News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:India's richest man pouring $80B into green energy, inclu... by reacharavindh on Friday January 14, 2022 @08:33AM (#29934235)
Rich men throwing their weight behind renewable power to make money. Good.

Public infra wise, it would be great if the government spends money in several directions

1. Setting up solar farms in the deserts of North west - Gujurat, Rajasthan where the land is obviously not being used for agriculture or industrial buildings. The industrial footprint of Gujurat will no doubt be thankful for the renewable power during the operational hours of the day coinciding with solar power generation.

2. Set up solar panels atop irrigation canals which not only generate power for agriculture, but also reduce fresh water evaporation.

3. Strengthen the power grid in populated areas to handle power generation from roof tops and let people make money by sending solar power into their grid. The Indian entrepreneurial public will find creative ways to generate power and make some money for themselves.

4. Add buffers that can absorb bursts in power production that can be used for later(or would have used peak power unnecessarily). Example - run drinking water pumping and filtration systems, sewage treatment systems, seawater desalination plants etc during peak solar production times of the day.

Easier said than done I know. But that’s what leadership should look like. Not triggering political divisions and trying to exploit emotions to stay in power.

Re:India's richest man pouring $80B into green energy, inclu... by nmridul on Friday January 14, 2022 @12:35PM (#29937384)
Just outlining few of the developments from the various (state /central) governments.

1. Solar plant planned in Desert, https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bhadla_Solar_Park

Mostly organised by https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_Energy_Corporation_of_... and installed by private players.

2. Floating solar power on top of dams. https://www.deccanchronicle.com/nation/in-other-news/300416/...

3. This is also for state of Kerala. grid connected systems are available.

"Consumers have the option of choosing from two models of power generation. In the first model, the energy generated is fed into the grid for 25 years and 10 per cent of the energy is given to the premises owner. In the second model, the energy generated is sold to the consumer at a fixed tariff for 25 years. In both models, the total cost of the installation is borne by KSEB, while the premise owner gives the rooftop for installation. "

https://www.newindianexpress.com/cities/kochi/2020/feb/29/ks...

Re:India's richest man pouring $80B into green energy, inclu... by prashantsengar on Friday January 14, 2022 @09:22AM (#29934710)
Interestingly, current PM said in one of his election speeches in 2014 (when he was the CM of Gujarat) what you mentioned in point 1 (not exactly the same). I don't think there has been any progress there.

Otherwise, a lot of focus has been put by the current government towards renewal energy.

Re:India's richest man pouring $80B into green energy, inclu... by eldaisfish on Friday January 14, 2022 @11:11AM (#29936219)
there's an important element of this that rarely gets mentioned - demand growth in India. At the moment, the per capita electrical energy consumption of India is between 20% - 25% that of China. What this means is that if India is to continue to grow, this energy must come from somewhere. Bear in mind, this is 4x - 5x as much energy as is delivered today to get to where China is today. While more renewable energy is a good thing, the fact is that no gigawatt scale power grid anywhere has managed to do this i.e. meet demand growth solely through renewable energy.

You mention strengthening the power grid - this is one of India's biggest choke points to domestic energy generation. their transmission grid is truly world-class but their distribution grid is regularly on the verge of collapse and power cuts are frequent. Before someone chimes in with "batteries" those are expensive and the Indian government already subsidises fuel - something that already works well. Batteries are not a solution to rickety distribution infrastructure in the developing world.

Re:India's richest man pouring $80B into green energy, inclu... by pwarner on Friday January 14, 2022 @11:47AM (#29936823)
Long term we need a lot more energy globally than we have today. Think like 2x USA per capita total energy consumption, but all as electricity. Take that model global, and we need a lot more electricity.
Re:India's richest man pouring $80B into green energy, inclu... by hazza_n_dazza on Sunday January 16, 2022 @06:58PM (#29961766)
Why? My 7nm CPU consumes heaps less power than my old 28nm CPU. What we need is a shift to fully renewable that dosen't eat the planet on the way.
Re:India's richest man pouring $80B into green energy, inclu... by soperj on Friday January 14, 2022 @11:57AM (#29936925)
Why? Cars? Think about how much less traffic a city like Mumbai would have if it was all electric bikes instead of electric cars.
Re:India's richest man pouring $80B into green energy, inclu... by HWR_14 on Friday January 14, 2022 @11:29AM (#29936526)
> Rich men throwing their weight behind renewable power to make money. Good.

