News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by sschueller on Thursday January 20, 2022 @03:06PM (#30013992)
Sorry to say but who ever decided that the phrase "defund the police" is good or smart made a huge mistake. Or they may have deliberately picked a phrase that would upset and confuse a large number of people. It has split the political discord right down the middle and you will never get proper reform.

The phrase that should have been used is "reform the police" because it would get almost every one aboard even the police themselves. Nothing is perfect in this world and almost every one can think of a way to improve something.

This decade of attempt to reform the police most people didn't know or care about. This new movement could have brought it to light and get something done that everyone can agree on. Instead it turned into a left vs right shit show.

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by s17n on Thursday January 20, 2022 @03:12PM (#30014079)
They had been trying to "reform" the Minneapolis police (where George Floyd was killed) for years, but the police union had successfully blocked even the most moderate changes. There are similar stories everywhere.

"Defund the police" is a good slogan because it makes it clear that you have to pick a side - the police have made it clear that "reform" is not going to be possible through cooperation. This isn't to say that there aren't plenty of individual officers who would support, or at least not obstruct, reform, but without destroying the existing institutions (police unions, primarily) that perpetuate the status quo, and disempowering the individuals who are committed to it, nothing is going to change.

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by nsxwolf on Thursday January 20, 2022 @03:33PM (#30014454)
“Defund the police” is one of the most shockingly terrible slogans I’ve heard in my life. I know a lot of life long Midwestern Democrats that gasped in utter dismay when they heard this term and saw that yup, this is in fact what our party is going with.

It inspired some of the most insane and vile hatred I have ever witnessed.

Not being able to see that really just means you are out of touch with huge swaths of Americans of every political persuasion.

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by a_shovel on Thursday January 20, 2022 @03:50PM (#30014737)
"Defund the police" is not a slogan. It's a policy demand.

It's not designed to appeal to Midwestern life-long democrats. It's designed to fix a problem.

The activists promoting the demand are out of touch with huge swaths of Americans, but by symmetry, that means huge swaths of Americans are out of touch with the activists who, through their activism, research, and personal experience, know the nature of policing in America is closer to Brookside, Alabama than to what their Elementary school teachers told them about the police.

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by mindslight on Thursday January 20, 2022 @05:00PM (#30015724)
> "Defund the police" is not a slogan. It's a policy demand ... designed to fix a problem

The "police" in this article are not a cost center, but rather a profit center. So, problem fixed?

I agree that the cancerous police budgets consuming municipal budgets is a problem, but the even deeper problem is that they're not bound by the law they purport to uphold. "Defund" does nothing to advocate for legal accountability, which is the primary problem.

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by throwaway0a5e on Thursday January 20, 2022 @05:50PM (#30016463)
There is no shortage of people all over the political spectrum who absolutely abhor the status quo of law enforcement in the US. You could have had the problem fixed already if you a) didn't go off half cocked with a stupid slogan that appeals to pretty much nobody b) thrown the conservatives a bone by abolishing the ATF or something.
Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by ashwagary on Friday January 21, 2022 @08:16AM (#30023046)
Videos of unarmed people constantly being murdered by police had no effect on the public after activists shouted "defund the police". Silly.

I'm more inclined to believe corporate media convinced people the phrase was an issue.... most people dont have a problem with it, they were just given an opinion to parrot.

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by tunesmith on Thursday January 20, 2022 @06:02PM (#30016606)
I like to contrast it with "black lives matter" by asking, if you literally succeeded, what would be the new reality. With "black lives matter" you'd be in a reality where everyone agreed that black lives matter. Which is great! With "defund the police" you'd be in a reality without any police forces. Not so great.

Locally we have an organization called "stop having kids". It's so dumb. If they succeeded literally, humanity would die out. They say it's a great slogan because it gets people talking. That's a lousy defense.

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by s17n on Friday January 21, 2022 @02:13AM (#30020237)
If you're trying to win elections, it's probably a bad battle to pick. But if you actually want to reform the police, it's a battle you are going to have to fight. I'll leave it to the galaxy brains to determine what the appropriate balance between the two is.
Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by sschueller on Thursday January 20, 2022 @03:18PM (#30014175)
People who don't live in areas of police corruption don't know this and will "vote" for the other side because they don't know what is meant with defund the police.
Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by tunesmith on Thursday January 20, 2022 @06:04PM (#30016636)
Right, because the intended meaning is different than what the words literally say.
Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by a_shovel on Thursday January 20, 2022 @07:28PM (#30017521)
Defund means "withdraw funding for", not "withdraw all funding for".
Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by tunesmith on Friday January 21, 2022 @12:22AM (#30019494)
That is literally incorrect. You can google "defund" and the first definition is "prevent from continuing to receive funds". And it's common usage, as well - anytime a government passes a bill to "defund" a bill or a department, it means they are basically without money.
Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by a_shovel on Friday January 21, 2022 @01:44AM (#30020023)
Saying I'm "literally incorrect" just makes me wonder what "figuratively incorrect" would mean in this situation.

You've made multiple comments under this article about how "defund" can only possibly mean removing 100% of funding. Sometimes other people use words differently from the way you do personally. You need to adapt your interpretation to their usage, not the other way around.

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by tunesmith on Monday January 24, 2022 @07:20PM (#30066129)
No I have not. I've made multiple comments about how "defund" is often, and reasonably (see definition and common usage), interpreted as such. Just expecting people to adapt their interpretation in the figurative way you want is not reasonable, and is not a winning political strategy either.
Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by everdrive on Thursday January 20, 2022 @03:38PM (#30014549)
It’s not necessarily a good slogan if you live in a high crime area, where better or more policing might be highly desired. At least in the press, people calling for the defunding of the police were often co-located with some of the more violent riots of the last few years. I can appreciate that there are arguments to suggest that this is a false comparison. However, it must be admitted that the slogan was confusing and divisive, whereas not all issues around policing were nearly as divisive. (For example, there was broad support, and rightly so, for the jury verdict in the George Floyd case. )
Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by kmonsen on Thursday January 20, 2022 @03:46PM (#30014674)
Everywhere in the US is a high enough crime area that people need the police to feel safe.
Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by crawfordcomeaux on Thursday January 20, 2022 @04:01PM (#30014930)
A feeling of safety comes from within. Establishing a brutal traumatizing system that isn't oriented toward healing doesn't create a culture of safety, but of emotional codependence on violence.
Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by asgraham on Thursday January 20, 2022 @04:36PM (#30015418)
"A feeling of safety comes from within." --- This is an actively counterproductive statement. Just look at the impetus behind "defund the police": the real police violence causes people of color to feel unsafe. On the flipside, crime often involves real violence that makes people feel unsafe. You can argue that policing isn't the answer to crime, but real danger is the root of feeling unsafe, even if (like everything) it is mediated by perception. A "culture of safety" must be rooted in a reality of safety.
Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by jimmygrapes on Thursday January 20, 2022 @04:00PM (#30014907)
Why?
Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by kmonsen on Thursday January 20, 2022 @05:27PM (#30016144)
I have lived in NYC and Bay area. Both times safe places in those areas. And sure I have never seen a crime happen.

