News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by travisd on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @12:39PM (#29727242)
Don’t forget this gem:

> Missing or Kidnapped Children: You may be able to claim a child who was kidnapped by a non-family member. IRS treats a kidnapped child as living with you for more than half of the year if the child lived with you for more than half the part of the year before the date of the kidnapping.

https://www.eitc.irs.gov/other-refundable-credits-toolkit/un...

Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by VWWHFSfQ on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @12:48PM (#29727384)
It seems funny but what else are they supposed to do? Otherwise people would still be claiming dependents on kids gone since the 70s
Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by 650REDHAIR on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @01:00PM (#29727557)
If your kid is kidnapped you should get a break…
Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by vikingerik on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @01:03PM (#29727595)
If you reward something, you get more of it. This creates a black market of arranging kidnappings for the tax break.

The original topic about stolen property is the patch for the same kind of loophole. Without this rule, you could arrange to have something of value stolen in order to avoid a taxable transaction. Imagine your employer giving a bonus by leaving an envelope of cash conspicuously unguarded.

Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by roughly on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @01:53PM (#29728394)
> If you reward something, you get more of it. This creates a black market of arranging kidnappings for the tax break.

This is the kind of unhinged batshit economic thinking that leads to people dying because they can’t afford insulin.

Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by more_corn on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @02:37PM (#29729054)
I understand what you’re saying. I too hate the practice of discarding real solutions because of overblown fears of misuse. But on the other hand, go and look up The Cobra Effect.
Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by roughly on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @05:50PM (#29731170)
> go and look up the Cobra Effect

So, first, the "cobra effect," like most economic proverbs, is apocryphal. It didn't happen. It's a story economists tell their kids to keep them from sharing.

Second, there's a big damn difference between "I'm going to grow a snake because I'm getting paid for it" and "I'm going to get my kids kidnapped so I can collect a tax credit without actually having to pay for the kids." It may not appear that way if one's working model of people is "dispassionate rational actor," but it turns out in the real world most people have some kind of irrational emotional attachment to their kids.

Finally, I'd submit that "Cobra Effect"-type problems arise as a factor of two errors - the first is misunderstanding the cultural group for which you're designing practices, and the second is a weirdly inflexible view of society that accepts someone manipulating the system as just a sort of thing that happens and not an egregious breach of the social contract warranting a response.

Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by manicdee on Thursday December 30, 2021 @08:27AM (#29736530)
There are people who have no attachment to their kids and would happily use them as ammunition in personal conflicts, as cheap labour for their business, or as property to exchange for other goods.

Don’t assume that everyone else subscribes to your morality, ideology or “ethics”. It’s a brutal world out there and some people value power much more than you do.

Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by joshspankit on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @02:08PM (#29728646)
Kind of, yes.

Health care for profit rewards companies who limit supply, increase prices, and set the goal of having long-term “customers” because each of those things brings in more cash.

It’s not economic thinking that’s driving the ship though.

Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by ahzhou on Friday December 31, 2021 @10:41AM (#29748995)
It’s not that crazy. People sometimes sell their baby off to finance gambling debts. Some parents are terrible and we shouldn’t be giving them economic reason to have more children.
Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by Guest42 on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @02:12PM (#29728705)
I wish more data was available for this phenomenon, I estimate the number of deaths would be surprisingly high.
Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by qeternity on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @01:59PM (#29728488)
No, it's not. This is a well studied phenomenon, and completely unrelated to healthcare affordability.
Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by roughly on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @02:04PM (#29728571)
The core argument from economists for things like co-pays and against free healthcare is that absent a cost, people will over-consume health care, which misses the forest for the trees in the same way that the post I was responding does. The notion of humans as primarily rational actors and the conception of policy as needing primarily to guard against exploitation by those actors leads to policies like saying "sorry, as far as the IRS is concerned, those aren't your kids anymore" or "sorry, guess you gotta go without insulin or food," which are frankly fucking monstrous and should be rejected by reasonable people.
Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by dragonwriter on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @02:22PM (#29728849)
> The core argument from economists for things like co-pays and against free healthcare is that absent a cost, people will over-consume health care

People dying because they can't afford insulin are usually not dying because they have insurance where the prescription co-pays for insulin is too high, but because they either are actually uninsured, are effectively uninsured because of a high deductible, or have insurance that works on a coinsurance rather than co-payment model.

