News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:About Three-in-Ten U.S. Adults Are Now Religiously Unaffi... by maroonblazer on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @08:37PM (#29560937)
> Science appears to be growing it's own clergy, demanding deference as opposed to encouraging debate.

What are some examples of this? I'm also an atheist (although I detest the label) who was raised Catholic and seriously considered joining the priesthood. But a life guided by reason and rationality I've found to be so much more fulfilling than the guilt and fear that made up much of my Catholic life.

Re:About Three-in-Ten U.S. Adults Are Now Religiously Unaffi... by Animats on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @09:05PM (#29561151)
What are some examples of this?

String theory? Read Smolin, who points out that for decades, string theorists dominated physics, despite the absence of experimental evidence.

Expert systems? I saw this back in the mid 1980s at Stanford, when the CS department had gone all-in on expert systems. Claims were made that strong AI was just around the corner. This from a technology that doesn't really do all that much. You write simple statements about something in a notation based on predicate calculus, after which you can ask questions. You get out pretty much what you put in. Systems like that still exist, mostly as chatbots for answering the easy questions so customer support doesn't have to talk to you. A programmed FAQ, basically.

And those are hard sciences. Economics is hopeless. Psychology is worse.

(I made the unpopular comment at the time that expert systems would turn out to be more important than syntax-directed parsing, but less important than relational databases.)

As Fred Hoyle once said, "Science is prediction, not explanation". The parts of science that work lead to engineering that works and products that work. Belief is then unnecessary.

Re:About Three-in-Ten U.S. Adults Are Now Religiously Unaffi... by simonh on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @09:17PM (#29561236)
And yet debate and progress continued. The scientific method doesn’t stop people being people, with all the associated flaws. It just sets a set of standards we can measure against. String theory and expert systems came up short and we moved on, but when you have questions and genuinely don’t know the answers sure, we end up exploring some dead ends. Science is just a heuristics to telling when that’s happening, but it doesn’t stop it happening in the first place.
Re:About Three-in-Ten U.S. Adults Are Now Religiously Unaffi... by warmfuzzykitten on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @03:29PM (#29571213)
Computing, much less AI, is not a hard science. Computing is an art that gets practical results in limited domains.
Re:About Three-in-Ten U.S. Adults Are Now Religiously Unaffi... by willcipriano on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @09:19PM (#29561252)
Specific examples can be quibbled about, but I will first say there is still good science occurring everyday. What I am talking about more are people who have donned the mantle of science. At some point along the line, science went from more of a verb to a proper noun (figuratively). We went from doing the science, to trusting or believing the science.

Think about the statement "We believe in science in this house". What does that even really mean? As you considered joining the priesthood, you should know there is a great deal of scholarship that priests engage in. Not just religious scholarship, but the study of the natural world. Many of the minds that pushed humanity forward were priests. Priests believe in science, but the people who put those signs on their lawns tend not to agree.

That gets me to my point, science isn't a noun to me. Yet everyday I keep hearing how the science has spoken. Often, when I look at the evidence provided and I deem what was said to be correct. Just as often, I find small sample sizes, hacked p values or a logical flaw with the conclusion. If I start a dialog about my findings in the wrong places, I get told I'm anti-science by people who didn't even read the paper.

If forced to provide a good example it would the talk of Covid escaping the Wuhan Institute of Virology. This has become a more main stream opinion in the past month or so, but if you wanted to discuss the possibility of this around this time last year, you would've been called a conspiracy theorist by people who reportedly "believe in science" or even be censored by some of the major platforms in the name of science. That is the opposite of the science I grew up with.

Re:About Three-in-Ten U.S. Adults Are Now Religiously Unaffi... by thewebcount on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @09:51PM (#29561479)
> Think about the statement "We believe in science in this house". What does that even really mean?

I think for most people it means that they believe the process of using science to discover how the world works is better than the other alternatives offered by religion, philosophy, conspiracy theories, etc. They don’t usually think it’s infallible, just better than the alternatives.

Re:About Three-in-Ten U.S. Adults Are Now Religiously Unaffi... by philistine on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @06:13AM (#29564400)
Your issues seem to be rooted in linguistics more than anything. People take poor shortcuts. When they say “we believe in science”, they mean “we respect science”.
Re:About Three-in-Ten U.S. Adults Are Now Religiously Unaffi... by Tepix on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @10:34PM (#29561760)
> Priests believe in science, but the people who put those signs on their lawns tend not to agree.

