it doesn't mean someone can be successfully convicted of performing a 'fact pattern' that looks like it might violate the letter of the law. For someone formally trained in law you have a shockingly poor attention to detail or even accurately recalling facts.

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by otterley on Thursday January 27, 2022 @01:31AM (#30096953)
You need to stop making personal attacks or you risk being removed from HN.
Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by notch656a on Thursday January 27, 2022 @01:46AM (#30097048)
If saying you haven't recalled facts correctly or paid attention to detail is a 'personal attack', then you calling me 'wrong' and insinuating I was dumb enough to mix up indictment and conviction (despite that I hadn't) is also a personal attack. Stop playing the victim, it's a sad pathetic look.

> or you risk being removed from HN.

Is this some kind of threat? You have a power play fetish too eh? What would I _ever_ do without non-practicing lawyers arguing with me about the risk of me going to jail for some Texas penal code offense they can't even find a conviction for under one of the most common socially frowned upon 'fact patterns' known to man (Texan drunk at the wheel on his fenced-in property). But hey man, however you keep your razor sharp I guess.

--------------------

Other snips from Otterley's attacks on my character:

'Worse, you are a hypocrite: You gladly take full advantage of the protections the law affords you, while expressing disdain for the protections and fairness-guiding that the law affords others.'

'I think we've reached the end of this conversation with a clear understanding of the type of person you are. This is a garden-variety description of egotistical selfishness'

'Good for you. I bet you have a Black friend, too.'

Mr. Otterley: YOU are the hypocrite.

---------------------

Oh and another one for my friend Otterley from our old conversation, in case we don't meet each other under this username again:

'But I really thank you for the laughs. Maybe the next time I spark up a blunt, I'll stop and think to myself "lawless egotistical selfishness" and think back about dear Otterley'

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by otterley on Thursday January 27, 2022 @02:27AM (#30097356)
I admit I did do that in a prior conversation. I apologize. I should not have done that. I disagree with you on many things, but it should not stoop to a personal level.
Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by notch656a on Thursday January 27, 2022 @02:50AM (#30097533)
Thank you. I also apologize for the times I've overstepped the bounds of politeness, inclusive of my statement regarding 'someone formally trained in law.' I hope from here on out we can focus more attention on making any interactions with each other more focused on learning from each others' different perspectives in a positive and constructive way. I will try channel these experiences into become a better communicator.
Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by smileysteve on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @04:48PM (#30092411)
You give Texas as an example; but important for your example, its government disincentivized and removed the rights from companies, private property, and small local governments to require masks, vaccines, or reduction in capacities.
Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by notch656a on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @05:05PM (#30092683)
Can you point to me where it was made illegal to require a mask on private property in Texas (other than perhaps for certain disabled persons per ADA)?

My understanding is masks mandates were only banned in places like public schools, where the owner is the public thus the individual public student has the decision to wear a mask or not. I would certainly disagree with this sort of control on private school, although I might add it could be a public health risk to mandate masks in school as it could harm the linguistic health of some young children developing language skills.

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by smileysteve on Thursday January 27, 2022 @06:23PM (#30108497)
I believe you're correct on masks, only applying to smaller local government and not private property.

Employers were banned from vaccine mandates (even on their private property).

Court rulings were that these were abuse of the state government on smaller local governments and private entities.

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by greysphere on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @03:23PM (#30091215)
Obviously you should be able to be unvaccinated only on private property then...
Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by nicoburns on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @03:19PM (#30091158)
> The suggested (stricken) OSHA mandates were basically forcing non-consensual penetration, or lose your job.

Is that really so different? If you need to drive for your job and try to do so without a licence you'll lose your job too. Conversely, if you're in your own home then nobody is going to make you wear a mask (well certainly not the government anyway).

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by pessimizer on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @02:07PM (#30090215)
Of course you can. You're just making this up.
Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by jokethrowaway on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @03:22PM (#30091203)
Your example is a transaction between people (the doctor and you). You don't have a right to that transaction. The other party can withdraw for whatever reason (including not having time).

The freedom to roam is freedom. I understand the point you're trying to make, but the parent comment is correct in the usage of the world freedom, whether you like it or not.