And even then that's usually not really the problem, the problem is usually that they can't afford a more basic life necessity (often food or shelter) for themselves or their dependents, and voluntarily forego (or limit use of) insulin to afford the other need. Which is a real problem (and a real public economic policy problem), but usually not fundamentally a healthcare policy problem.

(On the other hand, it's often a problem where moral hazard arguments of the type at issue here contribute to the failure to solve, so the argument about that being the problem may still be correct by a less direct route then seems to have been intended.)

Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by roughly on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @02:27PM (#29728917)
I am not arguing about health care policy, I am arguing about the core economic philosophy that makes "just give them the insulin they need so they don't die" not a tractable proposal in our society.
Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by Sebguer on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @02:07PM (#29728633)
Please show me the studies that suggest people would arrange kidnapping of their children for tax improvement if the IRS hadn't put this in the codes.
Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by motoxpro on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @02:27PM (#29728926)
I think it's similar to people adopting kids for the payment. Nothing to stop these people from then arranging for a "kidknapping" afterward.

Some tangential articles to show that people exploit children for money. https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2021/10/25/how-an-adoptio... https://www.npr.org/2019/10/09/768533784/arizona-official-ar...

Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by darawk on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @02:28PM (#29728938)
Every study ever done on demand curves for literally anything shows that they consistently slope downwards, with the exception of Veblen goods, which kidnapped children most certainly are not.
Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by dragonwriter on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @02:31PM (#29728981)
> Every study ever done on demand curves for literally anything shows that they consistently slope downwards, with the exception of Veblen goods

Since Veblen goods are defined as anything where the demand curve slopes upward, that would only be a result of an empirical study if the study was designed to test, and strong enough to confidently disprove, the existence of goods with a flat demand curve. But it's not meaningful in any case.

> Veblen goods, which kidnapped children most certainly are not.

[citation needed]

Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by darawk on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @02:55PM (#29729227)
> Since Veblen goods are defined as anything where the demand curve slopes upward, that would only be a result of an empirical study if the study was designed to test, and strong enough to confidently disprove, the existence of goods with a flat demand curve. But it's not meaningful in any case.

Look at the other things that are Veblen goods. They are status symbols. Handbags, rare cars, etc. Kidnapped children are clearly not a member of this category.

> [citation needed]

Please. This is a ludicrous demand for rigor, and not how science actually works.

Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by dragonwriter on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @03:01PM (#29729295)
> Look at the other things that are Veblen goods. They are status symbols. Handbags, rare cars, etc. Kidnapped children are clearly not a member of this category.

Captives and slaves, which kidnapped children are the first and often also the second, can be either tools or status symbols (or both simultaneously).

Obviously, flagrantly illegal (and not wink-wink-nudge-nudge tolerated in public) goods tend to only be status symbols in particular criminal subcultures, but those subcultures very much exist.

Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by darawk on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @03:04PM (#29729322)
> Captives and slaves, which kidnapped children are the first and often also the second, can be either tools or status symbols (or both simultaneously).

Yes, that's true. But that's the wrong side of the transaction. This IRS policy is disincentivizing false kidnapping. Not actual kidnapping.

The IRS policy is designed to prevent you from claiming a child as a dependent indefinitely after they have been kidnapped. So, for this to be a Veblen good, it'd have to be a status symbol in your social circle to have had a child kidnapped from you.

Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by zeteo on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @02:02PM (#29728548)
> If you reward something, you get more of it. This creates a black market of arranging kidnappings for the tax break.

There's no reward, you'd be getting the same tax break if the child was not kidnapped. The rule is about how long it takes to lose the tax break in case of kidnapping.

Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by masklinn on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @02:15PM (#29728749)
> There's no reward, you'd be getting the same tax break if the child was not kidnapped.

Except if the kid was not kidnapped, you have to pay for the kid's expenses and welfare.

I expect somebody who wants to keep the tax break without the kid is not too worried about the kid's intrinsic welfare.

Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by isoskeles on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @02:57PM (#29729248)
I agree, but why bother to arrange to have them kidnapped? Surely the risk is much higher than the reward of a tax break. It seems like an inherently stupid idea compared to just abandoning the kid.

Who would even agree to kidnap somebody else’s child for this purpose? I’d suspect the first 9 out of 10 convicted felons would still tell the police your plans. Most people would be too suspicious that you’re trying to entrap them, asking them to kidnap your child.

And what can you offer someone to agree to do this if your own reward is a temporary tax break? At this point, you might as well kidnap your own child.

Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by musingsole on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @01:17PM (#29727783)
You get more of the thing, but you don't necessarily get so much more of it that it outweighs the benefit of having incidentally induced it.

Using a corner case of behavior to justify systemic suppression of otherwise rational behavior just perpetuates the cycle of pain. Welfare royalty exist. But not nearly in numbers high enough to ethically justify hamstringing the system.

Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by arbitrage on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @01:30PM (#29727991)
There is also the question of just how richly "welfare royalty" is actually living it up.

If they exist, it's nowhere near the levels portrayed in popular media.

Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by ineedasername on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @02:17PM (#29728776)
There was one tv opinion commentators who, upon seeing video from inside welfare recipients' home, remarked something along the lines off "They have a refrigerator! If they can afford that, how badly can they have it?"

So, part of the problem is where people choose to draw the line on "royalty". If refrigerator ownership meet your criteria then sure, you're going to see royalty everywhere.

Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by isoskeles on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @03:09PM (#29729375)
I hear people bring up this example to scoff at every now and then, but it’s always some unstated rationale. The progression of technology mostly allows us to live like royalty compared to people 300 years ago, minus the terrible indignity of having to work.

I’ve yet to hear an explicitly stated argument for why I’m supposed to think someone who has access to a refrigerator, internet, food, etc. is impoverished, except for, “Somesuch CEO earns 100000000x more than they do.”

That said, sure, “welfare royalty” seems like a misnomer. I assume they typically live like regular, “middle-class” people without the job part.

Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by ineedasername on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @05:11PM (#29730744)
I'm a little surprised: Do you honestly believe that having a refrigerator, internet, and food makes a person middle class? For refrigerator & food it's hard to have one without the other unless you spend a heck of a lot more money on takeout etc. As for internet, that's pretty much a bare minimum of communicating these days, and in many cases of poverty the way people get their internet is through their cell phones, which absent home internet (which many don't have) is both the gateway to the internet and absolutely necessary to function in today's society.

Maybe we are talking about "welfare" in different ways? In the US, welfare is a constellation of programs, not just one single program that gives $$ each week/month. Everything from subsidized school lunches, medicaid (CHIP for additional care for children), SNAP... your comment about "without the job part" indicates that you might not be aware that a very large number of people are on one or more of these programs and work fulltime+ jobs. Where I live it was a real crisis during COVID school closures because the poorest children had parents with jobs that could not be done remotely and parents could not find or afford alternatives, at the same time that any internet they had was through cell phones (usually the parents phones) so the school district needed to send out wifi hotspots & chromebooks so that students at least had the basic tools to learn... but had to be left alone (if they were old enough) or parents quit their already low-paying jobs to watch over their kids.

None of the above sounds like middle-class without the job part. As you began your comment: I hear people bring up your sort of argument to scoff at the idea that significant % of the population may fall through the cracks or just get left behind. I don't understand the point of view except as lack of direct experience with people living in these not-middle-class positions of poverty on the brink of collapse.

Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by Schroedingersat on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @08:23PM (#29732401)
The impoverishment is in terms of the same things the lower class have always lacked.

A lack of agency and security. Often their situation is such that they cannot change it. For the employed, there is no time or energy to improve life. For the unemployed, employment often has a negative net income (once accounting for transport costs, reduction in benefits and costs they can currently pay with time such as food prep which would have to be paid in money).

There are no spare resources for education or entrepreneurship. No resources for fulfilling hobbies or self development.

