News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google Had Secret Project to ‘Convince’ Employees ‘That U... by yupper32 on Monday January 10, 2022 @12:00PM (#29877784)
A lot of people seem confused why a lot of tech people aren't pushing for unions.

For me it's simple: Tech has brought me from near poverty to pretty darn wealthy. Why mess with that?

Could a union help increase wages even more? Maybe. Are we being paid too little compared to our output? Maybe. But at the same time I'm being paid more than I could have possibly imagined before I entered the field.

Re:Google Had Secret Project to ‘Convince’ Employees ‘That U... by kixiQu on Monday January 10, 2022 @12:26PM (#29878211)
If I were in a union, I don't need them to negotiate on pay at all -- I'd want them to negotiate for better transparency about the ways that people get managed out / fired, because at the company where I work, that's all very The Pit And The Pendulum, hanging over your head even if you're doing good work. I'd want them to set some boundaries around oncall shifts, because unfairness or imbalance in those practices is handled entirely through watching for attrition. I'd want them to approximate some portion of the protections that the employees in Europe that I work with have, because clearly that's not so unreasonable that the company would fold, and it's led to some really unfair situations being shoved on non EU teams. I find this kind of thing tiresome to have to get political about and my interests are simple enough to have someone else represent them.
Re:Google Had Secret Project to ‘Convince’ Employees ‘That U... by timmg on Monday January 10, 2022 @12:12PM (#29877971)
I agree. To take it one step further: I have a pretty good relationship with my employer (coincidentally, Google). I don't need or want a third party to get in the middle of it.
Re:Google Had Secret Project to ‘Convince’ Employees ‘That U... by guyzero on Monday January 10, 2022 @12:16PM (#29878030)
Everyone has a good relationship with their employer _until they don't._

And when the relationship goes bad it also becomes very, very one-sided.

Re:Google Had Secret Project to ‘Convince’ Employees ‘That U... by julienb_sea on Monday January 10, 2022 @01:01PM (#29878769)
From what I can tell, a "bad relationship" with employer particularly in competitive tech fields is a direct result of poor performance by the employee, which actually seems reasonable. I don't think it makes sense to introduce bureaucracy with the explicit purpose of covering for poor performance, as that pummels incentives to actually perform well at work. It seems actively unfair to people that are doing their job well if a union is covering for people that aren't.

Of course, a union can offer other benefits, but the downside of devaluing good performance seems strikingly not worthwhile.

Re:Google Had Secret Project to ‘Convince’ Employees ‘That U... by benhurmarcel on Monday January 10, 2022 @05:07PM (#29883440)
Early in my career, HR refused to apply me a significant raise that they had written I would get, because I wasn’t old enough. I had support from my managers, great results and feedbacks. And yet it didn’t matter that it was illegal, illogical, and against their own written words, they still refused. I almost quit over it.

In the end one of the unions helped me, and collaborated with my manager to push HR to give me an even slightly bigger promotion based on my more recent results.

I drastically changed opinion on the unions after that, and have subscribed ever since. They’re not perfect, but HR can be worse, even if you make them money.

I was an engineer in Europe in a Fortune 500 company, for the record.

Re:Google Had Secret Project to ‘Convince’ Employees ‘That U... by guyzero on Monday January 10, 2022 @01:40PM (#29879411)
Apparently if you go on maternity leave or extended sick/disability leave the relationship can also go bad. I think there are a significant number of cases where the relationship goes bad because of reasons other than just straight poor performance. But certainly, sure, straight poor performance is a frequent reason.

I don't think that unions like AWU are particularly concerned with the general performance review process.

Re:Google Had Secret Project to ‘Convince’ Employees ‘That U... by remram on Monday January 10, 2022 @05:56PM (#29884140)
What could you possibly be basing this on, and how are you so sure that this gut feeling is not at all caused by the various campaigns that corporations are provably spending millions of dollars on every year?

Did you really never have a bad manager? Can you truly not believe that bad managers exist? I am really surprised by this comment.