But very close to me (like 15 min of walking), there are major armed crimes happening. There are enough guns and people willing to use them in this country that it is just not safe without the police.

There are many reasons for this, I probably agree with most of them, but until they are all solved we need the police.

I grew up in Norway, did not feel like this there at all. Of course crime does still exist, but I would not care how far it was to my local police station.

Also lived in the UK, felt very safe compared to the US.

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by adamrezich on Thursday January 20, 2022 @03:20PM (#30014214)
why do you consider "the police" a single unified group (aside from some "individual officers")? "the police" are not a federalized entity (yet(??)), so it seems at the very least disingenuous, but also possibly dangerous, to lump tens of thousands of people from disparate cities and counties and states into a single amorphous group, and then generate a slogan that "makes it clear you have to pick a side" on how you feel about them.

has anything good come from this pattern of overgeneralizing and then generating purposefully disingenuous propagandistic terms to force people to "pick a side"?

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by folkhack on Thursday January 20, 2022 @03:40PM (#30014580)
> why do you consider "the police" a single unified group

Police unions are strong in this country. The police are definitely on an organized and unified front in regards to this. Saying "the police" referring to a "single unified group" is normal in every-day conversation in this country.

> "the police" are not a federalized entity (yet(??))

We have police that are federal in this country. "Federal police officer" is an actual term.

> it seems at the very least disingenuous [...] to lump [...] thousands of people [...] into a single amorphous group, and then generate a slogan that "makes it clear you have to pick a side" on how you feel about them.

The police are an organized force in this country protected and backed by local and federal governments. I feel like it's a weird and reductionist to say we can't address systemic issues with police as a group. I think we should both address the individualistic issues happening, as well as address the systemic issues that police are facing as an organized group.

Also - who cares if someone picks a side? In regards to the police I have been held at gunpoint for holding my wallet up in a dark car to see if I had my bank card. They thought it was a weapon I was brandishing toward them - it was not. My point here is that if/when the police suspect you of wrongdoing they will immediately be "picking a side" so why shouldn't I be able to pick a side?

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by adamrezich on Thursday January 20, 2022 @03:53PM (#30014795)
> We have police that are federal in this country.

of course we have federal officers, but "the police" are not federalized, and hopefully that distinction and the reason for making it are clear. there is a huge difference between the current state of affairs vs. a world where our nation's police force was actually federalized & centrally managed. we don't live in that world, and pretending that we do, when we don't, but we easily could, isn't a very good idea.

> I feel like it's a weird and reductionist to say we can't address systemic issues with police as a group.

I never said that. where did I say that?

> Also - who cares if someone picks a side?

the problem isn't so much picking a side as it is in presenting any sort of political rhetoric in black-and-white, zero-or-one, left-or-right binaries—especially when distortionary, obfuscating memes/slogans are used to do so. this is literally the single biggest problem in contemporary politics. all nuanced discussion on an issue is lost when you frame things in terms of, "pick a side, you're either with us, or you're with the Nazis/etc. etc." ("well actually I take issue with this one aspect of what you're saying." "you would, Nazi! I knew you weren't really on Our Side.")

overgeneralizing issues and using propagandistic slogans literally designed to inflame and polarize, specifically in order to bifurcate the perception of reality among the general populace, has yet to be proven to actually solve anything—it really just seems like it makes people feel good for joining Team A or Team B, feeling righteous about being on The Correct Side Of The Issue, and vitriolic toward The Other Side. it's a great way to lead a country into a downward spiral nosedive toward destruction, and it's been highly effective so far—maybe we should stop and take notice of this phenomenon and take steps to rectify it!

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by folkhack on Thursday January 20, 2022 @04:14PM (#30015113)
> of course we have federal officers, but "the police" are not federalized

Huge swaths of police officers in this country are federal police officers - that was my only point. You made a claim that made it seem like police officers were not "federalized" yet and I rebutted that federal police are absolutely a thing.

I don't want to go off on a hypothetical tangent about a centrally managed police force.

---

> me: I feel like it's a weird and reductionist to say we can't address systemic issues with police as a group.

> you: I never said that. where did I say that?

The comment I responded to is as-follows (your words):

1. why do you consider "the police" a single unified group (aside from some "individual officers")?

2. "the police" are not a federalized entity (yet(??))

3. it seems at the very least disingenuous, but also possibly dangerous, to lump tens of thousands of people from disparate cities and counties and states into a single amorphous group

You are making a very clear argument against addressing police as a group, to the point of calling it "disingenuous" and "possibly dangerous." You make a very direct argument here and I think it's disingenuous to claim that you "never said that."

And with that specific bit - I'm done reading your post, and I'm done conversing with you on this topic.

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by adamrezich on Thursday January 20, 2022 @04:31PM (#30015361)
> Huge swaths of police officers in this country are federal police officers - that was my only point.

right which is why "defund the police" is once again such a ridiculously overgeneralized thing to say! there's 17985 police agencies in the country, which includes federal, state, county, and city officers. each one of these things is wildly different from the other, and you're just throwing them all together and saying "defund 'em all," as though that could possibly be a solution to such a complex problem.

here's where the miscommunication lies, I believe:

put aside for a second why "reform the police" isn't a great slogan to get anything done (I agree btw)—let's say the idea of reforming police corruption had never been floated before, and then when "defund the police" came about, instead the slogan was "reform the police." in this hypothetical world, I would have much, much less of an issue with the idea of collecting all the police from all the disparate parts of the country and lumping them together. the reason for this is that if you live in a small town with a small local police department that is well-liked and good and fair and all that, then the locals could very easily agree that "the police," in general, should be reformed, but that the local cops are doing fine as is. you wouldn't be choosing them to "pick a side" ("for the police" or "against the police"), you're merely asking people to acknowledge that, in many places in the country, the police are not as just and good as your local cops, and as long as we can all agree that that's the case, then we can maybe start to work together to make things better for everyone.

instead, when you say "defund the police," you're alienating these same people who don't have a problem at all with their local police, especially in smaller towns and cities, because you're essentially instilling cognitive dissonance upon them, asking them to hold both "all police should be defunded" and "but idk I think my local cops are alright" in their heads at the same time. cognitive dissonance in values like this leads to political/ideological zealotry which doesn't accomplish anything other than dividing people and making everyone feel worse, while nothing really changes because your movement's explicitly stated goals (even if you don't actually mean "defund," it's what you're saying) are beyond the pale for many, many people. this is how you bifurcate and demoralize a population, and it's working fantastically.

