News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:IQ decline and Piaget: Does the rot start at the top? [pdf] by bingohbangoh on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @12:44PM (#29797531)
There was a theory floating about on Twitter about apparent European noble practices regarding child birth.

Basically, nobles that failed out of society for whatever reason (drunkards, second borns, etc.) would intermix with the lower classes. This would propagate out "superior" genes that may have aided increases in intelligence over time.

This is quite controversial but it is thought provoking.

Re:IQ decline and Piaget: Does the rot start at the top? [pdf] by zuminator on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @12:50PM (#29797592)
Why in the world would nobles have superior genes in the first place? Since being noble is merely hereditary by "blood," there's no genetic pressure that would select for intelligence. If anything due to intermarriage they'd be more likely to have birth defects leading to low intelligence, I would imagine.
Re:IQ decline and Piaget: Does the rot start at the top? [pdf] by flenserboy on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @12:59PM (#29797721)
Quick speculation: It could simply come down to being better fed over time. There is evidence of negative multi-generational effects on descendants from malnourishment suffered by progenitors. If nobles had better access to food (which makes sense, given power differences), that could propagate down the generations (and promote increased reproduction) not due to a stronger gene pool, but rather through improved gene expression and general health.
Re:IQ decline and Piaget: Does the rot start at the top? [pdf] by gumby on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @12:52PM (#29797617)
Yes, if they selected for anything at all it would be for a willingness to carry around a long sharp knife and push it into people who don't do what the knife-wielder says.
Re:IQ decline and Piaget: Does the rot start at the top? [pdf] by roywiggins on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @12:54PM (#29797645)
Or, to be fair, the ability to get other people with pointy sticks to do it for you. That's also an important skill for nobles.
Re:IQ decline and Piaget: Does the rot start at the top? [pdf] by mc32 on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @01:11PM (#29797909)
The implication I think is a missing a point. Before the advent of mechanization people were subject to the whims of nature.

When nature ravaged them, they were forced to seek developed resources elsewhere and this’d who had those resources normally would not want to share them with others as all resources were meager and most people lived on the edge of existence where one bad summer meant winter was bare and people starved or died by disease taking advantage of weakened systems.

Thus people had to fight of they’d die themselves. So it wasnt always, let’s make war so we can subjugate more; though that did happen too Vikings. Huns and Ottomans among others.

Of course there were petty rivalries that also just produced unproductive wars.

Re:IQ decline and Piaget: Does the rot start at the top? [pdf] by bencollier49 on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @12:55PM (#29797654)
Let's assume the opposite - that success is not correlated with fitness (intelligence amongst other things). Is that a rational position to take?
Re:IQ decline and Piaget: Does the rot start at the top? [pdf] by woodruffw on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @01:01PM (#29797763)
That's not the opposite; success can be correlated with fitness (i.e., success) in disparate social strata without necessitating the correctness of the strata themselves. The strata themselves can be the product of pressures unrelated to individual fitness, like our individual propensity for selfishness.
Re:IQ decline and Piaget: Does the rot start at the top? [pdf] by femiagbabiaka on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @01:01PM (#29797761)
We're talking royals here, not some entrepreneur. Unless of course what you're suggesting is that royal families gain and maintain power due to intelligence.
Re:IQ decline and Piaget: Does the rot start at the top? [pdf] by actually_a_dog on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @01:14PM (#29797945)
Perhaps not, but the most successful individuals are generally not the most talented. Rather, they tend to be the luckiest. See, e.g. https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/beautiful-minds/the-rol...
Re:IQ decline and Piaget: Does the rot start at the top? [pdf] by zuminator on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @01:37PM (#29798267)
That was certainly the position of the eugenicist monsters of the 20th century, who saw themselves as supremely rational, yet they believed that only by sterilization could they prevent the "marching morons" of the lower classes from overwhelming the elite with their sheer fecundity.

On a less controversial note, I'm thinking of lions, believed by some to be the smartest of all cats [0], yet in terms of population and habitat spread much less successful than the lowly housecat.

[0] https://www.pbs.org/wnet/nature/super-cats-a-nature-miniseri...