I don't see how you can claim with a straight face that priests believe in science. Religion at its core is asking for belief without proof. Science is the opposite.

Re:About Three-in-Ten U.S. Adults Are Now Religiously Unaffi... by etempleton on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @11:18PM (#29562042)
Most priests are incredibly educated. There is a reason a lot of colleges and universities were founded by religious orders. There are Catholic priests who are well regarded and published scientists and mathematicians.
Re:About Three-in-Ten U.S. Adults Are Now Religiously Unaffi... by trasz on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @05:08AM (#29563944)
It might depend on country. In Poland, for example, the opposite is true: priests are essentially modern political officers, with very poor understanding of pretty much anything. Polish catholic universities are generally mediocre, except for stuff that can’t be corrupted by religion, eg food technology.
Re:About Three-in-Ten U.S. Adults Are Now Religiously Unaffi... by mbfg on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @09:44AM (#29566573)
Science is accepting things based on evidence.

Faith is believing things without evidence.

If you have evidence for a thing, you don't say, "i believe it on faith".

Re:About Three-in-Ten U.S. Adults Are Now Religiously Unaffi... by Tepix on Wednesday December 22, 2021 @04:57AM (#29647383)
Being educated doesn't mean that they believe in science, does it?
Re:About Three-in-Ten U.S. Adults Are Now Religiously Unaffi... by willcipriano on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @10:55PM (#29561904)
Thusly: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Catholic_clergy_scient...

Further: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_lay_Catholic_scientist...

You are robbing yourself if you don't speak to priests you encounter. They tend to be very well read people, with an interesting perspective on the world if you can be tolerant enough of them.

Re:About Three-in-Ten U.S. Adults Are Now Religiously Unaffi... by trasz on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @05:09AM (#29563956)
Anything past 1950? Because the religion wasn’t _always_ hostile to science.
Re:About Three-in-Ten U.S. Adults Are Now Religiously Unaffi... by mbfg on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @09:44AM (#29566584)
Believing things without evidence is "hostile" to science.
Re:About Three-in-Ten U.S. Adults Are Now Religiously Unaffi... by trasz on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @12:38PM (#29569085)
Really? Is children's belief in Santa Claus hostile to science?

What I've meant above is hostility in the literal sense. As in, trying to oppose science with some religious fantasies, like with Intelligent Design, or pretty much anything Catholicism says about human sexuality.

Re:About Three-in-Ten U.S. Adults Are Now Religiously Unaffi... by mbfg on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @01:18PM (#29569613)
"Science" is a process. That of collecting observations, building theories and testing those theories, rinse repeat. So yes a belief in Santa is 'hostile' to science, because it is completely at odds with that process.
Re:About Three-in-Ten U.S. Adults Are Now Religiously Unaffi... by Kye on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @10:46PM (#29561844)
The ways the human brain can find to bridge two things that seem contradictory to someone outside that experience are numerous. It can be as easy as simply not applying scientific processes to something inherently unscientific. Sometimes there's a lot of unchecked confirmation bias in finding proof of faith.
Re:About Three-in-Ten U.S. Adults Are Now Religiously Unaffi... by andi999 on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @09:33PM (#29561362)
You only do science on a very small area at most. I mean, if you have a certain bacterial infection do you trust the science that the specific antibiotic is likely to be effective, or do you start to 'do' science?
Re:About Three-in-Ten U.S. Adults Are Now Religiously Unaffi... by ummonk on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @09:50PM (#29561473)
Can't speak for GP, but generally I believe there is a not insignificant chance that the treatment I'm being provided by the doctor is ineffective or even counterproductive. I'll still generally follow the doctor's advice at least after doing a brief literature search to confirm that the doctor's advice is aligned with contemporary best practices.

Part of science is acknowledging epistemic uncertainty yet still acting on imperfect information.