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by kube-system on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @04:04PM (#30091816)
>You don't have a right to that transaction. The other party can withdraw for whatever reason

This is not always the case, even with hospitals in the US. Few markets are 100% laissez-faire in the US, and definitely not regulated industries like healthcare.

For example, if you are a hospital in the US that participates in Medicare, you must provide basic treatment to stabilize a patient with an emergency medical condition, or transfer the patient to another facility that can.

https://www.cms.gov/Regulations-and-Guidance/Legislation/EMT...

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by jatone on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @03:37PM (#30091428)
no its not, you can't roam into another's house. another's place of business. or a government building without following the rules of said environment.

nor do mask or vax mandates limit this concept of 'roaming' in any way.

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by vanusa on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @01:53PM (#30090003)
Having anyone's freedoms dependent on available hospital capacity is a terrible way to run a society.

So is letting people die from otherwise treatable injuries and infections so someone else can enjoy their "freedom" to ... you know what I'm driving at.

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by enchiridion on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @02:00PM (#30090104)
Yes, exactly. The world is dangerous and full of risks.

Freedom is literally worth sacrificing lives for. This is a fundamental founding idea of the US.

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by laurent92 on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @02:06PM (#30090199)
And many people, given the choice between money or freedom, choose freedom, even if it can make them poor. Heck, Snowden chose to relinquish wealth to defend everyone’s liberty.
Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by vanusa on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @02:04PM (#30090171)
Other people's lives, you mean.
Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by notch656a on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @02:33PM (#30090528)
Yes exactly. When the lock down and mask mandates resulted in neuroplastic infants and toddlers not seeing as much lip and face movement during critical speech and socialization age (and in many case, daycares and schools being shut down resulting in less critical socialization), you sacrifice younger children in the hopes some others will be saved.

So we sacrifice other lives (young children) so our own adult lives can perhaps be saved.

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by vanusa on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @02:43PM (#30090635)
So we sacrifice other lives (young children) so our own adult lives can perhaps be saved.

The lives of their grandparents (and of older folks not related to us), you mean. You know, the ones actually the most vulnerable to this epidemic.

I agree that the choices are difficult, no matter what we do. But there's no need to distort the basic equation, and make this particular choice appear to be something plainly selfish (young and mid-life adults snubbing the kids to cover their own asses) when it plainly is not.

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by notch656a on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @02:46PM (#30090671)
No I don't mean just our grandparents. I benefit way more from any reduction in exposure to covid than my kid does. The difference between a 2 year old and a mid 30s person is significant.
Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by vanusa on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @02:53PM (#30090771)
The point is it's misleading to say "so our own adult lives can be saved" when that's not the main motivation for these policies.

If the health system becomes incapacitated, and we have to push people out of ICUs to make way for the "freedom fighter" who won't vaccinate (which is already happening in some areas), then everyone suffers -- not just "mid 30s adults".

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by notch656a on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @03:00PM (#30090869)
So you want "freedom fighter" (whatever you consider that to be) to sign their death warrant? How are you going to keep them out of the hospital? I'd happily sign a death warrant today if it means the end of this tired argument of people complaining that people seek healthcare when they are ill.

>If the health system becomes incapacitated

If the health care system isn't working, then we need to look at expanding healthcare; perhaps by eliminating a lot of the regulations that drag it down. You don't have the right to force someone to make sure there are beds at a hospital. I don't think the answer is compelling non-consensual activity in private business such as masks.

------------------

>It's not that they "seek healthcare". But that they expect to have critical resources like ICU beds available to them (and therefore, denied to others) so they can enjoy their "freedom" (to ignore common sense) -- that folks take issue with.

You're seriously complaining that when someone seeks healthcare they are using a bed? You know how many people using beds are there for non-essential activities (motorcycling, roofing a non-essential shed, snake bite because they went hiking, whatever). Should we outlaw any non-essential activity that could send you to the ED?

It's 'common sense' to me that my (almost) 2 year old's speech development will be harmed if she can't see me speak (and at least one initial study suggests that is correct), so I don't wear a mask anywhere when she's with me nor do I enter establishments that require me to. Maybe that makes me a 'freedom fighter' for my kid's development.