---

response to below comment:

> This is textbook moving the goalpost. Your original point was that we shouldn't make general statements about police, which is clearly nonsense. If you have other problems with "defund the police" as a slogan that's a separate issue.

how are any goalposts being moved when my initial post ended with

> has anything good come from this pattern of overgeneralizing and then generating purposefully disingenuous propagandistic terms to force people to "pick a side"?

it's called establishing a position and then building it up over the course of debate, I thought I made my overarching position here pretty clear: propagandistic overgeneralizations and slogans specifically designed to inflame and divide rather than unite are the single biggest threat we face as a nation today, and are quite rapidly bringing about the decline of the Republic as our perception of reality splits roughly in two.

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by mrtranscendence on Thursday January 20, 2022 @04:52PM (#30015643)
This is textbook moving the goalpost. Your original point was that we shouldn't make general statements about police, which is clearly nonsense. If you have other problems with "defund the police" as a slogan that's a separate issue.
Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by ruined on Thursday January 20, 2022 @03:31PM (#30014416)
the police see themselves as a single unified group. this is actualized through culture (thin blue line, sheepdogs), organization (80% unionized, literally the state), and informal local agreements (gangs, corruption, coverups)
Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by geofft on Thursday January 20, 2022 @03:32PM (#30014432)
Because every police department is organized in the same general way and has the same incentives. It's not at all about the individual officers - it's that organizing the police in this way has a corrupting influence. (Or, at best, it attracts people who wish to abuse power in various ways.)

As mentioned upthread, this story of the small town that has turned into a front organization for a police force that, were they not operating under the label "police," would be a gang of highwaymen, is a pattern that repeats itself a lot! When you see something that happens repeatedly from many different individuals who all happen to be in the same circumstance, Occam's Razor demands you at least consider investigating the circumstance and not the people.

There are almost certainly a large number of genuinely good and kindhearted and well-intentioned people in the employ of various police departments. They should leave their jobs, lest they stop being good and kindhearted and well-intentioned and become dangerous to society. Ideally, they would do that of their own free will; alternatively, we can defund their payroll. I have no problem with the individual former police officer merely by virtue of their former employment, and I am more than happy to judge them as an individual on their own merits.

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by adamrezich on Thursday January 20, 2022 @03:42PM (#30014606)
might it be possible that entire police/county sheriff departments are actually generally good people who don't do anything wrong? when you frame things as "'the police' are bad, except for some individuals," you are implicitly discounting this possibility, instead choosing to make broad sweeping statements about tens of thousands of people spread across millions of square miles, in wildly differing settings, with wildly differing local circumstances.

(I will refrain from commenting on your last paragraph so as to not get into an ideological flamewar.)

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by geofft on Thursday January 20, 2022 @03:55PM (#30014828)
Well, I am not actually framing things as "'the police' are bad, except for some individuals." Sorry if that was unclear.

I really don't think it is either well-defined or relevant whether the individuals are "good" or "bad." As an analogy that is hopefully clear at the risk of being a little inflammatory: almost all of the 18-year-old conscripts of any random country you might be at war with have absolutely zero influence over the political direction of that country. But that doesn't change the fact that people handed them a gun and told them (even, perhaps, forced them) to shoot at you. They can be utterly kind and friendly individuals (see e.g. the World War I Christmas truce), but if they're about to shoot at you, that's a problem regardless of whether they're kind. When someone says "The XYZ army is about to invade us," it makes no sense to say "Well most of the XYZ soldiers are good people!"

And no, the distinction is not whether they're actually shooting at you. If they're lined up on the border ready to invade, if they're in training camps practicing shooting, if they're not assigned to be a footsoldier but they are assigned to build infrastructure and implement logistics for the invasion, etc., they're contributing to the invasion, and you'd still say that the entire invading army needs to be stopped. Saying that most of the invading army hasn't seen active combat yet and therefore isn't personally culpable is also nonsensical.

Or put another way - in gang-ridden territories or in post-war countries ruled by warlords, it's often the case that gang members or soldiers will do things to genuinely benefit the people who live there, running essential food and medicines across blockades, keeping people safe from other gangs or warlords, etc. That hardly justifies the gang or the warlord as a good government, though!

Every single person who works for a police department, without exception, works for an organization that is doing bad things. If, somehow, the specific things they do as individuals are good, when they do them on behalf of the organization, it serves to increase the legitimacy of that organization to gain more power and do more bad things in the future. If they are good people who haven't incurred personal moral culpability for doing anything wrong, great! I'm not in the business of judging souls for heaven or hell. I'm in the business of having opinions, as a citizen of a republic, about how that republic should be constituted.

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by adamrezich on Thursday January 20, 2022 @04:10PM (#30015058)
> Every single person who works for a police department, without exception, works for an organization that is doing bad things.

I find this assertion, combined with the final paragraph from your previous post, interesting—given the very loose and broad criteria of "doing bad things" here, could you not replace "police department" with "government"? if so, then should your previous post's third paragraph not also apply to all employees of city, county, state, and federal governments as well?

if this is your end goal: uh, do you know anyone who's hiring?

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by UncleEntity on Thursday January 20, 2022 @04:04PM (#30014995)
Well… Every single person who votes in an election , without exception, votes for an organization that is doing bad things.

The simplest thing to do to solve this problem is just do away with elections, no?

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by geofft on Thursday January 20, 2022 @04:16PM (#30015149)
There are in fact multiple political movements, from all sorts of perspectives, that refuse to vote because they don't want to grant legitimacy to an organization they have problems with! This is certainly a position I've seen on the American far left about our elections, but you also see it from entire political parties (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Election_boycott), and there's the more interesting position where Sinn Fein to this day gets elected to Parliament and refuses to participate or vote on things (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abstentionism).

So, yes, I think that's a defensible position, and if you wanted to characterize my decision to vote as evidence that I believe that my government as an institution is salvageable and not inherently hopeless the way I believe the police as an institution are, I don't think you'd be wrong.

The other thing is that you wouldn't really do away with elections, you'd do away with the whole organization (the government) that you're electing people to. Which is, in fact, the anarchist position, and I think that position is also defensible.

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by kansface on Thursday January 20, 2022 @04:34PM (#30015387)
This argument is hopelessly generalizable. Who in the world would does it not apply to!? Literally ever organization does “bad things” sometimes. That’s just the nature of groups of people. You are throwing out the baby with the bath water if you disregard kind, degree, personal involvement, etc.
Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by kmonsen on Thursday January 20, 2022 @03:48PM (#30014701)
That is exactly why it is stupid, if you force people to pick sides they will pick the police. I don't really love them, but I also don't want them gone and would not feel safe with no police.

I am super left wing, but if you force me to pick a side I am choosing the police without much thinking.

I understand not everyone thinks like this, but if you want to win elections in a two party system you need a broad coalition. You will not find a broad coalition that is willing to pick the side you want here.

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by sli on Thursday January 20, 2022 @04:19PM (#30015200)
You should instead actually consider the side being offered here instead of seemingly rejecting it over a slogan.