Re:About Three-in-Ten U.S. Adults Are Now Religiously Unaffi... by andi999 on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @03:30AM (#29563360)
I agree. I also read the literature, but (at least in my narrow definition) literature review is not doing science (which is creating new knowledge). Literature review is a precondition of reviewing science though.
Re:About Three-in-Ten U.S. Adults Are Now Religiously Unaffi... by P_I_Staker on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @09:52AM (#29566698)
That's not really a good example of science demanding deference, or "blind faith". It's a silly catchphrase that's maybe worded a bit poorly.

I've seen a few things quite concerning, specifically with COVID. However, the overall message (that I'm guessing you'd disagree with) to trust the experts, isn't necessarily a call for deference/faith either.

The concern is that people will go out looking for validation of their preconceived biases, listen to misinformed parties, possibly with perverse incentives, or political motivations. It's not all about shutting down discussion, as much as keeping the crazies from preventing the public from gaining herd immunity.

Re:About Three-in-Ten U.S. Adults Are Now Religiously Unaffi... by Osiris on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @09:35PM (#29561382)
I live by reason and rationality and am also religious. I see "God" as Truth, or a consciousness that knows all truth, and that seeking truth, including natural laws/science, is equivalent to seeking god.

The two do (religion and rationality) are not mutually exclusive concepts.

Re:About Three-in-Ten U.S. Adults Are Now Religiously Unaffi... by paulryanrogers on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @09:45PM (#29561443)
> The two do (religion and rationality) are not mutually exclusive concepts.

Only if the religion is unfalsifiable. If it can be proven false then it's irrational to believe in it. If it can be proven true there is no need for faith.

Re:About Three-in-Ten U.S. Adults Are Now Religiously Unaffi... by mbrock on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @02:12AM (#29562953)
What if believing in it is proven to have significant benefits, regardless of the scientific truth value of the doctrinal propositions? How do you really judge the rationality of that?
Re:About Three-in-Ten U.S. Adults Are Now Religiously Unaffi... by mbfg on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @09:50AM (#29566671)
The issue is, as is amply shown in the United States, is that minds that can accept things without evidence that are considered benign, can also accept things that are harmful. A mind that doesn't consider truth to be an important part of a belief system can believe anything. This "My Truth" is a pervasive virus that is occurring here in the US, and you see it every day destroying our society.

If i don't need evidence,

I can believe white people are better than black people and take it on faith. I can believe men are better than women and take it on faith. I can believe cis people are better than lbgtq+ people and take it on faith.

If i don't have to demonstrate the accuracy of my claims, My claims are as valid as your claims.

Re:About Three-in-Ten U.S. Adults Are Now Religiously Unaffi... by paulryanrogers on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @08:39AM (#29565713)
> What if believing in it is proven to have significant benefits, regardless of the scientific truth...

If the beliefs are benign then one could make a case. Even so I prefer believing only what can be proven over ignorance and self deception.

Re:About Three-in-Ten U.S. Adults Are Now Religiously Unaffi... by BLKNSLVR on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @09:49PM (#29561467)
If that's how you see "god" then the only thing we differ on, as such, is the meaning of the label 'religious'. For me, religious means following a specific set of beliefs, behaviours, and traditions - which is somewhat incompatible with the idea of seeking truth inasmuch that some newfound truths may be incompatible with said beliefs, behaviours, and traditions.

According my mental dictionary, religion and rationality are mutually exclusive when the religious doctrine is proven irrational.

Re:About Three-in-Ten U.S. Adults Are Now Religiously Unaffi... by rackjack on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @09:55PM (#29561504)
I do not think this is what most people believe the definition of religion or God is.
Re:About Three-in-Ten U.S. Adults Are Now Religiously Unaffi... by tengbretson on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @12:37AM (#29562482)
I would recommend the prologue of the book of John to learn more about this.
Re:About Three-in-Ten U.S. Adults Are Now Religiously Unaffi... by mbfg on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @09:46AM (#29566606)
Believing things without evidence is a core disagreement with science.
Re:About Three-in-Ten U.S. Adults Are Now Religiously Unaffi... by brnaftr181 on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @09:13PM (#29561207)
Obviously not OP,

If we look at the history of the Varna, particularly the Brahmin, if I'm not mistaken... From my fragmented recollection, the Brahmins created increasingly sophisticated and esoteric rituals which began to jointly increase in expense. They were eventually castigated [EDIT: the Vedic religion was actually challenged by a variety of religions, this period, ≈700BCE, gave rise to Buddhism and Jainism.] for this — I'd say science draws a pretty close parallel.