Re:Google Had Secret Project to ‘Convince’ Employees ‘That U... by Crash0v3rid3 on Monday January 10, 2022 @12:15PM (#29878013)
Also, Googles largest union, AWU, does not focus on anything I care about, so why should I pay them dues?
Re:Google Had Secret Project to ‘Convince’ Employees ‘That U... by guyzero on Monday January 10, 2022 @04:48PM (#29883143)
You can be interested in fixing bad behaviour on the part of companies with a lot of power and leverage even if you're not the victim of it.

Sure, you can also do nothing.

Re:Google Had Secret Project to ‘Convince’ Employees ‘That U... by UncleMeat on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @08:40AM (#29891306)
That's fine. Unions are democratically controlled organizations and they won't always align with your personal interests. "This specific union does not align with my priorities, so I'll avoid joining" is not something that will aggravate too many activists. "Unions suck and everybody should resist them in general" is what bothers people.
Re:Google Had Secret Project to ‘Convince’ Employees ‘That U... by cjbgkagh on Monday January 10, 2022 @03:22PM (#29881647)
I think that is intentional
Re:Google Had Secret Project to ‘Convince’ Employees ‘That U... by mrweasel on Monday January 10, 2022 @12:35PM (#29878362)
I’m a member of a union here in Denmark. It’s cheap, it provides some safety, but they do not interfer when I talk salary with my boss. We’re paid well enough that the union don’t have to interven.

The only time I’ve seen my union take action was when a previous employeer started bullshittimg about our pay been “industry leading” while in reality it was just average. Having a union that remaims friendly with the industry but isn’t afraid to callout single companies and use it’s leverage in that industry to make that company behave is extremely powerful.

Re:Google Had Secret Project to ‘Convince’ Employees ‘That U... by tempnow987 on Monday January 10, 2022 @12:22PM (#29878146)
I wish that the US almost had mandated unions for anyone earning < 20/hr or something. All the cleaners, janitors, etc etc.

The focus on the unions on public sector, and the horribly distorted and weird policies that result is a negative.

It's hard to imagine a google being started by a union. Did the NY teachers union try to do a charter school in new york to show they could do as well as others? My impression was this was a flop.

In CA union passed rules banning schools from maintaining reserves. This is while the same schools teach students about having some reserves (critical) as a life skill.

It was AB5 which made life miserable for even folks who WANT to try to do right by staff and moved from a principles based a approach to a carve-out / exemptions approach (ie, forcing gig musicians to become employees for a 20 minute opening gig at a bar, forcing writers to clock in and out when thinking of their writing, and a ton more insanity). The list of careveouts they've had to add is mind boggling and illustrates how backwards they got it. Obama had this right by focusing on wage rates and hourly vs exempt. His approach was easy to implement and would have gotten rid of a ton of the "manager" abuse out there.

The fight against someone groups like success academy (delivering amazing results to historically under served groups) - denying primarily minority parents the kind of choices that the union bosses and chancellors take for granted.

I'm aware of a case where a union guy showed up drunk, drove a forklift and injured another worker and kept their job. I mean, more power to the union but I have friends who've quit working in a union workplace because showing up and working was like being a traitor to the rest of the group there (who had figured out how to create weird work rule conflicts for extra benefits with scheduling craziness etc).

The history of corruption also less than ideal. "The unsealed criminal case describes a prolonged embezzlement scheme starting in involving union money from the Warren-based union local that bankrolled high-end shopping sprees at Louis Vuitton, Balenciaga and Apple, and more union funds spent on child support payments and Greektown Casino gambling binges."

Re:Google Had Secret Project to ‘Convince’ Employees ‘That U... by tyingq on Monday January 10, 2022 @12:06PM (#29877894)
Makes sense. They might be initially more popular in areas where companies tend not to treat their technology folks well. Game development, for example.

Though there are some things that are pretty universal and unions would help with. Things like non-compete agreements, ownership of code written in off work hours, collusion across companies to "not poach", and so on.