Even if you accept the negatives for long term growth, getting an entry level job from that position requires grovelling and outright lying to your 'betters' about how you want to dedicate your life to breaking your back stacking shelves for $8/hr on a split shift 100% availability basis (that doesn't give you enough time to get home in your 3hr 'break') because you love it so much.

Then there's the precarity that poverty brings. Not knowing how you'll afford an emergency, and constantly weighing eating vs. paying the power is mentally draining and incredibly harmful to your mental health. Not conceding to your landlord's insane demands could leave you permanently homeless, and now debt collectors are calling you for a bill you have receipts of paying every 3 hours.

A car is unaffordable, public transit is underfunded, demeaning and unreliable, and pedestrian or cycling infrastructure is unaffordable.

No level of government will listen to your concerns, in fact their decisions are actually anticorrelated with public support.

On top of that you are constantly told that everything wrong is your fault, and you just have to drink fewer lattes and vote with your wallet more.

Public space is stolen and turned into space for cars or privately owned malls.

Anything your community does build for mutual benefit is torn down and rebuild to be extractive.

This is not the life of nobility. It's basically just the same as a peasant with easier access to propaganda, protein, calories, and mentally destructive dopamine buttons.

In many ways it is worse because it is so isolating, and the source of the harm is so nebulous.

Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by cycomanic on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @02:32PM (#29728993)
Yes this is one of the crazy things about politics and populism. If we compare the efforts to combat welfare fraud to the ones to combat tax evasion considering the losses to the state it's completely disproportionate and from an economic standpoint doesn't make sense. From a political standpoint however it likely does, many people feel much more strongly about welfare fraud than tax evasion.
Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by plafl on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @03:55PM (#29729907)
> many people feel much more strongly about welfare fraud than tax evasion.

Many people are way more against crimes which offer them little returns than against crimes that may happen in their social circles.

Edit: I want to clarify that it's not some kind of conspiracy, it's that we simply are more empathic with people in a similar position to us

Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by bryanrasmussen on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @02:19PM (#29728800)
>If you reward something, you get more of it. This creates a black market of arranging kidnappings for the tax break.

you already have a tax break for the kid, it's a dependent, all that was being said if your kid gets kidnapped you can still claim it as a dependent for half a year and the commenter thought it would be reasonable to allow longer.

Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by bryanrasmussen on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @05:05PM (#29730675)
In fact to expand the tax dependency of a kidnapping - you should be allowed to write off whatever moneys are spent on trying to get the kid back - although for all I know that is already deductible in some systems.
Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by giantg2 on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @02:30PM (#29728958)
It doesn't really reward it. You're still claiming the dependent as you did the year prior to them being kidnapped. It's basically status quo.
Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by dmingod666 on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @02:27PM (#29728925)
I mean "I'll have that large police investigation to go with my taxes" doesn't sound like a sane strategy..
Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by thescriptkiddie on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @02:00PM (#29728514)
Economists love to hear an apocryphal story about a bounty on dead cobras backfiring, then generalize it until they do incalculable damage to society.
Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by VWWHFSfQ on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @01:20PM (#29727824)
The tax code doesn't deal with emotions
Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by roughly on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @01:55PM (#29728434)
Of course it does. The tax code is a law written by humans, which means it’s a set of emotional value judgements written in dry enough language that we can pretend what you said is true.
Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by VWWHFSfQ on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @02:03PM (#29728552)
The tax code itself does not deal with emotions. There's no code with a provision that says you can ignore it if you feel sad about something.

The people applying the tax code can make exceptions at their discretion. It's a difference.

Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by roughly on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @02:08PM (#29728639)
It's not, though. The code was written with a certain emotional state. If Senator Jones of the Great State of Wherever's kids were kidnapped, we'd have the Jones amendment to the tax code saying that kids were dependents until they clearly weren't, because we were all sad for Senator Jones at the time we wrote the code. Ignoring that fact means that we treat the law as some piece of inviolable logic, as opposed to something we thought made sense at the time, and prevents us from seeing it as something we both can and ought to change should it not deliver the results we want.
Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by voakbasda on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @02:23PM (#29728859)
If ever you wanted to see a prime example of emotionally derived laws, look at how fast the Patriot Act was passed after 9/11. That body of legislation was sitting in a desk, waiting for the day where it could exploit our emotions about the situation. And their plan worked perfectly.
Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by simplestats on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @03:06PM (#29729339)
There's also a distinction between rules that were created by the legislature, possibly motivated by emotion as you describe, and rules resulting from interpretations by courts. While the former has no limits on their reasoning process, the latter is supposed to stick to the intentions of the law, which would preclude emotional decisions.