Police duties are expensive and stretched pretty thing, and thus they get funding for things that should not be within the purview of policing. A classic example is police response to mental health crises, and the frankly bizarre and spurious justification that creates for outlawing suicide. Far too often, people need help but are sent a militarized police response instead.

A retort to this is frequently around the suicidal person being armed and therefore needing armed police, but that seems to me like exactly what you should expect when sending heavily armed wannabe-soldiers to bust down the door of someone who needs a doctor or a therapist. Predictable fear responses are used as justification to continue or even escalate the problem rather than address it systemically.

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by ctoth on Thursday January 20, 2022 @04:47PM (#30015584)
Hold on so if someone is intending to kill themselves with a gun, so cops that come have guns, the only reason a person has a gun suddenly becomes to defend themselves from the police? What happened to the original gun? Am I just parsing this wrong?
Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by relaxing on Thursday January 20, 2022 @05:40PM (#30016313)
The original gun probably wasn’t going to be fired at all. A trained responder could talk then down. But throw in a hostile force and you’ve increased the likelihood of a shootout.

Also it may not even have been a gun. The police will also treat a knife or a motor vehicle as a deadly weapon and respond with lethal force.

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by kmonsen on Thursday January 20, 2022 @08:55PM (#30018225)
I don't think so, if there is a gun the police is coming with guns. That is true even in Norway. Once you start waving around a gun or something that looks like a gun with some threats as well you will be taken seriously. With one very possible consequence that you will be shot.

Defund the police is not solving this situation. It could solve a lot of situations more calmly but not this one.

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by tunesmith on Thursday January 20, 2022 @06:05PM (#30016652)
Which has nothing to do with "Defund the police". People hear "defund the police" and take it to mean literally defunding them, with zero budget.
Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by crawfordcomeaux on Thursday January 20, 2022 @04:03PM (#30014971)
You are making life choices without much thinking, by your own admission. You're allowed to do that.

Some of us choose more thoughtful paths and recognize 2-party systems as inherently abusive because they're out of alignment with reality, which is inherently nonbinary.

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by ctoth on Thursday January 20, 2022 @04:12PM (#30015095)
You are making life choices without much consideration of political and electoral reality, by your own admission. You're allowed to do that. Some of us choose more pragmatic paths and recognize that our individual dislike for 2-party systems does ~nothing to change the fact that we actually physically currently live in a 2-party system which is inherently binary.

If you want to win elections, build coalitions. If you want to rant about how abusive the current system is, you can do that, but don't expect to actually win anything.

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by crawfordcomeaux on Thursday January 20, 2022 @04:16PM (#30015162)
I don't allow existing systems to limit my thinking like that. Optimizing a part or feature of a system that doesn't need to exist is an element of dumb design. Pragmatism demands exploring ideas beyond the existing systems, otherwise we'll remain trapped in them.
Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by kmonsen on Thursday January 20, 2022 @05:25PM (#30016100)
The system can only be changed by the current political parties, so at the very least you need to build a coalition to change the system.
Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by crawfordcomeaux on Friday January 21, 2022 @01:30AM (#30019925)
That's definitely disempowerment talking. There's nothing stopping anyone from creating an alternative government that meets more needs and is more fun to interact with. If it accomplishes that and people are willing to implement it and it doesn't violate laws by existing, then how does any preexisting system prevent people from switching over to it, aside from locking up people who use the new system?

Disruption isn't just for companies.

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by kmonsen on Friday January 21, 2022 @07:35PM (#30031825)
I don't even understand what you are talking about. Will this new government control the military/police/taxation? If not then it is just another burden for me. And the old government will still be around so you achieved nothing.

I am all for disruption but I really don't know what your plan is. And please understand that disruption is not always good for everyone. A lot of people depend on our current government to survive.

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by crawfordcomeaux on Saturday January 22, 2022 @01:17AM (#30034184)
I'm trying to point out the system can be changed from the outside. That's it. I'm not trying to tell you how to do it. I'm simply pointing out it's possible.
Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by ctoth on Thursday January 20, 2022 @04:29PM (#30015341)
Thinking on this more this conversation reminds me of the new programmer who joins the team and then starts advocating we rewrite everything in Rust, when we need to ship in two weeks. Yes, there might be a perfect system. No, we do not live in or possess this perfect system. Any reform, any positive change, needs to be based on where we actually are. Saying this is how things should be does approximately nothing to get us there. Refusing to engage with the current system does nothing to get us there. disparaging the current system does nothing to get us there. The only thing that actually moves the needle is sitting down and fixing things one little bug at a time. It isn't fun or glamorous and there certainly isn't a divisive slogan for it, but that is reality as I know it.
Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by crawfordcomeaux on Friday January 21, 2022 @01:36AM (#30019972)
It's possible to envision a new systemand map a transition from old to new.

Iterative, incremental design is one way change can happen, not the only way.

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by openasocket on Thursday January 20, 2022 @03:53PM (#30014791)
Good lord yes. The second I heard the phrase "defund the police" I immediately had a vision of the conservative attack ads:

Open on an elderly woman, sitting quietly at home knitting. Suddenly we hear a window smash, and we see a burgler, in a ski mask and everything, attacking her window with an axe. She lets out a scream and runs for her landline. She dials 911, breathing heavily, and says "Hello, I need help-". But an automated voice on the other line cuts her off "we're sorry, due to recent funding changes, the operating hours of emergency services has been reduced. To leave a message, please stay on the line". As the voice drones on, we zoom in on the phone, hear a muffled scream, and the phone drops dramatically onto the floor. Fade to black, brought to you my Americans for a more American America.

... I mean seriously, the attack ad writes itself. I would honestly donate money every month to a nonprofit who's sole job was to find progressive activists, and run whatever shit they are saying through a focus group. I'm in favor of police reform and everything those activists are saying, but they need to get their shit together.

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by dls2016 on Thursday January 20, 2022 @03:26PM (#30014323)
> Sorry to say but who ever decided that the phrase "defund the police" is good or smart made a huge mistake.

Yet we're here talking about it, repeating the phrase. So I disagree.

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by folkhack on Thursday January 20, 2022 @03:43PM (#30014623)
Exactly how I feel - any softer language would be forgotten and swept aside. I've heard the "police reform" drum being banged on my entire life with little to no effect - I don't blame them for trying a new slogan that cuts deeper.
Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by datavirtue on Thursday January 20, 2022 @04:21PM (#30015227)
The middle class, the main power center in America, rarely interfaces with the police. When they do the police are very nice and polite to them and provide a sense of safety, help, and support. They are viewed as super heros.

The lower classes are not treated like this in any way, shape, or form. My family spent many years being targeted and harassed by local small town police in various jurisdictions. Driving a car that is more than ten years old is a great way to attract police attention. Driving a new F-150, they just smile and at you and hollar "Nice truck!".