I imagine some of that might be a lot worse if the state of California didn't happen to take the positions they do. If Texas were instead the hotbed for tech companies, I think unions might be more popular.

Re:Google Had Secret Project to ‘Convince’ Employees ‘That U... by gundmc on Monday January 10, 2022 @12:17PM (#29878045)
I think this is a big part of it. Unions at FAANG companies these days seem to be more a vehicle for social activists than winning rights for employees. If you don't agree with the goals of the union organizers, there doesn't seem to be a benefit of joining.
Re:Google Had Secret Project to ‘Convince’ Employees ‘That U... by analog31 on Monday January 10, 2022 @12:36PM (#29878367)
But speaking cynically, computer programmers have a lot of the clout that unions enjoy, due to market demand and also creating barriers to entry (programming languages and code bases that are difficult to learn). I refer to it as a guild. Doctors and professors are guilds in a similar fashion.

My dad spent his career at a unionized company. There were both union and salaried workers. He was salaried. He experienced all of the frustrations of working in a union shop, such as practically having to bribe people to do things for him like plugging something into an electrical outlet (required an electrician). At some companies, they literally had to bribe people.

Non-developers experience many of the same frustrations dealing with software. It's no secret why "shadow IT" is such a game changer for people who can engage in it.

My point is that it may be technically true that programmers don't need a union, because they have something that functions like a union.

Re:Google Had Secret Project to ‘Convince’ Employees ‘That U... by pjmlp on Monday January 10, 2022 @04:16PM (#29882656)
We do, when we are lucky to work in countries that see programming that way, not everywhere being a computer guy is that high on the society scale, specially in those where electricity comes and goes.
Re:Google Had Secret Project to ‘Convince’ Employees ‘That U... by busterarm on Monday January 10, 2022 @12:14PM (#29877995)
Indeed.

Also everyone seems to forget that the history of unions in the US is inseparable from mafia racketeering.

To the point that the federal government had to break some of the power of unions in order to break up the effectiveness of mafia racketeering.

Re:Google Had Secret Project to ‘Convince’ Employees ‘That U... by danans on Monday January 10, 2022 @12:51PM (#29878604)
> Also everyone seems to forget that the history of unions in the US is inseparable from mafia racketeering.

This is disingenuous, because the sort of unions that were involved with racketeering were manufacturing unions, specifically the Teamsters, and overlapping a period during the late 19th century where corporations often employed actual violence (with paid armed security squads) against workers who attempted to organize.

Both were wrong to engage in criminal behavior, but the incentives to do so were pretty strong. Furthermore, because the workers for these industries were drawn from largely impoverished communities where low-level organized rackets were practically a necessity for survival, it's not at all surprising that the relationships and methods continued into the workplace.

There is, however, no history of mafia racketeering with teachers or nurses unions, and regardless of one's opinion about tech worker unions, there is no reason to think that they would have any affinity for organized crime outfits.

Re:Google Had Secret Project to ‘Convince’ Employees ‘That U... by busterarm on Monday January 10, 2022 @01:34PM (#29879299)
The American Mafia ran it's biggest and most profitable racket, concrete for construction in NYC, aka the Concrete Club, from 1977 to 1985...long after the period you're talking about.

You can even read about the corruption and (non-mafia) racketeering involved in NYC's lifeguard union, which continues literally to this very day.

In most major cities, the mafia controlled a majority of the unions and used them to effectively provide mafia made men and associates with no-show jobs to provide non-earners in their organization with a paycheck -- on top of all of that they would find ways to skim a few percent off any labor being done.

It's also easy for you to bring up teachers and nurses' unions not being mafia controlled -- jobs predominantly staffed with women. The American mafia literally cannot have women members per its own rules, so of course they couldn't influence those unions.

If you do your research though, you'll see that the Russian mafia is heavily skimming from medical services through control of the nurses' union in Germany. There is no reason they couldn't replicate that here.