Presumably the rule is there to subsidize child-rearing. When the child is gone (kidnapping, death, ascention to heaven, etc), the law would logically not apply any more, so there will be details about where the cuttoff falls. If people wanted want to give cash to unfortunate parents, judges interpreting the laws should tell you to pass another law for it.

Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by Hamuko on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @01:46PM (#29728280)
But only because there's no monetary value with emotions. If your tears had price tags attached to them, IRS would be all over it.
Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by ipaddr on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @01:03PM (#29727585)
The child would be an adult by then.
Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by henvic on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @01:45PM (#29728260)
How about not messing with people? Let them claim it.
Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by throwaway0a5e on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @01:15PM (#29727766)
The point is that they don't have to wait for some state bureaucracy full of dolts to settle a complicated custody dispute in order to figure out who owes what.
Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by toomuchtodo on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @01:29PM (#29727981)
People give the IRS a lot of grief, but they do their best (imho) to provide reasonable guidance in edge cases to ensure compliance with statute they didn't write.

Edit: @toolz: I can both be satisfied how they provide customer service and dissatisfied that they were in bed with Intuit preventing obsoleting commercial tax prep services. Nuance! (HN throttled, had to reply here to your comment)

Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by culturestate on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @01:41PM (#29728170)
I'd imagine there's some regulatory purpose for this, but really the IRS just does what every well-functioning customer support team should be doing - maintaining an extensive customer-driven FAQ.

When someone asks a question that requires clarification, they go get the answer through whichever channel(s) are required, then they not only respond directly to the customer (taxpayer) but they also format the response for public consumption.

If more companies treated documentation this way, life would be a whole lot easier.

Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by toolz on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @01:57PM (#29728455)
Wasn't trying to suggest you should be dissatisfied with everything about the IRS, but it seemed you were implying the IRS shouldn't get "a lot of grief", which in my opinion they should.
Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by toolz on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @01:51PM (#29728347)
Other countries get a bill in the mail for how much taxes are owed. It's entirely reasonable to be disappointed with the IRS.
Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by adventured on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @01:54PM (#29728409)
> Other countries get a bill in the mail for how much taxes are owed. It's entirely reasonable to be disappointed with the IRS.

No it's not. The IRS didn't make it that way, Congress did (bought and paid for by Intuit & Co.).

Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by treeman79 on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @01:41PM (#29728166)
My older half sister was kidnapped repeatedly by her bio parents.

Legal custody seemed to be whomever had the kid in whichever state at any given time.

One episode ended when her bio dad showed up at air port with a shotgun and bio-mom had convinced the out of state police to be on her side. After a night in jail anyway. Police made the bio-dad go home.

My mom tailed her at school for a few years. Stopping another attempt before it ended.

Was messed up every way possible.

Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by kerneloftruth on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @02:26PM (#29728914)
Who did your older sister prefer and want to live with... the biological parents, or the other family?
Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by cecilpl2 on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @12:41PM (#29727272)
What if you kidnapped someone else's child, can you claim them on your taxes?
Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by DarylZero on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @01:03PM (#29727589)
The same person can only be claimed as a dependent from one person. So the kidnapper has to wait until the next tax year to claim the kidnap victim.
Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by cletus on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @01:28PM (#29727962)
I imagine there's a real drop in kidnappings after July 1 then. That's just sensible tax planning.
Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by Hamuko on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @01:48PM (#29728306)
Surely kidnapping a child for over six months if not sensible financial planning in any way. You're just spending more money to kept the child fed for the same amount of ransom.
Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by dylan604 on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @03:47PM (#29729805)
Are you able to claim deductions for the expenses incurred in attempting to avoid detection by the FBI? It is technically business expenses.
Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by cletus on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @04:03PM (#29729996)
Yes but it’s only deductible against kidnapping related income.
Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by howdydoo on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @02:45PM (#29729132)
A good number of people claim their kids as dependents but (unfortunately) don't take great care of them otherwise
Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by kiklion on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @01:28PM (#29727956)
I mean, that’s why the person had to be kidnapped by a non-family member.