I mean, it's good that he's doing this. Whether one person should have the financial resources to make that decision by himself is a different question.

Re:India's richest man pouring $80B into green energy, inclu... by xibalba on Friday January 14, 2022 @11:53AM (#29936882)
> Whether one person should have the financial resources to make that decision by himself is a different question

This implies 1) a belief that wealth accumulation is zero sum, which is false, and 2) a scary conception of how property rights should work.

Re:India's richest man pouring $80B into green energy, inclu... by aristus on Friday January 14, 2022 @12:00PM (#29936956)
Scary for property owners, for sure. ;) And there's an important difference between wealth generation like organizing some group of people to produce value, and wealth accumulation at three-comma scales, which usually involves screwing over aforesaid people.
Re:India's richest man pouring $80B into green energy, inclu... by dcgudeman on Friday January 14, 2022 @12:08PM (#29937055)
Huh? So if a person generates the wealth in someone else’s name then the organized people are not screwed? How does that make sense?
Re:India's richest man pouring $80B into green energy, inclu... by aristus on Friday January 14, 2022 @12:13PM (#29937104)
Generating wealth is separate from how you divvy up the proceeds after. On that second step is where many people have an issue with how it's done today.

And, not to put too fine a point on it, intentionally confusing one with the other is a basic tactic to defend unfair divvying. "Well, you must hate business, then!"

Re:India's richest man pouring $80B into green energy, inclu... by chii on Saturday January 15, 2022 @05:26AM (#29945312)
What would be a different way of divvying?
Re:India's richest man pouring $80B into green energy, inclu... by aristus on Saturday January 15, 2022 @11:43AM (#29947815)
Whatever the parties (owners, managers, workers) involved collectively agree is fair. Instead of the boss earning five orders of magnitude more than the average employee, why not four? But as it stands today, workers don't even get the chance to ask that question. Any hint of organizing is crushed ruthlessly. And if you argue that Musk/Bezos/etc is essential and the company wouldn't exist without him, well, the same applies to the workers in aggregate. That's why owners are paranoid about collective action.
Re:India's richest man pouring $80B into green energy, inclu... by davidatbu on Saturday January 15, 2022 @11:52AM (#29947911)
I couldn't reply to a deeply nested comment you made in which you suggested that you'd like to see workers with more power to determine wealth distribution (after the creation is done).

Aren't workers free to not take up job offers, or to change jobs (which they have been doing at record levels recently), which, in effect, would mean they are rejecting the employer's proposed wealth distribution scheme?

I think Noam Chomsky would respond to my question with a resounding "no" (haven't read deeply, but I believe he supports "abolishing the Job Contract as it stands today", or something like that). I'm genuinely curious as to what you think about this.

Re:India's richest man pouring $80B into green energy, inclu... by xibalba on Friday January 14, 2022 @01:04PM (#29937811)
> usually involves screwing over aforesaid people.

So take a high profile example, say, Elon Musk: explain to me how he is "screwing over" the "aforesaid people".

Because, from my perspective, he has produced massive wealth for many, many people: retail investors, anyone with a 401k, employees, etc. etc. Not to mention, Tesla is almost single handedly responsible for the widespread adoption of electric vehicles.

Re:India's richest man pouring $80B into green energy, inclu... by aristus on Friday January 14, 2022 @01:11PM (#29937914)
A bonanza, to be sure. But does that justify one guy taking 5 or 6 orders of magnitude more from that bonanza than the average employee? Where you land on that question doesn't matter.

