News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Invention of Chinese by bradrn on Saturday December 11, 2021 @07:33PM (#29525779)
> Most dialects, Cantonese included, use the same Chinese character system.

I don’t think GP is arguing about this. The question is about whether they use the same sounds, whether they have the same grammar, and whether people from different dialects can understand each other without special training. Even though Cantonese uses the same character set as other dialects, my understanding is that you can’t just transcribe Cantonese word-by-word onto a page without it becoming unintelligible to a speaker of other dialects — all of which implies that the ‘dialects’ are actually separate languages.

Re:The Invention of Chinese by z2 on Saturday December 11, 2021 @10:36PM (#29526913)
As a mandarin speaker (not from northern China though), I feel that the OP's anecdotes seem a bit extreme and appeared to imply ignorance in most speakers. Anecdotally I know none to few people who would claim that dialects can be written and then read back in another dialect. It also would strike me and all the mandarin speakers I know as fairly obvious that most dialects don't even have well-defined characters to use. Rather, written Cantonese (or Shanghainese etc.) often use characters for phonetic purposes rather than true etymological meaning (e.g., 海-sea is pronounced "hai" in many dialects, and 嗨 with a 口-mouth character hints that this is now a sound word to represent the "hai" sound, and no longer has any relation to the ocean). And that is if the dialect mainstream enough to actually have a writing convention. A lack of popular non-mandarin convention today is tough, hence the dominance of written mandarin grammar, to the extent that a lot of Cantonese news programs will actually provide captions in written mandarin.
Re:The Invention of Chinese by jimworm on Sunday December 12, 2021 @04:11AM (#29528166)
> Rather, written Cantonese (or Shanghainese etc.) often use characters for phonetic purposes rather than true etymological meaning

This is where the mistake is. Written Chinese does have all those characters - it is the adoption of a "standard Chinese" that caused those characters not to be taught when mass education was introduced. The people were left to transliterate or create new characters for their spoken native tongue, and the correct characters are now known only to researchers.

One very annoying part of Mandarin's effect on modern Chinese is that many words are being replaced by transliterations of/in Mandarin, even when the Chinese word itself exists. Often this is because the source of the word was foreign. To a non-Mandarin speaker, written Chinese is very slowly turning into complete nonsense, and written Chinese is losing its edge in longevity by no longer being a ideograph-based language.

Re:The Invention of Chinese by CorrectHorseBat on Sunday December 12, 2021 @05:14AM (#29528413)
Chinese was never an ideograph based language to begin with. Yes, most characters have that somewhere in their origin, but there's so much corruption, change of meaning and borrowing of sound going on all through history that you really don't get anywhere using ideographs.

Example in Mandarin: 我不知道 : I don't know. But in ideographs: weapon flower root arrow mouth foot head.

Re:The Invention of Chinese by ncmncm on Sunday December 12, 2021 @05:03AM (#29528375)
It has been a very, very long time since written Chinese was a substantially ideograph-based language.

It is amazing how many literate Chinese people think of it as one.

Re:The Invention of Chinese by jimworm on Sunday December 12, 2021 @01:03PM (#29531885)
That's merely refuting the least relevant part.

The ideographs were important in that they could tie together vastly different spoken languages in the same family. Because the writing was unified, all the spoken variants had their own influence on it by way of traders and administrators, and successful changes by proxy affected the speech of other regions. This meant that all the different places effectively evolved their languages around a virtual core based on the communications of the literate class - even the phonetic-based parts; and they could do it peacefully and continuously, constantly realigning their definitions without legal or violent coercion, uninterrupted by the constant evolution of the whole group of spoken languages.

For example, French has had a great influence on English, and they both use the Latin alphabet. Would such influence have been possible in the same time without violent conquest, given the alphabetic system of writing?

Re:The Invention of Chinese by CorrectHorseBat on Sunday December 12, 2021 @03:54PM (#29533509)
Do you have any literature backing this up? It all sounds like pseudoscience to me, but I could be wrong.
Re:The Invention of Chinese by ncmncm on Monday December 13, 2021 @06:24AM (#29538616)
> written Cantonese (or Shanghainese etc.) often use characters for phonetic purposes rather than true etymological meaning

This is the case for all Chinese writing, and has been for a very long time. But complicated rules for which character may be used to spell which Mandarin word obscure the fact.

Re:The Invention of Chinese by z2 on Monday December 13, 2021 @10:24AM (#29540359)
It's the case for about 80% of characters by my very unscientific estimate -- there are of course some logograms and ideographs left even if the meanings have also shifted. But the difference (and maybe one awkward part) in written non-Mandarin today is the flagrant use of 口 + similar sounding word with zero meaning, just as foreign words are sometimes imported for pure sound reasons. Chinese is far from a pure language, but I'd argue that whatever "rules" that created 清,情,晴 are better attempts at capturing both sound and meaning.
Re:The Invention of Chinese by xwolfi on Saturday December 11, 2021 @10:29PM (#29526878)
I'm in Hong Kong (majority Cantonese), my wife cant for her life help me navigate taobao in Mandarin, even when she transcribes the simplified into traditional without getting annoyed and frustrated.

So while it's not totally unintelligle to her, because it's sort of similar, I think for her to read mandarin is like for me, French, to read Spanish. I can grasp it, it's sort of the same thing, but there are so many little details in divergence it takes me ages just to get a grasp of what it's saying.