If a family member kidnaps them the it follows the usual formula of who cared for the kidnapped person for half the year plus a day.

Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by desdiv on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @01:12PM (#29727727)
The thought of a kidnapper inquiring about the child's social security number in the ransom note is pretty good dark humor. But I think the IRS has some restrictions on who you can claim as your dependent.

To claim someone as your dependent child, they must be either:

- Your son, daughter, stepchild, foster child, or a descendant (for example, your grandchild) of any of them; or

- Your brother, sister, half brother, half sister, stepbrother, stepsister, or a descendant (for example, your niece or nephew) of any of them.

To claim someone as your dependent relative, they must be either:

- Your child, stepchild, foster child, or a descendant of any of them (for example, your grandchild). (A legally adopted child is considered your child.)

- Your brother, sister, half brother, half sister, stepbrother, or stepsister.

- Your father, mother, grandparent, or other direct ancestor, but not foster parent.

- Your stepfather or stepmother.

- A son or daughter of your brother or sister.

- A son or daughter of your half brother or half sister.

- A brother or sister of your father or mother.

- Your son-in-law, daughter-in-law, father-in-law, mother-in-law, brother-in-law, or sister-in-law.

[0] https://www.irs.gov/publications/p501#en_US_2020_publink1000...

[1] https://www.irs.gov/publications/p501#en_US_2020_publink1000...

Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by evilduck on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @01:48PM (#29728307)
I'm no tax lawyer but it would seem like a kidnapper wouldn't meet the criteria for having legal custody of a person and wouldn't qualify for any relief of their tax burden. But given that a large number of those type of kidnappers are family members, it's likely they already have the information needed to file them as a dependent (which in the case of a kidnapping, seems like it would be cut and dried tax fraud).

The question that lingers in my mind is if your dependent is kidnapped and gone for too long (but not dead... let's say they're kidnapped on December 31st and returned 366 days later conveniently removing custody for an entire calendar year), are you ineligible to claim them as a dependent while they're missing? Seems like strictly and amorally speaking your financial burde has been lessened and you wouldn't need the tax relief for caring for that person.

Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by SilasX on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @01:19PM (#29727813)
>The thought of a kidnapper inquiring about the child's social security number in the ransom note is pretty good dark humor.

lol yeah I'm imagining some skit (or real life situation!) where the kidnapper is calling in to the IRS and explaining the situation to the agent, who dutifully works through the flowchart about which statuses apply when, completely oblivious to the missing child they're dealing with.

And then they just sit there listening in while the kidnapper interrogates the child for the SSN before coming back and reporting that they "can't obtain it", followed by the agent reading off their options.

With that said, not all "kidnappings" in this context are the "masked men/unmarked van" type, I assume you have these same considerations for stuff like "other legal guardian picked up child three days before court authorized them to".

Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by bluGill on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @01:40PM (#29728156)
Because you are legally obliged to tell the IRS of this crime they are not allowed to tell the police about it as then telling the IRS would be self incrimination against the 5th amendment.

Though the IRS has other ways to inform the police if they can find anything you didn't tell them

Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by toss1 on Thursday December 30, 2021 @10:04AM (#29737249)
NO

The article described how the SCOTUS in 1927 resolved this question.

>>Manly Sullivan was convicted in 1922 of evading federal taxes on the income he earned through “running illegal whiskey” in violation of the Volstead Act, according to The Mob Museum.

>> A U.S. circuit court of appeals, however, reversed Sullivan’s conviction. It ruled that, while income from illegally trafficking liquor was subject to taxation, the Fifth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution — which protects against self-incrimination — protected Sullivan from declaring that income on his tax returns.

>> But the U.S Supreme Court in 1927 reversed the court’s decision.