Re:Google Had Secret Project to ‘Convince’ Employees ‘That U... by danans on Monday January 10, 2022 @04:25PM (#29882803)
> It's also easy for you to bring up teachers and nurses' unions not being mafia controlled -- jobs predominantly staffed with women. The American mafia literally cannot have women members per its own rules, so of course they couldn't influence those unions.

How about the Aerospace Engineer's union, then: https://www.speea.org/ Pretty sure it's predominately male.

> If you do your research though, you'll see that the Russian mafia is heavily skimming from medical services through control of the nurses' union in Germany. There is no reason they couldn't replicate that here.

Organized crime could get entrenched in any industry given enough incentives and lack of rule of law, and just as much: lack of protection by the law for regular people. I could just as easily say the mafia could start heavily skimming the bagel business.

If you have any evidence that teachers and nurses unions are any more likely to fall into that, or that current manufacturing or professional unions are beholden to organized crime, present it. Otherwise it's just an attempt to smear all industries' organized labor with the past of a very specific sector.

Re:Google Had Secret Project to ‘Convince’ Employees ‘That U... by busterarm on Monday January 10, 2022 @05:08PM (#29883451)
> How about the Aerospace Engineer's union, then: https://www.speea.org/ Pretty sure it's predominately male.

And up until a decade or two ago had maybe a single-digit number of possible employers you could be working for. Also fucking goombahs don't have engineering degrees. Again, you're talking about another field the mafia, largely uneducated street people, could never penetrate.

Let's at least start your argument from a place of intellectual honesty.

Re:Google Had Secret Project to ‘Convince’ Employees ‘That U... by danans on Monday January 10, 2022 @05:37PM (#29883868)
> Let's at least start your argument from a place of intellectual honesty.

Your original statement:

> Also everyone seems to forget that the history of unions in the US is inseparable from mafia racketeering.

As we've discussed, major parts of union history has nothing to do with mafia racketeering.

Falsely associating all organized labor with the parts that were involved with organized crime is intellectually dishonest.

Re:Google Had Secret Project to ‘Convince’ Employees ‘That U... by busterarm on Monday January 10, 2022 @08:09PM (#29885704)
Right, and despite all of the decades of evidence of problems with union corruption, the pro-unionists still beat the drum of "more unions. right now. we'll figure out the problems later."

How about no. How about solve the problems that make corruption inevitable and then maybe I'll support your union.

Re:Google Had Secret Project to ‘Convince’ Employees ‘That U... by danans on Monday January 10, 2022 @08:29PM (#29885903)
> How about no. How about solve the problems that make corruption inevitable and then maybe I'll support your union.

All systems that organize and collect power inevitably experience corruption, including corporations, governments, and religious institutions, not just unions.

Even small businesses and sole proprietorships have incentives to engage in corrupt practices like bribery, especially at the local level. Singling out unions for corruption is selective reasoning.

Re:Google Had Secret Project to ‘Convince’ Employees ‘That U... by JAlexoid on Thursday January 13, 2022 @10:38AM (#29921865)
Oh.... I agree! That's why I'm an anarchist and I demand that all government be disbanded immediately, as it's the single most continuously corrupt institution that we experience.

(Unless you're a hypocrite, that will support government... while using the same talking points against something you personally don't like)

Re:Google Had Secret Project to ‘Convince’ Employees ‘That U... by bathtub365 on Monday January 10, 2022 @01:59PM (#29879813)
This is one of the anti-union talking points from documents produced by IRI (the firm Google has hired to fight unionization efforts) in a previous union-busting effort.

> “Talk about any bad experience you or others you know may have had with unions,” the document instructs managers. “Also talk about the union’s past. Tell employees about documented history of Mafia influence and corruption of unions. Tell employees examples where union leaders have embezzled money from their members’ pension and health insurance funds. Tell them about situations where unions have made promises and have not delivered.”

https://yaledailynews.com/blog/2007/03/14/hospital-document-...

