I eventually borrowed a friend's phone. It proceeded to stonewall me and insist I was not a real person, again with no visible error message or explanation apart from a strange oscillating blue 3D head... Kafkaesque doesn't begin to describe it.
It's indeed one of the weirdest modern tech phenomena: you are blocked/flagged/shadowbanned/what have you by an inscrutable AI and given no reason or explanation, just a blank "you have been banned".
The other option was to go in person to the local social security office, but at the time it was completely closed due to COVID.
Always seemed a bit odd to me, because I would have thought that even if the government didn't trust its own departments to validate government-issued documents securely (fair enough, actually, they'd probably leave it on a train), all they had to do is provide their own separate, secure, service. They say the government won't know who you're validating with, but why is that an issue anyway. At some point you have to trust the government if you're verifying your identity with their own documents in order to access government services.
Though I guess it's probably just because when they eventually do get hacked they can just blame the provider and ditch them publicly rather than have another IT disaster in the papers with their name on it.
It was pushed agressively at one point by GDS, but despite what it claims about being easy to use, it provided a poor user experience, with very high failure rates for certain demographics.
Universal login, which was the vision for this product for UK government services, is a seemingly appealing proposition but if a high percentage of people can't use it, it's pretty much doomed.
The various UK government departments adopted it sparingly or developed alternatives, which further undermined it.
1 - https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/introducing-govuk...
People are often missing a lot of inherited context, like what the steps of the process are (for buying, insuring and registering a car), what the terms mean (all the different numbers and IDs).
Then it gets messier. Immigrants have to get everything at once: papers, permits, certificates, IDs, accounts. All of them depend on each other, and most of them take weeks to get. People need an income now. A big part of my work was to disentangle a few catch-22 situations around residence permits, bank accounts, apartments and health insurance.
I've talked to a few employees at the immigration office, and since all of them are native to this country, they seemed surprised that a whole Facebook community was dedicated to navigating their office and its requirements.
The same problems apply to tech, but it's worsened by the fact that the builders are well-paid people in developed Western countries, but the users can be anyone, anywhere.
Here's to hoping that neither you or I ever become that irrelevant, because that doesn't look like a pretty existence to me.
It may be disheartening to hear, but this is by design. A (Western) government cannot get away with entirely not providing or dismantling basic elements of a social safety net (unemployment insurance, healthcare insurance, disability assistance) for publicity reasons... but what perfectly works is to make the system as complex and hoop-jumping-dependent as possible to reduce the number of claims:
- requiring modern devices (or not making sure that older devices work too, like you witnessed) is a major hurdle many people who are too poor and under-served by libraries or other public Internet access
- requiring in-person presence with short opening hours during weekdays discriminate against people who have to take care of sick relatives/children, have to work two or more jobs or have certain mental health issues that make following up with appointments very difficult (e.g. some of the strains of autism)
- requiring specific forms of ID or other paper documents (e.g. birth certificates) can be almost impossible (or, very expensive) to solve for people who have lost their belongings/are homeless
- requiring proof of residence is an automatic exclusion of the homeless
- complex forms with bureaucratic language discriminate against illiterate people, non-English speakers and frankly, most people who don't know or can't afford a lawyer to help them out
- automatically rejecting the first claim and only allowing after an appeal / a lawsuit is commonplace for disability claims, it is very effective in "weeding out" poor and already troubled people
The ones that do not require a lot of bureaucracy are not governments... the void that helps those left behind by governmental bureaucracy is more often than not religiously affiliated: churches, Salvation Army, other charities - but unlike government (which is theoretically bound by constitutions and anti-discrimination laws), they are free to choose whom they help and how much.
And now: good luck if you're a publicly outed LGBT member, a person of color or otherwise marginalized person right in a religious-conservative stronghold. The government won't help you as you can't jump the hoops that were designed to be that way, and the "private sector" won't help you as you are not mainstream conformant. This threat is what makes dysfunctional government bureaucracy so insidious.
I've seen and tried to help people who are navigating these systems, and this describes my observations each time.
I live in Texas fwiw.
This is even more cynical, and just flat out wrong. Just because you have succesfully navigated the system doesn't matter you can hold down a permanent full time job. Also, "so many people abuse the system" is just nonsense. FullFact [0] estimates that £2bn was lost to benefit fraud in the UK, some of which is reclaimed after the fact. This is about 1% of the benefit budget, or 0.01% of the UK's budget, before any of the reclaimed amounts.
[0] https://fullfact.org/online/comparing-benefit-and-tax-fraud/
thou, shifting the "navigation of service meshes" away from buerocatics, law literacy and ppl-skills to proficiency with electronic devices has done little for the kafkaesqueness.
> it often looks like nobody is even trying anymore.
The key thing behind that is diffusion of responsibility: everyone knows that shit is broken beyond belief, but since there are so many different layers of responsibility, politicians (with whom the responsibility should rest!) often are successful in deflecting liability in a lot of different ways. The end result is that nothing changes.
Access to government services should be a right accessible to everyone, not just the select few that can jump through intentional hoops!
Every town I’ve lived in has had at least one well run library if not a network
That being said, the librarian's there are quite helpful to those who need assistance with anything like that - going ao far as to ait with people and help them navigate it.
This labyrinthian effort is basically what being a poor person is like, on a daily basis.
State Departments of Labor have access to extensive consumer data and are unable to utilize it effectively. ID.me shouldn’t exist.
Being a developer, I'm one of the main points of contact in my family whenever a relative can't figure out how to do something software-related, and boy has it been a sobering look into the future.
I recently helped a relative file for unemployment verification through ID.me, which is a popular identity verification platform. My relative, who is not well off financially, had an old phone that didn't play nicely at all with the ID.me verification flow. I spent an hour trying to get my relative signed up and I never could get it to work. The site was barely mobile-friendly, and the photo upload process kept failing, which was a required step for verification.
It was so Orwellian to see this kind of UX on a device that wasn't new (and of course, how is someone on unemployment expected to purchase a new phone?) I truly wonder how many people have starved because they didn't have access to devices that allowed them to collect their unemployment through this platform. It really kept me up that night.