It did cause me to get very aquianted with my civil rights though. At the end we were pretty good at thwarting the harassment using a variety of methods to assert our rights.

When I was 18 I ran over two brothers on purpose and skipped town. They were on drugs and beating someone in my passenger seat to death. Their sister blocked the front of my car so I threw it in reverse and floored the gas. They were inside the passenger door that was open, sweeping them under the car (a Ford Thunderbird).

Anyway, when the police caught up with me at work the officer saw that I was a clean cut white boy with a new car and decided on the spot that I had already been punished enough (after confirming I was there to buy/sell drugs). My car door was wasted. He just chuckled and left after mentioning the brothers were still in the hospital in really bad condition.

I thought for sure I was going to prison. I have more stories like this.

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by alsetmusic on Tuesday January 25, 2022 @09:09PM (#30080794)
> The middle class, the main power center in America…

I’ve got a bridge to sell you.

The power in America is at the very top with wealth and favors. The middle class has no real say in anything. I’m pretty sure most people would agree that they have no pull with their congress people after voting. But ultra wealthy people sure do.

Edit: I left out corporations and lobbyists.

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by autoexec on Thursday January 20, 2022 @05:32PM (#30016215)
> Exactly how I feel - any softer language would be forgotten and swept aside

It's not as if they only had this one horrible slogan and everything else is "softer language" or exactly the same. Yes, a new slogan that has some bite was a good idea, the one they went with was a horrible mistake that only made it harder for them to accomplish their goals.

Many many people want changes to the way police operate, no one wants a police force that doesn't have any funding.

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by autoexec on Thursday January 20, 2022 @05:28PM (#30016154)
Just because we're here talking about how terrible it is doesn't mean that it isn't also hurting the actual cause. The cause isn't to get people to repeat or discuss a slogan, but to make dramatic reforms to police. The slogan hurts that effort by turning people who'd otherwise agree to reforms against supporting the movement. It's a horrible slogan that has made it harder to accomplish the actual aim of police reform.
Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by moate on Thursday January 20, 2022 @03:51PM (#30014745)
It's almost like slogans aren't politics, but just a way of summing up something you don't want to think too hard about...

"Make America Great Again" means literally nothing. At least defund the police states a concrete goal. Don't even get me started on how bastardized "Critical Race Theory" has become.

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by autoexec on Thursday January 20, 2022 @05:35PM (#30016245)
> At least defund the police states a concrete goal.

A goal that no one wants. Every one wants police to exist. That means they want police to be funded. The minute that slogan reached the public conservatives started with "If they are successful you won't have police when you are in danger because they will have no funds to help you". The slogan has done more to hurt the changes of meaningful change than to help it.

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by moate on Friday January 21, 2022 @09:43AM (#30024120)
Counterpoint: I do not want police. I do not want policing to exist. I do not want the police to have a single penny of public funds.

The slogan is not the problem. People wanting police in its current form are the problem.

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by autoexec on Friday January 21, 2022 @03:05PM (#30029234)
Without any police how would you suggest people in a city deal with a murder? Who would investigate it? Who would arrest the person responsible? Who would enforce contracts? What would stop anyone from taking anything they could take by force? Not wanting police publicly funded (“Home Depot™ Presents the Police!®” style) is absurd enough, but to think that policing as a whole doesn't need to exist at all is a new take I hadn't seen before. What's the alternative?
Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by moate on Sunday January 23, 2022 @12:20AM (#30043841)
Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by autoexec on Sunday January 23, 2022 @08:35AM (#30046022)
I appreciate the responsive, but that's a very poorly thought out piece. It gives a very small number of very specific cases where police (supposedly) aren't needed at all, and others where they could be replaced but fails to say what they'd replace them with beyond "civilian services". The police are a "civilian service". Police officers are civilians.

It also fails to address what the difference is between police and "civilian services" that perform exactly the same function, what will stop the new service providers from becoming exactly what the current one has become, or how breaking up the current organizational structure into multiple entirely separate organizations tasked with extremely limited roles would produce greater efficiencies and effectiveness.

I agree that police are poorly suited for mental health work and I think we would be much better off getting mental health professionals in that role to help the person in crisis, probably along with police backup (for safety). Police do a very poor job of both helping people with mental illness and keeping people safe while responding to mental health crisis, but with oversight and accountability they could do one of those things very well.

I agree that traffic cops don't need to be armed to the teeth to pull over speeders and that they shouldn't use unmarked cars, but I think it's pretty useful that when they pull someone over they can see if they are a wanted criminal, determine if the car they are driving has been stolen, and arrest people who are intoxicated. They can do those things because they are working under a single organization. The cop pulling over speeders has access to criminal databases updated by other police officers in other departments (like the ones dealing with homicide, missing persons, and stolen cars) and can take dangerous people to a jail cell to be watched over by jailers who are also other police officers. Having all those different types of officers under one umbrella organization means that hiring practices, training, and polices can be consistent between them, that inter-departmental communications can flow easily, and that oversight can be simplified and consolidated. Imagine how much more work it would take to get multiple different "civilian" organizations to work together, handle passing around access to highly sensitive information securely, and to monitor them all individually.

They entirely hand-wave police preventing and stopping violence by saying that "In most incidents of violent crime, police are responding to a crime that has already taken place." which is great for "most incidents" but none of the rest of them. They say police are "ill-equipped" to investigate crime, ignoring the fact that every crime that has ever been investigated and justice was served happened because they did their job. Yes, there are problems, but no alternative organization has ever done a better job and they say nothing about why or how their "specialized service" would.

Ultimately their plan to replace police with "New Police but somehow also not connected to an institution of policing" isn't compelling. All of the fundamental problems with oversight and regulation are still unsolved. All of the problems with police unions and the relationship between law enforcement and the court system are still unsolved. It's "New Police", but less organized, and less capable.

It's a whole lot easier to reform and manage one system, than try to reform and manage countless separate unaffiliated systems trying to do the exact same job in different ways. Change is needed, and not all of their ideas are terrible, but there's no reason we couldn't accomplish them without making the problem larger and harder to manage and there's no indication on that website as to why that wouldn't be case with hundreds of totally separate New Police forces doing the same essential job of policing.

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by autoexec on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @11:04PM (#30096053)
That pretty much sums up what I've seen so far. A lot of differing ideas about what defending the police means where the most extreme voices (abolish the police for example) offer zero explanations on how a society can get by without any law enforcement or why their alternatives would fair any better while more moderate takes deal solidly with reforming the system that we have.

I do get the frustrations expressed by those taking the more extreme view, but it comes off as more of an emotional outburst than a path forward. It's understandable to be frustrated and outraged enough to want to abolish policing entirely at this point, but it's also not constructive or helpful.

