News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:German police use coronavirus contact-tracing app to find... by Tainnor on Saturday January 15, 2022 @12:25PM (#29948264)
Unfortunately, people here are misunderstanding this story.

This is not about the official contact-tracing app by the government (the CWA), which by its very nature is decentralised and doesn't allow for that.

This is about the Luca app, a privately developed contact tracing app that is used by some German states and that uses centralised tracking.

This app has absolutely been the focus of criticism inside of Germany, notably including most security experts and the CCC (Germany's largest hackers' association). These criticisms are not dismissed as conspiracy theories by anyone. As a result, some states are also considering pulling out of the deals with Luca.

What is happening here is a discussion about privacy vs. surveillance which is very much in the open, and has very little to do with the official Coronavirus policy of the federal government.

Re:German police use coronavirus contact-tracing app to find... by SpicyLemonZest on Saturday January 15, 2022 @12:34PM (#29948357)
That's definitely valuable context, but it kinda seems like it just shifts the criticism to German state governments. Why are they using this centralized app with privacy issues if there was a perfectly good decentralized one they could have used?
Re:German police use coronavirus contact-tracing app to find... by Tainnor on Saturday January 15, 2022 @12:38PM (#29948380)
Yes it does, and the German state governments have made very questionable decisions here.

I'm arguing against the misguided notion that this is being dismissed as conspiracy theory, which it absolutely is not. Luca has been controversial since the beginning.

The reason why a centralised solution was chosen is quite simple to see, though:

In the centralised system, the health agency knows who to contact when they might have been infected and could in theory force these people to do a test or into quarantine (in practice, they usually don't have enough personnel to do so, though...).

With the decentralised system, every person can get a notification when they could have been exposed. Whether or not they act upon that notification is up to them.

In the end, I don't think the privacy nightmare is worth it (especially given that health departments are understaffed), but I can see how other actors could come to a different conclusion without it having to be a conscious decision to collect a ton of data for other purposes.

Re:German police use coronavirus contact-tracing app to find... by throw827474737 on Saturday January 15, 2022 @12:43PM (#29948415)
The state one was a little late with features (as always, nevertheless, now has all we need) and a famous pop star lobbied around like crazy in talkshows and on politicians (he is financially invested in that stupid luca app).

How it goes as usually.

Just wanted to also leave this here: https://www.ccc.de/en/updates/2021/luca-app-ccc-fordert-bund...

"The Chaos Computer Club (CCC) demands an immediate end to states' alimentation of Smudo's million-dollar tax grab "Luca app."

and also as always, predicted the illegal data grab, but noone ever listens..

Re:German police use coronavirus contact-tracing app to find... by eqvinox on Saturday January 15, 2022 @12:41PM (#29948405)
They basically fell for an opportunist gold digger with a PR department. The driving factor has literally been a rapper, this dude: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smudo

(… I wish I was joking. I'm not.)

[ed.] just to be clear: that absolutely does not excuse the states' decisions. While it might be understandable that someone can drive social and media discourse with some luck and prior experience, it's the states' job to do their due diligence and not base their decisions on empty PR.

Re:German police use coronavirus contact-tracing app to find... by rgrieselhuber on Saturday January 15, 2022 @02:43PM (#29949493)
Yup it’s not really government surveillance if they outsource it to a private company.
Re:German police use coronavirus contact-tracing app to find... by syshum on Saturday January 15, 2022 @07:39PM (#29952063)
umm it still is government surveillance
Re:German police use coronavirus contact-tracing app to find... by rgrieselhuber on Saturday January 15, 2022 @09:16PM (#29952637)
Yes
Re:German police use coronavirus contact-tracing app to find... by mountainriver on Saturday January 15, 2022 @11:51AM (#29947899)
This is the exact thing that people worry about with these kinds of technologies. We are always assured that our data is safe. Then when people forget about it, forces muscle their way into your data.

I guess this is the promise of web3, but it looks like we’re technologically a ways out from that, if ever.

Re:German police use coronavirus contact-tracing app to find... by nexuist on Saturday January 15, 2022 @12:03PM (#29948007)
As someone with a generally favorable view of web3 I don't see how it could help here. All data on the blockchain is public by default and contract tracing on the blockchain would just make it easier, not harder, for bad actors to track you throughout your day.
Re:German police use coronavirus contact-tracing app to find... by vmception on Saturday January 15, 2022 @01:35PM (#29948943)
Depends on the implementation.

Many organizations are just using blockchains for a standardized namespace for pseudonyms and standardized toolkit for non-chain encryption.

So the users in this case would just sign a message for uniqueness, instead of relying on other forms of entropy like their phone or something. They wouldnt be writing anything to a blockchain for tracking and the addresses wouldnt be used by anything else or have funds in them.