The real problem is that if the employees themselves try to organize and ask that question for reals, they get stomped on hard. That is basically the definition of "screwed over". You are allowed to take what is given, but any questioning of the fairness is met with resistance, up to and including state force.

The actions that result in the harshest punishments are the ones the state/baron/company/etc fear most. Empirically, the thing they fear most is workers organizing to negotiate a better deal. Not to get a better deal, simply to ask whether it's possible. As some people say, hey, they are just asking questions.

Re:India's richest man pouring $80B into green energy, inclu... by esyir on Saturday January 15, 2022 @03:52AM (#29944925)
The workers could happily found a coop that does exactly that. They didn't, he did.

That coops haven't been doing very much makes me inclined to believe that there's something fundamentally wrong with them, either in incentives or organizational cruft.

Re:India's richest man pouring $80B into green energy, inclu... by ngcc_hk on Friday January 14, 2022 @02:02PM (#29938680)
Should be 100x if not 1000x. That is why individual matters. Some are better than the others. As long as he does not use power to get to that. Not be a communist party member. Or Labour Party,say, to get $ from communist spy etc. just fight the idea.

It is not communism.

He should distribute and be taxed no doubt. But I do not want a world of equals. Sone basic income for all yes. But all equal. No. Not even if forced 5-6 times unequal.

One Steve …

One E…

Re:India's richest man pouring $80B into green energy, inclu... by aristus on Friday January 14, 2022 @02:15PM (#29938951)
Ok, so your limit is 1,000X. Fine, whatever. Let's take it as read that that is fair. But he is getting 100,000X or more. And worse, any hint of worker organization to maybe kinda sort of ask whether that's fair gets crushed.
Re:India's richest man pouring $80B into green energy, inclu... by smt88 on Friday January 14, 2022 @11:57AM (#29936919)
> a scary conception of how property rights should work

I didn't interpret it to have anything to do with changing property rights. We just shouldn't have a single, unelected person who has the power to make decisions at the level of a major nation-state.

Regardless of the reasons it happens, no individual should accumulate that much power. If that means we need to reduce the amount of power someone has based on the amount of property they have, fine. There are many solutions to it. It's still a problem though.

Re:India's richest man pouring $80B into green energy, inclu... by xibalba on Friday January 14, 2022 @01:06PM (#29937845)
The implication is that your property (aka your wealth, in whatever asset form it lives) is not yours to dispose of as you choose. Rather, the GP thinks it should either be seized or managed someone else (which is really just seizure under a nicer name).
Re:India's richest man pouring $80B into green energy, inclu... by dwaltrip on Saturday January 15, 2022 @04:56AM (#29945201)
You can’t become a billionaire living on a desert island by yourself. You need a high-functioning civilization for innovation and wealth creation. Those who contribute to wealth creation owe something to the civilization that enabled them to do so. We can debate exactly what they owe, but it is clear they owe something.
Re:India's richest man pouring $80B into green energy, inclu... by HWR_14 on Friday January 14, 2022 @03:21PM (#29939853)
> The implication is that your property (aka your wealth, in whatever asset form it lives) is not yours to dispose of as you choose.

That's a bad interpretation. I said is no one should be allowed to accumulate that much wealth.

Re:India's richest man pouring $80B into green energy, inclu... by spoonjim on Friday January 14, 2022 @12:16PM (#29937142)
Why does “elected” make it better? If you had a problem you needed solving would you rather have Elon Musk on the case, or any of the last 4 American presidents?
Re:India's richest man pouring $80B into green energy, inclu... by smt88 on Friday January 14, 2022 @01:44PM (#29938375)
I would vastly prefer one of the last four people who received a majority vote (Biden, Clinton, Obama, Bush) over Elon Musk.

Elon Musk is a childish narcissist whose chief skills are being rich, ignoring laws, and promoting himself. I would leave the US permanently if he ran it.