The good thing is that everybody is pretty clear on what the problems are, but I fear that those seeking radical/counterproductive changes to society like getting rid of police entirely will hold back the rest of us either by rejecting anything that doesn't burn the justice system to the ground, or by convincing others that there's no hope in reformation of what we have today while offering no actual solutions leading people to feel helpless and defeated at a time when the message people need is "Change is possible and necessary, we just need to insist on it and work to make it happen"

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by relaxing on Thursday January 20, 2022 @05:49PM (#30016449)
Good, because it’s gotten people to realize the police weren’t coming to help when you were in danger anyway.
Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by autoexec on Thursday January 20, 2022 @06:28PM (#30016933)
Not that audience. They already felt that depending only on police for protection was stupid. They buy guns so they can protect themselves and their families. They still depend on police though.

Conservatives are fearful by nature. They always suspect that some group of "others" is out there just waiting to take everything they love from them. Many of them live in rural/remote areas where "others" aren't as prevalent and police response times are poor. They still love police though, in part because they want to feel safe and protected, but also because they like to see "others" being punished. They really love punishment. They're convinced that fear of punishment is the only thing standing between order and chaos. The harsher the punishment, the more peaceful the world. Police represent order, safety, and help keep the "others" in control. Defunding them is not an option for these people.

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by tehwebguy on Thursday January 20, 2022 @03:20PM (#30014212)
> The phrase that should have been used is "reform the police" because it would get almost every one aboard even the police themselves.

Yeah, that's the problem with "reform", it is so meaningless that the very police that need to be reformed are all for it!

This is not a system that can be fixed, a ludicrous percentage, maybe as high as 95%, of current police will need to find a new line of work for policing to be fixed in the US.

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by moate on Thursday January 20, 2022 @03:55PM (#30014825)
"Reform the police"

Okay, we gave them hundreds of millions of dollars for body cams!

body cam footage not available, officer turned off prior to incident

For a pretty solid breakdown on why it's not likely to ever expect the cops to get on the side of checks notes taking funding and job security away from themselves: https://www.nytimes.com/2020/06/06/us/police-unions-minneapo...

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by mixedCase on Thursday January 20, 2022 @04:14PM (#30015114)
> officer turned off prior to incident

> it's not likely to ever expect the cops to get on the side of checks notes taking funding and job security away from themselves

Then align the incentives.

Harsher penalties for turning them off/disabling them/tampering with their wear protocol in any way.

Weave into the salary a financial bonus for long periods of time without incidents.

And since this is HN: Add some AI bullshit that reviews the tapes to make sure the cameras are not being covered or whatever with a secondary manual review by an outside entity to rule out false positives, make sure every police officer is aware of the automated review, and even if that system doesn't work perfectly I'm sure even a shitty government contractor can make it made good enough to put enough fear into enough corrupt cops so that camera shutdowns don't become routine.

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by moate on Thursday January 20, 2022 @04:42PM (#30015511)
I'm just going to go ahead and say that police unions wield outsized political power, which is why people who own the "abolish/defund the police" slogan think "reform" isn't enough. The reforms may get passed (or we might have another, more "important" political cause that sucks momentum away) but if the cops themselves are hostile to the reforms, they have plenty of ways to pull the teeth out of the regulations, or just get them overturned/taken out of the next CBA.

Police "unions" are exceedingly well-funded, well-networked groups that can apply a TON of political and electoral pressure. They also provide (very good/expensive) lawyers for any cop found guilty of an infraction. On top of that, the very act of prosecuting cops is essentially biting the hand that feeds you for a DA/AG.

The cops will always opposing things that make the job of being a cop harder. The same way a software developer does. You can't make the incentives align if the people who currently are police are the people you feel should not, under any circumstances, be the ones in charge of public safety. The number of low-grade thugs in the US police forces is pretty apparent when you look at the domestic violence numbers.1 Either abusive people are self-selecting into being cops, or being a cop makes you abusive.

TL;dr- You want "reform" because you think there's inherent value created by the current system, and I don't because I think the value is an byproduct and not the goal.

1-https://sites.temple.edu/klugman/2020/07/20/do-40-of-police-...

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by krapp on Thursday January 20, 2022 @03:48PM (#30014696)
"Defund the police" was born out of the anger within the Black activist community post the events of the George Floyd shooting. It wasn't something that was run through a PR firm and focus group tested, it was very much a primal scream of "fuck the system and burn it to the ground" against the establishment in its entirety.

Obviously, it became problematic once it was assimilated by the very machine it was raging against, but it was never meant to be palatable to the mainstream or politically correct.

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by TimTheTinker on Thursday January 20, 2022 @04:06PM (#30015012)
I think you've articulated what the problems are -- that people are speaking out of anger, not carefully and thoughtfully.

Classical activists like Rosa Parks, MLK, and Frederick Douglass were careful, articulate, and thoughtful -- and they had far more of a positive influence because of it.

That's not to say that we should close our ears to people's political expressions, but advocating untenable policy never achieves much good, no matter how much feeling is behind it. We have to move beyond the primal screams and feelings toward thoughtful, articulate, actionable policy that makes good sense and has a net effect of building up society into something good instead of merely tearing it down. It's much harder and more important to build well than to tear down.

This is where good education becomes an absolute necessity. Instead of lowering standards and making school easier, we should focus on making it more accessible while keeping standards high. We need articulate, thoughtful, well-read people if we are to achieve a better society; I'm not talking about STEM -- while it's important, STEM helps people do, not think. How many of these modern activists have read Milton, Locke, Hegel, Descartes, or Aristotle?

So I see these problems (people talking about "tearing it all down") as primarily a symptom of a lack of good education.

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by alphabettsy on Thursday January 20, 2022 @05:13PM (#30015911)
> Classical activists like Rosa Parks, MLK, and Frederick Douglass were careful, articulate, and thoughtful -- and they had far more of a positive influence because of it.

If we’re being honest about history it’s because these are the people that some choose to celebrate and elevate. They are certainly worthy of praise and remembrance, but especially with regards to the civil rights movement it was not all of even mostly pretty. Even then some people choose to ignore words from the “articulate” people mentioned that make them feel uncomfortable.

I think it’s pretty rich to deny good education and then complain when the neglected don’t speak in the preferred manner. There are plenty of educated and articulate people who have been making the same point for years and nobody listened.

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by TimTheTinker on Thursday January 20, 2022 @06:34PM (#30016998)
> Even then some people choose to ignore words from the “articulate” people mentioned that make them feel uncomfortable.

If you're making good points that contradict what people believe, they'll ridicule or at least ignore you -- that's par for the course. We celebrate people like this because they persevered in doing good in the face of intense opposition.

> I think it’s pretty rich to deny good education and then complain when the neglected don’t speak in the preferred manner.

I'm not sure what your point is. I am promoting good education - I think the system as-is has to be reformed. People need good education, especially people trying to promote societal reform.

> There are plenty of educated and articulate people who have been making the same point for years and nobody listened.