Re:IQ decline and Piaget: Does the rot start at the top? [pdf] by TheOtherHobbes on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @01:20PM (#29798023)
Depending how you define success, absolutely.

The worst thing about pseudo-Darwinism is the fact that so few people really understand that "success" just means reproductive success. It has absolutely no moral or ethical dimension, and is partly circular.

Averagely intelligent sociopaths who are charming and pathologically unfaithful can generate a large number of kids. So - in historical times - could travelling bandits who were also rapists. That's what Darwinian success looks like.

Meanwhile someone with a PhD who dies childless is a Darwinian failure.

The problem is the usual one - evolution is stupid and selects for shallow local minima.

So the "Darwinian success" continues - until the species as a whole fails.

Re:IQ decline and Piaget: Does the rot start at the top? [pdf] by api on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @01:00PM (#29797747)
Either claim would be wrong if it assumed perfect correlation or lack thereof. Correlations are floats not booleans. There is going to be some correlation, but there are lots and lots of factors like luck, network effects, heritable wealth, etc.
Re:IQ decline and Piaget: Does the rot start at the top? [pdf] by actually_a_dog on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @01:16PM (#29797967)
Right, and it would seem to be silly to argue that all else being equal, someone more intelligent isn't more likely to be successful than someone less intelligent. It's more that in the real world, all else rarely is equal.
Re:IQ decline and Piaget: Does the rot start at the top? [pdf] by stonogo on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @01:02PM (#29797777)
Yes. Being second-born is not a heritable trait.
Re:IQ decline and Piaget: Does the rot start at the top? [pdf] by jimbob45 on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @01:11PM (#29797890)
Nobles were far more likely to be healthy with better diets and less disease which would certainly be correlated with better offspring outcomes. We can discard better genetics (have fun proving that lol) entirely and still be somewhat on board with this theory.
Re:IQ decline and Piaget: Does the rot start at the top? [pdf] by rowanG077 on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @12:55PM (#29797668)
To become a noble you would generally have to have done something of great note. I'd think someone of higher intelligence would have a higher likelihood to do that.
Re:IQ decline and Piaget: Does the rot start at the top? [pdf] by rendall on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @01:14PM (#29797944)
> To become a noble you would generally have to have done something of great note

This might be arguably true for the 1st generation, the one who becomes a noble. Maybe this noble marries another 1st or 2nd generation noble and they have children who are also pretty great. But regression to the mean indicates that, at best, future generations will inevitably be average, and half will be below average. Especially, and this cannot be over emphasized, when they interbreed.

Add into the mix that nobility is conferred via political maneuvering, and it's not guaranteed that even the 1st generation was all that notable

Re:IQ decline and Piaget: Does the rot start at the top? [pdf] by rowanG077 on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @02:33PM (#29799027)
Just to note that regression to the mean doesn't apply here. Nobles back in the day most of the time married only other nobles. A kid of 2 extremes is not a new sample of the same random variable the 1st gen noble was taken from. If that were the case evolution would never work, your more fit specimens would regress to the mean. Which is obviously not the case.

Plus I would also argue that successful political maneuvering is a sign of superior fitness.

Re:IQ decline and Piaget: Does the rot start at the top? [pdf] by rendall on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @03:45PM (#29800205)
> "Just to note that regression to the mean doesn't apply here"

Ok? You didn't really explain why. Surely by extreme you don't mean "being noble". You're asserting that 2 nobles will have a child who is "extremely noble"?

Do you also believe that 2 rich people will have a child who is, genetically, "extremely rich"? That over generations, these descendents will just be inherently richer and richer?

Re:IQ decline and Piaget: Does the rot start at the top? [pdf] by lumost on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @12:59PM (#29797730)
Is there any backing to this? As I recall feudal societies in both Europe and Japan had the origin of "nobility" in land ownership/control. If you could successfully hold a piece of land as your own you were a noble.

You can imagine this as a form of de facto rule.