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by drugstorecowboy on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @03:42PM (#30091485)
I think you are making an important point here that I would love somebody to answer. Why is covid different than riding a motorcycle? Nobody is required to ride a motorcycle. We know for a fact, it's more dangerous than driving a car as a mode of transport. It's a person needlessly putting themselves in danger purely for their own reasons. Why is there no talk of denying a hospital bed to them? The same applies to obesity and a 1000 other things.
Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by vanusa on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @06:24PM (#30093613)
Why is covid different than riding a motorcycle?

Would you agree with this analogy:

"Going out into crowded public spaces unmasked and unvaccinated ... is not unlike riding a motorcycle without a helmet. And with a busted taillight and bad brakes too, because you're also putting other people at risk."

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by notch656a on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @07:11PM (#30094126)
The mask is like having disc brakes. No mask is like having drum breaks. Walking up to someone and coughing in their face is no brakes. You may be more likely to save a life with the disc brakes, but I admit I occasionally ride bikes with drum brakes instead.

Being vaccinated is a strong tail light (having already had COVID before may be a strong tail light too). Being unvaccinated but never caught COVID is a legal but moderate tail light. Being deathly ill but sneezing on the produce is no tail light.

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by drugstorecowboy on Thursday January 27, 2022 @09:33AM (#30101013)
Wonderful, so I take it you are advocating that anybody who drives a motorcycle with no tail light and drum brakes should be left to die outside the hospital if something happens? Would that be an accurate assessment of your position?
Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by notch656a on Thursday January 27, 2022 @10:12AM (#30101480)
Not at all.
Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by nradov on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @08:58PM (#30095160)
I would not agree with that analogy regarding masks. Nor, I suspect, would noted expert on infectious diseases Dr. Monica Gandhi. I recommend you listen to her recent statements on the subject.

https://peterattiamd.com/covid-part2/

https://profiles.ucsf.edu/monica.gandhi

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by vanusa on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @09:13PM (#30095291)
I'm not sure what you're driving at, because she clearly doesn't think that "masks" as such are ineffective - just the cloth/surgical masks -- she advocates N95/KN95. Which of course are what everyone should be wearing now (in close public settings), by this point.

Also, the discussion in that podcast is a bit strange (for a bunch of reasons). For one thing, it seems to reduce the "mask question" to one of individual (or close family) risk -- "If I'm comfortable with the risk level (as affects me and my family), I should be able to decide whether to wear a mask or not (paraphrasing)" -- and completely sidesteps the community risk issue (especially in crowded public settings). Which is very different, and is of course what mask mandates (whether you agree with them or not) are designed to address.

For another, it dwells a lot on the "shame" and (what they think of) as quasi-religious aspects of mask wearing - this idea that people expect others to wear masks because those who do not are "unclean". Which may be what some people think, but to suggest that this is what most people think or that this should be part of the policy debate is just ... werid.

[dead]
Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by vanusa on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @10:38PM (#30095899)
Did you actually listen to her explanation?

I did, and it's rather obnoxious of you to suggest otherwise.

I just think your own reading of what she said is off, for reasons I'll let you figure out (or not) on your own.

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by dang on Friday January 28, 2022 @03:58PM (#30120270)
Please don't cross into personal attack or name-calling, and please don't take HN threads further into flamewar. It's not what this site is for, and it destroys what it is for.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by nradov on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @10:42PM (#30095934)
If you actually listened to it and still missed the point that badly then I can only conclude you are intentionally misunderstanding to push an irrational, unscientific narrative.
Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by dang on Friday January 28, 2022 @03:57PM (#30120252)
Personal attacks are not ok on HN. We ban accounts that do this, and we've had to warn you about this in the past. That's seriously not cool.

I'm not going to ban you right now, but if you'd please review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and stick to the rules when posting here, we'd appreciate it.

Please also stop posting flamewar comments to HN generally. It's not what this site is for, and it destroys what it is for.

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by vanusa on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @03:20PM (#30091178)
You're seriously complaining that when someone seeks healthcare they are using a bed?

No, not when they "seek healthcare". But when they go out and inevitably get themselves covid because they think they're making bold, individualist statement (as many of these people apparently do think) by not masking and not getting vaccinated.