It's increasingly opaque, expensive, esoteric, and despite all that it's informing opinion, debate, and policy. It's also a closed circle that is arbitrarily delimited, and given high autonomy and authority in society. Not to mention most people have a poor grasp of the fact that science isn't the truth. It also does little to inform us in the way of morality, yet it appears the "rationalists" (pardon, I've no better term) in usurping religion, have little in the way of an answer for this. Yet the constituent mass that composes it is one of the most trusted groups[1]. Which is easily exploitable if you factor all this together, not unlike religion. And it has been leveraged for maligned purposes, before and will continue to be.

[1] https://www.pewresearch.org/science/2019/08/02/trust-and-mis...

Re:About Three-in-Ten U.S. Adults Are Now Religiously Unaffi... by jimbokun on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @09:45PM (#29561440)
Being an atheist is not automatically tied to reason and rationality.
Re:About Three-in-Ten U.S. Adults Are Now Religiously Unaffi... by ummonk on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @08:57PM (#29561095)
There are numerous examples of this, but I think the most glaring would be on issues relating to the COVID pandemic.

At the start, the scientific dogma was that masks don't work, and travel bans don't work, and worrying about COVID was irrational alarmism. Anyone who suggested otherwise was treated as not believing in science (this extended to censorship or at least misinformation banners on major social media platforms).

Now, the scientific dogma has flipped, and for example anyone questioning the effectiveness of masks is treated as a science denier.

Re:About Three-in-Ten U.S. Adults Are Now Religiously Unaffi... by simonh on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @09:23PM (#29561285)
People are flawed and when they have insufficient evidence or misleading evidence, or questionable incentives they make mistakes. Science doesn’t stop that happening, it doesn’t stop people being flawed. It just generates the evidence to tell us when it has happened so we can correct. It worked. Job done.

> travel bans don't work, and worrying about COVID was irrational alarmism…

Clearly you were listening to different medical and scientific advice than I was seeing at the time. The medical establishment was warning about the dangers from very early on. The question about travel bans was mainly about timing, not whether they would be needed or not.

Re:About Three-in-Ten U.S. Adults Are Now Religiously Unaffi... by systemvoltage on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @11:04PM (#29561956)
You can't see the amount of dislikes this video had (Thanks Google), but you really should watch NIH Director's interview as he fumbles on the most basic questions: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mRZE-SJShkE

This is not some crackpot interviewer.

I work with good hearted scientists everyday. Science is amazing. Science is the foundation for my whole goddamn life. But, our leadership did not hold up to the standard I was expecting them to. And, they crumbled under political influence and their inability to lead with objectivity and truth. They are weak. Almost childish (see it for yourself). It is no surprise they eroded public trust.

Re:About Three-in-Ten U.S. Adults Are Now Religiously Unaffi... by nitrogen on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @12:20AM (#29562398)
Can you link to specific timestamps where there were stumbles? I watched the first 8 minutes and it seemed like he was on top of things and answering well.
Re:About Three-in-Ten U.S. Adults Are Now Religiously Unaffi... by diputsmonro on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @09:13PM (#29561206)
This is not all "science's" fault. This whole thing has been political from the beginning, both in that those in power during the initial outbreak tried to downplay the dangers, and those opposing them tried to overcompensate to distance themselves.

Besides, it is perfectly scientific to change your beliefs and guidance based on new evidence, especially when it comes to novel diseases and a generation-defining pandemic.

Re:About Three-in-Ten U.S. Adults Are Now Religiously Unaffi... by ummonk on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @09:29PM (#29561333)
It's not the fault of "science" in the abstract or even the fault of most scientists (who're sincere and open to debate and disagreement, and generally acknowledge the limits of their epistemic certainty).

But there is clearly a faction of media and political institutions which wield "Science (TM)" as a cudgel to stifle public debate / opinions - and they aren't even doing it out of bad faith / political opportunism - they're doing it because they believe it's important to have the general public universally believe in established science "facts".