Re:Google Had Secret Project to ‘Convince’ Employees ‘That U... by busterarm on Monday January 10, 2022 @03:38PM (#29881976)
Documenting facts does not mean your documentation produced those facts if you're a detractor.

Both in America and in Sicily are a trail of dead bodies from unionists who didn't want to play ball with the mob.

Re:Google Had Secret Project to ‘Convince’ Employees ‘That U... by philwelch on Monday January 10, 2022 @03:33PM (#29881883)
That doesn’t mean it’s wrong.
Re:Google Had Secret Project to ‘Convince’ Employees ‘That U... by remram on Monday January 10, 2022 @06:03PM (#29884257)
That doesn't mean it's right. In this case, it is wrong; collective bargaining goes way back, and while it is true that some unions officers have been crooks (and indeed controlled by Mafia), unions did not come from the Mafia.

It's one of those technically true statements. Like "the history of the web in the US is inseparable from child pornography". Yes, some regulations were put in place because of the existence of child porn, but the implication that the web was created by/for child molesters is wrong.

Re:Google Had Secret Project to ‘Convince’ Employees ‘That U... by busterarm on Monday January 10, 2022 @08:06PM (#29885682)
I never alleged that though. I just said that you can't separate the existence of unions from racketeering.

Union racketeering still goes on today.

Re:Google Had Secret Project to ‘Convince’ Employees ‘That U... by remram on Monday January 10, 2022 @10:26PM (#29887073)
That's only true in the same sense that you "can't separate" the existence of hardware stores from murders.

People still get killed by hammers today.

Re:Google Had Secret Project to ‘Convince’ Employees ‘That U... by gremlinsinc on Monday January 10, 2022 @10:29PM (#29887096)
Can you elaborate how the Pinkerington's opening fire on union strikers, isn't Mafia racketeering and criminal behavior?

Anti-union behavior has been FAR more corrupt than unionizing.

The history bears this out. CEO's and Owners have a lot more to lose, and a lot more to fight with than workers who have nothing and are begging for the scraps they do get.

Re:Google Had Secret Project to ‘Convince’ Employees ‘That U... by busterarm on Wednesday January 12, 2022 @09:15AM (#29906540)
Yes, let's weigh the single incident of the Homestead Strike of 1892 against decades of systemic corruption. That's a fair comparison.
Re:Google Had Secret Project to ‘Convince’ Employees ‘That U... by UncleMeat on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @08:52AM (#29891415)
Yes, organized crime is part of the history of unions. Illegal violence has absolutely been used against scabs.

But we don't hold private corporations to the same standard here. Industrialists cannot be separated from a history of outright murder of labor activists. Rockefeller Jr. had labor activists shot with machine guns. But we don't see many calls to avoid working for any private business because of this connection.

Re:Google Had Secret Project to ‘Convince’ Employees ‘That U... by Kneecaps07 on Monday January 10, 2022 @12:22PM (#29878141)
A union offers other protections. Right now, your employer can (I'm assuming) just fire you for whatever they want. If you have a union and a proper contract, then they need justification and the union will back you up.
Re:Google Had Secret Project to ‘Convince’ Employees ‘That U... by 0xy on Monday January 10, 2022 @04:12PM (#29882579)
Given how teacher's unions regularly protect sexual predators from firing, I'm not sure I want the same institution in tech protecting incompetent, malicious and/or predator co-workers.
Re:Google Had Secret Project to ‘Convince’ Employees ‘That U... by jakelazaroff on Monday January 10, 2022 @04:58PM (#29883305)
I guess since tech companies themselves already protect sexual predators, a union would just be unnecessary overhead in that regard.

(/s, in case it's unclear)

Re:Google Had Secret Project to ‘Convince’ Employees ‘That U... by JAlexoid on Thursday January 13, 2022 @10:42AM (#29921907)
No /s necessary.

From startups to mega corporations - sexual predators and outright rapists are systemically protected. (I am aware of a few "hushed up" incidents personally here in NYC)

Re:Google Had Secret Project to ‘Convince’ Employees ‘That U... by omegaworks on Monday January 10, 2022 @12:12PM (#29877979)
Your talents may be used to make the lives of people that did not have the same opportunity as you more unfair, difficult, surveilled, and dangerous. Whatever it takes to maximize the amount of profit.