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by vanusa on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @03:05PM (#30090948)
we need to look at expanding healthcare;

Not happening in the short term.

complaining that people seek healthcare when they are ill.

It's not that they "seek healthcare". But that they expect to have critical resources like ICU beds available to them (and therefore, denied to others) so they can enjoy their "freedom" (to ignore common sense) -- that folks take issue with.

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by spookthesunset on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @06:45PM (#30093842)
> Not happening in the short term.

Why not? It's an emergency. It's completely possible to fix this short term in a way that lets us move on without all these socially toxic and corrosive restrictions. Probably would cost an order of magnitude less, even.

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by vanusa on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @07:03PM (#30094018)
It's completely possible to fix this short term

That's not what people in healthcare say. But hey, you can say whatever you want.

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by notch656a on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @07:17PM (#30094186)
Because the front-line people in health care don't have the legislative or fiscal power to change the system they're working in. We need systematic update to healthcare system, not to blame the "people in healthcare" which are the least of all the problems.
Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by spookthesunset on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @07:33PM (#30094317)
Naw. This is an emergency, right? You don't need any of that. You just need people that are trainable enough to handle covid surges. Medical students, nurses, hell maybe even veterinarians... use your creativity.

If hospital capacity was an issue caused by covid surges, we'd have fixed it already.

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by notch656a on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @10:12PM (#30095742)
Letting people not normally licensed to expand their scope and authority to practice on humans is a regulatory and legislative challenge. Healthcare workers badly need cooperation of regulators, legislators, and fiscal stakeholders of the industry to un-fuck the industry. Also capital can be better directed towards results rather than bloated administrators in a less regulatory burdened market.
Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by spookthesunset on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @10:56PM (#30096013)
And lockdowns, forced masking and vaccine passports aren’t a “regulatory and legislative challenge”? Really?

This is supposed to be an emergency, right? Give me a break. Covid specific healthcare capacity can easily be scaled up with the amount of resources we are pouring in this dumpster fire. Figure it out.

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by notch656a on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @11:35PM (#30096253)
Agree on all points.
Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by vanusa on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @07:41PM (#30094394)
I wasn't, by even the remotest possible interpretation, "blaming people in healthcare".

So I find that a very, very weird implication for you to make.

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by notch656a on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @10:07PM (#30095708)
Apologies, blame is probably too strong of a word.

I interpreted you were holding them accountable to answer the question of expanding/fixing health care in the short term. Clearly their answers are going to be in the context of their limited power to change the whole system without the cooperation of others. They need the cooperation of both the capital holders / owners of the health care industry as well as regulators and legislators. I think when you answering this question, they are answering it within the context of working within their current constraints, which can be quite tight.

To say they are the one to answer the question, in my opinion, is to shift the onus on them to answer it. In fact we need the feedback of these workers, and they're critical in us solving current problems. They need our cooperation. But I think framing the question as something they're supposed to answer, as you have done, narrows the focus on people not to be blamed for the constraints that hold them back and thus force an otherwise unreasonable answer.

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by vanusa on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @10:14PM (#30095755)
No, just that they definitely would not agree with your view that the current system limitations are "completely possible to fix in the short term". For the simple reason that the most critical resource it depends on (trained people) is finite and highly inelastic. And is already contracting (i.e. they're are already starting to burn out and leave the profession).

Along with the second most critical resource that we expect them to have for us: empathy. Especially for those who won't vax.

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by spookthesunset on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @10:58PM (#30096026)
This is an emergency. Find a way. It isn’t fair to blame the public and then force them into some dystopian “new normal” for years because a bunch of highly paid people can’t figure out how to fix emergency Covid hospitalization capacity.

If somebody says it isn’t possible, fire them and find somebody who can figure it out. It’s a fucking emergency, remember? It’s completely possible. Saying otherwise is an excuse. Figure it the fuck out.

Zero excuses.