Re:India's richest man pouring $80B into green energy, inclu... by dragonwriter on Friday January 14, 2022 @12:52PM (#29937623)
> If you had a problem you needed solving would you rather have Elon Musk on the case, or any of the last 4 American presidents

I mean, it depends on the problem and alignment of interests, but if I had to make a blind choice knowing only that it was a public policy problem then any of the last 4 American Presidents (though Trump is a close call), any of their major party opponents, any of the top 3 primary opponents to any of them in the season in which they were nominated. Also, any of the members of the US Senate, and any but about dozen members of the US House of Representatives, and any of the 50 US Governors, any of the chief executives of US Territories, and most mayors of major American cities.

Re:India's richest man pouring $80B into green energy, inclu... by HWR_14 on Friday January 14, 2022 @12:40PM (#29937438)
Wait, is this a real question? With one exception, I would prefer to have any of the last four US presidents or their major party opponents solve problems instead of Elon Musk.
Re:India's richest man pouring $80B into green energy, inclu... by surfmike on Friday January 14, 2022 @11:32AM (#29936580)
All I can say is I’m thankful for Elon Musk. The electric car revolution would not have happened without him.
Re:India's richest man pouring $80B into green energy, inclu... by smt88 on Friday January 14, 2022 @11:58AM (#29936934)
Nissan was outselling Tesla in the electric car market until pretty recently. It was already happening. Tesla actually released an affordable electric car quite a while after other companies like Nissan, GM, and Chevy. I would credit the "revolution" to tax credits and affordable cars, not to Tesla.
Re:India's richest man pouring $80B into green energy, inclu... by Bayart on Friday January 14, 2022 @11:37AM (#29936675)
That's patently false. Musk can have credit for accelerating the transition.
Re:India's richest man pouring $80B into green energy, inclu... by marcosdumay on Friday January 14, 2022 @11:59AM (#29936941)
Every car manufacturer was fighting it for decades. They did things like lobbying against electric cars, and pushing vaporware to stop change every time. When they gave-up to demand and created some electric car, they would always make it flawed in every possible way so it doesn't compete with the money-makers of the day.

Car manufacturing is a highly oligopolistic market, with almost impossible barriers to entry. If somebody irrational enough to push it didn't appear, those manufacturers would have their way for as long as they wanted.

Re:India's richest man pouring $80B into green energy, inclu... by kshacker on Friday January 14, 2022 @11:42AM (#29936739)
Sometimes revolution == acceleration

For example if French just guillitoned one bad guy per year, it probably would not be called French Revolution

Re:India's richest man pouring $80B into green energy, inclu... by beebmam on Friday January 14, 2022 @11:50AM (#29936848)
Didn't he buy Tesla?
Re:India's richest man pouring $80B into green energy, inclu... by darknavi on Friday January 14, 2022 @11:54AM (#29936892)
Yes.

Not to praise him too much but the Tesla he bought and the Tesla that exists today are 99.9% different. You have to have some major chops to take a small start up poking around with the Tesla Roadster concept and make it to factories on three continents producing 1,000,000 cars a year.

I think Musk is a huge ass but also that Tesla really proved that EVs work and mainstream* people want them.

Re:India's richest man pouring $80B into green energy, inclu... by xibalba on Friday January 14, 2022 @11:55AM (#29936907)
No.

He was Tesla's primary funder at founding and then stepped into the CEO role when he determined the founder wasn't getting it done. 99% of the amazing engineering, design, and, most importantly, sales, occurred after Elon took over as CEO.

Re:India's richest man pouring $80B into green energy, inclu... by stayfrosty420 on Friday January 14, 2022 @12:08PM (#29937048)
green != renewable
[dead]
Re:India's richest man pouring $80B into green energy, inclu... by givemeethekeys on Friday January 14, 2022 @01:38PM (#29938283)
I think your interpretation of what he said is out of line. Certain efforts take a lot of capital. There's no "waiting" - that's just the reality of the situation.