A union isn't just about wages, it's also about being able to speak collectively against decisions that commoditize human lives.

Re:Google Had Secret Project to ‘Convince’ Employees ‘That U... by marricks on Monday January 10, 2022 @12:15PM (#29878009)
Yep, tech can pay their employees very very well to ignore moral quandaries. Yet many still do care, goes to show money can’t fully buy people out.
Re:Google Had Secret Project to ‘Convince’ Employees ‘That U... by satsuma on Monday January 10, 2022 @12:52PM (#29878625)
see: meta/facebook having to raise salaries to get interest. there's a morality "tax" you have to pay if your employees are not proud of what your firm does.
Re:Google Had Secret Project to ‘Convince’ Employees ‘That U... by nonameiguess on Monday January 10, 2022 @01:03PM (#29878808)
While I don't think the situations are necessarily completely analogous because the total workforce size is a lot different, I think it's still worth pointing out that this is somewhat analogous in a lot of ways to the situation with pro athletes. They could easily have stayed happy earning many multiples of an American median salary, even though owners were taking an immensely disproportionate share of the profit pie. But, instead, they unionized, and now earn even more multiples of an American median salary.
Re:Google Had Secret Project to ‘Convince’ Employees ‘That U... by binthere on Monday January 10, 2022 @02:06PM (#29879938)
Yes, but you are not the only person working for that company. I for one fight for the right of every employee of the company I work for to be treated fairly and greatly. Just because YOU have a good relationship with your company (or more so with your manager) doesn't mean everyone is on equal foot. I feel extremely uncomfortable when my coworkers are crying for help and all I show is indifference.
Re:Google Had Secret Project to ‘Convince’ Employees ‘That U... by saltminer on Monday January 10, 2022 @08:18PM (#29885799)
This is a point I think needs to be shouted from the rooftops. We should always have sympathy for our fellow workers and stand up for each other. Even if you are doing a technically demanding job, you should still look out for those doing janitorial work and other "low skill" tasks you couldn't bear to come into the office without.

Historically, the most successful unions in the southern US were those run by communists, because they didn't exclude people on the basis of their race. They correctly recognized that the liberation of the workers could only happen if everyone was united. It was often a hard sell to the white workers, being paid the same as a black man during Jim Crow, but the results ultimately spoke for themselves.

Unions which were whites-only were far less effective. When the white workers would go on strike, temp agencies would just round up a bunch of black men to break the strike. Turns out being able to see people who look like yourself on a picket line makes you much less likely to cross.

Source: "The Noir Forties" by Richard Lingeman

Re:Google Had Secret Project to ‘Convince’ Employees ‘That U... by btmiller on Monday January 10, 2022 @12:07PM (#29877907)
I tend to agreed because I’m very likely to retire/be financially independent much, much earlier than 65 thanks to my tech career.
Re:Google Had Secret Project to ‘Convince’ Employees ‘That U... by pjmlp on Monday January 10, 2022 @04:14PM (#29882621)
Thing is, in many countries the union is for everyone on the building, and those in the tech floor benefit as everyone else.
Re:Google Had Secret Project to ‘Convince’ Employees ‘That U... by Chris2048 on Monday January 10, 2022 @12:32PM (#29878322)
> Why mess with that?

Because the bubble might burst? corps are constantly trying to lowball devs, but for competitive leverage they might succeed. Unions are a way to build the profession while the going is good and bargaining power on our side - good luck getting that foosball table when there are more devs than jobs.

Re:Google Had Secret Project to ‘Convince’ Employees ‘That U... by amrangaye on Monday January 10, 2022 @06:13PM (#29884423)
Not only that (how tech brought you out of poverty), the calculus is also very different for immigrant workers on immigrant visas. I wish their perspective was more represented in the conversation.