There’s no reason the Luca app also couldn't do it this way. But I’m not sure if it would have mattered, or why the health department had identifying data after decrypting anything.

Re:German police use coronavirus contact-tracing app to find... by pjmlp on Saturday January 15, 2022 @12:11PM (#29948092)
Which is why I find the response from some German federal states to cancel their contracts with Luca is a good message that this kind of data leakage shouldn't be tolerated.

Lets see if they wouldn't be getting a GDPR lawsuit as well.

Re:German police use coronavirus contact-tracing app to find... by ksaj on Saturday January 15, 2022 @12:32PM (#29948338)
GDPR is exactly what came to mind when I read this. I don't have a full understanding of GDPR, but I thought this is what it is supposed to guard you from.

Likewise, I haven't read the Terms of Use for installing the app. It very well might have a clause for this use case.

Re:German police use coronavirus contact-tracing app to find... by vmception on Saturday January 15, 2022 @01:36PM (#29948954)
Can sovereigns like the health department be sued under GDPR?
Re:German police use coronavirus contact-tracing app to find... by pjmlp on Saturday January 15, 2022 @03:35PM (#29949979)
I guess the main issue is that no one has ever done it.
Re:German police use coronavirus contact-tracing app to find... by TeeMassive on Saturday January 15, 2022 @12:15PM (#29948146)
Here in Québec we have the most restrictive measures in Canada and probably the Americas. All private assemblies banned, vaccine passport for restaurants and other public spaces (soon to be extended to big surface stores such as Walmart and Costco), booster shots now required for the vaccine passport and finally curfew.

And now I just received a recruitment pamphlet from the government for a "citizen digital identity" which will be used on smart phones.

Am I the only one seeing a pattern here?

Re:German police use coronavirus contact-tracing app to find... by belval on Saturday January 15, 2022 @01:27PM (#29948868)
Digital identity is not about finding you, it's a way to keep you various *.gouv.qc.ca in one place. It's a unification of their login and websites in one entity that should make it easier to interact with the government's services.

You can dislike and oppose the current measures (I'm not a fan either FWIW) but that does not mean that everything they are doing to modernize their terrible IT infra is part of a bigger plan.

Re:German police use coronavirus contact-tracing app to find... by TeeMassive on Saturday January 15, 2022 @07:43PM (#29952093)
> Digital identity is not about finding you, it's a way to keep you various *.gouv.qc.ca in one place. It's a unification of their login and websites in one entity that should make it easier to interact with the government's services.

[CITATION NEEDED] That's the what the job offers talked about and doesn't justify the focus on smart phones. Unless you've read the job offer or, like me, personally know people on the inside, you're just making stuff up.

> You can dislike and oppose the current measures (I'm not a fan either FWIW) but that does not mean that everything they are doing to modernize their terrible IT infra is part of a bigger plan.

A personal identity application, on a cell phone, is already being abused by the government.

Re:German police use coronavirus contact-tracing app to find... by belval on Sunday January 16, 2022 @11:45AM (#29957474)
> [CITATION NEEDED] That's the what the job offers talked about and doesn't justify the focus on smart phones. Unless you've read the job offer or, like me, personally know people on the inside, you're just making stuff up.

Why do I need to provide a citation when your entire comment is itself a conjecture? It's also a request made in bad faith because everything we know about that program is from the government which you clearly don't trust so any citation I offer will be striked down as "from the gov".

> A personal identity application, on a cell phone, is already being abused by the government.

The article is about a centralized system, that was already decried by critics, in Germany. The Quebec "VaxiCode" app is not used for tracking, only to provide an easy way to give proof of vaccination and was not abused in any way. It gives the same information as your drivers' license + your vaccination status with the added benefit of allowing contactless verification through the QR code.

Canada's Covid Alert app is not centralized and does not give any information to the government. The code is even on GitHub.

Re:German police use coronavirus contact-tracing app to find... by alexvoda on Sunday January 16, 2022 @12:22PM (#29957856)
I think i figured out something conspiracy theorists.

It always baffled me that they can be completely wrong, but when something happens that tangential to their position, they feel vindicated and therefore even more rooted in thair beliefs.

I used to believe they lack nuance. I now believe they lack both structure an nuance. Conspiracy theories operate as a word cloud. If a real world event happens to correspond to at least two keywords, bingo, "I told you so", the theory is vindicated.

It is irrelevant that the Luca app was not the official app. It is irrelevant that Canadian IT infra needs simplifications. It is irrelevant that when you install an app you see the permissions it needs. It is irrelevant that there are valid reasons to use 2FA for government online resources.

"Police", "covid app" -> it was a way to track and monitor individuals from the start. Covid was the tool to drive acceptance.

"Government", "id app" -> same

Conspiracy theorists really are satisfied with "in the same galactic sector" levels of accuracy.