For people who are promoting good causes, let's support them and encourage them to persevere despite how difficult it is to continue being ignored and/or persecuted. The truth will prevail in the end: "For nothing is secret that will not be revealed, nor anything hidden that will not be known and come to light." (Luke 8:17)

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by PoignardAzur on Saturday January 22, 2022 @06:40AM (#30035833)
> If you're making good points that contradict what people believe, they'll ridicule or at least ignore you -- that's par for the course.

I think GP is saying people still ignore the point of those very people they're praising.

In particular, Republicans (and politicians in general) love quoting MLK, but weirdly, they never seem to remember the "white moderate" quote:

> I have almost reached the regrettable conclusion that the Negro’s great stumbling block in his stride toward freedom is not the White Citizen’s Counciler or the Ku Klux Klanner, but the white moderate, who is more devoted to “order” than to justice; who prefers a negative peace which is the absence of tension to a positive peace which is the presence of justice; who constantly says: “I agree with you in the goal you seek, but I cannot agree with your methods of direct action”; who paternalistically believes he can set the timetable for another man’s freedom; who lives by a mythical concept of time and who constantly advises the Negro to wait for a “more convenient season.”

You're making the point that MLK was beloved and effective because he was thoughtful and articulate, but there wasn't a single day in his life that he wasn't disliked by the majority of white americans: https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2022/jan/17/mlk-is...

What made King popular was dying.

So, yes, wagging the finger at people shouting "defund the police!" and pointing to MLK as an alternative is pretty rich.

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by TimTheTinker on Thursday January 27, 2022 @08:59AM (#30100613)
> What made King popular was dying.

That's a rather cynical view on a man whose influence during his life was incalculable.

Do you have any sources for that statement?

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by nanomonkey on Thursday January 20, 2022 @04:02PM (#30014950)
I wish the slogan "demilitarize the police" was used instead. Police should be thought of as peace officers, not a civilian policing militia.
Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by stadium on Thursday January 20, 2022 @03:36PM (#30014507)
When I hear the phrase, to me it's more about shifting resources from punishment based (policing), to community development in historically underserved minority communities. The effects of redlining mean we still have many highly racially segregated cities. It's directly acknowledging and confronting that history, which is uncomfortable for a lot of white people.

One can support both public safety and community development, and it's win-win if helping raise people up out of poverty reduces the need for police presence.

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by autoexec on Thursday January 20, 2022 @05:48PM (#30016439)
> When I hear the phrase, to me it's more about shifting resources from punishment based (policing), to community development

Nothing in the phrase "defund the police" says anything about any of that. It is the goal, but the slogan doesn't reflect that anywhere in any way. When you hear it, you think about the intended meaning, while the vast majority hears only what it actually says which is "remove funding from the police" and no one wants that.

Conservatives are fearful people and those against police reform took the opportunity handed to them and reinforced that very message: "If you let these liberals have their way they will make it impossible for police to protect you by defunding them". It's too bad because lots of people who would support reforms to police want nothing to do with any effort under the "defund the police" banner. No one wants a police force that doesn't have any funds.

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by stadium on Friday January 21, 2022 @11:33AM (#30025876)
> while the vast majority hears only what it actually says which is "remove funding from the police" and no one wants that.

The vast majority of white people? It's okay to be angry about state executions at the hands of police, and about the legacy of slavery. The wording reflects that anger. If it makes white people uncomfortable that's their problem. (This is coming from a white person who does not self-identify as "liberal")

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by BolexNOLA on Thursday January 20, 2022 @03:17PM (#30014161)
>it would get almost everyone on aboard even the police themselves
Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by sschueller on Thursday January 20, 2022 @03:21PM (#30014217)
I think at this point you need a national change and force new regulations down from the top. But the movement has turned into a left vs right issue and there will be no change from this government stalemate.
Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by AyyWS on Thursday January 20, 2022 @04:15PM (#30015131)
It's a bad slogan if it requires a 5 minute explanation when introducing the concept.
Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by KittenInABox on Thursday January 20, 2022 @03:11PM (#30014057)
(Disclaimer: I don't fully agree with the position but I felt it there is context collapse[0] happening that I want to push back against because I think context collapse is deeply poisonous to intelligent conversation.)

My understanding is "defund the police" is actually within the context that efforts to reform policing as an institution in america have broadly failed, so the only solution to try and make less-shitty police is to burn the institution to the ground and rebuild anew. In that context, "defund the police" makes total sense from the perspective of an activist who is agitating for a better system of community safety.

0. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Context_collapse

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by geofft on Thursday January 20, 2022 @03:24PM (#30014287)
The phrase I would use, myself, is "abolish the police". "Defund the police" also adequately captures my view: "reform the police" does not. I do not want "proper reform."

There is clearly a need for some governmental mechanism for public safety: it's also clear that the police, as we know it are the wrong starting point, and if at all the existence of the police prevents crime, it's by coincidence.

(I also have no problem being partisan about my political views. They're political views! If you could get everyone of every political view to agree on something, it's probably ineffective. Standing up for specific strong viewpoints is a good thing.)

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by AussieWog93 on Thursday January 20, 2022 @04:19PM (#30015197)
>Sorry to say but who ever decided that the phrase "defund the police" is good or smart made a huge mistake. Or they may have deliberately picked a phrase that would upset and confuse a large number of people.

I believe it was Black Lives Matter (an organisation whose name is literally a divisive statement) that coined that phrase, or at least popularised it.

To be honest with you, if you look at their actions, I'm not sure if the goal is to actually end police violence/abuse of power. If that did happen, all of these influential activists would suddenly be out of a "job".

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by acid__ on Thursday January 20, 2022 @03:52PM (#30014771)
The phrase is ubiquitous not in spite of its controversial nature, but rather _because of_ it.

https://slatestarcodex.com/2014/12/17/the-toxoplasma-of-rage...

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by helen___keller on Thursday January 20, 2022 @04:14PM (#30015116)
This is definitely one of the less-fun emergent phenomena of the internet and social media.

Personally this is why I believe in building better social media bubbles, as much as most people disagree with the concept of a social media bubble I think it’s the only way to stay sane

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by mschuster91 on Thursday January 20, 2022 @03:11PM (#30014059)
The problem is, "reform" is an extremely vague term that can be stretched from "rebuild completely" to "issue receipts to every subject of a police stop so that PoC can prove discrimination".

"Defund"/"Abolish" are crystal clear in their meaning.

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by sschueller on Thursday January 20, 2022 @03:15PM (#30014125)
But who wants to abolish the police? People these days read only headlines and you can not get people to vote for your movement when the title reads "abolish the police" and a few paragraphs down it says that you aren't for no police but a new police that is better etc.
Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by reducesuffering on Thursday January 20, 2022 @04:11PM (#30015066)
Literally an HN commenter a few comments up: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30014287

and the NYT running pieces like: https://www.nytimes.com/2020/06/12/opinion/sunday/floyd-abol...