I wouldnt dare call Spanish or French a dialect of Italian and I think it's weird to call Cantonese a dialect of Mandarin just like saying humans descendend from modern monkeys: these things are trees with common ancestors but also diverging influences that make them break away further from each other.

I think americans exagerate the oppressive nature of language teaching in China since the guy you replied to has a point: they experience it and they very well must see it's not 1:1 sound transcription.

Re:The Invention of Chinese by causi on Sunday December 12, 2021 @01:21AM (#29527577)
Just the fact Mandarin has four tones and Cantonese has between six and nine depending on the location is enough for me to fall on the "separate languages" side of the opinion.
Re:The Invention of Chinese by powerapple on Sunday December 12, 2021 @02:36AM (#29527818)
Cantonese is not a dialect of Mandarin, rather it is a dialect of Chinese. The fact is that Cantonese is close to classical written Chinese than northern dialects. The writing system was unified thousands years go, but not the spoken language. A classic text written by a Cantonese a thousand years ago could be understandable by someone in Beijing that time. Mandarin was created afterwards and was mainly based on northern dialects.

The difference is that traditional written language was very formal, and far from spoken language. Now whatever written online are very close to spoken language. I wouldn't understand many words the kids in my city use.

Re:The Invention of Chinese by xwolfi on Sunday December 12, 2021 @07:21AM (#29528990)
Then would you say French and Italian are dialects of Latin - clearly derived bastardized version for a Latin person at the time, same writing ?

Or would you say French and Italian are dialect of "Westernese", the same imaginary concept as "Chinese" would be as a language ?

I don't really know what's the right boundary between dialect and language. I know I use it in a French context when I want to speak of the peasant's language in my region which has no literature, doesn't expand beyond the villages in Normandy, cannot be written and has a grammar that can fluctuate between villages. Then I call that a dialect because I would discourage someone from using it too much lol

What's your definition ? Should we say French is a dialect of Latin if Canto is a dialect of "Chinese" ? And what value would it have, since the Latin world is as divided as the "Chinese" one, politically or linguistically ?

Interestingly, I think French people are a bit more "proud" or happy about the Latin link than Hong Kong people are about the Chinese link. At least, each time we discuss the subject, they get mad fast about how their language (and broader "culture" whatever they think that means) is being a little bit dismissed by the mainland to the profit of a more efficient lingua franca they feel loses some features they like (the butchered simplified writing is to them an anathema). I think they overestimate the value of keeping a culture/language and underestimate the benefit of unity but... touchy subject to say the least :D

Re:The Invention of Chinese by ncmncm on Sunday December 12, 2021 @07:39PM (#29535282)
"Dialect" normally requires substantial mutual intelligibility. In English we have a Scots dialect with many unique words (many fallen out of common English, but preserved in Scots), that could become a distinct language with a little encouragement and time, but probably won't. American and British English are mutually intelligible dialects with variant pronunciation and small variations in spelling and vocabulary. English and Dutch sound similar, but have little vocabulary in common. Romanian and Portuguese, likewise. Romanian went through a recent scrubbing make it more like Latin.

The Romance languages all started out as local dialects of Latin. After casting loose they have evolved mostly independently, and lost inter-intelligibility. But idioms often cross over, with constituent words substituted literally.

Re:The Invention of Chinese by jhvkjhk on Sunday December 12, 2021 @08:39AM (#29529509)
> I think French people are a bit more "proud" or happy about the Latin link than Hong Kong people are about the Chinese link

A little bit off-topic, but I'm curious: do HK people proud or happy about their UK link?

Re:The Invention of Chinese by xwolfi on Sunday December 12, 2021 @09:04PM (#29535745)
Well it changed the last 7 years. When I arrived, they didnt care and I was surprised they vehemently told me "we're Chinese through and through we just dont like the communists", fast forward 7 years, I m married to a local etc, she's religiously renewing her British National Overseas passport, like most people who are eligible, talk now of the "mainlanders" as the problem more than the communists, and 2 years ago the British flag was flying higher than the red flag...

As a french it annoys me you can imagine so Im not neutral on the subject, but I d say this Britsh link expanded. China managed to make the HK people regress by their mismanagement of the Taiwan murder issue (which turned into insane anti extraditions protests - how the hell did they screw up that much) and I lost many friends and colleagues to the anglosphere (many moved to Canada and US, some UK but life isnt as good there). I hear them say it was better with the UK, forgetting a bit their grandma sleeping on the streets of Sham Shui Po during the worst of the colonial era... but it was probably also the communists' fault if so many left Canton at that time.

Could also be me integrating deeper and seeing the issue as it always was, so take my comment with a grain of salt :D

Oh and linguistically, they're surprisingly less fluent than Singapore weirdly, and there are large pockets of HK where it's impossible to use English (usually poorer parts or more mainland populated) so it's very much a political link, not a love or influence of English as a language itself, unlike Latin in France where random grassroot people would fight against grammar reform to keep the Latin influence even if it's irrational, confusing or hard to write.

Re:The Invention of Chinese by frenchy on Sunday December 12, 2021 @12:11AM (#29527331)
There's a saying that a language is a dialect with an army and a navy. What people choose to call the communications of a specific language community is often a very political thing.