>> “We see no reason to doubt the interpretation of the Act, or any reason why the fact that a business is unlawful should exempt it from paying the taxes that, if lawful, it would have to pay,” Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes Jr. wrote in the majority opinion, according to Justia. "

This is what got Al Capone convicted, not his widespread criminal and murderous enterprises, but his tax evasion.

So, yes, you are required to report all illegal income to the IRS. However, you don't need to go into any detail - just say "Self Employment Income = $XX,000,000" for your drug smuggling empire and pay the tax.

There are also, afaik, strict rules for the IRS to firewall this info from criminal (as opposed to tax) prosecutions. The motivation for these rules is to not discourage people from paying tax on all their enterprises.

[[[ obviously not legal advice, only general info, consult your attorney for actual advise, and maybe avoid crimes ]]]

Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by SilasX on Thursday December 30, 2021 @11:49AM (#29738289)
>There are also, afaik, strict rules for the IRS to firewall this info from criminal (as opposed to tax) prosecutions. The motivation for these rules is to not discourage people from paying tax on all their enterprises.

I don't know how well that works in practice, but I feel like if it is used at all in criminal prosecutions then that would still be a 5th Amendment violation. That is, imagine this hypothetical:

- They have evidence you're a head gangster.

- They raid your warehouses and find a set of accounting books showing profits of $17,530,000.

- They subpoena tax records that turn out to have you saying "Misc income: $17,530,000."

- They argue in (criminal) court that, "aha, he must be running a criminal enterprise because his books show the very same income he reported on his tax forms."

There, even though you didn't report it as criminal income, they're still using compelled testimony (legal requirement to report that criminal enterprise income) against you in prosecution of said criminal enterprise.

Again, I don't know what happens in practice, just saying that if they did it like that, that would be a clear 5th Amendment violation.

Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by toss1 on Thursday December 30, 2021 @01:03PM (#29739292)
As much as I'm inclined to agree in theory, the in practice part was settled by SCOTUS in 1927.

Also, if it's any comfort, they wouldn't need to bother with your tax returns. Unexplained deposits and expenditures are often used to convict people of various crimes. So, I'd expect it to be quite an exception for them to bother with upsetting the IRS <-> criminal taxpayer equilibrium.

Hell, it seems pretty routine now for police, TSA, etc. to just find cash and seize it, forcing the owner to defend the legitimacy of the cash in court, as in funding the prosecution of "$12,345.67 vs State of Texas"; yup, you aren't even considered a party, the govt case is setup to be vs the cash pile itself, presumed to be guilty of being illegal proceeds.

Fun Stuff!

Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by bena on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @02:25PM (#29728897)
That is just not true.

https://www.irs.gov/businesses/small-businesses-self-employe...

It's not like it's a line item on your 1040 "Crime: $4000". It's just self-employed income.

Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by hinkley on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @01:42PM (#29728186)
The IRS got mixed up in anti-mob activity in Chicago. They couldn't get anything to stick locally, but they could get them on tax evasion. They didn't have to prove the money was obtained by a particular crime, they just had to prove they hadn't paid taxes on it.

This conversation feels... familiar.

Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by sdenton4 on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @12:55PM (#29727492)
The text is very close to being symmetric; it's just the 'before the date of the kidnapping' which keeps it from applying to the kidnapper.
Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by hartator on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @12:43PM (#29727309)
Probably if it’s more than 6 calendar months.
Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by mleo on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @01:00PM (#29727552)
Maybe not 100% requirement, but we have always had the kids’ social security number on taxes. Might make it more difficult to claim without.
Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by seventytwo on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @12:52PM (#29727446)
There’s some legit arguments for doing this -

1) even if the kid is kidnapped, we still theoretically want the person watching that child to receive financial support (keep in mind most kidnappings are from ex-spouses or other family members).

2) It provides one more paper trail for authorities to track the child down.

Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by jandrese on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @12:57PM (#29727509)
The rule specifically calls out non-family members though.
Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by kerneloftruth on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @02:24PM (#29728890)
So there is a Child Tax Credit... of sorts. /s
Re:IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes by duxup on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @01:07PM (#29727654)
I’m sure someone asked so… gotta have an answer.