People need to stop with this gaslighting "No one ever meant abolish, it was always about lessening funding." It's not true and only hurts your cause when you don't acknowledge there are actual significant views more radical than your leanings.

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by sschueller on Friday January 21, 2022 @02:23AM (#30020286)
OK but you can not remove/abolish something before you show/prove/build an alternative to take it's place.
Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by mschuster91 on Friday January 21, 2022 @03:49AM (#30020885)
Of course you can. With the despicable state some police departments are in, completely disbanding them without replacement would be the better alternative.
Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by zdragnar on Thursday January 20, 2022 @03:44PM (#30014641)
Minneapolis city council members were absolutely on board with abolishing the police department. They tried to get the police department removed entirely from the city charter, replaced with a "safety" department that could optionally hire police staff, if they felt it was necessary.

They have since backed off (and several were voted out of office). They also used "abolish" and "defund" interchangably, because defunding and abolishing the police department was the goal.

Edit: I also just noticed several comments in this thread explicitely calling for abolishing as the commenters believe reform is impossible.

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by myself248 on Thursday January 20, 2022 @03:43PM (#30014614)
I've long suspected that the "defund" moniker was maliciously attached by the other side, as a way of shaping the narrative. "Rebuild" or "reform" would sound entirely too reasonable. If you just repeat the inflammatory term loud enough and often enough, it becomes the de facto name for something even if it's almost entirely wrong. And then you spend the rest of your career tearing down the strawman that you built. It's very profitable.
Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by labster on Thursday January 20, 2022 @04:05PM (#30015006)
The thing is, for most police reform activists, defunding the police is the key method by which reform takes place. I agree it’s bad branding, but it’s pretty obvious we won’t see substantial police reform unless we defund them. More police is not always the answer to more crime, sometimes it makes more sense to fund other civil services instead.
Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by dragonwriter on Thursday January 20, 2022 @04:09PM (#30015043)
> The thing is, for most police reform activists, defunding the police is the key method by which reform takes place

“Defund” advocates distinguish themselves from “reform” advocates because they see the police reform movement as having made the problem worse by sucking money out of other local services into police budgets in the name of supporting reforms (leading to police role expansion as there are fewer other tools to handle local issues.)

They literally see “police reform” as a major source of current problems, not the solution.

(They can accurately be described as local government reform activists, but the central specific reform they support is reducing the resources and role of the local centralized paramilitary law enforcement entities, and distributing both resources and responsibilities elsewhere.)

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by mixedCase on Thursday January 20, 2022 @04:27PM (#30015307)
> sometimes it makes more sense to fund other civil services instead

Such as? The US invests an absurd amount of money into education and a sizable amount on welfare. Both of which also seemingly suffer from efficiency issues.

Reform is really the only option when money stops being efficient. Over time, systems accumulate crusts of leeches who live off the system offering little in return, stealing resources from others who are more honest, by merely knowing what the weaknesses of the system are. It's at that point where reviewing and heavily reforming your rules until these people are screaming bloody murder becomes the only fix.

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by autoexec on Thursday January 20, 2022 @06:10PM (#30016717)
> but it’s pretty obvious we won’t see substantial police reform unless we defund them.

I disagree. While we can't just throw money at a problem and expect it to get better, we're going to have to invest in police far more than we have done to get real change. No one wants to live somewhere where police don't have the funds to do their job correctly. We all just want police to do their jobs correctly. That requires oversight and that requires funding.

We have to buy body cams for every officer and build/maintain the backend systems to support them, we have to pay for better training in deescalation tactics, we have to pay for better tracking of incidents and reporting, we have to pay for new hires to replace problem officers, we have to pay for independent oversight boards and community programs. There is a lot of work to do and all of it is going to require extensive funding.

Accountability is the key to reformation, not defunding. That means removing the police's ability to police themselves (something they've failed at) and having independent review boards handle minor issues while district attorneys and judges throw police behind bars for major ones. Changes are needed throughout the justice system to make this happen.

You have to invest in something to repair it, not starve it. Some reforms, like investing in mental health services, restricting civil asset forfeiture, and demilitarization will mean that some departments can get by with fewer officers and might shrink their budgets, but I suspect we'll just be spending much of what we save on oversight and training.

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by throwawayboise on Thursday January 20, 2022 @03:49PM (#30014726)
No, "defund the police" was the literal phrase used by activist proponents. It was not a perjorative used to describe the effort by "the other side".
Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by will4274 on Thursday January 20, 2022 @04:11PM (#30015070)
The phrase I would have used is "pass the Obama police reforms." "Reform the police" is perhaps too vague - reform means different things to different people and status quo keepers are often celebrated as "reformers". On the other hand, Obama wrote a list of seven explicit reforms that police departments should make. They really aren't that controversial. And, Obama was going through a popularity surge (as Trump was going through an unpopularity surge).

I think such a slogan would have captured a solid 60-70% of the electorate, which the current "defund" rhetoric hovers around the high 30s.

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by yeetaccount4 on Thursday January 20, 2022 @03:16PM (#30014145)
Saying something measured and reasonable doesn’t get anyone talking at all. Creating a contentious debate gets you press.

In reality, the single issue should have been around qualified immunity. Get rid of that and the ducks will fall into line.

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by tehwebguy on Thursday January 20, 2022 @03:37PM (#30014525)
There are essentially 3 ways to get rid of qualified immunity:

1. constitutional amendment (3/4 of the states)

2. supreme court entirely throws it out (5 supreme court justices)

3. prosecutors (DAs, AGs & US Attorneys) chip away at it bit by bit

When a case comes before the supreme court they can essentially create a new set of circumstances that will no longer be qualified going forward. The problem with even making slow, incremental progress is that most prosecutors just don't seem to ever prosecute cops.

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by thereddaikon on Thursday January 20, 2022 @04:28PM (#30015317)
The problem is that you cannot expect an organization to effectively police itself. That's just a simple fact of life. Organizations will protect their own and refuse to admit wrongdoing until they are forced to by outside means. This is human nature. Prosecutors can't prosecute cops because they are part of the same system. The only way you hold the justice system accountable for miscarriage of justice is to have a completely separate body act as the check.

Might as well extend that to the other branches as well. Create a 4th branch of government who's only purpose and power is to jail members of the other branches who break the law since they can't be expected to police themselves and power corrupts all.

Kind of like how members of the military are subject to UCMJ courts. Civilian members of government should be subject to a court as well.

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by mlyle on Thursday January 20, 2022 @04:48PM (#30015592)
States can choose to make their personnel subject to lawsuits in defined circumstances.

Colorado, Connecticut, and New Mexico have done it --- e.g. https://lawandcrime.com/live-trials/live-trials-current/geor...

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by cuteboy19 on Thursday January 20, 2022 @03:22PM (#30014253)
Wouldn't this result in increased polarization? For one side it would have the literal meaning and for the other it would have the sanewashed figurative meaning.