Re:German police use coronavirus contact-tracing app to find... by TeeMassive on Sunday January 16, 2022 @04:43PM (#29960447)
Well good thing I didn't say most of those things you're accusing me.

> Police", "covid app" -> it was a way to track and monitor individuals from the start. Covid was the tool to drive acceptance.

https://globalnews.ca/news/8503895/watchdog-probing-official...

Re:German police use coronavirus contact-tracing app to find... by TeeMassive on Sunday January 16, 2022 @04:41PM (#29960436)
> Why do I need to provide a citation when your entire comment is itself a conjecture?

I did make an explicit conjecture that was based on hard facts but then you made a statement out of thin air with nothing to back it up.

> It's also a request made in bad faith because everything we know about that program is from the government which you clearly don't trust so any citation I offer will be striked down as "from the gov".

That's not what bad faith is. And then you're making a strawman about trust which I didn't even make or even mentionned.

> The article is about a centralized system, that was already decried by critics, in Germany. The Quebec "VaxiCode" app is not used for tracking, only to provide an easy way to give proof of vaccination and was not abused in any way.

I never mentioned anything about tracking.

> Canada's Covid Alert app is not centralized and does not give any information to the government. The code is even on GitHub.

Our government was just caught collecting "de-identified" location data (which is bullshit given location easily translates into address of residence and work) https://globalnews.ca/news/8503895/watchdog-probing-official... Canada admitted they spied

Re:German police use coronavirus contact-tracing app to find... by belval on Monday January 17, 2022 @03:02PM (#29971096)
> I did make an explicit conjecture that was based on hard facts but then you made a statement out of thin air with nothing to back it up.

"And now I just received a recruitment pamphlet from the government for a "citizen digital identity" which will be used on smart phones. Am I the only one seeing a pattern here?"

This is the conjecture, you assume that "citizen digital identity" is part of a wider trend or pattern and not simply a modernization effort. Your comment was made under a post about government overreach using covid tracking apps.

You can't just say I am building a strawman because you didn't explicitly write "CDI will be used for tracking". It is still very much the implication of your comment.

> I never mentioned anything about tracking.

Idem

> Our government was just caught collecting "de-identified" location data (which is bullshit given location easily translates into address of residence and work) https://globalnews.ca/news/8503895/watchdog-probing-official... Canada admitted they spied

This is so far removed from CDI that I don't understand why you think this is relevant... Yes Canada is also part of the five eyes and violates the rights of its citizens often, that's not what we are discussing at all.

Re:German police use coronavirus contact-tracing app to find... by syshum on Saturday January 15, 2022 @07:41PM (#29952078)
the road to tyranny is paved with convenience and "modernization"
Re:German police use coronavirus contact-tracing app to find... by sfusato on Saturday January 15, 2022 @01:25PM (#29948850)
No, you're not, but the majority doesn't care at this point at all.
Re:German police use coronavirus contact-tracing app to find... by alexvoda on Sunday January 16, 2022 @12:27PM (#29957906)
Yes you are seing a pattern. The same way a neural net will classify a sofa as a leopard. It also saw a pattern. And in both cases the level of confidence is maximum. But wrong.
Re:German police use coronavirus contact-tracing app to find... by chiefalchemist on Saturday January 15, 2022 @11:19AM (#29947544)
> German police used a tracing app to scout crime witnesses. Some fear that’s fuel for covid conspiracists.

How is it that something happens, actually really happens, and it's still dismissed as fuel for conspiracists?

Re:German police use coronavirus contact-tracing app to find... by YXNjaGVyZWdlbgo on Saturday January 15, 2022 @12:28PM (#29948293)
Because the official app is built so this could never happen there is another commercial app LUCA that got adopted by states and companies because of nepotism and false advertising. The police is using the data of this app not the official one.
Re:German police use coronavirus contact-tracing app to find... by djbebs on Sunday January 16, 2022 @05:02AM (#29954707)
That's not true. There are ways to use the official app to track your past locations, particularly if they have physical access to it.
Re:German police use coronavirus contact-tracing app to find... by alexvoda on Sunday January 16, 2022 @12:35PM (#29957980)
Assuming you are correct that the app keeps a history, your argument is still bullshit. Requiring physical access and unlocking of the phone is not at all comparable to having a server somewhere storing such data.
Re:German police use coronavirus contact-tracing app to find... by kleiba on Saturday January 15, 2022 @12:04PM (#29948019)
"COVID conspiracists" claim that the pandemic is not real but rather a ploy by the government(s) to control the masses. They would see the use of the data from the corona app as evidence for the latter. However, still, the former does not follow.
Re:German police use coronavirus contact-tracing app to find... by bondarchuk on Saturday January 15, 2022 @12:13PM (#29948118)
Nah, that's just the typical "caricature conspiracy theory" that's used to dismiss the actually reasonable theories-of-government-misbehaviour held by the vast majority of people who have such beliefs.
Re:German police use coronavirus contact-tracing app to find... by syshum on Saturday January 15, 2022 @12:22PM (#29948229)
While I am sure those people do exist, just like extreme claims of all manner and stripe exist, to dismiss everyone labeled as a covid conspiracist as believing that is factually incorrect