Re:IQ decline and Piaget: Does the rot start at the top? [pdf] by pbalau on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @01:36PM (#29798251)
Holding into a piece of land is not a given. The fact that one could hold into that could mean that individual was smarter than the individuals that did not.
Re:IQ decline and Piaget: Does the rot start at the top? [pdf] by KittenInABox on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @01:44PM (#29798364)
It's pretty easy to hold onto a piece of land if you're the only one who is well-fed, literate, and capable of hiring and feeding personal guards.
Re:IQ decline and Piaget: Does the rot start at the top? [pdf] by rowanG077 on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @02:24PM (#29798898)
Isn't that the point? A person with superior genes is more likely to have those qualities.
Re:IQ decline and Piaget: Does the rot start at the top? [pdf] by api on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @01:01PM (#29797755)
Your ancestors were probably above average in either intelligence or physical ability. That doesn't mean you are after a century or two of noble inbreeding.
Re:IQ decline and Piaget: Does the rot start at the top? [pdf] by rowanG077 on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @02:27PM (#29798942)
The point is that inbreeding while having some bad outcomes can also have the good outcome of the nobility having higher intelligence. You can't just argue when someone says: "this is A", with: "No this is B". At least put some substance behind it.
Re:IQ decline and Piaget: Does the rot start at the top? [pdf] by TheCoelacanth on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @05:28PM (#29801608)
The only thing of great note most nobles did to become noble is to emerge from the right vagina.
Re:IQ decline and Piaget: Does the rot start at the top? [pdf] by jcadam on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @01:53PM (#29798477)
> If anything due to intermarriage they'd be more likely to have birth defects leading to low intelligence, I would imagine.

It's widely speculated that the demise of the Hapsburg empire was due to centuries of inbreeding eventually producing rather... simple monarchs.

Re:IQ decline and Piaget: Does the rot start at the top? [pdf] by rory on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @12:54PM (#29797638)
If you cast out the "inferior," you don't have to start out superior to end up so.
Re:IQ decline and Piaget: Does the rot start at the top? [pdf] by api on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @12:55PM (#29797657)
Why would you assume nobles have superior genes, especially the ones who "flunked out." If anything the inbreeding practices of the nobility were dysgenic. Unprecedented levels of outbreeding has been suggested as a possible source of IQ increase over the past 100-200 years.

You can argue that today's somewhat-meritocracy is going to sort people by social class in a way that roughly overlaps with IQ if you zoom out very far. I don't see why this would be true at all in an autocratic caste system society.

This sounds like a made up just-so theory that belongs on a neoreactionary Reddit group.

Re:IQ decline and Piaget: Does the rot start at the top? [pdf] by defen on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @01:02PM (#29797768)
You might be conflating nobility with Gregory Clark's thesis in "A Farewell to Alms". There never would have been enough nobles for their failsons to have any kind of measurable genetic impact on the wider society; plus nobles were never really selected for intelligence in the first place - they were the descendants of successful warlords.
Re:IQ decline and Piaget: Does the rot start at the top? [pdf] by slibhb on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @01:22PM (#29798048)
If you believe in general intelligence, successful warlords are more likely to be intelligent.
Re:IQ decline and Piaget: Does the rot start at the top? [pdf] by scarmig on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @01:05PM (#29797801)
Are successful warlords likely comparable in intelligence to landless peasants?
Re:IQ decline and Piaget: Does the rot start at the top? [pdf] by TheOtherHobbes on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @01:22PM (#29798049)
Are VCs likely comparable in intelligence to competent engineers?
Re:IQ decline and Piaget: Does the rot start at the top? [pdf] by PeterisP on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @02:10PM (#29798714)
> There never would have been enough nobles for their failsons to have any kind of measurable genetic impact on the wider society;

I'm not sure if this is true - I seem to recall studies that can clearly see a genetic impact of just a single particular noble (Gengis Khan), so it seems plausible that the genetic impact of nobles would be oversized as high-status males can have many children from the society in which they have violent power, and their children (even if bastards) have less issues with childhood malnutrition and early death.

