I'm arguing against the misguided notion that this is being dismissed as conspiracy theory, which it absolutely is not. Luca has been controversial since the beginning.
The reason why a centralised solution was chosen is quite simple to see, though:
In the centralised system, the health agency knows who to contact when they might have been infected and could in theory force these people to do a test or into quarantine (in practice, they usually don't have enough personnel to do so, though...).
With the decentralised system, every person can get a notification when they could have been exposed. Whether or not they act upon that notification is up to them.
In the end, I don't think the privacy nightmare is worth it (especially given that health departments are understaffed), but I can see how other actors could come to a different conclusion without it having to be a conscious decision to collect a ton of data for other purposes.
How it goes as usually.
Just wanted to also leave this here: https://www.ccc.de/en/updates/2021/luca-app-ccc-fordert-bund...
"The Chaos Computer Club (CCC) demands an immediate end to states' alimentation of Smudo's million-dollar tax grab "Luca app."
and also as always, predicted the illegal data grab, but noone ever listens..
(… I wish I was joking. I'm not.)
[ed.] just to be clear: that absolutely does not excuse the states' decisions. While it might be understandable that someone can drive social and media discourse with some luck and prior experience, it's the states' job to do their due diligence and not base their decisions on empty PR.
This is not about the official contact-tracing app by the government (the CWA), which by its very nature is decentralised and doesn't allow for that.
This is about the Luca app, a privately developed contact tracing app that is used by some German states and that uses centralised tracking.
This app has absolutely been the focus of criticism inside of Germany, notably including most security experts and the CCC (Germany's largest hackers' association). These criticisms are not dismissed as conspiracy theories by anyone. As a result, some states are also considering pulling out of the deals with Luca.
What is happening here is a discussion about privacy vs. surveillance which is very much in the open, and has very little to do with the official Coronavirus policy of the federal government.