(Or the more simple answer is there actually isn’t a problem with hospital capacity because otherwise we’d have fixed it. You know… because it is something that could be fixed… with money alone)

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by theandrewbailey on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @02:38PM (#30090576)
Also consider that young children are the demographic least affected (symptoms and death) by COVID. It was obvious a few months in, but these debilitating policies continued.
Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by ipaddr on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @05:20PM (#30092901)
You choose to leave your house. Isn't that your choice?
Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by lost-found on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @05:28PM (#30093015)
Ahh yes because everyone knows heart attacks, strokes, aneurisms and burst appendixes never happen in your own home.
Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by caditinpiscinam on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @06:08PM (#30093433)
I think it's less about freedoms and more about rights

Is it a person's right to fly on an airplane without wearing a mask? I'd don't think so

Is it a person's right to decide what medicines they take? I'd say yes, definitely

You can take away freedoms in the interest of others, but not rights, in my opinion. The policies I've seen are pretty fuzzy on this distinction

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by vanusa on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @06:28PM (#30093665)
Is it a person's right to decide what medicines they take? I'd say yes, definitely.

Note that the mandates in question (those in Quebec) don't force you to get the vaccine.

They just say that if you don't, you no longer have an inalienable "right" to shop at Walmart.

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by x3n0ph3n3 on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @01:52PM (#30089995)
Especially since hospital capacity is induced scarcity due to government regulation and the AMA.
Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by tzs on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @02:56PM (#30090810)
We'd be having the same shortages right now even in a completely unregulated free market hospital system. A free market isn't going to build and maintain a bunch of extra capacity that goes unused except during once in a hundred year outliers like major pandemics.

All that an unregulated free market would change is how we decide who gets treated when there isn't enough capacity to treat everyone.

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by walterbell on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @02:00PM (#30090112)
Or firing doctors and nurses who recovered from Covid and declined vaccination.
Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by yibg on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @02:07PM (#30090212)
Freedoms aren’t considered in isolation. Maintaining freedom for some means removing freedom for others some times. In this case the “freedom” to get timely treatment for those that need it.
Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by xdennis on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @05:29PM (#30093018)
> the “freedom” to get timely treatment for those that need it.

That's not freedom. Freedom is not putting up barriers.

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by yibg on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @05:51PM (#30093263)
Interesting. In this take, what are the limits to freedom? Your right to swing your fist and all that. If your actions are limiting what I can do, is that not curtailing my freedoms?

Edit: to be clear on where I stand. I think you can do whatever you want, as long as it doesn't affect me. If it affects me, maybe you should still be able to do it, but then we need some thought and discussion and isn't an automatic right because "freedom".

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by ipaddr on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @05:22PM (#30092929)
Are you not getting timely treatment? Is this your reality?
Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by spookthesunset on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @03:32PM (#30091345)
> In this case the “freedom” to get timely treatment for those that need it

So why not build more capacity instead of forcing the public to adhere to a bunch of toxic and socially corrosive mandates?

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by jokethrowaway on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @03:26PM (#30091254)
> In this case the “freedom” to get timely treatment for those that need it.

That's not freedom, that's an entitlement.

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by nlarion on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @03:52PM (#30091633)
I recommend you do some basic research on the history of quarantine and the united states as well as colonial america. You'll quickly see your assertion stands on shaky ground. https://www.ushistory.org/laz/history/index.htm
Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by sanderjd on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @03:50PM (#30091612)
What freedoms are you talking about here?
Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by throwaway6734 on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @01:47PM (#30089915)
Are you opposed to laws mandating seatbelts or criminalizing heroine?
Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by Enginerrrd on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @01:58PM (#30090070)
Not OP, but I am. I don't mind laws mandating that cars HAVE seatbelts. But I think it's your choice if you want to wear them.

With Heroin, I'm not sure criminalization really had much affect at all on the percentage of heroin addicts. And I'd bet that it had less effect than the rate of prescriptions for synthetic opiates did.

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by Terretta on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @02:48PM (#30090715)
what about laws mandating cloth triangles on your face^H^H^H^H chest at the beach?

what about laws banning second-hand smoke indoors?

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by hbn on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @02:08PM (#30090224)
Yes to both of those things. The government shouldn't get to take money from me because I endangered myself.
Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by Domenic_S on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @03:23PM (#30091212)
You think not wearing a seatbelt only endangers you?