Re:IQ decline and Piaget: Does the rot start at the top? [pdf] by defen on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @03:34PM (#29800036)
The proposed hypothesis though is that unsuccessful nobles spread their "favorable genes" by descending into the lower classes. To fall that far you'd have to be deeply in debt and not particularly high status.
Re:IQ decline and Piaget: Does the rot start at the top? [pdf] by jcranmer on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @01:21PM (#29798038)
There are a number of literally insane monarchs who didn't "fail out of society." In general, nobility tended to select not for intelligence or strength but political connections.
Re:IQ decline and Piaget: Does the rot start at the top? [pdf] by throwaway5590 on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @01:48PM (#29798416)
I think many people are confused about this post. There is no need to believe that nobles were initially "superior", and that their initial superiority was the reason they became nobles in the first place. The increase in "gene quality" at the top, and its diffusion to the bottom, can be understood as the simple result of Malthusian constraints, and high survival rates for nobles (as compared to the harsh conditions of the lower classes).

Imagine you start a society where nobles have the same "gene quality" as everyone else. Some nobles are pretty smart, others not so much. As nobles would have more children surviving into adulthood (due to better nutrition and living standards) compared to the amount of land/titles they could distribute, some of the children of the nobility would be cast aside. The assumption, and I agree it's an assumption (although a rational one in my opinion), is that the smarter children would tend to inherit, and the less capable children would be dispossessed.

Over time, this constant churn would lead to a concentration of "good genes" among the aristocracy, which would trickle down into the lower classes when every generation some of the nobility lost their position.

I believe that this "trickling down" phenomenon has been proven to have occurred in England during the second millennia by Gregory Clark using census data, although I'll admit I've only heard of his work, not read it.

Re:IQ decline and Piaget: Does the rot start at the top? [pdf] by cmyr on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @12:59PM (#29797726)
Ignoring the other blatant problems with this interpretation (e.g. that social class was highly correlated with fitness) I suspect that the nobility were intermixing their genes quit successfully via coercion & violence.

I am not a geneticist or a historian or even more than barely literate

Re:IQ decline and Piaget: Does the rot start at the top? [pdf] by JasonFruit on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @01:19PM (#29798007)
IANAGOAHOEMTBL
Re:IQ decline and Piaget: Does the rot start at the top? [pdf] by wayoutthere on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @01:11PM (#29797894)
Be wary of any talk of “superior” genes. We have no way to judge one set of genes relative to another even if we did understand genetics a lot better than we do. A genetic trait’s advantage can change depending on environmental factors, so any attempt to do so is effectively retreading debunked eugenic theory (a favorite pastime among some reactionary groups, particularly on social media).
Re:IQ decline and Piaget: Does the rot start at the top? [pdf] by giantg2 on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @01:24PM (#29798090)
This can be true of things like personality traits and beliefs too - useful in one situation but not another. Society still punishes people who don't conform or rewards those who do. I think society will accept, or even push for, some level of genetic discrimination. I believe there was a recent article on HN about fetal genetic defect testing being used to make abortion decisions. The question is where should the line be, as it seems to already exist.
Re:IQ decline and Piaget: Does the rot start at the top? [pdf] by fristechill on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @01:41PM (#29798320)
It's not so much 'superior genes' as an absence of deleterious mutations. The brain requires the cooperation of the greatest number of genes (compared with other organs) in order in the develop in embryo.

Since the industrial revolution infant death has thankfully dropped but it seems likely this improvement has had the side-effect of increasing the number of deleterious mutations and therefore also of decreasing the average IQ in Western populations.

[dead]
Re:IQ decline and Piaget: Does the rot start at the top? [pdf] by dang on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @03:11PM (#29799672)
You can't do this here. Since it's already a pattern, we've banned this account.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:IQ decline and Piaget: Does the rot start at the top? [pdf] by wayoutthere on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @02:21PM (#29798841)
Suggest you read Guns, Germs and Steel if you want a more plausible explanation for that.
Re:IQ decline and Piaget: Does the rot start at the top? [pdf] by sitkack on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @12:55PM (#29797669)
That is plot of Starwars.
Re:IQ decline and Piaget: Does the rot start at the top? [pdf] by cblconfederate on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @12:54PM (#29797644)
Highly doubtful considering their recessive traits. Evidently intelligence doesnt correlate with social dominance , its the same today or in roman times
Re:IQ decline and Piaget: Does the rot start at the top? [pdf] by thatfrenchguy on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @01:10PM (#29797876)
I don't know if you're read a little bit about European aristocracy, but one can easily say they were pretty dumb.