Things like Lab Leak, masking, hell at one time people claiming that the covid vaccine would need boosters were labeled "conspiracist" spreading mis information

Pretty much anyone that says anything 1day to 6 weeks before that thing is uttered by Dr Fauci is labeled as "conspiracist" until such time as Dr Fauci has blessed the position as "Science" because he after all he "is the Science"

Re:German police use coronavirus contact-tracing app to find... by kleiba on Saturday January 15, 2022 @02:04PM (#29949175)
This seems all a bit far fetched if you ask me. Do you have any sources to back up your claims?
Re:German police use coronavirus contact-tracing app to find... by chana_masala on Saturday January 15, 2022 @03:02PM (#29949675)
Try reading any newspaper, then read it again a few weeks later. You really have to have been not paying attention for a long time to not have noticed
Re:German police use coronavirus contact-tracing app to find... by kleiba on Saturday January 15, 2022 @05:17PM (#29950939)
Baloney.
Re:German police use coronavirus contact-tracing app to find... by SpicyLemonZest on Saturday January 15, 2022 @12:18PM (#29948183)
At least in the US (relevant because the Washington Post is a US outlet) privacy-related skepticism of contact tracing apps was never seen as a conspiracy theory in the first place. Mainstream organizations expressed significant skepticism and the few contact tracing apps which have gained traction here are built to be structurally incapable of releasing personal information in any circumstances.
Re:German police use coronavirus contact-tracing app to find... by Tainnor on Saturday January 15, 2022 @12:29PM (#29948301)
Yeah, it's the same thing in Germany. The CCC and data protection agencies have raised concerns about the Luca app from day one and were never in danger of being seen as conspiracy theorists.

OP is just strawmanning.

(Moreover, the phrase "could be seen as fuel for conspiracy theorists" doesn't mean that something bad isn't happening, it's usually used as a way of saying "don't do this stupid thing because it encourages people to think we do even stupider things").

Re:German police use coronavirus contact-tracing app to find... by belter on Saturday January 15, 2022 @11:58AM (#29947962)
What is the name for that pattern, where any conspiracy theory, no matter how outlandish, sooner or later always ends up proven as true?
Re:German police use coronavirus contact-tracing app to find... by TeeMassive on Saturday January 15, 2022 @12:06PM (#29948040)
"Alex Jones was right"
Re:German police use coronavirus contact-tracing app to find... by superdisk on Saturday January 15, 2022 @03:33PM (#29949965)
For all sad words of tongue and pen, the saddest are these: Jones was right again.
Re:German police use coronavirus contact-tracing app to find... by detaro on Saturday January 15, 2022 @01:17PM (#29948764)
Luca app was widely criticized from the start for this being possible, so this isn't really an example of this.
Re:German police use coronavirus contact-tracing app to find... by syshum on Saturday January 15, 2022 @12:17PM (#29948169)
Because no matter how many times history repeats itself people dismiss the warnings as "conspiracy" because people want to believe the government is inherently good, or has good intentions, this is a false belief.
Re:German police use coronavirus contact-tracing app to find... by vmception on Saturday January 15, 2022 @01:37PM (#29948965)
Its diplomatic writing.

It is fuel. And it should also be criticized by people not susceptible to theories.

Re:German police use coronavirus contact-tracing app to find... by chana_masala on Saturday January 15, 2022 @11:40AM (#29947781)
Well said.
Re:German police use coronavirus contact-tracing app to find... by vmception on Saturday January 15, 2022 @01:27PM (#29948863)
> “We must not allow faith in digital apps, which are an important tool in the fight against covid-19, to disappear,” Konstantin von Notz, a lawmaker for the German Greens, told the Handelsblatt newspaper.

Too late!

Re:German police use coronavirus contact-tracing app to find... by haspoken on Tuesday January 25, 2022 @05:38AM (#30070338)
Re:German police use coronavirus contact-tracing app to find... by nkmnz on Saturday January 15, 2022 @03:36PM (#29949988)
Mainz - known for Gutenberg, BioNTech and illegally using corona contact-tracing data.
Re:German police use coronavirus contact-tracing app to find... by svensken on Saturday January 15, 2022 @12:16PM (#29948160)
Four Main Roles of Government:

1. Keep a rule of law

2. Maintain a stable & competitive economy

3. Turn taxes into public services (defense, roads, etc)

4. Lie