Re:About Three-in-Ten U.S. Adults Are Now Religiously Unaffi... by tshaddox on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @09:01PM (#29561126)
It seems like you’ve skipped a step to “therefore there is a science clergy.” Who are these supposed clergy, and how do they resemble religious clergy? A credentialed scientist saying something they knew was incorrect or later learned to be incorrect seems unrelated to the concept of clergy.
Re:About Three-in-Ten U.S. Adults Are Now Religiously Unaffi... by ummonk on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @09:13PM (#29561205)
The institutions are the clergy. To a small extent this can include credentialed scientists, peer-reviewed journals, etc., but really it's the government institutions (e.g. WHO, CDC, FDA, Surgeon General) and media institutions (e.g. newspapers, cable news, and social media platforms) that constitute the clergy.

The "Science" dogma that the general public is induced to adhere to gets filtered through these institutions.

Re:About Three-in-Ten U.S. Adults Are Now Religiously Unaffi... by rayiner on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @09:51PM (#29561477)
This is the part I find scary. Credentialism has given rise to a new clerisy. This is especially evident in fields where “there’s no there there” like social studies.
Re:About Three-in-Ten U.S. Adults Are Now Religiously Unaffi... by olliej on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @09:07PM (#29561166)
… what?

Science changes course as more data comes in.

At first there wasn’t evidence that masks worked, once that had been accrued science was pro-mask.

The reason people questioning the effectiveness of masks is called a science denier is because there have been innumerable studies on the effectiveness of masks, and every one that has stood up to scrutiny has come out in favor of masks.

Calling scientific consensus that is backed but huge amounts of direct evidence “dogma” is nonsense.

Dogma is an absolute opinion on something in the absence of (or indeed denied by) evidence.

Re:About Three-in-Ten U.S. Adults Are Now Religiously Unaffi... by barry-cotter on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @09:27PM (#29561319)
> At first there wasn’t evidence that masks worked, once that had been accrued science was pro-mask.

This is not how that worked. The evidence in terms of tests and trials is inconclusive, either for or against masks, in terms of experimental evidence of effectiveness. Nevertheless East Asia was all fro masks from the beginning and the WHO, CDC, FDA, Surgeon General were against, very vehemently. The western establishment changed their minds based not on experimental evidence but on people going "Are you morons? You're saying masks are literally useless? Not of limited use, actually worthless? Do you understand how airflow and droplets work at all?"

Re:About Three-in-Ten U.S. Adults Are Now Religiously Unaffi... by ummonk on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @09:23PM (#29561281)
> Science changes course as more data comes in.

And that's reason to express epistemic uncertainty when basing one's conclusions off limited data.

> At first there wasn’t evidence that masks worked, once that had been accrued science was pro-mask.

First of all, there was already evidence that masks worked.

Second, officials did not tell people that we lacked evidence that masks work - they told people that masks don't work period.

> The reason people questioning the effectiveness of masks is called a science denier is because there have been innumerable studies on the effectiveness of masks, and every one that has stood up to scrutiny has come out in favor of masks. Calling scientific consensus that is backed but huge amounts of direct evidence “dogma” is nonsense.

The studies show limited effectiveness of masks, particularly with newer variants that have higher exhaled viral loads. People who argue that the benefits of masking are outweighed by the costs are labeled science deniers. This is despite there being some evidence of negative impacts from masking (e.g. on childhood development).

Re:About Three-in-Ten U.S. Adults Are Now Religiously Unaffi... by simonh on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @09:39PM (#29561408)
> Second, officials did not tell people that we lacked evidence that masks work - they told people that masks don't work period.

Some said we lacked evidence, others said they didn’t work. There was no single voice on this.

Re:About Three-in-Ten U.S. Adults Are Now Religiously Unaffi... by ShamelessC on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @09:14PM (#29561211)
I don't think this particular issue was viewed through the lens of science for many. It's been a confusing two years and Americans got a lot of mixed messaging from elites in general, and definitely from the FDA. This was seen as institutional failure though, not scientific failure. JTBC, I'm not arguing what it _was_, but how it was perceived.

Your portrayal of the recent scientific dogma as being discriminatory of people who don't wear masks does not match mine, however. As far as I know, the current dogma is "get vaccinated and no one really cares if you have a mask on or not, maybe wear one when your grandma comes over though and consider getting a booster if your regional leaders are advising you to".

Anyway. The culture war is still firmly between the un/vaccinated, not the vaccinated but unmasked.

edit: Maybe try leaving the bay area if you disagree.